-
Cartesian closed varieties II: links to algebra and self-similarity
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
This paper is the second in a series investigating cartesian closed varieties. In first of these, we showed that every non-degenerate finitary cartesian variety is a variety of sets equipped with an action by a Boolean algebra B and a monoid M which interact to form what we call a matched pair [B|M]. In this paper, we show that such pairs [B|M] are equivalent to Boolean restriction monoids and als…
▽ More
This paper is the second in a series investigating cartesian closed varieties. In first of these, we showed that every non-degenerate finitary cartesian variety is a variety of sets equipped with an action by a Boolean algebra B and a monoid M which interact to form what we call a matched pair [B|M]. In this paper, we show that such pairs [B|M] are equivalent to Boolean restriction monoids and also to ample source-étale topological categories; these are generalisations of the Boolean inverse monoids and ample étale topological groupoids used to encode self-similar structures such as Cuntz and Cuntz--Krieger $C^\ast$-algebras, Leavitt path algebras and the $C^\ast$-algebras associated to self-similar group actions. We explain and illustrate these links, and begin the programme of understanding how topological and algebraic properties of such groupoids can be understood from the logical perspective of the associated varieties.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2024; v1 submitted 8 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Cartesian closed varieties I: the classification theorem
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
In 1990, Johnstone gave a syntactic characterisation of the equational theories whose associated varieties are cartesian closed. Among such theories are all unary theories -- whose models are sets equipped with an action by a monoid M -- and all hyperaffine theories -- whose models are sets with an action by a Boolean algebra B. We improve on Johnstone's result by showing that an equational theory…
▽ More
In 1990, Johnstone gave a syntactic characterisation of the equational theories whose associated varieties are cartesian closed. Among such theories are all unary theories -- whose models are sets equipped with an action by a monoid M -- and all hyperaffine theories -- whose models are sets with an action by a Boolean algebra B. We improve on Johnstone's result by showing that an equational theory is cartesian closed just when its operations have a unique hyperaffine-unary decomposition. It follows that any non-degenerate cartesian closed variety is a variety of sets equipped with compatible actions by a monoid M and a Boolean algebra B; this is the classification theorem of the title.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2023; v1 submitted 8 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Monoidal Kleisli Bicategories and the Arithmetic Product of Coloured Symmetric Sequences
Authors:
Nicola Gambino,
Richard Garner,
Christina Vasilakopoulou
Abstract:
We extend the arithmetic product of species of structures and symmetric sequences studied by Maia and Mendez and by Dwyer and Hess to coloured symmetric sequences and show that it determines a normal oplax monoidal structure on the bicategory of coloured symmetric sequences. In order to do this, we establish general results on extending monoidal structures to Kleisli bicategories. Our approach use…
▽ More
We extend the arithmetic product of species of structures and symmetric sequences studied by Maia and Mendez and by Dwyer and Hess to coloured symmetric sequences and show that it determines a normal oplax monoidal structure on the bicategory of coloured symmetric sequences. In order to do this, we establish general results on extending monoidal structures to Kleisli bicategories. Our approach uses monoidal double categories, which help us to attack the difficult problem of verifying the coherence conditions for a monoidal bicategory in an efficient way.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2024; v1 submitted 14 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Functorial aggregation
Authors:
David I. Spivak,
Richard Garner,
Aaron David Fairbanks
Abstract:
We study polynomial comonads and polynomial bicomodules. Polynomial comonads amount to categories. Polynomial bicomodules between categories amount to parametric right adjoint functors between corresponding copresheaf categories. These may themselves be understood as generalized polynomial functors. They are also called data migration functors because of applications in categorical database theory…
▽ More
We study polynomial comonads and polynomial bicomodules. Polynomial comonads amount to categories. Polynomial bicomodules between categories amount to parametric right adjoint functors between corresponding copresheaf categories. These may themselves be understood as generalized polynomial functors. They are also called data migration functors because of applications in categorical database theory. We investigate several universal constructions in the framed bicategory of categories, retrofunctors, and parametric right adjoints. We then use the theory we develop to model database aggregation alongside querying, all within this rich ecosystem.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2025; v1 submitted 21 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Stream processors and comodels
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
In 2009, Hancock, Pattinson and Ghani gave a coalgebraic characterisation of stream processors $A^\mathbb{N} \to B^\mathbb{N}$ drawing on ideas of Brouwerian constructivism. Their stream processors have an intensional character; in this paper, we give a corresponding coalgebraic characterisation of extensional stream processors, i.e., the set of continuous functions…
▽ More
In 2009, Hancock, Pattinson and Ghani gave a coalgebraic characterisation of stream processors $A^\mathbb{N} \to B^\mathbb{N}$ drawing on ideas of Brouwerian constructivism. Their stream processors have an intensional character; in this paper, we give a corresponding coalgebraic characterisation of extensional stream processors, i.e., the set of continuous functions $A^\mathbb{N} \to B^\mathbb{N}$. Our account sites both our result and that of op. cit. within the apparatus of comodels for algebraic effects originating with Power-Shkaravska. Within this apparatus, the distinction between intensional and extensional equivalence for stream processors arises in the same way as the the distinction between bisimulation and trace equivalence for labelled transition systems and probabilistic generative systems.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2023; v1 submitted 9 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
An Essential Local Geometric Morphism which is not Locally Connected though its Inverse Image Part defines an Exponential Ideal
Authors:
Richard Garner,
Thomas Streicher
Abstract:
We describe an essential local geometric morphism which is not locally connected, though its inverse image part defines an exponential ideal
We describe an essential local geometric morphism which is not locally connected, though its inverse image part defines an exponential ideal
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2022; v1 submitted 21 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
The costructure-cosemantics adjunction for comodels for computational effects
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
It is well established that equational algebraic theories, and the monads they generate, can be used to encode computational effects. An important insight of Power and Shkaravska is that comodels of an algebraic theory T -- i.e., models in the opposite category Set^op -- provide a suitable environment for evaluating the computational effects encoded by T. As already noted by Power and Shkaravska,…
▽ More
It is well established that equational algebraic theories, and the monads they generate, can be used to encode computational effects. An important insight of Power and Shkaravska is that comodels of an algebraic theory T -- i.e., models in the opposite category Set^op -- provide a suitable environment for evaluating the computational effects encoded by T. As already noted by Power and Shkaravska, taking comodels yields a functor from accessible monads to accessible comonads on Set. In this paper, we show that this functor is part of an adjunction -- the "costructure-cosemantics adjunction" of the title -- and undertake a thorough investigation of its properties.
