-
Renormalization Group in far-from-equilibrium states
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Michael Smolkin
Abstract:
We study renormalization group flows in far-from-equilibrium states. The study is made tractable by focusing on states that are spatially homogeneous, time-independent, and scale-invariant. Such states, in which mode $k$ has occupation numbers $n_k \sim k^{-γ}$, are well known in nonlinear physics. RG flow in such states is qualitatively different from that in the vacuum -- a positive $γ$ decrease…
▽ More
We study renormalization group flows in far-from-equilibrium states. The study is made tractable by focusing on states that are spatially homogeneous, time-independent, and scale-invariant. Such states, in which mode $k$ has occupation numbers $n_k \sim k^{-γ}$, are well known in nonlinear physics. RG flow in such states is qualitatively different from that in the vacuum -- a positive $γ$ decreases the dimension of an operator, turning marginal interactions into relevant interactions. We compute one-loop beta functions. Depending on the sign of the beta function, backreaction may either cause a minor shift of the state in the IR, or completely change the nature of the state. Focusing on nearly marginal interactions, we construct an analog of the epsilon expansion and IR fixed points, with epsilon now set by the scaling of the interaction rather than the spacetime dimension. In the language of RG flow, critical-balance scaling -- which has applications in fields as varied as astrophysics and ocean waves -- corresponds to the state dynamically adjusting itself along the RG flow until the interaction becomes marginal.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Beyond the Boltzmann equation for weakly coupled quantum fields
Authors:
Xu-Yao Hu,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
We study the kinetic theory of a weakly interacting quantum field. Assuming a state that is close to homogeneous and stationary, we derive a closed kinetic equation for the rate of change of the occupation numbers, perturbatively in the coupling. For a dilute gas, this reproduces the quantum Boltzmann equation, which only accounts for two-to-two scattering processes. Our expression goes beyond thi…
▽ More
We study the kinetic theory of a weakly interacting quantum field. Assuming a state that is close to homogeneous and stationary, we derive a closed kinetic equation for the rate of change of the occupation numbers, perturbatively in the coupling. For a dilute gas, this reproduces the quantum Boltzmann equation, which only accounts for two-to-two scattering processes. Our expression goes beyond this, with terms accounting for multi-particle scattering processes, which are higher order in the density.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Weak and strong turbulence in self-focusing and defocusing media
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Gregory Falkovich
Abstract:
While the focusing and defocusing Nonlinear Schrodinger Equations have similar behavior in the weak turbulence regime, they must differ dramatically in the strong turbulence regime. Here, we show that this difference is already present at next-to-leading order in the nonlinearity in the weak turbulence regime: The one-loop correction to the interaction vertex suppresses repulsion (like screening i…
▽ More
While the focusing and defocusing Nonlinear Schrodinger Equations have similar behavior in the weak turbulence regime, they must differ dramatically in the strong turbulence regime. Here, we show that this difference is already present at next-to-leading order in the nonlinearity in the weak turbulence regime: The one-loop correction to the interaction vertex suppresses repulsion (like screening in electrodynamics), leading to a steeper spectrum in the defocusing case. In contrast, attraction enhancement (like antiscreening in chromodynamics) makes the spectrum less steep in the focusing case. To describe strong turbulence, we consider a vector model in the limit of a large number of components. A large-N kinetic equation, valid at all scales, can be derived analytically. It has an inverse-cascade solution whose two asymptotics, at high and low wavenumbers, describe weak and strong turbulence, respectively. We find two forms of universality in the strong turbulence spectrum: in focusing media it is independent of the flux magnitude, while in defocusing media it is independent of the bare coupling constant, with the largest scale appearing instead.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Strong wave turbulence in strongly local large $N$ theories
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Daniel Schubring
Abstract:
We study wave turbulence in systems with two special properties: a large number of fields (large $N$) and a nonlinear interaction that is strongly local in momentum space. The first property allows us to find the kinetic equation at all interaction strengths -- both weak and strong, at leading order in $1/N$. The second allows us to turn the kinetic equation -- an integral equation -- into a diffe…
▽ More
We study wave turbulence in systems with two special properties: a large number of fields (large $N$) and a nonlinear interaction that is strongly local in momentum space. The first property allows us to find the kinetic equation at all interaction strengths -- both weak and strong, at leading order in $1/N$. The second allows us to turn the kinetic equation -- an integral equation -- into a differential equation. We find stationary solutions for the occupation number as a function of wave number, valid at all scales. As expected, on the weak coupling end the solutions asymptote to Kolmogorov-Zakharov scaling. On the strong coupling end, they asymptote to either the widely conjectured generalized Phillips spectrum (also known as critical balance), or a Kolmogorov-like scaling exponent.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Loop diagrams in the kinetic theory of waves
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Daniel Schubring,
Md Shaikot Jahan Shuvo,
Michael Smolkin
Abstract:
Recent work has given a systematic way for studying the kinetics of classical weakly interacting waves beyond leading order, having analogies with renormalization in quantum field theory. An important context is weak wave turbulence, occurring for waves which are small in magnitude and weakly interacting, such as those on the surface of the ocean. Here we continue the work of perturbatively comput…
▽ More
Recent work has given a systematic way for studying the kinetics of classical weakly interacting waves beyond leading order, having analogies with renormalization in quantum field theory. An important context is weak wave turbulence, occurring for waves which are small in magnitude and weakly interacting, such as those on the surface of the ocean. Here we continue the work of perturbatively computing correlation functions and the kinetic equation in this far-from-equilibrium state. In particular, we obtain the two-loop kinetic equation for waves with a cubic interaction. Our main result is a simple graphical prescription for the terms in the kinetic equation, at any order in the nonlinearity.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2024; v1 submitted 1 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Interaction renormalization and validity of kinetic equations for turbulent states
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Gregory Falkovich
Abstract:
