-
Hagedorn singularity in exact U_q(su(2)) S-matrix theories with arbitrary spins
Authors:
Changrim Ahn,
Tommaso Franzini,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
Generalizing the quantum sine-Gordon and sausage models, we construct exact S-matrices for higher spin representations with quantum U_q(su(2)) symmetry, which satisfy unitarity, crossing-symmetry, and the Yang-Baxter equations with minimality assumption, i.e. without any unnecessary CDD factor. The deformation parameter q is related to a coupling constant. Based on these S-matrices, we derive the…
▽ More
Generalizing the quantum sine-Gordon and sausage models, we construct exact S-matrices for higher spin representations with quantum U_q(su(2)) symmetry, which satisfy unitarity, crossing-symmetry, and the Yang-Baxter equations with minimality assumption, i.e. without any unnecessary CDD factor. The deformation parameter q is related to a coupling constant. Based on these S-matrices, we derive the thermodynamic Bethe ansatz equations for q a root of unity in terms of a universal kernel where the nodes are connected by graphs of non-Dynkin type. We solve these equations numerically to find out Hagedorn-like singularities in the free energies at some critical scales and find a universality in the critical exponents, all near 0.5 for different values of the spin and the coupling constant.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2024; v1 submitted 24 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
The Staircase Model: Massless Flows and Hydrodynamics
Authors:
Michele Mazzoni,
Octavio Pomponio,
Olalla A. Castro-Alvaredo,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
The staircase model is a simple generalization of the sinh-Gordon model, obtained by complexifying the coupling constant. This produces a new theory with many interesting features. Chief among them is the fact that scaling functions such as Zamolodchikov's $c$-function display "roaming" behaviour, that is, they visit the vicinity of an infinite number of conformal fixed points, the unitary minimal…
▽ More
The staircase model is a simple generalization of the sinh-Gordon model, obtained by complexifying the coupling constant. This produces a new theory with many interesting features. Chief among them is the fact that scaling functions such as Zamolodchikov's $c$-function display "roaming" behaviour, that is, they visit the vicinity of an infinite number of conformal fixed points, the unitary minimal models of conformal field theory. This rich structure also makes the model an interesting candidate for study using the generalized hydrodynamic approach to integrable quantum field theory (IQFT). By studying hydrodynamic quantities such as the effective velocities of quasiparticles we can develop a more physical picture of interaction in the theory, both at and away from equilibrium. Indeed, we find that in the staircase model the effective velocity displays monotonicity features not found in any other IQFT. These admit a natural interpretation when investigated in the context of the massless theories known as $\mathcal{M}A_k^{(+)}$ models, which provide an effective description of massless flows between consecutive unitary minimal models. Remarkably, we find that the effective velocity in the staircase model can be reconstructed by a "cut and paste" procedure involving the equivalent functions associated to the massless excitations of suitable $\mathcal{M}A_k^{(+)}$ models. We also investigate the average currents and densities of higher spin conserved quantities in the partitioning protocol.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
On the Hydrodynamics of Unstable Excitations
Authors:
Olalla A. Castro-Alvaredo,
Cecilia De Fazio,
Benjamin Doyon,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
The generalized hydrodynamic (GHD) approach has been extremely successful in describing the out-of-equilibrium properties of a great variety of integrable many-body quantum systems. It naturally extracts the large-scale dynamical degrees of freedom of the system, and is thus a particularly good probe for emergent phenomena. One such phenomenon is the presence of unstable particles, traditionally s…
▽ More
The generalized hydrodynamic (GHD) approach has been extremely successful in describing the out-of-equilibrium properties of a great variety of integrable many-body quantum systems. It naturally extracts the large-scale dynamical degrees of freedom of the system, and is thus a particularly good probe for emergent phenomena. One such phenomenon is the presence of unstable particles, traditionally seen via special analytic structures of the scattering matrix. Because of their finite lifetime and energy threshold, these are especially hard to study. In this paper we apply the GHD approach to a model possessing both unstable excitations and quantum integrability. The largest family of relativistic integrable quantum field theories known to have these features are the homogeneous sine-Gordon models. We consider the simplest non-trivial example of such theories and investigate the effect of an unstable excitation on various physical quantities, both at equilibrium and in the non-equilibrium state arising from the partitioning protocol. The hydrodynamic approach sheds new light onto the physics of the unstable particle, going much beyond its definition via the analytic structure of the scattering matrix, and clarifies its effects both on the equilibrium and out-of-equilibrium properties of the theory. Crucially, within this dynamical perspective, we identify unstable particles as finitely-lived bound states of co-propagating stable particles of different types, and observe how stable populations of unstable particles emerge in large-temperature thermal baths.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Addendum: Nonlinear integral equations for the sausage model
Authors:
Changrim Ahn,
Janos Balog,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
We complete the derivation of the sausage model NLIE by giving a proof of the crucial relation (3.24) of the original paper based on the analytic properties of $Q$ and $\bar Q$.
