-
Entropic Fluctuation Theorems for the Spin-Fermion Model
Authors:
Tristan Benoist,
Laurent Bruneau,
Vojkan Jakšić,
Annalisa Panati,
Claude-Alain Pillet
Abstract:
We study entropic fluctuations in the Spin-Fermion model describing an $N$-level quantum system coupled to several independent thermal free Fermi gas reservoirs. We establish the quantum Evans-Searles and Gallavotti-Cohen fluctuation theorems and identify their link with entropic ancilla state tomography and quantum phase space contraction of non-equilibrium steady state. The method of proof invol…
▽ More
We study entropic fluctuations in the Spin-Fermion model describing an $N$-level quantum system coupled to several independent thermal free Fermi gas reservoirs. We establish the quantum Evans-Searles and Gallavotti-Cohen fluctuation theorems and identify their link with entropic ancilla state tomography and quantum phase space contraction of non-equilibrium steady state. The method of proof involves the spectral resonance theory of quantum transfer operators developed by the authors in previous works.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Entropic Fluctuations in Statistical Mechanics II. Quantum Dynamical Systems
Authors:
T. Benoist,
L. Bruneau,
V. Jakšić,
A. Panati,
C. -A. Pillet
Abstract:
The celebrated Evans-Searles, respectively Gallavotti-Cohen, fluctuation theorem concerns certain universal statistical features of the entropy production rate of a classical system in a transient, respectively steady, state. In this paper, we consider and compare several possible extensions of these fluctuation theorems to quantum systems. In addition to the direct two-time measurement approach w…
▽ More
The celebrated Evans-Searles, respectively Gallavotti-Cohen, fluctuation theorem concerns certain universal statistical features of the entropy production rate of a classical system in a transient, respectively steady, state. In this paper, we consider and compare several possible extensions of these fluctuation theorems to quantum systems. In addition to the direct two-time measurement approach whose discussion is based on (LMP 114:32 (2024)), we discuss a variant where measurements are performed indirectly on an auxiliary system called ancilla, and which allows to retrieve non-trivial statistical information using ancilla state tomography. We also show that modular theory provides a way to extend the classical notion of phase space contraction rate to the quantum domain, which leads to a third extension of the fluctuation theorems. We further discuss the quantum version of the principle of regular entropic fluctuations, introduced in the classical context in (Nonlinearity 24, 699 (2011)). Finally, we relate the statistical properties of these various notions of entropy production to spectral resonances of quantum transfer operators. The obtained results shed a new light on the nature of entropic fluctuations in quantum statistical mechanics.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
On the thermodynamic limit of two-times measurement entropy production
Authors:
Tristan Benoist,
Laurent Bruneau,
Vojkan Jakšić,
Annalisa Panati,
Claude-Alain Pillet
Abstract:
We provide a justification, via the thermodynamic limit, of the modular formula for entropy production in two-times measurement proposed in [Benoist, Bruneau, Jakšić, Panati and Pillet: Lett. Math. Phys. 114:32, (2023)]. We consider the cases of open quantum systems in which all thermal reservoirs are either (discrete) quantum spin systems or free Fermi gases.
