-
The Affine Tamari Lattice
Authors:
Grant Barkley,
Colin Defant
Abstract:
Given a fixed integer $n\geq 2$, we construct two new finite lattices that we call the cyclic Tamari lattice and the affine Tamari lattice. The cyclic Tamari lattice is a sublattice and a quotient lattice of the cyclic Dyer lattice, which is the infinite lattice of translation-invariant total orders under containment of inversion sets. The affine Tamari lattice is a quotient of the Dyer lattice, w…
▽ More
Given a fixed integer $n\geq 2$, we construct two new finite lattices that we call the cyclic Tamari lattice and the affine Tamari lattice. The cyclic Tamari lattice is a sublattice and a quotient lattice of the cyclic Dyer lattice, which is the infinite lattice of translation-invariant total orders under containment of inversion sets. The affine Tamari lattice is a quotient of the Dyer lattice, which in turn is a quotient of the cyclic Dyer lattice and is isomorphic to the collection of biclosed sets of the root system of type $\widetilde{A}_{n-1}$ under inclusion. We provide numerous combinatorial and algebraic descriptions of these lattices using translation-invariant total orders, translation-invariant binary in-ordered trees, noncrossing arc diagrams, torsion classes, triangulations, and translation-invariant noncrossing partitions. The cardinalities of the cyclic and affine Tamari lattices are the Catalan numbers of types $B_n$ and $D_n$, respectively. We show that these lattices are self-dual and semidistributive, and we describe their decompositions coming from the Fundamental Theorem of Finite Semidistributive Lattices. We also show that the rowmotion operators on these lattices have well-behaved orbit structures, which we describe via the cyclic sieving phenomenon. Our new combinatorial framework allows us to prove that the lengths of maximal green sequences for the completed path algebra of the oriented $n$-cycle are precisely the integers in the interval $[2n-1,\binom{n+1}{2}]$.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Extended weak order for the affine symmetric group
Authors:
Grant T. Barkley
Abstract:
The extended weak order on a Coxeter group $W$ is the poset of biclosed sets in its root system. In (Barkley-Speyer 2024), it was shown that when $W=\widetilde{S}_n$ is the affine symmetric group, then the extended weak order is a quotient of the lattice $L_n$ of translation-invariant total orderings of the integers. In this article, we give a combinatorial introduction to $L_n$ and the extended w…
▽ More
The extended weak order on a Coxeter group $W$ is the poset of biclosed sets in its root system. In (Barkley-Speyer 2024), it was shown that when $W=\widetilde{S}_n$ is the affine symmetric group, then the extended weak order is a quotient of the lattice $L_n$ of translation-invariant total orderings of the integers. In this article, we give a combinatorial introduction to $L_n$ and the extended weak order on $\widetilde{S}_n$. We show that $L_n$ is an algebraic completely semidistributive lattice. We describe its canonical join representations using a cyclic version of Reading's non-crossing arc diagrams. We also show analogous statements for the lattice of all total orders of the integers, which is the extended weak order on the symmetric group $S_\infty$. A key property of both of these lattices is that they are profinite; we also prove that a profinite lattice is join semidistributive if and only if its compact elements have canonical join representations. We conjecture that the extended weak order of any Coxeter group is a profinite semidistributive lattice.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
The BBDVW Conjecture for Kazhdan-Lusztig polynomials of lower intervals
Authors:
Grant T. Barkley,
Christian Gaetz
Abstract:
Blundell, Buesing, Davies, Veličković, and Williamson (BBDVW) introduced the notion of a hypercube decomposition of an interval in Bruhat order. They conjectured a recursive formula in terms of this structure which, if shown for all intervals, would imply the Combinatorial Invariance Conjecture of Lusztig and Dyer, for Kazhdan-Lusztig polynomials of the symmetric group. In this article, we prove i…
▽ More