We complete the derivation of the sausage model NLIE by giving a proof of the crucial relation (3.24) of the original paper based on the analytic properties of $Q$ and $\bar Q$.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Irreversibility of the renormalization group flow in non-unitary quantum field theory
Authors:
Olalla A. Castro-Alvaredo,
Benjamin Doyon,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
We show irreversibility of the renormalization group flow in non-unitary but ${\cal PT}$-invariant quantum field theory in two space-time dimensions. In addition to unbroken $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetry and a positive energy spectrum, we assume standard properties of quantum field theory including a local energy-momentum tensor and relativistic invariance. This generalizes Zamolodchikov's $c$-theorem t…
▽ More
We show irreversibility of the renormalization group flow in non-unitary but ${\cal PT}$-invariant quantum field theory in two space-time dimensions. In addition to unbroken $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetry and a positive energy spectrum, we assume standard properties of quantum field theory including a local energy-momentum tensor and relativistic invariance. This generalizes Zamolodchikov's $c$-theorem to ${\cal PT}$-symmetric hamiltonians. Our proof follows closely Zamolodchikov's arguments. We show that a function $c_{\mathrm{eff}}(s)$ of the renormalization group parameter $s$ exists which is non-negative and monotonically decreasing along renormalization group flows. Its value at a critical point is the "effective central charge" entering the specific free energy. At least in rational models, this equals $c_{\mathrm{eff}}=c-24Δ$, where $c$ is the central charge and $Δ$ is the lowest primary field dimension in the conformal field theory which describes the critical point.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
NLIE for the Sausage model
Authors:
Changrim Ahn,
Janos Balog,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
The sausage model, first proposed by Fateev, Onofri, and Zamolodchikov, is a deformation of the O(3) sigma model preserving integrability. The target space is deformed from the sphere to "sausage" shape by a deformation parameter ν. This model is defined by a factorizable S-matrix which is obtained by deforming that of the O(3) sigma model by a parameter λ. Clues for the deformed sigma model are p…
▽ More
The sausage model, first proposed by Fateev, Onofri, and Zamolodchikov, is a deformation of the O(3) sigma model preserving integrability. The target space is deformed from the sphere to "sausage" shape by a deformation parameter ν. This model is defined by a factorizable S-matrix which is obtained by deforming that of the O(3) sigma model by a parameter λ. Clues for the deformed sigma model are provided by various UV and IR information through the thermodynamic Bethe ansatz (TBA) analysis based on the S-matrix. Application of TBA to the sausage model is, however, limited to the case of 1/λinteger where the coupled integral equations can be truncated to a finite number. In this paper, we propose a finite set of nonliear integral equations (NLIEs), which are applicable to generic value of λ. Our derivation is based on T-Q relations extracted from the truncated TBA equations. For consistency check, we compute next-leading order corrections of the vacuum energy and extract the S-matrix information in the IR limit. We also solved the NLIE both analytically and numerically in the UV limit to get the effective central charge and compared with that of the zero-mode dynamics to obtain exact relation between νand λ.
