-
Discrete Optimal Designs for Distributed Energy Systems with Nonconvex Multiphase Optimal Power Flow
Authors:
Ishanki De Mel,
Oleksiy V. Klymenko,
Michael Short
Abstract:
The optimal selection, sizing, and location of small-scale technologies within a grid-connected distributed energy system (DES) can contribute to reducing carbon emissions, consumer costs, and network imbalances. This is the first study to present an optimisation framework for obtaining discrete technology sizing and selection for grid-connected DES design, while simultaneously considering multiph…
▽ More
The optimal selection, sizing, and location of small-scale technologies within a grid-connected distributed energy system (DES) can contribute to reducing carbon emissions, consumer costs, and network imbalances. This is the first study to present an optimisation framework for obtaining discrete technology sizing and selection for grid-connected DES design, while simultaneously considering multiphase optimal power flow (MOPF) constraints to accurately represent unbalanced low-voltage distribution networks. An algorithm is developed to solve the resulting Mixed-Integer Nonlinear Programming (MINLP) formulation. It employs a decomposition based on Mixed-Integer Linear Programming (MILP) and Nonlinear Programming (NLP), and utilises integer cuts and complementarity reformulations to obtain discrete designs that are also feasible with respect to the network constraints. A heuristic modification to the original algorithm is also proposed to improve computational speed. Improved formulations for selecting feasible combinations of air source heat pumps (ASHPs) and hot water storage tanks are also presented. The algorithms outperform the existing state-of-the-art commercial MINLP solver, which fails to find any solutions in two instances. While feasible solutions were obtained for all cases, convergence was not achieved for all, especially for those involving the larger network. Where converged, the algorithm with the heuristic modification has achieved results up to 70% faster than the original algorithm. Results for case studies suggest that including ASHPs can support up to 16% higher renewable generation capacity compared to gas boilers, albeit with higher ASHP investment costs. The optimisation framework and results can be used to inform stakeholders such as policy-makers and network operators, to increase renewable energy capacity and aid the decarbonisation of domestic heating systems.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Complementarity Reformulations for the Optimal Design of Distributed Energy Systems with Multiphase Optimal Power Flow
Authors:
Ishanki De Mel,
Oleksiy V. Klymenko,
Michael Short
Abstract:
The design of grid-connected distributed energy systems (DES) has been investigated extensively as an optimisation problem in the past, but most studies do not include nonlinear constraints associated with unbalanced alternating current (AC) power flow in distribution networks. Previous studies that do consider AC power flow use either less complex balanced formulations applicable to transmission…
▽ More
The design of grid-connected distributed energy systems (DES) has been investigated extensively as an optimisation problem in the past, but most studies do not include nonlinear constraints associated with unbalanced alternating current (AC) power flow in distribution networks. Previous studies that do consider AC power flow use either less complex balanced formulations applicable to transmission networks, or iterative linearisations derived from local power flow solutions and prior knowledge of the design. To address these limitations, this study proposes a new algorithm for obtaining DES design decisions subject to nonlinear power flow models. The use of regularised complementarity reformulations for operational constraints that contain binary variables is proposed. This allows the use of large-scale nonlinear solvers that can find locally optimal solutions, eliminating the need for linearisations and prior knowledge while improving accuracy. DES design models with either multiphase optimal power flow (MOPF), which captures inherent phase imbalances present in distribution networks, or balanced optimal power flow formulations (OPF) are tested using a modified version of the unbalanced IEEE EU low-voltage network. Results are compared with a popular linear DES design framework, which proposes an infeasible operational schedule when tested with MOPF, while the fixed design alone produces the highest annualised costs. Despite the increased complexity, DES with MOPF obtains the best solution, enabling a greater integration of solar capacity and reducing total annualised cost when compared to DES with OPF. The new algorithm achieves a 19% improvement when compared with solving a bi-level model for DES with OPF, where the entire binary topology in the nonlinear model is fixed. The study therefore enables the acquisition of DES designs that can work symbiotically within distribution networks.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Optimal Design of Distributed Energy Systems Considering the Impacts on Electrical Power Networks
Authors:
Ishanki De Mel,
Oleksiy V. Klymenko,
Michael Short
Abstract:
Distributed energy systems (DES) have the potential to minimise costly network upgrades while increasing the proportion of renewable energy generation in the electrical grid, when properly designed. In contrast, poorly designed DES can accelerate the degeneration of existing network infrastructure. Most optimisation models used to design grid-connected DES have oversimplified or excluded constrain…
▽ More
