-
Snort Played on Triangular Grids
Authors:
Melanie Gauthier,
Svenja Huntemann
Abstract:
Snort is a two-player game played on a simple graph in which the players take turns colouring vertices in their own colour, with the restriction that two adjacent vertices cannot have opposite colours. We will show that on triangular grids with one or two rows of triangles, and many of their variants, the first player will win when playing optimally.
Snort is a two-player game played on a simple graph in which the players take turns colouring vertices in their own colour, with the restriction that two adjacent vertices cannot have opposite colours. We will show that on triangular grids with one or two rows of triangles, and many of their variants, the first player will win when playing optimally.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
High Temperature Domineering Positions
Authors:
Svenja Huntemann,
Tomasz Maciosowski
Abstract:
Domineering is a partizan game where two players have a collection of dominoes which they place on the grid in turn, covering up squares. One player places tiles vertically, while the other places them horizontally; the first player who cannot move loses. It has been conjectured that the highest temperature possible in Domineering is 2. We have developed a program that enables a parallel exhaustiv…
▽ More
Domineering is a partizan game where two players have a collection of dominoes which they place on the grid in turn, covering up squares. One player places tiles vertically, while the other places them horizontally; the first player who cannot move loses. It has been conjectured that the highest temperature possible in Domineering is 2. We have developed a program that enables a parallel exhaustive search of Domineering positions with temperatures close to or equal to 2 to allow for analysis of such positions
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Degrees are Useless in SNORT When Measuring Temperature
Authors:
Svenja Huntemann,
Tomasz Maciosowski
Abstract:
Snort is a two-player game played on a simple graph in which players alternately colour a vertex such that they do not colour adjacent to their opponents' vertex. In combinatorial game theory, the temperature of a position is a measure of the urgency of moving first. It is known that the temperature of \snort in general is infinite ($K_{1,n}$ has temperature $n$). We show that the temperature in a…
▽ More
Snort is a two-player game played on a simple graph in which players alternately colour a vertex such that they do not colour adjacent to their opponents' vertex. In combinatorial game theory, the temperature of a position is a measure of the urgency of moving first. It is known that the temperature of \snort in general is infinite ($K_{1,n}$ has temperature $n$). We show that the temperature in addition can be infinitely larger than the degree of the board being played on. We do so by constructing a family of positions in which the temperature grows twice as fast as the degree of the board.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
A Tractability Gap Beyond Nim-Sums: It's Hard to Tell Whether a Bunch of Superstars Are Losers
Authors:
Kyle Burke,
Matthew Ferland,
Svenja Huntemann,
Shang-Hua Teng
Abstract:
In this paper, we address a natural question at the intersection of combinatorial game theory and computational complexity: "Can a sum of simple tepid games in canonical form be intractable?" To resolve this fundamental question, we consider superstars, positions first introduced in Winning Ways where all options are nimbers. Extending Morris' classic result with hot games to tepid games, we prove…
▽ More
In this paper, we address a natural question at the intersection of combinatorial game theory and computational complexity: "Can a sum of simple tepid games in canonical form be intractable?" To resolve this fundamental question, we consider superstars, positions first introduced in Winning Ways where all options are nimbers. Extending Morris' classic result with hot games to tepid games, we prove that disjunctive sums of superstars are intractable to solve. This is striking as sums of nimbers can be computed in linear time. Our analyses also lead to a family of elegant board games with intriguing complexity, for which we present web-playable versions of the rulesets described within.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
The Polynomial Profile of Distance Games on Paths and Cycles
Authors:
Svenja Huntemann,
Lexi A. Nash
Abstract:
Distance games are games played on graphs in which the players alternately colour vertices, and which vertices can be coloured only depends on the distance to previously coloured vertices. The polynomial profile encodes the number of positions with a fixed number of vertices from each player. We extend previous work on finding the polynomial profile of several distance games (Col, Snort, and Cis)…
▽ More
Distance games are games played on graphs in which the players alternately colour vertices, and which vertices can be coloured only depends on the distance to previously coloured vertices. The polynomial profile encodes the number of positions with a fixed number of vertices from each player. We extend previous work on finding the polynomial profile of several distance games (Col, Snort, and Cis) played on paths. We give recursions and generating functions for the polynomial profiles of generalizations of these three games when played on paths. We also find the polynomial profile of Cis played on cycles and the total number of positions of Col and Snort on cycles, as well as pose a conjecture about the number of positions when playing Col and Snort on complete bipartite graphs.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
