-
Open Problems in Computability Theory and Descriptive Set Theory
Authors:
George Barmpalias,
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Chi Tat Chong,
Wei Dai,
Su Gao,
Jun Le Goh,
Jialiang He,
Keng Meng Selwyn Ng,
Andre Nies,
Theodore Slaman,
Riley Thornton,
Wei Wang,
Jing Yu,
Liang Yu
Abstract:
These open problems were presented in the Problem Sessions held during the Tianyuan Workshop on Computability Theory and Descriptive Set Theory, June 16-20, 2025. The problems are organized into sections named after their contributors, in the order of their presentations during the workshop. Notes were taken and compiled by Wei Dai, Feng Li, Ruiwen Li, Ming Xiao, Xu Wang, Víctor Hugo Yañez Salazar…
▽ More
These open problems were presented in the Problem Sessions held during the Tianyuan Workshop on Computability Theory and Descriptive Set Theory, June 16-20, 2025. The problems are organized into sections named after their contributors, in the order of their presentations during the workshop. Notes were taken and compiled by Wei Dai, Feng Li, Ruiwen Li, Ming Xiao, Xu Wang, Víctor Hugo Yañez Salazar, and Yang Zheng.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2025;
originally announced July 2025.
-
Online and feasible presentability: from trees to modal algebras
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Dariusz Kalociński,
Michał Wrocławski
Abstract:
We investigate whether every computable member of a given class of structures admits a fully primitive recursive (also known as punctual) or fully P-TIME copy. A class with this property is referred to as punctually robust or P-TIME robust, respectively. We present both positive and negative results for structures corresponding to well-known representations of trees, such as binary trees, ordered…
▽ More
We investigate whether every computable member of a given class of structures admits a fully primitive recursive (also known as punctual) or fully P-TIME copy. A class with this property is referred to as punctually robust or P-TIME robust, respectively. We present both positive and negative results for structures corresponding to well-known representations of trees, such as binary trees, ordered trees, sequential (or prefix) trees, and partially ordered (poset) trees. A corollary of one of our results on trees is that semilattices and lattices are not punctually robust. In the main result of the paper, we demonstrate that, unlike Boolean algebras, modal algebras - that is, Boolean algebras with modality - are not punctually robust. The question of whether distributive lattices are punctually robust remains open. The paper contributes to a decades-old program on effective and feasible algebra, which has recently gained momentum due to rapid developments in punctual structure theory and its connections to online presentations of structures.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Classifying different criteria for learning algebraic structures
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Vittorio Cipriani,
Sanjay Jain,
Luca San Mauro,
Frank Stephan
Abstract:
In the last years there has been a growing interest in the study of learning problems associated with algebraic structures. The framework we use models the scenario in which a learner is given larger and larger fragments of a structure from a given target family and is required to output an hypothesis about the structure's isomorphism type. So far researchers focused on $\mathbf{Ex}$-learning, in…
▽ More
In the last years there has been a growing interest in the study of learning problems associated with algebraic structures. The framework we use models the scenario in which a learner is given larger and larger fragments of a structure from a given target family and is required to output an hypothesis about the structure's isomorphism type. So far researchers focused on $\mathbf{Ex}$-learning, in which the learner is asked to eventually stabilize to the correct hypothesis, and on restrictions where the learner is allowed to change the hypothesis a fixed number of times. Yet, other learning paradigms coming from classical algorithmic learning theory remained unexplored. We study the "learning power" of such criteria, comparing them via descriptive-set-theoretic tools thanks to the novel notion of $E$-learnability. The main outcome of this paper is that such criteria admit natural syntactic characterizations in terms of infinitary formulas analogous to the one given for $\mathbf{Ex}$-learning in [6]. Such characterizations give a powerful method to understand whether a family of structure is learnable with respect to the desired criterion.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Learning Families of Algebraic Structures from Text
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Ekaterina Fokina,
Dino Rossegger,
Alexandra Soskova,
Stefan Vatev
Abstract:
We adapt the classical notion of learning from text to computable structure theory. Our main result is a model-theoretic characterization of the learnability from text for classes of structures. We show that a family of structures is learnable from text if and only if the structures can be distinguished in terms of their theories restricted to positive infinitary $Σ_2$ sentences.