We show that, on the one hand, the cosemantics functor takes its image in what we term the presheaf comonads induced by small categories; and that, on the other, costructure takes its image in the presheaf monads induced by small categories. In particular, the cosemantics comonad of an accessible monad will be induced by an explicitly-described category called its behaviour category that encodes the static and dynamic properties of the comodels. Similarly, the costructure monad of an accessible comonad will be induced by a behaviour category encoding static and dynamic properties of the comonad coalgebras. We tie these results together by showing that the costructure-cosemantics adjunction is idempotent, with fixpoints to either side given precisely by the presheaf monads and comonads. Along the way, we illustrate the value of our results with numerous examples drawn from computation and mathematics.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Generalising the étale groupoid--complete pseudogroup correspondence
Authors:
Robin Cockett,
Richard Garner
Abstract:
We prove a generalisation of the correspondence, due to Resende and Lawson--Lenz, between étale groupoids---which are topological groupoids whose source map is a local homeomorphisms---and complete pseudogroups---which are inverse monoids equipped with a particularly nice representation on a topological space.
Our generalisation improves on the existing functorial correspondence in four ways. Fi…
▽ More
We prove a generalisation of the correspondence, due to Resende and Lawson--Lenz, between étale groupoids---which are topological groupoids whose source map is a local homeomorphisms---and complete pseudogroups---which are inverse monoids equipped with a particularly nice representation on a topological space.
Our generalisation improves on the existing functorial correspondence in four ways. Firstly, we enlarge the classes of maps appearing to each side. Secondly, we generalise on one side from inverse monoids to inverse categories, and on the other side, from étale groupoids to what we call partite étale groupoids. Thirdly, we generalise from étale groupoids to source-étale categories, and on the other side, from inverse monoids to restriction monoids. Fourthly, and most far-reachingly, we generalise from topological étale groupoids to étale groupoids internal to any join restriction category C with local glueings; and on the other side, from complete pseudogroups to ``complete C-pseudogroups'', i.e., inverse monoids with a nice representation on an object of C. Taken together, our results yield an equivalence, for a join restriction category C with local glueings, between join restriction categories with a well-behaved functor to C, and partite source-étale internal categories in C. In fact, we obtain this by cutting down a larger adjunction between arbitrary restriction categories over C, and partite internal categories in C.
Beyond proving this main result, numerous applications are given, which reconstruct and extend existing correspondences in the literature, and provide general formulations of completion processes.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Cartesian differential categories as skew enriched categories
Authors:
Richard Garner,
Jean-Simon Pacaud Lemay
Abstract:
We exhibit the cartesian differential categories of Blute, Cockett and Seely as a particular kind of enriched category. The base for the enrichment is the category of commutative monoids -- or in a straightforward generalisation, the category of modules over a commutative rig $k$. However, the tensor product on this category is not the usual one, but rather a warping of it by a certain monoidal co…
▽ More
We exhibit the cartesian differential categories of Blute, Cockett and Seely as a particular kind of enriched category. The base for the enrichment is the category of commutative monoids -- or in a straightforward generalisation, the category of modules over a commutative rig $k$. However, the tensor product on this category is not the usual one, but rather a warping of it by a certain monoidal comonad $Q$. Thus the enrichment base is not a monoidal category in the usual sense, but rather a skew monoidal category in the sense of Szlachányi. Our first main result is that cartesian differential categories are the same as categories with finite products enriched over this skew monoidal base.
The comonad $Q$ involved is, in fact, an example of a differential modality. Differential modalities are a kind of comonad on a symmetric monoidal $k$-linear category with the characteristic feature that their co-Kleisli categories are cartesian differential categories. Using our first main result, we are able to prove our second one: that every small cartesian differential category admits a full, structure-preserving embedding into the cartesian differential category induced by a differential modality (in fact, a monoidal differential modality on a monoidal closed category -- thus, a model of intuitionistic differential linear logic). This resolves an important open question in this area.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2021; v1 submitted 6 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Inner automorphisms of groupoids
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
Bergman has given the following abstract characterisation of the inner automorphisms of a group $G$: they are exactly those automorphisms of $G$ which can be extended functorially along any homomorphism $G \rightarrow H$ to an automorphism of $H$. This leads naturally to a definition of "inner automorphism" applicable to the objects of any category. Bergman and Hofstra--Parker--Scott have computed…
▽ More
Bergman has given the following abstract characterisation of the inner automorphisms of a group $G$: they are exactly those automorphisms of $G$ which can be extended functorially along any homomorphism $G \rightarrow H$ to an automorphism of $H$. This leads naturally to a definition of "inner automorphism" applicable to the objects of any category. Bergman and Hofstra--Parker--Scott have computed these inner automorphisms for various structures including $k$-algebras, monoids, lattices, unital rings, and quandles---showing that, in each case, they are given by an obvious notion of conjugation.
In this note, we compute the inner automorphisms of groupoids, showing that they are exactly the automorphisms induced by conjugation by a bisection. The twist is that this result is false in the category of groupoids and homomorphisms; to make it true, we must instead work with the less familiar category of groupoids and comorphisms in the sense of Higgins and Mackenzie. Besides our main result, we also discuss generalisations to topological and Lie groupoids, to categories and to partial automorphisms, and examine the link with the theory of inverse semigroups.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Every 2-Segal space is unital
Authors:
Matthew Feller,
Richard Garner,
Joachim Kock,
May U. Proulx,
Mark Weber
Abstract:
We prove that every 2-Segal space is unital.