We consider turbulence of waves that interact weakly via four-wave scattering (sea waves, plasma waves, spin waves, and many others). In the first non-vanishing order in the interaction, the occupation number of waves satisfy a closed kinetic equation which has stationary solutions describing turbulent cascades. We show that a straightforward perturbation theory beyond the kinetic equation gives t…
▽ More
We consider turbulence of waves that interact weakly via four-wave scattering (sea waves, plasma waves, spin waves, and many others). In the first non-vanishing order in the interaction, the occupation number of waves satisfy a closed kinetic equation which has stationary solutions describing turbulent cascades. We show that a straightforward perturbation theory beyond the kinetic equation gives terms that generally diverge both at small (IR) and large (UV) wavenumbers for a direct cascade. The analysis up to the third order identifies the most UV-divergent terms. In order to gain qualitative analytic control, we sum a subset of the most UV divergent term, to all orders, giving a perturbation theory which is generally free from UV divergence, showing that turbulence becomes independent of the dissipation scale when it goes to zero. On the contrary, the ever-present IR divergence means that the effective coupling is parametrically larger than the naive estimate and grows with the pumping scale (similar to anomalous scaling in fluid turbulence). This suggests that the kinetic equation does not describe wave turbulence even of arbitrarily small level if the cascade is sufficiently long. We show that the character of strong turbulence is determined by the sign of the coupling, that is, whether the effective four-wave interaction is enhanced or suppressed by collective effects. The enhancement possibly signals that strong turbulence is dominated by multi-wave bound states (solitons, shocks, cusps), similar to confinement in quantum chromodynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2024; v1 submitted 31 July, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Random coupling model of turbulence as a classical Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model
Authors:
Xu-Yao Hu,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
We point out that a classical analog of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model -- a solvable model of quantum many-body chaos, was studied long ago in the turbulence literature. Motivated by the Navier-Stokes equation in the turbulent regime and the nonlinear Schrödinger equation describing plasma turbulence, in which there is mixing between many different modes, the random coupling model has a Gaussian-rand…
▽ More
We point out that a classical analog of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model -- a solvable model of quantum many-body chaos, was studied long ago in the turbulence literature. Motivated by the Navier-Stokes equation in the turbulent regime and the nonlinear Schrödinger equation describing plasma turbulence, in which there is mixing between many different modes, the random coupling model has a Gaussian-random coupling between any four of a large number $N$ of modes. The model was solved in the 1960s, before the introduction of large $N$ path integral techniques, using a method referred to as the direct interaction approximation. We use the path integral to derive the effective action for the model. The large-$N$ saddle gives an integral equation for the two-point function, which is very similar to the corresponding equation in the SYK model. The connection between the SYK model and the random coupling model may, on the one hand, provide new physical contexts in which to realize the SYK model and, on the other hand, suggest new models of turbulence and techniques for studying them.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2024; v1 submitted 6 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Wave turbulence and the kinetic equation beyond leading order
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Michael Smolkin
Abstract:
We derive a scheme by which to solve the Liouville equation perturbatively in the nonlinearity, which we apply to weakly nonlinear classical field theories. Our solution is a variant of the Prigogine diagrammatic method, and is based on an analogy between the Liouville equation in infinite volume and scattering in quantum mechanics, described by the Lippmann-Schwinger equation. The motivation for…
▽ More
We derive a scheme by which to solve the Liouville equation perturbatively in the nonlinearity, which we apply to weakly nonlinear classical field theories. Our solution is a variant of the Prigogine diagrammatic method, and is based on an analogy between the Liouville equation in infinite volume and scattering in quantum mechanics, described by the Lippmann-Schwinger equation. The motivation for our work is wave turbulence: a broad class of nonlinear classical field theories are believed to have a stationary turbulent state -- a far-from-equilibrium state, even at weak coupling. Our method provides an efficient way to derive properties of the weak wave turbulent state. A central object in these studies, which is a reduction of the Liouville equation, is the kinetic equation, which governs the occupation numbers of the modes. All properties of wave turbulence to date are based on the kinetic equation found at leading order in the weak nonlinearity. We explicitly obtain the kinetic equation to next-to-leading order.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2024; v1 submitted 5 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Photon emission from an excited string
Authors:
Maurizio Firrotta,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
We compute the amplitude for an excited string in any precisely specified state to decay into another excited string in any precisely specified state, via emission of a tachyon or photon. For generic and highly excited string states, the amplitude is a complicated function of the outgoing kinematic angle, sensitive to the precise state. We compute the square of this amplitude, averaged over polari…
▽ More
We compute the amplitude for an excited string in any precisely specified state to decay into another excited string in any precisely specified state, via emission of a tachyon or photon. For generic and highly excited string states, the amplitude is a complicated function of the outgoing kinematic angle, sensitive to the precise state. We compute the square of this amplitude, averaged over polarizations of the ingoing string and summed over polarizations of the outgoing string. The seeming intractability of these calculations is made possible by extracting amplitudes involving excited strings from amplitudes involving tachyons and a large number of photons; the number of photons grows with the complexity of the excited string state. Our work is in the spirit of the broad range of recent studies of statistical mechanics and chaos for quantum many-body systems. The number of different excited string states at a given mass is exponentially large, and our calculation gives the emission amplitude of a single photon from each of the microstates -- which, through the Horowitz-Polchinski correspondence principle, are in correspondence with black hole microstates.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2022; v1 submitted 4 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Correlation functions in linear chaotic maps
Authors:
Xu-Yao Hu,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