We provide a justification, via the thermodynamic limit, of the modular formula for entropy production in two-times measurement proposed in [Benoist, Bruneau, Jakšić, Panati and Pillet: Lett. Math. Phys. 114:32, (2023)]. We consider the cases of open quantum systems in which all thermal reservoirs are either (discrete) quantum spin systems or free Fermi gases.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2024; v1 submitted 14 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
A note on two-times measurement entropy production and modular theory
Authors:
Tristan Benoist,
Laurent Bruneau,
Vojkan Jaksic,
Annalisa Panati,
Claude-Alain Pillet
Abstract:
Recent theoretical investigations of the two-times measurement entropy production (2TMEP) in quantum statistical mechanics have shed a new light on the mathematics and physics of the quantum-mechanical probabilistic rules. Among notable developments are the extensions of entropic fluctuation relations to quantum domain and discovery of a deep link between 2TMEP and modular theory of operator algeb…
▽ More
Recent theoretical investigations of the two-times measurement entropy production (2TMEP) in quantum statistical mechanics have shed a new light on the mathematics and physics of the quantum-mechanical probabilistic rules. Among notable developments are the extensions of entropic fluctuation relations to quantum domain and discovery of a deep link between 2TMEP and modular theory of operator algebras. All these developments concerned the setting where the state of the system at the instant of the first measurement is the same as the state whose entropy production is measured. In this work we consider the case where these two states are different and link this more general 2TEMP to modular theory. The established connection allows us to show that under general ergodicity assumptions the 2TEMP is essentially independent of the choice of the system state at the instant of the first measurement due to a decoherence effect induced by the first measurement. This stability sheds a new light on the concept of quantum entropy production, and, in particular, on possible quantum formulations of the celebrated classical Gallavotti--Cohen Fluctuation Theorem which will be studied in the continuation of this work.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2024; v1 submitted 16 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Heat conservation and fluctuations between quantum reservoirs in the Two-Time Measurement picture
Authors:
Tristan Benoist,
Annalisa Panati,
Yan Pautrat
Abstract:
This work concerns the statistics of the Two-Time Measurement definition of heat variation in each reservoir of a thermodynamic quantum system. We study the cumulant generating function of the heat flows in the thermodynamic and large-time limits. It is well-known that, if the system is time-reversal invariant, this cumulant generating function satisfies the celebrated Evans--Searles symmetry. We…
▽ More
This work concerns the statistics of the Two-Time Measurement definition of heat variation in each reservoir of a thermodynamic quantum system. We study the cumulant generating function of the heat flows in the thermodynamic and large-time limits. It is well-known that, if the system is time-reversal invariant, this cumulant generating function satisfies the celebrated Evans--Searles symmetry. We show in addition that, under appropriate ultraviolet regularity assumptions on the local interaction between the reservoirs, it satisfies a translation-invariance property, as proposed in [Andrieux et al. New J. Phys. 2009]. We particularly fix some proofs of the latter article where the ultraviolet condition was not mentioned. We detail how these two symmetries lead respectively to fluctuation relations and a statistical refinement of heat conservation for isolated thermodynamic quantum systems. As in [Andrieux \emph{et al.} New J. Phys. 2009], we recover the Fluctuation-Dissipation Theorem in the linear response theory, short of Green--Kubo relations. We illustrate the general theory on a number of canonical models.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2019; v1 submitted 23 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Control of fluctuations and heavy tails for heat variation in the two-time measurement framework
Authors:
Tristan Benoist,
Annalisa Panati,
Renaud Raquépas
Abstract:
We study heat fluctuations in the two-time measurement framework. For bounded perturbations, we give sufficient ultraviolet regularity conditions on the perturbation for the moments of the heat variation to be uniformly bounded in time, and for the Fourier transform of the heat variation distribution to be analytic and uniformly bounded in time in a complex neighborhood of 0. On a set of canonical…
▽ More
We study heat fluctuations in the two-time measurement framework. For bounded perturbations, we give sufficient ultraviolet regularity conditions on the perturbation for the moments of the heat variation to be uniformly bounded in time, and for the Fourier transform of the heat variation distribution to be analytic and uniformly bounded in time in a complex neighborhood of 0. On a set of canonical examples, with bounded and unbounded perturbations, we show that our ultraviolet conditions are essentially necessary. If the form factor of the perturbation does not meet our assumptions, the heat variation distribution exhibits heavy tails. The tails can be as heavy as preventing the existence of a fourth moment of the heat variation.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2018; v1 submitted 6 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Reflection probabilities of one-dimensional Schroedinger operators and scattering theory
Authors:
Benjamin Landon,
Jane Panangaden,
Annalisa Panati,
Justine Zwicker
Abstract:
The dynamic reflection probability and the spectral reflection probability for a one-dimensional Schroedinger operator $H = - Δ+ V$ are characterized in terms of the scattering theory of the pair $(H, H_\infty)$ where $H_\infty$ is the operator obtained by decoupling the left and right half-lines $\mathbb{R}_{\leq 0}$ and $\mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}$. An immediate consequence is that these reflection pro…
