-
$d$-dimensional spherical ferromagnets in random fields: Metastates, continuous symmetry breaking, and spin-glass features
Authors:
Kalle Koskinen,
Christof Külske
Abstract:
We study the large-volume behavior of the spherical model for $d$-dimensional local spins, in the presence of $d$-dimensional random fields, for $d\geq 2$. We compare two models, one with volume-scaled random fields, and another one with non-scaled random fields, on the level of Aizenman-Wehr metastates, Newman-Stein metastates, as well as overlap distributions. We show that in $d\geq 2$ the metas…
▽ More
We study the large-volume behavior of the spherical model for $d$-dimensional local spins, in the presence of $d$-dimensional random fields, for $d\geq 2$. We compare two models, one with volume-scaled random fields, and another one with non-scaled random fields, on the level of Aizenman-Wehr metastates, Newman-Stein metastates, as well as overlap distributions. We show that in $d\geq 2$ the metastates are fully supported on a continuity of random product states, with weights which we describe, for both models. For the non-scaled random fields, the set of a.s. cluster points of Gibbs measures contains these product states, but behaves differently in the 'recurrent' spin dimension $d=2$ where it also contains non-trivial mixtures of tilted measures. For the scaled model, moreover the overlap distribution displays spin-glass characteristics, as it is non-self averaging, and shows replica symmetry breaking, although it is ultrametric if and only if $d=1$. For $d\geq 2$ it oscillates chaotically on a set of continuous distributions for large volumes, while the limiting set contains only discrete distributions in $d=1$. Our results are based on concentration estimates, analysis of Gibbs measures in finite but large volumes, and the asymptotics of $d$-dimensional random walks and their spherical projections.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
The Ising model: Highlights and perspectives
Authors:
Christof Kuelske
Abstract:
We give a short non-technical introduction to the Ising model, and review some successes as well as challenges which have emerged from its study in probability and mathematical physics. This includes the infinite-volume theory of phase transitions, and ideas like scaling, renormalization group, universality, SLE, and random symmetry breaking in disordered systems and networks. This note is based o…
▽ More
We give a short non-technical introduction to the Ising model, and review some successes as well as challenges which have emerged from its study in probability and mathematical physics. This includes the infinite-volume theory of phase transitions, and ideas like scaling, renormalization group, universality, SLE, and random symmetry breaking in disordered systems and networks. This note is based on a talk given on 15 August 2024, as part of the Ising lecture during the 11th Bernoulli-IMS world congress, Bochum.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Height-offset variables and pinning at infinity for gradient Gibbs measures on trees
Authors:
Florian Henning,
Christof Kuelske
Abstract:
We provide a general theory of height-offset variables and their properties for nearest-neighbor integer-valued gradient models on trees. This notion goes back to Sheffield [25], who realized that such tail-measurable variables can be used to associate to gradient Gibbs measures also proper Gibbs measures, via the procedure of pinning at infinity. On the constructive side, our theory incorporates…
▽ More
We provide a general theory of height-offset variables and their properties for nearest-neighbor integer-valued gradient models on trees. This notion goes back to Sheffield [25], who realized that such tail-measurable variables can be used to associate to gradient Gibbs measures also proper Gibbs measures, via the procedure of pinning at infinity. On the constructive side, our theory incorporates the existence of height-offset variables, regularity properties of their Lebesgue densities and concentration properties of the associated Gibbs measure. On the pathological side, we show that pinning at infinity necessarily comes at a cost. This phenomenon will be analyzed on the levels of translation invariance, the tree-indexed Markov chain property, and extremality. The scope of our theory incorporates free measures, and also height-periodic measures of period 2, assuming only finite second moments of the transfer operator which encodes the nearest neighbor interaction. Our proofs are based on investigations of the respective martingale limits, past and future tail-decompositions, and infinite product representations for moment generating functions.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Continuity of the extremal decomposition of the free state for finite-spin models on Cayley trees
Authors:
Loren Coquille,
Christof Kuelske,
Arnaud Le Ny
Abstract:
We prove the continuity of the extremal decomposition measure of the free state of low temperature Potts models, and more generally of ferromagnetic finite-spin models, on a regular tree, including general clock models. The decomposition is supported on uncountably many inhomogeneous extremal states, that we call glassy states. The method of proof provides explicit concentration bounds on branch o…
▽ More
We prove the continuity of the extremal decomposition measure of the free state of low temperature Potts models, and more generally of ferromagnetic finite-spin models, on a regular tree, including general clock models. The decomposition is supported on uncountably many inhomogeneous extremal states, that we call glassy states. The method of proof provides explicit concentration bounds on branch overlaps, which play the role of an order parameter for typical extremals. The result extends to the counterpart of the free state (called central state) in a wide range of models which have no symmetry, allowing also the presence of sufficiently small field terms. Our work shows in particular that the decomposition of central states into uncountably many glassy states in finite-spin models on trees at low temperature is a generic phenomenon, and does not rely on symmetries of the Hamiltonian.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Gibbs Properties of the Bernoulli field on inhomogeneous trees under the removal of isolated sites
Authors:
Florian Henning,
Christof Külske,
Niklas Schubert
Abstract:
We consider the i.i.d. Bernoulli field $μ_p$ with occupation density $p \in (0,1)$ on a possibly non-regular countably infinite tree with bounded degrees. For large $p$, we show that the quasilocal Gibbs property, i.e. compatibility with a suitable quasilocal specification, is lost under the deterministic transformation which removes all isolated ones and replaces them by zeros, while a quasilocal…
▽ More
