Showing 1–17 of 17 results for author: Kruckman, A

Three surprising instances of dividing

Authors: Gabriel Conant, Alex Kruckman

Abstract: We give three counterexamples to the folklore claim that in an arbitrary theory, if a complete type $p$ over a set $B$ does not divide over $C\subseteq B$, then no extension of $p$ to a complete type over $\text{acl}(B)$ divides over $C$. Two of our examples are also the first known theories where all sets are extension bases for nonforking, but forking and dividing differ for complete types (answ… ▽ More We give three counterexamples to the folklore claim that in an arbitrary theory, if a complete type $p$ over a set $B$ does not divide over $C\subseteq B$, then no extension of $p$ to a complete type over $\text{acl}(B)$ divides over $C$. Two of our examples are also the first known theories where all sets are extension bases for nonforking, but forking and dividing differ for complete types (answering a question of Adler). One example is an NSOP$_1$ theory with a complete type that forks, but does not divide, over a model (answering a question of d'Elbée). Moreover, dividing independence fails to imply M-independence in this example (which refutes another folklore claim). In addition to these counterexamples, we summarize various related properties of dividing that are still true. We also address consequences for previous literature, including an earlier unpublished result about forking and dividing in free amalgamation theories, and some claims about dividing in the theory of generic $K_{m,n}$-free incidence structures. △ Less

Submitted 4 April, 2024; v1 submitted 1 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Comments: 19 pages, minor revisions from first version, to appear in JSL

A New Kim's Lemma

Authors: Alex Kruckman, Nicholas Ramsey

Abstract: Kim's Lemma is a key ingredient in the theory of forking independence in simple theories. It asserts that if a formula divides, then it divides along every Morley sequence in type of the parameters. Variants of Kim's Lemma have formed the core of the theories of independence in two orthogonal generalizations of simplicity - namely, the classes of NTP2 and NSOP1 theories. We introduce a new variant… ▽ More Kim's Lemma is a key ingredient in the theory of forking independence in simple theories. It asserts that if a formula divides, then it divides along every Morley sequence in type of the parameters. Variants of Kim's Lemma have formed the core of the theories of independence in two orthogonal generalizations of simplicity - namely, the classes of NTP2 and NSOP1 theories. We introduce a new variant of Kim's Lemma that simultaneously generalizes the NTP2 and NSOP1 variants. We explore examples and non-examples in which this lemma holds, discuss implications with syntactic properties of theories, and ask several questions. △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2024; v1 submitted 6 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Comments: Minor corrections and improvements. To appear in Model Theory

Journal ref: Model Th. 3 (2024) 825-860

Interpolative fusions II: Preservation results

Authors: Alex Kruckman, Minh Chieu Tran, Erik Walsberg

Abstract: We study interpolative fusion, a method of combining theories $T_1$ and $T_2$ in distinct languages in a "generic" way over a common reduct $T_\cap$, to obtain a theory $T_\cup^*$. When each $T_i$ is model-complete, $T_\cup^*$ is the model companion of the union $T_1\cup T_2$. Our goal is to prove preservation results, i.e., to find sufficient conditions under which model-theoretic properties of… ▽ More We study interpolative fusion, a method of combining theories $T_1$ and $T_2$ in distinct languages in a "generic" way over a common reduct $T_\cap$, to obtain a theory $T_\cup^*$. When each $T_i$ is model-complete, $T_\cup^*$ is the model companion of the union $T_1\cup T_2$. Our goal is to prove preservation results, i.e., to find sufficient conditions under which model-theoretic properties of $T_1$ and $T_2$ are inherited by $T_\cup^*$. We first prove preservation results for quantifier elimination, model-completeness, and related properties. We then apply these tools to show that, under mild hypotheses, including stability of $T_\cap$, the property $\mathrm{NSOP}_1$ is preserved. We also show that simplicity is preserved under stronger hypotheses on algebraic closure in $T_1$ and $T_2$. This generalizes many previous results; for example, simplicity of $\mathrm{ACFA}$ and the random $n$-hypergraph are both non-obvious corollaries. We also address preservation of stability, $\mathrm{NIP}$, and $\aleph_0$-categoricity, and we describe examples which witness that these results are sharp. △ Less

Submitted 10 January, 2022; originally announced January 2022.

