-
Comments on characterizing demand flexibility to provide power grid services
Authors:
Prabir Barooah
Abstract:
Many loads have flexibility in demand that can be used to provide ancillary services to power grids. A large body of literature exists on designing algorithms to coordinate actions of many loads to provide such a service. The topic of characterizing the flexibility of one or a collection of loads - to determine what kinds of demand deviation from the baseline is feasible - has also been studied. H…
▽ More
Many loads have flexibility in demand that can be used to provide ancillary services to power grids. A large body of literature exists on designing algorithms to coordinate actions of many loads to provide such a service. The topic of characterizing the flexibility of one or a collection of loads - to determine what kinds of demand deviation from the baseline is feasible - has also been studied. However, there is a large diversity in definitions of flexibility and methods proposed to characterize flexibility. As a result there are several gaps in the literature on flexibility characterization. Some approaches on flexibility characterization are based on ad-hoc approximations that lead to highly conservative estimates. In this paper we point out some of these issues and their implications, with the hope to encourage additional research to address them.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Increasing Energy Resiliency to Hurricanes with Battery and Rooftop Solar Through Intelligent Control
Authors:
Ninad Gaikwad,
Naren Srivaths Raman,
Prabir Barooah
Abstract:
Rooftop solar photovoltaic (PV) panels together with batteries can provide resiliency to blackouts during natural disasters such as hurricanes. Without intelligent and automated decision making that can trade off conflicting requirements, a large PV system and a large battery is needed to provide meaningful resiliency. By utilizing the flexibility of various household demands, an intelligent syste…
▽ More
Rooftop solar photovoltaic (PV) panels together with batteries can provide resiliency to blackouts during natural disasters such as hurricanes. Without intelligent and automated decision making that can trade off conflicting requirements, a large PV system and a large battery is needed to provide meaningful resiliency. By utilizing the flexibility of various household demands, an intelligent system can ensure that critical loads are serviced longer than a non-intelligent system. As a result a smaller (and thus lower cost) system can provide the same energy resilience that a much larger system will be needed otherwise.
In this paper we propose such an intelligent control system that uses a model predictive control (MPC) architecture. The optimization problem is formulated as a MILP (mixed integer linear program) due to the on/off decisions for the loads. Performance is compared with two rule based controllers, a simple all-or-none controller that mimics what is available now commercially, and a Rule-Based controller that uses the same information that the MPC controller uses. The controllers are tested through simulation on a PV-battery system chosen carefully for a small single family house in Florida. Simulations are conducted for a one week period during hurricane Irma in 2017. Simulations show that the size of the PV+battery system to provide a certain resiliency performance can be halved by the proposed control system.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Smart Home Energy Management System for Power System Resiliency
Authors:
Ninad Gaikwad,
Naren Srivaths Raman,
Prabir Barooah
Abstract:
The need for resiliency of electricity supply is increasing due to increasing frequency of natural disasters---such as hurricanes---that disrupt supply from the power grid. Rooftop solar photovoltaic (PV) panels together with batteries can provide resiliency in many scenarios. Without intelligent and automated decision making that can trade off conflicting requirements, a large PV system and a lar…
▽ More
The need for resiliency of electricity supply is increasing due to increasing frequency of natural disasters---such as hurricanes---that disrupt supply from the power grid. Rooftop solar photovoltaic (PV) panels together with batteries can provide resiliency in many scenarios. Without intelligent and automated decision making that can trade off conflicting requirements, a large PV system and a large battery is needed to provide meaningful resiliency. By using forecast of solar generation and household demand, an intelligent decision maker can operate the equipment (battery and critical loads) to ensure that the critical loads are serviced to the maximum duration possible. With the aid of such an intelligent control system, a smaller (and thus lower cost) system can service the primary loads for the same duration that a much larger system will be needed to service otherwise.
