-
On the Birkhoff conjecture for Kepler billiards
Authors:
Stefano Baranzini,
Vivina L. Barutello,
Irene De Blasi,
Susanna Terracini
Abstract:
We investigate the integrability of Kepler billiards-mechanical billiard systems in which a particle moves under the influence of a Keplerian potential and reflects elastically at the boundary of a strictly convex planar domain. Our main result establishes that, except possibly for one location of the gravitational center, analytic integrability at high energies occurs only when the domain is an e…
▽ More
We investigate the integrability of Kepler billiards-mechanical billiard systems in which a particle moves under the influence of a Keplerian potential and reflects elastically at the boundary of a strictly convex planar domain. Our main result establishes that, except possibly for one location of the gravitational center, analytic integrability at high energies occurs only when the domain is an ellipse and the center is placed at one of its foci. This provides a partial affirmative answer to a Keplerian analogue of the classical Birkhoff-Poritsky Conjecture.
Our approach is based on the construction of symbolic dynamics arising from chaotic subsystems that emerge in the high-energy regime. Depending on the geometric configuration of the boundary and the location of the attraction center, we construct three types of symbolic dynamics by shadowing chains of punctured Birkhoff-type trajectories. These constructions yield subsystems conjugated to Bernoulli shifts, implying positive topological entropy and precluding analytic integrability.
We further analyze the notion of focal points of the second kind, showing that in real-analytic, non-elliptic domains there can be at most one such point, while ellipses are the only domains admitting two-coinciding with their classical foci. Finally, we demonstrate the existence of an infinite-dimensional family of non-elliptic domains possessing a focal point of the second kind, and conclude with numerical simulations illustrating chaotic behavior in such cases.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2025;
originally announced July 2025.
-
Exploration of billiards with Keplerian potential
Authors:
Vivina L. Barutello,
Anna Maria Cherubini,
Irene De Blasi
Abstract:
We study a class of elliptic billiards with a Keplerian potential inside, considering two cases: a reflective one, where the particle reflects elastically on the boundary, and a refractive one, where the particle can cross the billiard's boundary entering a region with a harmonic potential. In the latter case the dynamics is therefore given by concatenations of inner and outer arcs, connected by a…
▽ More
We study a class of elliptic billiards with a Keplerian potential inside, considering two cases: a reflective one, where the particle reflects elastically on the boundary, and a refractive one, where the particle can cross the billiard's boundary entering a region with a harmonic potential. In the latter case the dynamics is therefore given by concatenations of inner and outer arcs, connected by a refraction law. In recent papers (e.g. arXiv:2105.02108, arXiv:2108.11159, arXiv:2212.01150, arXiv:2110.03376) these billiards have been extensively studied in order to identify which conditions give rise to either regular or chaotic dynamics. In this paper we complete the study by analysing the non focused reflective case, thus complementing the results obtained in arXiv:2110.03376 in the focused one. We then analyse the focused and non focused refractive case, where no results on integrability are known except for the centred circular case, by providing an extensive numerical analysis. We present also a theoretical result regarding the linear stability of homothetic equilibrium orbits in the reflective case for general ellipses, highlighting the possible presence of bifurcations even in the integrable framework.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2024; v1 submitted 3 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Chaotic dynamics in refraction galactic billiards
Authors:
Vivina L. Barutello,
Irene De Blasi,
Susanna Terracini
Abstract:
We prove the presence of topological chaos at high internal energies for a new class of mechanical refraction billiards coming from Celestial Mechanics. Given a smooth closed domain $D\in\mathbb{R}^2$, a central mass generates a Keplerian potential in it, while, in $\mathbb{R}^2\setminus \overline{D}$, a harmonic oscillator-type potential acts. At the interface, Snell's law of refraction holds. Th…
▽ More
We prove the presence of topological chaos at high internal energies for a new class of mechanical refraction billiards coming from Celestial Mechanics. Given a smooth closed domain $D\in\mathbb{R}^2$, a central mass generates a Keplerian potential in it, while, in $\mathbb{R}^2\setminus \overline{D}$, a harmonic oscillator-type potential acts. At the interface, Snell's law of refraction holds. The chaoticity result is obtained by imposing progressive assumptions on the domain, arriving to geometric conditions which hold generically in $C^1$. The workflow starts with the existence of a symbolic dynamics and ends with the proof of topological chaos, passing through the analytic non-integrability and the presence of multiple heteroclinic connections between different equilibrium saddle points. This work can be considered as the final step of the investigation carried on in arXiv:2108.11159 [math.DS] and arXiv:2105.02108 [math.DS].
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2022; v1 submitted 2 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Sturm theory with applications in geometry and classical mechanics
Authors:
Vivina L. Barutello,
Daniel Offin,
Alessandro Portaluri,
Li Wu
Abstract:
Classical Sturm non-oscillation and comparison theorems as well as the Sturm theorem on zeros for solutions of second order differential equations have a natural symplectic version, since they describe the rotation of a line in the phase plane of the equation. In the higher dimensional symplectic version of these theorems, lines are replaced by Lagrangian subspaces and intersections with a given l…
▽ More
Classical Sturm non-oscillation and comparison theorems as well as the Sturm theorem on zeros for solutions of second order differential equations have a natural symplectic version, since they describe the rotation of a line in the phase plane of the equation. In the higher dimensional symplectic version of these theorems, lines are replaced by Lagrangian subspaces and intersections with a given line are replaced by non-transversality instants with a distinguished Lagrangian subspace. Thus the symplectic Sturm theorems describe some properties of the Maslov index.
Starting from the celebrated paper of Arnol'd on symplectic Sturm theory for optical Hamiltonians, we provide a generalization of his results to general Hamiltonians. We finally apply these results for detecting some geometrical information about the distribution of conjugate and focal points on semi-Riemannian manifolds and for studying the geometrical properties of the solutions space of singular Lagrangian systems arising in Celestial Mechanics.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
An Index theory for asymptotic motions under singular potentials
Authors:
Vivina L. Barutello,
Xijun Hu,
Alessandro Portaluri,
Susanna Terracini
Abstract:
We develop an index theory for parabolic and collision solutions to the classical n-body problem and we prove sufficient conditions for the finiteness of the spectral index valid in a large class of trajectories ending with a total collapse or expanding with vanishing limiting velocities. Both problems suffer from a lack of compactness and can be brought in a similar form of a Lagrangian System on…
▽ More
We develop an index theory for parabolic and collision solutions to the classical n-body problem and we prove sufficient conditions for the finiteness of the spectral index valid in a large class of trajectories ending with a total collapse or expanding with vanishing limiting velocities. Both problems suffer from a lack of compactness and can be brought in a similar form of a Lagrangian System on the half time line by a regularising change of coordinates which preserve the Lagrangian structure. We then introduce a Maslov-type index which is suitable to capture the asymptotic nature of these trajectories as half-clinic orbits: by taking into account the underlying Hamiltonian structure we define the appropriate notion of geometric index for this class of solutions and we develop the relative index theory.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2018; v1 submitted 3 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
