Showing 1–14 of 14 results for author: Goldblatt, R

Strong completeness of a first-order temporal logic for real time

Authors: Robert Goldblatt

Abstract: Propositional temporal logic over the real number time flow is finitely axiomatisable, but its first-order counterpart is not recursively axiomatisable. We study the logic that combines the propositional axiomatisation with the usual axioms for first-order logic with identity, and develop an alternative ``admissible'' semantics for it, showing that it is strongly complete for admissible models ove… ▽ More Propositional temporal logic over the real number time flow is finitely axiomatisable, but its first-order counterpart is not recursively axiomatisable. We study the logic that combines the propositional axiomatisation with the usual axioms for first-order logic with identity, and develop an alternative ``admissible'' semantics for it, showing that it is strongly complete for admissible models over the reals. By contrast there is no recursive axiomatisation of the first-order temporal logic of admissible models whose time flow is the integers, or any scattered linear ordering. △ Less

Submitted 30 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

MSC Class: 03B44

Canonicity in power and modal logics of finite achronal width

Authors: Robert Goldblatt, Ian Hodkinson

Abstract: We develop a method for showing that various modal logics that are valid in their countably generated canonical Kripke frames must also be valid in their uncountably generated ones. This is applied to many systems, including the logics of finite width, and a broader class of multimodal logics of `finite achronal width' that are introduced here. We develop a method for showing that various modal logics that are valid in their countably generated canonical Kripke frames must also be valid in their uncountably generated ones. This is applied to many systems, including the logics of finite width, and a broader class of multimodal logics of `finite achronal width' that are introduced here. △ Less

Submitted 25 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

MSC Class: 03B45; 06E25

Journal ref: The Review of Symbolic Logic 17 (2024) 705-735

Completeness of Pledger's modal logics of one-sorted projective and elliptic planes

Authors: Robert Goldblatt

Abstract: Ken Pledger devised a one-sorted approach to the incidence relation of plane geometries, using structures that also support models of propositional modal logic. He introduced a modal system 12g that is valid in one-sorted projective planes, proved that it has finitely many non-equivalent modalities, and identified all possible modality patterns of its extensions. One of these extensions 8f is vali… ▽ More Ken Pledger devised a one-sorted approach to the incidence relation of plane geometries, using structures that also support models of propositional modal logic. He introduced a modal system 12g that is valid in one-sorted projective planes, proved that it has finitely many non-equivalent modalities, and identified all possible modality patterns of its extensions. One of these extensions 8f is valid in elliptic planes. These results were presented in his doctoral dissertation [14], which has been reprinted in the Australasian Journal of Logic, vol. 18, no. 4. https://doi.org/10.26686/ajl.v18i4.6831 Here we show that 12g and 8f are strongly complete for validity in their intended one-sorted geometrical interpretations, and have the finite model property. The proofs apply standard technology of modal logic (canonical models, filtrations) together with a step-by-step procedure introduced by Yde Venema for constructing two-sorted projective planes. △ Less

Submitted 24 May, 2021; v1 submitted 30 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

MSC Class: 03B45; 51A05; 15M10

Journal ref: Australasian Journal of Logic, vol. 18 no. 4, 2021, pp.106-131

Modal Logics of Some Hereditarily Irresolvable Spaces

Authors: Robert Goldblatt

Abstract: A topological space is \emph{hereditarily $k$-irresolvable} if none of its subspaces can be partitioned into $k$ dense subsets, We use this notion to provide a topological semantics for a sequence of modal logics whose $n$-th member K4$\mathbb{C}_n$ is characterised by validity in transitive Kripke frames of circumference at most $n$. We show that under the interpretation of the modality… ▽ More A topological space is \emph{hereditarily $k$-irresolvable} if none of its subspaces can be partitioned into $k$ dense subsets, We use this notion to provide a topological semantics for a sequence of modal logics whose $n$-th member K4$\mathbb{C}_n$ is characterised by validity in transitive Kripke frames of circumference at most $n$. We show that under the interpretation of the modality $\Diamond$ as the derived set (of limit points) operation, K4$\mathbb{C}_n$ is characterised by validity in all spaces that are hereditarily $n+1$-irresolvable and have the T$_D$ separation property. We also identify the extensions of K4$\mathbb{C}_n$ that result when the class of spaces involved is restricted to those that are weakly scattered, or crowded, or openly irresolvable, the latter meaning that every non-empty open subspace is 2-irresolvable. Finally we give a topological semantics for K4M, where M is the McKinsey axiom. △ Less

Submitted 30 September, 2020; v1 submitted 29 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