Comments: Some parts of this paper originally appeared in the first version of the first interpolative fusion paper. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1811.06108

Invariant measures in simple and in small theories

Authors: Artem Chernikov, Ehud Hrushovski, Alex Kruckman, Krzysztof Krupinski, Slavko Moconja, Anand Pillay, Nicholas Ramsey

Abstract: We give examples of (i) a simple theory with a formula (with parameters) which does not fork over the empty set but has mu measure 0 for every automorphism invariant Keisler measure mu, and (ii) a definable group G in a simple theory such that G is not definably amenable, i.e. there is no translation invariant Keisler measure on G We also discuss paradoxical decompositions both in the setting of… ▽ More We give examples of (i) a simple theory with a formula (with parameters) which does not fork over the empty set but has mu measure 0 for every automorphism invariant Keisler measure mu, and (ii) a definable group G in a simple theory such that G is not definably amenable, i.e. there is no translation invariant Keisler measure on G We also discuss paradoxical decompositions both in the setting of discrete groups and of definable groups, and prove some positive results about small theories, including the definable amenability of definable groups, and nontriviality of the graded Grothendieck ring. △ Less

Submitted 2 July, 2022; v1 submitted 15 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Comments: 32 pages. This is a revised version of the paper taking into account suggestions of the referee. It has been accepted by the Journal of Math. Logic

MSC Class: 03C45; 43A07

The almost sure theory of finite metric spaces

Authors: Isaac Goldbring, Bradd Hart, Alex Kruckman

Abstract: We establish an approximate zero-one law for sentences of continuous logic over finite metric spaces of diameter at most $1$. More precisely, we axiomatize a complete metric theory $T_{\mathrm{as}}$ such that, given any sentence $σ$ in the language of pure metric spaces and any $ε>0$, the probability that the difference of the value of $σ$ in a random metric space of size $n$ and the value of $σ$… ▽ More We establish an approximate zero-one law for sentences of continuous logic over finite metric spaces of diameter at most $1$. More precisely, we axiomatize a complete metric theory $T_{\mathrm{as}}$ such that, given any sentence $σ$ in the language of pure metric spaces and any $ε>0$, the probability that the difference of the value of $σ$ in a random metric space of size $n$ and the value of $σ$ in any model of $T_{\mathrm{as}}$ is less than $ε$ approaches $1$ as $n$ approaches infinity. We also establish some model-theoretic properties of the theory $T_{\mathrm{as}}$. △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2022; v1 submitted 4 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: Final version

Journal ref: Bulletin of the London Mathematical Society, Volume 53, Issue 6, December 2021, pp. 1740-1748

Examples of weak amalgamation classes

Authors: Adam Krawczyk, Alex Kruckman, Wiesław Kubiś, Aristotelis Panagiotopoulos

Abstract: We present several examples of hereditary classes of finite structures satisfying the joint embedding property and the weak amalgamation property, but failing the cofinal amalgamation property. These include a continuum-sized family of classes of finite undirected graphs, as well as an example due to Pouzet with countably categorical generic limit. We present several examples of hereditary classes of finite structures satisfying the joint embedding property and the weak amalgamation property, but failing the cofinal amalgamation property. These include a continuum-sized family of classes of finite undirected graphs, as well as an example due to Pouzet with countably categorical generic limit. △ Less

Submitted 13 July, 2021; v1 submitted 22 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: Some additions and tiny corrections; 15 pages

MSC Class: 03C07; 03C50

Interpolative Fusions I

Authors: Alex Kruckman, Minh Chieu Tran, Erik Walsberg

Abstract: We define the interpolative fusion $T^*_\cup$ of a family $(T_i)_{i \in I}$ of first-order theories over a common reduct $T_\cap$, a notion that generalizes many examples of random or generic structures in the model-theoretic literature. When each $T_i$ is model-complete, $T^*_\cup$ coincides with the model companion of $T_\cup = \bigcup_{i \in I} T_i$. By obtaining sufficient conditions for the e… ▽ More We define the interpolative fusion $T^*_\cup$ of a family $(T_i)_{i \in I}$ of first-order theories over a common reduct $T_\cap$, a notion that generalizes many examples of random or generic structures in the model-theoretic literature. When each $T_i$ is model-complete, $T^*_\cup$ coincides with the model companion of $T_\cup = \bigcup_{i \in I} T_i$. By obtaining sufficient conditions for the existence of $T^*_\cup$, we develop new tools to show that theories of interest have model companions. △ Less

Submitted 1 November, 2021; v1 submitted 14 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: Final version, as published in J. Mathematical Logic. This is about half of the first version of this paper, the other half is now in the second paper

Journal ref: Journal of Mathematical Logic, Volume 21, Issue 2, August 2021, Article No. 2150010