This paper is a tribute to the memory of Prof. Petr Kulish.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Entanglement Entropy from Corner Transfer Matrix in Forrester Baxter non-unitary RSOS models
Authors:
Davide Bianchini,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
Using a Corner Transfer Matrix approach, we compute the bipartite entanglement Rényi entropy in the off-critical perturbations of non-unitary conformal minimal models realised by lattice spin chains Hamiltonians related to the Forrester Baxter RSOS models in regime III. This allows to show on a set of explicit examples that the Rényi entropies for non-unitary theories rescale near criticality as t…
▽ More
Using a Corner Transfer Matrix approach, we compute the bipartite entanglement Rényi entropy in the off-critical perturbations of non-unitary conformal minimal models realised by lattice spin chains Hamiltonians related to the Forrester Baxter RSOS models in regime III. This allows to show on a set of explicit examples that the Rényi entropies for non-unitary theories rescale near criticality as the logarithm of the correlation length with a coefficient proportional to the effective central charge. This complements a similar result, recently established for the size rescaling at the critical point, showing the expected agreement of the two behaviours. We also compute the first subleading unusual correction to the scaling behaviour, showing that it is expressible in terms of expansions of various fractional powers of the correlation length, related to the differences $Δ-Δ_{\min}$ between the conformal dimensions of fields in the theory and the minimal conformal dimension. Finally, a few observations on the limit leading to the off-critical logarithmic minimal models of Pearce and Seaton are put forward.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
RSOS Quantum Chains Associated with Off-Critical Minimal Models and $\mathbb{Z}_n$ Parafermions
Authors:
Davide Bianchini,
Elisa Ercolessi,
Paul A. Pearce,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
We consider the $\varphi_{1,3}$ off-critical perturbation ${\cal M}(m,m';t)$ of the general non-unitary minimal models where $2\le m\le m'$ and $m, m'$ are coprime and $t$ measures the departure from criticality corresponding to the $\varphi_{1,3}$ integrable perturbation. We view these models as the continuum scaling limit in the ferromagnetic Regime III of the Forrester-Baxter Restricted Solid-O…
▽ More
We consider the $\varphi_{1,3}$ off-critical perturbation ${\cal M}(m,m';t)$ of the general non-unitary minimal models where $2\le m\le m'$ and $m, m'$ are coprime and $t$ measures the departure from criticality corresponding to the $\varphi_{1,3}$ integrable perturbation. We view these models as the continuum scaling limit in the ferromagnetic Regime III of the Forrester-Baxter Restricted Solid-On-Solid (RSOS) models on the square lattice. We also consider the RSOS models in the antiferromagnetic Regime II related in the continuum scaling limit to $\mathbb{Z}_n$ parfermions with $n=m'-2$. Using an elliptic Yang-Baxter algebra of planar tiles encoding the allowed face configurations, we obtain the Hamiltonians of the associated quantum chains defined as the logarithmic derivative of the transfer matrices with periodic boundary conditions. The transfer matrices and Hamiltonians act on a vector space of paths on the $A_{m'-1}$ Dynkin diagram whose dimension is counted by generalized Fibonacci numbers.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Entanglement Entropy of Non Unitary Conformal Field Theory
Authors:
Davide Bianchini,
Olalla A. Castro-Alvaredo,
Benjamin Doyon,
Emanuele Levi,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
In this letter we show that the Rényi entanglement entropy of a region of large size $\ell$ in a one-dimensional critical model whose ground state breaks conformal invariance (such as in those described by non-unitary conformal field theories), behaves as $S_n \sim \frac{c_{\mathrm{eff}}(n+1)}{6n} \log \ell$, where $c_{\mathrm{eff}}=c-24Δ>0$ is the effective central charge, $c$ (which may be negat…
▽ More