▽ More
The dynamic reflection probability and the spectral reflection probability for a one-dimensional Schroedinger operator $H = - Δ+ V$ are characterized in terms of the scattering theory of the pair $(H, H_\infty)$ where $H_\infty$ is the operator obtained by decoupling the left and right half-lines $\mathbb{R}_{\leq 0}$ and $\mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}$. An immediate consequence is that these reflection probabilities are in fact the same, thus providing a short and transparent proof of the main result of Breuer, J., E. Ryckman, and B. Simon (2010) . This approach is inspired by recent developments in non-equilibrium statistical mechanics of the electronic black box model and follows a strategy parallel to the Jacobi case.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Full statistics of energy conservation in two times measurement protocols
Authors:
Tristan Benoist,
Vojkan Jaksic,
Annalisa Panati,
Yan Pautrat,
Claude-Alain Pillet
Abstract:
The first law of thermodynamics states that the average total energy current between different reservoirs vanishes at large times. In this note we examine this fact at the level of the full statistics of two times measurement protocols also known as the Full Counting Statistics. Under very general conditions, we establish a tight form of the first law asserting that the fluctuations of the total e…
▽ More
The first law of thermodynamics states that the average total energy current between different reservoirs vanishes at large times. In this note we examine this fact at the level of the full statistics of two times measurement protocols also known as the Full Counting Statistics. Under very general conditions, we establish a tight form of the first law asserting that the fluctuations of the total energy current computed from the energy variation distribution are exponentially suppressed in the large time limit. We illustrate this general result using two examples: the Anderson impurity model and a 2D spin lattice model.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2015; v1 submitted 25 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Energy conservation, counting statistics, and return to equilibrium
Authors:
Vojkan Jaksic,
Jane Panangaden,
Annalisa Panati,
Claude-Alain Pillet
Abstract:
We study a microscopic Hamiltonian model describing an N-level quantum system S coupled to an infinitely extended thermal reservoir R. Initially, the system S is in an arbitrary state while the reservoir is in thermal equilibrium at temperature T. Assuming that the coupled system S+R is mixing with respect to the joint thermal equilibrium state, we study the Full Counting Statistics (FCS) of the e…
▽ More
We study a microscopic Hamiltonian model describing an N-level quantum system S coupled to an infinitely extended thermal reservoir R. Initially, the system S is in an arbitrary state while the reservoir is in thermal equilibrium at temperature T. Assuming that the coupled system S+R is mixing with respect to the joint thermal equilibrium state, we study the Full Counting Statistics (FCS) of the energy transfers S->R and R->S in the process of return to equilibrium. The first FCS describes the increase of the energy of the system S. It is an atomic probability measure, denoted $P_{S,λ,t}$, concentrated on the set of energy differences $σ(H_S)-σ(H_S)$ ($σ(H_S)$ is the spectrum of the Hamiltonian of S, $t$ is the length of the time interval during which the measurement of the energy transfer is performed, and $λ$ is the strength of the interaction between S and R). The second FCS, $P_{R,λ,t}$, describes the decrease of the energy of the reservoir R and is typically a continuous probability measure whose support is the whole real line. We study the large time limit $t\rightarrow\infty$ of these two measures followed by the weak coupling limit $λ\rightarrow 0$ and prove that the limiting measures coincide. This result strengthens the first law of thermodynamics for open quantum systems. The proofs are based on modular theory of operator algebras and on a representation of $P_{R,λ,t}$ by quantum transfer operators.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
A note on reflectionless Jacobi matrices
Authors:
Vojkan Jaksic,
Benjamin Landon,
Annalisa Panati
Abstract:
The property that a Jacobi matrix is reflectionless is usually characterized either in terms of Weyl m-functions or the vanishing of the real part of the boundary values of the diagonal matrix elements of the resolvent. We introduce a characterization in terms of stationary scattering theory (the vanishing of the reflection coefficients) and prove that this characterization is equivalent to the us…
▽ More
The property that a Jacobi matrix is reflectionless is usually characterized either in terms of Weyl m-functions or the vanishing of the real part of the boundary values of the diagonal matrix elements of the resolvent. We introduce a characterization in terms of stationary scattering theory (the vanishing of the reflection coefficients) and prove that this characterization is equivalent to the usual ones. We also show that the new characterization is equivalent to the notion of being dynamically reflectionless, thus providing a short proof of an important result of [Breuer-Ryckman-Simon]. The motivation for the new characterization comes from recent studies of the non-equilibrium statistical mechanics of the electronic black box model and we elaborate on this connection. To appear in Commun. Math. Phys.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2013; v1 submitted 8 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Removal of UV cutoff for the Nelson model with variable coefficients
Authors:
C. Gérard,
F. Hiroshima,
A. Panati,
A. Suzuki
Abstract:
We consider the Nelson model with variable coefficients. Nelson models with variable coefficients arise when one replaces in the usual Nelson model the flat Minkowski metric by a static metric, allowing also the boson mass to depend on position. We study the removal of the ultraviolet cutoff.