Blundell, Buesing, Davies, Veličković, and Williamson (BBDVW) introduced the notion of a hypercube decomposition of an interval in Bruhat order. They conjectured a recursive formula in terms of this structure which, if shown for all intervals, would imply the Combinatorial Invariance Conjecture of Lusztig and Dyer, for Kazhdan-Lusztig polynomials of the symmetric group. In this article, we prove implications between the BBDVW Conjecture and several other recurrences for hypercube decompositions, under varying hypotheses, which have appeared in the recent literature. As an application, we prove the BBDVW Conjecture for lower intervals $[e,v]$, the first non-trivial class of intervals for which it has been established.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2025; v1 submitted 13 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
On two notions of total positivity for generalized partial flag varieties of classical Lie types
Authors:
Grant Barkley,
Jonathan Boretsky,
Christopher Eur,
Jiyang Gao
Abstract:
For Grassmannians, Lusztig's notion of total positivity coincides with positivity of the Plucker coordinates. This coincidence underpins the rich interaction between matroid theory, tropical geometry, and the theory of total positivity. Bloch and Karp furthermore characterized the (type A) partial flag varieties for which the two notions of positivity similarly coincide. We characterize the symple…
▽ More
For Grassmannians, Lusztig's notion of total positivity coincides with positivity of the Plucker coordinates. This coincidence underpins the rich interaction between matroid theory, tropical geometry, and the theory of total positivity. Bloch and Karp furthermore characterized the (type A) partial flag varieties for which the two notions of positivity similarly coincide. We characterize the symplectic (type C) and odd-orthogonal (type B) partial flag varieties for which Lusztig's total positivity coincides with Plucker positivity.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2024; v1 submitted 15 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Oriented matroid structures on rank 3 root systems
Authors:
Grant Barkley,
Katherine Tung
Abstract:
We show that, given a rank 3 affine root system $Φ$ with Weyl group $W$, there is a unique oriented matroid structure on $Φ$ which is $W$-equivariant and restricts to the usual matroid structure on rank 2 subsystems. Such oriented matroids were called oriented matroid root systems in Dyer-Wang (2021), and are known to be non-unique in higher rank. We also show uniqueness for any finite root system…
▽ More
We show that, given a rank 3 affine root system $Φ$ with Weyl group $W$, there is a unique oriented matroid structure on $Φ$ which is $W$-equivariant and restricts to the usual matroid structure on rank 2 subsystems. Such oriented matroids were called oriented matroid root systems in Dyer-Wang (2021), and are known to be non-unique in higher rank. We also show uniqueness for any finite root system or "clean" rank 3 root system (which conjecturally includes all rank 3 root systems).
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
A note on Combinatorial Invariance of Kazhdan--Lusztig polynomials
Authors:
Francesco Esposito,
Mario Marietti,
Grant T. Barkley,
Christian Gaetz
Abstract:
We introduce the concepts of an amazing hypercube decomposition and a double shortcut for it, and use these new ideas to formulate a conjecture implying the Combinatorial Invariance Conjecture of the Kazhdan--Lusztig polynomials for the symmetric group. This conjecture has the advantage of being combinatorial in nature. The appendix by Grant T. Barkley and Christian Gaetz discusses the related not…
▽ More
We introduce the concepts of an amazing hypercube decomposition and a double shortcut for it, and use these new ideas to formulate a conjecture implying the Combinatorial Invariance Conjecture of the Kazhdan--Lusztig polynomials for the symmetric group. This conjecture has the advantage of being combinatorial in nature. The appendix by Grant T. Barkley and Christian Gaetz discusses the related notion of double hypercubes and proves an analogous conjecture for these in the case of co-elementary intervals.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2024; v1 submitted 19 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
On combinatorial invariance of parabolic Kazhdan-Lusztig polynomials
Authors:
Grant T. Barkley,
Christian Gaetz
Abstract:
We show that the Combinatorial Invariance Conjecture for Kazhdan-Lusztig polynomials due to Lusztig and to Dyer, its parabolic analog due to Marietti, and a refined parabolic version that we introduce, are equivalent. We use this to give a new proof of Marietti's conjecture in the case of lower Bruhat intervals and to prove several new cases of the parabolic conjectures.
