-
Monoidal strengthening of simple $\mathcal{V}$-polyhedral disjunctive cuts
Authors:
Aleksandr M. Kazachkov,
Egon Balas
Abstract:
Disjunctive cutting planes can tighten a relaxation of a mixed-integer linear program. Traditionally, such cuts are obtained by solving a higher-dimensional linear program, whose additional variables cause the procedure to be computationally prohibitive. Adopting a $\mathcal{V}$-polyhedral perspective is a practical alternative that enables the separation of disjunctive cuts via a linear program w…
▽ More
Disjunctive cutting planes can tighten a relaxation of a mixed-integer linear program. Traditionally, such cuts are obtained by solving a higher-dimensional linear program, whose additional variables cause the procedure to be computationally prohibitive. Adopting a $\mathcal{V}$-polyhedral perspective is a practical alternative that enables the separation of disjunctive cuts via a linear program with only as many variables as the original problem. The drawback is that the classical approach of monoidal strengthening cannot be directly employed without the values of the extra variables appearing in the extended formulation. We derive how to compute these values from a solution to the linear program generating $\mathcal{V}$-polyhedral disjunctive cuts. We then present computational experiments with monoidal strengthening of cuts from disjunctions with as many as 64 terms. Some instances are dramatically impacted, with strengthening increasing the gap closed by the cuts from 0 to 100%. However, for larger disjunctions, monoidal strengthening appears to be less effective, for which we identify a potential cause.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
$\mathcal{V}$-Polyhedral Disjunctive Cuts
Authors:
Egon Balas,
Aleksandr M. Kazachkov
Abstract:
We introduce $\mathcal{V}$-polyhedral disjunctive cuts (VPCs) for generating valid inequalities from general disjunctions. Cuts are critical to integer programming solvers, but the benefit from many families is only realized when the cuts are applied recursively, causing numerical instability and "tailing off" of cut strength after several rounds. To mitigate these difficulties, the VPC framework…
▽ More
We introduce $\mathcal{V}$-polyhedral disjunctive cuts (VPCs) for generating valid inequalities from general disjunctions. Cuts are critical to integer programming solvers, but the benefit from many families is only realized when the cuts are applied recursively, causing numerical instability and "tailing off" of cut strength after several rounds. To mitigate these difficulties, the VPC framework offers a practical method for generating strong cuts without resorting to recursion. The framework starts with a disjunction whose terms partition the feasible region into smaller subproblems, then obtains a collection of points and rays from the disjunctive terms, from which we build a linear program whose feasible solutions correspond to valid disjunctive cuts. Though a naïve implementation would result in an exponentially-sized optimization problem, we show how to efficiently construct this linear program, such that it is much smaller than the one from the alternative higher-dimensional cut-generating linear program. This enables us to test strong multiterm disjunctions that arise from the leaf nodes of a partial branch-and-bound tree. In addition to proving useful theoretical properties of the cuts, we evaluate their performance computationally through an implementation in the open-source COIN-OR framework. In the results, VPCs from a strong disjunction significantly improve the gap closed compared to existing cuts in solvers, and they also decrease some instances' solving time when used with branch and bound.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2024; v1 submitted 27 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
When Lift-and-Project Cuts are Different
Authors:
Egon Balas,
Thiago Serra
Abstract:
In this paper, we present a method to determine if a lift-and-project cut for a mixed-integer linear program is irregular, in which case the cut is not equivalent to any intersection cut from the bases of the linear relaxation. This is an important question due to the intense research activity for the past decade on cuts from multiple rows of simplex tableau as well as on lift-and-project cuts fro…
▽ More
