Showing 1–50 of 74 results for author: Rychkov, S

Exact Diagonalization, Matrix Product States and Conformal Perturbation Theory Study of a 3D Ising Fuzzy Sphere Model

Authors: Andreas M. Läuchli, Loïc Herviou, Patrick H. Wilhelm, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: Numerical studies of phase transitions in statistical and quantum lattice models provide crucial insights into the corresponding Conformal Field Theories (CFTs). In higher dimensions, comparing finite-volume numerical results to infinite-volume CFT data is facilitated by choosing the sphere $S^{d-1}$ as the spatial manifold. Recently, the fuzzy sphere regulator in Ref. [Zhu et al, Phys. Rev. X 13… ▽ More Numerical studies of phase transitions in statistical and quantum lattice models provide crucial insights into the corresponding Conformal Field Theories (CFTs). In higher dimensions, comparing finite-volume numerical results to infinite-volume CFT data is facilitated by choosing the sphere $S^{d-1}$ as the spatial manifold. Recently, the fuzzy sphere regulator in Ref. [Zhu et al, Phys. Rev. X 13 021009 (2023)] has enabled such studies with exact rotational invariance, yielding impressive agreement with known 3D Ising CFT predictions, as well as new results. However, systematic improvements and a deeper understanding of finite-size corrections remain essential. In this work, we revisit the fuzzy sphere regulator, focusing on the original Ising model, with two main goals. First, we assess the robustness of this approach using Conformal Perturbation Theory (CPT), to which we provide a detailed guidebook. We demonstrate how CPT provides a unified framework for determining the critical point, the speed of light, and residual deviations from CFT predictions. Applying this framework, we study finite-size corrections and clarify the role of tuning the model in minimizing these effects. Second, we develop a novel method for extracting Operator Product Expansion (OPE) coefficients from fuzzy sphere data. This method leverages the sensitivity of energy levels to detuning from criticality, providing new insights into level mixing and avoided crossings in finite systems. Our work also includes validation of CPT in a 1+1D Ising model away from the integrable limit. △ Less

Submitted 1 April, 2025; originally announced April 2025.

Comments: 51 pages, 12 figures, comments welcome

Transfer Matrix and Lattice Dilatation Operator for High-Quality Fixed Points in Tensor Network Renormalization Group

Authors: Nikolay Ebel, Tom Kennedy, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: Tensor network renormalization group maps study critical points of 2d lattice models like the Ising model by finding the fixed point of the RG map. In a prior work arXiv:2408.10312 we showed that by adding a rotation to the RG map, the Newton method could be implemented to find an extremely accurate fixed point. For a particular RG map (Gilt-TNR) we studied the spectrum of the Jacobian of the RG m… ▽ More Tensor network renormalization group maps study critical points of 2d lattice models like the Ising model by finding the fixed point of the RG map. In a prior work arXiv:2408.10312 we showed that by adding a rotation to the RG map, the Newton method could be implemented to find an extremely accurate fixed point. For a particular RG map (Gilt-TNR) we studied the spectrum of the Jacobian of the RG map at the fixed point and found good agreement between the eigenvalues corresponding to relevant and marginal operators and their known exact values. In this companion work we use two further methods to extract many more scaling dimensions from this Newton method fixed point, and compare the numerical results with the predictions of conformal field theory (CFT). The first method is the well-known transfer matrix. We introduce some extensions of this method that provide spins of the CFT operators modulo an integer. We find good agreement for the scaling dimensions and spins up to $Δ=3\frac1 8$. The second method we refer to as the lattice dilatation operator (LDO). This lesser-known method obtains good agreement with CFT up to $Δ=6$. Moreover, the inclusion of a rotation in the RG map makes it possible to extract spins of the CFT operators modulo 4 from this method. Some of the eigenvalues of the Jacobian of the RG map can come from perturbations associated with total derivative interactions and so are not universal. In some past studies (arXiv:2102.08136, arXiv:2305.09899) such non-universal eigenvalues did not appear in the Jacobian. We explain this surprising result by showing that their RG map has the unusual property that the Jacobian is equivalent to the LDO operator. △ Less

Submitted 7 October, 2024; v1 submitted 19 September, 2024; originally announced September 2024.

Comments: 25+13 pages, 5 tables, 6 figures, data in ancillary files

Rotations, Negative Eigenvalues, and Newton Method in Tensor Network Renormalization Group

Authors: Nikolay Ebel, Tom Kennedy, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: In the tensor network approach to statistical physics, properties of the critical point of a 2D lattice model are encoded by a four-legged tensor which is a fixed point of an RG map. The traditional way to find the fixed point tensor consists in iterating the RG map after having tuned the temperature to criticality. Here we develop a different and more direct technique, which solves the fixed poin… ▽ More In the tensor network approach to statistical physics, properties of the critical point of a 2D lattice model are encoded by a four-legged tensor which is a fixed point of an RG map. The traditional way to find the fixed point tensor consists in iterating the RG map after having tuned the temperature to criticality. Here we develop a different and more direct technique, which solves the fixed point equation via the Newton method. This is challenging due to the existence of marginal deformations -- linear transformations of the coordinate frame, which parametrize a two-dimensional family of fixed points. We address this challenge by including a 90 degree rotation into the RG map. This flips the sign of the problematic marginal eigenvalues, rendering the fixed point isolated and accessible via the Newton method. We demonstrate the power of this technique via explicit computations for the 2D Ising and 3-state Potts models. Using the Gilt-TNR algorithm at bond dimension $χ=30$, we find the fixed point tensors with $10^{-9}$ accuracy, much higher than what was previously achieved. △ Less

Submitted 16 January, 2025; v1 submitted 19 August, 2024; originally announced August 2024.

Comments: 37+24 pages, 16 figures, 7 tables. Version 4: 3-state Potts model discussion was added; discussions of CFT and RG were extended; discussion of Jacobian approximations was rearranged and extended; many clarifying comments were added

Bootstrapping frustrated magnets: the fate of the chiral ${\rm O}(N)\times {\rm O}(2)$ universality class

Authors: Marten Reehorst, Slava Rychkov, Benoit Sirois, Balt C. van Rees

Abstract: We study multiscalar theories with $\text{O}(N) \times \text{O}(2)$ symmetry. These models have a stable fixed point in $d$ dimensions if $N$ is greater than some critical value $N_c(d)$. Previous estimates of this critical value from perturbative and non-perturbative renormalization group methods have produced mutually incompatible results. We use numerical conformal bootstrap methods to constrai… ▽ More We study multiscalar theories with $\text{O}(N) \times \text{O}(2)$ symmetry. These models have a stable fixed point in $d$ dimensions if $N$ is greater than some critical value $N_c(d)$. Previous estimates of this critical value from perturbative and non-perturbative renormalization group methods have produced mutually incompatible results. We use numerical conformal bootstrap methods to constrain $N_c(d)$ for $3 \leq d < 4$. Our results show that $N_c> 3.78$ for $d = 3$. This favors the scenario that the physically relevant models with $N = 2,3$ in $d=3$ do not have a stable fixed point, indicating a first-order transition. Our result exemplifies how conformal windows can be rigorously constrained with modern numerical bootstrap algorithms. △ Less

Submitted 6 January, 2025; v1 submitted 29 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: 48 pages, 15 figures ; Added references

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 18, 060 (2025)

Non-trivial fixed point of a $ψ^4_d$ fermionic theory, II. Anomalous exponent and scaling operators

Authors: Alessandro Giuliani, Vieri Mastropietro, Slava Rychkov, Giuseppe Scola

Abstract: We consider the Renormalization Group (RG) fixed-point theory associated with a fermionic $ψ^4_d$ model in $d=1,2,3$ with fractional kinetic term, whose scaling dimension is fixed so that the quartic interaction is weakly relevant in the RG sense. The model is defined in terms of a Grassmann functional integral with interaction $V^*$, solving a fixed-point RG equation in the presence of external f… ▽ More We consider the Renormalization Group (RG) fixed-point theory associated with a fermionic $ψ^4_d$ model in $d=1,2,3$ with fractional kinetic term, whose scaling dimension is fixed so that the quartic interaction is weakly relevant in the RG sense. The model is defined in terms of a Grassmann functional integral with interaction $V^*$, solving a fixed-point RG equation in the presence of external fields, and a fixed ultraviolet cutoff. We define and construct the field and density scale-invariant response functions, and prove that the critical exponent of the former is the naive one, while that of the latter is anomalous and analytic. We construct the corresponding (almost-)scaling operators, whose two point correlations are scale-invariant up to a remainder term, which decays like a stretched exponential at distances larger than the inverse of the ultraviolet cutoff. Our proof is based on constructive RG methods and, specifically, on a convergent tree expansion for the generating function of correlations, which generalizes the approach developed by three of the authors in a previous publication [A. Giuliani, V. Mastropietro, S. Rychkov, JHEP 01 (2021) 026]. △ Less

