-
Center-symmetric Landau gauge, the deconfinement transition and the gluon propagator as seen in lattice QCD
Authors:
Duifje Maria van Egmond,
Orlando Oliveira,
Urko Reinosa,
Julien Serreau,
Paulo J. Silva,
Matthieu Tissier
Abstract:
We address the lattice computation of the gluon propagator in the center-symmetric Landau gauge. After discussing a proper lattice implementation of the center-symmetric Landau gauge, we compare the lattice data with analytical results, and we identify various signatures of center symmetry breaking.
We address the lattice computation of the gluon propagator in the center-symmetric Landau gauge. After discussing a proper lattice implementation of the center-symmetric Landau gauge, we compare the lattice data with analytical results, and we identify various signatures of center symmetry breaking.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
The center-symmetric Landau gauge meets the lattice
Authors:
Duifje Maria van Egmond,
Orlando Oliveira,
Urko Reinosa,
Julien Serreau,
Paulo J. Silva,
Matthieu Tissier
Abstract:
A lattice implementation of the recently introduced center-symmetric Landau gauge is discussed and its predictions confronted with numerical Monte Carlo simulations. It is shown that the link average and the link correlators computed in that gauge are order parameters of the confinement-deconfinement transition at nonzero temperature. Strictly speaking, this requires a specific treatment of the Gr…
▽ More
A lattice implementation of the recently introduced center-symmetric Landau gauge is discussed and its predictions confronted with numerical Monte Carlo simulations. It is shown that the link average and the link correlators computed in that gauge are order parameters of the confinement-deconfinement transition at nonzero temperature. Strictly speaking, this requires a specific treatment of the Gribov copies that we discuss in detail. The numerical simulations comply with the theoretical predictions for the link average computed below and above the deconfinement temperature. Our results show that, within appropriately chosen gauges, one can construct local order parameters for center symmetry, as proxies for the non-local Polyakov loop.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Working towards a gauge-invariant description of the Higgs model: from local composite operators to spectral density functions
Authors:
D. M. van Egmond
Abstract:
We analyze different BRST invariant solutions for the introduction of a mass term in Yang-Mills (YM) theories. First, we analyze the non-local composite gauge-invariant field $A^h_μ(x)$, which can be localized by the Stueckelberg-like field $ξ^a(x)$. This enables us to introduce a mass term in the $SU(N)$ YM model, a feature that has been indicated at a non-perturbative level by both analytical an…
▽ More
We analyze different BRST invariant solutions for the introduction of a mass term in Yang-Mills (YM) theories. First, we analyze the non-local composite gauge-invariant field $A^h_μ(x)$, which can be localized by the Stueckelberg-like field $ξ^a(x)$. This enables us to introduce a mass term in the $SU(N)$ YM model, a feature that has been indicated at a non-perturbative level by both analytical and numerical studies. We also consider the unitary Abelian Higgs model and investigate its spectral functions at one-loop order. This analysis allows to disentangle what is physical and what is not at the level of the elementary particle propagators, in conjunction with the Nielsen identities. We highlight the role of the tadpole graphs and the gauge choices to get sensible results. We also introduce an Abelian Curci-Ferrari action coupled to a scalar field to model a massive photon which, like the non-Abelian Curci-Ferarri model, is left invariant by a modified non-nilpotent BRST symmetry. Finally, the spectral properties of a set of local gauge-invariant composite operators are investigated in the $U(1)$ and $SU(2)$ Higgs model quantized in the 't Hooft $R_ξ$ gauge. These operators enable us to give a gauge-invariant description of the spectrum of the theory, thereby surpassing certain incommodities when using the standard elementary fields. The corresponding two-point correlation functions are evaluated at one-loop order and their spectral functions are obtained explicitly. It is shown that the spectral functions of the elementary fields suffer from a strong unphysical dependence from the gauge parameter $ξ$, and can even exhibit positivity violating behaviour. In contrast, the BRST invariant local operators exhibit a well defined positive spectral density.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
BRST invariant scalar and vector operators in the $SU\left(2\right)\times U\left(1\right)$ Higgs model
Authors:
David Dudal,
Duifje Maria van Egmond,
Giovani Peruzzo,
Silvio Paolo Sorella
Abstract:
We present a set of BRST invariant composite operators in the $SU\left(2\right)\times U\left(1\right)$ Higgs model which exhibit an overlap with the observable scalar and vector particle states of the theory. Some of these operators are non-local in the standard formulation of the Higgs model, however, we show that they can be localized using the Stuckelberg trick, this without changing the physic…
▽ More
