-
Long-range effects in asymptotic fields and angular momentum of classical field electrodynamics
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
Asymptotic properties of classical field electrodynamics are considered. Special attention is paid to the long-range structure of the electromagnetic field. It is shown that conserved Poincare quantities may be expressed in terms of the asymptotic fields. Long-range variables are shown to be responsible for an angular momentum contribution which mixes Coulomb and infrared free field characteristic…
▽ More
Asymptotic properties of classical field electrodynamics are considered. Special attention is paid to the long-range structure of the electromagnetic field. It is shown that conserved Poincare quantities may be expressed in terms of the asymptotic fields. Long-range variables are shown to be responsible for an angular momentum contribution which mixes Coulomb and infrared free field characteristics; otherwise angular momentum and energy-momentum separate into electromagnetic and matter fields contributions.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Infrared structure beyond locality in electrodynamics
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
The infrared problems of quantum electrodynamics, in contrast to ultraviolet difficulties which are of technical nature, are related to fundamental, conceptual physical questions, such as: what is a charged particle, is the particle interpretation of the electromagnetic field complete, does a vacuum state exist, or what is the quantum status of long range degrees of freedom. On the calculational l…
▽ More
The infrared problems of quantum electrodynamics, in contrast to ultraviolet difficulties which are of technical nature, are related to fundamental, conceptual physical questions, such as: what is a charged particle, is the particle interpretation of the electromagnetic field complete, does a vacuum state exist, or what is the quantum status of long range degrees of freedom. On the calculational level, the standard local formulations of quantum field theory have achieved procedures to deal with infinities related to long range correlations. However, the answers to the conceptual questions formulated above, based on the locality paradigm, do not seem to be fully convincing, which is confirmed by the fact that no canonical picture did emerge. This contribution briefly characterizes perspectives which open with an admission of nonlocal variables residing in infinity, or at the boundary of spacetime after compactification. Recently, this line of investigation gains popularity.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2024; v1 submitted 14 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
There is no 'velocity kick' memory in electrodynamics
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
The memory effect in electrodynamics, as discovered in 1981 by Staruszkiewicz, and also analysed later, consists of adiabatic shift of the position of a test particle. The proposed 'velocity kick' memory effect, supposedly discovered recently, is in contradiction to these findings. We show that the 'velocity kick' memory is an artefact resulting from an unjustified interchange of limits. This exam…
▽ More
The memory effect in electrodynamics, as discovered in 1981 by Staruszkiewicz, and also analysed later, consists of adiabatic shift of the position of a test particle. The proposed 'velocity kick' memory effect, supposedly discovered recently, is in contradiction to these findings. We show that the 'velocity kick' memory is an artefact resulting from an unjustified interchange of limits. This example is a warning against drawing uncritical conclusions for spacetime fields, from their asymptotic behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2024; v1 submitted 10 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Undressing the electron
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
The extended algebra of the free electromagnetic fields, including infrared singular fields, and the almost radial gauge, both introduced earlier, are postulated for the construction of the quantum electrodynamics in a Hilbert space (no indefinite metric). Both the Dirac and electromagnetic fields are constructed up to the first order (based on the incoming fields) as operators in the Hilbert spac…
▽ More