We adapt the classical notion of learning from text to computable structure theory. Our main result is a model-theoretic characterization of the learnability from text for classes of structures. We show that a family of structures is learnable from text if and only if the structures can be distinguished in terms of their theories restricted to positive infinitary $Σ_2$ sentences.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
A note on the degree structure of primitive recursive m-reducibility
Authors:
Birzhan Kalmurzayev,
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Alibek Iskakov
Abstract:
Let $C^{pr}_m$ be the upper semilattice of degrees of computable sets with respect to primitive recursive $m$-reducibility. We prove that the first-order theory of $C^{pr}_m$ is hereditarily undecidable.
Let $C^{pr}_m$ be the upper semilattice of degrees of computable sets with respect to primitive recursive $m$-reducibility. We prove that the first-order theory of $C^{pr}_m$ is hereditarily undecidable.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
A Lopez-Escobar Theorem for Continuous Domains
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Ekaterina Fokina,
Dino Rossegger,
Alexandra A. Soskova,
Stefan V. Vatev
Abstract:
We prove an effective version of the Lopez-Escobar theorem for continuous domains. Let $Mod(τ)$ be the set of countable structures with universe $ω$ in vocabulary $τ$ topologized by the Scott topology. We show that an invariant set $X \subseteq Mod(τ)$ is $Π^0_α$ in the effective Borel hierarchy of this topology if and only if it is definable by a $Π^p_α$ - formula, a positive $Π^0_α$ formula in t…
▽ More
We prove an effective version of the Lopez-Escobar theorem for continuous domains. Let $Mod(τ)$ be the set of countable structures with universe $ω$ in vocabulary $τ$ topologized by the Scott topology. We show that an invariant set $X \subseteq Mod(τ)$ is $Π^0_α$ in the effective Borel hierarchy of this topology if and only if it is definable by a $Π^p_α$ - formula, a positive $Π^0_α$ formula in the infinitary logic $L_{ω_1,ω}$. As a corollary of this result we obtain a new pullback theorem for positive computable embeddings: Let $K$ be positively computably embeddable in $K'$ by $Φ$, then for every $Π^p_α$ formula $ξ$ in the vocabulary of $K'$ there is a $Π^p_α$ formula $ξ^\star$ in the vocabulary of $K$ such that for all $A \in K$, $A \models ξ^\star$ if and only if $Φ(A) \models ξ$. We use this to obtain new results on the possibility of positive computable embeddings into the class of linear orderings.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2024; v1 submitted 24 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Primitive recursive reverse mathematics
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Marta Fiori-Carones,
Lu Liu,
Alexander Melnikov
Abstract:
We use a second-order analogy $\mathsf{PRA}^2$ of $\mathsf{PRA}$ to investigate the proof-theoretic strength of theorems in countable algebra, analysis, and infinite combinatorics. We compare our results with similar results in the fast-developing field of primitive recursive (\lq punctual\rq) algebra and analysis, and with results from \lq online\rq\ combinatorics. We argue that $\mathsf{PRA}^2$…
▽ More
We use a second-order analogy $\mathsf{PRA}^2$ of $\mathsf{PRA}$ to investigate the proof-theoretic strength of theorems in countable algebra, analysis, and infinite combinatorics. We compare our results with similar results in the fast-developing field of primitive recursive (\lq punctual\rq) algebra and analysis, and with results from \lq online\rq\ combinatorics. We argue that $\mathsf{PRA}^2$ is sufficiently robust to serve as an alternative base system below $\mathsf{RCA}_0$ to study the proof-theoretic content of theorems in ordinary mathematics. (The most popular alternative is perhaps $\mathsf{RCA}_0^*$.) We discover that many theorems that are known to be true in $\mathsf{RCA}_0$ either hold in $\mathsf{PRA}^2$ or are equivalent to $\mathsf{RCA}_0$ or its weaker (but natural) analogy $2^N-\mathsf{RCA}_0$ over $\mathsf{PRA}^2$. However, we also discover that some standard mathematical and combinatorial facts are incomparable with these natural subsystems.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Relatively acceptable notation
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Dariusz Kalociński
Abstract:
Shapiro's notations for natural numbers, and the associated desideratum of acceptability - the property of a notation that all recursive functions are computable in it - is well-known in philosophy of computing. Computable structure theory, however, although capable of fully reconstructing Shapiro's approach, seems to be off philosophers' radar. Based on the case study of natural numbers with stan…
▽ More