Submitted 23 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: 56 pages, 11 figures

New Developments in the Numerical Conformal Bootstrap

Authors: Slava Rychkov, Ning Su

Abstract: The numerical conformal bootstrap has become in the last 15 years an indispensable tool for studying strongly coupled CFTs in various dimensions. Here we review the main developments in the field in the last 5 years, since the appearance of the previous comprehensive review \cite{Poland:2018epd}. We describe developments in the software ({\tt SDPB 2.0}, {\tt scalar\_blocks}, {\tt blocks\_3d}, {\tt… ▽ More The numerical conformal bootstrap has become in the last 15 years an indispensable tool for studying strongly coupled CFTs in various dimensions. Here we review the main developments in the field in the last 5 years, since the appearance of the previous comprehensive review \cite{Poland:2018epd}. We describe developments in the software ({\tt SDPB 2.0}, {\tt scalar\_blocks}, {\tt blocks\_3d}, {\tt autoboot}, {\tt hyperion}, {\tt simpleboot}), and on the algorithmic side (Delauney triangulation, cutting surface, tiptop, navigator function, skydive). We also describe the main physics applications which were obtained using the new technology. △ Less

Submitted 11 November, 2024; v1 submitted 27 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Comments: 49 pages, 11 figures. Version to appear in Rev.Mod.Phys. Typos fixed

Scale without Conformal Invariance in Dipolar Ferromagnets

Authors: Aleix Gimenez-Grau, Yu Nakayama, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: We revisit critical phenomena in isotropic ferromagnets with strong dipolar interactions. The corresponding RG fixed point - dipolar fixed point - was first studied in 1973 by Aharony and Fisher. It is distinct from the Heisenberg fixed point, although the critical exponents are close. On the theoretical side, we discuss scale invariance without conformal invariance realized by this fixed point. W… ▽ More We revisit critical phenomena in isotropic ferromagnets with strong dipolar interactions. The corresponding RG fixed point - dipolar fixed point - was first studied in 1973 by Aharony and Fisher. It is distinct from the Heisenberg fixed point, although the critical exponents are close. On the theoretical side, we discuss scale invariance without conformal invariance realized by this fixed point. We elucidate the non-renormalization of the virial current due to a shift symmetry, and show that the same mechanism is at work in all other known local fixed points which are scale but not conformal invariant. On the phenomenological side, we discuss the relative strength of dipolar and short-range interactions. In some materials, like the europium compounds, dipolar interactions are strong, and the critical behavior is dipolar. In others, like Fe or Ni, dipolar interactions are weaker, and the Heisenberg critical behavior in a range of temperatures is followed by the dipolar behavior closer to the critical point. Some of these effects have been seen experimentally. △ Less

Submitted 22 September, 2023; v1 submitted 5 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Comments: 28 pages + 15 pages appendix, 2 figures

Report number: YITP-23-107

3D Ising CFT and Exact Diagonalization on Icosahedron: The Power of Conformal Perturbation Theory

Authors: Bing-Xin Lao, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: We consider the transverse field Ising model in $(2+1)$D, putting 12 spins at the vertices of the regular icosahedron. The model is tiny by the exact diagonalization standards, and breaks rotation invariance. Yet we show that it allows a meaningful comparison to the 3D Ising CFT on $\mathbb{R}\times S^2$, by including effective perturbations of the CFT Hamiltonian with a handful of local operators… ▽ More We consider the transverse field Ising model in $(2+1)$D, putting 12 spins at the vertices of the regular icosahedron. The model is tiny by the exact diagonalization standards, and breaks rotation invariance. Yet we show that it allows a meaningful comparison to the 3D Ising CFT on $\mathbb{R}\times S^2$, by including effective perturbations of the CFT Hamiltonian with a handful of local operators. This extreme example shows the power of conformal perturbation theory in understanding finite $N$ effects in models on regularized $S^2$. Its ideal arena of application should be the recently proposed models of fuzzy sphere regularization. △ Less

Submitted 14 December, 2023; v1 submitted 5 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 22 pages, 9 figures; v2 - footnote 5 added; v3 - typos corrected and footnotes added, subtitle added; v4 - a paragraph in conclusions added, version to appear in SciPost

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 15, 243 (2023)

Classifying irreducible fixed points of five scalar fields in perturbation theory

Authors: Junchen Rong, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: Classifying perturbative fixed points near upper critical dimensions plays an important role in understanding the space of conformal field theories and critical phases of matter. In this work, we consider perturbative fixed points of $N=5$ scalar bosons coupled with quartic interactions preserving an arbitrary subgroup $G\subset {\rm O}(5)$. We perform an exhaustive algorithmic search over the sym… ▽ More Classifying perturbative fixed points near upper critical dimensions plays an important role in understanding the space of conformal field theories and critical phases of matter. In this work, we consider perturbative fixed points of $N=5$ scalar bosons coupled with quartic interactions preserving an arbitrary subgroup $G\subset {\rm O}(5)$. We perform an exhaustive algorithmic search over the symmetry groups $G$ which are irreducible and satisfy the Landau condition, so that the fixed point can be reached by fine-tuning a single mass term and there is no need to tune the cubic couplings. We also impose stability of the RG flow in the space of quartic couplings, and reality. We thus prove that there exist no new stable fixed points in $d=4-ε$ dimensions beyond the two known ones: namely the ${\rm O}(5)$ invariant fixed point and the Cubic(5) fixed point. This work is a continuation of the classification of such fixed points with $N=4$ scalars by Toledano, Michel, Toledano, and Brézin in 1985. △ Less

Submitted 6 July, 2023; v1 submitted 15 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 37 pages, 4 figures, references updated

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 16, 040 (2024)

Four Lectures on the Random Field Ising Model, Parisi-Sourlas Supersymmetry, and Dimensional Reduction

Authors: Slava Rychkov

Abstract: Numerical evidence suggests that the Random Field Ising Model loses Parisi-Sourlas SUSY and the dimensional reduction property somewhere between 4 and 5 dimensions, while a related model of branched polymers retains these features in any $d$. These notes give a leisurely introduction to a recent theory, developed jointly with A. Kaviraj and E. Trevisani, which aims to explain these facts. Based on… ▽ More Numerical evidence suggests that the Random Field Ising Model loses Parisi-Sourlas SUSY and the dimensional reduction property somewhere between 4 and 5 dimensions, while a related model of branched polymers retains these features in any $d$. These notes give a leisurely introduction to a recent theory, developed jointly with A. Kaviraj and E. Trevisani, which aims to explain these facts. Based on the lectures given in Cortona and at the IHES in 2022. △ Less

Submitted 27 March, 2023; v1 submitted 16 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: 55 pages, 11 figures; v2 - minor changes, mentioned forthcoming work by Fytas et al

Journal ref: SpringerBriefs in Physics (2023)

Twist accumulation in conformal field theory. A rigorous approach to the lightcone bootstrap

Authors: Sridip Pal, Jiaxin Qiao, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: We prove that in any unitary CFT, a twist gap in the spectrum of operator product expansion (OPE) of identical scalar primary operators (i.e. $φ\times φ$) implies the existence of a family of primary operators $\mathcal{O}_{τ, \ell}$ with spins $\ell \rightarrow \infty$ and twists $τ\rightarrow 2 Δ_φ$ in the same OPE spectrum. A similar twist-accumulation result is proven for any two-dimensional V… ▽ More We prove that in any unitary CFT, a twist gap in the spectrum of operator product expansion (OPE) of identical scalar primary operators (i.e. $φ\times φ$) implies the existence of a family of primary operators $\mathcal{O}_{τ, \ell}$ with spins $\ell \rightarrow \infty$ and twists $τ\rightarrow 2 Δ_φ$ in the same OPE spectrum. A similar twist-accumulation result is proven for any two-dimensional Virasoro-invariant, modular-invariant, unitary CFT with a normalizable vacuum and central charge $c > 1$, where we show that a twist gap in the spectrum of Virasoro primaries implies the existence of a family of Virasoro primaries $\mathcal{O}_{h, \bar{h}}$ with $h \rightarrow \infty$ and $\bar{h} \rightarrow \frac{c - 1}{24}$ (the same is true with $h$ and $\bar{h}$ interchanged). We summarize the similarity of the two problems and propose a general formulation of the lightcone bootstrap. △ Less

Submitted 17 May, 2023; v1 submitted 9 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Comments: 35+10 pages, 1 figure. v2: minor changes, typos corrected. v3: version accepted for publication by Comm.Math.Phys., with minor changes, typos corrected and references added

