Showing 1–3 of 3 results for author: Baak, W

Ordered Weighted Averaging for Combinatorial Decision Problems with Interval Uncertainty

Authors: Werner Baak, Marc Goerigk

Abstract: This paper introduces a novel approach to applying the Ordered Weighted Averaging (OWA) operator for uncertain combinatorial problems characterized by interval uncertainty. In this setting, an interval of possible cost outcomes is known for each item, and we would like to minimize the sum of these item costs. By using a weighted integral over the Value-at-Risk, our method provides a more nuanced r… ▽ More This paper introduces a novel approach to applying the Ordered Weighted Averaging (OWA) operator for uncertain combinatorial problems characterized by interval uncertainty. In this setting, an interval of possible cost outcomes is known for each item, and we would like to minimize the sum of these item costs. By using a weighted integral over the Value-at-Risk, our method provides a more nuanced representation of uncertainty and the decision-maker's risk attitude than a previously proposed OWA aggregation method. We analyze fundamental properties of the OWA operator we propose, show that the classic discrete OWA operator converges to our framework when scenarios are sampled, and propose a 2-approximation algorithm. In computational experiments, we compare heuristic solution algorithms to alternative aggregation methods and demonstrate the improved flexibility of our setting. △ Less

Submitted 13 October, 2024; originally announced October 2024.

Robust Min-Max (Regret) Optimization using Ordered Weighted Averaging

Authors: Werner Baak, Marc Goerigk, Adam Kasperski, Paweł Zieliński

Abstract: In decision-making under uncertainty, several criteria have been studied to aggregate the performance of a solution over multiple possible scenarios. This paper introduces a novel variant of ordered weighted averaging (OWA) for optimization problems. It generalizes the classic OWA approach, which includes robust min-max optimization as a special case, as well as min-max regret optimization. We der… ▽ More In decision-making under uncertainty, several criteria have been studied to aggregate the performance of a solution over multiple possible scenarios. This paper introduces a novel variant of ordered weighted averaging (OWA) for optimization problems. It generalizes the classic OWA approach, which includes robust min-max optimization as a special case, as well as min-max regret optimization. We derive new complexity results for this setting, including insights into the inapproximability and approximability of this problem. In particular, we provide stronger positive approximation results that asymptotically improve the previously best-known bounds for the classic OWA approach. In computational experiments, we evaluate the quality of the proposed methods and compare the proposed setting with classic OWA and min-max regret approaches. △ Less

Submitted 29 January, 2024; v1 submitted 16 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

A Preference Elicitation Approach for the Ordered Weighted Averaging Criterion using Solution Choice Observations

Authors: Werner Baak, Marc Goerigk, Michael Hartisch

Abstract: Decisions under uncertainty or with multiple objectives usually require the decision maker to formulate a preference regarding risks or trade-offs. If this preference is known, the ordered weighted averaging (OWA) criterion can be applied to aggregate scenarios or objectives into a single function. Formulating this preference, however, can be challenging, as we need to make explicit what is usuall… ▽ More Decisions under uncertainty or with multiple objectives usually require the decision maker to formulate a preference regarding risks or trade-offs. If this preference is known, the ordered weighted averaging (OWA) criterion can be applied to aggregate scenarios or objectives into a single function. Formulating this preference, however, can be challenging, as we need to make explicit what is usually only implicit knowledge. We explore an optimization-based method of preference elicitation to identify appropriate OWA weights. We follow a data-driven approach, assuming the existence of observations, where the decision maker has chosen the preferred solution, but otherwise remains passive during the elicitation process. We then use these observations to determine the underlying preference by finding the preference vector that is at minimum distance to the polyhedra of feasible vectors for each of the observations. Using our optimization-based model, weights are determined by solving an alternating sequence of linear programs and standard OWA problems. Numerical experiments on risk-averse preference vectors for selection, assignment and knapsack problems show that our passive elicitation method compares well against having to conduct pairwise comparisons and performs particularly well when there are inconsistencies in the decision maker's choices. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2023; v1 submitted 2 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.