Comment on: "Comment on "Nonperturbative calculation of Born-Infeld effects on the Schrödinger spectrum of the hydrogen atom"" by M. N. Smolyakov
Authors:
H. K. Carley,
M. K. -H. Kiessling
Abstract:
This reply to Dr. Smolyakov's comment [2] on our PRL paper [1] was solicited by PRL on Nov. 17, 2021 and submitted to PRL on Nov. 30, 2021. Regretfully, the editors of PRL decided not to publish Dr. Smolyakov's comment; hence, not our reply to it. However, since Dr. Smolyakov made his comment publicly available at the arXiv.org in June 2022 (of which we learned only on Dec. 26, 2024), we have deci…
▽ More
This reply to Dr. Smolyakov's comment [2] on our PRL paper [1] was solicited by PRL on Nov. 17, 2021 and submitted to PRL on Nov. 30, 2021. Regretfully, the editors of PRL decided not to publish Dr. Smolyakov's comment; hence, not our reply to it. However, since Dr. Smolyakov made his comment publicly available at the arXiv.org in June 2022 (of which we learned only on Dec. 26, 2024), we have decided to make our reply to his comment publicly available as well.
△ Less
Submitted 31 December, 2024;
originally announced January 2025.
A study of the radiation-reaction on a point charge that moves along a constant applied electric field in an electromagnetic Bopp-Landé-Thomas-Podolsky vacuum
Authors:
Holly K. Carley,
Michael K. -H. Kiessling
Abstract:
The relativistic problem of motion of a classical electrical point charge that has been placed between the plates of a charged capacitor and then released from rest is well-posed in Bopp-Landé-Thomas-Podolsky (BLTP) electrodynamics. That theory introduces a single new parameter, Bopp's $\varkappa$, a reciprocal length. The present article concerns the small-$\varkappa$ regime. Radiation-reaction e…
▽ More
The relativistic problem of motion of a classical electrical point charge that has been placed between the plates of a charged capacitor and then released from rest is well-posed in Bopp-Landé-Thomas-Podolsky (BLTP) electrodynamics. That theory introduces a single new parameter, Bopp's $\varkappa$, a reciprocal length. The present article concerns the small-$\varkappa$ regime. Radiation-reaction effects on the motion are shown to appear at order $\varkappa^3$. It is found that in the initial phase the motion is accurately accounted for by test particle theory, with the inertia determined by the bare mass of the particle. Subsequently, radiation-reaction effects cause substantial deviations from the test particle motion.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2023; v1 submitted 3 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
On the Schrödinger spectrum of a hydrogen atom with electrostatic Bopp-Landé-Thomas-Podolsky interaction between electron and proton
Authors:
Holly K. Carley,
Michael K. -H. Kiessling,
Volker Perlick
Abstract:
The Schrödinger spectrum of a hydrogen atom, modelled as a two-body system consisting of a point electron and a point proton, interacting with a modification of Coulomb's law proposed, in the 1940s, by Bopp, Landé--Thomas, and Podolsky (BLTP). The BLTP theory hypothesizes the existence of an electromagnetic length scale of nature --- the Bopp length $\varkappa ^{-1}$ ---, to the effect that the el…
▽ More
The Schrödinger spectrum of a hydrogen atom, modelled as a two-body system consisting of a point electron and a point proton, interacting with a modification of Coulomb's law proposed, in the 1940s, by Bopp, Landé--Thomas, and Podolsky (BLTP). The BLTP theory hypothesizes the existence of an electromagnetic length scale of nature --- the Bopp length $\varkappa ^{-1}$ ---, to the effect that the electrostatic pair interaction deviates significantly from Coulomb's law only for distances much shorter than $\varkappa^{-1}$. Rigorous lower and upper bounds are constructed for the Schrödinger energy levels of the hydrogen atom, $E_{\ell,n}(\varkappa)$, for all $\ell\in\{0,1,2,...\}$ and $n >\ell$. The energy levels $E_{0,1}(\varkappa)$, $E_{0,2}(\varkappa)$, and $E_{1,2}(\varkappa)$ are also computed numerically and plotted versus $\varkappa^{-1}$. It is found that the BLTP theory predicts a non-relativistic correction to the splitting of the Lyman-$α$ line in addition to its well-known relativistic fine-structure splitting. Under the assumption, that this splitting doesn't go away in a relativistic calculation, it is argued that present-day precision measurements of the Lyman-$α$ line suggest that $\varkappa^{-1}$ must be smaller than $\approx 10^{-18}\,\mathrm{m}$. Finite proton size effects are found not to modify this conclusion. As a consequence, the electrostatic field energy of an elementary point charge, although finite in BLTP electrodynamics, is much larger than the empirical rest energy of an electron. If, as assumed in all `renormalized theories' of the electron, the empirical rest mass of a physical electron is the sum of its bare rest mass plus its electrostatic field energy ($/c^2$), then in BLTP electrodynamics the electron has to be assigned a negative bare rest mass.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2019; v1 submitted 22 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.