We present a set of BRST invariant composite operators in the $SU\left(2\right)\times U\left(1\right)$ Higgs model which exhibit an overlap with the observable scalar and vector particle states of the theory. Some of these operators are non-local in the standard formulation of the Higgs model, however, we show that they can be localized using the Stuckelberg trick, this without changing the physical content. These operators provide thus a BRST invariant resolution of the physical spectrum of the theory, thereby giving the next step in constructing a manifestly BRST invariant formulation of the particle spectrum of the Electroweak and Standard model.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Center-symmetric Landau gauge: Further signatures of confinement
Authors:
Duifje Maria van Egmond,
Urko Reinosa
Abstract:
In a recent article [1], we have identified new signatures for the Yang-Mills deconfinement transition, based on the finite-temperature longitudinal or (chromo-)electric gluon propagator as computed in the center-symmetric Landau gauge. Here, we generalize these considerations into a systematic study of the center symmetry identities obeyed by the correlation functions in this gauge. Any violation…
▽ More
In a recent article [1], we have identified new signatures for the Yang-Mills deconfinement transition, based on the finite-temperature longitudinal or (chromo-)electric gluon propagator as computed in the center-symmetric Landau gauge. Here, we generalize these considerations into a systematic study of the center symmetry identities obeyed by the correlation functions in this gauge. Any violation of these constraints signals the breaking of center symmetry and can thus serve as a probe for the deconfinement transition.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Gauge fixing and physical symmetries
Authors:
Duifje Maria van Egmond,
Urko Reinosa
Abstract:
We analyze how gauge fixing, which is required by any practical continuum approach to gauge systems, can interfere with the physical symmetries of such systems. In principle, the gauge fixing procedure, which deals with the (unphysical) gauge symmetry, should not interfere with the other (physical) symmetries. In practice, however, there can be an interference which takes two different forms. Firs…
▽ More
We analyze how gauge fixing, which is required by any practical continuum approach to gauge systems, can interfere with the physical symmetries of such systems. In principle, the gauge fixing procedure, which deals with the (unphysical) gauge symmetry, should not interfere with the other (physical) symmetries. In practice, however, there can be an interference which takes two different forms. First, depending on the considered gauge, it might not always be simple or possible to devise approximation schemes that preserve the physical symmetry constraints on (gauge-independent) observables. Second, even at an exact level of discussion, the (gauge-dependent) effective action for the gauge field, and thus the related vertex functions, may not reflect the physical symmetries of the problem. We illustrate these difficulties using a very general class of gauge fixings that contains the usual gauge fixings as particular cases. Using background field techniques, we then propose specific gauge choices that allow one to keep the physical symmetries explicit, both at the level of the observables and at the level of the effective action for the gauge field. Our analysis is based on the notion of invariance modulo gauge transformations. This is not only a convenient framework to discuss symmetries in the presence of unphysical degrees of freedom, but it also allows one to reinterpret certain well known phenomena in gauge theories without the need to invoke the conceptually annoying ``breaking of a gauge symmetry''.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2024; v1 submitted 3 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Polyakov loop, gluon mass, gluon condensate and its asymmetry near deconfinement
Authors:
D. Dudal,
D. M. van Egmond,
U. Reinosa,
D. Vercauteren
Abstract:
We consider a BRST invariant generalization of the "massive background Landau gauge", resembling the original Curci-Ferrari model that saw a revived interest due to its phenomenological success in modeling infrared Yang-Mills dynamics, including that of the phase transition. Unlike the Curci-Ferrari model, however, the mass parameter is no longer a phenomenological input but it enters as a result…
▽ More
We consider a BRST invariant generalization of the "massive background Landau gauge", resembling the original Curci-Ferrari model that saw a revived interest due to its phenomenological success in modeling infrared Yang-Mills dynamics, including that of the phase transition. Unlike the Curci-Ferrari model, however, the mass parameter is no longer a phenomenological input but it enters as a result of dimensional transmutation via a BRST invariant dimension two gluon condensate. The associated renormalization constant is dealt with using Zimmermann's reduction of constants program which fixes the value of the mass parameter to values close to those obtained within the Curci-Ferrari approach. Using a self-consistent background field, we can include the Polyakov loop and probe the deconfinement transition, including its interplay with the condensate and its electric-magnetic asymmetry. We report a continuous phase transition at Tc ~ 0.230 GeV in the SU(2) case and a first order one at Tc ~ 0.164 GeV in the SU(3) case, values which are again rather close to those obtained within the Curci-Ferrari model at one-loop order.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2022; v1 submitted 13 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Signatures of the Yang-Mills deconfinement transition from the gluon two-point correlator