In this paper we propose such an intelligent control system. A model predictive control (MPC) architecture is used that uses available measurements and forecasts to make optimal decisions for batteries and critical loads in real time. The optimization problem is formulated as a MILP (mixed integer linear program) due to the on/off decisions for the loads. Performance is compared with a non-intelligent baseline controller, for a PV-battery system chosen carefully for a single family house in Florida. Simulations are conducted for a one week period during hurricane Irma in 2017. Simulations show that the cost of the PV+battery system to provide a certain resiliency performance, duration the primary load can be serviced successfully, can be halved by the proposed control system.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
MPC for Energy Efficient HVAC Control with Humidity and Latent Heat Considerations
Authors:
Naren Srivaths Raman,
Karthikeya Devaprasad,
Bo Chen,
Herbert A. Ingley,
Prabir Barooah
Abstract:
Even though energy efficient climate control of buildings using model predictive control (MPC) has been widely investigated, most MPC formulations ignore humidity and latent heat. The inclusion of moisture makes the problem considerably more challenging, primarily since a cooling and dehumidifying coil model which accounts for both sensible and latent heat transfers is needed. In this work, we pro…
▽ More
Even though energy efficient climate control of buildings using model predictive control (MPC) has been widely investigated, most MPC formulations ignore humidity and latent heat. The inclusion of moisture makes the problem considerably more challenging, primarily since a cooling and dehumidifying coil model which accounts for both sensible and latent heat transfers is needed. In this work, we propose an MPC controller in which humidity and latent heat are incorporated in a principled manner. We construct low order data-driven models of a cooling and dehumidifying coil that can be used in the MPC formulation. The resulting controller's performance is tested in simulation using a plant that differs significantly from the model used by the optimizer. Additionally, the performance of the proposed controller is compared with that of a naive MPC controller which does not explicitly consider humidity, and also to that of a conventional rule-based controller. Simulations show that the proposed MPC controller outperforms the other two consistently. It is also observed that the naive MPC formulation which does not consider humidity leads to poor humidity control under certain conditions. Such violations in humidity can adversely affect occupant comfort and health.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Differentially Private Smart Metering: Implementation, Analytics, and Billing
Authors:
Matthew Hale,
Prabir Barooah,
Kendall Parker,
Kasra Yazdani
Abstract:
Smart power grids offer to revolutionize power distribution by sharing granular power usage data, though this same data sharing can reveal a great deal about users, and there are serious privacy concerns for customers. In this paper, we address these concerns using differential privacy. Differential privacy is a statistical notion of privacy that adds carefully-calibrated noise to sensitive data b…
▽ More
Smart power grids offer to revolutionize power distribution by sharing granular power usage data, though this same data sharing can reveal a great deal about users, and there are serious privacy concerns for customers. In this paper, we address these concerns using differential privacy. Differential privacy is a statistical notion of privacy that adds carefully-calibrated noise to sensitive data before sharing it, and we apply it to provide strong privacy guarantees to individual customers. Under this implementation, we quantify the impact of privacy upon smart grid analytics, which are of interest to utilities, to quantify the loss in accuracy incurred by privacy. Simultaneously, we quantify the financial impact of privacy through bounding deviations in customers' utility bills. Simulation results are provided using actual power usage data, demonstrating the viability of this approach in practice.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
On the round-trip efficiency of an HVAC-based virtual battery
Authors:
Naren Srivaths Raman,
Prabir Barooah
Abstract:
Flexible loads, especially heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning (HVAC) systems can be used to provide a battery-like service to the power grid by varying their demand up and down over a baseline. Recent work has reported that providing virtual energy storage with HVAC systems lead to a net loss of energy, akin to a low round-trip efficiency (RTE) of a battery. In this work we rigorously anal…
▽ More
Flexible loads, especially heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning (HVAC) systems can be used to provide a battery-like service to the power grid by varying their demand up and down over a baseline. Recent work has reported that providing virtual energy storage with HVAC systems lead to a net loss of energy, akin to a low round-trip efficiency (RTE) of a battery. In this work we rigorously analyze the RTE of a virtual battery through a simplified physics-based model. We show that the low RTEs reported in recent experimental and simulation work are an artifact of the experimental/simulation setup. When the HVAC system is repeatedly used as a virtual battery, the asymptotic RTE is 1. Robustness of the result to assumptions made in the analysis is illustrated through a simulation case study.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2018; v1 submitted 7 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Distributed demand-side contingency-service provisioning while minimizing consumer disutility through local frequency measurements and inter-load communication