Shapiro's notations for natural numbers, and the associated desideratum of acceptability - the property of a notation that all recursive functions are computable in it - is well-known in philosophy of computing. Computable structure theory, however, although capable of fully reconstructing Shapiro's approach, seems to be off philosophers' radar. Based on the case study of natural numbers with standard order, we make initial steps to reconcile these two perspectives. First, we lay the elementary conceptual groundwork for the reconstruction of Shapiro's approach in terms of computable structures and show, on a few examples, how results pertinent to the former can inform our understanding of the latter. Secondly, we prove a new result, inspired by Shapiro's notion of acceptability, but also relevant for computable structure theory. The result explores the relationship between the classical notion of degree spectrum of a computable function on the structure in question - specifically, having all c.e. degrees as a spectrum - and our ability to compute the (image of the) successor from the (image of the) function in any computable copy of the structure. The latter property may be otherwise seen as relativized acceptability of every notation for the structure.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Learning algebraic structures with the help of Borel equivalence relations
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Vittorio Cipriani,
Luca San Mauro
Abstract:
We study algorithmic learning of algebraic structures. In our framework, a learner receives larger and larger pieces of an arbitrary copy of a computable structure and, at each stage, is required to output a conjecture about the isomorphism type of such a structure. The learning is successful if the conjectures eventually stabilize to a correct guess. We prove that a family of structures is learna…
▽ More
We study algorithmic learning of algebraic structures. In our framework, a learner receives larger and larger pieces of an arbitrary copy of a computable structure and, at each stage, is required to output a conjecture about the isomorphism type of such a structure. The learning is successful if the conjectures eventually stabilize to a correct guess. We prove that a family of structures is learnable if and only if its learning domain is continuously reducible to the relation $E_0$ of eventual agreement on reals. This motivates a novel research program, that is, using descriptive set theoretic tools to calibrate the (learning) complexity of nonlearnable families. Here, we focus on the learning power of well-known benchmark Borel equivalence relations (i.e., $E_1$, $E_2$, $E_3$, $Z_0$, and $E_{set}$).
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Intrinsic complexity of recursive functions on natural numbers with standard order
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Dariusz Kalociński,
Michał Wrocławski
Abstract:
Intrinsic complexity of a relation on a given computable structure is captured by the notion of its degree spectrum - the set of Turing degrees of images of the relation in all computable isomorphic copies of that structure. We investigate the intrinsic complexity of unary total recursive functions on nonnegative integers with standard order. According to existing results, possible spectra of such…
▽ More
Intrinsic complexity of a relation on a given computable structure is captured by the notion of its degree spectrum - the set of Turing degrees of images of the relation in all computable isomorphic copies of that structure. We investigate the intrinsic complexity of unary total recursive functions on nonnegative integers with standard order. According to existing results, possible spectra of such functions include three sets consisting of precisely: the computable degree, all c.e. degrees and all $Δ_2$ degrees. These results, however, fall far short of the full classification. In this paper, we obtain a more complete picture by giving a few criteria for a function to have intrinsic complexity equal to one of the three candidate sets of degrees. Our investigations are based on the notion of block functions and a broader class of quasi-block functions beyond which all functions of interest have intrinsic complexity equal to the c.e. degrees. We also answer the questions raised by Wright and Harrison-Trainor by showing that the division between computable, c.e. and $Δ_2$ degrees is insufficient in this context as there is a unary total recursive function whose spectrum contains all c.e. degrees but is strictly contained in the $Δ_2$ degrees.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Punctual equivalence relations and their (punctual) complexity
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Keng Meng Ng,
Luca San Mauro,
Andrea Sorbi
Abstract:
The complexity of equivalence relations has received much attention in the recent literature. The main tool for such endeavour is the following reducibility: given equivalence relations $R$ and $S$ on natural numbers, $R$ is computably reducible to $S$ if there is a computable function $f \colon ω\to ω$ that induces an injective map from $R$-equivalence classes to $S$-equivalence classes. In order…
▽ More
The complexity of equivalence relations has received much attention in the recent literature. The main tool for such endeavour is the following reducibility: given equivalence relations $R$ and $S$ on natural numbers, $R$ is computably reducible to $S$ if there is a computable function $f \colon ω\to ω$ that induces an injective map from $R$-equivalence classes to $S$-equivalence classes. In order to compare the complexity of equivalence relations which are computable, researchers considered also feasible variants of computable reducibility, such as the polynomial-time reducibility. In this work, we explore $\mathbf{Peq}$, the degree structure generated by primitive recursive reducibility on punctual equivalence relations (i.e., primitive recursive equivalence relations with domain $ω$). In contrast with all other known degree structures on equivalence relations, we show that $\mathbf{Peq}$ has much more structure: e.g., we show that it is a dense distributive lattice. On the other hand, we also offer evidence of the intricacy of $\mathbf{Peq}$, proving, e.g., that the structure is neither rigid nor homogeneous.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Approximating approximate reasoning: Fuzzy sets and the Ershov hierarchy