We prove that every 2-Segal space is unital.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2019; v1 submitted 23 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Operadic categories and décalage
Authors:
Richard Garner,
Joachim Kock,
Mark Weber
Abstract:
Batanin and Markl's operadic categories are categories in which each map is endowed with a finite collection of "abstract fibres" -- also objects of the same category -- subject to suitable axioms. We give a reconstruction of the data and axioms of operadic categories in terms of the décalage comonad D on small categories. A simple case involves unary operadic categories -- ones wherein each map h…
▽ More
Batanin and Markl's operadic categories are categories in which each map is endowed with a finite collection of "abstract fibres" -- also objects of the same category -- subject to suitable axioms. We give a reconstruction of the data and axioms of operadic categories in terms of the décalage comonad D on small categories. A simple case involves unary operadic categories -- ones wherein each map has exactly one abstract fibre -- which are exhibited as categories which are, first of all, coalgebras for the comonad D, and, furthermore, algebras for the monad induced on the category of D-coalgebras by the forgetful-cofree adjunction. A similar description is found for general operadic categories arising out of a corresponding analysis that starts from a "modified décalage" comonad on the arrow category of Cat.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Abstract hypernormalisation, and normalisation-by-trace-evaluation for generative systems
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
Jacobs' hypernormalisation is a construction on finitely supported discrete probability distributions, obtained by generalising certain patterns occurring in quantitative information theory. In this paper, we generalise Jacobs' notion in turn, by describing a notion of hypernormalisation in the abstract setting of a symmetric monoidal category endowed with a linear exponential monad -- a structure…
▽ More
Jacobs' hypernormalisation is a construction on finitely supported discrete probability distributions, obtained by generalising certain patterns occurring in quantitative information theory. In this paper, we generalise Jacobs' notion in turn, by describing a notion of hypernormalisation in the abstract setting of a symmetric monoidal category endowed with a linear exponential monad -- a structure arising in the categorical semantics of linear logic. We show that Jacobs' hypernormalisation arises in this fashion from the finitely supported probability measure monad on the category of sets, which can be seen as a linear exponential monad with respect to a non-standard monoidal structure on sets which we term the convex monoidal structure. We give the construction of this monoidal structure in terms of a quantum-algebraic notion known as a tricocycloid. Besides the motivating example, and its natural generalisations to the continuous context, we give a range of other instances of our abstract hypernormalisation, which swap out the side-effect of probabilistic choice for other important side-effects such as non-deterministic choice, logical choice via tests in a Boolean algebra, and input from a stream of values. Finally, we exploit our framework to describe a normalisation-by-trace-evaluation process for behaviours of various kinds of coalgebraic generative systems, including labelled transition systems, probabilistic generative systems, and stream processors.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2022; v1 submitted 6 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
The Vietoris monad and weak distributive laws
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
The Vietoris monad on the category of compact Hausdorff spaces is a topological analogue of the power-set monad on the category of sets. Exploiting Manes' characterisation of the compact Hausdorff spaces as algebras for the ultrafilter monad on sets, we give precise form to the above analogy by exhibiting the Vietoris monad as induced by a weak distributive law, in the sense of Böhm, of the power-…
▽ More
The Vietoris monad on the category of compact Hausdorff spaces is a topological analogue of the power-set monad on the category of sets. Exploiting Manes' characterisation of the compact Hausdorff spaces as algebras for the ultrafilter monad on sets, we give precise form to the above analogy by exhibiting the Vietoris monad as induced by a weak distributive law, in the sense of Böhm, of the power-set monad over the ultrafilter monad.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2020; v1 submitted 1 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Ultrafilters, finite coproducts and locally connected classifying toposes
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
We prove a single category-theoretic result encapsulating the notions of ultrafilters, ultrapower, ultraproduct, tensor product of ultrafilters, the Rudin--Kiesler partial ordering on ultrafilters, and Blass's category of ultrafilters UF. The result in its most basic form states that the category FC(Set,Set) of finite-coproduct-preserving endofunctors of Set is equivalent to the presheaf category…
▽ More
We prove a single category-theoretic result encapsulating the notions of ultrafilters, ultrapower, ultraproduct, tensor product of ultrafilters, the Rudin--Kiesler partial ordering on ultrafilters, and Blass's category of ultrafilters UF. The result in its most basic form states that the category FC(Set,Set) of finite-coproduct-preserving endofunctors of Set is equivalent to the presheaf category [UF,Set]. Using this result, and some of its evident generalisations, we re-find in a natural manner the important model-theoretic realisation relation between n-types and n-tuples of model elements; and draw connections with Makkai and Lurie's work on conceptual completeness for first-order logic via ultracategories.
As a further application of our main result, we use it to describe a first-order analogue of Jónsson and Tarski's canonical extension. Canonical extension is an algebraic formulation of the link between Lindenbaum--Tarski and Kripke semantics for intuitionistic and modal logic, and extending it to first-order logic has precedent in the topos of types construction studied by Joyal, Reyes, Makkai, Pitts, Coumans and others. Here, we study the closely related, but distinct, construction of the locally connected classifying topos of a first-order theory. The existence of this is known from work of Funk, but the description is inexplicit; ours, by contrast, is quite concrete.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2020; v1 submitted 27 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Monads and theories
Authors:
John Bourke,
Richard Garner
Abstract:
Given a locally presentable enriched category $\mathcal{E}$ together with a small dense full subcategory $\mathcal A$ of arities, we study the relationship between monads on $\mathcal E$ and identity-on-objects functors out of $\mathcal A$, which we call $\mathcal A$-pretheories. We show that the natural constructions relating these two kinds of structure form an adjoint pair. The fixpoints of the…
▽ More
Given a locally presentable enriched category $\mathcal{E}$ together with a small dense full subcategory $\mathcal A$ of arities, we study the relationship between monads on $\mathcal E$ and identity-on-objects functors out of $\mathcal A$, which we call $\mathcal A$-pretheories. We show that the natural constructions relating these two kinds of structure form an adjoint pair. The fixpoints of the adjunction are characterised as the $\mathcal A$-nervous monads---those for which the conclusions of Weber's nerve theorem hold---and the $\mathcal A$-theories, which we introduce here.
The resulting equivalence between $\mathcal A$-nervous monads and $\mathcal A$-theories is best possible in a precise sense, and extends almost all previously known monad--theory correspondences. It also establishes some completely new correspondences, including one which captures the globular theories defining Grothendieck weak $ω$-groupoids.