We consider the i.i.d. Bernoulli field $μ_p$ with occupation density $p \in (0,1)$ on a possibly non-regular countably infinite tree with bounded degrees. For large $p$, we show that the quasilocal Gibbs property, i.e. compatibility with a suitable quasilocal specification, is lost under the deterministic transformation which removes all isolated ones and replaces them by zeros, while a quasilocal specification does exist at small $p$. Our results provide an example for an independent field in a spatially non-homogeneous setup which loses the quasilocal Gibbs property under a local deterministic transformation.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2024; v1 submitted 6 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Stable and metastable phases for the Curie-Weiss-Potts model in vector-valued fields via singularity theory
Authors:
Christof Kuelske,
Daniel Meissner
Abstract:
We study the metastable minima of the Curie-Weiss Potts model with three states, as a function of the inverse temperature, and for arbitrary vector-valued external fields. Extending the classic work of Ellis/Wang and Wang we use singularity theory to provide the global structure of metastable (or local) minima. In particular, we show that the free energy has up to four local minimizers (some of wh…
▽ More
We study the metastable minima of the Curie-Weiss Potts model with three states, as a function of the inverse temperature, and for arbitrary vector-valued external fields. Extending the classic work of Ellis/Wang and Wang we use singularity theory to provide the global structure of metastable (or local) minima. In particular, we show that the free energy has up to four local minimizers (some of which may at the same time be global) and describe the bifurcation geometry of their transitions under variation of the parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2020; v1 submitted 4 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Coexistence of localized Gibbs measures and delocalized gradient Gibbs measures on trees
Authors:
Florian Henning,
Christof Kuelske
Abstract:
We study gradient models for spins taking values in the integers (or an integer lattice), which interact via a general potential depending only on the differences of the spin values at neighboring sites, located on a regular tree with d + 1 neighbors. We first provide general conditions in terms of the relevant p-norms of the associated transfer operator Q which ensure the existence of a countable…
▽ More
We study gradient models for spins taking values in the integers (or an integer lattice), which interact via a general potential depending only on the differences of the spin values at neighboring sites, located on a regular tree with d + 1 neighbors. We first provide general conditions in terms of the relevant p-norms of the associated transfer operator Q which ensure the existence of a countable family of proper Gibbs measures. Next we prove existence of delocalized gradient Gibbs measures, under natural conditions on Q. This implies coexistence of both types of measures for large classes of models including the SOS-model, and heavy-tailed models arising for instance for potentials of logarithmic growth.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2021; v1 submitted 21 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Dynamical Gibbs-non-Gibbs transitions in lattice Widom-Rowlinson models with hard-core and soft-core interactions
Authors:
Sascha Kissel,
Christof Kuelske
Abstract:
We consider the Widom-Rowlinson model on the lattice $\mathbb{Z}^d$ in two versions, comparing the cases of a hard-core repulsion and of a soft-core repulsion between particles carrying opposite signs. For both versions we investigate their dynamical Gibbs-non-Gibbs transitions under an independent stochastic symmetric spin-flip dynamics. While both models have a similar phase transition in the hi…
▽ More
We consider the Widom-Rowlinson model on the lattice $\mathbb{Z}^d$ in two versions, comparing the cases of a hard-core repulsion and of a soft-core repulsion between particles carrying opposite signs. For both versions we investigate their dynamical Gibbs-non-Gibbs transitions under an independent stochastic symmetric spin-flip dynamics. While both models have a similar phase transition in the high-intensity regime in equilibrium, we show that they behave differently under time-evolution: The time-evolved soft-core model is Gibbs for small times and loses the Gibbs property for large enough times. By contrast, the time-evolved hard-core model loses the Gibbs property immediately, and for asymmetric intensities, shows a transition back to the Gibbsian regime at a sharp transition time.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Hard-Core and Soft-Core Widom-Rowlinson models on Cayley trees
Authors:
Sascha Kissel,
Christof Kuelske,
Utkir A. Rozikov
Abstract:
We consider both Hard-Core and Soft-Core Widom-Rowlinson models with spin values $-1,0,1$ on a Cayley tree of order $k\geq 2$ and we are interested in the Gibbs measures of the models. The models depend on 3 parameters: the order $k$ of the tree, $θ$ describing the strength of the (ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic) interaction, and $λ$ describing the intensity for particles. The Hard-Core Widom-…
▽ More
We consider both Hard-Core and Soft-Core Widom-Rowlinson models with spin values $-1,0,1$ on a Cayley tree of order $k\geq 2$ and we are interested in the Gibbs measures of the models. The models depend on 3 parameters: the order $k$ of the tree, $θ$ describing the strength of the (ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic) interaction, and $λ$ describing the intensity for particles. The Hard-Core Widom-Rowlinson model corresponds to the case $θ=0$. For the binary tree $k=2$, and for $k=3$ we prove that the ferromagnetic model has either one or three splitting Gibbs measures (tree-automorphism invariant Gibbs measures (TISGM) which are tree-indexed Markov chains). We also give the exact form of the corresponding critical curves in parameter space. For higher values of $k$ we give an explicit sufficient bound ensuring non-uniqueness which we conjecture to be the exact curve. Moreover, for the antiferromagnetic model we explicitly give two critical curves and prove that on these curves there are exactly two TISGMs; between these curves there are exactly three TISGMs; otherwise there exists a unique TISGM. Also some periodic and non-periodic SGMs are constructed in the ferromagnetic model.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Continuous spin models on annealed generalized random graphs
Authors:
Sander Dommers,
Christof Kuelske,
Philipp Schriever
Abstract:
We study Gibbs distributions of spins taking values in a general compact Polish space, interacting via a pair potential along the edges of a generalized random graph with a given asymptotic weight distribution $P$, obtained by annealing over the random graph distribution.
First we prove a variational formula for the corresponding annealed pressure and provide criteria for absence of phase transi…
▽ More
We study Gibbs distributions of spins taking values in a general compact Polish space, interacting via a pair potential along the edges of a generalized random graph with a given asymptotic weight distribution $P$, obtained by annealing over the random graph distribution.
First we prove a variational formula for the corresponding annealed pressure and provide criteria for absence of phase transitions in the general case.