Tensor Renormalization Group at Low Temperatures: Discontinuity Fixed Point

Authors: Tom Kennedy, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: We continue our study of rigorous renormalization group (RG) maps for tensor networks that was begun in arXiv:2107.11464. In this paper we construct a rigorous RG map for 2D tensor networks whose domain includes tensors that represent the 2D Ising model at low temperatures with a magnetic field $h$. We prove that the RG map has two stable fixed points, corresponding to the two ground states, and o… ▽ More We continue our study of rigorous renormalization group (RG) maps for tensor networks that was begun in arXiv:2107.11464. In this paper we construct a rigorous RG map for 2D tensor networks whose domain includes tensors that represent the 2D Ising model at low temperatures with a magnetic field $h$. We prove that the RG map has two stable fixed points, corresponding to the two ground states, and one unstable fixed point which is an example of a discontinuity fixed point. For the Ising model at low temperatures the RG map flows to one of the stable fixed points if $h \neq 0$, and to the discontinuity fixed point if $h=0$. In addition to the nearest neighbor and magnetic field terms in the Hamiltonian, we can include small terms that need not be spin-flip invariant. In this case we prove there is a critical value $h_c$ of the field (which depends on these additional small interactions and the temperature) such that the RG map flows to the discontinuity fixed point if $h=h_c$ and to one of the stable fixed points otherwise. We use our RG map to give a new proof of previous results on the first-order transition, namely, that the free energy is analytic for $h \neq h_c$, and the magnetization is discontinuous at $h = h_c$. The construction of our low temperature RG map, in particular the disentangler, is surprisingly very similar to the construction of the map in arXiv:2107.11464 for the high temperature phase. We also give a pedagogical discussion of some general rigorous transformations for infinite dimensional tensor networks and an overview of the proof of stability of the high temperature fixed point for the RG map in arXiv:2107.11464. △ Less

Submitted 29 August, 2023; v1 submitted 12 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: Version 2: Diagram (6.44) has been corrected and footnote 14 has been added. Remark 6.6 is new. A sentence was added at the end of the proof of theorem 7.4. An additional acknowledgement has been added. Version 3 is the version that was published by Annales Henri Poincaré. Changes from version 2 to version 3 are very minor

MSC Class: 82B28; 82B27; 82B20

Journal ref: Ann. Henri Poincaré (2023)

The fate of Parisi-Sourlas supersymmetry in Random Field models

Authors: Apratim Kaviraj, Slava Rychkov, Emilio Trevisani

Abstract: By the Parisi-Sourlas conjecture, the critical point of a theory with random field (RF) disorder is described by a supersymmeric (SUSY) conformal field theory (CFT), related to a $d-2$ dimensional CFT without SUSY. Numerical studies indicate that this is true for the RF $φ^3$ model but not for RF $φ^4$ model in $d<5$ dimensions. Here we argue that the SUSY fixed point is not reached because of new… ▽ More By the Parisi-Sourlas conjecture, the critical point of a theory with random field (RF) disorder is described by a supersymmeric (SUSY) conformal field theory (CFT), related to a $d-2$ dimensional CFT without SUSY. Numerical studies indicate that this is true for the RF $φ^3$ model but not for RF $φ^4$ model in $d<5$ dimensions. Here we argue that the SUSY fixed point is not reached because of new relevant SUSY-breaking interactions. We use perturbative renormalization group in a judiciously chosen field basis, allowing systematic exploration of the space of interactions. Our computations agree with the numerical results for both cubic and quartic potential. △ Less

Submitted 12 July, 2022; v1 submitted 13 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: 16 pages, 2 figures; minor modifications, version accepted for publication in PRL

Tensor RG approach to high-temperature fixed point

Authors: Tom Kennedy, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: We study a renormalization group (RG) map for tensor networks that include two-dimensional lattice spin systems such as the Ising model. Numerical studies of such RG maps have been quite successful at reproducing the known critical behavior. In those numerical studies the RG map must be truncated to keep the dimension of the legs of the tensors bounded. Our tensors act on an infinite-dimensional H… ▽ More We study a renormalization group (RG) map for tensor networks that include two-dimensional lattice spin systems such as the Ising model. Numerical studies of such RG maps have been quite successful at reproducing the known critical behavior. In those numerical studies the RG map must be truncated to keep the dimension of the legs of the tensors bounded. Our tensors act on an infinite-dimensional Hilbert space, and our RG map does not involve any truncations. Our RG map has a trivial fixed point which represents the high-temperature fixed point. We prove that if we start with a tensor that is close to this fixed point tensor, then the iterates of the RG map converge in the Hilbert-Schmidt norm to the fixed point tensor. It is important to emphasize that this statement is not true for the simplest tensor network RG map in which one simply contracts four copies of the tensor to define the renormalized tensor. The linearization of this simple RG map about the fixed point is not a contraction due to the presence of so-called CDL tensors. Our work provides a first step towards the important problem of the rigorous study of RG maps for tensor networks in a neighborhood of the critical point. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2023; v1 submitted 23 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: version 2: The exposition of the proof of proposition 2.3 has been expanded. version 3 (this version): A minor error in the first paragraph of the proof of Lemma 2.1 has been corrected and figure 2.55 has been replaced as part of this correction

MSC Class: 82B28 (Primary) 82B27; 82B20 (Secondary)

Journal ref: J. Statist. Phys. 187 no. 3, (2022) 33

Navigator Function for the Conformal Bootstrap

Authors: Marten Reehorst, Slava Rychkov, David Simmons-Duffin, Benoit Sirois, Ning Su, Balt van Rees

Abstract: Current numerical conformal bootstrap techniques carve out islands in theory space by repeatedly checking whether points are allowed or excluded. We propose a new method for searching theory space that replaces the binary information "allowed"/"excluded" with a continuous "navigator" function that is negative in the allowed region and positive in the excluded region. Such a navigator function allo… ▽ More Current numerical conformal bootstrap techniques carve out islands in theory space by repeatedly checking whether points are allowed or excluded. We propose a new method for searching theory space that replaces the binary information "allowed"/"excluded" with a continuous "navigator" function that is negative in the allowed region and positive in the excluded region. Such a navigator function allows one to efficiently explore high-dimensional parameter spaces and smoothly sail towards any islands they may contain. The specific functions we introduce have several attractive features: they are everywhere well-defined, can be computed with standard methods, and evaluation of their gradient is immediate due to an SDP gradient formula that we provide. The latter property allows for the use of efficient quasi-Newton optimization methods, which we illustrate by navigating towards the 3d Ising island. △ Less

Submitted 15 September, 2021; v1 submitted 19 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 60 pages, 22 figures. v2: minor changes and fixes, added subsection 3.1 on differentiability

Report number: CPHT-RR032.042021

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 11, 072 (2021)

Distributions in CFT II. Minkowski Space

Authors: Petr Kravchuk, Jiaxin Qiao, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: CFTs in Euclidean signature satisfy well-accepted rules, such as the convergent Euclidean OPE. It is nowadays common to assume that CFT correlators exist and have various properties also in Lorentzian signature. Some of these properties may represent extra assumptions, and it is an open question if they hold for familiar statistical-physics CFTs such as the critical 3d Ising model. Here we conside… ▽ More CFTs in Euclidean signature satisfy well-accepted rules, such as the convergent Euclidean OPE. It is nowadays common to assume that CFT correlators exist and have various properties also in Lorentzian signature. Some of these properties may represent extra assumptions, and it is an open question if they hold for familiar statistical-physics CFTs such as the critical 3d Ising model. Here we consider Wightman 4-point functions of scalar primaries in Lorentzian signature. We derive a minimal set of their properties solely from the Euclidean unitary CFT axioms, without using extra assumptions. We establish all Wightman axioms (temperedness, spectral property, local commutativity, clustering), Lorentzian conformal invariance, and distributional convergence of the s-channel Lorentzian OPE. This is done constructively, by analytically continuing the 4-point functions using the s-channel OPE expansion in the radial cross-ratios $ρ, \barρ$. We prove a key fact that $|ρ|, |\barρ| < 1$ inside the forward tube, and set bounds on how fast $|ρ|, |\barρ|$ may tend to 1 when approaching the Minkowski space. We also provide a guide to the axiomatic QFT literature for the modern CFT audience. We review the Wightman and Osterwalder-Schrader (OS) axioms for Lorentzian and Euclidean QFTs, and the celebrated OS theorem connecting them. We also review a classic result of Mack about the distributional OPE convergence. Some of the classic arguments turn out useful in our setup. Others fall short of our needs due to Lorentzian assumptions (Mack) or unverifiable Euclidean assumptions (OS theorem). △ Less

Submitted 27 July, 2021; v1 submitted 5 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 88+18 pages, 18 figures, a 25-page fast track included on page 5; v2: published version

Random Field Ising Model and Parisi-Sourlas Supersymmetry. Part II. Renormalization Group