Authors:
Jonathan Brooks,
Prabir Barooah
Abstract:
We consider the problem of smart and flexible loads providing contingency reserves to the electric grid and provide a Distributed Gradient Projection (DGP) algorithm to minimize loads' disutility while providing contingency services. Each load uses locally obtained grid-frequency measurements and inter-load communication to coordinate their actions, and the privacy of each load is preserved: only…
▽ More
We consider the problem of smart and flexible loads providing contingency reserves to the electric grid and provide a Distributed Gradient Projection (DGP) algorithm to minimize loads' disutility while providing contingency services. Each load uses locally obtained grid-frequency measurements and inter-load communication to coordinate their actions, and the privacy of each load is preserved: only gradient information is exchanged---not disutility or consumption information. We provide a proof of convergence of the proposed DGP algorithm, and we compare its performance through simulations to that of a "dual algorithm" previously proposed in the literature that solved the dual optimization problem. The DGP algorithm solves the primal problem. Its main advantage over the dual algorithm is that it is applicable to convex---but not necessarily strictly convex---consumer disutility functions, such as a model of consumer behavior that is insensitive to small changes in consumption, while the dual algorithm is not. Simulations show the DGP algorithm aids in arresting grid-frequency deviations in response to contingency events and performs better or similarly to the dual algorithm in cases where the two can be compared.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2017; v1 submitted 15 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Ancillary Service to the Grid Using Intelligent Deferrable Loads
Authors:
Sean Meyn,
Prabir Barooah,
Ana Bušić,
Yue Chen,
Jordan Ehren
Abstract:
Renewable energy sources such as wind and solar power have a high degree of unpredictability and time-variation, which makes balancing demand and supply challenging. One possible way to address this challenge is to harness the inherent flexibility in demand of many types of loads. Introduced in this paper is a technique for decentralized control for automated demand response that can be used by gr…
▽ More
Renewable energy sources such as wind and solar power have a high degree of unpredictability and time-variation, which makes balancing demand and supply challenging. One possible way to address this challenge is to harness the inherent flexibility in demand of many types of loads. Introduced in this paper is a technique for decentralized control for automated demand response that can be used by grid operators as ancillary service for maintaining demand-supply balance.
A Markovian Decision Process (MDP) model is introduced for an individual load. A randomized control architecture is proposed, motivated by the need for decentralized decision making, and the need to avoid synchronization that can lead to large and detrimental spikes in demand. An aggregate model for a large number of loads is then developed by examining the mean field limit. A key innovation is an LTI-system approximation of the aggregate nonlinear model, with a scalar signal as the input and a measure of the aggregate demand as the output. This makes the approximation particularly convenient for control design at the grid level.
The second half of the paper contains a detailed application of these results to a network of residential pools. Simulations are provided to illustrate the accuracy of the approximations and effectiveness of the proposed control approach.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Improving Convergence Rate of Distributed Consensus Through Asymmetric Weights
Authors:
He Hao,
Prabir Barooah
Abstract:
We propose a weight design method to increase the convergence rate of distributed consensus. Prior work has focused on symmetric weight design due to computational tractability. We show that with proper choice of asymmetric weights, the convergence rate can be improved significantly over even the symmetric optimal design. In particular, we prove that the convergence rate in a lattice graph can be…
▽ More
We propose a weight design method to increase the convergence rate of distributed consensus. Prior work has focused on symmetric weight design due to computational tractability. We show that with proper choice of asymmetric weights, the convergence rate can be improved significantly over even the symmetric optimal design. In particular, we prove that the convergence rate in a lattice graph can be made independent of the size of the graph with asymmetric weights. We then use a Sturm-Liouville operator to approximate the graph Laplacian of more general graphs. A general weight design method is proposed based on this continuum approximation. Numerical computations show that the resulting convergence rate with asymmetric weight design is improved considerably over that with symmetric optimal weights and Metropolis-Hastings weights.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2012;
originally announced March 2012.