The simplest examples of chaotic maps are linear, area-preserving maps on the circle, torus, or product of tori; respectively known as the Bernoulli map, the cat map, and the recently introduced "spatiotemporal" cat map. We study correlation functions in these maps. For the Bernoulli map, we compute the correlation functions in a variety of ways: by direct computation of the integral, through Four…
▽ More
The simplest examples of chaotic maps are linear, area-preserving maps on the circle, torus, or product of tori; respectively known as the Bernoulli map, the cat map, and the recently introduced "spatiotemporal" cat map. We study correlation functions in these maps. For the Bernoulli map, we compute the correlation functions in a variety of ways: by direct computation of the integral, through Fourier series, through symbolic dynamics, and through periodic orbits. In relation to the more standard treatment in terms of eigenfunctions of the Perron-Frobenius operator, some of these methods are simpler and also extend to multipoint correlation functions. For the cat map, we compute correlation functions through a Fourier expansion, review and expand on a prior treatment of two-point functions by Crawford and Cary, and discuss the limitations of shadowing. Finally, for the spatiotemporal cat map -- intended to be a model of many-body chaos -- we show that connected correlation functions of local operators vanish.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Feynman rules for forced wave turbulence
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Michael Smolkin
Abstract:
It has long been known that weakly nonlinear field theories can have a late-time stationary state that is not the thermal state, but a wave turbulent state with a far-from-equilibrium cascade of energy. We go beyond the existence of the wave turbulent state, studying fluctuations about the wave turbulent state. Specifically, we take a classical field theory with an arbitrary quartic interaction an…
▽ More
It has long been known that weakly nonlinear field theories can have a late-time stationary state that is not the thermal state, but a wave turbulent state with a far-from-equilibrium cascade of energy. We go beyond the existence of the wave turbulent state, studying fluctuations about the wave turbulent state. Specifically, we take a classical field theory with an arbitrary quartic interaction and add dissipation and Gaussian-random forcing. Employing the path integral relation between stochastic classical field theories and quantum field theories, we give a prescription, in terms of Feynman diagrams, for computing correlation functions in this system. We explicitly compute the two-point and four-point functions of the field to next-to-leading order in the coupling. Through an appropriate choice of forcing and dissipation, these correspond to correlation functions in the wave turbulent state. In particular, we derive the kinetic equation to next-to-leading order.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2024; v1 submitted 15 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Chaos in a many-string scattering amplitude
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
String theory provides a compact integral expression for the tree-level scattering amplitude of an arbitrary number of light strings. We focus on amplitudes involving a few tachyons and many photons, with a special choice of polarizations and kinematics. We pick out a particular pole in the amplitude -- one corresponding to successive photon scatterings, which lead to an intermediate state with a…
▽ More
String theory provides a compact integral expression for the tree-level scattering amplitude of an arbitrary number of light strings. We focus on amplitudes involving a few tachyons and many photons, with a special choice of polarizations and kinematics. We pick out a particular pole in the amplitude -- one corresponding to successive photon scatterings, which lead to an intermediate state with a highly excited string in a definite state. This provides a physical process which creates a highly excited string. The observed erratic behavior of the amplitude suggests that this may serve as a simple and explicit illustration of chaos in many-particle scattering.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2022; v1 submitted 19 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Chaotic scattering of highly excited strings
Authors:
David J. Gross,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
Motivated by the desire to understand chaos in the $S$-matrix of string theory, we study tree level scattering amplitudes involving highly excited strings. While the amplitudes for scattering of light strings have been a hallmark of string theory since its early days, scattering of excited strings has been far less studied. Recent results on black hole chaos, combined with the correspondence princ…
▽ More
Motivated by the desire to understand chaos in the $S$-matrix of string theory, we study tree level scattering amplitudes involving highly excited strings. While the amplitudes for scattering of light strings have been a hallmark of string theory since its early days, scattering of excited strings has been far less studied. Recent results on black hole chaos, combined with the correspondence principle between black holes and strings, suggest that the amplitudes have a rich structure. We review the procedure by which an excited string is formed by repeatedly scattering photons off of an initial tachyon (the DDF formalism). We compute the scattering amplitude of one arbitrary excited string and any number of tachyons in bosonic string theory. At high energies and high mass excited state these amplitudes are determined by a saddle-point in the integration over the positions of the string vertex operators on the sphere (or the upper half plane), thus yielding a generalization of the "scattering equations". We find a compact expression for the amplitude of an excited string decaying into two tachyons, and study its properties for a generic excited string. We find the amplitude is highly erratic as a function of both the precise excited string state and of the tachyon scattering angle relative to its polarization, a sign of chaos.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2021; v1 submitted 28 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
The background field method and critical vector models
Authors:
Mikhail Goykhman,
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Michael Smolkin
Abstract:
We use the background field method to systematically derive CFT data for the critical $φ^6$ vector model in three dimensions, and the Gross-Neveu model in dimensions $2\leq d \leq 4$. Specifically, we calculate the OPE coefficients and anomalous dimensions of various operators, up to next-to-leading order in the $1/N$ expansion.
We use the background field method to systematically derive CFT data for the critical $φ^6$ vector model in three dimensions, and the Gross-Neveu model in dimensions $2\leq d \leq 4$. Specifically, we calculate the OPE coefficients and anomalous dimensions of various operators, up to next-to-leading order in the $1/N$ expansion.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2021; v1 submitted 28 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Chaos in the Quantum Field Theory $S$-matrix
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
A number of studies have shown that chaos occurs in scattering: the outgoing deflection angle is seen to be an erratic function of the impact parameter. We propose to extend this to quantum field theory, and to use erratic behavior of the many-particle $S$-matrix as a probe of chaos.