The extended algebra of the free electromagnetic fields, including infrared singular fields, and the almost radial gauge, both introduced earlier, are postulated for the construction of the quantum electrodynamics in a Hilbert space (no indefinite metric). Both the Dirac and electromagnetic fields are constructed up to the first order (based on the incoming fields) as operators in the Hilbert space, and shown to have physically well interpretable asymptotic behavior in far past and spacelike separations. The Dirac field tends in far past to the free incoming field, carrying its own Coulomb field, but with no 'soft photon dressing'. The spacelike asymptotic limit of the electromagnetic field yields a conserved operator field, which is a sum of contributions of the incoming Coulomb field, and of the low energy limit of the incoming free electromagnetic field. This should agree with the operator field similarly constructed with the use of outgoing fields, which then relates these past and future characteristics. Higher orders are expected not to change this picture, but their construction needs a treatment of the UV question, which has not been undertaken and remains a problem for further investigation.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2024; v1 submitted 31 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Remarks on mathematical structure of the Staruszkiewicz theory
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
The purpose of this note is threefold: (i) to recall (with some points made more explicit) the mathematical Weyl algebra model formulation, given before, of the Staruszkiewicz theory of quantum Coulomb field; (ii) to add some new elements to the discussion of the representation of the Lorentz group within this model; (iii) to comment on some statements on the structure of the theory which appeared…
▽ More
The purpose of this note is threefold: (i) to recall (with some points made more explicit) the mathematical Weyl algebra model formulation, given before, of the Staruszkiewicz theory of quantum Coulomb field; (ii) to add some new elements to the discussion of the representation of the Lorentz group within this model; (iii) to comment on some statements on the structure of the theory which appeared recently.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Almost radial gauge
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
An almost radial gauge $A^\mathrm{ar}$ of the electromagnetic potential is constructed for which $x\cdot A^\mathrm{ar}(x)$ vanishes arbitrarily fast in timelike directions. This potential is in the class introduced by Dirac with the purpose of forming gauge-invariant quantities in quantum electrodynamics. In quantum case the construction of smeared operators $A^\mathrm{ar}(K)$ is enabled by a natu…
▽ More
An almost radial gauge $A^\mathrm{ar}$ of the electromagnetic potential is constructed for which $x\cdot A^\mathrm{ar}(x)$ vanishes arbitrarily fast in timelike directions. This potential is in the class introduced by Dirac with the purpose of forming gauge-invariant quantities in quantum electrodynamics. In quantum case the construction of smeared operators $A^\mathrm{ar}(K)$ is enabled by a natural extension of the free electromagnetic field algebra introduced earlier (represented in a Hilbert space). The space of possible smearing functions $K$ includes vector fields with the asymptotic spacetime behavior typical for scattered currents (the conservation condition in the whole spacetime need not be assumed). This construction is motivated by a possible application to the infrared problem in QED.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2022; v1 submitted 5 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Infrared problem vs gauge choice: scattering of classical Dirac field
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
We consider the Dirac equation for the classical spinor field placed in an external, time-dependent electromagnetic field of the form typical for scattering settings: $F=F^\mathrm{ret}+F^\mathrm{in}=F^\mathrm{adv}+F^\mathrm{out}$, where the current producing $F^{\mathrm{ret}/\mathrm{adv}}$ has past and future asymptotes homogeneous of degree $-3$, and the free fields…
▽ More
We consider the Dirac equation for the classical spinor field placed in an external, time-dependent electromagnetic field of the form typical for scattering settings: $F=F^\mathrm{ret}+F^\mathrm{in}=F^\mathrm{adv}+F^\mathrm{out}$, where the current producing $F^{\mathrm{ret}/\mathrm{adv}}$ has past and future asymptotes homogeneous of degree $-3$, and the free fields $F^{\mathrm{in}/\mathrm{out}}$ are radiation fields produced by currents with similar asymptotic behavior. We show the existence of the electromagnetic gauges in which the particle has 'in' and 'out' asymptotic states approaching free field states, with no long-time corrections of the free dynamics. Using a special Cauchy foliation of the spacetime we show in this context the existence and asymptotic completeness of the wave operators. Moreover, we define a special 'evolution picture' in which the free evolution operator has well-defined limits for $t\to\pm\infty$, thus the scattering wave operators do not need the free evolution counteraction.