In this letter we show that the Rényi entanglement entropy of a region of large size $\ell$ in a one-dimensional critical model whose ground state breaks conformal invariance (such as in those described by non-unitary conformal field theories), behaves as $S_n \sim \frac{c_{\mathrm{eff}}(n+1)}{6n} \log \ell$, where $c_{\mathrm{eff}}=c-24Δ>0$ is the effective central charge, $c$ (which may be negative) is the central charge of the conformal field theory and $Δ\neq 0$ is the lowest holomorphic conformal dimension in the theory. We also obtain results for models with boundaries, and with a large but finite correlation length, and we show that if the lowest conformal eigenspace is logarithmic ($L_0 = ΔI + N$ with $N$ nilpotent), then there is an additional term proportional to $\log(\log \ell)$. These results generalize the well known expressions for unitary models. We provide a general proof, and report on numerical evidence for a non-unitary spin chain and an analytical computation using the corner transfer matrix method for a non-unitary lattice model. We use a new algebraic technique for studying the branching that arises within the replica approach, and find a new expression for the entanglement entropy in terms of correlation functions of twist fields for non-unitary models.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2014; v1 submitted 12 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Modular invariance in the gapped XYZ spin 1/2 chain
Authors:
Elisa Ercolessi,
Stefano Evangelisti,
Fabio Franchini,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
We show that the elliptic parametrization of the coupling constants of the quantum XYZ spin chain can be analytically extended outside of their natural domain, to cover the whole phase diagram of the model, which is composed of 12 adjacent regions, related to one another by a spin rotation. This extension is based on the modular properties of the elliptic functions and we show how rotations in par…
▽ More
We show that the elliptic parametrization of the coupling constants of the quantum XYZ spin chain can be analytically extended outside of their natural domain, to cover the whole phase diagram of the model, which is composed of 12 adjacent regions, related to one another by a spin rotation. This extension is based on the modular properties of the elliptic functions and we show how rotations in parameter space correspond to the double covering PGL(2,Z)of the modular group, implying that the partition function of the XYZ chain is invariant under this group in parameter space, in the same way as a Conformal Field Theory partition function is invariant under the modular group acting in real space. The encoding of the symmetries of the model into the modular properties of the partition function could shed light on the general structure of integrable models.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2013; v1 submitted 28 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Correlation Length and Unusual Corrections to the Entanglement Entropy
Authors:
Elisa Ercolessi,
Stefano Evangelisti,
Fabio Franchini,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
We study analytically the corrections to the leading terms in the Renyi entropy of a massive lattice theory, showing significant deviations from naive expectations. In particular, we show that finite size and finite mass effects give rise to different contributions (with different exponents) and thus violate a simple scaling argument.
In the specific, we look at the entanglement entropy of a bip…
▽ More
We study analytically the corrections to the leading terms in the Renyi entropy of a massive lattice theory, showing significant deviations from naive expectations. In particular, we show that finite size and finite mass effects give rise to different contributions (with different exponents) and thus violate a simple scaling argument.
In the specific, we look at the entanglement entropy of a bipartite XYZ spin-1/2 chain in its ground state. When the system is divided into two semi-infinite half-chains, we have an analytical expression of the Renyi entropy as a function of a single mass parameter. In the scaling limit, we show that the entropy as a function of the correlation length formally coincides with that of a bulk Ising model. This should be compared with the fact that, at criticality, the model is described by a c=1 Conformal Field Theory and the corrections to the entropy due to finite size effects show exponents depending on the compactification radius of the theory. We will argue that there is no contradiction between these statements.