A number of studies have shown that chaos occurs in scattering: the outgoing deflection angle is seen to be an erratic function of the impact parameter. We propose to extend this to quantum field theory, and to use erratic behavior of the many-particle $S$-matrix as a probe of chaos.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2021; v1 submitted 16 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Integrability and Renormalization under $T \bar T$
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Michael Smolkin
Abstract:
Smirnov and Zamolodchikov recently introduced a new class of two-dimensional quantum field theories, defined through a differential change of any existing theory by the determinant of the energy-momentum tensor. From this $T\bar T$ flow equation one can find a simple expression for both the energy spectrum and the $S$-matrix of the $T\bar T$ deformed theories. Our goal is to find the renormalized…
▽ More
Smirnov and Zamolodchikov recently introduced a new class of two-dimensional quantum field theories, defined through a differential change of any existing theory by the determinant of the energy-momentum tensor. From this $T\bar T$ flow equation one can find a simple expression for both the energy spectrum and the $S$-matrix of the $T\bar T$ deformed theories. Our goal is to find the renormalized Lagrangian of the $T\bar T$ deformed theories. In the context of the $T\bar T$ deformation of an integrable theory, the deformed theory is also integrable and, correspondingly, the $S$-matrix factorizes into two-to-two $S$-matrices. One may thus hope to be able to extract the renormalized Lagrangian from the $S$-matrix. We do this explicitly for the $T\bar T$ deformation of a free massive scalar, to second order in the deformation parameter. Once one has the renormalized Lagrangian one can, in principle, compute all other observables, such as correlation functions. We briefly discuss this, as well as the relation between the renormalized Lagrangian, the $T\bar T$ flow equation, and the $S$-matrix. We also mention a more general class of integrability-preserving deformations of a free scalar field theory.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2020; v1 submitted 5 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Multipoint Conformal Blocks in the Comb Channel
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
Conformal blocks are the building blocks for correlation functions in conformal field theories. The four-point function is the most well-studied case. We consider conformal blocks for $n$-point correlation functions. For conformal field theories in dimensions $d=1$ and $d=2$, we use the shadow formalism to compute $n$-point conformal blocks, for arbitrary $n$, in a particular channel which we refe…
▽ More
Conformal blocks are the building blocks for correlation functions in conformal field theories. The four-point function is the most well-studied case. We consider conformal blocks for $n$-point correlation functions. For conformal field theories in dimensions $d=1$ and $d=2$, we use the shadow formalism to compute $n$-point conformal blocks, for arbitrary $n$, in a particular channel which we refer to as the comb channel. The result is expressed in terms of a multivariable hypergeometric function, for which we give series, differential, and integral representations. In general dimension $d$ we derive the $5$-point conformal block, for external and exchanged scalar operators.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
$d$-dimensional SYK, AdS Loops, and $6j$ Symbols
Authors:
Junyu Liu,
Eric Perlmutter,
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
David Simmons-Duffin
Abstract:
We study the $6j$ symbol for the conformal group, and its appearance in three seemingly unrelated contexts: the SYK model, conformal representation theory, and perturbative amplitudes in AdS. The contribution of the planar Feynman diagrams to the three-point function of the bilinear singlets in SYK is shown to be a $6j$ symbol. We generalize the computation of these and other Feynman diagrams to…
▽ More
We study the $6j$ symbol for the conformal group, and its appearance in three seemingly unrelated contexts: the SYK model, conformal representation theory, and perturbative amplitudes in AdS. The contribution of the planar Feynman diagrams to the three-point function of the bilinear singlets in SYK is shown to be a $6j$ symbol. We generalize the computation of these and other Feynman diagrams to $d$ dimensions. The $6j$ symbol can be viewed as the crossing kernel for conformal partial waves, which may be computed using the Lorentzian inversion formula. We provide closed-form expressions for $6j$ symbols in $d=1,2,4$. In AdS, we show that the $6j$ symbol is the Lorentzian inversion of a crossing-symmetric tree-level exchange amplitude, thus efficiently packaging the double-trace OPE data. Finally, we consider one-loop diagrams in AdS with internal scalars and external spinning operators, and show that the triangle diagram is a $6j$ symbol, while one-loop $n$-gon diagrams are built out of $6j$ symbols.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2019; v1 submitted 1 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
An introduction to the SYK model
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
These notes are a short introduction to the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model. We discuss: SYK and tensor models as a new class of large N quantum field theories, the near-conformal invariance in the infrared, the computation of correlation functions, generalizations of SYK, and applications to AdS/CFT and strange metals.