We consider the Nelson model with variable coefficients. Nelson models with variable coefficients arise when one replaces in the usual Nelson model the flat Minkowski metric by a static metric, allowing also the boson mass to depend on position. We study the removal of the ultraviolet cutoff.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
-
Absence of ground state for the Nelson model on static space-times
Authors:
Christian Gérard,
Fumio Hiroshima,
Annalisa Panati,
A. Suzuki
Abstract:
We consider the Nelson model on some static space-times and investigate the problem of absence of a ground state. Nelson models with variable coefficients arise when one replaces in the usual Nelson model the flat Minkowski metric by a static metric, allowing also the boson mass to depend on position. We investigate the absence of a ground state of the Hamiltonian in the presence of the infrared p…
▽ More
We consider the Nelson model on some static space-times and investigate the problem of absence of a ground state. Nelson models with variable coefficients arise when one replaces in the usual Nelson model the flat Minkowski metric by a static metric, allowing also the boson mass to depend on position. We investigate the absence of a ground state of the Hamiltonian in the presence of the infrared problem, i.e. assuming that the boson mass $m(x)$ tends to $0$ at spatial infinity. Using path space techniques, we show that if $m(x)\leq C |x|^{-μ}$ at infinity for some $C>0$ and $μ>1$ then the Nelson Hamiltonian has no ground state.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
Infrared problem for the Nelson model on static space-times
Authors:
Christian Gérard,
Fumio Hiroshima,
Annalisa Panati,
Akito Suzuki
Abstract:
We consider the Nelson model with variable coefficients and investigate the problem of existence of a ground state and the removal of the ultraviolet cutoff. Nelson models with variable coefficients arise when one replaces in the usual Nelson model the flat Minkowski metric by a static metric, allowing also the boson mass to depend on position. A physical example is obtained by quantizing the Klei…
▽ More
We consider the Nelson model with variable coefficients and investigate the problem of existence of a ground state and the removal of the ultraviolet cutoff. Nelson models with variable coefficients arise when one replaces in the usual Nelson model the flat Minkowski metric by a static metric, allowing also the boson mass to depend on position. A physical example is obtained by quantizing the Klein-Gordon equation on a static space-time coupled with a non-relativistic particle. We investigate the existence of a ground state of the Hamiltonian in the presence of the infrared problem, i.e. assuming that the boson mass tends to 0 at infinity.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2011; v1 submitted 29 April, 2010;
originally announced April 2010.
-
Infrared divergence of a scalar quantum field model on a pseudo Riemannian manifold
Authors:
C. Gérard,
F. Hiroshima,
A. Panati,
A. Suzuki
Abstract:
A scalar quantum field model defined on a pseudo Riemann manifold is considered. The model is unitarily transformed the one with a variable mass. By means of a Feynman-Kac-type formula, it is shown that when the variable mass is short range, the Hamiltonian has no ground state. Moreover the infrared divergence of the expectation values of the number of bosons in the ground state is discussed.
A scalar quantum field model defined on a pseudo Riemann manifold is considered. The model is unitarily transformed the one with a variable mass. By means of a Feynman-Kac-type formula, it is shown that when the variable mass is short range, the Hamiltonian has no ground state. Moreover the infrared divergence of the expectation values of the number of bosons in the ground state is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2011; v1 submitted 17 April, 2009;
originally announced April 2009.