Authors: Apratim Kaviraj, Slava Rychkov, Emilio Trevisani

Abstract: We revisit perturbative RG analysis in the replicated Landau-Ginzburg description of the Random Field Ising Model near the upper critical dimension 6. Working in a field basis with manifest vicinity to a weakly-coupled Parisi-Sourlas supersymmetric fixed point (Cardy, 1985), we look for interactions which may destabilize the SUSY RG flow and lead to the loss of dimensional reduction. This problem… ▽ More We revisit perturbative RG analysis in the replicated Landau-Ginzburg description of the Random Field Ising Model near the upper critical dimension 6. Working in a field basis with manifest vicinity to a weakly-coupled Parisi-Sourlas supersymmetric fixed point (Cardy, 1985), we look for interactions which may destabilize the SUSY RG flow and lead to the loss of dimensional reduction. This problem is reduced to studying the anomalous dimensions of "leaders" -- lowest dimension parts of $S_n$-invariant perturbations in the Cardy basis. Leader operators are classified as non-susy-writable, susy-writable or susy-null depending on their symmetry. Susy-writable leaders are additionally classified as belonging to superprimary multiplets transforming in particular $\textrm{OSp}(d | 2)$ representations. We enumerate all leaders up to 6d dimension $Δ= 12$, and compute their perturbative anomalous dimensions (up to two loops). We thus identify two perturbations (with susy-null and non-susy-writable leaders) becoming relevant below a critical dimension $d_c \approx 4.2$ - $4.7$. This supports the scenario that the SUSY fixed point exists for all $3 < d \leq 6$, but becomes unstable for $d < d_c$. △ Less

Submitted 15 July, 2022; v1 submitted 21 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: 103 pages, 15 figures. v2: susy-null leader discussion modified (Sec. 8.5 and App. A.6), and other tweaks. v3: version accepted by JHEP, added executive summary in Sec. 1.1, discussion in Sec 11.1.1 and Sec. 11.2.1, corrected typos. v4: corrected typos. Conclusions unchanged

Gentle introduction to rigorous Renormalization Group: a worked fermionic example

Authors: Alessandro Giuliani, Vieri Mastropietro, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: Much of our understanding of critical phenomena is based on the notion of Renormalization Group (RG), but the actual determination of its fixed points is usually based on approximations and truncations, and predictions of physical quantities are often of limited accuracy. The RG fixed points can be however given a fully rigorous and non-perturbative characterization, and this is what is presented… ▽ More Much of our understanding of critical phenomena is based on the notion of Renormalization Group (RG), but the actual determination of its fixed points is usually based on approximations and truncations, and predictions of physical quantities are often of limited accuracy. The RG fixed points can be however given a fully rigorous and non-perturbative characterization, and this is what is presented here in a model of symplectic fermions with a nonlocal ("long-range") kinetic term depending on a parameter $\varepsilon$ and a quartic interaction. We identify the Banach space of interactions, which the fixed point belongs to, and we determine it via a convergent approximation scheme. The Banach space is not limited to relevant interactions, but it contains all possible irrelevant terms with short-ranged kernels, decaying like a stretched exponential at large distances. As the model shares a number of features in common with $φ^4$ or Ising models, the result can be used as a benchmark to test the validity of truncations and approximations in RG studies. The analysis is based on results coming from Constructive RG to which we provide a tutorial and self-contained introduction. In addition, we prove that the fixed point is analytic in $\varepsilon$, a somewhat surprising fact relying on the fermionic nature of the problem. △ Less

Submitted 30 January, 2021; v1 submitted 10 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Comments: 55 pages + appendices, many figures; v2: refs added; v3: refs added, intro greatly expanded, App. J.1 added, version accepted by JHEP; v4: minor misprints corrected

Journal ref: JHEP 2021, 26 (2021)

3D Ising Model: a view from the Conformal Bootstrap Island

Authors: Slava Rychkov

Abstract: We explain how the axioms of Conformal Field Theory are used to make predictions about critical exponents of continuous phase transitions in three dimensions, via a procedure called the conformal bootstrap. The method assumes conformal invariance of correlation functions, and imposes some relations between correlation functions of different orders. Numerical analysis shows that these conditions ar… ▽ More We explain how the axioms of Conformal Field Theory are used to make predictions about critical exponents of continuous phase transitions in three dimensions, via a procedure called the conformal bootstrap. The method assumes conformal invariance of correlation functions, and imposes some relations between correlation functions of different orders. Numerical analysis shows that these conditions are incompatible unless the critical exponents take particular values, or more precisely that they must belong to a small island in the parameter space. △ Less

Submitted 28 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

Comments: 16 pages, 3 figures, accepted for publication by C.R.Physique

Journal ref: Comptes Rendus. Physique, Tome 21 (2020) no. 2, pp. 185-198

Distributions in CFT I. Cross-Ratio Space

Authors: Petr Kravchuk, Jiaxin Qiao, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: We show that the four-point functions in conformal field theory are defined as distributions on the boundary of the region of convergence of the conformal block expansion. The conformal block expansion converges in the sense of distributions on this boundary, i.e. it can be integrated term by term against appropriate test functions. This can be interpreted as a giving a new class of functionals th… ▽ More We show that the four-point functions in conformal field theory are defined as distributions on the boundary of the region of convergence of the conformal block expansion. The conformal block expansion converges in the sense of distributions on this boundary, i.e. it can be integrated term by term against appropriate test functions. This can be interpreted as a giving a new class of functionals that satisfy the swapping property when applied to the crossing equation, and we comment on the relation of our construction to other types of functionals. Our language is useful in all considerations involving the boundary of the region of convergence, e.g. for deriving the dispersion relations. We establish our results by elementary methods, relying only on crossing symmetry and the standard convergence properties of the conformal block expansion. This is the first in a series of papers on distributional properties of correlation functions in conformal field theory. △ Less

Submitted 23 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Comments: 24 pages + appendices

Random Field Ising Model and Parisi-Sourlas Supersymmetry I. Supersymmetric CFT

Authors: Apratim Kaviraj, Slava Rychkov, Emilio Trevisani

Abstract: Quenched disorder is very important but notoriously hard. In 1979, Parisi and Sourlas proposed an interesting and powerful conjecture about the infrared fixed points with random field type of disorder: such fixed points should possess an unusual supersymmetry, by which they reduce in two less spatial dimensions to usual non-supersymmetric non-disordered fixed points. This conjecture however is kno… ▽ More Quenched disorder is very important but notoriously hard. In 1979, Parisi and Sourlas proposed an interesting and powerful conjecture about the infrared fixed points with random field type of disorder: such fixed points should possess an unusual supersymmetry, by which they reduce in two less spatial dimensions to usual non-supersymmetric non-disordered fixed points. This conjecture however is known to fail in some simple cases, but there is no consensus on why this happens. In this paper we give new non-perturbative arguments for dimensional reduction. We recast the problem in the language of Conformal Field Theory (CFT). We then exhibit a map of operators and correlation functions from Parisi-Sourlas supersymmetric CFT in $d$ dimensions to a $(d-2)$-dimensional ordinary CFT. The reduced theory is local, i.e. it has a local conserved stress tensor operator. As required by reduction, we show a perfect match between superconformal blocks and the usual conformal blocks in two dimensions lower. This also leads to a new relation between conformal blocks across dimensions. This paper concerns the second half of the Parisi-Sourlas conjecture, while the first half (existence of a supersymmetric fixed point) will be examined in a companion work. △ Less

Submitted 2 April, 2020; v1 submitted 3 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: 36 pages, 2 figures. Minor corrections, new references, some comments and clarifications in section 4, a new appendix on "Supersymmetry in the problem of critical dynamics" are added. To appear in JHEP

Deligne Categories in Lattice Models and Quantum Field Theory, or Making Sense of $O(N)$ Symmetry with Non-integer $N$

Authors: Damon J. Binder, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: When studying quantum field theories and lattice models, it is often useful to analytically continue the number of field or spin components from an integer to a real number. In spite of this, the precise meaning of such analytic continuations has never been fully clarified, and in particular the symmetry of these theories is obscure. We clarify these issues using Deligne categories and their assoc… ▽ More When studying quantum field theories and lattice models, it is often useful to analytically continue the number of field or spin components from an integer to a real number. In spite of this, the precise meaning of such analytic continuations has never been fully clarified, and in particular the symmetry of these theories is obscure. We clarify these issues using Deligne categories and their associated Brauer algebras, and show that these provide logically satisfactory answers to these questions. Simple objects of the Deligne category generalize the notion of an irreducible representations, avoiding the need for such mathematically nonsensical notions as vector spaces of non-integer dimension. We develop a systematic theory of categorical symmetries, applying it in both perturbative and non-perturbative contexts. A partial list of our results is: categorical symmetries are preserved under RG flows; continuous categorical symmetries come equipped with conserved currents; CFTs with categorical symmetries are necessarily non-unitary. △ Less

Submitted 24 February, 2023; v1 submitted 18 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: 59 pages, many figures; v3 typos fixed, version submitted to journal; v4 note 21 added about a terminological clash

