-
Finite-temperature bubble nucleation with shifting scale hierarchies
Authors:
Maciej Kierkla,
Philipp Schicho,
Bogumila Swiezewska,
Tuomas V. I. Tenkanen,
Jorinde van de Vis
Abstract:
Focusing on supercooled phase transitions in models with classical scale symmetry, we formulate a state-of-the art framework for computing the bubble-nucleation rate, accounting for the presence of various energy scales. In particular, we examine the limitations of derivative expansions in constructing a thermal effective field theory for bubble nucleation. We show that for gauge field fluctuation…
▽ More
Focusing on supercooled phase transitions in models with classical scale symmetry, we formulate a state-of-the art framework for computing the bubble-nucleation rate, accounting for the presence of various energy scales. In particular, we examine the limitations of derivative expansions in constructing a thermal effective field theory for bubble nucleation. We show that for gauge field fluctuations, derivative expansions diverge after the leading two orders due to the strong variation in gauge field masses between the high- and low-temperature phases. By directly computing these contributions using the fluctuation determinant, we capture these effects while also accounting for large explicit logarithms at two loops, utilising the exact renormalisation group structure of the EFT. Finally, we demonstrate how this approach significantly improves nucleation rate calculations compared to leading-order results, providing a more robust framework for predicting gravitational-wave signals from supercooled phase transitions in models such as the SU(2)cSM.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Radiative symmetry breaking from the on-shell perspective
Authors:
Bartosz Sojka,
Bogumila Swiezewska
Abstract:
Models with classical scale symmetry, which feature radiative symmetry breaking, generically lead to a supercooled first-order phase transition in the early Universe resulting in a strong gravitational-wave signal, potentially observable by LISA. This is thanks to the absence of mass terms in the potential and the resulting logarithmic structure of the zero-temperature effective potential. It is k…
▽ More
Models with classical scale symmetry, which feature radiative symmetry breaking, generically lead to a supercooled first-order phase transition in the early Universe resulting in a strong gravitational-wave signal, potentially observable by LISA. This is thanks to the absence of mass terms in the potential and the resulting logarithmic structure of the zero-temperature effective potential. It is known that imposing a symmetry at classical level does not prohibit breaking it by quantum corrections. In the case of scale symmetry, a mass term can in principle appear through renormalisation. This is not the case in the commonly used $\overline{\mathrm{MS}}$ or Coleman-Weinberg schemes. In this work, we renormalise a scale-invariant model in the on-shell scheme to check whether parameterising it with the physical masses will introduce mass terms to the potential. We find that indeed mass terms appear for an arbitrary choice of the physical masses. However, we formulate an on-shell condition for radiative symmetry breaking, sufficient and necessary for the cancellation of mass terms in the renormalised potential, yielding a logarithmic potential needed for supercooled phase transitions.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2024; v1 submitted 10 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Scale-Invariant Model for Gravitational Waves and Dark Matter
Authors:
Alexandros Karam,
Maciej Kierkla,
Bogumiła Świeżewska
Abstract:
We have conducted a revised analysis of the first-order phase transition that is associated with symmetry breaking in a classically scale-invariant model that has been extended with a new $SU(2)$ gauge group. By incorporating recent developments in the understanding of supercooled phase transitions, we were able to calculate all of its features and significantly limit the parameter space. We were…
▽ More
We have conducted a revised analysis of the first-order phase transition that is associated with symmetry breaking in a classically scale-invariant model that has been extended with a new $SU(2)$ gauge group. By incorporating recent developments in the understanding of supercooled phase transitions, we were able to calculate all of its features and significantly limit the parameter space. We were also able to predict the gravitational wave spectra generated during this phase transition and found that this model is well-testable with LISA. Additionally, we have made predictions regarding the relic dark matter abundance. Our predictions are consistent with observations but only within a narrow part of the parameter space. We have placed significant constraints on the supercool dark matter scenario by improving the description of percolation and reheating after the phase transition, as well as including the running of couplings. Finally, we have also analyzed the renormalization-scale dependence of our results.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Conformal model for gravitational waves and dark matter: A status update
Authors:
Maciej Kierkla,
Alexandros Karam,
Bogumila Swiezewska
Abstract:
We present an updated analysis of the first-order phase transition associated with symmetry breaking in the early Universe in a classically scale-invariant model extended with a new SU(2) gauge group. Including recent developments in understanding supercooled phase transitions, we compute all of its characteristics and significantly constrain the parameter space. We then predict gravitational wave…
▽ More
We present an updated analysis of the first-order phase transition associated with symmetry breaking in the early Universe in a classically scale-invariant model extended with a new SU(2) gauge group. Including recent developments in understanding supercooled phase transitions, we compute all of its characteristics and significantly constrain the parameter space. We then predict gravitational wave spectra generated during this phase transition and by computing the signal-to-noise ratio we conclude that this model is well testable (and falsifiable) with LISA. We also provide predictions for the relic dark matter abundance. It is consistent with observations in a rather narrow part of the parameter space, since we exclude the so-called supercool dark matter scenario based on an improved description of percolation and reheating after the phase transition as well as inclusion of the running of couplings. Finally, we devote attention to renormalisation-scale dependence of the results. Even though our main results are obtained with the use of renormalisation-group improved effective potential, we also perform a fixed-scale analysis which proves that the dependence on the scale is not only qualitative but also quantitative.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2023; v1 submitted 13 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Field-theoretic derivation of bubble-wall force
Authors:
Marc Barroso Mancha,
Tomislav Prokopec,
Bogumila Swiezewska
Abstract:
We derive a general quantum field theoretic formula for the force acting on expanding bubbles of a first order phase transition in the early Universe setting. In the thermodynamic limit the force is proportional to the entropy increase across the bubble of active species that exert a force on the bubble interface. When local thermal equilibrium is attained, we find a strong friction force which gr…