We furthermore study classes of models with second order phase transitions which include rotation-invariant models on spheres and models on intervals, and classify their critical exponents. We find critical exponents which are modified relative to the corresponding mean-field values when $P$ becomes too heavy-tailed, in which case they move continuously with the tail-exponent of $P$. For large classes of models they are the same as for the Ising model treated in \cite{DomGiaGibHofPri16}. On the other hand, we provide conditions under which the model is in a different universality class, and construct an explicit example of such a model on the interval.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Extremality of translation-invariant phases for a finite-state SOS-model on the binary tree
Authors:
C. Kuelske,
U. A. Rozikov
Abstract:
We consider the SOS (solid-on-solid) model, with spin values $0,1,2$, on the Cayley tree of order two (binary tree). We treat both ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic coupling, with interactions which are proportional to the absolute value of the spin differences.
We present a classification of all translation-invariant phases (splitting Gibbs measures) of the model: We show uniqueness in the ca…
▽ More
We consider the SOS (solid-on-solid) model, with spin values $0,1,2$, on the Cayley tree of order two (binary tree). We treat both ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic coupling, with interactions which are proportional to the absolute value of the spin differences.
We present a classification of all translation-invariant phases (splitting Gibbs measures) of the model: We show uniqueness in the case of antiferromagnetic interactions, and existence of up to seven phases in the case of ferromagnetic interactions, where the number of phases depends on the interaction strength.
Next we investigate whether these states are extremal or non-extremal in the set of all Gibbs measures, when the coupling strength is varied, whenever they exist.
We show that two states are always extremal, two states are always non-extremal, while three of the seven states make transitions between extremality and non-extremality. We provide explicit bounds on those transition values, making use of algebraic properties of the models, and an adaptation of the method of Martinelli, Sinclair, Weitz.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Fuzzy transformations and extremality of Gibbs measures for the Potts model on a Cayley tree
Authors:
C. Kuelske,
U. A. Rozikov
Abstract:
We continue our study of the full set of translation-invariant splitting Gibbs measures (TISGMs, translation-invariant tree-indexed Markov chains) for the $q$-state Potts model on a Cayley tree. In our previous work \cite{KRK} we gave a full description of the TISGMs, and showed in particular that at sufficiently low temperatures their number is $2^{q}-1$.
In this paper we find some regions for…
▽ More
We continue our study of the full set of translation-invariant splitting Gibbs measures (TISGMs, translation-invariant tree-indexed Markov chains) for the $q$-state Potts model on a Cayley tree. In our previous work \cite{KRK} we gave a full description of the TISGMs, and showed in particular that at sufficiently low temperatures their number is $2^{q}-1$.
In this paper we find some regions for the temperature parameter ensuring that a given TISGM is (non-)extreme in the set of all Gibbs measures.
In particular we show the existence of a temperature interval for which there are at least $2^{q-1} + q$ extremal TISGMs.
For the Cayley tree of order two we give explicit formulae and some numerical values.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2016; v1 submitted 23 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Description of the translation-invariant splitting Gibbs measures for the Potts model on a Cayley tree
Authors:
C. Külske,
U. A. Rozikov,
R. M. Khakimov
Abstract:
For the $q$-state Potts model on a Cayley tree of order $k\geq 2$ it is well-known that at sufficiently low temperatures there are at least $q+1$ translation-invariant Gibbs measures which are also tree-indexed Markov chains. Such measures are called translation-invariant splitting Gibbs measures (TISGMs).
In this paper we find all TISGMs, and show in particular that at sufficiently low temperat…
▽ More
For the $q$-state Potts model on a Cayley tree of order $k\geq 2$ it is well-known that at sufficiently low temperatures there are at least $q+1$ translation-invariant Gibbs measures which are also tree-indexed Markov chains. Such measures are called translation-invariant splitting Gibbs measures (TISGMs).
In this paper we find all TISGMs, and show in particular that at sufficiently low temperatures their number is $2^{q}-1$. We prove that there are $[q/2]$ (where $[a]$ is the integer part of $a$) critical temperatures at which the number of TISGMs changes and give the exact number of TISGMs for each intermediate temperature. For the binary tree we give explicit formulae for the critical temperatures and the possible TISGMs.
While we show that these measures are never convex combinations of each other, the question which of these measures are extremals in the set of all Gibbs measures will be treated in future work.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2014; v1 submitted 23 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Metastates in mean-field models with random external fields generated by Markov chains
Authors:
M. Formentin,
C. Kuelske,
A. Reichenbachs
Abstract:
We extend the construction by Kuelske and Iacobelli of metastates in finite-state mean-field models in independent disorder to situations where the local disorder terms are are a sample of an external ergodic Markov chain in equilibrium. We show that for non-degenerate Markov chains, the structure of the theorems is analogous to the case of i.i.d. variables when the limiting weights in the metasta…
▽ More
We extend the construction by Kuelske and Iacobelli of metastates in finite-state mean-field models in independent disorder to situations where the local disorder terms are are a sample of an external ergodic Markov chain in equilibrium. We show that for non-degenerate Markov chains, the structure of the theorems is analogous to the case of i.i.d. variables when the limiting weights in the metastate are expressed with the aid of a CLT for the occupation time measure of the chain. As a new phenomenon we also show in a Potts example that, for a degenerate non-reversible chain this CLT approximation is not enough and the metastate can have less symmetry than the symmetry of the interaction and a Gaussian approximation of disorder fluctuations would suggest.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2011; v1 submitted 20 September, 2011;
originally announced September 2011.