Report number: PUPT-2601

General Properties of Multiscalar RG Flows in $d=4-\varepsilon$

Authors: Slava Rychkov, Andreas Stergiou

Abstract: Fixed points of scalar field theories with quartic interactions in $d=4-\varepsilon$ dimensions are considered in full generality. For such theories it is known that there exists a scalar function $A$ of the couplings through which the leading-order beta-function can be expressed as a gradient. It is here proved that the fixed-point value of $A$ is bounded from below by a simple expression linear… ▽ More Fixed points of scalar field theories with quartic interactions in $d=4-\varepsilon$ dimensions are considered in full generality. For such theories it is known that there exists a scalar function $A$ of the couplings through which the leading-order beta-function can be expressed as a gradient. It is here proved that the fixed-point value of $A$ is bounded from below by a simple expression linear in the dimension of the vector order parameter, $N$. Saturation of the bound requires a marginal deformation, and is shown to arise when fixed points with the same global symmetry coincide in coupling space. Several general results about scalar CFTs are discussed, and a review of known fixed points is given. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2019; v1 submitted 24 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 29 pages, 4 figures; see section 3 for a prize problem. v2: small correction in appendix, typos fixed. v3: minor additions. v4: some next-to-leading order results added, typos fixed

Report number: CERN-TH-2018-225

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 6, 008 (2019)

Walking, Weak first-order transitions, and Complex CFTs II. Two-dimensional Potts model at $Q>4$

Authors: Victor Gorbenko, Slava Rychkov, Bernardo Zan

Abstract: We study complex CFTs describing fixed points of the two-dimensional $Q$-state Potts model with $Q>4$. Their existence is closely related to the weak first-order phase transition and walking RG behavior present in the real Potts model at $Q>4$. The Potts model, apart from its own significance, serves as an ideal playground for testing this very general relation. Cluster formulation provides nonper… ▽ More We study complex CFTs describing fixed points of the two-dimensional $Q$-state Potts model with $Q>4$. Their existence is closely related to the weak first-order phase transition and walking RG behavior present in the real Potts model at $Q>4$. The Potts model, apart from its own significance, serves as an ideal playground for testing this very general relation. Cluster formulation provides nonperturbative definition for a continuous range of parameter $Q$, while Coulomb gas description and connection to minimal models provide some conformal data of the complex CFTs. We use one and two-loop conformal perturbation theory around complex CFTs to compute various properties of the real walking RG flow. These properties, such as drifting scaling dimensions, appear to be common features of the QFTs with walking RG flows, and can serve as a smoking gun for detecting walking in Monte Carlo simulations. The complex CFTs discussed in this work are perfectly well defined, and can in principle be seen in Monte Carlo simulations with complexified coupling constants. In particular, we predict a pair of $S_5$-symmetric complex CFTs with central charges $c\approx 1.138 \pm 0.021 i$ describing the fixed points of a 5-state dilute Potts model with complexified temperature and vacancy fugacity. △ Less

Submitted 12 October, 2018; v1 submitted 13 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Comments: 34 pages, 13 figures. v2: refs added; v3 refs added, typos corrected, presentation of several arguments clarified

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 5, 050 (2018)

Walking, Weak first-order transitions, and Complex CFTs

Authors: Victor Gorbenko, Slava Rychkov, Bernardo Zan

Abstract: We discuss walking behavior in gauge theories and weak first-order phase transitions in statistical physics. Despite appearing in very different systems (QCD below the conformal window, the Potts model, deconfined criticality) these two phenomena both imply approximate scale invariance in a range of energies and have the same RG interpretation: a flow passing between pairs of fixed point at comple… ▽ More We discuss walking behavior in gauge theories and weak first-order phase transitions in statistical physics. Despite appearing in very different systems (QCD below the conformal window, the Potts model, deconfined criticality) these two phenomena both imply approximate scale invariance in a range of energies and have the same RG interpretation: a flow passing between pairs of fixed point at complex coupling. We discuss what distinguishes a real theory from a complex theory and call these fixed points complex CFTs. By using conformal perturbation theory we show how observables of the walking theory are computable by perturbing the complex CFTs. This paper discusses the general mechanism while a companion paper [1] will treat a specific and computable example: the two-dimensional Q-state Potts model with Q > 4. Concerning walking in 4d gauge theories, we also comment on the (un)likelihood of the light pseudo-dilaton, and on non-minimal scenarios of the conformal window termination. △ Less

Submitted 17 August, 2018; v1 submitted 30 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: 38 pages, added references

The Conformal Bootstrap: Theory, Numerical Techniques, and Applications

Authors: David Poland, Slava Rychkov, Alessandro Vichi

Abstract: Conformal field theories have been long known to describe the fascinating universal physics of scale invariant critical points. They describe continuous phase transitions in fluids, magnets, and numerous other materials, while at the same time sit at the heart of our modern understanding of quantum field theory. For decades it has been a dream to study these intricate strongly coupled theories non… ▽ More Conformal field theories have been long known to describe the fascinating universal physics of scale invariant critical points. They describe continuous phase transitions in fluids, magnets, and numerous other materials, while at the same time sit at the heart of our modern understanding of quantum field theory. For decades it has been a dream to study these intricate strongly coupled theories nonperturbatively using symmetries and other consistency conditions. This idea, called the conformal bootstrap, saw some successes in two dimensions but it is only in the last ten years that it has been fully realized in three, four, and other dimensions of interest. This renaissance has been possible both due to significant analytical progress in understanding how to set up the bootstrap equations and the development of numerical techniques for finding or constraining their solutions. These developments have led to a number of groundbreaking results, including world record determinations of critical exponents and correlation function coefficients in the Ising and $O(N)$ models in three dimensions. This article will review these exciting developments for newcomers to the bootstrap, giving an introduction to conformal field theories and the theory of conformal blocks, describing numerical techniques for the bootstrap based on convex optimization, and summarizing in detail their applications to fixed points in three and four dimensions with no or minimal supersymmetry. △ Less

Submitted 17 April, 2019; v1 submitted 11 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: 81 pages, double column, 58 figures; v3: updated references, minor typos corrected

Journal ref: Rev. Mod. Phys. 91, 15002 (2019)

A structural test for the conformal invariance of the critical 3d Ising model

Authors: Simao Meneses, Joao Penedones, Slava Rychkov, J. M. Viana Parente Lopes, Pierre Yvernay

Abstract: How can a renormalization group fixed point be scale invariant without being conformal? Polchinski (1988) showed that this may happen if the theory contains a virial current -- a non-conserved vector operator of dimension exactly $(d-1)$, whose divergence expresses the trace of the stress tensor. We point out that this scenario can be probed via lattice Monte Carlo simulations, using the critical… ▽ More How can a renormalization group fixed point be scale invariant without being conformal? Polchinski (1988) showed that this may happen if the theory contains a virial current -- a non-conserved vector operator of dimension exactly $(d-1)$, whose divergence expresses the trace of the stress tensor. We point out that this scenario can be probed via lattice Monte Carlo simulations, using the critical 3d Ising model as an example. Our results put a lower bound $Δ_V>5.0$ on the scaling dimension of the lowest virial current candidate $V$, well above 2 expected for the true virial current. This implies that the critical 3d Ising model has no virial current, providing a structural explanation for the conformal invariance of the model. △ Less

Submitted 16 January, 2021; v1 submitted 7 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Comments: v2: 27pp; many explanations and some corrections added; Monte Carlo measurement reinterpreted as a lower bound; conclusions unchanged; v3: misprint in Eq. (2.5) corrected; v4: Eqs (1.4,1.5) and appendix B added, version to appear in JHEP; v5: Ref. [4] to 3d SAW conformal invariance added

A tauberian theorem for the conformal bootstrap

Authors: Jiaxin Qiao, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: For expansions in one-dimensional conformal blocks, we provide a rigorous link between the asymptotics of the spectral density of exchanged primaries and the leading singularity in the crossed channel. Our result has a direct application to systems of SL(2,R)-invariant correlators (also known as 1d CFTs). It also puts on solid ground a part of the lightcone bootstrap analysis of the spectrum of op… ▽ More For expansions in one-dimensional conformal blocks, we provide a rigorous link between the asymptotics of the spectral density of exchanged primaries and the leading singularity in the crossed channel. Our result has a direct application to systems of SL(2,R)-invariant correlators (also known as 1d CFTs). It also puts on solid ground a part of the lightcone bootstrap analysis of the spectrum of operators of high spin and bounded twist in CFTs in d>2. In addition, a similar argument controls the spectral density asymptotics in large N gauge theories. △ Less

Submitted 23 October, 2017; v1 submitted 31 August, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