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Electromagnetic gauge choice for scattering of Schrödinger particle
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
We consider a Schrödinger particle placed in an external electromagnetic field of the form typical for scattering settings in the field theory: $F=F^\mathrm{ret}+F^\mathrm{in}=F^\mathrm{adv}+F^\mathrm{out}$, where the current producing $F^{\mathrm{ret}/\mathrm{adv}}$ has the past and future asymptotes homogeneous of degree $-3$, and the free fields $F^{\mathrm{in}/\mathrm{out}}$ are radiation fiel…
▽ More
We consider a Schrödinger particle placed in an external electromagnetic field of the form typical for scattering settings in the field theory: $F=F^\mathrm{ret}+F^\mathrm{in}=F^\mathrm{adv}+F^\mathrm{out}$, where the current producing $F^{\mathrm{ret}/\mathrm{adv}}$ has the past and future asymptotes homogeneous of degree $-3$, and the free fields $F^{\mathrm{in}/\mathrm{out}}$ are radiation fields produced by currents with similar asymptotic behavior. We show that with appropriate choice of electromagnetic gauge the particle has 'in' and 'out' states reached with no further modification of the asymptotic dynamics. We use a special quantum-mechanical evolution 'picture' in which the free evolution operator has well-defined limits for $t\to\pm\infty$, thus the scattering wave operators do not need the free evolution counteraction. The existence of wave operators in this setting is established, but the proof of asymptotic completeness is not complete: more precise characterization of the asymptotic behavior of the particle for $|\mathbf{x}|=|t|$ would be needed.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Asymptotic structure of electrodynamics revisited
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
We point out that recently published analyses of null and timelike infinity and long-range structures in electrodynamics to large extent rediscover results present in literature. At the same time, some of the conclusions these recent works put forward may prove controversial. In view of these facts we find it desirable to revisit the analysis taken up more than two decades ago, starting from earli…
▽ More
We point out that recently published analyses of null and timelike infinity and long-range structures in electrodynamics to large extent rediscover results present in literature. At the same time, some of the conclusions these recent works put forward may prove controversial. In view of these facts we find it desirable to revisit the analysis taken up more than two decades ago, starting from earlier works on null infinity by other authors.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2017; v1 submitted 14 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Generalized uncertainty relations
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen,
Piotr Ziobro
Abstract:
The standard uncertainty relations (UR) in quantum mechanics are typically used for unbounded operators (like the canonical pair). This implies the need for the control of the domain problems. On the other hand, the use of (possibly bounded) functions of basic observables usually leads to more complex and less readily interpretable relations. Also, UR may turn trivial for certain states if the com…
▽ More
The standard uncertainty relations (UR) in quantum mechanics are typically used for unbounded operators (like the canonical pair). This implies the need for the control of the domain problems. On the other hand, the use of (possibly bounded) functions of basic observables usually leads to more complex and less readily interpretable relations. Also, UR may turn trivial for certain states if the commutator of observables is not proportional to a positive operator. In this letter we consider a generalization of standard UR resulting from the use of two, instead of one, vector states. The possibility to link these states to each other in various ways adds additional flexibility to UR, which may compensate some of the above mentioned drawbacks. We discuss applications of the general scheme, leading not only to technical improvements, but also to interesting new insight.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Massless asymptotic fields and Haag-Ruelle theory
Authors:
Paweł Duch,
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
We revisit the problem of the existence of asymptotic massless boson fields in quantum field theory. The well-known construction of such fields by Buchholz [2], [4] is based on locality and the existence of vacuum vector, at least in regions spacelike to spacelike cones. Our analysis does not depend on these assumptions and supplies a more general framework for fields only very weakly decaying in…
▽ More
We revisit the problem of the existence of asymptotic massless boson fields in quantum field theory. The well-known construction of such fields by Buchholz [2], [4] is based on locality and the existence of vacuum vector, at least in regions spacelike to spacelike cones. Our analysis does not depend on these assumptions and supplies a more general framework for fields only very weakly decaying in spacelike directions. In this setting the existence of appropriate null asymptotes of fields is linked with their spectral properties in the neighborhood of the lightcone. The main technical tool is one of the results of a recent analysis by one of us [11], which allows application of the null asymptotic limit separately to creation/annihilation parts of a wide class of non-local fields. In vacuum representation the scheme allows application of the methods of the Haag-Ruelle theory closely analogous to those of the massive case. In local case this Haag-Ruelle procedure may be combined with the Buchholz method, which leads to significant simplification.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
On energy-momentum transfer of quantum fields
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
We prove the following theorem on bounded operators in quantum field theory: if $\|[B,B^*(x)]\|\leq \mathrm{const} D(x)$, then $\|B^k_\pm(ν)G(P^0)\|^2\leq\mathrm{const}\int D(x-y)d|ν|(x)d|ν|(y)$, where $D(x)$ is a function weakly decaying in spacelike directions, $B^k_\pm$ are creation/annihilation parts of an appropriate time derivative of $B$, $G$ is any positive, bounded, non-increasing functio…
▽ More
We prove the following theorem on bounded operators in quantum field theory: if $\|[B,B^*(x)]\|\leq \mathrm{const} D(x)$, then $\|B^k_\pm(ν)G(P^0)\|^2\leq\mathrm{const}\int D(x-y)d|ν|(x)d|ν|(y)$, where $D(x)$ is a function weakly decaying in spacelike directions, $B^k_\pm$ are creation/annihilation parts of an appropriate time derivative of $B$, $G$ is any positive, bounded, non-increasing function in $L^2(\mathbb{R})$, and $ν$ is any finite complex Borel measure; creation/annihilation operators may be also replaced by $B^k_t$ with $\check{B^k_t}(p)=|p|^k\check{B}(p)$. We also use the notion of energy-momentum scaling degree of $B$ with respect to a submanifold (Steinmann-type, but in momentum space, and applied to the norm of an operator). These two tools are applied to the analysis of singularities of $\check{B}(p)G(P^0)$. We prove, among others, the following statement (modulo some more specific assumptions): outside $p=0$ the only allowed contributions to this functional which are concentrated on a submanifold (including the trivial one -- a single point) are Dirac measures on hypersurfaces (if the decay of $D$ is not to slow).