Besides establishing our general correspondence and illustrating its reach, we study good properties of $\mathcal A$-nervous monads and $\mathcal A$-theories that allow us to recognise and construct them with ease. We also compare them with the monads with arities and theories with arities introduced and studied by Berger, Melliès and Weber.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2020; v1 submitted 11 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Lifting accessible model structures
Authors:
Richard Garner,
Magdalena Kedziorek,
Emily Riehl
Abstract:
A Quillen model structure is presented by an interacting pair of weak factorization systems. We prove that in the world of locally presentable categories, any weak factorization system with accessible functorial factorizations can be lifted along either a left or a right adjoint. It follows that accessible model structures on locally presentable categories - ones admitting accessible functorial fa…
▽ More
A Quillen model structure is presented by an interacting pair of weak factorization systems. We prove that in the world of locally presentable categories, any weak factorization system with accessible functorial factorizations can be lifted along either a left or a right adjoint. It follows that accessible model structures on locally presentable categories - ones admitting accessible functorial factorizations, a class that includes all combinatorial model structures but others besides - can be lifted along either a left or a right adjoint if and only if an essential "acyclicity" condition holds. A similar result was claimed in a paper of Hess-Kedziorek-Riehl-Shipley, but the proof given there was incorrect. In this note, we explain this error and give a correction, and also provide a new statement and a different proof of the theorem which is more tractable for homotopy-theoretic applications.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Bousfield localisation and colocalisation of one-dimensional model structures
Authors:
Scott Balchin,
Richard Garner
Abstract:
We give an account of Bousfield localisation and colocalisation for one-dimensional model categories---ones enriched over the model category of $0$-types. A distinguishing feature of our treatment is that it builds localisations and colocalisations using only the constructions of projective and injective transfer of model structures along right and left adjoint functors, and without any reference…
▽ More
We give an account of Bousfield localisation and colocalisation for one-dimensional model categories---ones enriched over the model category of $0$-types. A distinguishing feature of our treatment is that it builds localisations and colocalisations using only the constructions of projective and injective transfer of model structures along right and left adjoint functors, and without any reference to Smith's theorem.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2020; v1 submitted 8 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
An enriched view on the extended finitary monad--Lawvere theory correspondence
Authors:
Richard Garner,
John Power
Abstract:
We give a new account of the correspondence, first established by Nishizawa--Power, between finitary monads and Lawvere theories over an arbitrary locally finitely presentable base. Our account explains this correspondence in terms of enriched category theory: the passage from a finitary monad to the corresponding Lawvere theory is exhibited as an instance of free completion of an enriched categor…
▽ More
We give a new account of the correspondence, first established by Nishizawa--Power, between finitary monads and Lawvere theories over an arbitrary locally finitely presentable base. Our account explains this correspondence in terms of enriched category theory: the passage from a finitary monad to the corresponding Lawvere theory is exhibited as an instance of free completion of an enriched category under a class of absolute colimits. This extends work of the first author, who established the result in the special case of finitary monads and Lawvere theories over the category of sets; a novel aspect of the generalisation is its use of enrichment over a bicategory, rather than a monoidal category, in order to capture the monad--theory correspondence over all locally finitely presentable bases simultaneously.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2018; v1 submitted 26 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
An embedding theorem for tangent categories
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
Tangent categories were introduced by Rosicky as a categorical setting for differential structures in algebra and geometry; in recent work of Cockett, Crutwell and others, they have also been applied to the study of differential structure in computer science. In this paper, we prove that every tangent category admits an embedding into a representable tangent category---one whose tangent structure…
▽ More
Tangent categories were introduced by Rosicky as a categorical setting for differential structures in algebra and geometry; in recent work of Cockett, Crutwell and others, they have also been applied to the study of differential structure in computer science. In this paper, we prove that every tangent category admits an embedding into a representable tangent category---one whose tangent structure is given by exponentiating by a free-standing tangent vector, as in, for example, any model of Kock and Lawvere's synthetic differential geometry. The key step in our proof uses a coherence theorem for tangent categories due to Leung to exhibit tangent categories as a certain kind of enriched category.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2020; v1 submitted 26 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Cocompletion of restriction categories
Authors:
Richard Garner,
Daniel Lin
Abstract:
Restriction categories were introduced as a way of generalising the notion of partial map categories. In this paper, we define cocomplete restriction category, and give the free cocompletion of a small restriction category as a suitably defined category of restriction presheaves. We also consider the case where our restriction category is locally small.
Restriction categories were introduced as a way of generalising the notion of partial map categories. In this paper, we define cocomplete restriction category, and give the free cocompletion of a small restriction category as a suitably defined category of restriction presheaves. We also consider the case where our restriction category is locally small.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Shapely monads and analytic functors
Authors:
Richard Garner,
Tom Hirschowitz
Abstract:
In this paper, we give precise mathematical form to the idea of a structure whose data and axioms are faithfully represented by a graphical calculus; some prominent examples are operads, polycategories, properads, and PROPs. Building on the established presentation of such structures as algebras for monads on presheaf categories, we describe a characteristic property of the associated monads---the…
▽ More
In this paper, we give precise mathematical form to the idea of a structure whose data and axioms are faithfully represented by a graphical calculus; some prominent examples are operads, polycategories, properads, and PROPs. Building on the established presentation of such structures as algebras for monads on presheaf categories, we describe a characteristic property of the associated monads---the shapeliness of the title---which says that "any two operations of the same shape agree". An important part of this work is the study of analytic functors between presheaf categories, which are a common generalisation of Joyal's analytic endofunctors on sets and of the parametric right adjoint functors on presheaf categories introduced by Diers and studied by Carboni--Johnstone, Leinster and Weber. Our shapely monads will be found among the analytic endofunctors, and may be characterised as the submonads of a universal analytic monad with "exactly one operation of each shape". In fact, shapeliness also gives a way to define the data and axioms of a structure directly from its graphical calculus, by generating a free shapely monad on the basic operations of the calculus. In this paper we do this for some of the examples listed above; in future work, we intend to do so for graphical calculi such as Milner's bigraphs, Lafont's interaction nets, or Girard's multiplicative proof nets, thereby obtaining canonical notions of denotational model.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2017; v1 submitted 18 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Hochschild homology, lax codescent, and duplicial structure
Authors:
Richard Garner,
Stephen Lack,
Paul Slevin
Abstract:
We study the duplicial objects of Dwyer and Kan, which generalize the cyclic objects of Connes. We describe duplicial objects in terms of the decalage comonads, and we give a conceptual account of the construction of duplicial objects due to Bohm and Stefan. This is done in terms of a 2-categorical generalization of Hochschild homology. We also study duplicial structure on nerves of categories, bi…
▽ More
We study the duplicial objects of Dwyer and Kan, which generalize the cyclic objects of Connes. We describe duplicial objects in terms of the decalage comonads, and we give a conceptual account of the construction of duplicial objects due to Bohm and Stefan. This is done in terms of a 2-categorical generalization of Hochschild homology. We also study duplicial structure on nerves of categories, bicategories, and monoidal categories.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Coalgebras governing both weighted Hurwitz products and their pointwise transforms
Authors:
Richard Garner,
Ross Street
Abstract:
We give further insights into the weighted Hurwitz product and the weighted tensor product of Joyal species. Our first group of results relate the Hurwitz product to the pointwise product, including the interaction with Rota--Baxter operators. Our second group of results explain the first in terms of convolution with suitable bialgebras, and show that these bialgebras are in fact obtained in a par…
▽ More
We give further insights into the weighted Hurwitz product and the weighted tensor product of Joyal species. Our first group of results relate the Hurwitz product to the pointwise product, including the interaction with Rota--Baxter operators. Our second group of results explain the first in terms of convolution with suitable bialgebras, and show that these bialgebras are in fact obtained in a particularly straightforward way by freely generating from pointed coalgebras. Our third group of results extend this from linear algebra to two-dimensional linear algebra, deriving the existence of weighted Hurwitz monoidal structures on the category of species using convolution with freely generated bimonoidales. Our final group of results relate Hurwitz monoidal structures with equivalences of of Dold--Kan type.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Orientals and cubes, inductively
Authors:
Mitchell Buckley,
Richard Garner
Abstract:
We provide direct inductive constructions of the orientals and the cubes, exhibiting them as the iterated cones, respectively, the iterated cylinders, of the terminal strict globular omega-category.