Authors:
Duifje Maria van Egmond,
Urko Reinosa
Abstract:
We evaluate the longitudinal or (chromo-)electric Yang-Mills gluon propagator in the recently proposed center-symmetric Landau gauge at finite temperature [1]. To model the effect of the Gribov copies in the infrared, we use the Curci-Ferrari model which, in turn, allows us to rely on perturbative calculations. At one-loop order in the SU(2) case, the so-obtained longitudinal gluon propagator prov…
▽ More
We evaluate the longitudinal or (chromo-)electric Yang-Mills gluon propagator in the recently proposed center-symmetric Landau gauge at finite temperature [1]. To model the effect of the Gribov copies in the infrared, we use the Curci-Ferrari model which, in turn, allows us to rely on perturbative calculations. At one-loop order in the SU(2) case, the so-obtained longitudinal gluon propagator provides a clear signature for Z2 center-symmetry breaking with a singular behavior, characteristic of a continuous phase transition. This is in sharp contrast with what is found within the standard Landau gauge. We also identify various signatures for Z3 center-symmetry breaking in the SU(3) case in the form of genuine order parameters. Among those, we find that the gluon propagator, although degenerate along the diagonal color directions in the confining phase, becomes non-degenerate in the deconfined phase. Our results open new ways of identifying the transition from correlation functions both within continuum approaches and on the lattice.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Gauge Invariant Description of the $SU(2)$ Higgs model: Ward identities and Renormalization
Authors:
David Dudal,
Duifje Maria van Egmond,
Igor Figueiredo Justo,
Giovani Peruzzo,
Silvio Paolo Sorella
Abstract:
The renormalization properties of two local gauge invariant composite operators $(O,R^a_μ)$ corresponding, respectively, to the gauge invariant description of the Higgs particle and of the massive gauge vector boson, are analyzed to all orders in perturbation theory by means of the algebraic renormalization in the $SU(2)$ Higgs model, with a single scalar in the fundamental representation, when qu…
▽ More
The renormalization properties of two local gauge invariant composite operators $(O,R^a_μ)$ corresponding, respectively, to the gauge invariant description of the Higgs particle and of the massive gauge vector boson, are analyzed to all orders in perturbation theory by means of the algebraic renormalization in the $SU(2)$ Higgs model, with a single scalar in the fundamental representation, when quantized in the Landau gauge in Euclidean space-time. The present analysis generalizes earlier results presented in the case of the $U(1)$ Higgs model. A powerful global Ward identity, related to an exact custodial symmetry, is derived for the first time, with deep consequences at the quantum level. In particular, the gauge invariant vector operators $R^a_μ$ turn out to be the conserved Noether currents of the above-mentioned custodial symmetry. As such, these composite operators do not renormalize, as expressed by the fact that the renormalization $Z$-factors of the corresponding external sources, needed to define the operators $R^a_μ$ at the quantum level, do not receive any quantum corrections. Another consistency feature of our analysis is that the longitudinal component of the two-point correlation function $\langle R^a_μ(p) R^b_ν(-p) \rangle$ exhibits only a tree level non-vanishing contribution which, moreover, is momentum independent, being thus not associated to any physical propagating mode. Finally, we point out that the renowned non-renormalization theorem for the ghost-antighost-vector boson vertex in Landau gauge remains true to all orders, also in presence of the Higgs field.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
SU($N$) Cartan-Weyl bases and color factors
Authors:
Duifje Maria van Egmond,
Urko Reinosa
Abstract:
Constant temporal backgrounds have become a convenient tool for the discussion of continuum non-abelian gauge theories at finite temperature, as they provide a grasp on the confinement/deconfinement transition. It has been pointed that such backgrounds are better dealt with within so-called Cartan-Weyl color bases, rather than within the standard Cartesian bases. Here, we discuss the specificities…
▽ More
Constant temporal backgrounds have become a convenient tool for the discussion of continuum non-abelian gauge theories at finite temperature, as they provide a grasp on the confinement/deconfinement transition. It has been pointed that such backgrounds are better dealt with within so-called Cartan-Weyl color bases, rather than within the standard Cartesian bases. Here, we discuss the specificities of the evaluation of SU($N$) color factors within these bases, extending the discussion in Ref. [1].