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Infraparticle problem, asymptotic fields and Haag-Ruelle theory
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
In this article we want to argue that an appropriate generalization of the Wigner concepts may lead to an asymptotic particle with well-defined mass, although no mass hyperboloid in the energy-momentum spectrum exists.
In this article we want to argue that an appropriate generalization of the Wigner concepts may lead to an asymptotic particle with well-defined mass, although no mass hyperboloid in the energy-momentum spectrum exists.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2013; v1 submitted 5 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Infrared limit in external field scattering
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
Scattering of electrons/positrons by external classical electromagnetic wave packet is considered in infrared limit. In this limit the scattering operator exists and produces physical effects, although the scattering cross-section is trivial.
Scattering of electrons/positrons by external classical electromagnetic wave packet is considered in infrared limit. In this limit the scattering operator exists and produces physical effects, although the scattering cross-section is trivial.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2012; v1 submitted 20 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Spacelike localization of long-range fields in a model of asymptotic electrodynamics
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen,
Katarzyna Rejzner
Abstract:
A previously proposed algebra of asymptotic fields in quantum electrodynamics is formulated as a net of algebras localized in regions which in general have unbounded spacelike extension. Electromagnetic fields may be localized in `symmetrical spacelike cones', but there are strong indications this is not possible in the present model for charged fields, which have tails extending in all space dire…
▽ More
A previously proposed algebra of asymptotic fields in quantum electrodynamics is formulated as a net of algebras localized in regions which in general have unbounded spacelike extension. Electromagnetic fields may be localized in `symmetrical spacelike cones', but there are strong indications this is not possible in the present model for charged fields, which have tails extending in all space directions. Nevertheless, products of appropriately `dressed' fermion fields (with compensating charges) yield bi-localized observables.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2011;
originally announced March 2011.
-
Global vs local Casimir effect
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen,
Mariusz Stopa
Abstract:
This paper continues the investigation of the Casimir effect with the use of the algebraic formulation of quantum field theory in the initial value setting. Basing on earlier papers by one of us (AH) we approximate the Dirichlet and Neumann boundary conditions by simple interaction models whose nonlocality in physical space is under strict control, but which at the same time are admissible from th…
▽ More
This paper continues the investigation of the Casimir effect with the use of the algebraic formulation of quantum field theory in the initial value setting. Basing on earlier papers by one of us (AH) we approximate the Dirichlet and Neumann boundary conditions by simple interaction models whose nonlocality in physical space is under strict control, but which at the same time are admissible from the point of view of algebraic restrictions imposed on models in the context of Casimir backreaction. The geometrical setting is that of the original parallel plates. By scaling our models and taking appropriate limit we approach the sharp boundary conditions in the limit. The global force is analyzed in that limit. One finds in Neumann case that although the sharp boundary interaction is recovered in the norm resolvent sense for each model considered, the total force per area depends substantially on its choice and diverges in the sharp boundary conditions limit. On the other hand the local energy density outside the interaction region, which in the limit includes any compact set outside the strict position of the plates, has a universal limit corresponding to sharp conditions. This is what one should expect in general, and the lack of this discrepancy in Dirichlet case is rather accidental. Our discussion pins down its precise origin: the difference in the order in which scaling limit and integration over the whole space is carried out.