Comments: 36pp; v2: refs and comments added, misprints corrected

Report number: CERN TH/2017-176

NLO Renormalization in the Hamiltonian Truncation

Authors: Joan Elias-Miro, Slava Rychkov, Lorenzo G. Vitale

Abstract: Hamiltonian Truncation (a.k.a. Truncated Spectrum Approach) is a numerical technique for solving strongly coupled QFTs, in which the full Hilbert space is truncated to a finite-dimensional low-energy subspace. The accuracy of the method is limited only by the available computational resources. The renormalization program improves the accuracy by carefully integrating out the high-energy states, in… ▽ More Hamiltonian Truncation (a.k.a. Truncated Spectrum Approach) is a numerical technique for solving strongly coupled QFTs, in which the full Hilbert space is truncated to a finite-dimensional low-energy subspace. The accuracy of the method is limited only by the available computational resources. The renormalization program improves the accuracy by carefully integrating out the high-energy states, instead of truncating them away. In this paper we develop the most accurate ever variant of Hamiltonian Truncation, which implements renormalization at the cubic order in the interaction strength. The novel idea is to interpret the renormalization procedure as a result of integrating out exactly a certain class of high-energy "tail states". We demonstrate the power of the method with high-accuracy computations in the strongly coupled two-dimensional quartic scalar theory, and benchmark it against other existing approaches. Our work will also be useful for the future goal of extending Hamiltonian Truncation to higher spacetime dimensions. △ Less

Submitted 29 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: 28pp + appendices, detailed version of arXiv:1706.06121

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 96, 065024 (2017)

High-Precision Calculations in Strongly Coupled Quantum Field Theory with Next-to-Leading-Order Renormalized Hamiltonian Truncation

Authors: Joan Elias-Miro, Slava Rychkov, Lorenzo G. Vitale

Abstract: Hamiltonian Truncation (a.k.a. Truncated Spectrum Approach) is an efficient numerical technique to solve strongly coupled QFTs in d=2 spacetime dimensions. Further theoretical developments are needed to increase its accuracy and the range of applicability. With this goal in mind, here we present a new variant of Hamiltonian Truncation which exhibits smaller dependence on the UV cutoff than other e… ▽ More Hamiltonian Truncation (a.k.a. Truncated Spectrum Approach) is an efficient numerical technique to solve strongly coupled QFTs in d=2 spacetime dimensions. Further theoretical developments are needed to increase its accuracy and the range of applicability. With this goal in mind, here we present a new variant of Hamiltonian Truncation which exhibits smaller dependence on the UV cutoff than other existing implementations, and yields more accurate spectra. The key idea for achieving this consists in integrating out exactly a certain class of high energy states, which corresponds to performing renormalization at the cubic order in the interaction strength. We test the new method on the strongly coupled two-dimensional quartic scalar theory. Our work will also be useful for the future goal of extending Hamiltonian Truncation to higher dimensions d >= 3. △ Less

Submitted 15 December, 2017; v1 submitted 19 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: 8 pages, 4 figures; v2: published version

Report number: CERN-TH-2017-132

Journal ref: JHEP 1710 (2017) 213

Cut-touching linear functionals in the conformal bootstrap

Authors: Jiaxin Qiao, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: The modern conformal bootstrap program often employs the method of linear functionals to derive the numerical or analytical bounds on the CFT data. These functionals must have a crucial "swapping" property, allowing to swap infinite summation with the action of the functional in the conformal bootstrap sum rule. Swapping is easy to justify for the popular functionals involving finite sums of deriv… ▽ More The modern conformal bootstrap program often employs the method of linear functionals to derive the numerical or analytical bounds on the CFT data. These functionals must have a crucial "swapping" property, allowing to swap infinite summation with the action of the functional in the conformal bootstrap sum rule. Swapping is easy to justify for the popular functionals involving finite sums of derivatives. However, it is far from obvious for "cut-touching" functionals, involving integration over regions where conformal block decomposition does not converge uniformly. Functionals of this type were recently considered by Mazac in his work on analytic derivation of optimal bootstrap bounds. We derive general swapping criteria for the cut-touching functionals, and check in a few explicit examples that Mazac's functionals pass our criteria. △ Less

Submitted 10 August, 2017; v1 submitted 3 May, 2017; originally announced May 2017.

Comments: 19 pages, 7 figures, v2: author order corrected, v3: full domain of 4pt analyticity made more precise, v4: misprint corrected and acknowledgement added

Report number: CERN PH-TH/2017-098

A scaling theory for the long-range to short-range crossover and an infrared duality

Authors: Connor Behan, Leonardo Rastelli, Slava Rychkov, Bernardo Zan

Abstract: We study the second-order phase transition in the $d$-dimensional Ising model with long-range interactions decreasing as a power of the distance $1/r^{d+s}$. For $s$ below some known value $s_*$, the transition is described by a conformal field theory without a local stress tensor operator, with critical exponents varying continuously as functions of $s$. At $s=s_*$, the phase transition crosses o… ▽ More We study the second-order phase transition in the $d$-dimensional Ising model with long-range interactions decreasing as a power of the distance $1/r^{d+s}$. For $s$ below some known value $s_*$, the transition is described by a conformal field theory without a local stress tensor operator, with critical exponents varying continuously as functions of $s$. At $s=s_*$, the phase transition crosses over to the short-range universality class. While the location $s_*$ of this crossover has been known for 40 years, its physics has not been fully understood, the main difficulty being that the standard description of the long-range critical point is strongly coupled at the crossover. In this paper we propose another field-theoretic description which, on the contrary, is weakly coupled near the crossover. We use this description to clarify the nature of the crossover and make predictions about the critical exponents. That the same long-range critical point can be reached from two different UV descriptions provides a new example of infrared duality. △ Less

Submitted 23 August, 2017; v1 submitted 15 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Comments: 57pp, detailed version of arXiv:1703.03430, v2: misprints corrected, v3: refs and discussion of log corrections at the crossover added, v4: published version plus extra comments in appendix A,B and an acknowledgement, v5: published version plus extra comments in appendix A,B and an acknowledgement (replacing the wrong tex file of v4)

Report number: CERN PH-TH/2017-052, YITP-SB-17-13

Journal ref: J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 50 (2017) 354002

Long-range critical exponents near the short-range crossover

Authors: Connor Behan, Leonardo Rastelli, Slava Rychkov, Bernardo Zan

Abstract: The $d$-dimensional long-range Ising model, defined by spin-spin interactions decaying with the distance as the power $1/r^{d+s}$, admits a second order phase transition with continuously varying critical exponents. At $s = s_*$, the phase transition crosses over to the usual short-range universality class. The standard field-theoretic description of this family of models is strongly coupled at th… ▽ More The $d$-dimensional long-range Ising model, defined by spin-spin interactions decaying with the distance as the power $1/r^{d+s}$, admits a second order phase transition with continuously varying critical exponents. At $s = s_*$, the phase transition crosses over to the usual short-range universality class. The standard field-theoretic description of this family of models is strongly coupled at the crossover. We find a new description, which is instead weakly coupled near the crossover, and use it to compute critical exponents. The existence of two complementary UV descriptions of the same long-range fixed point provides a novel example of infrared duality. △ Less

Submitted 18 August, 2017; v1 submitted 9 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Comments: 5pp

Report number: CERN PH-TH/2017-058, YITP-SB-17-12

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 241601 (2017)

Non-gaussianity of the critical 3d Ising model

Authors: Slava Rychkov, David Simmons-Duffin, Bernardo Zan

Abstract: We discuss the 4pt function of the critical 3d Ising model, extracted from recent conformal bootstrap results. We focus on the non-gaussianity Q - the ratio of the 4pt function to its gaussian part given by three Wick contractions. This ratio reveals significant non-gaussianity of the critical fluctuations. The bootstrap results are consistent with a rigorous inequality due to Lebowitz and Aizenma… ▽ More We discuss the 4pt function of the critical 3d Ising model, extracted from recent conformal bootstrap results. We focus on the non-gaussianity Q - the ratio of the 4pt function to its gaussian part given by three Wick contractions. This ratio reveals significant non-gaussianity of the critical fluctuations. The bootstrap results are consistent with a rigorous inequality due to Lebowitz and Aizenman, which limits Q to lie between 1/3 and 1. △ Less

Submitted 10 August, 2017; v1 submitted 7 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 10 pages, 6 figures; v2: refs added; v3: refs updated, published version; v4: acknowledgement added

Report number: CERN PH-TH/2016-249

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 2, 001 (2017)

EPFL Lectures on Conformal Field Theory in D>= 3 Dimensions

Authors: Slava Rychkov

Abstract: This is a writeup of lectures given at the EPFL Lausanne in the fall of 2012. The topics covered: physical foundations of conformal symmetry, conformal kinematics, radial quantization and the OPE, and a very basic introduction to conformal bootstrap. This is a writeup of lectures given at the EPFL Lausanne in the fall of 2012. The topics covered: physical foundations of conformal symmetry, conformal kinematics, radial quantization and the OPE, and a very basic introduction to conformal bootstrap. △ Less

Submitted 10 June, 2016; v1 submitted 19 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Comments: 68 pages; v2 - misprints corrected

Report number: CERN TH/2016-012

Hamiltonian Truncation Study of the Phi^4 Theory in Two Dimensions II. The Z_2-Broken Phase and the Chang Duality

Authors: Slava Rychkov, Lorenzo G. Vitale

Abstract: The Fock-space Hamiltonian truncation method is developed further, paying particular attention to the treatment of the scalar field zero mode. This is applied to the two-dimensional Phi^4 theory in the phase where the Z_2-symmetry is spontaneously broken, complementing our earlier study of the Z_2-invariant phase and of the critical point. We also check numerically the weak/strong duality of this… ▽ More The Fock-space Hamiltonian truncation method is developed further, paying particular attention to the treatment of the scalar field zero mode. This is applied to the two-dimensional Phi^4 theory in the phase where the Z_2-symmetry is spontaneously broken, complementing our earlier study of the Z_2-invariant phase and of the critical point. We also check numerically the weak/strong duality of this theory discussed long ago by Chang. △ Less

Submitted 2 April, 2019; v1 submitted 1 December, 2015; originally announced December 2015.