These notes are a short introduction to the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model. We discuss: SYK and tensor models as a new class of large N quantum field theories, the near-conformal invariance in the infrared, the computation of correlation functions, generalizations of SYK, and applications to AdS/CFT and strange metals.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
All point correlation functions in SYK
Authors:
David J. Gross,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
Large $N$ melonic theories are characterized by two-point function Feynman diagrams built exclusively out of melons. This leads to conformal invariance at strong coupling, four-point function diagrams that are exclusively ladders, and higher-point functions that are built out of four-point functions joined together. We uncover an incredibly useful property of these theories: the six-point function…
▽ More
Large $N$ melonic theories are characterized by two-point function Feynman diagrams built exclusively out of melons. This leads to conformal invariance at strong coupling, four-point function diagrams that are exclusively ladders, and higher-point functions that are built out of four-point functions joined together. We uncover an incredibly useful property of these theories: the six-point function, or equivalently, the three-point function of the primary $O(N)$ invariant bilinears, regarded as an analytic function of the operator dimensions, fully determines all correlation functions, to leading nontrivial order in $1/N$, through simple Feynman-like rules. The result is applicable to any theory, not necessarily melonic, in which higher-point correlators are built out of four-point functions. We explicitly calculate the bilinear three-point function for $q$-body SYK, at any $q$. This leads to the bilinear four-point function, as well as all higher-point functions, expressed in terms of higher-point conformal blocks, which we discuss. We find universality of correlators of operators of large dimension, which we simplify through a saddle point analysis. We comment on the implications for the AdS dual of SYK.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2017; v1 submitted 23 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
A line of CFTs: from generalized free fields to SYK
Authors:
David J. Gross,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
We point out that there is a simple variant of the SYK model, which we call cSYK, that is $SL(2,R)$ invariant for all values of the coupling. The modification consists of replacing the UV part of the SYK action with a quadratic bilocal term. The corresponding bulk dual is a non-gravitational theory in a rigid AdS$_2$ background. At weak coupling cSYK is a generalized free field theory; at strong c…
▽ More
We point out that there is a simple variant of the SYK model, which we call cSYK, that is $SL(2,R)$ invariant for all values of the coupling. The modification consists of replacing the UV part of the SYK action with a quadratic bilocal term. The corresponding bulk dual is a non-gravitational theory in a rigid AdS$_2$ background. At weak coupling cSYK is a generalized free field theory; at strong coupling, it approaches the infrared of SYK. The existence of this line of fixed points explains the previously found connection between the three-point function of bilinears in these two theories at large $q$.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2017; v1 submitted 21 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
The Bulk Dual of SYK: Cubic Couplings
Authors:
David J. Gross,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
The SYK model, a quantum mechanical model of $N \gg 1$ Majorana fermions $χ_i$, with a $q$-body, random interaction, is a novel realization of holography. It is known that the AdS$_2$ dual contains a tower of massive particles, yet there is at present no proposal for the bulk theory. As SYK is solvable in the $1/N$ expansion, one can systematically derive the bulk. We initiate such a program, by a…
▽ More
The SYK model, a quantum mechanical model of $N \gg 1$ Majorana fermions $χ_i$, with a $q$-body, random interaction, is a novel realization of holography. It is known that the AdS$_2$ dual contains a tower of massive particles, yet there is at present no proposal for the bulk theory. As SYK is solvable in the $1/N$ expansion, one can systematically derive the bulk. We initiate such a program, by analyzing the fermion two, four and six-point functions, from which we extract the tower of singlet, large $N$ dominant, operators, their dimensions, and their three-point correlation functions. These determine the masses of the bulk fields and their cubic couplings. We present these couplings, analyze their structure and discuss the simplifications that arise for large $q$.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2017; v1 submitted 26 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
A Generalization of Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev
Authors:
David J. Gross,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
The SYK model: fermions with a $q$-body, Gaussian-random, all-to-all interaction, is the first of a fascinating new class of solvable large $N$ models. We generalize SYK to include $f$ flavors of fermions, each occupying $N_a$ sites and appearing with a $q_a$ order in the interaction. Like SYK, this entire class of models generically has an infrared fixed point. We compute the infrared dimensions…
▽ More
The SYK model: fermions with a $q$-body, Gaussian-random, all-to-all interaction, is the first of a fascinating new class of solvable large $N$ models. We generalize SYK to include $f$ flavors of fermions, each occupying $N_a$ sites and appearing with a $q_a$ order in the interaction. Like SYK, this entire class of models generically has an infrared fixed point. We compute the infrared dimensions of the fermions, and the spectrum of singlet bilinear operators. We show that there is always a dimension-two operator in the spectrum, which implies that, like in SYK, there is breaking of conformal invariance and maximal chaos in the infrared four-point function of the generalized model. After a disorder average, the generalized model has a global $O(N_1) \times O(N_2) \times \ldots\times O(N_f)$ symmetry: a subgroup of the $O(N)$ symmetry of SYK; thereby giving a richer spectrum. We also elucidate aspects of the large $q$ limit and the OPE, and solve $q=2$ SYK at finite $N$.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2017; v1 submitted 5 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Four-point function in the IOP matrix model
Authors:
Ben Michel,
Joseph Polchinski,
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
S. Josephine Suh
Abstract:
The IOP model is a quantum mechanical system of a large-$N$ matrix oscillator and a fundamental oscillator, coupled through a quartic interaction. It was introduced previously as a toy model of the gauge dual of an AdS black hole, and captures a key property that at infinite $N$ the two-point function decays to zero on long time scales. Motivated by recent work on quantum chaos, we sum all planar…
▽ More
The IOP model is a quantum mechanical system of a large-$N$ matrix oscillator and a fundamental oscillator, coupled through a quartic interaction. It was introduced previously as a toy model of the gauge dual of an AdS black hole, and captures a key property that at infinite $N$ the two-point function decays to zero on long time scales. Motivated by recent work on quantum chaos, we sum all planar Feynman diagrams contributing to the four-point function. We find that the IOP model does not satisfy the more refined criteria of exponential growth of the out-of-time-order four-point function.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
The Spectrum in the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev Model
Authors:
Joseph Polchinski,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
The SYK model consists of $N\gg 1$ fermions in $0+1$ dimensions with a random, all-to-all quartic interaction. Recently, Kitaev has found that the SYK model is maximally chaotic and has proposed it as a model of holography. We solve the Schwinger-Dyson equation and compute the spectrum of two-particle states in SYK, finding both a continuous and discrete tower. The four-point function is expressed…