We show that the Combinatorial Invariance Conjecture for Kazhdan-Lusztig polynomials due to Lusztig and to Dyer, its parabolic analog due to Marietti, and a refined parabolic version that we introduce, are equivalent. We use this to give a new proof of Marietti's conjecture in the case of lower Bruhat intervals and to prove several new cases of the parabolic conjectures.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2025; v1 submitted 5 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Bender--Knuth Billiards in Coxeter Groups
Authors:
Grant Barkley,
Colin Defant,
Eliot Hodges,
Noah Kravitz,
Mitchell Lee
Abstract:
Let $(W,S)$ be a Coxeter system, and write $S=\{s_i:i\in I\}$, where $I$ is a finite index set. Fix a nonempty convex subset $\mathscr{L}$ of $W$. If $W$ is of type $A$, then $\mathscr{L}$ is the set of linear extensions of a poset, and there are important Bender--Knuth involutions $\mathrm{BK}_i\colon\mathscr{L}\to\mathscr{L}$ indexed by elements of $I$. For arbitrary $W$ and for each $i\in I$, w…
▽ More
Let $(W,S)$ be a Coxeter system, and write $S=\{s_i:i\in I\}$, where $I$ is a finite index set. Fix a nonempty convex subset $\mathscr{L}$ of $W$. If $W$ is of type $A$, then $\mathscr{L}$ is the set of linear extensions of a poset, and there are important Bender--Knuth involutions $\mathrm{BK}_i\colon\mathscr{L}\to\mathscr{L}$ indexed by elements of $I$. For arbitrary $W$ and for each $i\in I$, we introduce an operator $τ_i\colon W\to W$ (depending on $\mathscr{L}$) that we call a noninvertible Bender--Knuth toggle; this operator restricts to an involution on $\mathscr{L}$ that coincides with $\mathrm{BK}_i$ in type $A$. Given a Coxeter element $c=s_{i_n}\cdots s_{i_1}$, we consider the operator $\mathrm{Pro}_c=τ_{i_n}\cdotsτ_{i_1}$. We say $W$ is futuristic if for every nonempty finite convex set $\mathscr{L}$, every Coxeter element $c$, and every $u\in W$, there exists an integer $K\geq 0$ such that $\mathrm{Pro}_c^K(u)\in\mathscr{L}$. We prove that finite Coxeter groups, right-angled Coxeter groups, rank-3 Coxeter groups, affine Coxeter groups of types $\widetilde A$ and $\widetilde C$, and Coxeter groups whose Coxeter graphs are complete are all futuristic. When $W$ is finite, we actually prove that if $s_{i_N}\cdots s_{i_1}$ is a reduced expression for the long element of $W$, then $τ_{i_N}\cdotsτ_{i_1}(W)=\mathscr{L}$; this allows us to determine the smallest integer $\mathrm{M}(c)$ such that $\mathrm{Pro}_c^{\mathrm{M}(c)}(W)=\mathscr{L}$ for all $\mathscr{L}$. We also exhibit infinitely many non-futuristic Coxeter groups, including all irreducible affine Coxeter groups that are not of type $\widetilde A$, $\widetilde C$, or $\widetilde G_2$.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2024; v1 submitted 30 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Affine extended weak order is a lattice
Authors:
Grant T. Barkley,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Coxeter groups are equipped with a partial order known as the weak Bruhat order, such that $u \leq v$ if the inversions of $u$ are a subset of the inversions of $v$. In finite Coxeter groups, weak order is a complete lattice, but in infinite Coxeter groups it is only a meet semi-lattice. Motivated by questions in Kazhdan-Lusztig theory, Matthew Dyer introduced a larger poset, now known as extended…
▽ More
Coxeter groups are equipped with a partial order known as the weak Bruhat order, such that $u \leq v$ if the inversions of $u$ are a subset of the inversions of $v$. In finite Coxeter groups, weak order is a complete lattice, but in infinite Coxeter groups it is only a meet semi-lattice. Motivated by questions in Kazhdan-Lusztig theory, Matthew Dyer introduced a larger poset, now known as extended weak order, which contains the weak Bruhat order as an order ideal and coincides with it for finite Coxeter groups. The extended weak order is the containment order on certain sets of positive roots: those which satisfy a geometric condition making them "biclosed". The finite biclosed sets are precisely the inversion sets of Coxeter group elements. Generalizing the result for finite Coxeter groups, Dyer conjectured that the extended weak order is always a complete lattice, even for infinite Coxeter groups.