MSC Class: 03B45; 54F99

Journal ref: In "Alasdair Urquhart on Nonclassical and Algebraic Logic and Complexity of Proofs", edited by I. Duntsch and E. Mares, Springer, 2022, pp. 303-322

Modal Logics that Bound the Circumference of Transitive Frames

Authors: Robert Goldblatt

Abstract: For each natural number $n$ we study the modal logic determined by the class of transitive Kripke frames in which there are no cycles of length greater than $n$ and no strictly ascending chains. The case $n=0$ is the Gödel-Löb provability logic. Each logic is axiomatised by adding a single axiom to K4, and is shown to have the finite model property and be decidable. We then consider a number of… ▽ More For each natural number $n$ we study the modal logic determined by the class of transitive Kripke frames in which there are no cycles of length greater than $n$ and no strictly ascending chains. The case $n=0$ is the Gödel-Löb provability logic. Each logic is axiomatised by adding a single axiom to K4, and is shown to have the finite model property and be decidable. We then consider a number of extensions of these logics, including restricting to reflexive frames to obtain a corresponding sequence of extensions of S4. When $n=1$, this gives the famous logic of Grzegorczyk, known as S4Grz, which is the strongest modal companion to intuitionistic propositional logic. A topological semantic analysis shows that the $n$-th member of the sequence of extensions of S4 is the logic of hereditarily $n+1$-irresolvable spaces when the modality $\Diamond$ is interpreted as the topological closure operation. We also study the definability of this class of spaces under the interpretation of $\Diamond$ as the derived set (of limit points) operation. The variety of modal algebras validating the $n$-th logic is shown to be generated by the powerset algebras of the finite frames with cycle length bounded by $n$. Moreover each algebra in the variety is a model of the universal theory of the finite ones, and so is embeddable into an ultraproduct of them. △ Less

Submitted 4 September, 2019; v1 submitted 28 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Journal ref: In "Hajnal Andréka and István Németi on Unity of Science: From Computing to Relativity Theory Through Algebraic Logic", edited by Judit Madarász and Gergely Székely, Springer, 2021, pp. 233-265

Strong completeness of modal logics over 0-dimensional metric spaces

Authors: Robert Goldblatt, Ian Hodkinson

Abstract: We prove strong completeness results for some modal logics with the universal modality, with respect to their topological semantics over 0-dimensional dense-in-themselves metric spaces. We also use failure of compactness to show that, for some languages and spaces, no standard modal deductive system is strongly complete. We prove strong completeness results for some modal logics with the universal modality, with respect to their topological semantics over 0-dimensional dense-in-themselves metric spaces. We also use failure of compactness to show that, for some languages and spaces, no standard modal deductive system is strongly complete. △ Less

Submitted 28 November, 2019; v1 submitted 9 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

MSC Class: 03B45; 54E35

Journal ref: The Review of Symbolic Logic 13 (2020) 611-632

Morphisms and Duality for Polarities and Lattices with Operators

Authors: Robert Goldblatt

Abstract: Structures based on polarities have been used to provide relational semantics for propositional logics that are modelled algebraically by non-distributive lattices with additional operators. This article develops a first order notion of morphism between polarity-based structures that generalises the theory of bounded morphisms for Boolean modal logics. It defines a category of such structures that… ▽ More Structures based on polarities have been used to provide relational semantics for propositional logics that are modelled algebraically by non-distributive lattices with additional operators. This article develops a first order notion of morphism between polarity-based structures that generalises the theory of bounded morphisms for Boolean modal logics. It defines a category of such structures that is contravariantly dual to a given category of lattice-based algebras whose additional operations preserve either finite joins or finite meets. Two different versions of the Goldblatt-Thomason theorem are derived in this setting. △ Less

Submitted 10 April, 2019; v1 submitted 26 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Journal ref: Journal of Applied Logics, Volume 7, no. 6, December 2020, pp. 1019-1072. Open access at www.collegepublications.co.uk/ifcolog/?00042

Definable operators on stable set lattices

Authors: Robert Goldblatt

Abstract: A fundamental result from Boolean modal logic states that a first-order definable class of Kripke frames defines a logic that is validated by all of its canonical frames. We generalise this to the level of non-distributive logics that have a relational semantics provided by structures based on polarities. Such structures have associated complete lattices of stable subsets, and these have been used… ▽ More A fundamental result from Boolean modal logic states that a first-order definable class of Kripke frames defines a logic that is validated by all of its canonical frames. We generalise this to the level of non-distributive logics that have a relational semantics provided by structures based on polarities. Such structures have associated complete lattices of stable subsets, and these have been used to construct canonical extensions of lattice-based algebras. We study classes of structures that are closed under ultraproducts and whose stable set lattices have additional operators that are first-order definable in the underlying structure. We show that such classes generate varieties of algebras that are closed under canonical extensions. The proof makes use of a relationship between canonical extensions and MacNeille completions. △ Less