▽ More
The SYK model consists of $N\gg 1$ fermions in $0+1$ dimensions with a random, all-to-all quartic interaction. Recently, Kitaev has found that the SYK model is maximally chaotic and has proposed it as a model of holography. We solve the Schwinger-Dyson equation and compute the spectrum of two-particle states in SYK, finding both a continuous and discrete tower. The four-point function is expressed as a sum over the spectrum. The sum over the discrete tower is evaluated.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Entanglement and RG in the $O(N)$ vector model
Authors:
Chris Akers,
Omer Ben-Ami,
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Michael Smolkin,
Shimon Yankielowicz
Abstract:
We consider the large $N$ interacting vector $O(N)$ model on a sphere in $4-ε$ Euclidean dimensions. The Gaussian theory in the UV is taken to be either conformally or non-conformally coupled. The endpoint of the RG flow corresponds to a conformally coupled scalar field at the Wilson-Fisher fixed point. We take a spherical entangling surface in de Sitter space and compute the entanglement entropy…
▽ More
We consider the large $N$ interacting vector $O(N)$ model on a sphere in $4-ε$ Euclidean dimensions. The Gaussian theory in the UV is taken to be either conformally or non-conformally coupled. The endpoint of the RG flow corresponds to a conformally coupled scalar field at the Wilson-Fisher fixed point. We take a spherical entangling surface in de Sitter space and compute the entanglement entropy everywhere along the RG trajectory. In $4$ dimensions, a free non-conformal scalar has a universal area term scaling with the logarithm of the UV cutoff. In $4-ε$ dimensions, such a term scales as $1/ε$. For a non-conformal scalar, a $1/ε$ term is present both at the UV fixed point, and its vicinity. For flow between two conformal fixed points, $1/ε$ terms are absent everywhere. Finally, we make contact with replica trick calculations. The conical singularity gives rise to boundary terms residing on the entangling surface, which are usually discarded. Consistency with our results requires they be kept. We argue that, in fact, this conclusion also follows from the work of Metlitski, Fuertes, and Sachdev, which demonstrated that such boundary terms will be generated through quantum corrections.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Bulk-Boundary Duality, Gauge Invariance, and Quantum Error Correction
Authors:
Eric Mintun,
Joseph Polchinski,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
Recently, Almheiri, Dong, and Harlow have argued that the localization of bulk information in a boundary dual should be understood in terms of quantum error correction. We show that this structure appears naturally when the gauge invariance of the boundary theory is incorporated. This provides a new understanding of the non-uniqueness of the bulk fields (precursors). It suggests a close connection…
▽ More
Recently, Almheiri, Dong, and Harlow have argued that the localization of bulk information in a boundary dual should be understood in terms of quantum error correction. We show that this structure appears naturally when the gauge invariance of the boundary theory is incorporated. This provides a new understanding of the non-uniqueness of the bulk fields (precursors). It suggests a close connection between gauge invariance and the emergence of spacetime.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2015; v1 submitted 26 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Entanglement Entropy for Relevant and Geometric Perturbations
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Michael Smolkin
Abstract:
We continue the study of entanglement entropy for a QFT through a perturbative expansion of the path integral definition of the reduced density matrix. The universal entanglement entropy for a CFT perturbed by a relevant operator is calculated to second order in the coupling. We also explore the geometric dependence of entanglement entropy for a deformed planar entangling surface, finding surprise…
▽ More
We continue the study of entanglement entropy for a QFT through a perturbative expansion of the path integral definition of the reduced density matrix. The universal entanglement entropy for a CFT perturbed by a relevant operator is calculated to second order in the coupling. We also explore the geometric dependence of entanglement entropy for a deformed planar entangling surface, finding surprises at second order.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2015; v1 submitted 23 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Entanglement entropy, planar surfaces, and spectral functions
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Michael Smolkin
Abstract:
We consider the universal part of entanglement entropy across a plane in flat space for a QFT, giving a non-perturbative expression in terms of a spectral function. We study the change in entanglement entropy under a deformation by a relevant operator, providing a pertrubative expansion where the terms are correlation functions in the undeformed theory. The entanglement entropy for free massive fe…
▽ More
We consider the universal part of entanglement entropy across a plane in flat space for a QFT, giving a non-perturbative expression in terms of a spectral function. We study the change in entanglement entropy under a deformation by a relevant operator, providing a pertrubative expansion where the terms are correlation functions in the undeformed theory. The entanglement entropy for free massive fermions and scalars easily follows. Finally, we study entanglement entropy across a plane in a background geometry that is a deformation of flat space, finding new universal terms arising from mixing of geometry and couplings of the QFT.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2014; v1 submitted 10 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Entanglement Entropy Flow and the Ward Identity
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Michael Smolkin
Abstract:
We derive differential equations for the flow of entanglement entropy as a function of the metric and the couplings of the theory. The variation of the universal part of entanglement entropy under a local Weyl transformation is related to the variation under a local change in the couplings. We show that this relation is in fact equivalent to the trace Ward identity. As a concrete application of ou…
▽ More
We derive differential equations for the flow of entanglement entropy as a function of the metric and the couplings of the theory. The variation of the universal part of entanglement entropy under a local Weyl transformation is related to the variation under a local change in the couplings. We show that this relation is in fact equivalent to the trace Ward identity. As a concrete application of our formalism, we express the entanglement entropy for massive free fields as a two-point function of the energy-momentum tensor.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2014; v1 submitted 10 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Scanning Tunneling Macroscopy, Black Holes, and AdS/CFT Bulk Locality
Authors:
Soo-Jong Rey,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
We establish resolution bounds on reconstructing a bulk field from boundary data on a timelike hypersurface. If the bulk only supports propagating modes, reconstruction is complete. If the bulk also supports evanescent modes, local reconstruction is not achievable unless one has exponential precision in knowledge of the boundary data. Without exponential precision, for a Minkowski bulk, one can re…
▽ More