-
Spectral and scattering theory for some abstract QFT Hamiltonians
Authors:
Christian Gérard,
Annalisa Panati
Abstract:
We introduce an abstract class of bosonic QFT Hamiltonians and study their spectral and scattering theories. These Hamiltonians are of the form $H=\d\G(ω)+ V$ acting on the bosonic Fock space $\G(\ch)$, where $ω$ is a massive one-particle Hamiltonian acting on $\ch$ and $V$ is a Wick polynomial $\Wick(w)$ for a kernel $w$ satisfying some decay properties at infinity. We describe the essential sp…
▽ More
We introduce an abstract class of bosonic QFT Hamiltonians and study their spectral and scattering theories. These Hamiltonians are of the form $H=\d\G(ω)+ V$ acting on the bosonic Fock space $\G(\ch)$, where $ω$ is a massive one-particle Hamiltonian acting on $\ch$ and $V$ is a Wick polynomial $\Wick(w)$ for a kernel $w$ satisfying some decay properties at infinity. We describe the essential spectrum of $H$, prove a Mourre estimate outside a set of thresholds and prove the existence of asymptotic fields. Our main result is the {\em asymptotic completeness} of the scattering theory, which means that the CCR representations given by the asymptotic fields are of Fock type, with the asymptotic vacua equal to the bound states of $H$. As a consequence $H$ is unitarily equivalent to a collection of second quantized Hamiltonians.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2008;
originally announced June 2008.
-
Spectral and scattering theory for space-cutoff $P(\varphi)_{2}$ models with variable metric
Authors:
Christian Gérard,
Annalisa Panati
Abstract:
We consider space-cutoff $P(\varphi)_{2}$ models with a variable metric of the form \[ H= \d\G(ω)+ \int_{\rr}g(x):P(x, \varphi(x)):\d x, \] on the bosonic Fock space $L^{2}(\rr)$, where the kinetic energy $ω= h^{\12}$ is the square root of a real second order differential operator \[ h= Da(x)D+ c(x), \] where the coefficients $a(x), c(x)$ tend respectively to 1 and $m_{\infty}^{2}$ at $\infty$ f…
▽ More
We consider space-cutoff $P(\varphi)_{2}$ models with a variable metric of the form \[ H= \d\G(ω)+ \int_{\rr}g(x):P(x, \varphi(x)):\d x, \] on the bosonic Fock space $L^{2}(\rr)$, where the kinetic energy $ω= h^{\12}$ is the square root of a real second order differential operator \[ h= Da(x)D+ c(x), \] where the coefficients $a(x), c(x)$ tend respectively to 1 and $m_{\infty}^{2}$ at $\infty$ for some $m_{\infty}>0$. The interaction term $\int_{\rr}g(x):P(x, \varphi(x)):\d x$ is defined using a bounded below polynomial in $λ$ with variable coefficients $P(x, λ)$ and a positive function $g$ decaying fast enough at infinity. We extend in this paper the results of \cite{DG} where $h$ had constant coefficients and $P(x, λ)$ was independent of $x$. We describe the essential spectrum of $H$, prove a Mourre estimate outside a set of thresholds and prove the existence of asymptotic fields. Our main result is the {\em asymptotic completeness} of the scattering theory, which means that the CCR representation given by the asymptotic fields is of Fock type, with the asymptotic vacua equal to bound states of $H$. As a consequence $H$ is unitarily equivalent to a collection of second quantized Hamiltonians. An important role in the proofs is played by the {\em higher order estimates}, which allow to control powers of the number operator by powers of the resolvent. To obtain these estimates some conditions on the eigenfunctions and generalized eigenfunctions of $h$ are necessary. We also discuss similar models in higher space dimensions where the interaction has an ultraviolet cutoff.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2008;
originally announced June 2008.
-
Existence and non existence of a ground state for the massless Nelson model under binding condition
Authors:
Annalisa Panati
Abstract:
We consider a model describing $N$ non-relativistic particles coupled to a massless quantum scalar field, called \emph{Nelson model}, under a binding condition on the external potential. We prove that this model does not admit ground state in the Fock representation of the canonical commutation relations, but it does in another not unitarily equivalent coherent representation. Remark that the bi…
▽ More
We consider a model describing $N$ non-relativistic particles coupled to a massless quantum scalar field, called \emph{Nelson model}, under a binding condition on the external potential. We prove that this model does not admit ground state in the Fock representation of the canonical commutation relations, but it does in another not unitarily equivalent coherent representation. Remark that the binding condition is satisfied for small values of the coupling constant.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2009; v1 submitted 24 September, 2006;
originally announced September 2006.