We provide direct inductive constructions of the orientals and the cubes, exhibiting them as the iterated cones, respectively, the iterated cylinders, of the terminal strict globular omega-category.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2015; v1 submitted 2 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Commutativity
Authors:
Richard Garner,
Ignacio López Franco
Abstract:
We describe a general framework for notions of commutativity based on enriched category theory. We extend Eilenberg and Kelly's tensor product for categories enriched over a symmetric monoidal base to a tensor product for categories enriched over a normal duoidal category; using this, we re-find notions such as the commutativity of a finitary algebraic theory or a strong monad, the commuting tenso…
▽ More
We describe a general framework for notions of commutativity based on enriched category theory. We extend Eilenberg and Kelly's tensor product for categories enriched over a symmetric monoidal base to a tensor product for categories enriched over a normal duoidal category; using this, we re-find notions such as the commutativity of a finitary algebraic theory or a strong monad, the commuting tensor product of two theories, and the Boardman-Vogt tensor product of symmetric operads.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2015; v1 submitted 30 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
When coproducts are biproducts
Authors:
Richard Garner,
Daniel Schäppi
Abstract:
Among right-closed monoidal categories with finite coproducts, we characterise those with finite biproducts as being precisely those in which the initial object and the coproduct of the unit with itself admit right duals. This generalises Houston's result that any compact closed category with finite coproducts admits biproducts.
Among right-closed monoidal categories with finite coproducts, we characterise those with finite biproducts as being precisely those in which the initial object and the coproduct of the unit with itself admit right duals. This generalises Houston's result that any compact closed category with finite coproducts admits biproducts.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2016; v1 submitted 7 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Algebraic weak factorisation systems II: categories of weak maps
Authors:
John Bourke,
Richard Garner
Abstract:
We investigate the categories of weak maps associated to an algebraic weak factorisation system (AWFS) in the sense of Grandis-Tholen. For any AWFS on a category with an initial object, cofibrant replacement forms a comonad, and the category of (left) weak maps associated to the AWFS is by definition the Kleisli category of this comonad. We exhibit categories of weak maps as a kind of "homotopy ca…
▽ More
We investigate the categories of weak maps associated to an algebraic weak factorisation system (AWFS) in the sense of Grandis-Tholen. For any AWFS on a category with an initial object, cofibrant replacement forms a comonad, and the category of (left) weak maps associated to the AWFS is by definition the Kleisli category of this comonad. We exhibit categories of weak maps as a kind of "homotopy category", that freely adjoins a section for every "acyclic fibration" (=right map) of the AWFS; and using this characterisation, we give an alternate description of categories of weak maps in terms of spans with left leg an acyclic fibration. We moreover show that the 2-functor sending each AWFS on a suitable category to its cofibrant replacement comonad has a fully faithful right adjoint: so exhibiting the theory of comonads, and dually of monads, as incorporated into the theory of AWFS. We also describe various applications of the general theory: to the generalised sketches of Kinoshita-Power-Takeyama, to the two-dimensional monad theory of Blackwell-Kelly-Power, and to the theory of dg-categories.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2015; v1 submitted 19 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Algebraic weak factorisation systems I: accessible AWFS
Authors:
John Bourke,
Richard Garner
Abstract:
Algebraic weak factorisation systems (AWFS) refine weak factorisation systems by requiring that the assignations sending a map to its first and second factors should underlie an interacting comonad--monad pair on the arrow category. We provide a comprehensive treatment of the basic theory of AWFS---drawing on work of previous authors---and complete the theory with two main new results. The first p…
▽ More
Algebraic weak factorisation systems (AWFS) refine weak factorisation systems by requiring that the assignations sending a map to its first and second factors should underlie an interacting comonad--monad pair on the arrow category. We provide a comprehensive treatment of the basic theory of AWFS---drawing on work of previous authors---and complete the theory with two main new results. The first provides a characterisation of AWFS and their morphisms in terms of their double categories of left or right maps. The second concerns a notion of cofibrant generation of an AWFS by a small double category; it states that, over a locally presentable base, any small double category cofibrantly generates an AWFS, and that the AWFS so arising are precisely those with accessible monad and comonad. Besides the general theory, numerous applications of AWFS are developed, emphasising particularly those aspects which go beyond the non-algebraic situation.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2015; v1 submitted 19 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
The Isbell monad
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
In 1966, John Isbell introduced a construction on categories which he termed the "couple category" but which has since come to be known as the Isbell envelope. The Isbell envelope, which combines the ideas of contravariant and covariant presheaves, has found applications in category theory, logic, and differential geometry. We clarify its meaning by exhibiting the assignation sending a locally sma…
▽ More
In 1966, John Isbell introduced a construction on categories which he termed the "couple category" but which has since come to be known as the Isbell envelope. The Isbell envelope, which combines the ideas of contravariant and covariant presheaves, has found applications in category theory, logic, and differential geometry. We clarify its meaning by exhibiting the assignation sending a locally small category to its Isbell envelope as the action on objects of a pseudomonad on the 2-category of locally small categories; this is the Isbell monad of the title. We characterise the pseudoalgebras of the Isbell monad as categories equipped with a cylinder factorisation system; this notion, which appears to be new, is an extension of Freyd and Kelly's notion of factorisation system from orthogonal classes of arrows to orthogonal classes of cocones and cones.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Diagrammatic characterisation of enriched absolute colimits
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
We provide a diagrammatic criterion for the existence of an absolute colimit in the context of enriched category theory.