-
Discrete approximations to vector spin models
Authors:
A. C. D. van Enter,
C. Kuelske,
A. A. Opoku
Abstract:
We strengthen a result of two of us on the existence of effective interactions for discretised continuous-spin models. We also point out that such an interaction cannot exist at very low temperatures. Moreover, we compare two ways of discretising continuous-spin models, and show that, except for very low temperatures, they behave similarly in two dimensions. We also discuss some possibilities in h…
▽ More
We strengthen a result of two of us on the existence of effective interactions for discretised continuous-spin models. We also point out that such an interaction cannot exist at very low temperatures. Moreover, we compare two ways of discretising continuous-spin models, and show that, except for very low temperatures, they behave similarly in two dimensions. We also discuss some possibilities in higher dimensions.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Gibbs-non-Gibbs properties for evolving Ising models on trees
Authors:
Aernout van Enter,
Victor Ermolaev,
Giulio Iacobelli,
Christof Kuelske
Abstract:
In this paper we study homogeneous Gibbs measures on a Cayley tree, subjected to an infinite-temperature Glauber evolution, and consider their (non-)Gibbsian properties. We show that the intermediate Gibbs state (which in zero field is the free-boundary-condition Gibbs state) behaves different from the plus and the minus state. E.g. at large times, all configurations are bad for the intermediate s…
▽ More
In this paper we study homogeneous Gibbs measures on a Cayley tree, subjected to an infinite-temperature Glauber evolution, and consider their (non-)Gibbsian properties. We show that the intermediate Gibbs state (which in zero field is the free-boundary-condition Gibbs state) behaves different from the plus and the minus state. E.g. at large times, all configurations are bad for the intermediate state, whereas the plus configuration never is bad for the plus state. Moreover, we show that for each state there are two transitions. For the intermediate state there is a transition from a Gibbsian regime to a non-Gibbsian regime where some, but not all configurations are bad, and a second one to a regime where all configurations are bad. For the plus and minus state, the two transitions are from a Gibbsian regime to a non-Gibbsian one and then back to a Gibbsian regime again.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
-
Low-temperature dynamics of the Curie-Weiss Model: Periodic orbits, multiple histories, and loss of Gibbsianness
Authors:
Victor Ermolaev,
Christof Kuelske
Abstract:
We consider the Curie-Weiss model at a given initial temperature in vanishing external field evolving under a Glauber spin-flip dynamics corresponding to a possibly different temperature. We study the limiting conditional probabilities and their continuity properties and discuss their set of points of discontinuity (bad points). We provide a complete analysis of the transition between Gibbsian and…
▽ More
We consider the Curie-Weiss model at a given initial temperature in vanishing external field evolving under a Glauber spin-flip dynamics corresponding to a possibly different temperature. We study the limiting conditional probabilities and their continuity properties and discuss their set of points of discontinuity (bad points). We provide a complete analysis of the transition between Gibbsian and non-Gibbsian behavior as a function of time, extending earlier work for the case of independent spin-flip dynamics. For initial temperature bigger than one we prove that the time-evolved measure stays Gibbs forever, for any (possibly low) temperature of the dynamics. In the regime of heating to low-temperatures from even lower temperatures, when the initial temperature is smaller than the temperature of the dynamics, and smaller than 1, we prove that the time-evolved measure is Gibbs initially and becomes non-Gibbs after a sharp transition time. We find this regime is further divided into a region where only symmetric bad configurations exist, and a region where this symmetry is broken. In the regime of further cooling from low-temperatures there is always symmetry-breaking in the set of bad configurations. These bad configurations are created by a new mechanism which is related to the occurrence of periodic orbits for the vector field which describes the dynamics of Euler-Lagrange equations for the path large deviation functional for the order parameter. To our knowledge this is the first example of the rigorous study of non-Gibbsian phenomena related to cooling, albeit in a mean-field setup.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2010; v1 submitted 6 May, 2010;
originally announced May 2010.
-
Metastates in finite-type mean-field models: visibility, invisibility, and random restoration of symmetry
Authors:
Giulio Iacobelli,
Christof Kuelske
Abstract:
We consider a general class of disordered mean-field models where both the spin variables and disorder variables take finitely many values. To investigate the size-dependence in the phase-transition regime we construct the metastate describing the probabilities to find a large system close to a particular convex combination of the pure infinite-volume states. We show that, under a non-degeneracy…
▽ More
We consider a general class of disordered mean-field models where both the spin variables and disorder variables take finitely many values. To investigate the size-dependence in the phase-transition regime we construct the metastate describing the probabilities to find a large system close to a particular convex combination of the pure infinite-volume states. We show that, under a non-degeneracy assumption, only pure states are seen, with non-random probability weights for which we derive explicit expressions in terms of interactions and distributions of the disorder variables. We provide a geometric construction distinguishing invisible states (having zero weights) from visible ones. As a further consequence we show that, in the case where precisely two pure states are available, these must necessarily occur with the same weight, even if the model has no obvious symmetry relating the two.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
-
Multilayer parking with screening on a random tree
Authors:
S. R. Fleurke,
C. Kuelske
Abstract:
In this paper we present a multilayer particle deposition model on a random tree. We derive the time dependent densities of the first and second layer analytically and show that in all trees the limiting density of the first layer exceeds the density in the second layer. We also provide a procedure to calculate higher layer densities and prove that random trees have a higher limiting density in…
▽ More
In this paper we present a multilayer particle deposition model on a random tree. We derive the time dependent densities of the first and second layer analytically and show that in all trees the limiting density of the first layer exceeds the density in the second layer. We also provide a procedure to calculate higher layer densities and prove that random trees have a higher limiting density in the first layer than regular trees. Finally, we compare densities between the first and second layer and between regular and random trees.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2009;
originally announced November 2009.
-
A symmetric entropy bound on the non-reconstruction regime of Markov chains on Galton-Watson trees
Authors:
M. Formentin,
C. Kuelske
Abstract:
We give a criterion of the form Q(d)c(M)<1 for the non-reconstructability of tree-indexed q-state Markov chains obtained by broadcasting a signal from the root with a given transition matrix M. Here c(M) is an explicit function, which is convex over the set of M's with a given invariant distribution, that is defined in terms of a (q-1)-dimensional variational problem over symmetric entropies. Fu…
▽ More
We give a criterion of the form Q(d)c(M)<1 for the non-reconstructability of tree-indexed q-state Markov chains obtained by broadcasting a signal from the root with a given transition matrix M. Here c(M) is an explicit function, which is convex over the set of M's with a given invariant distribution, that is defined in terms of a (q-1)-dimensional variational problem over symmetric entropies. Further Q(d) is the expected number of offspring on the Galton-Watson tree. This result is equivalent to proving the extremality of the free boundary condition-Gibbs measure within the corresponding Gibbs-simplex. Our theorem holds for possibly non-reversible M and its proof is based on a general Recursion Formula for expectations of a symmetrized relative entropy function, which invites their use as a Lyapunov function.