We establish resolution bounds on reconstructing a bulk field from boundary data on a timelike hypersurface. If the bulk only supports propagating modes, reconstruction is complete. If the bulk also supports evanescent modes, local reconstruction is not achievable unless one has exponential precision in knowledge of the boundary data. Without exponential precision, for a Minkowski bulk, one can reconstruct a spatially coarse-grained bulk field, but only out to a depth set by the coarse-graining scale. For an asymptotically AdS bulk, reconstruction is limited to a spatial coarse-graining proper distance set by the AdS scale. AdS black holes admit evanescent modes. We study the resolution bound in the large AdS black hole background and provide a dual CFT interpretation. Our results demonstrate that, if there is a black hole of any size in the bulk, then sub-AdS bulk locality is no longer well-encoded in boundary data in terms of local CFT operators. Specifically, in order to probe the bulk on sub-AdS scales using only boundary data in terms of local operators, one must either have such data to exponential precision or make further assumptions about the bulk state.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2014; v1 submitted 16 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Entanglement Entropy: A Perturbative Calculation
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Michael Smolkin
Abstract:
We provide a framework for a perturbative evaluation of the reduced density matrix. The method is based on a path integral in the analytically continued spacetime. It suggests an alternative to the holographic and `standard' replica trick calculations of entanglement entropy. We implement this method within solvable field theory examples to evaluate leading order corrections induced by small pertu…
▽ More
We provide a framework for a perturbative evaluation of the reduced density matrix. The method is based on a path integral in the analytically continued spacetime. It suggests an alternative to the holographic and `standard' replica trick calculations of entanglement entropy. We implement this method within solvable field theory examples to evaluate leading order corrections induced by small perturbations in the geometry of the background and entangling surface. Our findings are in accord with Solodukhin's formula for the universal term of entanglement entropy for four dimensional CFTs.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2014; v1 submitted 14 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Holography for a small world
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
The holographic principle asserts that the complete description of the interior of a sphere is a theory which not only lives on the surface of the sphere, but also has A/4 binary degrees of freedom. In this context we revisit the question of whether AdS/CFT is fully holographic. We construct states which are localized deep in the interior yet are encoded on short scales in the CFT, seemingly in co…
▽ More
The holographic principle asserts that the complete description of the interior of a sphere is a theory which not only lives on the surface of the sphere, but also has A/4 binary degrees of freedom. In this context we revisit the question of whether AdS/CFT is fully holographic. We construct states which are localized deep in the interior yet are encoded on short scales in the CFT, seemingly in conflict with the UV/IR prescription. We make a proposal to address the more basic question of which CFT states are sufficient to describe physics within a certain region of the bulk.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2014; v1 submitted 17 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
AdS black holes, the bulk-boundary dictionary, and smearing functions
Authors:
Stefan Leichenauer,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
In Lorentzian AdS/CFT there exists a mapping between local bulk operators and nonlocal CFT operators. In global AdS this mapping can be found through use of bulk equations of motion and allows the nonlocal CFT operator to be expressed as a local operator smeared over a range of positions and times. We argue that such a construction is not possible if there are bulk normal modes with exponentially…
▽ More
In Lorentzian AdS/CFT there exists a mapping between local bulk operators and nonlocal CFT operators. In global AdS this mapping can be found through use of bulk equations of motion and allows the nonlocal CFT operator to be expressed as a local operator smeared over a range of positions and times. We argue that such a construction is not possible if there are bulk normal modes with exponentially small near boundary imprint. We show that the AdS-Schwarzschild background is such a case, with the horizon introducing modes with angular momentum much larger than frequency, causing them to be trapped by the centrifugal barrier. More generally, we argue that any barrier in the radial effective potential which prevents null geodesics from reaching the boundary will lead to modes with vanishingly small near boundary imprint, thereby obstructing the existence of a smearing function. While one may have thought the bulk-boundary dictionary for low curvature regions, such as the exterior of a black hole, should be as in empty AdS, our results demonstrate otherwise.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2013; v1 submitted 25 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Null Geodesics, Local CFT Operators and AdS/CFT for Subregions
Authors:
Raphael Bousso,
Ben Freivogel,
Stefan Leichenauer,
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Claire Zukowski
Abstract:
We investigate the nature of the AdS/CFT duality between a subregion of the bulk and its boundary. In global AdS/CFT in the classical G_N=0 limit, the duality reduces to a boundary value problem that can be solved by restricting to one-point functions of local operators in the CFT. We show that the solution of this boundary value problem depends continuously on the CFT data. In contrast, the AdS-R…
▽ More
We investigate the nature of the AdS/CFT duality between a subregion of the bulk and its boundary. In global AdS/CFT in the classical G_N=0 limit, the duality reduces to a boundary value problem that can be solved by restricting to one-point functions of local operators in the CFT. We show that the solution of this boundary value problem depends continuously on the CFT data. In contrast, the AdS-Rindler subregion cannot be continuously reconstructed from local CFT data restricted to the associated boundary region. Motivated by related results in the mathematics literature, we posit that a continuous bulk reconstruction is only possible when every null geodesic in a given bulk subregion has an endpoint on the associated boundary subregion. This suggests that a subregion duality for AdS-Rindler, if it exists, must involve nonlocal CFT operators in an essential way.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2013; v1 submitted 20 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Light-sheets and AdS/CFT
Authors:
Raphael Bousso,
Stefan Leichenauer,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
One may ask whether the CFT restricted to a subset b of the AdS boundary has a well-defined dual restricted to a subset H(b) of the bulk geometry. The Poincare patch is an example, but more general choices of b can be considered. We propose a geometric construction of H. We argue that H should contain the set C of causal curves with both endpoints on b. Yet H should not reach so far from the bound…
▽ More
One may ask whether the CFT restricted to a subset b of the AdS boundary has a well-defined dual restricted to a subset H(b) of the bulk geometry. The Poincare patch is an example, but more general choices of b can be considered. We propose a geometric construction of H. We argue that H should contain the set C of causal curves with both endpoints on b. Yet H should not reach so far from the boundary that the CFT has insufficient degrees of freedom to describe it. This can be guaranteed by constructing a superset of H from light-sheets off boundary slices and invoking the covariant entropy bound in the bulk. The simplest covariant choice is L, the intersection of L^+ and L^-, where L^+ (L^-) is the union of all future-directed (past-directed) light-sheets. We prove that C=L, so the holographic domain is completely determined by our assumptions: H=C=L. In situations where local bulk operators can be constructed on b, H is closely related to the set of bulk points where this construction remains unambiguous under modifications of the CFT Hamiltonian outside of b. Our construction leads to a covariant geometric RG flow. We comment on the description of black hole interiors and cosmological regions via AdS/CFT.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2012; v1 submitted 29 March, 2012;
originally announced March 2012.