If the lattice spacing is retained finite, the relation between the mass parameter and the correlation length generates new subleading terms in the entropy, whose form is path-dependent in phase-space and whose interpretation within a field theory is not available yet. These contributions arise as a consequence of the existence of stable bound states and are thus a distinctive feature of truly interacting theories, such as the XYZ chain.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2012; v1 submitted 30 January, 2012;
originally announced January 2012.
-
Essential singularity in the Renyi entanglement entropy of the one-dimensional XYZ spin-1/2 chain
Authors:
Elisa Ercolessi,
Stefano Evangelisti,
Fabio Franchini,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
We study the Renyi entropy of the one-dimensional XYZ spin-1/2 chain in the entirety of its phase diagram. The model has several quantum critical lines corresponding to rotated XXZ chains in their paramagnetic phase, and four tri-critical points where these phases join. Two of these points are described by a conformal field theory and close to them the entropy scales as the logarithm of its mass g…
▽ More
We study the Renyi entropy of the one-dimensional XYZ spin-1/2 chain in the entirety of its phase diagram. The model has several quantum critical lines corresponding to rotated XXZ chains in their paramagnetic phase, and four tri-critical points where these phases join. Two of these points are described by a conformal field theory and close to them the entropy scales as the logarithm of its mass gap. The other two points are not conformal and the entropy has a peculiar singular behavior in their neighbors, characteristic of an essential singularity. At these non-conformal points the model undergoes a discontinuous transition, with a level crossing in the ground state and a quadratic excitation spectrum. We propose the entropy as an efficient tool to determine the discontinuous or continuous nature of a phase transition also in more complicated models.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2011; v1 submitted 23 August, 2010;
originally announced August 2010.
-
Exact entanglement entropy of the XYZ model and its sine-Gordon limit
Authors:
Elisa Ercolessi,
Stefano Evangelisti,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
We obtain the exact expression for the Von Neumann entropy for an infinite bipartition of the XYZ model, by connecting its reduced density matrix to the corner transfer matrix of the eight vertex model. Then we consider the anisotropic scaling limit of the XYZ chain that yields the 1+1 dimensional sine-Gordon model. We present the formula for the entanglement entropy of the latter, which has the s…
▽ More
We obtain the exact expression for the Von Neumann entropy for an infinite bipartition of the XYZ model, by connecting its reduced density matrix to the corner transfer matrix of the eight vertex model. Then we consider the anisotropic scaling limit of the XYZ chain that yields the 1+1 dimensional sine-Gordon model. We present the formula for the entanglement entropy of the latter, which has the structure of a dominant logarithmic term plus a constant, in agreement with what is generally expected for a massive quantum field theory.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2012; v1 submitted 25 May, 2009;
originally announced May 2009.
-
NLIE of Dirichlet sine-Gordon Model for Boundary Bound States
Authors:
Changrim Ahn,
Zoltan Bajnok,
Laszlo Palla,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
We investigate boundary bound states of sine-Gordon model on the finite-size strip with Dirichlet boundary conditions. For the purpose we derive the nonlinear integral equation (NLIE) for the boundary excited states from the Bethe ansatz equation of the inhomogeneous XXZ spin 1/2 chain with boundary imaginary roots discovered by Saleur and Skorik. Taking a large volume (IR) limit we calculate bo…
▽ More
We investigate boundary bound states of sine-Gordon model on the finite-size strip with Dirichlet boundary conditions. For the purpose we derive the nonlinear integral equation (NLIE) for the boundary excited states from the Bethe ansatz equation of the inhomogeneous XXZ spin 1/2 chain with boundary imaginary roots discovered by Saleur and Skorik. Taking a large volume (IR) limit we calculate boundary energies, boundary reflection factors and boundary Luscher corrections and compare with the excited boundary states of the Dirichlet sine-Gordon model first considered by Dorey and Mattsson. We also consider the short distance limit and relate the IR scattering data with that of the UV conformal field theory.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2007;
originally announced November 2007.