-
On achieving size-independent stability margin of vehicular lattice formations with distributed control
Authors:
He Hao,
Prabir Barooah
Abstract:
We study the stability margin of a vehicular formation with distributed control, in which the control at each vehicle only depends on the information from its neighbors in an information graph. We consider a D-dimensional lattice as information graph, of which the 1-D platoon is a special case. The stability margin is measured by the real part of the least stable eigenvalue of the closed-loop stat…
▽ More
We study the stability margin of a vehicular formation with distributed control, in which the control at each vehicle only depends on the information from its neighbors in an information graph. We consider a D-dimensional lattice as information graph, of which the 1-D platoon is a special case. The stability margin is measured by the real part of the least stable eigenvalue of the closed-loop state matrix, which quantifies the rate of decay of initial errors. In [1], it was shown that with symmetric control, in which two neighbors put equal weight on information received from each other, the stability margin of a 1-D vehicular platoon decays to 0 as O(1/N^2), where N is the number of vehicles. Moreover, a perturbation analysis was used to show that with vanishingly small amount of asymmetry in the control gains, the stability margin scaling can be improved to O(1/N). In this paper, we show that, with judicious choice of non-vanishing asymmetry in control, the stability margin of the closed loop can be bounded away from zero uniformly in N. Asymmetry in control gains thus makes the control architecture highly scalable. The results are also generalized to D-dimensional lattice information graphs that were studied in [2], and the correspondingly stronger conclusions than those derived in [2] are obtained. In addition, we show that the size-independent stability margin can be achieved with relative position and relative velocity (RPRV) feedback as well as relative position and absolute velocity (RPAV) feedback, while the analysis in [1], [2] was only for the RPAV case.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2012; v1 submitted 8 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
-
Stability Margin Scaling Laws for Distributed Formation Control as a Function of Network Structure
Authors:
He Hao,
Prabir Barooah,
Prashant G. Mehta
Abstract:
We consider the problem of distributed formation control of a large number of vehicles. An individual vehicle in the formation is assumed to be a fully actuated point mass. A distributed control law is examined: the control action on an individual vehicle depends on (i) its own velocity and (ii) the relative position measurements with a small subset of vehicles (neighbors) in the formation. The ne…
▽ More
We consider the problem of distributed formation control of a large number of vehicles. An individual vehicle in the formation is assumed to be a fully actuated point mass. A distributed control law is examined: the control action on an individual vehicle depends on (i) its own velocity and (ii) the relative position measurements with a small subset of vehicles (neighbors) in the formation. The neighbors are defined according to an information graph.
In this paper we describe a methodology for modeling, analysis, and distributed control design of such vehicular formations whose information graph is a D-dimensional lattice. The modeling relies on an approximation based on a partial differential equation (PDE) that describes the spatio-temporal evolution of position errors in the formation. The analysis and control design is based on the PDE model. We deduce asymptotic formulae for the closed-loop stability margin (absolute value of the real part of the least stable eigenvalue) of the controlled formation. The stability margin is shown to approach 0 as the number of vehicles N goes to infinity. The exponent on the scaling law for the stability margin is influenced by the dimension and the structure of the information graph. We show that the scaling law can be improved by employing a higher dimensional information graph.
Apart from analysis, the PDE model is used for a mistuning-based design of control gains to maximize the stability margin. Mistuning here refers to small perturbation of control gains from their nominal symmetric values. We show that the mistuned design can have a significantly better stability margin even with a small amount of perturbation. The results of the analysis with the PDE model are corroborated with numerical computation of eigenvalues with the state-space model of the formation.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2010; v1 submitted 3 May, 2010;
originally announced May 2010.
-
Mistuning-based Control Design to Improve Closed-Loop Stability of Vehicular Platoons
Authors:
Prabir Barooah,
Prashant G. Mehta,
Joao P Hespanha
Abstract:
We consider a decentralized bidirectional control of a platoon of N identical vehicles moving in a straight line. The control objective is for each vehicle to maintain a constant velocity and inter-vehicular separation using only the local information from itself and its two nearest neighbors. Each vehicle is modeled as a double integrator. To aid the analysis, we use continuous approximation to…
▽ More
We consider a decentralized bidirectional control of a platoon of N identical vehicles moving in a straight line. The control objective is for each vehicle to maintain a constant velocity and inter-vehicular separation using only the local information from itself and its two nearest neighbors. Each vehicle is modeled as a double integrator. To aid the analysis, we use continuous approximation to derive a partial differential equation (PDE) approximation of the discrete platoon dynamics. The PDE model is used to explain the progressive loss of closed-loop stability with increasing number of vehicles, and to devise ways to combat this loss of stability.
If every vehicle uses the same controller, we show that the least stable closed-loop eigenvalue approaches zero as O(1/N^2) in the limit of a large number (N) of vehicles. We then show how to ameliorate this loss of stability by small amounts of "mistuning", i.e., changing the controller gains from their nominal values. We prove that with arbitrary small amounts of mistuning, the asymptotic behavior of the least stable closed loop eigenvalue can be improved to O(1/N) All the conclusions drawn from analysis of the PDE model are corroborated via numerical calculations of the state-space platoon model.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