Higher dimensional obstructions for star reductions

Authors: Alex Kruckman, Aristotelis Panagiotopoulos

Abstract: A $*$-reduction between two equivalence relations is a Baire measurable reduction which preserves generic notions, i.e., preimages of meager sets are meager. We show that a $*$-reduction between orbit equivalence relations induces generically an embedding between the associated Becker graphs. We introduce a notion of dimension for Polish $G$-spaces which is generically preserved under $*$-reductio… ▽ More A $*$-reduction between two equivalence relations is a Baire measurable reduction which preserves generic notions, i.e., preimages of meager sets are meager. We show that a $*$-reduction between orbit equivalence relations induces generically an embedding between the associated Becker graphs. We introduce a notion of dimension for Polish $G$-spaces which is generically preserved under $*$-reductions. For every natural number $n$ we define a free action of $S_{\infty}$ whose dimension is $n$ on every invariant Baire measurable non-meager set. We also show that the $S_{\infty}$-space which induces the equivalence relation $=^{+}$ of countable sets of reals is $\infty$-dimensional on every invariant Baire measurable non-meager set. We conclude that the orbit equivalence relations associated to all these actions are pairwise incomparable with respect to $*$-reductions. △ Less

Submitted 3 November, 2021; v1 submitted 6 September, 2018; originally announced September 2018.

Comments: 20 pages, 2 figures. Final version

MSC Class: 03E15; 54H20

Journal ref: Fundamenta Mathematicae, Volume 255, Number 2, 2021, pp. 209-230

Exploring the Landscape of Relational Syllogistic Logics

Authors: Alex Kruckman, Lawrence S. Moss

Abstract: This paper explores relational syllogistic logics, a family of logical systems related to reasoning about relations in extensions of the classical syllogistic. These are all decidable logical systems. We prove completeness theorems and complexity results for a natural subfamily of relational syllogistic logics, parametrized by constructors for terms and for sentences. This paper explores relational syllogistic logics, a family of logical systems related to reasoning about relations in extensions of the classical syllogistic. These are all decidable logical systems. We prove completeness theorems and complexity results for a natural subfamily of relational syllogistic logics, parametrized by constructors for terms and for sentences. △ Less

Submitted 3 November, 2021; v1 submitted 3 September, 2018; originally announced September 2018.

Comments: Final version

MSC Class: 03B20; 03B65

Journal ref: The Review of Symbolic Logic 14 (2021) 728-765

Properly ergodic structures

Authors: Nathanael Ackerman, Cameron Freer, Alex Kruckman, Rehana Patel

Abstract: We consider ergodic $\mathrm{Sym}(\mathbb{N})$-invariant probability measures on the space of $L$-structures with domain $\mathbb{N}$ (for $L$ a countable relational language), and call such a measure a properly ergodic structure when no isomorphism class of structures is assigned measure $1$. We characterize those theories in countable fragments of $\mathcal{L}_{ω_1, ω}$ for which there is a prop… ▽ More We consider ergodic $\mathrm{Sym}(\mathbb{N})$-invariant probability measures on the space of $L$-structures with domain $\mathbb{N}$ (for $L$ a countable relational language), and call such a measure a properly ergodic structure when no isomorphism class of structures is assigned measure $1$. We characterize those theories in countable fragments of $\mathcal{L}_{ω_1, ω}$ for which there is a properly ergodic structure concentrated on the models of the theory. We show that for a countable fragment $F$ of $\mathcal{L}_{ω_1, ω}$ the almost-sure $F$-theory of a properly ergodic structure has continuum-many models (an analogue of Vaught's Conjecture in this context), but its full almost-sure $\mathcal{L}_{ω_1, ω}$-theory has no models. We also show that, for an $F$-theory $T$, if there is some properly ergodic structure that concentrates on the class of models of $T$, then there are continuum-many such properly ergodic structures. △ Less

Submitted 25 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 41 pages

Independence in generic incidence structures

Authors: Gabriel Conant, Alex Kruckman

Abstract: We study the theory $T_{m,n}$ of existentially closed incidence structures omitting the complete incidence structure $K_{m,n}$, which can also be viewed as existentially closed $K_{m,n}$-free bipartite graphs. In the case $m = n = 2$, this is the theory of existentially closed projective planes. We give an $\forall\exists$-axiomatization of $T_{m,n}$, show that $T_{m,n}$ does not have a countable… ▽ More We study the theory $T_{m,n}$ of existentially closed incidence structures omitting the complete incidence structure $K_{m,n}$, which can also be viewed as existentially closed $K_{m,n}$-free bipartite graphs. In the case $m = n = 2$, this is the theory of existentially closed projective planes. We give an $\forall\exists$-axiomatization of $T_{m,n}$, show that $T_{m,n}$ does not have a countable saturated model when $m,n\geq 2$, and show that the existence of a prime model for $T_{2,2}$ is equivalent to a longstanding open question about finite projective planes. Finally, we analyze model theoretic notions of complexity for $T_{m,n}$. We show that $T_{m,n}$ is NSOP$_1$, but not simple when $m,n\geq 2$, and we show that $T_{m,n}$ has weak elimination of imaginaries but not full elimination of imaginaries. These results rely on combinatorial characterizations of various notions of independence, including algebraic independence, Kim independence, and forking independence. △ Less

