-
A Continuum Model for Cities Based on the Macroscopic Fundamental Diagram: a Semi-Lagrangian Solution Method
Authors:
Rafegh Aghamohammadi,
Jorge A. Laval
Abstract:
This paper presents a formulation of the reactive dynamic user equilibrium problem in continuum form using a network-level Macroscopic Fundamental Diagram (MFD). Compared to existing continuum models for cities -- all based in Hughes' pedestrian model in 2002 -- the proposed formulation (i) is consistent with reservoir-type models of the MFD literature, shedding some light into the connection betw…
▽ More
This paper presents a formulation of the reactive dynamic user equilibrium problem in continuum form using a network-level Macroscopic Fundamental Diagram (MFD). Compared to existing continuum models for cities -- all based in Hughes' pedestrian model in 2002 -- the proposed formulation (i) is consistent with reservoir-type models of the MFD literature, shedding some light into the connection between these two modeling approaches, (ii) can have destinations continuously distributed on the region, and (iii) can incorporate multi-commodity flows without additional numerical error. The proposed multi-reservoir numerical solution method treats the multi-commodity component of the model in Lagrangian coordinates, which is the natural representation to propagate origin-destination information (and any vehicle-specific characteristic) through the traffic stream. Fluxes between reservoir boundaries are computed in the Eulerian representation, and are used to calculate the speed of vehicles crossing the boundary. Simple examples are included that show the convergence of the model and its agreements with the available analytical solutions. We find that (i) when origins and destinations are uniformly distributed in a region, the distribution of the travel times can be approximated analytically, (ii) the magnitude of the detours from the optimal free-flow route due to congestion increase linearly with the inflow and decreases with the square of the speed, and (iii) the total delay of vehicles in the network converges to the analytical approximation when the size of reservoirs tends to zero.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2020; v1 submitted 13 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Dynamic Traffic Assignment using the Macroscopic Fundamental Diagram: A Review of Vehicular and Pedestrian Flow Models
Authors:
Rafegh Aghamohammadi,
Jorge A. Laval
Abstract:
Traditional DTA models of large cities suffer from prohibitive computation times and calibration/validation can become major challenges faced by practitioners. The empirical evidence in 2008 in support of the existence of a Macroscopic Fundamental Diagram (MFD) on urban networks led to the formulation of discrete-space models, where the city is divided into a collection of reservoirs. Prior to 200…
▽ More
Traditional DTA models of large cities suffer from prohibitive computation times and calibration/validation can become major challenges faced by practitioners. The empirical evidence in 2008 in support of the existence of a Macroscopic Fundamental Diagram (MFD) on urban networks led to the formulation of discrete-space models, where the city is divided into a collection of reservoirs. Prior to 2008, a large body of DTA models based on pedestrian flow models had been formulated in continuum space as 2-dimensional conservation laws where the speed-density relationship can now be interpreted as the MFD. Perhaps surprisingly, we found that this continuum-space literature has been mostly unaware of MFD theory, and no attempts exist to verify the assumptions of MFD theory. This has the potential to create significant inconsistencies, and research is needed to analyze their extent and ways to resolve them. We also find that further research is needed to (i) incorporate departure time choice, (ii) improve existing numerical methods, possibly extending recent advances on the one-dimensional kinematic wave (LWR) model, (iii) study the properties of system optimum solutions, (iv) examine the real-time applicability of current continuum-space models compared to traditional DTA methods, and (v) formulate anisotropic models for the interaction of intersecting flows.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
The impact of source terms in the variational representation of traffic flow
Authors:
Jorge A Laval,
Guillaume Costeseque,
Rama Chilukuri
Abstract:
This paper revisits the variational theory of traffic flow, now under the presence of continuum lateral inflows and outflows to the freeway say Eulerian source terms. It is found that a VT solution exists only in Eulerian coordinates when source terms are exogenous meaning that they only depend on time and space, but not when they are a function of traffic conditions, as per a merge model. In disc…
▽ More
This paper revisits the variational theory of traffic flow, now under the presence of continuum lateral inflows and outflows to the freeway say Eulerian source terms. It is found that a VT solution exists only in Eulerian coordinates when source terms are exogenous meaning that they only depend on time and space, but not when they are a function of traffic conditions, as per a merge model. In discrete time, however, these dependencies become exogenous, which allowed us to propose improved numerical solution methods. In Lagrangian and vehicle number-space coordinates, VT solutions may not exist even if source terms are exogenous.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