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Manat Mustafa,
Sergei Ospichev,
Luca San Mauro
Abstract:
Computability theorists have introduced multiple hierarchies to measure the complexity of sets of natural numbers. The Kleene Hierarchy classifies sets according to the first-order complexity of their defining formulas. The Ershov Hierarchy classifies $Δ^0_2$ sets with respect to the number of mistakes that are needed to approximate them. Biacino and Gerla extended the Kleene Hierarchy to the real…
▽ More
Computability theorists have introduced multiple hierarchies to measure the complexity of sets of natural numbers. The Kleene Hierarchy classifies sets according to the first-order complexity of their defining formulas. The Ershov Hierarchy classifies $Δ^0_2$ sets with respect to the number of mistakes that are needed to approximate them. Biacino and Gerla extended the Kleene Hierarchy to the realm of fuzzy sets, whose membership functions range in a complete lattice $L$ (e.g., the real interval $[0; 1]_\mathbb{R}$). In this paper, we combine the Ershov Hierarchy and fuzzy set theory, by introducing and investigating the Fuzzy Ershov Hierarchy. In particular, we focus on the fuzzy $n$-c.e. sets which form the finite levels of this hierarchy. Intuitively, a fuzzy set is $n$-c.e. if its membership function can be approximated by changing monotonicity at most $n-1$ times. We prove that the Fuzzy Ershov Hierarchy does not collapse; that, in analogy with the classical case, each fuzzy $n$-c.e. set can be represented as a Boolean combination of fuzzy c.e. sets; but that, contrary to the classical case, the Fuzzy Ershov Hierarchy does not exhaust the class of all $Δ^0_2$ fuzzy sets.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Computable Stone spaces
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Matthew Harrison-Trainor,
Alexander Melnikov
Abstract:
We investigate computable metrizability of Polish spaces up to homeomorphism. In this paper we focus on Stone spaces. We use Stone duality to construct the first known example of a computable topological Polish space not homeomorphic to any computably metrized space. In fact, in our proof we construct a right-c.e. metrized Stone space which is not homeomorphic to any computably metrized space. The…
▽ More
We investigate computable metrizability of Polish spaces up to homeomorphism. In this paper we focus on Stone spaces. We use Stone duality to construct the first known example of a computable topological Polish space not homeomorphic to any computably metrized space. In fact, in our proof we construct a right-c.e. metrized Stone space which is not homeomorphic to any computably metrized space. Then we introduce a new notion of effective categoricity for effectively compact spaces and prove that effectively categorical Stone spaces are exactly the duals of computably categorical Boolean algebras. Finally, we prove that, for a Stone space $X$, the Banach space $C(X;\mathbb{R})$ has a computable presentation if, and only if, $X$ is homeomorphic to a computably metrized space. This gives an unexpected positive partial answer to a question recently posed by McNicholl.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2023; v1 submitted 4 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
On the Turing complexity of learning finite families of algebraic structures
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Luca San Mauro
Abstract:
In previous work, we have combined computable structure theory and algorithmic learning theory to study which families of algebraic structures are learnable in the limit (up to isomorphism). In this paper, we measure the computational power that is needed to learn finite families of structures. In particular, we prove that, if a family of structures is both finite and learnable, then any oracle wh…
▽ More
In previous work, we have combined computable structure theory and algorithmic learning theory to study which families of algebraic structures are learnable in the limit (up to isomorphism). In this paper, we measure the computational power that is needed to learn finite families of structures. In particular, we prove that, if a family of structures is both finite and learnable, then any oracle which computes the Halting set is able to achieve such a learning. On the other hand, we construct a pair of structures which is learnable but no computable learner can learn it.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Rogers semilattices in the analytical hierarchy: The case of finite families
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Manat Mustafa
Abstract:
A numbering of a countable family $S$ is a surjective map from the set of natural numbers $ω$ onto $S$. The paper studies Rogers semilattices, i.e. upper semilattices induced by the reducibility between numberings, for families $S\subset P(ω)$. Working in set theory ZF+DC+PD, we obtain the following results on families from various levels of the analytical hierarchy.