The combinatorial game nofil played on Steiner Triple Systems
Authors:
Melissa A. Huggan,
Svenja Huntemann,
Brett Stevens
Abstract:
We introduce an impartial combinatorial game on Steiner triple systems called Nofil. Players move alternately, choosing points of the triple system. If a player is forced to fill a block on their turn, they lose. We explore the play of Nofil on all Steiner triple systems up to order 15 and a sampling for orders 19, 21, and 25. We determine the optimal strategies by computing the nim-values for eac…
▽ More
We introduce an impartial combinatorial game on Steiner triple systems called Nofil. Players move alternately, choosing points of the triple system. If a player is forced to fill a block on their turn, they lose. We explore the play of Nofil on all Steiner triple systems up to order 15 and a sampling for orders 19, 21, and 25. We determine the optimal strategies by computing the nim-values for each game and its subgames. The game Nofil can be thought of in terms of play on a corresponding hypergraph. As game play progresses, the hypergraph shrinks and will eventually be equivalent to playing the game Node Kayles on an isomorphic graph. Node Kayles is well studied and understood. Motivated by this, we study which Node Kayles positions can be reached, i.e. embedded into a Steiner triple system. We prove necessary conditions and sufficient conditions for the existence of such graph embeddings and conclude that the complexity of determining the outcome of the game Nofil on Steiner triple systems is PSPACE-complete.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Counting Domineering Positions
Authors:
Svenja Huntemann,
Neil A. McKay
Abstract:
Domineering is a two player game played on a checkerboard in which one player places dominoes vertically and the other places them horizontally. We give bivariate generating polynomials enumerating Domineering positions by the number of each player's pieces. We enumerate all positions, maximal positions, and positions where one player has no move. Using these polynomials we count the number of pos…
▽ More
Domineering is a two player game played on a checkerboard in which one player places dominoes vertically and the other places them horizontally. We give bivariate generating polynomials enumerating Domineering positions by the number of each player's pieces. We enumerate all positions, maximal positions, and positions where one player has no move. Using these polynomials we count the number of positions that occur during alternating play. Our method extends to enumerating positions from mid-game positions and we include an analysis of a tournament game.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2020; v1 submitted 26 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Game Values of Strong Placement Games
Authors:
Svenja Huntemann
Abstract:
The legal positions of a strong placement game, such as Domineering, form a simplicial complex called the legal complex. In this paper, we use the legal complex to study the game values taken on by the class of strong placement games using the legal complex. We show that many interesting values are possible, including all numbers and nimbers. We further consider how structures of the legal complex…
▽ More
The legal positions of a strong placement game, such as Domineering, form a simplicial complex called the legal complex. In this paper, we use the legal complex to study the game values taken on by the class of strong placement games using the legal complex. We show that many interesting values are possible, including all numbers and nimbers. We further consider how structures of the legal complex influence which values are possible.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Bounding Game Temperature Using Confusion Intervals
Authors:
Svenja Huntemann,
Richard J. Nowakowski,
Carlos Pereira dos Santos
Abstract:
For combinatorial games, temperature is a measure of the volatility, that is, by how much the advantage can change. Typically, the temperature has been measured for individual positions within specific games. In this paper, we give the first general upper bounds on the temperature for any class of games.
For a position $G$, the closure of the set of numbers $\{g\}$ such that $G-g$ is a first pla…
▽ More
For combinatorial games, temperature is a measure of the volatility, that is, by how much the advantage can change. Typically, the temperature has been measured for individual positions within specific games. In this paper, we give the first general upper bounds on the temperature for any class of games.
For a position $G$, the closure of the set of numbers $\{g\}$ such that $G-g$ is a first player win, is called the confusion interval of $G$. Let $\ell(G)$ be the length of this interval. Our first main result is: For a class of games $\mathscr{S}$, if there are constants $J$ and $K$ such that $\ell(G^L),\ell(G^R)\leq J$ and $\ell(G)\leq K$ for for every $G\in \mathscr{S}$, then the temperature of every game is bounded by $K/2+J$. We give an example to show that this bound is tight.
