-
A Computational Search for Minimal Obstruction Graphs for the Lovász--Schrijver SDP Hierarchy
Authors:
Yu Hin Au,
Levent Tunçel
Abstract:
We study the lift-and-project relaxations of the stable set polytope of graphs generated by $\text{LS}_+$, the SDP lift-and-project operator devised by Lovász and Schrijver. In particular, we focus on searching for $\ell$-minimal graphs, which are graphs on $3\ell$ vertices whose stable set polytope has rank $\ell$ with respect to $\text{LS}_+$. These are the graphs which are the most challenging…
▽ More
We study the lift-and-project relaxations of the stable set polytope of graphs generated by $\text{LS}_+$, the SDP lift-and-project operator devised by Lovász and Schrijver. In particular, we focus on searching for $\ell$-minimal graphs, which are graphs on $3\ell$ vertices whose stable set polytope has rank $\ell$ with respect to $\text{LS}_+$. These are the graphs which are the most challenging for the $\text{LS}_+$ operator according to one of the main complexity measures (smallest graphs with largest $\text{LS}_+$-rank). We introduce the notion of $\text{LS}_+$ certificate packages, which is a framework that allows for efficient and reliable verification of membership of points in $\text{LS}_+$-relaxations. Using this framework, we present numerical certificates which (combined with other results) show that there are at least $49$ $3$-minimal graphs, as well as over $4000$ $4$-minimal graphs. This marks a significant leap from the $14$ $3$-minimal and $588$ $4$-minimal graphs known before this work, with many of the newly-discovered graphs containing novel structures which helps enrich and recalibrate our understanding of $\ell$-minimal graphs. Some of this computational work leads to interesting conjectures. We also find all of the smallest vertex-transitive graphs with $\text{LS}_+$-rank $\ell$ for every $\ell \leq 4$.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Stable Set Polytopes with Rank $|V(G)|/3$ for the Lovász--Schrijver SDP Operator
Authors:
Yu Hin Au,
Levent Tunçel
Abstract:
We study the lift-and-project rank of the stable set polytope of graphs with respect to the Lovász--Schrijver SDP operator $\text{LS}_+$ applied to the fractional stable set polytope. In particular, we show that for every positive integer $\ell$, the smallest possible graph with $\text{LS}_+$-rank $\ell$ contains $3\ell$ vertices. This result is sharp and settles a conjecture posed by Lipták and t…
▽ More
We study the lift-and-project rank of the stable set polytope of graphs with respect to the Lovász--Schrijver SDP operator $\text{LS}_+$ applied to the fractional stable set polytope. In particular, we show that for every positive integer $\ell$, the smallest possible graph with $\text{LS}_+$-rank $\ell$ contains $3\ell$ vertices. This result is sharp and settles a conjecture posed by Lipták and the second author in 2003, as well as answers a generalization of a problem posed by Knuth in 1994. We also show that for every positive integer $\ell$ there exists a vertex-transitive graph on $4\ell+12$ vertices with $\text{LS}_+$-rank at least $\ell$.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2025; v1 submitted 13 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
On Rank-Monotone Graph Operations and Minimal Obstruction Graphs for the Lovász--Schrijver SDP Hierarchy
Authors:
Yu Hin Au,
Levent Tunçel
Abstract:
We study the lift-and-project rank of the stable set polytopes of graphs with respect to the Lovász--Schrijver SDP operator $\text{LS}_+$, with a particular focus on finding and characterizing the smallest graphs with a given $\text{LS}_+$-rank (the needed number of iterations of the $\text{LS}_+$ operator on the fractional stable set polytope to compute the stable set polytope). We introduce a ge…
▽ More
We study the lift-and-project rank of the stable set polytopes of graphs with respect to the Lovász--Schrijver SDP operator $\text{LS}_+$, with a particular focus on finding and characterizing the smallest graphs with a given $\text{LS}_+$-rank (the needed number of iterations of the $\text{LS}_+$ operator on the fractional stable set polytope to compute the stable set polytope). We introduce a generalized vertex-stretching operation that appears to be promising in generating $\text{LS}_+$-minimal graphs and study its properties. We also provide several new $\text{LS}_+$-minimal graphs, most notably the first known instances of $12$-vertex graphs with $\text{LS}_+$-rank $4$, which provides the first advance in this direction since Escalante, Montelar, and Nasini's discovery of a $9$-vertex graph with $\text{LS}_+$-rank $3$ in 2006.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2024; v1 submitted 2 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Stable Set Polytopes with High Lift-and-Project Ranks for the Lovász-Schrijver SDP Operator