For a non-zero number $n$, b…
▽ More
A numbering of a countable family $S$ is a surjective map from the set of natural numbers $ω$ onto $S$. The paper studies Rogers semilattices, i.e. upper semilattices induced by the reducibility between numberings, for families $S\subset P(ω)$. Working in set theory ZF+DC+PD, we obtain the following results on families from various levels of the analytical hierarchy.
For a non-zero number $n$, by $E^1_n$ we denote $Π^1_n$ if $n$ is odd, and $Σ^1_n$ if $n$ is even. We show that for a finite family $S$ of $E^1_n$ sets, its Rogers $E^1_n$-semilattice has the greatest element if and only if $S$ contains the least element under set-theoretic inclusion. Furthermore, if $S$ does not have the $\subseteq$-least element, then the corresponding Rogers $E^1_n$-semilattice is upwards dense.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
On bi-embeddable categoricity of algebraic structures
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Dino Rossegger,
Maxim Zubkov
Abstract:
In several classes of countable structures it is known that every hyperarithmetic structure has a computable presentation up to bi-embeddability. In this article we investigate the complexity of embeddings between bi-embeddable structures in two such classes, the classes of linear orders and Boolean algebras. We show that if $\mathcal L$ is a computable linear order of Hausdorff rank $n$, then for…
▽ More
In several classes of countable structures it is known that every hyperarithmetic structure has a computable presentation up to bi-embeddability. In this article we investigate the complexity of embeddings between bi-embeddable structures in two such classes, the classes of linear orders and Boolean algebras. We show that if $\mathcal L$ is a computable linear order of Hausdorff rank $n$, then for every bi-embeddable copy of it there is an embedding computable in $2n-1$ jumps from the atomic diagrams. We furthermore show that this is the best one can do: Let $\mathcal L$ be a computable linear order of Hausdorff rank $n\geq 1$, then $\mathbf 0^{(2n-2)}$ does not compute embeddings between it and all its computable bi-embeddable copies. We obtain that for Boolean algebras which are not superatomic, there is no hyperarithmetic degree computing embeddings between all its computable bi-embeddable copies. On the other hand, if a computable Boolean algebra is superatomic, then there is a least computable ordinal $α$ such that $\mathbf 0^{(α)}$ computes embeddings between all its computable bi-embeddable copies. The main technique used in this proof is a new variation of Ash and Knight's pairs of structures theorem.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Comparing the isomorphism types of equivalence structures and preorders
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Luca San Mauro
Abstract:
A general theme of computable structure theory is to investigate when structures have copies of a given complexity $Γ$. We discuss such problem for the case of equivalence structures and preorders. We show that there is a $Π^0_1$ equivalence structure with no $Σ^0_1$ copy, and in fact that the isomorphism types realized by the $Π^0_1$ equivalence structures coincide with those realized by the…
▽ More
A general theme of computable structure theory is to investigate when structures have copies of a given complexity $Γ$. We discuss such problem for the case of equivalence structures and preorders. We show that there is a $Π^0_1$ equivalence structure with no $Σ^0_1$ copy, and in fact that the isomorphism types realized by the $Π^0_1$ equivalence structures coincide with those realized by the $Δ^0_2$ equivalence structures. We also construct a $Σ^0_1$ preorder with no $Π^0_1$ copy.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
A Note on Computable Embeddings for Ordinals and Their Reverses
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Stefan Vatev
Abstract:
We continue the study of computable embeddings for pairs of structures, i.e. for classes containing precisely two non-isomorphic structures. Surprisingly, even for some pairs of simple linear orders, computable embeddings induce a non-trivial degree structure. Our main result shows that although $\{ω\cdot 2, ω^\star \cdot 2\}$ is computably embeddable in $\{ω^2, {(ω^2)}^\star\}$, the class…
▽ More
We continue the study of computable embeddings for pairs of structures, i.e. for classes containing precisely two non-isomorphic structures. Surprisingly, even for some pairs of simple linear orders, computable embeddings induce a non-trivial degree structure. Our main result shows that although $\{ω\cdot 2, ω^\star \cdot 2\}$ is computably embeddable in $\{ω^2, {(ω^2)}^\star\}$, the class $\{ω\cdot k,ω^\star \cdot k\}$ is \emph{not} computably embeddable in $\{ω^2, {(ω^2)}^\star\}$ for any natural number $k \geq 3$.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2020; v1 submitted 17 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Isomorphism types of Rogers semilattices in the analytical hierarchy