In the case of the Potts model, the present theorem reproduces earlier results of the authors, with a simplified proof, in the case of the symmetric Ising model (where the argument becomes similar to the approach of Pemantle and Peres) the method produces the correct reconstruction threshold), in the case of the (strongly) asymmetric Ising model where the Kesten-Stigum bound is known to be not sharp the method provides improved numerical bounds.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2010; v1 submitted 17 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
-
Gibbs-non-Gibbs properties for n-vector lattice and mean-field models
Authors:
A. C. D. van Enter,
C. Kuelske,
A. A. Opoku,
W. M. Ruszel
Abstract:
We review some recent developments in the study of Gibbs and non-Gibbs properties of transformed n-vector lattice and mean-field models under various transformations. Also, some new results for the loss and recovery of the Gibbs property of planar rotor models during stochastic time evolution are presented.
We review some recent developments in the study of Gibbs and non-Gibbs properties of transformed n-vector lattice and mean-field models under various transformations. Also, some new results for the loss and recovery of the Gibbs property of planar rotor models during stochastic time evolution are presented.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
-
A second row Parking Paradox
Authors:
S. R. Fleurke,
C. Kuelske
Abstract:
We consider two variations of the discrete car parking problem where at every vertex of the integers a car arrives with rate one, now allowing for parking in two lines. a) The car parks in the first line whenever the vertex and all of its nearest neighbors are not occupied yet. It can reach the first line if it is not obstructed by cars already parked in the second line (screening). b) The car p…
▽ More
We consider two variations of the discrete car parking problem where at every vertex of the integers a car arrives with rate one, now allowing for parking in two lines. a) The car parks in the first line whenever the vertex and all of its nearest neighbors are not occupied yet. It can reach the first line if it is not obstructed by cars already parked in the second line (screening). b) The car parks according to the same rules, but parking in the first line can not be obstructed by parked cars in the second line (no screening). In both models, a car that can not park in the first line will attempt to park in the second line. If it is obstructed in the second line as well, the attempt is discarded. We show that both models are solvable in terms of finite-dimensional ODEs. We compare numerically the limits of first and second line densities, with time going to infinity. While it is not surprising that model a) exhibits an increase of the density in the second line from the first line, more remarkably this is also true for model b), albeit in a less pronounced way.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2008; v1 submitted 21 November, 2008;
originally announced November 2008.
-
On the Purity of the free boundary condition Potts measure on random trees
Authors:
M. Formentin,
C. Kuelske
Abstract:
We consider the free boundary condition Gibbs measure of the Potts model on a random tree. We provide an explicit temperature interval below the ferromagnetic transition temperature for which this measure is extremal, improving older bounds of Mossel and Peres. In information theoretic language extremality of the Gibbs measure corresponds to non-reconstructability for symmetric q-ary channels. T…
▽ More
We consider the free boundary condition Gibbs measure of the Potts model on a random tree. We provide an explicit temperature interval below the ferromagnetic transition temperature for which this measure is extremal, improving older bounds of Mossel and Peres. In information theoretic language extremality of the Gibbs measure corresponds to non-reconstructability for symmetric q-ary channels. The bounds are optimal for the Ising model and appear to be close to what we conjecture to be the true values up to a factor of 0.0150 in the case q = 3 and 0.0365 for q = 4. Our proof uses an iteration of random boundary entropies from the outside of the tree to the inside, along with a symmetrization argument.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2009; v1 submitted 3 October, 2008;
originally announced October 2008.
-
Continuous Spin Mean-Field models: Limiting kernels and Gibbs Properties of local transforms
Authors:
C. Kuelske,
A. A. Opoku
Abstract:
We extend the notion of Gibbsianness for mean-field systems to the set-up of general (possibly continuous) local state spaces. We investigate the Gibbs properties of systems arising from an initial mean-field Gibbs measure by application of given local transition kernels. This generalizes previous case-studies made for spins taking finitely many values to the first step in direction to a general…
▽ More
We extend the notion of Gibbsianness for mean-field systems to the set-up of general (possibly continuous) local state spaces. We investigate the Gibbs properties of systems arising from an initial mean-field Gibbs measure by application of given local transition kernels. This generalizes previous case-studies made for spins taking finitely many values to the first step in direction to a general theory, containing the following parts: (1) A formula for the limiting conditional probability distributions of the transformed system. It holds both in the Gibbs and non-Gibbs regime and invokes a minimization problem for a "constrained rate-function". (2) A criterion for Gibbsianness of the transformed system for initial Lipschitz-Hamiltonians involving concentration properties of the transition kernels. (3) A continuity estimate for the single-site conditional distributions of the transformed system. While (2) and (3) have provable lattice-counterparts, the characterization of (1) is stronger in mean-field. As applications we show short-time Gibbsianness of rotator mean-field models on the (q-1)-dimensional sphere under diffusive time-evolution and the preservation of Gibbsianness under local coarse-graining of the initial local spin space.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2008;
originally announced June 2008.
-
Parking on a Random Tree
Authors:
H. Dehling,
S. R. Fleurke,
C. Kuelske
Abstract:
Consider an infinite tree with random degrees, i.i.d. over the sites, with a prescribed probability distribution with generating function G(s). We consider the following variation of Renyi's parking problem, alternatively called blocking RSA: at every vertex of the tree a particle (or car) arrives with rate one. The particle sticks to the vertex whenever the vertex and all of its nearest neighbo…
▽ More
Consider an infinite tree with random degrees, i.i.d. over the sites, with a prescribed probability distribution with generating function G(s). We consider the following variation of Renyi's parking problem, alternatively called blocking RSA: at every vertex of the tree a particle (or car) arrives with rate one. The particle sticks to the vertex whenever the vertex and all of its nearest neighbors are not occupied yet. We provide an explicit expression for the so-called parking constant in terms of the generating function.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2007;
originally announced November 2007.