△ Less
Submitted 13 July, 2010;
originally announced July 2010.
-
Infrared problem and spatially local observables in electrodynamics
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
An algebra previously proposed as an asymptotic field structure in electrodynamics is considered in respect of localization properties of fields. Fields are 'spatially local' -- localized in regions resulting as unions of two intersecting (solid) lightcones: a future- and a past-lightcone. This localization remains in concord with the usual idealizations connected with the scattering theory. Fie…
▽ More
An algebra previously proposed as an asymptotic field structure in electrodynamics is considered in respect of localization properties of fields. Fields are 'spatially local' -- localized in regions resulting as unions of two intersecting (solid) lightcones: a future- and a past-lightcone. This localization remains in concord with the usual idealizations connected with the scattering theory. Fields thus localized naturally include infrared characteristics normally placed at spacelike infinity and form a structure respecting Gauss law. When applied to the description of the radiation of an external classical current the model is free of 'infrared catastrophe'.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2007; v1 submitted 2 October, 2007;
originally announced October 2007.
-
Quantum backreaction (Casimir) effect I. What are admissible idealizations?
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
Casimir effect, in a broad interpretation which we adopt here, consists in a backreaction of a quantum system to adiabatically changing external conditions. Although the system is usually taken to be a quantum field, we show that this restriction rather blurs than helps to clarify the statement of the problem. We discuss the problem from the point of view of algebraic structure of quantum theory…
▽ More
Casimir effect, in a broad interpretation which we adopt here, consists in a backreaction of a quantum system to adiabatically changing external conditions. Although the system is usually taken to be a quantum field, we show that this restriction rather blurs than helps to clarify the statement of the problem. We discuss the problem from the point of view of algebraic structure of quantum theory, which is most appropriate in this context. The system in question may be any quantum system, among others both finite as infinite dimensional canonical systems are allowed. A simple finite-dimensional model is discussed. We identify precisely the source of difficulties and infinities in most of traditional treatments of the problem for infinite dimensional systems (such as quantum fields), which is incompatibility of algebras of observables or their representations. We formulate conditions on model idealizations which are acceptable for the discussion of the adiabatic backreaction problem. In the case of quantum field models in that class we find that the normal ordered energy density is a well defined distribution, yielding global energy in the limit of a unit test function. Although we see the "zero point" expressions as inappropriate, we show how they can arise in the quantum field theory context as a result of uncontrollable manipulations.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2004;
originally announced December 2004.
-
Asymptotic algebra of quantum electrodynamics
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
The Staruszkiewicz quantum model of the long-range structure in electrodynamics is reviewed in the form of a Weyl algebra. This is followed by a personal view on the asymptotic structure of quantum electrodynamics.
The Staruszkiewicz quantum model of the long-range structure in electrodynamics is reviewed in the form of a Weyl algebra. This is followed by a personal view on the asymptotic structure of quantum electrodynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2004;
originally announced December 2004.
-
No-nonsense Casimir force
Authors:
Andrzej Herdegen
Abstract:
Two thin conducting, electrically neutral, parallel plates forming an isolated system in vacuum exert attracting force on each other, whose origin is the quantum electrodynamical interaction. This theoretical hypothesis, known as Casimir effect, has been also confirmed experimentally. Despite long history of the subject, no completely convincing theoretical analysis of this effect appears in the…
▽ More
Two thin conducting, electrically neutral, parallel plates forming an isolated system in vacuum exert attracting force on each other, whose origin is the quantum electrodynamical interaction. This theoretical hypothesis, known as Casimir effect, has been also confirmed experimentally. Despite long history of the subject, no completely convincing theoretical analysis of this effect appears in the literature. Here we discuss the effect (for the scalar field) anew, on a revised physical and mathematical basis. Standard, but advanced methods of relativistic quantum theory are used. No anomalous features of the conventional approaches appear. The Casimir quantitative prediction for the force is shown to constitute the leading asymptotic term, for large separation of the plates, of the full, model-dependent expression.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2001; v1 submitted 28 August, 2000;
originally announced August 2000.