Authors:
Yu Hin Au,
Levent Tunçel
Abstract:
We study the lift-and-project rank of the stable set polytopes of graphs with respect to the Lovász-Schrijver SDP operator $\text{LS}_+$. In particular, we focus on a search for relatively small graphs with high $\text{LS}_+$-rank (i.e., the least number of iterations of the $\text{LS}_+$ operator on the fractional stable set polytope to compute the stable set polytope). We provide families of gra…
▽ More
We study the lift-and-project rank of the stable set polytopes of graphs with respect to the Lovász-Schrijver SDP operator $\text{LS}_+$. In particular, we focus on a search for relatively small graphs with high $\text{LS}_+$-rank (i.e., the least number of iterations of the $\text{LS}_+$ operator on the fractional stable set polytope to compute the stable set polytope). We provide families of graphs whose $\text{LS}_+$-rank is asymptotically a linear function of its number of vertices, which is the best possible up to improvements in the constant factor. This improves upon the previous best result in this direction from 1999, which yielded graphs whose $\text{LS}_+$-rank only grew with the square root of the number of vertices.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2024; v1 submitted 15 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Decompositions of Unit Hypercubes and the Reversion of a Generalized Möbius Series
Authors:
Yu Hin Au
Abstract:
Let $s_d(n)$ be the number of distinct decompositions of the $d$-dimensional hypercube with $n$ rectangular regions that can be obtained via a sequence of splitting operations. We prove that the generating series $y = \sum_{n \geq 1} s_d(n)x^n$ satisfies the functional equation $x = \sum_{n\geq 1} μ_d(n)y^n$, where $μ_d(n)$ is the $d$-fold Dirichlet convolution of the Möbius function. This general…
▽ More
Let $s_d(n)$ be the number of distinct decompositions of the $d$-dimensional hypercube with $n$ rectangular regions that can be obtained via a sequence of splitting operations. We prove that the generating series $y = \sum_{n \geq 1} s_d(n)x^n$ satisfies the functional equation $x = \sum_{n\geq 1} μ_d(n)y^n$, where $μ_d(n)$ is the $d$-fold Dirichlet convolution of the Möbius function. This generalizes a recent result by Goulden et al., and shows that $s_1(n)$ also gives the number of natural exact covering systems of $\mZ$ with $n$ residual classes. We also prove an asymptotic formula for $s_d(n)$ and describe a bijection between $1$-dimensional decompositions and natural exact covering systems.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
On Connections Between Association Schemes and Analyses of Polyhedral and Positive Semidefinite Lift-and-Project Relaxations
Authors:
Yu Hin Au,
Nathan Lindzey,
Levent Tunçel
Abstract:
We explore some connections between association schemes and the analyses of the semidefinite programming (SDP) based convex relaxations of combinatorial optimization problems in the Lovász--Schrijver lift-and-project hierarchy. Our analysis of the relaxations of the stable set polytope leads to bounds on the clique and stability numbers of some regular graphs reminiscent of classical bounds by Del…
▽ More
We explore some connections between association schemes and the analyses of the semidefinite programming (SDP) based convex relaxations of combinatorial optimization problems in the Lovász--Schrijver lift-and-project hierarchy. Our analysis of the relaxations of the stable set polytope leads to bounds on the clique and stability numbers of some regular graphs reminiscent of classical bounds by Delsarte and Hoffman, as well as the notion of deeply vertex-transitive graphs -- highly symmetric graphs that we show arise naturally from some association schemes. We also study relaxations of the hypergraph matching problem, and determine exactly or provide bounds on the lift-and-project ranks of these relaxations. Our proofs for these results also inspire the study of the general hypermatching pseudo-scheme, which is an association scheme except it is generally non-commutative. We then illustrate the usefulness of obtaining commutative subschemes from non-commutative pseudo-schemes via contraction in this context.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2023; v1 submitted 19 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Some Properties and Combinatorial Implications of Weighted Small Schröder Numbers