Comments: 28 pages, 28 figures; V2: refs added, published version; V3: added note in Appendix on perturbation theory checks

Report number: CERN-PH-TH-2015-277

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 93, 065014 (2016)

Unitarity violation at the Wilson-Fisher fixed point in 4-epsilon dimensions

Authors: Matthijs Hogervorst, Slava Rychkov, Balt C. van Rees

Abstract: We consider the continuation of free and interacting scalar field theory to non-integer spacetime dimension d. We find that the correlation functions in these theories are necessarily incompatible with unitarity (or with reflection positivity in Euclidean signature). In particular, the theories contain negative norm states unless d is a positive integer. These negative norm states can be obtained… ▽ More We consider the continuation of free and interacting scalar field theory to non-integer spacetime dimension d. We find that the correlation functions in these theories are necessarily incompatible with unitarity (or with reflection positivity in Euclidean signature). In particular, the theories contain negative norm states unless d is a positive integer. These negative norm states can be obtained via the OPE from simple positive norm operators, and are therefore an integral part of the theory. At the Wilson-Fisher fixed point the non-unitarity leads to the existence of complex anomalous dimensions. We demonstrate that they appear already at leading order in the epsilon expansion. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2016; v1 submitted 30 November, 2015; originally announced December 2015.

Comments: 31 pages, 2 figures; v2: references added, version to appear in Phys. Rev. D

Report number: CERN TH/2015-282, YITP-SB-15-44, DCPT-15/65

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 93, 125025 (2016)

Remarks on the Convergence Properties of the Conformal Block Expansion

Authors: Slava Rychkov, Pierre Yvernay

Abstract: We show how to refine conformal block expansion convergence estimates from hep-th/1208.6449. In doing so we find a novel explicit formula for the 3d conformal blocks on the real axis. We show how to refine conformal block expansion convergence estimates from hep-th/1208.6449. In doing so we find a novel explicit formula for the 3d conformal blocks on the real axis. △ Less

Submitted 28 October, 2015; originally announced October 2015.

Comments: 12pp

Report number: CERN PH-TH/2015-253

Conformal Invariance in the Long-Range Ising Model

Authors: Miguel F. Paulos, Slava Rychkov, Balt C. van Rees, Bernardo Zan

Abstract: We consider the question of conformal invariance of the long-range Ising model at the critical point. The continuum description is given in terms of a nonlocal field theory, and the absence of a stress tensor invalidates all of the standard arguments for the enhancement of scale invariance to conformal invariance. We however show that several correlation functions, computed to second order in the… ▽ More We consider the question of conformal invariance of the long-range Ising model at the critical point. The continuum description is given in terms of a nonlocal field theory, and the absence of a stress tensor invalidates all of the standard arguments for the enhancement of scale invariance to conformal invariance. We however show that several correlation functions, computed to second order in the epsilon expansion, are nontrivially consistent with conformal invariance. We proceed to give a proof of conformal invariance to all orders in the epsilon expansion, based on the description of the long-range Ising model as a defect theory in an auxiliary higher-dimensional space. A detailed review of conformal invariance in the d-dimensional short-range Ising model is also included and may be of independent interest. △ Less

Submitted 9 December, 2015; v1 submitted 31 August, 2015; originally announced September 2015.

Comments: 52pp; V2: refs added; V3: ref added, published version

Report number: CERN PH-TH/2015-200

The Epsilon-Expansion from Conformal Field Theory

Authors: Slava Rychkov, Zhong Ming Tan

Abstract: Conformal multiplets of $φ$ and $φ^3$ recombine at the Wilson-Fisher fixed point, as a consequence of the equations of motion. Using this fact and other constraints from conformal symmetry, we reproduce the lowest nontrivial order results for the anomalous dimensions of operators, without any input from perturbation theory. Conformal multiplets of $φ$ and $φ^3$ recombine at the Wilson-Fisher fixed point, as a consequence of the equations of motion. Using this fact and other constraints from conformal symmetry, we reproduce the lowest nontrivial order results for the anomalous dimensions of operators, without any input from perturbation theory. △ Less

Submitted 24 June, 2015; v1 submitted 5 May, 2015; originally announced May 2015.

Comments: 24 pages; v2 - references added, minor changes; v3 - refs and comments added, misprints corrected, version to appear in J.Phys.A

Report number: CERN PH-TH/2015-104

Hamiltonian Truncation Study of the Phi^4 Theory in Two Dimensions

Authors: Slava Rychkov, Lorenzo G. Vitale

Abstract: We defend the Fock-space Hamiltonian truncation method, which allows to calculate numerically the spectrum of strongly coupled quantum field theories, by putting them in a finite volume and imposing a UV cutoff. The accuracy of the method is improved via an analytic renormalization procedure inspired by the usual effective field theory. As an application, we study the two-dimensional Phi^4 theory… ▽ More We defend the Fock-space Hamiltonian truncation method, which allows to calculate numerically the spectrum of strongly coupled quantum field theories, by putting them in a finite volume and imposing a UV cutoff. The accuracy of the method is improved via an analytic renormalization procedure inspired by the usual effective field theory. As an application, we study the two-dimensional Phi^4 theory for a wide range of couplings. The theory exhibits a quantum phase transition between the symmetry-preserving and symmetry-breaking phases. We extract quantitative predictions for the spectrum and the critical coupling and make contact with previous results from the literature. Future directions to further improve the accuracy of the method and enlarge its scope of applications are outlined. △ Less

Submitted 20 August, 2018; v1 submitted 10 December, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Comments: 41 pages, 27 pictures. Python code included with submission; v2: improved discussion of the work of Coser et al; v3: exponentially suppressed correction terms in the finite volume Hamiltonian made explicit; v4: Eq. (4.7) corrected; v5: refs updated; v6: errors corrected in appendix on perturbative checks

Report number: CERN-PH-TH-2014-254

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 91, 085011 (2015)

A Cheap Alternative to the Lattice?

Authors: Matthijs Hogervorst, Slava Rychkov, Balt C. van Rees

Abstract: We show how to perform accurate, nonperturbative and controlled calculations in quantum field theory in d dimensions. We use the Truncated Conformal Space Approach (TCSA), a Hamiltonian method which exploits the conformal structure of the UV fixed point. The theory is regulated in the IR by putting it on a sphere of a large finite radius. The QFT Hamiltonian is expressed as a matrix in the Hilbert… ▽ More We show how to perform accurate, nonperturbative and controlled calculations in quantum field theory in d dimensions. We use the Truncated Conformal Space Approach (TCSA), a Hamiltonian method which exploits the conformal structure of the UV fixed point. The theory is regulated in the IR by putting it on a sphere of a large finite radius. The QFT Hamiltonian is expressed as a matrix in the Hilbert space of CFT states. After restricting ourselves to energies below a certain UV cutoff, an approximation to the spectrum is obtained by numerical diagonalization of the resulting finite-dimensional matrix. The cutoff dependence of the results can be computed and efficiently reduced via a renormalization procedure. We work out the details of the method for the phi^4 theory in d dimensions with d not necessarily integer. A numerical analysis is then performed for the specific case d = 2.5, a value chosen in the range where UV divergences are absent. By going from weak to intermediate to strong coupling, we are able to observe the symmetry-preserving, symmetry-breaking, and conformal phases of the theory, and perform rough measurements of masses and critical exponents. As a byproduct of our investigations we find that both the free and the interacting theories in non integral d are not unitary, which however does not seem to cause much effect at low energies. △ Less

Submitted 3 December, 2015; v1 submitted 4 September, 2014; originally announced September 2014.