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
A novel background field approach to the confinement-deconfinement transition
Authors:
Duifje Maria van Egmond,
Urko Reinosa,
Julien Serreau,
Matthieu Tissier
Abstract:
We propose a novel approach to the confinement-deconfinement transition in Yang-Mills theories in the context of gauge-fixed calculations. The method is based on a background-field generalisation of the Landau gauge (to which it reduces at vanishing temperature) with a given, center-symmetric background. This is to be contrasted with most implementations of background field methods in gauge theori…
▽ More
We propose a novel approach to the confinement-deconfinement transition in Yang-Mills theories in the context of gauge-fixed calculations. The method is based on a background-field generalisation of the Landau gauge (to which it reduces at vanishing temperature) with a given, center-symmetric background. This is to be contrasted with most implementations of background field methods in gauge theories, where one uses a variable, self-consistent background. Our proposal is a bona fide gauge fixing that can easily be implemented on the lattice and in continuum approaches. The resulting gauge-fixed action explicitly exhibits the center symmetry of the nonzero temperature theory that controls the confinement-deconfinement transition. We show that, in that gauge, the electric susceptibility diverges at a second order transition [e.g., in the SU(2) theory], so that the gluon propagator is a clear probe of the transition. We implement our proposal in the perturbative Curci-Ferrari model, known for its successful description of various infrared aspects of Yang-Mills theories, including the confinement-deconfinement transition. Our one-loop calculation confirms our general expectation for the susceptibility while providing transition temperatures in excellent agreement with the SU(2) and SU(3) lattice values. Finally, the Polyakov loops above the transition show a more moderate rise, in contrast to previous implementations of the Curci-Ferrari model using a self-consistent background, and our SU(3) result agrees quite well with lattice results in the range $[0,2T_c]$.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2021; v1 submitted 18 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Spectral properties of local gauge invariant composite operators in the $SU(2)$ Yang--Mills--Higgs model
Authors:
D. Dudal,
D. M. van Egmond,
M. S. Guimaraes,
L. F. Palhares,
G. Peruzzo,
S. P. Sorella
Abstract:
The spectral properties of a set of local gauge (BRST) invariant composite operators are investigated in the $SU(2)$ Yang--Mills--Higgs model with a single Higgs field in the fundamental representation, quantized in the 't Hooft $R_ξ$-gauge. These operators can be thought of as a BRST invariant version of the elementary fields of the theory, the Higgs and gauge fields, with which they share a gaug…
▽ More
The spectral properties of a set of local gauge (BRST) invariant composite operators are investigated in the $SU(2)$ Yang--Mills--Higgs model with a single Higgs field in the fundamental representation, quantized in the 't Hooft $R_ξ$-gauge. These operators can be thought of as a BRST invariant version of the elementary fields of the theory, the Higgs and gauge fields, with which they share a gauge independent pole mass. The two-point correlation functions of both BRST invariant composite operators and elementary fields, as well as their spectral functions, are investigated at one-loop order. It is shown that the spectral functions of the elementary fields suffer from a strong unphysical dependence from the gauge parameter $ξ$, and can even exhibit positivity violating behaviour. In contrast, the BRST invariant local operators exhibit a well defined positive spectral density.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2020; v1 submitted 18 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
The scalar sunset diagram at finite temperature with imaginary square masses
Authors:
Duifje Maria van Egmond,
Urko Reinosa
Abstract:
We evaluate the finite temperature scalar sunset diagram with imaginary square masses, that appears in the Gribov-Zwanziger approach to Yang-Mills (YM) theory beyond one-loop order. Since YM theory at finite temperature is governed by center-symmetry and the Polyakov loop, we also include the possibility of a constant temporal background gauge field in the form of color-dependent imaginary chemica…
▽ More
We evaluate the finite temperature scalar sunset diagram with imaginary square masses, that appears in the Gribov-Zwanziger approach to Yang-Mills (YM) theory beyond one-loop order. Since YM theory at finite temperature is governed by center-symmetry and the Polyakov loop, we also include the possibility of a constant temporal background gauge field in the form of color-dependent imaginary chemical potentials.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Gauge-invariant spectral description of the $U(1)$ Higgs model from local composite operators
Authors:
David Dudal,
Duive Maria van Egmond,
Marcelo Santos Guimaraes,
Ozorio Holanda,
Leticia F. Palhares,
Giovani Peruzzo,
Silvio Paolo Sorella
Abstract:
The spectral properties of a set of local gauge-invariant composite operators are investigated in the $U(1)$ Higgs model quantized in the 't Hooft $R_ξ$ gauge. These operators enable us to give a gauge-invariant description of the spectrum of the theory, thereby surpassing certain incommodities when using the standard elementary fields. The corresponding two-point correlation functions are evaluat…
▽ More
The spectral properties of a set of local gauge-invariant composite operators are investigated in the $U(1)$ Higgs model quantized in the 't Hooft $R_ξ$ gauge. These operators enable us to give a gauge-invariant description of the spectrum of the theory, thereby surpassing certain incommodities when using the standard elementary fields. The corresponding two-point correlation functions are evaluated at one-loop order and their spectral functions are obtained explicitly. As expected, the above mentioned correlation functions are independent from the gauge parameter $ξ$, while exhibiting positive spectral densities as well as gauge-invariant pole masses corresponding to the massive photon and Higgs physical excitations.