In this paper, we prove Dyer's conjecture for Coxeter groups of affine type. To do so, we introduce the notion of a clean arrangement, which is a hyperplane arrangement where the regions are in bijection with biclosed sets. We show that root poset order ideals in a finite or rank 3 untwisted affine root system are clean. We set up a general framework for reducing Dyer's conjecture to checking cleanliness of certain subarrangements. We conjecture this framework can be used to prove Dyer's conjecture for all Coxeter groups.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2024; v1 submitted 9 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Combinatorial invariance for Kazhdan-Lusztig $R$-polynomials of elementary intervals
Authors:
Grant T. Barkley,
Christian Gaetz
Abstract:
We adapt the hypercube decompositions introduced by Blundell-Buesing-Davies-Veličković-Williamson to prove the Combinatorial Invariance Conjecture for Kazhdan-Lusztig $R$-polynomials in the case of elementary intervals in $S_n$. This significantly generalizes the main previously-known case of the conjecture, that of lower intervals.
We adapt the hypercube decompositions introduced by Blundell-Buesing-Davies-Veličković-Williamson to prove the Combinatorial Invariance Conjecture for Kazhdan-Lusztig $R$-polynomials in the case of elementary intervals in $S_n$. This significantly generalizes the main previously-known case of the conjecture, that of lower intervals.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2025; v1 submitted 27 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Combinatorial descriptions of biclosed sets in affine type
Authors:
Grant T. Barkley,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Let $W$ be a Coxeter group and let $Φ^+$ be its positive roots. A subset $B$ of $Φ^+$ is called biclosed if, whenever we have roots $α$, $β$ and $γ$ with $γ\in \mathbb{R}_{>0} α+ \mathbb{R}_{>0} β$, if $α$ and $β\in B$ then $γ\in B$ and, if $α$ and $β\not\in B$, then $γ\not\in B$. The finite biclosed sets are the inversion sets of the elements of $W$, and the containment between finite inversion s…
▽ More
Let $W$ be a Coxeter group and let $Φ^+$ be its positive roots. A subset $B$ of $Φ^+$ is called biclosed if, whenever we have roots $α$, $β$ and $γ$ with $γ\in \mathbb{R}_{>0} α+ \mathbb{R}_{>0} β$, if $α$ and $β\in B$ then $γ\in B$ and, if $α$ and $β\not\in B$, then $γ\not\in B$. The finite biclosed sets are the inversion sets of the elements of $W$, and the containment between finite inversion sets is the weak order on $W$. Matthew Dyer suggested studying the poset of all biclosed subsets of $Φ^+$, ordered by containment, and conjectured that it is a complete lattice. As progress towards Dyer's conjecture, we classify all biclosed sets in the affine root systems. We provide both a type uniform description, and concrete models in the classical types $\widetilde{A}$, $\widetilde{B}$, $\widetilde{C}$, $\widetilde{D}$. We use our models to prove that biclosed sets form a complete lattice in types $\widetilde{A}$ and $\widetilde{C}$.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2024; v1 submitted 13 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Channels, Billiards, and Perfect Matching 2-Divisibility
Authors:
Grant T. Barkley,
Ricky Ini Liu
Abstract:
Let $m_G$ denote the number of perfect matchings of the graph $G$. We introduce a number of combinatorial tools for determining the parity of $m_G$ and giving a lower bound on the power of 2 dividing $m_G$. In particular, we introduce certain vertex sets called channels, which correspond to elements in the kernel of the adjacency matrix of $G$ modulo $2$. A result of Lovász states that the existen…
▽ More
Let $m_G$ denote the number of perfect matchings of the graph $G$. We introduce a number of combinatorial tools for determining the parity of $m_G$ and giving a lower bound on the power of 2 dividing $m_G$. In particular, we introduce certain vertex sets called channels, which correspond to elements in the kernel of the adjacency matrix of $G$ modulo $2$. A result of Lovász states that the existence of a nontrivial channel is equivalent to $m_G$ being even. We give a new combinatorial proof of this result and strengthen it by showing that the number of channels gives a lower bound on the power of $2$ dividing $m_G$ when $G$ is planar. We describe a number of local graph operations which preserve the number of channels. We also establish a surprising connection between 2-divisibility of $m_G$ and dynamical systems by showing an equivalency between channels and billiard paths. We exploit this relationship to show that $2^{\frac{\gcd(m+1,n+1)-1}{2}}$ divides the number of domino tilings of the $m\times n$ rectangle. We also use billiard paths to give a fast algorithm for counting channels (and hence determining the parity of the number of domino tilings) in simply connected regions of the square grid.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2021; v1 submitted 19 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