Distributed energy systems (DES) have the potential to minimise costly network upgrades while increasing the proportion of renewable energy generation in the electrical grid, when properly designed. In contrast, poorly designed DES can accelerate the degeneration of existing network infrastructure. Most optimisation models used to design grid-connected DES have oversimplified or excluded constraints associated with alternating current (AC) power flow, as the latter has been studied in a standalone class of models known as Optimal Power Flow (OPF). A small subset of models, labelled DES-OPF models, have attempted to combine these independent frameworks. However, the impacts of using a DES-OPF framework on the resulting designs, as opposed to a conventional DES framework without AC power flow, have not been studied in previous work. This study aims to shed light on these impacts by proposing a bi-level method to solve the computationally-expensive DES-OPF framework, and simultaneously comparing results to a baseline MILP model that utilises direct current (DC) approximations in place of AC OPF, as found abundantly in literature. Two test cases of varying scale are employed to test the frameworks and compare resulting designs. The practical feasibility of the designs is assessed, based on whether the designs can mitigate network violations and energy wastage during standard operation. Results demonstrate that the baseline MILP underestimates total costs due to its inability to detect current and voltage violations, resulting in a 37% increase for one case study when tested with the DES-OPF framework. Major implications on battery capacity are also observed, primarily to manage higher levels of renewable energy curtailment, which emphasise the need to use DES-OPF frameworks when designing grid-connected DES.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2022; v1 submitted 23 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
A semi-continuous model for transmission of SARS-CoV-2 and other respiratory viruses in enclosed spaces via multiple pathways to assess risk of infection and mitigation strategies
Authors:
Panagiotis Demis,
Ishanki De Mel,
Hayley Wragg,
Michael Short,
Oleksiy V. Klymenko
Abstract:
The Covid-19 pandemic has taken millions of lives, demonstrating the tragedy and disruption of respiratory diseases, and how difficult they can be to manage. However, there is still significant debate in the scientific community as to which transmission pathways are most significant and how settings and behaviour affect risk of infection, which all have implications for which mitigation strategies…
▽ More
The Covid-19 pandemic has taken millions of lives, demonstrating the tragedy and disruption of respiratory diseases, and how difficult they can be to manage. However, there is still significant debate in the scientific community as to which transmission pathways are most significant and how settings and behaviour affect risk of infection, which all have implications for which mitigation strategies are most effective. This study presents a general model to estimate the rate of viral transfer between individuals, objects, and the air. The risk of infection to individuals in a setting is then computed considering the behaviour and interactions of individuals between themselves and the environment in the setting, survival times of the virus on different surface types and in the air, and mitigating interventions (ventilation, hand disinfection, surface cleaning, etc.). The model includes discrete events such as touch events, individuals entering/leaving the setting, and cleaning events.
We demonstrate the model capabilities on three case studies to quantify and understand the relative risk associated with the different transmission pathways and the effectiveness of mitigation strategies in different settings. The results show the importance of considering all transmission pathways and their interactions, with each scenario displaying different dominant pathways depending on the setting and behaviours of individuals therein. The flexible model, which is freely available, can be used to quickly simulate the spread of any respiratory virus via the modelled transmission pathways and the efficacy of potential mitigation strategies in any enclosed setting by making reasonable assumptions regarding the behaviour of its occupants. It is hoped that the model can be used to inform sensible decision-making regarding viral infection mitigations that are targeted to specific settings and pathogens.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Balancing Accuracy and Complexity in Optimisation Models of Distributed Energy Systems and Microgrids with Optimal Power Flow: A Review
Authors:
Ishanki A. De Mel,
Oleksiy V. Klymenko,
Michael Short
Abstract:
Optimisation and simulation models for the design and operation of grid-connected distributed energy systems (DES) often exclude the inherent nonlinearities related to power flow and generation and storage units, to maintain an accuracy-complexity balance. Such models may provide sub-optimal or even infeasible designs and dispatch schedules. In DES, optimal power flow (OPF) is often misrepresented…
▽ More
Optimisation and simulation models for the design and operation of grid-connected distributed energy systems (DES) often exclude the inherent nonlinearities related to power flow and generation and storage units, to maintain an accuracy-complexity balance. Such models may provide sub-optimal or even infeasible designs and dispatch schedules. In DES, optimal power flow (OPF) is often misrepresented and treated as a standalone problem. OPF consists of highly nonlinear and nonconvex constraints related to the underlying alternating current (AC) distribution network. This aspect of the optimisation problem has often been overlooked by researchers in the process systems and optimisation area. In this review we address the disparity between OPF and DES models, highlighting the importance of including elements of OPF in DES design and operational models to ensure that the design and operation of microgrids meet the requirements of the electrical grid. By analysing foundational models for both DES and OPF, we identify detailed technical power flow constraints that have been typically represented using oversimplified linear approximations in DES models. We also identify a subset of models, labelled DES-OPF, which include these detailed constraints and use innovative optimisation approaches to solve them. Results of these studies suggest that achieving feasible solutions with high-fidelity models is more important than achieving globally optimal solutions using less-detailed DES models. Recommendations for future work include the need for more comparisons between high-fidelity models and models with linear approximations, and the use of simulation tools to validate DES-OPF models. The review is aimed at a multidisciplinary audience of researchers and stakeholders who are interested in modelling DES to support the development of more robust and accurate optimisation models for the future.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2021; v1 submitted 14 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