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Sergey Ospichev,
Mars Yamaleev
Abstract:
A numbering of a countable family $S$ is a surjective map from the set of natural numbers $ω$ onto $S$. A numbering $ν$ is reducible to a numbering $μ$ if there is an effective procedure which given a $ν$-index of an object from $S$, computes a $μ$-index for the same object. The reducibility between numberings gives rise to a class of upper semilattices, which are usually called Rogers semilattice…
▽ More
A numbering of a countable family $S$ is a surjective map from the set of natural numbers $ω$ onto $S$. A numbering $ν$ is reducible to a numbering $μ$ if there is an effective procedure which given a $ν$-index of an object from $S$, computes a $μ$-index for the same object. The reducibility between numberings gives rise to a class of upper semilattices, which are usually called Rogers semilattices. The paper studies Rogers semilattices for families $S \subset P(ω)$ belonging to various levels of the analytical hierarchy. We prove that for any non-zero natural numbers $m\neq n$, any non-trivial Rogers semilattice of a $Π^1_m$-computable family cannot be isomorphic to a Rogers semilattice of a $Π^1_n$-computable family. One of the key ingredients of the proof is an application of the result by Downey and Knight on degree spectra of linear orders.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Minimal Equivalence Relations in Hyperarithmetical and Analytical Hierarchies
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Manat Mustafa,
Luca San Mauro,
Mars Yamaleev
Abstract:
A standard tool for classifying the complexity of equivalence relations on $ω$ is provided by computable reducibility. This reducibility gives rise to a rich degree structure. The paper studies equivalence relations, which induce minimal degrees with respect to computable reducibility. Let $Γ$ be one of the following classes: $Σ^0_α$, $Π^0_α$, $Σ^1_n$, or $Π^1_n$, where $α\geq 2$ is a computable o…
▽ More
A standard tool for classifying the complexity of equivalence relations on $ω$ is provided by computable reducibility. This reducibility gives rise to a rich degree structure. The paper studies equivalence relations, which induce minimal degrees with respect to computable reducibility. Let $Γ$ be one of the following classes: $Σ^0_α$, $Π^0_α$, $Σ^1_n$, or $Π^1_n$, where $α\geq 2$ is a computable ordinal and $n$ is a non-zero natural number. We prove that there are infinitely many pairwise incomparable minimal equivalence relations that are properly in $Γ$.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Degrees of bi-embeddable categoricity
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Ekaterina Fokina,
Dino Rossegger,
Luca San Mauro
Abstract:
We investigate the complexity of embeddings between bi-embeddable structures. In analogy with categoricity spectra, we define the bi-embeddable categoricity spectrum of a structure $\mathcal A$ as the family of Turing degrees that compute embeddings between any computable bi-embeddable copies of $\mathcal A$; the degree of bi-embeddable categoricity of $\mathcal A$ is the least degree in this spec…
▽ More
We investigate the complexity of embeddings between bi-embeddable structures. In analogy with categoricity spectra, we define the bi-embeddable categoricity spectrum of a structure $\mathcal A$ as the family of Turing degrees that compute embeddings between any computable bi-embeddable copies of $\mathcal A$; the degree of bi-embeddable categoricity of $\mathcal A$ is the least degree in this spectrum (if it exists). We extend many known results about categoricity spectra to the case of bi-embeddability. In particular, we exhibit structures without degree of bi-embeddable categoricity, and we show that every degree d.c.e. above $\mathbf{0}^{(α)}$ for $α$ a computable successor ordinal and $\mathbf{0}^{(λ)}$ for $λ$ a computable limit ordinal is a degree of bi-embeddable categoricity. We also give examples of families of degrees that are not bi-embeddable categoricity spectra.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Learning families of algebraic structures from informant
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Ekaterina Fokina,
Luca San Mauro
Abstract:
We combine computable structure theory and algorithmic learning theory to study learning of families of algebraic structures. Our main result is a model-theoretic characterization of the class $\mathbf{InfEx}_{\cong}$, consisting of the structures whose isomorphism types can be learned in the limit. We show that a family of structures $\mathfrak{K}$ is $\mathbf{InfEx}_{\cong}$-learnable if and onl…
▽ More
We combine computable structure theory and algorithmic learning theory to study learning of families of algebraic structures. Our main result is a model-theoretic characterization of the class $\mathbf{InfEx}_{\cong}$, consisting of the structures whose isomorphism types can be learned in the limit. We show that a family of structures $\mathfrak{K}$ is $\mathbf{InfEx}_{\cong}$-learnable if and only if the structures from $\mathfrak{K}$ can be distinguished in terms of their $Σ^{\mathrm{inf}}_2$-theories. We apply this characterization to familiar cases and we show the following: there is an infinite learnable family of distributive lattices; no pair of Boolean algebras is learnable; no infinite family of linear orders is learnable.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2020; v1 submitted 5 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Computable embeddings for pairs of linear orders
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Hristo Ganchev,
Stefan Vatev
Abstract:
We study computable embeddings for pairs of structures, i.e. for classes containing precisely two non-isomorphic structures. Surprisingly, even for some pairs of simple linear orders, computable embeddings induce a non-trivial degree structure. Our main result shows that $\{ω\cdot k,ω^\star \cdot k\}$ is computably embeddable in $\{ω\cdot t, ω^\star \cdot t\}$ iff $k$ divides $t$.
We study computable embeddings for pairs of structures, i.e. for classes containing precisely two non-isomorphic structures. Surprisingly, even for some pairs of simple linear orders, computable embeddings induce a non-trivial degree structure. Our main result shows that $\{ω\cdot k,ω^\star \cdot k\}$ is computably embeddable in $\{ω\cdot t, ω^\star \cdot t\}$ iff $k$ divides $t$.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2021; v1 submitted 7 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Classifying equivalence relations in the Ershov hierarchy
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Manat Mustafa,
Luca San Mauro,
Andrea Sorbi,
Mars Yamaleev
Abstract:
Computably enumerable equivalence relations (ceers) received a lot of attention in the literature. The standard tool to classify ceers is provided by the computable reducibility $\leq_c$. This gives rise to a rich degree-structure. In this paper, we lift the study of $c$-degrees to the $Δ^0_2$ case. In doing so, we rely on the Ershov hierarchy. For any notation $a$ for a non-zero computable ordina…
▽ More
Computably enumerable equivalence relations (ceers) received a lot of attention in the literature. The standard tool to classify ceers is provided by the computable reducibility $\leq_c$. This gives rise to a rich degree-structure. In this paper, we lift the study of $c$-degrees to the $Δ^0_2$ case. In doing so, we rely on the Ershov hierarchy. For any notation $a$ for a non-zero computable ordinal, we prove several algebraic properties of the degree-structure induced by $\leq_c$ on the $Σ^{-1}_{a}\smallsetminus Π^{-1}_a$ equivalence relations. A special focus of our work is on the (non)existence of infima and suprema of $c$-degrees.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Degrees of bi-embeddable categoricity of equivalence structures
Authors:
Nikolay Bazhenov,
Ekaterina Fokina,
Dino Rossegger,
Luca San Mauro
Abstract:
We study the algorithmic complexity of embeddings between bi-embeddable equivalence structures. We define the notions of computable bi-embeddable categoricity, (relative) $Δ^0_α$ bi-embeddable categoricity, and degrees of bi-embeddable categoricity. These notions mirror the classical notions used to study the complexity of isomorphisms between structures. We show that the notions of $Δ^0_α$ bi-emb…
▽ More
We study the algorithmic complexity of embeddings between bi-embeddable equivalence structures. We define the notions of computable bi-embeddable categoricity, (relative) $Δ^0_α$ bi-embeddable categoricity, and degrees of bi-embeddable categoricity. These notions mirror the classical notions used to study the complexity of isomorphisms between structures. We show that the notions of $Δ^0_α$ bi-embeddable categoricity and relative $Δ^0_α$ bi-embeddable categoricity coincide for equivalence structures for $α=1,2,3$. We also prove that computable equivalence structures have degree of bi-embeddable categoricity $\mathbf{0},\mathbf{0}'$, or $\mathbf{0}''$. We obtain results on index sets of computable equivalence structure with respect to bi-embeddability.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