-
The Posterior metric and the Goodness of Gibbsianness for transforms of Gibbs measures
Authors:
C. Kuelske,
A. A. Opoku
Abstract:
We present a general method to derive continuity estimates for conditional probabilities of general (possibly continuous) spin models sub jected to local transformations. Such systems arise in the study of a stochastic time-evolution of Gibbs measures or as noisy observations. We exhibit the minimal necessary structure for such double-layer systems. Assuming no a priori metric on the local state…
▽ More
We present a general method to derive continuity estimates for conditional probabilities of general (possibly continuous) spin models sub jected to local transformations. Such systems arise in the study of a stochastic time-evolution of Gibbs measures or as noisy observations. We exhibit the minimal necessary structure for such double-layer systems. Assuming no a priori metric on the local state spaces, we define the posterior metric on the local image space. We show that it allows in a natural way to divide the local part of the continuity estimates from the spatial part (which is treated by Dobrushin uniqueness here). We show in the concrete example of the time evolution of rotators on the q-1 dimensional sphere how this method can be used to obtain estimates in terms of the familiar Euclidean metric.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2007;
originally announced November 2007.
-
Continuous interfaces with disorder: Even strong pinning is too weak in 2 dimensions
Authors:
C. Kuelske,
E. Orlandi
Abstract:
We consider statistical mechanics models of continuous height effective interfaces in the presence of a delta-pinning at height zero. There is a detailed mathematical understanding of the depinning transition in 2 dimensions without disorder. Then the variance of the interface height w.r.t. the Gibbs measure stays bounded uniformly in the volume for any positive pinning force and diverges like t…
▽ More
We consider statistical mechanics models of continuous height effective interfaces in the presence of a delta-pinning at height zero. There is a detailed mathematical understanding of the depinning transition in 2 dimensions without disorder. Then the variance of the interface height w.r.t. the Gibbs measure stays bounded uniformly in the volume for any positive pinning force and diverges like the logarithm of the pinning force when it tends to zero.
How does the presence of a quenched disorder term in the Hamiltonian modify this transition? We show that an arbitarily weak random field term is enough to beat an arbitrarily strong delta-pinning in 2 dimensions and will cause delocalization. The proof is based on a rigorous lower bound for the overlap between local magnetizations and random fields in finite volume. In 2 dimensions it implies growth faster than the volume which is a contradiction to localization. We also derive a simple complementary inequality which shows that in higher dimensions the fraction of pinned sites converges to one when the pinning force tends to infinity.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2007;
originally announced April 2007.
-
Nonexistence of random gradient Gibbs measures in continuous interface models in $d=2$
Authors:
Aernout C. D. van Enter,
Christof Külske
Abstract:
We consider statistical mechanics models of continuous spins in a disordered environment. These models have a natural interpretation as effective interface models. It is well known that without disorder there are no interface Gibbs measures in infinite volume in dimension $d=2$, while there are ``gradient Gibbs measures'' describing an infinite-volume distribution for the increments of the field…
▽ More
We consider statistical mechanics models of continuous spins in a disordered environment. These models have a natural interpretation as effective interface models. It is well known that without disorder there are no interface Gibbs measures in infinite volume in dimension $d=2$, while there are ``gradient Gibbs measures'' describing an infinite-volume distribution for the increments of the field, as was shown by Funaki and Spohn. In the present paper we show that adding a disorder term prohibits the existence of such gradient Gibbs measures for general interaction potentials in $d=2$. This nonexistence result generalizes the simple case of Gaussian fields where it follows from an explicit computation. In $d=3$ where random gradient Gibbs measures are expected to exist, our method provides a lower bound of the order of the inverse of the distance on the decay of correlations of Gibbs expectations w.r.t. the distribution of the random environment.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2008; v1 submitted 6 November, 2006;
originally announced November 2006.
-
A simple fluctuation lower bound for a disordered massless random continuous spin model in d=2
Authors:
C. Kuelske,
E. Orlandi
Abstract:
We prove a finite volume lower bound of the order of the squareroot of log N on the delocalization of a disordered continuous spin model (resp. effective interface model) in d = 2 in a box of size N . The interaction is assumed to be massless, possibly anharmonic and dominated from above by a Gaussian. Disorder is entering via a linear source term. For this model delocalization with the same rat…
▽ More
We prove a finite volume lower bound of the order of the squareroot of log N on the delocalization of a disordered continuous spin model (resp. effective interface model) in d = 2 in a box of size N . The interaction is assumed to be massless, possibly anharmonic and dominated from above by a Gaussian. Disorder is entering via a linear source term. For this model delocalization with the same rate is proved to take place already without disorder. We provide a bound which is uniform in the configuration of the disorder, and so our proof shows that randomness will only enhance fluctuations.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2006; v1 submitted 4 April, 2006;
originally announced April 2006.
-
Two connections between random systems and non-Gibbsian measures
Authors:
A. C. D. van Enter,
C. Kuelske
Abstract:
In this contribution we discuss the role disordered (or random) systems have played in the study of non-Gibbsian measures. This role has two main aspects, the distinction between which has not always been fully clear:
1) {\em From} disordered systems: Disordered systems can be used as a tool; analogies with, as well as results and methods from the study of random systems can be employed to inv…
▽ More
In this contribution we discuss the role disordered (or random) systems have played in the study of non-Gibbsian measures. This role has two main aspects, the distinction between which has not always been fully clear:
1) {\em From} disordered systems: Disordered systems can be used as a tool; analogies with, as well as results and methods from the study of random systems can be employed to investigate non-Gibbsian properties of a variety of measures of physical and mathematical interest.
2) {\em Of} disordered systems: Non-Gibbsianness is a property of various (joint) measures describing quenched disordered systems.
We discuss and review this distinction and a number of results related to these issues. Moreover, we discuss the mean-field version of the non-Gibbsian property, and present some ideas how a Kac limit approach might connect the finite-range and the mean-field non-Gibbsian properties.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2006;
originally announced February 2006.