We provide a diagrammatic criterion for the existence of an absolute colimit in the context of enriched category theory.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Combinatorial structure of type dependency
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
We give an account of the basic combinatorial structure underlying the notion of type dependency. We do so by considering the category of all dependent sequent calculi, and exhibiting it as the category of algebras for a monad on a presheaf category. The objects of the presheaf category encode the basic judgements of a dependent sequent calculus, while the action of the monad encodes the deduction…
▽ More
We give an account of the basic combinatorial structure underlying the notion of type dependency. We do so by considering the category of all dependent sequent calculi, and exhibiting it as the category of algebras for a monad on a presheaf category. The objects of the presheaf category encode the basic judgements of a dependent sequent calculus, while the action of the monad encodes the deduction rules; so by giving an explicit description of the monad, we obtain an explicit account of the combinatorics of type dependency. We find that this combinatorics is controlled by a particular kind of decorated ordered tree, familiar from computer science and from innocent game semantics. Furthermore, we find that the monad at issue is of a particularly well-behaved kind: it is local right adjoint in the sense of Street--Weber. In future work, we will use this fact to describe nerves for dependent type theories, and to study the coherence problem for dependent type theory using the tools of two-dimensional monad theory.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Topological = total
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
A notion of central importance in categorical topology is that of topological functor. A faithful functor E -> B is called topological if it admits cartesian liftings of all (possibly large) families of arrows; the basic example is the forgetful functor Top -> Set. A topological functor E -> 1 is the same thing as a (large) complete preorder, and the general topological functor E -> B is intuitive…
▽ More
A notion of central importance in categorical topology is that of topological functor. A faithful functor E -> B is called topological if it admits cartesian liftings of all (possibly large) families of arrows; the basic example is the forgetful functor Top -> Set. A topological functor E -> 1 is the same thing as a (large) complete preorder, and the general topological functor E -> B is intuitively thought of as a complete preorder relative to B. We make this intuition precise by considering an enrichment base Q_B such that Q_B-enriched categories are faithful functors into B, and show that, in this context, a faithful functor is topological if and only if it is total (=totally cocomplete) in the sense of Street--Walters. We also consider the MacNeille completion of a faithful functor to a topological one, first described by Herrlich, and show that it may be obtained as an instance of Isbell's generalised notion of MacNeille completion for enriched categories.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2013; v1 submitted 3 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
The Catalan simplicial set
Authors:
Mitchell Buckley,
Richard Garner,
Stephen Lack,
Ross Street
Abstract:
The Catalan numbers are well-known to be the answer to many different counting problems, and so there are many different families of sets whose cardinalities are the Catalan numbers. We show how such a family can be given the structure of a simplicial set. We show how the low-dimensional parts of this simplicial set classify, in a precise sense, the structures of monoid and of monoidal category. T…
▽ More
The Catalan numbers are well-known to be the answer to many different counting problems, and so there are many different families of sets whose cardinalities are the Catalan numbers. We show how such a family can be given the structure of a simplicial set. We show how the low-dimensional parts of this simplicial set classify, in a precise sense, the structures of monoid and of monoidal category. This involves aspects of combinatorics, algebraic topology, quantum groups, logic, and category theory.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2014; v1 submitted 24 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Lawvere theories, finitary monads and Cauchy-completion
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
We consider the equivalence of Lawvere theories and finitary monads on Set from the perspective of Endf(Set)-enriched category theory, where Endf(Set) is the category of finitary endofunctors of Set. We identify finitary monads with one-object Endf(Set)-categories, and ordinary categories admitting finite powers (i.e., n-fold products of each object with itself) with Endf(Set)-categories admitting…
▽ More
We consider the equivalence of Lawvere theories and finitary monads on Set from the perspective of Endf(Set)-enriched category theory, where Endf(Set) is the category of finitary endofunctors of Set. We identify finitary monads with one-object Endf(Set)-categories, and ordinary categories admitting finite powers (i.e., n-fold products of each object with itself) with Endf(Set)-categories admitting a certain class Phi of absolute colimits; we then show that, from this perspective, the passage from a finitary monad to the associated Lawvere theory is given by completion under Phi-colimits. We also account for other phenomena from the enriched viewpoint: the equivalence of the algebras for a finitary monad with the models of the corresponding Lawvere theory; the functorial semantics in arbitrary categories with finite powers; and the existence of left adjoints to algebraic functors.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Skew-monoidal categories and the Catalan simplicial set
Authors:
Mitchell Buckley,
Richard Garner,
Stephen Lack,
Ross Street
Abstract:
The basic data for a skew-monoidal category are the same as for a monoidal category, except that the constraint morphisms are no longer required to be invertible. The constraints are given a specific orientation and satisfy Mac Lane's five axioms. Whilst recent applications justify the use of skew-monoidal structure, they do not give an intrinsic justification for the form the structure takes (the…
▽ More
The basic data for a skew-monoidal category are the same as for a monoidal category, except that the constraint morphisms are no longer required to be invertible. The constraints are given a specific orientation and satisfy Mac Lane's five axioms. Whilst recent applications justify the use of skew-monoidal structure, they do not give an intrinsic justification for the form the structure takes (the orientation of the constraints and the axioms that they satisfy). This paper provides a perspective on skew-monoidal structure which, amongst other things, makes it quite apparent why this particular choice is a natural one. To do this, we use the Catalan simplicial set C. It turns out to be quite easy to describe: it is the nerve of the monoidal poset (2, v, 0) and has a Catalan number of simplices at each dimension (hence the name). Our perspective is that C classifies skew-monoidal structures in the sense that simplicial maps from C into a suitably-defined nerve of Cat are precisely skew-monoidal categories. More generally, skew monoidales in a monoidal bicategory K are classified by maps from C into the simplicial nerve of K.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Two-dimensional regularity and exactness