Submitted 7 February, 2020; v1 submitted 4 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Comments: 18 pages

MSC Class: 03G10; 06B23; 03C20; 06A15; 06D50

Journal ref: Studia Logica, published online 5 February 2020

Canonical extensions and ultraproducts of polarities

Authors: Robert Goldblatt

Abstract: J{ó}nsson and Tarski's notion of the perfect extension of a Boolean algebra with operators has evolved into an extensive theory of canonical extensions of lattice-based algebras. After reviewing this evolution we make two contributions. First it is shown that the failure of a variety of algebras to be closed under canonical extensions is witnessed by a particular one of its free algebras. The size… ▽ More J{ó}nsson and Tarski's notion of the perfect extension of a Boolean algebra with operators has evolved into an extensive theory of canonical extensions of lattice-based algebras. After reviewing this evolution we make two contributions. First it is shown that the failure of a variety of algebras to be closed under canonical extensions is witnessed by a particular one of its free algebras. The size of the set of generators of this algebra can be made a function of a collection of varieties and is a kind of Hanf number for canonical closure. Secondly we study the complete lattice of stable subsets of a polarity structure, and show that if a class of polarities is closed under ultraproducts, then its stable set lattices generate a variety that is closed under canonical extensions. This generalises an earlier result of the author about generation of canonically closed varieties of Boolean algebras with operators, which was in turn an abstraction of the result that a first-order definable class of Kripke frames determines a modal logic that is valid in its so-called canonical frames. △ Less

Submitted 20 August, 2018; v1 submitted 28 September, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

MSC Class: 00A99 (Primary); 08A40; 06E30 (Secondary)

Journal ref: Algebra Universalis, Volume 79, Issue 4, 2018

Cover Systems for the Modalities of Linear Logic

Authors: Robert Goldblatt

Abstract: Ono's modal FL-algebras are models of an extension of Full Lambek logic that has the modalities ! and ? of linear logic. Here we define a notion of modal FL-cover system that combines aspects of Beth-Kripke-Joyal semantics with Girard's interpretation of the ! modality, and has structured subsets that interpret propositions. We show that any modal FL-algebra can be represented as an algebra of pro… ▽ More Ono's modal FL-algebras are models of an extension of Full Lambek logic that has the modalities ! and ? of linear logic. Here we define a notion of modal FL-cover system that combines aspects of Beth-Kripke-Joyal semantics with Girard's interpretation of the ! modality, and has structured subsets that interpret propositions. We show that any modal FL-algebra can be represented as an algebra of propositions of some modal FL-cover system. △ Less

Submitted 28 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

MSC Class: 03B47; 03B45; 03G10

Journal ref: In "Hiroakira Ono on Residuated Lattices and Substructural Logics", edited by N. Galatos and K. Terui, Springer, 2022, pp. 299-318

Tangled Closure Algebras

Authors: Robert Goldblatt, Ian Hodkinson

Abstract: The tangled closure of a collection of subsets of a topological space is the largest subset in which each member of the collection is dense. This operation models a logical `tangle modality' connective, of significance in finite model theory. Here we study an abstract equational algebraic formulation of the operation which generalises the McKinsey-Tarski theory of closure algebras. We show that an… ▽ More The tangled closure of a collection of subsets of a topological space is the largest subset in which each member of the collection is dense. This operation models a logical `tangle modality' connective, of significance in finite model theory. Here we study an abstract equational algebraic formulation of the operation which generalises the McKinsey-Tarski theory of closure algebras. We show that any dissectable tangled closure algebra, such as the algebra of subsets of any metric space without isolated points, contains copies of every finite tangled closure algebra. We then exhibit an example of a tangled closure algebra that cannot be embedded into any complete tangled closure algebra, so it has no MacNeille completion and no spatial representation. △ Less

Submitted 19 September, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

MSC Class: 03G25; 06E25; 06B23; 54H10

Journal ref: Categories and General Algebraic Structures with Applications, Volume 7, 2017, pp. 9-31, http://cgasa.ir/volume_5757.html

