-
Calibrating Coupling for Collaboration with Kuramoto
Authors:
Alexander Kalloniatis,
Timothy McLennan-Smith
Abstract:
We calibrate a Kuramoto model inspired representation of peer-to-peer collaboration using data on the maximum team-size where coordination breaks down. The Kuramoto model is modified, normalising the coupling by the degree of input and output nodes, reflecting dispersion of cognitive resources in both absorbing incoming-and tracking outgoing-information. We find a critical point, with loss of sync…
▽ More
We calibrate a Kuramoto model inspired representation of peer-to-peer collaboration using data on the maximum team-size where coordination breaks down. The Kuramoto model is modified, normalising the coupling by the degree of input and output nodes, reflecting dispersion of cognitive resources in both absorbing incoming-and tracking outgoing-information. We find a critical point, with loss of synchronisation as the number of nodes grows and analytically determine this point and calibrate the coupling with the known maximum team size. We test that against the known `span of control' for a leader/supervisor organisation. Our results suggest larger maximum team sizes than early management science proposes, but are consistent with recent studies.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Unifying warfighting functions in mathematical modelling: combat, manoeuvre, and C2
Authors:
Ryan Ahern,
Mathew Zuparic,
Keeley Hoek,
Alexander Kalloniatis
Abstract:
The outcomes of warfare have rarely only been characterised by the quantity and quality of individual combatant force elements. The ability to manoeuvre and adapt across force elements through effective Command and Control (C2) can allow smaller or weaker forces to overcome an adversary with greater resource and fire-power. In this paper, we combine the classic Lanchester combat model with the Kur…
▽ More
The outcomes of warfare have rarely only been characterised by the quantity and quality of individual combatant force elements. The ability to manoeuvre and adapt across force elements through effective Command and Control (C2) can allow smaller or weaker forces to overcome an adversary with greater resource and fire-power. In this paper, we combine the classic Lanchester combat model with the Kuramoto-Sakaguchi model for phase oscillators on a network to create a flexible Networked-Lanchester-C2 representation of force-on-force military engagement. The mathematical model thus unifies three of the military warfighting `functions': fires, manoeuvre and C2. We consider three illustrative use-cases, and show that an analytical treatment of a reduced model characterises global effects in the full system. For inhomogeneous forces we observe that with appropriate balance between internal organisational coupling, resource manoeuvrability and even weaker lethality the force can be adaptive to overcome an initially stronger adversary.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Mathematical modelling of decision cycles in a competitive environment with neutral parties
Authors:
Timothy McLennan-Smith,
Alexander Kalloniatis,
Simon Watt,
Zlatko Jovanoski,
Harvinder Sidhu,
Dale Roberts,
Isaac Towers
Abstract:
Decision making is a human process that is a fundamental part of competition. As a realisation of decision making, Command and Control, or C2, has been studied in the literature for adversarial populations, yet these models do not explicitly capture competition. Our work here seeks to enrich such competition models by extending ecologically inspired population models to include decision dynamics t…
▽ More
Decision making is a human process that is a fundamental part of competition. As a realisation of decision making, Command and Control, or C2, has been studied in the literature for adversarial populations, yet these models do not explicitly capture competition. Our work here seeks to enrich such competition models by extending ecologically inspired population models to include decision dynamics through coupling with a nonlinear system of oscillators (the Kuramoto equation) to model the action-perception cycle in decision making. Through asymmetric competition models of increasing complexity, we highlight the importance of competitive agility and decision making processes necessary for a population to be successful.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2023; v1 submitted 13 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Modelling host population support for combat adversaries
Authors:
Mathew Zuparic,
Sergiy Shelyag,
Maia Angelova,
Ye Zhu,
Alexander Kalloniatis
Abstract:
We consider a model of adversarial dynamics consisting of three populations, labelled Blue, Green and Red, which evolve under a system of first order nonlinear differential equations. Red and Blue populations are adversaries and interact via a set of Lanchester combat laws. Green is divided into three sub-populations: Red supporters, Blue supporters and Neutral. Green support for Red and Blue lead…
▽ More
We consider a model of adversarial dynamics consisting of three populations, labelled Blue, Green and Red, which evolve under a system of first order nonlinear differential equations. Red and Blue populations are adversaries and interact via a set of Lanchester combat laws. Green is divided into three sub-populations: Red supporters, Blue supporters and Neutral. Green support for Red and Blue leads to more combat effectiveness for either side. From Green's perspective, if either Red or Blue exceed a size according to the capacity of the local population to facilitate or tolerate, then support for that side diminishes; the corresponding Green population reverts to the neutral sub-population, who do not contribute to combat effectiveness of either side. The mechanism for supporters deciding if either Blue or Red are too big is given by a logistic-type interaction term. The intent of the model is to examine the role of influence in complex adversarial situations typical in counter-insurgency, where victory requires a genuine balance between maintaining combat effectiveness and support from a third party whose backing is not always assured.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Optimising structure in a networked Lanchester Model for Fires and Manoeuvre in Warfare
Authors:
Alexander Kalloniatis,
Keeley Hoek,
Mathew Zuparic,
Markus Brede
Abstract:
We present a generalisation of the classical Lanchester model for directed fire between two combat forces but now employing networks for the manoeuvre of Blue and Red forces, and the pattern of engagement between the two. The model therefore integrates fires between dispersed elements, as well as manoeuvre through an internal-to-each-side diffusive interaction. We explain the model with several si…
▽ More