-
Geometric origin of coincidences and hierarchies in the landscape
Authors:
Raphael Bousso,
Ben Freivogel,
Stefan Leichenauer,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
We show that the geometry of cutoffs on eternal inflation strongly constrains predictions for the timescales of vacuum domination, curvature domination, and observation. We consider three measure proposals: the causal patch, the fat geodesic, and the apparent horizon cutoff, which is introduced here for the first time. We impose neither anthropic requirements nor restrictions on landscape vacua. F…
▽ More
We show that the geometry of cutoffs on eternal inflation strongly constrains predictions for the timescales of vacuum domination, curvature domination, and observation. We consider three measure proposals: the causal patch, the fat geodesic, and the apparent horizon cutoff, which is introduced here for the first time. We impose neither anthropic requirements nor restrictions on landscape vacua. For vacua with positive cosmological constant, all three measures predict the double coincidence that most observers live at the onset of vacuum domination and just before the onset of curvature domination. The hierarchy between the Planck scale and the cosmological constant is related to the number of vacua in the landscape. These results require only mild assumptions about the distribution of vacua (somewhat stronger assumptions are required by the fat geodesic measure). At this level of generality, none of the three measures are successful for vacua with negative cosmological constant. Their applicability in this regime is ruled out unless much stronger anthropic requirements are imposed.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
A geometric solution to the coincidence problem, and the size of the landscape as the origin of hierarchy
Authors:
Raphael Bousso,
Ben Freivogel,
Stefan Leichenauer,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
Without assuming necessary conditions for observers such as galaxies or entropy production, we show that the causal patch measure predicts the coincidence of vacuum energy and present matter density. Their common scale, and thus the enormous size of the visible universe, has its origin in the number of metastable vacua in the landscape.
Without assuming necessary conditions for observers such as galaxies or entropy production, we show that the causal patch measure predicts the coincidence of vacuum energy and present matter density. Their common scale, and thus the enormous size of the visible universe, has its origin in the number of metastable vacua in the landscape.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2010; v1 submitted 2 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
-
Eternal inflation predicts that time will end
Authors:
Raphael Bousso,
Ben Freivogel,
Stefan Leichenauer,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
Present treatments of eternal inflation regulate infinities by imposing a geometric cutoff. We point out that some matter systems reach the cutoff in finite time. This implies a nonzero probability for a novel type of catastrophe. According to the most successful measure proposals, our galaxy is likely to encounter the cutoff within the next 5 billion years.
Present treatments of eternal inflation regulate infinities by imposing a geometric cutoff. We point out that some matter systems reach the cutoff in finite time. This implies a nonzero probability for a novel type of catastrophe. According to the most successful measure proposals, our galaxy is likely to encounter the cutoff within the next 5 billion years.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
-
Boundary definition of a multiverse measure
Authors:
Raphael Bousso,
Ben Freivogel,
Stefan Leichenauer,
Vladimir Rosenhaus
Abstract:
We propose to regulate the infinities of eternal inflation by relating a late time cut-off in the bulk to a short distance cut-off on the future boundary. The light-cone time of an event is defined in terms of the volume of its future light-cone on the boundary. We seek an intrinsic definition of boundary volumes that makes no reference to bulk structures. This requires taming the fractal geometry…
▽ More
We propose to regulate the infinities of eternal inflation by relating a late time cut-off in the bulk to a short distance cut-off on the future boundary. The light-cone time of an event is defined in terms of the volume of its future light-cone on the boundary. We seek an intrinsic definition of boundary volumes that makes no reference to bulk structures. This requires taming the fractal geometry of the future boundary, and lifting the ambiguity of the conformal factor. We propose to work in the conformal frame in which the boundary Ricci scalar is constant. We explore this proposal in the FRW approximation for bubble universes. Remarkably, we find that the future boundary becomes a round three-sphere, with smooth metric on all scales. Our cut-off yields the same relative probabilities as a previous proposal that defined boundary volumes by projection into the bulk along timelike geodesics. Moreover, it is equivalent to an ensemble of causal patches defined without reference to bulk geodesics. It thus yields a holographically motivated and phenomenologically successful measure for eternal inflation.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2010; v1 submitted 16 May, 2010;
originally announced May 2010.
-
Diversity in the Tail of the Intersecting Brane Landscape
Authors:
Vladimir Rosenhaus,
Washington Taylor
Abstract:
Techniques are developed for exploring the complete space of intersecting brane models on an orientifold. The classification of all solutions for the widely-studied T^6/Z_2 x Z_2 orientifold is made possible by computing all combinations of branes with negative tadpole contributions. This provides the necessary information to systematically and efficiently identify all models in this class with…
▽ More
Techniques are developed for exploring the complete space of intersecting brane models on an orientifold. The classification of all solutions for the widely-studied T^6/Z_2 x Z_2 orientifold is made possible by computing all combinations of branes with negative tadpole contributions. This provides the necessary information to systematically and efficiently identify all models in this class with specific characteristics. In particular, all ways in which a desired group G can be realized by a system of intersecting branes can be enumerated in polynomial time. We identify all distinct brane realizations of the gauge groups SU(3) x SU(2) and SU(3) x SU(2) x U(1) which can be embedded in any model which is compatible with the tadpole and SUSY constraints. We compute the distribution of the number of generations of "quarks" and find that 3 is neither suppressed nor particularly enhanced compared to other odd generation numbers. The overall distribution of models is found to have a long tail. Despite disproportionate suppression of models in the tail by K-theory constraints, the tail in the distribution contains much of the diversity of low-energy physics structure.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2009;
originally announced May 2009.