Fine's Theorem on First-Order Complete Modal Logics

Authors: Robert Goldblatt

Abstract: Fine's influential Canonicity Theorem states that if a modal logic is determined by a first-order definable class of Kripke frames, then it is valid in its canonical frames. This article reviews the background and context of this result, and the history of its impact on further research. It then develops a new characterisation of when a logic is canonically valid, providing a precise point of dist… ▽ More Fine's influential Canonicity Theorem states that if a modal logic is determined by a first-order definable class of Kripke frames, then it is valid in its canonical frames. This article reviews the background and context of this result, and the history of its impact on further research. It then develops a new characterisation of when a logic is canonically valid, providing a precise point of distinction with the property of first-order completeness. The ultimate point is that the construction of the canonical frame of a modal algebra does not commute with the ultrapower construction. △ Less

Submitted 24 January, 2017; v1 submitted 7 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

MSC Class: 03B45; 03C20; 06E25

Journal ref: In 'Metaphysics, Meaning and Modality. Themes from Kit Fine', edited by Mircea Dumitru, Oxford University Press 2020, pp. 316-334

Spatial logic of modal mu-calculus and tangled closure operators

Authors: Robert Goldblatt, Ian Hodkinson

Abstract: There has been renewed interest in recent years in McKinsey and Tarski's interpretation of modal logic in topological spaces and their proof that S4 is the logic of any separable dense-in-itself metric space. Here we extend this work to the modal mu-calculus and to a logic of tangled closure operators that was developed by Fernández-Duque after these two languages had been shown by Dawar and Otto… ▽ More There has been renewed interest in recent years in McKinsey and Tarski's interpretation of modal logic in topological spaces and their proof that S4 is the logic of any separable dense-in-itself metric space. Here we extend this work to the modal mu-calculus and to a logic of tangled closure operators that was developed by Fernández-Duque after these two languages had been shown by Dawar and Otto to have the same expressive power over finite transitive Kripke models. We prove that this equivalence remains true over topological spaces. We establish the finite model property in Kripke semantics for various tangled closure logics with and without the universal modality $\forall$. We also extend the McKinsey--Tarski topological `dissection lemma'. These results are used to construct a representation map (also called a d-p-morphism) from any dense-in-itself metric space $X$ onto any finite connected locally connected serial transitive Kripke frame. This yields completeness theorems over $X$ for a number of languages: (i) the modal mu-calculus with the closure operator $\Diamond$; (ii) $\Diamond$ and the tangled closure operators $\langle t \rangle$; (iii) $\Diamond,\forall$; (iv) $\Diamond,\forall,\langle t \rangle$; (v) the derivative operator $\langle d \rangle$; (vi) $\langle d \rangle$ and the associated tangled closure operators $\langle dt \rangle$; (vii) $\langle d \rangle,\forall$; (viii) $\langle d \rangle,\forall,\langle dt \rangle$. Soundness also holds, if: (a) for languages with $\forall$, $X$ is connected; and (b) for languages with $\langle d \rangle$, $X$ validates the well known axiom $\mathrm{G}_1$. For countable languages without $\forall$, we prove strong completeness. We also show that in the presence of $\forall$, strong completeness fails if $X$ is compact and locally connected. △ Less

Submitted 5 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

MSC Class: 03B45; 54E35 ACM Class: F.4.1; I.2.4

Journal ref: Part I: Studia Logica, Volume 106, Issue 1, February 2018, 131-166; Part II: Annals of Pure and Applied Logic, Volume 168, Issue 5, May 2017, 1032-1090

Well structured program equivalence is highly undecidable

Authors: Robert Goldblatt, Marcel Jackson

Abstract: We show that strict deterministic propositional dynamic logic with intersection is highly undecidable, solving a problem in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. In fact we show something quite a bit stronger. We introduce the construction of program equivalence, which returns the value $\mathsf{T}$ precisely when two given programs are equivalent on halting computations. We show that virtually… ▽ More We show that strict deterministic propositional dynamic logic with intersection is highly undecidable, solving a problem in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. In fact we show something quite a bit stronger. We introduce the construction of program equivalence, which returns the value $\mathsf{T}$ precisely when two given programs are equivalent on halting computations. We show that virtually any variant of propositional dynamic logic has $Π_1^1$-hard validity problem if it can express even just the equivalence of well-structured programs with the empty program \texttt{skip}. We also show, in these cases, that the set of propositional statements valid over finite models is not recursively enumerable, so there is not even an axiomatisation for finitely valid propositions. △ Less

Submitted 7 March, 2011; originally announced March 2011.

Comments: 8 pages

Journal ref: ACM Transactions on Computational Logic, Volume 13 Issue 3, Article 26, August 2012