-
The generalized non-linear Schrodinger model on the interval
Authors:
Anastasia Doikou,
Davide Fioravanti,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
The generalized (1+1)-D non-linear Schrodinger (NLS) theory with particular integrable boundary conditions is considered. More precisely, two distinct types of boundary conditions, known as soliton preserving (SP) and soliton non-preserving (SNP), are implemented into the classical $gl_N$ NLS model. Based on this choice of boundaries the relevant conserved quantities are computed and the corresp…
▽ More
The generalized (1+1)-D non-linear Schrodinger (NLS) theory with particular integrable boundary conditions is considered. More precisely, two distinct types of boundary conditions, known as soliton preserving (SP) and soliton non-preserving (SNP), are implemented into the classical $gl_N$ NLS model. Based on this choice of boundaries the relevant conserved quantities are computed and the corresponding equations of motion are derived. A suitable quantum lattice version of the boundary generalized NLS model is also investigated. The first non-trivial local integral of motion is explicitly computed, and the spectrum and Bethe Ansatz equations are derived for the soliton non-preserving boundary conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2008; v1 submitted 11 June, 2007;
originally announced June 2007.
-
Exact finite size spectrum in super sine-Gordon model
Authors:
Arpad Hegedus,
Francesco Ravanini,
Junji Suzuki
Abstract:
We present the coupled nonlinear integral equations (NLIE) governing the finite size effects in N=1 super sine-Gordon model for the vacuum as well as for the excited states. Their infrared limit correctly yields the scattering data of the super sine-Gordon S-matrix conjectured by Ahn. Ultraviolet analysis is in agreement with the expected conformal data of c=3/2 CFT. Conformal perturbation theor…
▽ More
We present the coupled nonlinear integral equations (NLIE) governing the finite size effects in N=1 super sine-Gordon model for the vacuum as well as for the excited states. Their infrared limit correctly yields the scattering data of the super sine-Gordon S-matrix conjectured by Ahn. Ultraviolet analysis is in agreement with the expected conformal data of c=3/2 CFT. Conformal perturbation theory further corroborates this result.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2006;
originally announced October 2006.
-
Excited states NLIE for sine-Gordon model in a strip with Dirichlet boundary conditions
Authors:
Changrim Ahn,
Marco Bellacosa,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
We investigate various excited states of Sine-Gordon model on a strip with Dirichlet boundary conditions on both boundaries using a Non Linear Integral Equation (NLIE) approach.
We investigate various excited states of Sine-Gordon model on a strip with Dirichlet boundary conditions on both boundaries using a Non Linear Integral Equation (NLIE) approach.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2004; v1 submitted 16 December, 2003;
originally announced December 2003.
-
Exact $φ_{1,3}$ boundary flows in the tricritical Ising model
Authors:
G. Feverati,
P. A. Pearce,
F. Ravanini
Abstract:
We consider the tricritical Ising model on a strip or cylinder under the integrable perturbation by the thermal $φ_{1,3}$ boundary field. This perturbation induces five distinct renormalization group (RG) flows between Cardy type boundary conditions labelled by the Kac labels $(r,s)$. We study these boundary RG flows in detail for all excitations. Exact Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz (TBA) equations…
▽ More
We consider the tricritical Ising model on a strip or cylinder under the integrable perturbation by the thermal $φ_{1,3}$ boundary field. This perturbation induces five distinct renormalization group (RG) flows between Cardy type boundary conditions labelled by the Kac labels $(r,s)$. We study these boundary RG flows in detail for all excitations. Exact Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz (TBA) equations are derived using the lattice approach by considering the continuum scaling limit of the $A_4$ lattice model with integrable boundary conditions. Fixing the bulk weights to their critical values, the integrable boundary weights admit a thermodynamic boundary field $ξ$ which induces the flow and, in the continuum scaling limit, plays the role of the perturbing boundary field $φ_{1,3}$. The excitations are completely classified, in terms of string content, by $(m,n)$ systems and quantum numbers but the string content changes by either two or three well-defined mechanisms along the flow. We identify these mechanisms and obtain the induced maps between the relevant finitized Virasoro characters. We also solve the TBA equations numerically to determine the boundary flows for the leading excitations.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2003; v1 submitted 11 August, 2003;
originally announced August 2003.