Comments: 56 pages, 22 figures; V2: defective figure file replaced; V3: minor corrections; refs added; V4: refs updated

Report number: CERN-PH-TH/2014-155

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 91, 025005 (2015)

Solving the 3d Ising Model with the Conformal Bootstrap II. c-Minimization and Precise Critical Exponents

Authors: Sheer El-Showk, Miguel F. Paulos, David Poland, Slava Rychkov, David Simmons-Duffin, Alessandro Vichi

Abstract: We use the conformal bootstrap to perform a precision study of the operator spectrum of the critical 3d Ising model. We conjecture that the 3d Ising spectrum minimizes the central charge c in the space of unitary solutions to crossing symmetry. Because extremal solutions to crossing symmetry are uniquely determined, we are able to precisely reconstruct the first several Z2-even operator dimensions… ▽ More We use the conformal bootstrap to perform a precision study of the operator spectrum of the critical 3d Ising model. We conjecture that the 3d Ising spectrum minimizes the central charge c in the space of unitary solutions to crossing symmetry. Because extremal solutions to crossing symmetry are uniquely determined, we are able to precisely reconstruct the first several Z2-even operator dimensions and their OPE coefficients. We observe that a sharp transition in the operator spectrum occurs at the 3d Ising dimension Delta_sigma=0.518154(15), and find strong numerical evidence that operators decouple from the spectrum as one approaches the 3d Ising point. We compare this behavior to the analogous situation in 2d, where the disappearance of operators can be understood in terms of degenerate Virasoro representations. △ Less

Submitted 4 June, 2014; v1 submitted 18 March, 2014; originally announced March 2014.

Comments: 55 pages, many figures; v2 - refs and comments added, to appear in a special issue of J.Stat.Phys. in memory of Kenneth Wilson

Report number: CERN-PH-TH/2014-038, NSF-KITP-14-022

Journal ref: J. Stat. Phys. 157, 869-914 (2014)

Conformal Field Theories in Fractional Dimensions

Authors: S. El-Showk, M. Paulos, D. Poland, S. Rychkov, D. Simmons-Duffin, A. Vichi

Abstract: We study the conformal bootstrap in fractional space-time dimensions, obtaining rigorous bounds on operator dimensions. Our results show strong evidence that there is a family of unitary CFTs connecting the 2D Ising model, the 3D Ising model, and the free scalar theory in 4D. We give numerical predictions for the leading operator dimensions and central charge in this family at different values of… ▽ More We study the conformal bootstrap in fractional space-time dimensions, obtaining rigorous bounds on operator dimensions. Our results show strong evidence that there is a family of unitary CFTs connecting the 2D Ising model, the 3D Ising model, and the free scalar theory in 4D. We give numerical predictions for the leading operator dimensions and central charge in this family at different values of D and compare these to calculations of phi^4 theory in the epsilon-expansion. △ Less

Submitted 12 October, 2015; v1 submitted 19 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: 11 pages, 4 figures - references updated - one affiliation modified

Report number: CERN-PH-TH/2013-219

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 141601 (2014)

Diagonal Limit for Conformal Blocks in d Dimensions

Authors: Matthijs Hogervorst, Hugh Osborn, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: Conformal blocks in any number of dimensions depend on two variables z, zbar. Here we study their restrictions to the special "diagonal" kinematics z = zbar, previously found useful as a starting point for the conformal bootstrap analysis. We show that conformal blocks on the diagonal satisfy ordinary differential equations, third-order for spin zero and fourth-order for the general case. These OD… ▽ More Conformal blocks in any number of dimensions depend on two variables z, zbar. Here we study their restrictions to the special "diagonal" kinematics z = zbar, previously found useful as a starting point for the conformal bootstrap analysis. We show that conformal blocks on the diagonal satisfy ordinary differential equations, third-order for spin zero and fourth-order for the general case. These ODEs determine the blocks uniquely and lead to an efficient numerical evaluation algorithm. For equal external operator dimensions, we find closed-form solutions in terms of finite sums of 3F2 functions. △ Less

Submitted 28 October, 2015; v1 submitted 6 May, 2013; originally announced May 2013.

Comments: 21 pages; v2: misprints in Eqs. 2.17 and 4.9 corrected; v3: misprints in A.5 and A.6 corrected

Report number: DAMTP-2013-16, LPTENS-13/10, CERN-PH-TH/2013-092

Radial Coordinates for Conformal Blocks

Authors: Matthijs Hogervorst, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: We develop the theory of conformal blocks in CFT_d expressing them as power series with Gegenbauer polynomial coefficients. Such series have a clear physical meaning when the conformal block is analyzed in radial quantization: individual terms describe contributions of descendants of a given spin. Convergence of these series can be optimized by a judicious choice of the radial quantization origin.… ▽ More We develop the theory of conformal blocks in CFT_d expressing them as power series with Gegenbauer polynomial coefficients. Such series have a clear physical meaning when the conformal block is analyzed in radial quantization: individual terms describe contributions of descendants of a given spin. Convergence of these series can be optimized by a judicious choice of the radial quantization origin. We argue that the best choice is to insert the operators symmetrically. We analyze in detail the resulting "rho-series" and show that it converges much more rapidly than for the commonly used variable z. We discuss how these conformal block representations can be used in the conformal bootstrap. In particular, we use them to derive analytically some bootstrap bounds whose existence was previously found numerically. △ Less

Submitted 21 March, 2013; v1 submitted 5 March, 2013; originally announced March 2013.

Comments: 27 pages, 9 figures; v2: misprints corrected

Report number: CERN-PH-TH/2013-043, LPTENS-13/05

OPE Convergence in Conformal Field Theory

Authors: Duccio Pappadopulo, Slava Rychkov, Johnny Espin, Riccardo Rattazzi

Abstract: We clarify questions related to the convergence of the OPE and conformal block decomposition in unitary Conformal Field Theories (for any number of spacetime dimensions). In particular, we explain why these expansions are convergent in a finite region. We also show that the convergence is exponentially fast, in the sense that the operators of dimension above Delta contribute to correlation functio… ▽ More We clarify questions related to the convergence of the OPE and conformal block decomposition in unitary Conformal Field Theories (for any number of spacetime dimensions). In particular, we explain why these expansions are convergent in a finite region. We also show that the convergence is exponentially fast, in the sense that the operators of dimension above Delta contribute to correlation functions at most exp(-a Delta). Here the constant a>0 depends on the positions of operator insertions and we compute it explicitly. △ Less

Submitted 12 June, 2015; v1 submitted 31 August, 2012; originally announced August 2012.

Comments: 26 pages, 6 figures; v2: a clarifying note and two refs added; v3: note added concerning an extra constant factor in the main error estimate, misprint corrected

Report number: LPTENS-12/31

Solving the 3D Ising Model with the Conformal Bootstrap

Authors: Sheer El-Showk, Miguel F. Paulos, David Poland, Slava Rychkov, David Simmons-Duffin, Alessandro Vichi

Abstract: We study the constraints of crossing symmetry and unitarity in general 3D Conformal Field Theories. In doing so we derive new results for conformal blocks appearing in four-point functions of scalars and present an efficient method for their computation in arbitrary space-time dimension. Comparing the resulting bounds on operator dimensions and OPE coefficients in 3D to known results, we find that… ▽ More We study the constraints of crossing symmetry and unitarity in general 3D Conformal Field Theories. In doing so we derive new results for conformal blocks appearing in four-point functions of scalars and present an efficient method for their computation in arbitrary space-time dimension. Comparing the resulting bounds on operator dimensions and OPE coefficients in 3D to known results, we find that the 3D Ising model lies at a corner point on the boundary of the allowed parameter space. We also derive general upper bounds on the dimensions of higher spin operators, relevant in the context of theories with weakly broken higher spin symmetries. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2012; v1 submitted 27 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: 32 pages, 11 figures; v2: refs added, small changes in Section 5.3, Fig. 7 replaced; v3: ref added, fits redone in Section 5.4

Report number: LPTENS-12/07

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 86, 025022 (2012)

Conformal Bootstrap in Three Dimensions?

Authors: Slava Rychkov

Abstract: We discuss an idea of how 3D critical exponents can be determined by Conformal Field Theory techniques. We discuss an idea of how 3D critical exponents can be determined by Conformal Field Theory techniques. △ Less

Submitted 9 November, 2011; originally announced November 2011.

Comments: 16 pages, 5 figures

Report number: LPTENS-11/44

Spinning Conformal Blocks

Authors: Miguel S. Costa, Joao Penedones, David Poland, Slava Rychkov

Abstract: For conformal field theories in arbitrary dimensions, we introduce a method to derive the conformal blocks corresponding to the exchange of a traceless symmetric tensor appearing in four point functions of operators with spin. Using the embedding space formalism, we show that one can express all such conformal blocks in terms of simple differential operators acting on the basic scalar conformal bl… ▽ More For conformal field theories in arbitrary dimensions, we introduce a method to derive the conformal blocks corresponding to the exchange of a traceless symmetric tensor appearing in four point functions of operators with spin. Using the embedding space formalism, we show that one can express all such conformal blocks in terms of simple differential operators acting on the basic scalar conformal blocks. This method gives all conformal blocks for conformal field theories in three dimensions. We demonstrate how this formalism can be applied in a few simple examples. △ Less

Submitted 28 September, 2011; originally announced September 2011.

Comments: 29 pages

Report number: LPTENS-11/37

Journal ref: JHEP 1111 (2011) 154