Authors:
John Bourke,
Richard Garner
Abstract:
We define notions of regularity and (Barr-)exactness for 2-categories. In fact, we define three notions of regularity and exactness, each based on one of the three canonical ways of factorising a functor in Cat: as (surjective on objects, injective on objects and fully faithful), as (bijective on objects, fully faithful), and as (bijective on objects and full, faithful). The correctness of our not…
▽ More
We define notions of regularity and (Barr-)exactness for 2-categories. In fact, we define three notions of regularity and exactness, each based on one of the three canonical ways of factorising a functor in Cat: as (surjective on objects, injective on objects and fully faithful), as (bijective on objects, fully faithful), and as (bijective on objects and full, faithful). The correctness of our notions is justified using the theory of lex colimits introduced by Lack and the second author. Along the way, we develop an abstract theory of regularity and exactness relative to a kernel--quotient factorisation, extending earlier work of Street and others.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Enriched categories as a free cocompletion
Authors:
Richard Garner,
Michael Shulman
Abstract:
This paper has two objectives. The first is to develop the theory of bicategories enriched in a monoidal bicategory -- categorifying the classical theory of categories enriched in a monoidal category -- up to a description of the free cocompletion of an enriched bicategory under a class of weighted bicolimits. The second objective is to describe a universal property of the process assigning to a m…
▽ More
This paper has two objectives. The first is to develop the theory of bicategories enriched in a monoidal bicategory -- categorifying the classical theory of categories enriched in a monoidal category -- up to a description of the free cocompletion of an enriched bicategory under a class of weighted bicolimits. The second objective is to describe a universal property of the process assigning to a monoidal category V the equipment of V-enriched categories, functors, transformations, and modules; we do so by considering, more generally, the assignation sending an equipment C to the equipment of C-enriched categories, functors, transformations, and modules, and exhibiting this as the free cocompletion of a certain kind of enriched bicategory under a certain class of weighted bicolimits.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2015; v1 submitted 14 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Restriction categories as enriched categories
Authors:
Robin Cockett,
Richard Garner
Abstract:
Restriction categories were introduced to provide an axiomatic setting for the study of partially defined mappings; they are categories equipped with an operation called restriction which assigns to every morphism an endomorphism of its domain, to be thought of as the partial identity that is defined to just the same degree as the original map. In this paper, we show that restriction categories ca…
▽ More
Restriction categories were introduced to provide an axiomatic setting for the study of partially defined mappings; they are categories equipped with an operation called restriction which assigns to every morphism an endomorphism of its domain, to be thought of as the partial identity that is defined to just the same degree as the original map. In this paper, we show that restriction categories can be identified with \emph{enriched categories} in the sense of Kelly for a suitable enrichment base. By varying that base appropriately, we are also able to capture the notions of join and range restriction category in terms of enriched category theory.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Remarks on exactness notions pertaining to pushouts
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
We call a finitely complete category diexact if every Mal'cev relation admits a pushout which is stable under pullback and itself a pullback. We prove three results relating to diexact categories: firstly, that a category is a pretopos if and only if it is diexact with a strict initial object; secondly, that a category is diexact if and only if it is Barr-exact, and every pair of monomorphisms adm…
▽ More
We call a finitely complete category diexact if every Mal'cev relation admits a pushout which is stable under pullback and itself a pullback. We prove three results relating to diexact categories: firstly, that a category is a pretopos if and only if it is diexact with a strict initial object; secondly, that a category is diexact if and only if it is Barr-exact, and every pair of monomorphisms admits a pushout which is stable and a pullback; and thirdly, that a small category with finite limits and pushouts of Mal'cev spans is diexact if and only if it admits a full structure-preserving embedding into a Grothendieck topos.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2012;
originally announced January 2012.
-
On semiflexible, flexible and pie algebras
Authors:
John Bourke,
Richard Garner
Abstract:
We introduce the notion of pie algebra for a 2-monad, these bearing the same relationship to the flexible and semiflexible algebras as pie limits do to flexible and semiflexible ones. We see that in many cases, the pie algebras are precisely those "free at the level of objects" in a suitable sense; so that, for instance, a strict monoidal category is pie just when its underlying monoid of objects…
▽ More
We introduce the notion of pie algebra for a 2-monad, these bearing the same relationship to the flexible and semiflexible algebras as pie limits do to flexible and semiflexible ones. We see that in many cases, the pie algebras are precisely those "free at the level of objects" in a suitable sense; so that, for instance, a strict monoidal category is pie just when its underlying monoid of objects is free. Pie algebras are contrasted with flexible and semiflexible algebras via a series of characterisations of each class; particular attention is paid to the case of pie, flexible and semiflexible weights, these being characterised in terms of the behaviour of the corresponding weighted limit functors.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2011;
originally announced December 2011.
-
A characterisation of algebraic exactness
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
An algebraically exact category in one that admits all of the limits and colimits which every variety of algebras possesses and every forgetful functor between varieties preserves, and which verifies the same interactions between these limits and colimits as hold in any variety. Such categories were studied by Adámek, Lawvere and Rosický: they characterised them as the categories with small limits…
▽ More
An algebraically exact category in one that admits all of the limits and colimits which every variety of algebras possesses and every forgetful functor between varieties preserves, and which verifies the same interactions between these limits and colimits as hold in any variety. Such categories were studied by Adámek, Lawvere and Rosický: they characterised them as the categories with small limits and sifted colimits for which the functor taking sifted colimits is continuous. They conjectured that a complete and sifted-cocomplete category should be algebraically exact just when it is Barr-exact, finite limits commute with filtered colimits, regular epimorphisms are stable by small products, and filtered colimits distribute over small products. We prove this conjecture.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2011;
originally announced September 2011.