Submitted 22 January, 2019; v1 submitted 27 September, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

Journal ref: J. symb. log. 84 (2019) 750-780

Tameness in least fixed-point logic and McColm's conjecture

Authors: Siddharth Bhaskar, Alex Kruckman

Abstract: We investigate four model-theoretic tameness properties in the context of least fixed-point logic over a family of finite structures. We find that each of these properties depends only on the elementary (i.e., first-order) limit theory, and we completely determine the valid entailments among them. In contrast to the context of first-order logic on arbitrary structures, the order property and indep… ▽ More We investigate four model-theoretic tameness properties in the context of least fixed-point logic over a family of finite structures. We find that each of these properties depends only on the elementary (i.e., first-order) limit theory, and we completely determine the valid entailments among them. In contrast to the context of first-order logic on arbitrary structures, the order property and independence property are equivalent in this setting. McColm conjectured that least fixed-point definability collapses to first-order definability exactly when proficiency fails. McColm's conjecture is known to be false in general. However, we show that McColm's conjecture is true for any family of finite structures whose limit theory is model-theoretically tame. △ Less

Submitted 21 January, 2021; v1 submitted 31 July, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Journal ref: Logical Methods in Computer Science, Volume 17, Issue 1 (January 22, 2021) lmcs:4419

Generic expansion and Skolemization in NSOP$_1$ theories

Authors: Alex Kruckman, Nicholas Ramsey

Abstract: We study expansions of NSOP$_1$ theories that preserve NSOP$_1$. We prove that if $T$ is a model complete NSOP$_1$ theory eliminating the quantifier $\exists^{\infty}$, then the generic expansion of $T$ by arbitrary constant, function, and relation symbols is still NSOP$_1$. We give a detailed analysis of the special case of the theory of the generic $L$-structure, the model companion of the empty… ▽ More We study expansions of NSOP$_1$ theories that preserve NSOP$_1$. We prove that if $T$ is a model complete NSOP$_1$ theory eliminating the quantifier $\exists^{\infty}$, then the generic expansion of $T$ by arbitrary constant, function, and relation symbols is still NSOP$_1$. We give a detailed analysis of the special case of the theory of the generic $L$-structure, the model companion of the empty theory in an arbitrary language $L$. Under the same hypotheses, we show that $T$ may be generically expanded to an NSOP$_1$ theory with built-in Skolem functions. In order to obtain these results, we establish strengthenings of several properties of Kim-independence in NSOP$_1$ theories, adding instances of algebraic independence to their conclusions. △ Less

Submitted 16 September, 2018; v1 submitted 20 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

MSC Class: 03C45; 03C10

Journal ref: Annals of Pure and Applied Logic 169 (2018), no. 8, 755-774

Disjoint $n$-amalgamation and pseudofinite countably categorical theories

Authors: Alex Kruckman

Abstract: Disjoint $n$-amalgamation is a condition on a complete first-order theory specifying that certain locally consistent families of types are also globally consistent. In this paper, we show that if a countably categorical theory $T$ admits an expansion with disjoint $n$-amalgamation for all $n$, then $T$ is pseudofinite. All theories which admit an expansion with disjoint $n$-amalgamation for all… ▽ More Disjoint $n$-amalgamation is a condition on a complete first-order theory specifying that certain locally consistent families of types are also globally consistent. In this paper, we show that if a countably categorical theory $T$ admits an expansion with disjoint $n$-amalgamation for all $n$, then $T$ is pseudofinite. All theories which admit an expansion with disjoint $n$-amalgamation for all $n$ are simple, but the method can be extended, using filtrations of Fraïssé classes, to show that certain non-simple theories are pseudofinite. As case studies, we examine two generic theories of equivalence relations, $T^*_{\text{feq}}$ and $T_{\text{CPZ}}$, and show that both are pseudofinite. The theories $T^*_{\text{feq}}$ and $T_{\text{CPZ}}$ are not simple, but they are NSOP$_1$. This is established here for $T_{\text{CPZ}}$ for the first time. △ Less

Submitted 16 September, 2018; v1 submitted 13 October, 2015; originally announced October 2015.