▽ More
We derive a general quantum field theoretic formula for the force acting on expanding bubbles of a first order phase transition in the early Universe setting. In the thermodynamic limit the force is proportional to the entropy increase across the bubble of active species that exert a force on the bubble interface. When local thermal equilibrium is attained, we find a strong friction force which grows as the Lorentz factor squared, such that the bubbles quickly reach stationary state and cannot run away. We also study an opposite case when scatterings are negligible across the wall (ballistic limit), finding that the force saturates for moderate Lorentz factors thus allowing for a runaway behavior. We apply our formalism to a massive real scalar field, the standard model and its simple portal extension. For completeness, we also present a derivation of the renormalized, one-loop, thermal energy-momentum tensor for the standard model and demonstrate its gauge independence.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2021; v1 submitted 21 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Gravitational waves from conformal symmetry breaking
Authors:
Tomislav Prokopec,
Jonas Rezacek,
Bogumila Swiezewska
Abstract:
We consider the electroweak phase transition in the conformal extension of the standard model known as SU(2)cSM. Apart from the standard model particles, this model contains an additional scalar and gauge field that are both charged under the hidden SU(2)$_X$. This model generically exhibits a very strong phase transition that proceeds after a large amount of supercooling. We estimate the gravitat…
▽ More
We consider the electroweak phase transition in the conformal extension of the standard model known as SU(2)cSM. Apart from the standard model particles, this model contains an additional scalar and gauge field that are both charged under the hidden SU(2)$_X$. This model generically exhibits a very strong phase transition that proceeds after a large amount of supercooling. We estimate the gravitational wave spectrum produced in this model and show that its amplitude and frequency fall within the observational window of LISA. We also discuss potential pitfalls and relevant points of improvement required to attain reliable estimates of the gravitational wave production in this - as well as in more general - class of models. In order to improve perturbativity during the early stages of transition that ends with bubble nucleation, we solve a thermal gap equation in the scalar sector inspired by the 2PI effective action formalism.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2019; v1 submitted 28 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Systematic analysis of radiative symmetry breaking in models with extended scalar sector
Authors:
Leonardo Chataignier,
Tomislav Prokopec,
Michael G. Schmidt,
Bogumila Swiezewska
Abstract:
Radiative symmetry breaking (RSB) is a theoretically appealing framework for the generation of mass scales through quantum effects. It can be successfully implemented in models with extended scalar and gauge sectors. We provide a systematic analysis of RSB in such models: we review the common approximative methods of studying RSB, emphasising their limits of applicability and discuss the relevance…
▽ More
Radiative symmetry breaking (RSB) is a theoretically appealing framework for the generation of mass scales through quantum effects. It can be successfully implemented in models with extended scalar and gauge sectors. We provide a systematic analysis of RSB in such models: we review the common approximative methods of studying RSB, emphasising their limits of applicability and discuss the relevance of the relative magnitudes of tree-level and loop contributions as well as the dependence of the results on the renormalisation scale. The general considerations are exemplified within the context of the conformal Standard Model extended with a scalar doublet of a new SU(2)$_X$ gauge group, the so-called SU(2)cSM. We show that various perturbative methods of studying RSB may yield significantly different results due to renormalisation-scale dependence. Implementing the renormalisation-group (RG) improvement method recently developed in arXiv:1801.05258, which is well-suited for multi-scale models, we argue that the use of the RG improved effective potential can alleviate this scale dependence providing more reliable results.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2018; v1 submitted 23 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Conformal symmetry and the cosmological constant problem
Authors:
Stefano Lucat,
Tomislav Prokopec,
Bogumila Swiezewska
Abstract:
We argue that, when a theory of gravity and matter is endowed with (classical) conformal symmetry, the fine tuning required to obtain the cosmological constant at its observed value can be significantly reduced. Once tuned, the cosmological constant is stable under a change of the scale at which it is measured.
We argue that, when a theory of gravity and matter is endowed with (classical) conformal symmetry, the fine tuning required to obtain the cosmological constant at its observed value can be significantly reduced. Once tuned, the cosmological constant is stable under a change of the scale at which it is measured.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2018; v1 submitted 3 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Single-scale Renormalisation Group Improvement of Multi-scale Effective Potentials
Authors:
Leonardo Chataignier,
Tomislav Prokopec,
Michael G. Schmidt,
Bogumila Swiezewska
Abstract:
We present a new method for renormalisation group improvement of the effective potential of a quantum field theory with an arbitrary number of scalar fields. The method amounts to solving the renormalisation group equation for the effective potential with the boundary conditions chosen on the hypersurface where quantum corrections vanish. This hypersurface is defined through a suitable choice of a…
▽ More
We present a new method for renormalisation group improvement of the effective potential of a quantum field theory with an arbitrary number of scalar fields. The method amounts to solving the renormalisation group equation for the effective potential with the boundary conditions chosen on the hypersurface where quantum corrections vanish. This hypersurface is defined through a suitable choice of a field-dependent value for the renormalisation scale. The method can be applied to any order in perturbation theory and it is a generalisation of the standard procedure valid for the one-field case. In our method, however, the choice of the renormalisation scale does not eliminate individual logarithmic terms but rather the entire loop corrections to the effective potential. It allows us to evaluate the improved effective potential for arbitrary values of the scalar fields using the tree-level potential with running coupling constants as long as they remain perturbative. This opens the possibility of studying various applications which require an analysis of multi-field effective potentials across different energy scales. In particular, the issue of stability of the scalar potential can be easily studied beyond tree level.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2018; v1 submitted 16 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