△ Less
Submitted 24 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Some remarks on the spectral functions of the Abelian Higgs Model
Authors:
D. Dudal,
D. M. van Egmond,
M. S. Guimaraes,
O. Holanda,
B. W. Mintz,
L. F. Palhares,
G. Peruzzo,
S. P. Sorella
Abstract:
We consider the unitary Abelian Higgs model and investigate its spectral functions at one-loop order. This analysis allows to disentangle what is physical and what is not at the level of the elementary particle propagators, in conjunction with the Nielsen identities. We highlight the role of the tadpole graphs and the gauge choices to get sensible results. We also introduce an Abelian Curci-Ferrar…
▽ More
We consider the unitary Abelian Higgs model and investigate its spectral functions at one-loop order. This analysis allows to disentangle what is physical and what is not at the level of the elementary particle propagators, in conjunction with the Nielsen identities. We highlight the role of the tadpole graphs and the gauge choices to get sensible results. We also introduce an Abelian Curci-Ferrari action coupled to a scalar field to model a massive photon which, like the non-Abelian Curci-Ferarri model, is left invariant by a modified non-nilpotent BRST symmetry. We clearly illustrate its non-unitary nature directly from the spectral function viewpoint. This provides a functional analogue of the Ojima observation in the canonical formalism: there are ghost states with nonzero norm in the BRST-invariant states of the Curci-Ferrari model.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Renormalizability of $\mathcal{N}=1$ super Yang-Mills theory in Landau gauge with a Stueckelberg-like field
Authors:
M. A. L. Capri,
D. M. van Egmond,
M. S. Guimaraes,
O. Holanda,
S. P. Sorella,
R. C. Terin,
H. C. Toledo
Abstract:
We construct a vector gauge invariant transverse field configuration $V^H$, consisting of the well-known superfield $V$ and of a Stueckelberg-like chiral superfield. The renormalizability of the Super Yang Mills action in the Landau gauge is analyzed in the presence of a gauge invariant mass term $m^2 \int dV \mathcal{M}(V^H)$, with $\mathcal{M}(V^H)$ a power series in $V^H$. Unlike the original S…
▽ More
We construct a vector gauge invariant transverse field configuration $V^H$, consisting of the well-known superfield $V$ and of a Stueckelberg-like chiral superfield. The renormalizability of the Super Yang Mills action in the Landau gauge is analyzed in the presence of a gauge invariant mass term $m^2 \int dV \mathcal{M}(V^H)$, with $\mathcal{M}(V^H)$ a power series in $V^H$. Unlike the original Stueckelberg action, the resulting action turns out to be renormalizable to all orders.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2018; v1 submitted 8 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
On a renormalizable class of gauge fixings for the gauge invariant operator $A_{\min }^{2}$
Authors:
M. A. L. Capri,
D. M. van Egmond,
G. Peruzzo,
M. S. Guimaraes,
O. Holanda,
S. P. Sorella,
R. C. Terin,
H. C. Toledo
Abstract:
The dimension two gauge invariant non-local operator $A_{\min }^{2}$, obtained through the minimization of $\int d^4x A^2$ along the gauge orbit, allows to introduce a non-local gauge invariant configuration $A^h_μ$ which can be employed to built up a class of Euclidean massive Yang-Mills models useful to investigate non-perturbative infrared effects of confining theories. A fully local setup for…
▽ More
The dimension two gauge invariant non-local operator $A_{\min }^{2}$, obtained through the minimization of $\int d^4x A^2$ along the gauge orbit, allows to introduce a non-local gauge invariant configuration $A^h_μ$ which can be employed to built up a class of Euclidean massive Yang-Mills models useful to investigate non-perturbative infrared effects of confining theories. A fully local setup for both $A_{\min }^{2}$ and $A^{h}_μ$ can be achieved, resulting in a local and BRST invariant action which shares similarities with the Stueckelberg formalism. Though, unlike the case of the Stueckelberg action, the use of $A_{\min }^{2}$ gives rise to an all orders renormalizable action, a feature which will be illustrated by means of a class of covariant gauge fixings which, as much as 't Hooft's $R_ζ$-gauge of spontaneously broken gauge theories, provide a mass for the Stueckelberg field.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