-
Concentration inequalities for random fields via coupling
Authors:
J. -R. Chazottes,
P. Collet,
C. Kuelske,
F. Redig
Abstract:
We present a new and simple approach to concentration inequalities for functions around their expectation with respect to non-product measures, i.e., for dependent random variables. Our method is based on coupling ideas and does not use information inequalities. When one has a uniform control on the coupling, this leads to exponential concentration inequalities. When such a uniform control is no…
▽ More
We present a new and simple approach to concentration inequalities for functions around their expectation with respect to non-product measures, i.e., for dependent random variables. Our method is based on coupling ideas and does not use information inequalities. When one has a uniform control on the coupling, this leads to exponential concentration inequalities. When such a uniform control is no more possible, this leads to polynomial or stretched-exponential concentration inequalities. Our abstract results apply to Gibbs random fields, in particular to the low-temperature Ising model which is a concrete example of non-uniformity of the coupling.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2006; v1 submitted 23 March, 2005;
originally announced March 2005.
-
Loss without recovery of Gibbsianness during diffusion of continuous spins
Authors:
C. Kuelske,
F. Redig
Abstract:
We consider a specific continuous-spin Gibbs distribution $μ_{t=0}$ for a double-well potential that allows for ferromagnetic ordering. We study the time-evolution of this initial measure under independent diffusions. For `high temperature' initial measures we prove that the time-evoved measure $μ_{t}$ is Gibbsian for all $t$. For `low temperature' initial measures we prove that $μ_t$ stays Gibb…
▽ More
We consider a specific continuous-spin Gibbs distribution $μ_{t=0}$ for a double-well potential that allows for ferromagnetic ordering. We study the time-evolution of this initial measure under independent diffusions. For `high temperature' initial measures we prove that the time-evoved measure $μ_{t}$ is Gibbsian for all $t$. For `low temperature' initial measures we prove that $μ_t$ stays Gibbsian for small enough times $t$, but loses its Gibbsian character for large enough $t$. In contrast to the analogous situation for discrete-spin Gibbs measures, there is no recovery of the Gibbs property for large $t$ in the presence of a non-vanishing external magnetic field. All of our results hold for any dimension $d\geq 2$. This example suggests more generally that time-evolved continuous-spin models tend to be non-Gibbsian more easily than their discrete-spin counterparts.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2004;
originally announced September 2004.
-
How non-Gibbsianness helps a metastable Morita minimizer to provide a stable free energy
Authors:
Christof Kuelske
Abstract:
We analyze a simple approximation scheme based on the Morita-approach for the example of the mean field random field Ising model where it is claimed to be exact in some of the physics literature. We show that the approximation scheme is flawed, but it provides a set of equations whose metastable solutions surprisingly yield the correct solution of the model. We explain how the same equations app…
▽ More
We analyze a simple approximation scheme based on the Morita-approach for the example of the mean field random field Ising model where it is claimed to be exact in some of the physics literature. We show that the approximation scheme is flawed, but it provides a set of equations whose metastable solutions surprisingly yield the correct solution of the model. We explain how the same equations appear in a different way as rigorous consistency equations. We clarify the relation between the validity of their solutions and the almost surely discontinuous behavior of the single-site conditional probabilities.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2004;
originally announced April 2004.
-
Gibbs properties of the fuzzy Potts model on trees and in mean field
Authors:
Olle Haeggstroem,
Christof Kuelske
Abstract:
We study Gibbs properties of the fuzzy Potts model in the mean field case (i.e on a complete graph) and on trees. For the mean field case, a complete characterization of the set of temperatures for which non-Gibbsianness happens is given. The results for trees are somewhat less explicit, but we do show for general trees that non-Gibbsianness of the fuzzy Potts model happens exactly for those tem…
▽ More
We study Gibbs properties of the fuzzy Potts model in the mean field case (i.e on a complete graph) and on trees. For the mean field case, a complete characterization of the set of temperatures for which non-Gibbsianness happens is given. The results for trees are somewhat less explicit, but we do show for general trees that non-Gibbsianness of the fuzzy Potts model happens exactly for those temperatures where the underlying Potts model has multiple Gibbs measures.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2003;
originally announced October 2003.
-
Variational principle for generalized Gibbsian measures
Authors:
Christof Kuelske,
Arnaud Le Ny,
Frank Redig
Abstract:
We study the thermodynamic formalism for generalized Gibbs measures, such as renormalization group transformations of Gibbs measures or joint measures of disordered spin systems. We first show existence of the relative entropy density and obtain a familiar expression in terms of entropy and relative energy for "almost Gibbsian measures" (almost sure continuity of conditional probabilities). We a…
▽ More
We study the thermodynamic formalism for generalized Gibbs measures, such as renormalization group transformations of Gibbs measures or joint measures of disordered spin systems. We first show existence of the relative entropy density and obtain a familiar expression in terms of entropy and relative energy for "almost Gibbsian measures" (almost sure continuity of conditional probabilities). We also describe these measures as equilibrium states and establish an extension of the usual variational principle. As a corollary, we obtain a full variational principle for quasilocal measures. For the joint measures of the random field Ising model, we show that the weak Gibbs property holds, with an almost surely rapidly decaying translation invariant potential. For these measures we show that the variational principle fails as soon as the measures loses the almost Gibbs property. These examples suggest that the class of weakly Gibbsian measures is too broad from the perspective of a reasonable thermodynamic formalism.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2002;
originally announced November 2002.
-
Universal bounds on the selfaveraging of random diffraction measures
Authors:
C. Kuelske
Abstract:
We consider diffraction at random point scatterers on general discrete point sets in $\R^ν$, restricted to a finite volume. We allow for random amplitudes and random dislocations of the scatterers. We investigate the speed of convergence of the random scattering measures applied to an observable towards its mean, when the finite volume tends to infinity. We give an explicit universal large devia…
▽ More
We consider diffraction at random point scatterers on general discrete point sets in $\R^ν$, restricted to a finite volume. We allow for random amplitudes and random dislocations of the scatterers. We investigate the speed of convergence of the random scattering measures applied to an observable towards its mean, when the finite volume tends to infinity. We give an explicit universal large deviation upper bound that is exponential in the number of scatterers. The rate is given in terms of a universal function that depends on the point set only through the minimal distance between points, and on the observable only through a suitable Sobolev-norm. Our proof uses a cluster expansion and also provides a central limit theorem.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2001;
originally announced September 2001.