Our second main result is a method to find a bound for the confusion intervals. In $G^L-G$ when Left gets to go first, the number of passing moves required by Right to win gives an upper bound on $\ell(G)$.
This is the first general upper bound on temperature. As examples of the bound and the method, we give upper bounds on the temperature of subclasses of Domineering and Snort.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Simplicial Complexes are Game Complexes
Authors:
Sara Faridi,
Svenja Huntemann,
Richard J. Nowakowski
Abstract:
Strong placement games (SP-games) are a class of combinatorial games whose structure allows one to describe the game via simplicial complexes. A natural question is whether well-known invariants of combinatorial games, such as "game value", appear as invariants of the simplicial complexes. This paper is the first step in that direction. We show that every simplicial complex encodes a certain type…
▽ More
Strong placement games (SP-games) are a class of combinatorial games whose structure allows one to describe the game via simplicial complexes. A natural question is whether well-known invariants of combinatorial games, such as "game value", appear as invariants of the simplicial complexes. This paper is the first step in that direction. We show that every simplicial complex encodes a certain type of SP-game (called an "invariant SP-game") whose ruleset is independent of the board it is played on. We also show that in the class of SP-games isomorphic simplicial complexes correspond to isomorphic game trees, and hence equal game values. We also study a subclass of SP-games corresponding to flag complexes, showing that there is always a game whose corresponding complex is a flag complex no matter which board it is played on.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2019; v1 submitted 19 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Keeping Your Distance is Hard
Authors:
Kyle Burke,
Silvia Heubach,
Melissa Huggan,
Svenja Huntemann
Abstract:
We study the computational complexity of distance games, a class of combinatorial games played on graphs. A move consists of colouring an uncoloured vertex subject to it not being at certain distances determined by two sets, D and S. D is the set of forbidden distances for colouring vertices in different colors, while S is the set of forbidden distances for the same colour. The last player to move…
▽ More
We study the computational complexity of distance games, a class of combinatorial games played on graphs. A move consists of colouring an uncoloured vertex subject to it not being at certain distances determined by two sets, D and S. D is the set of forbidden distances for colouring vertices in different colors, while S is the set of forbidden distances for the same colour. The last player to move wins. Well-known examples of distance games are Node-Kayles, Snort, and Col, whose complexities were shown to be PSPACE-hard. We show that many more distance games are also PSPACE-hard.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2019; v1 submitted 22 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Games and Complexes II: Weight Games and Kruskal-Katona Type Bounds
Authors:
Sara Faridi,
Svenja Huntemann,
Richard J. Nowakowski
Abstract:
A strong placement game $G$ played on a board $B$ is equivalent to a simplicial complex $Δ_{G,B}$. We look at weight games, a subclass of strong placement games, and introduce upper bounds on the number of positions with $i$ pieces in $G$, or equivalently the number of faces with $i$ vertices in $Δ_{G,B}$, which are reminiscent of the Kruskal-Katona bounds.
A strong placement game $G$ played on a board $B$ is equivalent to a simplicial complex $Δ_{G,B}$. We look at weight games, a subclass of strong placement games, and introduce upper bounds on the number of positions with $i$ pieces in $G$, or equivalently the number of faces with $i$ vertices in $Δ_{G,B}$, which are reminiscent of the Kruskal-Katona bounds.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2015; v1 submitted 4 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Games and Complexes I: Transformation via Ideals
Authors:
Sara Faridi,
Svenja Huntemann,
Richard J. Nowakowski
Abstract:
Placement games are a subclass of combinatorial games which are played on graphs. We will demonstrate that one can construct simplicial complexes corresponding to a placement game, and this game could be considered as a game played on these simplicial complexes. These complexes are constructed using square-free monomials.
Placement games are a subclass of combinatorial games which are played on graphs. We will demonstrate that one can construct simplicial complexes corresponding to a placement game, and this game could be considered as a game played on these simplicial complexes. These complexes are constructed using square-free monomials.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2015; v1 submitted 4 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