We present a generalisation of the classical Lanchester model for directed fire between two combat forces but now employing networks for the manoeuvre of Blue and Red forces, and the pattern of engagement between the two. The model therefore integrates fires between dispersed elements, as well as manoeuvre through an internal-to-each-side diffusive interaction. We explain the model with several simple examples, including cases where conservation laws hold. We then apply an optimisation approach where, for a fixed-in-structure adversary, we optimise the internal manoeuvre and external engagement structures where the trade-off between maximising damage on the adversary and minimising own-losses can be examined. In the space of combat outcomes this leads to a sequence of transitions from defeat to stalemate and then to victory for the force with optimised networks. Depending on the trade-off between destruction and self-preservation, the optimised networks develop a number of structures including the appearance of so-called sacrificial nodes, that may be interpreted as feints, manoeuvre hubs, and suppressive fires. We discuss these in light of Manoeuvre Warfare theory.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Sparse Network Optimization for Synchronization
Authors:
Regina S. Burachik,
Alexander C. Kalloniatis,
C. Yalçın Kaya
Abstract:
We propose new mathematical optimization models for generating sparse dynamical graphs, or networks, that can achieve synchronization. The synchronization phenomenon is studied using the Kuramoto model, defined in terms of the adjacency matrix of the graph and the coupling strength of the network, modelling the so-called coupled oscillators. Besides sparsity, we aim to obtain graphs which have goo…
▽ More
We propose new mathematical optimization models for generating sparse dynamical graphs, or networks, that can achieve synchronization. The synchronization phenomenon is studied using the Kuramoto model, defined in terms of the adjacency matrix of the graph and the coupling strength of the network, modelling the so-called coupled oscillators. Besides sparsity, we aim to obtain graphs which have good connectivity properties, resulting in small coupling strength for synchronization. We formulate three mathematical optimization models for this purpose. Our first model is a mixed integer optimization problem, subject to ODE constraints, reminiscent of an optimal control problem. As expected, this problem is computationally very challenging, if not impossible, to solve, not only because it involves binary variables but also some of its variables are functions. The second model is a continuous relaxation of the first one, and the third is a discretization of the second, which is computationally tractable by employing standard optimization software. We design dynamical graphs that synchronize, by solving the relaxed problem and applying a practical algorithm for various graph sizes, with randomly generated intrinsic natural frequencies and initial phase variables. We test robustness of these graphs by carrying out numerical simulations with random data and constructing the expected value of the network's order parameter and its variance under this random data, as a guide for assessment.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2020; v1 submitted 30 May, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Gaussian noise and the two-network frustrated Kuramoto model
Authors:
A. B. Holder,
M. L. Zuparic,
A. C. Kalloniatis
Abstract:
We examine analytically and numerically a variant of the stochastic Kuramoto model for phase oscillators coupled on a general network. Two populations of phased oscillators are considered, labelled `Blue' and `Red', each with their respective networks, internal and external couplings, natural frequencies, and frustration parameters in the dynamical interactions of the phases. We disentagle the dif…
▽ More
We examine analytically and numerically a variant of the stochastic Kuramoto model for phase oscillators coupled on a general network. Two populations of phased oscillators are considered, labelled `Blue' and `Red', each with their respective networks, internal and external couplings, natural frequencies, and frustration parameters in the dynamical interactions of the phases. We disentagle the different ways that additive Gaussian noise may influence the dynamics by applying it separately on zero modes or normal modes corresponding to a Laplacian decomposition for the sub-graphs for Blue and Red. Under the linearisation ansatz that the oscillators of each respective network remain relatively phase-sychronised centroids or clusters, we are able to obtain simple closed-form expressions using the Fokker-Planck approach for the dynamics of the average angle of the two centroids. In some cases, this leads to subtle effects of metastability that we may analytically describe using the theory of ratchet potentials. These considerations are extended to a regime where one of the populations has fragmented in two. The analytic expressions we derive largely predict the dynamics of the non-linear system seen in numerical simulation. In particular, we find that noise acting on a more tightly coupled population allows for improved synchronisation of the other population where deterministically it is fragmented.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Fixed points and stability in the two-network frustrated Kuramoto model
Authors:
A. C. Kalloniatis,
M. L. Zuparic
Abstract:
We examine a modification of the Kuramoto model for phase oscillators coupled on a network. Here, two populations of oscillators are considered, each with different network topologies, internal and cross-network couplings and frequencies. Additionally, frustration parameters for the interactions of the cross-network phases are introduced. This may be regarded as a model of competing populations: i…
▽ More
We examine a modification of the Kuramoto model for phase oscillators coupled on a network. Here, two populations of oscillators are considered, each with different network topologies, internal and cross-network couplings and frequencies. Additionally, frustration parameters for the interactions of the cross-network phases are introduced. This may be regarded as a model of competing populations: internal to any one network phase synchronisation is a target state, while externally one or both populations seek to frequency synchronise to a phase in relation to the competitor. We conduct fixed point analyses for two regimes: one, where internal phase synchronisation occurs for each population with the potential for instability in the phase of one population in relation to the other; the second where one part of a population remains fixed in phase in relation to the other population, but where instability may occur within the first population leading to `fragmentation'. We compare analytic results to numerical solutions for the system at various critical thresholds.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