-
Weakly Gibbsian representations for joint measures of quenched lattice spin models
Authors:
Christof Kuelske
Abstract:
Can the joint measures of quenched disordered lattice spin models (with finite range) on the product of spin-space and disorder-space be represented as (suitably generalized) Gibbs measures of an ``annealed system''? - We prove that there is always a potential (depending on both spin and disorder variables) that converges absolutely on a set of full measure w.r.t. the joint measure (``weak Gibbs…
▽ More
Can the joint measures of quenched disordered lattice spin models (with finite range) on the product of spin-space and disorder-space be represented as (suitably generalized) Gibbs measures of an ``annealed system''? - We prove that there is always a potential (depending on both spin and disorder variables) that converges absolutely on a set of full measure w.r.t. the joint measure (``weak Gibbsianness''). This ``positive'' result is surprising when contrasted with the results of a previous paper [K6], where we investigated the measure of the set of discontinuity points of the conditional expectations (investigation of ``a.s. Gibbsianness''). In particular we gave natural ``negative'' examples where this set is even of measure one (including the random field Ising model). Further we discuss conditions giving the convergence of vacuum potentials and conditions for the decay of the joint potential in terms of the decay of the disorder average over certain quenched correlations. We apply them to various examples. From this one typically expects the existence of a potential that decays superpolynomially outside a set of measure zero. Our proof uses a martingale argument that allows to cut (an infinite volume analogue of) the quenched free energy into local pieces, along with generalizations of Kozlov's constructions.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 1999;
originally announced October 1999.
-
(Non-) Gibbsianness and phase transitions in random lattice spin models
Authors:
C. Kuelske
Abstract:
We consider disordered lattice spin models with finite volume Gibbs measures $μ_Ł[η](d\s)$. Here $\s$ denotes a lattice spin-variable and $η$ a lattice random variable with product distribution $¶$ describing the disorder of the model. We ask: When will the joint measures $\lim_{Ł\uparrow\Z^d}¶(dη)μ_Ł[η](d\s)$ be [non-] Gibbsian measures on the product of spin-space and disorder-space? We obtain…
▽ More
We consider disordered lattice spin models with finite volume Gibbs measures $μ_Ł[η](d\s)$. Here $\s$ denotes a lattice spin-variable and $η$ a lattice random variable with product distribution $¶$ describing the disorder of the model. We ask: When will the joint measures $\lim_{Ł\uparrow\Z^d}¶(dη)μ_Ł[η](d\s)$ be [non-] Gibbsian measures on the product of spin-space and disorder-space? We obtain general criteria for both Gibbsianness and non-Gibbsianness providing an interesting link between phase transitions at a fixed random configuration and Gibbsianness in product space: Loosely speaking, a phase transition can lead to non-Gibbsianness, (only) if it can be observed on the spin-observable conjugate to the independent disorder variables.
Our main specific example is the random field Ising model in any dimension for which we show almost sure- [almost sure non-] Gibbsianness for the single- [multi-] phase region. We also discuss models with disordered couplings, including spinglasses and ferromagnets, where various mechanisms are responsible for [non-] Gibbsianness.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 1999;
originally announced April 1999.
-
Stability for a continuous SOS-interface model in a randomly perturbed periodic potential
Authors:
Christof Kuelske
Abstract:
We consider the Gibbs-measures of continuous-valued height configurations on the $d$-dimensional integer lattice in the presence a weakly disordered potential. The potential is composed of Gaussians having random location and random depth; it becomes periodic under shift of the interface perpendicular to the base-plane for zero disorder. We prove that there exist localized interfaces with probab…
▽ More
We consider the Gibbs-measures of continuous-valued height configurations on the $d$-dimensional integer lattice in the presence a weakly disordered potential. The potential is composed of Gaussians having random location and random depth; it becomes periodic under shift of the interface perpendicular to the base-plane for zero disorder. We prove that there exist localized interfaces with probability one in dimensions $d\geq 3+1$, in a `low-temperature' regime. The proof extends the method of continuous-to-discrete single- site coarse graining that was previously applied by the author for a double-well potential to the case of a non-compact image space. This allows to utilize parts of the renormalization group analysis developed for the treatment of a contour representation of a related integer-valued SOS-model in [BoK1]. We show that, for a.e. fixed realization of the disorder, the infinite volume Gibbs measures then have a representation as superpositions of massive Gaussian fields with centerings that are distributed according to the infinite volume Gibbs measures of the disordered integer-valued SOS-model with exponentially decaying interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 1998;
originally announced December 1998.
-
The continuous spin random field model: Ferromagnetic ordering in d>=3
Authors:
Christof Kuelske
Abstract:
We investigate the Gibbs-measures of ferromagnetically coupled continuous spins in double-well potentials subjected to a random field (our specific example being the $φ^4$ theory), showing ferromagnetic ordering in $d\geq 3$ dimensions for weak disorder and large energy barriers. We map the random continuous spin distributions to distributions for an Ising-spin system by means of a single-site c…
▽ More
We investigate the Gibbs-measures of ferromagnetically coupled continuous spins in double-well potentials subjected to a random field (our specific example being the $φ^4$ theory), showing ferromagnetic ordering in $d\geq 3$ dimensions for weak disorder and large energy barriers. We map the random continuous spin distributions to distributions for an Ising-spin system by means of a single-site coarse-graining method described by local transition kernels. We derive a contour- representation for them with notably positive contour activities and prove their Gibbsianness. This representation is shown to allow for application of the discrete-spin renormalization group developed by Bricmont/Kupiainen implying the result in $d\geq 3$.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 1998;
originally announced June 1998.