Comments: revised version, to appear in Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic

MSC Class: 03C13; 03C45

Journal ref: Notre Dame J. Formal Logic 60, no. 1 (2019), 139-160

Actions arising from intersection and union

Authors: Alex Kruckman, Lawrence Valby

Abstract: An action is a pair of sets, $C$ and $S$, and a function $f\colon C\times S \to C$. Rothschild and Yalcin gave a simple axiomatic characterization of those actions arising from set intersection, i.e.\ for which the elements of $C$ and $S$ can be identified with sets in such a way that elements of $S$ act on elements of $C$ by intersection. We introduce and axiomatically characterize two natural cl… ▽ More An action is a pair of sets, $C$ and $S$, and a function $f\colon C\times S \to C$. Rothschild and Yalcin gave a simple axiomatic characterization of those actions arising from set intersection, i.e.\ for which the elements of $C$ and $S$ can be identified with sets in such a way that elements of $S$ act on elements of $C$ by intersection. We introduce and axiomatically characterize two natural classes of actions which arise from set intersection and union. In the first class, the $\uparrow\mathrel{\mspace{-2mu}}\downarrow$-actions, each element of $S$ is identified with a pair of sets $(s^\downarrow,s^\uparrow)$, which act on a set $c$ by intersection with $s^\downarrow$ and union with $s^\uparrow$. In the second class, the $\uparrow\mathrel{\mspace{-2mu}}\downarrow$-biactions, each element of $S$ is labeled as an intersection or a union, and acts accordingly on $C$. We give intuitive examples of these actions, one involving conversations and another a university's changing student body. The examples give some motivation for considering these actions, and also help give intuitive readings of the axioms. The class of $\uparrow\mathrel{\mspace{-2mu}}\downarrow$-actions is closely related to a class of single-sorted algebras, which was previously treated by Margolis et al., albeit in another guise (hyperplane arrangements), and we note this connection. Along the way, we make some useful, though very general, observations about axiomatization and representation problems for classes of algebras. △ Less

Submitted 3 May, 2016; v1 submitted 30 October, 2014; originally announced October 2014.

Comments: Revised version, to appear in Journal of Logic, Language and Information

Journal ref: Journal of Logic, Language and Information, Volume 25, Issue 2, June 2016, pp. 139-161

The Ax-Kochen Theorem: an application of model theory to algebra

Authors: Alex Kruckman

Abstract: The Ax-Kochen Theorem is a purely algebraic statement about the zeros of homogeneous polynomials over the p-adic numbers, but it was originally proved using techniques from mathematical logic. This document, the author's undergraduate honors thesis, provides an exposition of the theorem and its proof via model theory, assuming no previous experience with logic. The Ax-Kochen Theorem is a purely algebraic statement about the zeros of homogeneous polynomials over the p-adic numbers, but it was originally proved using techniques from mathematical logic. This document, the author's undergraduate honors thesis, provides an exposition of the theorem and its proof via model theory, assuming no previous experience with logic. △ Less

Submitted 18 August, 2013; originally announced August 2013.

Comments: Undergraduate honors thesis, 66 pages

Chains of distributions, hierarchical Bayesian models and Benford's Law

Authors: Dennis Jang, Jung Uk Kang, Alex Kruckman, Jun Kudo, Steven J. Miller

Abstract: Kossovsky recently conjectured that the distribution of leading digits of a chain of probability distributions converges to Benford's law as the length of the chain grows. We prove his conjecture in many cases, and provide an interpretation in terms of products of independent random variables and a central limit theorem. An interesting consequence is that in hierarchical Bayesian models priors t… ▽ More Kossovsky recently conjectured that the distribution of leading digits of a chain of probability distributions converges to Benford's law as the length of the chain grows. We prove his conjecture in many cases, and provide an interpretation in terms of products of independent random variables and a central limit theorem. An interesting consequence is that in hierarchical Bayesian models priors tend to satisfy Benford's Law as the number of levels of the hierarchy increases, which allows us to develop some simple tests (based on Benford's law) to test proposed models. We give explicit formulas for the error terms as sums of Mellin transforms, which converges extremely rapidly as the number of terms in the chain grows. We may interpret our results as showing that certain Markov chain Monte Carlo processes are rapidly mixing to Benford's law. △ Less

Submitted 15 June, 2008; v1 submitted 27 May, 2008; originally announced May 2008.

Comments: 15 pages, second draft: added some additional remarks on connections to Hierarchical Bayes and MCMC, fixed some typos, added additional explanations

MSC Class: 11K06; 60A10 (Primary); 62F99 (Secondary)

Journal ref: Journal of Algebra, Number Theory: Advances and Applications, volume 1, number 1 (March 2009), 37--60