Authors:
Yu Hin Au
Abstract:
The $n^{\text{th}}$ small Schröder number is $s(n) = \sum_{k \geq 0} s(n,k)$, where $s(n,k)$ denotes the number of plane rooted trees with $n$ leaves and $k$ internal nodes that each has at least two children. In this manuscript, we focus on the weighted small Schröder numbers $s_d(n) = \sum_{k \geq 0} s(n,k) d^k$, where $d$ is an arbitrary fixed real number. We provide recursive and asymptotic fo…
▽ More
The $n^{\text{th}}$ small Schröder number is $s(n) = \sum_{k \geq 0} s(n,k)$, where $s(n,k)$ denotes the number of plane rooted trees with $n$ leaves and $k$ internal nodes that each has at least two children. In this manuscript, we focus on the weighted small Schröder numbers $s_d(n) = \sum_{k \geq 0} s(n,k) d^k$, where $d$ is an arbitrary fixed real number. We provide recursive and asymptotic formulas for $s_d(n)$, as well as some identities and combinatorial interpretations for these numbers. We also establish connections between $s_d(n)$ and several families of Dyck paths.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Enumeration and Asymptotic Formulas for Rectangular Partitions of the Hypercube
Authors:
Yu Hin Au,
Fatemeh Bagherzadeh,
Murray R. Bremner
Abstract:
We study a two-parameter generalization of the Catalan numbers: $C_{d,p}(n)$ is the number of ways to subdivide the $d$-dimensional hypercube into $n$ rectangular blocks using orthogonal partitions of fixed arity $p$. Bremner \& Dotsenko introduced $C_{d,p}(n)$ in their work on Boardman--Vogt tensor products of operads; they used homological algebra to prove a recursive formula and a functional eq…
▽ More
We study a two-parameter generalization of the Catalan numbers: $C_{d,p}(n)$ is the number of ways to subdivide the $d$-dimensional hypercube into $n$ rectangular blocks using orthogonal partitions of fixed arity $p$. Bremner \& Dotsenko introduced $C_{d,p}(n)$ in their work on Boardman--Vogt tensor products of operads; they used homological algebra to prove a recursive formula and a functional equation. We express $C_{d,p}(n)$ as simple finite sums, and determine their growth rate and asymptotic behaviour. We give an elementary proof of the functional equation, using a bijection between hypercube decompositions and a family of full $p$-ary trees. Our results generalize the well-known correspondence between Catalan numbers and full binary trees.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Elementary polytopes with high lift-and-project ranks for strong positive semidefinite operators
Authors:
Yu Hin Au,
Levent Tunçel
Abstract:
We consider operators acting on convex subsets of the unit hypercube. These operators are used in constructing convex relaxations of combinatorial optimization problems presented as a 0,1 integer programming problem or a 0,1 polynomial optimization problem. Our focus is mostly on operators that, when expressed as a lift-and-project operator, involve the use of semidefiniteness constraints in the l…
▽ More
We consider operators acting on convex subsets of the unit hypercube. These operators are used in constructing convex relaxations of combinatorial optimization problems presented as a 0,1 integer programming problem or a 0,1 polynomial optimization problem. Our focus is mostly on operators that, when expressed as a lift-and-project operator, involve the use of semidefiniteness constraints in the lifted space, including operators due to Lasserre and variants of the Sherali--Adams and Bienstock--Zuckerberg operators. We study the performance of these semidefinite-optimization-based lift-and-project operators on some elementary polytopes --- hypercubes that are chipped (at least one vertex of the hypercube removed by intersection with a closed halfspace) or cropped (all $2^n$ vertices of the hypercube removed by intersection with $2^n$ closed halfspaces) to varying degrees of severity $ρ$. We prove bounds on $ρ$ where these operators would perform badly on the aforementioned examples. We also show that the integrality gap of the chipped hypercube is invariant under the application of several lift-and-project operators of varying strengths.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