-
On the axioms for adhesive and quasiadhesive categories
Authors:
Richard Garner,
Stephen Lack
Abstract:
A category is adhesive if it has all pullbacks, all pushouts along monomorphisms, and all exactness conditions between pullbacks and pushouts along monomorphisms which hold in a topos. This condition can be modified by considering only pushouts along regular monomorphisms, or by asking only for the exactness conditions which hold in a quasitopos. We prove four characterization theorems dealing wit…
▽ More
A category is adhesive if it has all pullbacks, all pushouts along monomorphisms, and all exactness conditions between pullbacks and pushouts along monomorphisms which hold in a topos. This condition can be modified by considering only pushouts along regular monomorphisms, or by asking only for the exactness conditions which hold in a quasitopos. We prove four characterization theorems dealing with adhesive categories and their variants.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2012; v1 submitted 15 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
-
Lex colimits
Authors:
Richard Garner,
Stephen Lack
Abstract:
Many kinds of categorical structure require the existence of finite limits, of colimits of some specified type, and of "exactness" conditions between the finite limits and the specified colimits. Some examples are the notions of regular, or Barr-exact, or lextensive, or coherent, or adhesive category. We introduce a general notion of exactness, of which each of the structures listed above, and oth…
▽ More
Many kinds of categorical structure require the existence of finite limits, of colimits of some specified type, and of "exactness" conditions between the finite limits and the specified colimits. Some examples are the notions of regular, or Barr-exact, or lextensive, or coherent, or adhesive category. We introduce a general notion of exactness, of which each of the structures listed above, and others besides, are particular instances. The notion can be understood as a form of cocompleteness "in the lex world" -- more precisely, in the 2-category of finitely complete categories and finite-limit preserving functors.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2012; v1 submitted 5 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
-
Grothendieck quasitoposes
Authors:
Richard Garner,
Stephen Lack
Abstract:
A full reflective subcategory E of a presheaf category [C*,Set] is the category of sheaves for a topology j on C if and only if the reflection preserves finite limits. Such an E is called a Grothendieck topos. More generally, one can consider two topologies, j contained in k, and the category of sheaves for j which are separated for k. The categories E of this form, for some C, j, and k, are the G…
▽ More
A full reflective subcategory E of a presheaf category [C*,Set] is the category of sheaves for a topology j on C if and only if the reflection preserves finite limits. Such an E is called a Grothendieck topos. More generally, one can consider two topologies, j contained in k, and the category of sheaves for j which are separated for k. The categories E of this form, for some C, j, and k, are the Grothendieck quasitoposes of the title, previously studied by Borceux and Pedicchio, and include many examples of categories of spaces. They also include the category of concrete sheaves for a concrete site. We show that a full reflective subcategory E of [C*,Set] arises in this way for some j and k if and only if the reflection preserves monomorphisms as well as pullbacks over elements of E.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2012; v1 submitted 27 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
-
An abstract view on syntax with sharing
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
The notion of term graph encodes a refinement of inductively generated syntax in which regard is paid to the the sharing and discard of subterms. Inductively generated syntax has an abstract expression in terms of initial algebras for certain endofunctors on the category of sets, which permits one to go beyond the set-based case, and speak of inductively generated syntax in other settings. In this…
▽ More
The notion of term graph encodes a refinement of inductively generated syntax in which regard is paid to the the sharing and discard of subterms. Inductively generated syntax has an abstract expression in terms of initial algebras for certain endofunctors on the category of sets, which permits one to go beyond the set-based case, and speak of inductively generated syntax in other settings. In this paper we give a similar abstract expression to the notion of term graph. Aspects of the concrete theory are redeveloped in this setting, and applications beyond the realm of sets discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2011; v1 submitted 19 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
-
Topological and simplicial models of identity types
Authors:
Benno van den Berg,
Richard Garner
Abstract:
In this paper we construct new categorical models for the identity types of Martin-Löf type theory, in the categories Top of topological spaces and SSet of simplicial sets. We do so building on earlier work of Awodey and Warren, which has suggested that a suitable environment for the interpretation of identity types should be a category equipped with a weak factorisation system in the sense of Bou…
▽ More
In this paper we construct new categorical models for the identity types of Martin-Löf type theory, in the categories Top of topological spaces and SSet of simplicial sets. We do so building on earlier work of Awodey and Warren, which has suggested that a suitable environment for the interpretation of identity types should be a category equipped with a weak factorisation system in the sense of Bousfield--Quillen. It turns out that this is not quite enough for a sound model, due to some subtle coherence issues concerned with stability under substitution; and so our first task is to introduce a slightly richer structure---which we call a homotopy-theoretic model of identity types---and to prove that this is sufficient for a sound interpretation.
Now, although both Top and SSet are categories endowed with a weak factorisation system---and indeed, an entire Quillen model structure---exhibiting the additional structure required for a homotopy-theoretic model is quite hard to do. However, the categories we are interested in share a number of common features, and abstracting away from these leads us to introduce the notion of a path object category. This is a relatively simple axiomatic framework, which is nonetheless sufficiently strong to allow the construction of homotopy-theoretic models. Now by exhibiting suitable path object structures on Top and SSet, we endow those categories with the structure of a homotopy-theoretic model: and in this way, obtain the desired topological and simplicial models of identity types.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2011; v1 submitted 27 July, 2010;
originally announced July 2010.
-
Ionads
Authors:
Richard Garner
Abstract:
The notion of Grothendieck topos may be considered as a generalisation of that of topological space, one in which the points of the space may have non-trivial automorphisms. However, the analogy is not precise, since in a topological space, it is the points which have conceptual priority over the open sets, whereas in a topos it is the other way around. Hence a topos is more correctly regarded as…
▽ More
The notion of Grothendieck topos may be considered as a generalisation of that of topological space, one in which the points of the space may have non-trivial automorphisms. However, the analogy is not precise, since in a topological space, it is the points which have conceptual priority over the open sets, whereas in a topos it is the other way around. Hence a topos is more correctly regarded as a generalised locale, than as a generalised space. In this article we introduce the notion of ionad, which stands in the same relationship to a topological space as a (Grothendieck) topos does to a locale. We develop basic aspects of their theory and discuss their relationship with toposes.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2011; v1 submitted 8 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
Variable binding, symmetric monoidal closed theories, and bigraphs
Authors:
Richard Garner,
Tom Hirschowitz,
Aurélien Pardon
Abstract:
This paper investigates the use of symmetric monoidal closed (SMC) structure for representing syntax with variable binding, in particular for languages with linear aspects. In our setting, one first specifies an SMC theory T, which may express binding operations, in a way reminiscent from higher-order abstract syntax. This theory generates an SMC category S(T) whose morphisms are, in a sense, te…
▽ More
This paper investigates the use of symmetric monoidal closed (SMC) structure for representing syntax with variable binding, in particular for languages with linear aspects. In our setting, one first specifies an SMC theory T, which may express binding operations, in a way reminiscent from higher-order abstract syntax. This theory generates an SMC category S(T) whose morphisms are, in a sense, terms in the desired syntax. We apply our approach to Jensen and Milner's (abstract binding) bigraphs, which are linear w.r.t. processes. This leads to an alternative category of bigraphs, which we compare to the original.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2009;
originally announced May 2009.
-
Types are weak omega-groupoids
Authors:
Benno van den Berg,
Richard Garner
Abstract:
We define a notion of weak omega-category internal to a model of Martin-Löf type theory, and prove that each type bears a canonical weak omega-category structure obtained from the tower of iterated identity types over that type. We show that the omega-categories arising in this way are in fact omega-groupoids.
We define a notion of weak omega-category internal to a model of Martin-Löf type theory, and prove that each type bears a canonical weak omega-category structure obtained from the tower of iterated identity types over that type. We show that the omega-categories arising in this way are in fact omega-groupoids.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2011; v1 submitted 1 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