In this paper, we present a method to determine if a lift-and-project cut for a mixed-integer linear program is irregular, in which case the cut is not equivalent to any intersection cut from the bases of the linear relaxation. This is an important question due to the intense research activity for the past decade on cuts from multiple rows of simplex tableau as well as on lift-and-project cuts from non-split disjunctions. While it is known since Balas and Perregaard (2003) that lift-and-project cuts from split disjunctions are always equivalent to intersection cuts and consequently to such multi-row cuts, Balas and Kis (2016) have recently shown that there is a necessary and sufficient condition in the case of arbitrary disjunctions: a lift-and-project cut is regular if, and only if, it corresponds to a regular basic solution of the Cut Generating Linear Program (CGLP). This paper has four contributions. First, we state a result that simplifies the verification of regularity for basic CGLP solutions from Balas and Kis (2016). Second, we provide a mixed-integer formulation that checks whether there is a regular CGLP solution for a given cut that is regular in a broader sense, which also encompasses irregular cuts that are implied by the regular cut closure. Third, we describe a numerical procedure based on such formulation that identifies irregular lift-and-project cuts. Finally, we use this method to evaluate how often lift-and-project cuts from simple $t$-branch split disjunctions are irregular, and thus not equivalent to multi-row cuts, on 74 instances of the MIPLIB benchmarks.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2020; v1 submitted 15 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Partial hyperplane activation for generalized intersection cuts
Authors:
Aleksandr M. Kazachkov,
Selvaprabu Nadarajah,
Egon Balas,
François Margot
Abstract:
The generalized intersection cut (GIC) paradigm is a recent framework for generating cutting planes in mixed integer programming with attractive theoretical properties. We investigate this computationally unexplored paradigm and observe that a key hyperplane activation procedure embedded in it is not computationally viable. To overcome this issue, we develop a novel replacement to this procedure c…
▽ More
The generalized intersection cut (GIC) paradigm is a recent framework for generating cutting planes in mixed integer programming with attractive theoretical properties. We investigate this computationally unexplored paradigm and observe that a key hyperplane activation procedure embedded in it is not computationally viable. To overcome this issue, we develop a novel replacement to this procedure called partial hyperplane activation (PHA), introduce a variant of PHA based on a notion of hyperplane tilting, and prove the validity of both algorithms. We propose several implementation strategies and parameter choices for our PHA algorithms and provide supporting theoretical results. We computationally evaluate these ideas in the COIN-OR framework on MIPLIB instances. Our findings shed light on the the strengths of the PHA approach as well as suggest properties related to strong cuts that can be targeted in the future.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2018; v1 submitted 7 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Intersection cuts from multiple rows: a disjunctive programming approach
Authors:
Egon Balas,
Andrea Qualizza
Abstract:
We address the issue of generating cutting planes for mixed integer programs from multiple rows of the simplex tableau with the tools of disjunctive programming. A cut from q rows of the simplex tableau is an intersection cuts from a q-dimensional parametric cross-polytope, which can also be viewed as a disjunctive cut from a 2q-term disjunction. We define the disjunctive hull of the q-row problem…
▽ More
We address the issue of generating cutting planes for mixed integer programs from multiple rows of the simplex tableau with the tools of disjunctive programming. A cut from q rows of the simplex tableau is an intersection cuts from a q-dimensional parametric cross-polytope, which can also be viewed as a disjunctive cut from a 2q-term disjunction. We define the disjunctive hull of the q-row problem, describe its relation to the integer hull, and show how to generate its facets. For the case of binary basic variables, we derive cuts from the stronger disjunctions whose terms are equations. We give cut strengthening procedures using the integrality of the nonbasic variables for both the integer and the binary case. Finally, we discuss some computational experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
From Cognitive Binary Logic to Cognitive Intelligent Agents
Authors:
Nicolaie Popescu-Bodorin,
Valentina E. Balas
Abstract:
The relation between self awareness and intelligence is an open problem these days. Despite the fact that self awarness is usually related to Emotional Intelligence, this is not the case here. The problem described in this paper is how to model an agent which knows (Cognitive) Binary Logic and which is also able to pass (without any mistake) a certain family of Turing Tests designed to verify its…
▽ More
The relation between self awareness and intelligence is an open problem these days. Despite the fact that self awarness is usually related to Emotional Intelligence, this is not the case here. The problem described in this paper is how to model an agent which knows (Cognitive) Binary Logic and which is also able to pass (without any mistake) a certain family of Turing Tests designed to verify its knowledge and its discourse about the modal states of truth corresponding to well-formed formulae within the language of Propositional Binary Logic.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