A Comprehensive Analysis of Polyhedral Lift-and-Project Methods
Authors:
Yu Hin Au,
Levent Tunçel
Abstract:
We consider lift-and-project methods for combinatorial optimization problems and focus mostly on those lift-and-project methods which generate polyhedral relaxations of the convex hull of integer solutions. We introduce many new variants of Sherali--Adams and Bienstock--Zuckerberg operators. These new operators fill the spectrum of polyhedral lift-and-project operators in a way which makes all of…
▽ More
We consider lift-and-project methods for combinatorial optimization problems and focus mostly on those lift-and-project methods which generate polyhedral relaxations of the convex hull of integer solutions. We introduce many new variants of Sherali--Adams and Bienstock--Zuckerberg operators. These new operators fill the spectrum of polyhedral lift-and-project operators in a way which makes all of them more transparent, easier to relate to each other, and easier to analyze. We provide new techniques to analyze the worst-case performances as well as relative strengths of these operators in a unified way. In particular, using the new techniques and a result of Mathieu and Sinclair from 2009, we prove that the polyhedral Bienstock--Zuckerberg operator requires at least $\sqrt{2n}- \frac{3}{2}$ iterations to compute the matching polytope of the $(2n+1)$-clique. We further prove that the operator requires approximately $\frac{n}{2}$ iterations to reach the stable set polytope of the $n$-clique, if we start with the fractional stable set polytope. Lastly, we show that some of the worst-case instances for the positive semidefinite Lovász--Schrijver lift-and-project operator are also bad instances for the strongest variants of the Sherali--Adams operator with positive semidefinite strengthenings, and discuss some consequences for integrality gaps of convex relaxations.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2016; v1 submitted 20 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Generalized de Bruijn words for Primitive words and Powers
Authors:
Yu Hin Au
Abstract:
We show that for every $n \geq 1$ and over any finite alphabet, there is a word whose circular factors of length $n$ have a one-to-one correspondence with the set of primitive words. In particular, we prove that such a word can be obtained by a greedy algorithm, or by concatenating all Lyndon words of length $n$ in increasing lexicographic order. We also look into connections between de Bruijn gra…
▽ More
We show that for every $n \geq 1$ and over any finite alphabet, there is a word whose circular factors of length $n$ have a one-to-one correspondence with the set of primitive words. In particular, we prove that such a word can be obtained by a greedy algorithm, or by concatenating all Lyndon words of length $n$ in increasing lexicographic order. We also look into connections between de Bruijn graphs of primitive words and Lyndon graphs.
Finally, we also show that the shortest word that contains every $p$-power of length $pn$ over a $k$-letter alphabet has length between $pk^n$ and roughly $(p+ \frac{1}{k}) k^n$, for all integers $p \geq 1$. An algorithm that generates a word which achieves the upper bound is provided.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2015; v1 submitted 25 April, 2009;
originally announced April 2009.
-
Van der Waerden's Theorem and Avoidability in Words
Authors:
Yu-Hin Au,
Aaron Robertson,
Jeffrey Shallit
Abstract:
Pirillo and Varricchio, and independently, Halbeisen and Hungerbuhler considered the following problem, open since 1994: Does there exist an infinite word w over a finite subset of Z such that w contains no two consecutive blocks of the same length and sum? We consider some variations on this problem in the light of van der Waerden's theorem on arithmetic progressions.
Pirillo and Varricchio, and independently, Halbeisen and Hungerbuhler considered the following problem, open since 1994: Does there exist an infinite word w over a finite subset of Z such that w contains no two consecutive blocks of the same length and sum? We consider some variations on this problem in the light of van der Waerden's theorem on arithmetic progressions.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2009; v1 submitted 12 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