-
Completeness of the Bethe Ansatz solution of the open XXZ chain with nondiagonal boundary terms
Authors:
Rafael I. Nepomechie,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
A Bethe Ansatz solution of the open spin-1/2 XXZ quantum spin chain with nondiagonal boundary terms has recently been proposed. Using a numerical procedure developed by McCoy et al., we find significant evidence that this solution can yield the complete set of eigenvalues for generic values of the bulk and boundary parameters satisfying one linear relation. Moreover, our results suggest that thi…
▽ More
A Bethe Ansatz solution of the open spin-1/2 XXZ quantum spin chain with nondiagonal boundary terms has recently been proposed. Using a numerical procedure developed by McCoy et al., we find significant evidence that this solution can yield the complete set of eigenvalues for generic values of the bulk and boundary parameters satisfying one linear relation. Moreover, our results suggest that this solution is practical for investigating the ground state of this model in the thermodynamic limit.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2003; v1 submitted 10 July, 2003;
originally announced July 2003.
-
Excited Boundary TBA in the Tricritical Ising Model
Authors:
G. Feverati,
P. A. Pearce,
F. Ravanini
Abstract:
By considering the continuum scaling limit of the $A_{4}$ RSOS lattice model of Andrews-Baxter-Forrester with integrable boundaries, we derive excited state TBA equations describing the boundary flows of the tricritical Ising model. Fixing the bulk weights to their critical values, the integrable boundary weights admit a parameter $ξ$ which plays the role of the perturbing boundary field…
▽ More
By considering the continuum scaling limit of the $A_{4}$ RSOS lattice model of Andrews-Baxter-Forrester with integrable boundaries, we derive excited state TBA equations describing the boundary flows of the tricritical Ising model. Fixing the bulk weights to their critical values, the integrable boundary weights admit a parameter $ξ$ which plays the role of the perturbing boundary field $φ_{1,3}$ and induces the renormalization group flow between boundary fixed points. The boundary TBA equations determining the RG flows are derived in the $\mathcal{B}_{(1,2)}\to \mathcal{B}_{(2,1)}$ example. The induced map between distinct Virasoro characters of the theory are specified in terms of distribution of zeros of the double row transfer matrix.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2004; v1 submitted 20 June, 2003;
originally announced June 2003.
-
Lattice Approach to Excited TBA Boundary Flows: Tricritical Ising Model
Authors:
Giovanni Feverati,
Paul A. Pearce,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
We show how a lattice approach can be used to derive Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz (TBA) equations describing all excitations for boundary flows. The method is illustrated for a prototypical flow of the tricritical Ising model by considering the continuum scaling limit of the A4 lattice model with integrable boundaries. Fixing the bulk weights to their critical values, the integrable boundary weigh…
▽ More
We show how a lattice approach can be used to derive Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz (TBA) equations describing all excitations for boundary flows. The method is illustrated for a prototypical flow of the tricritical Ising model by considering the continuum scaling limit of the A4 lattice model with integrable boundaries. Fixing the bulk weights to their critical values, the integrable boundary weights admit two boundary fields $ξ$ and $η$ which play the role of the perturbing boundary fields $φ_{1,3}$ and $φ_{1,2}$ inducing the renormalization group flow between boundary fixed points. The excitations are completely classified in terms of (m,n) systems and quantum numbers but the string content changes by certain mechanisms along the flow. For our prototypical example, we identify these mechanisms and the induced map between the relevant finitized Virasoro characters. We also solve the boundary TBA equations numerically to determine the flows for the leading excitations.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2002; v1 submitted 7 February, 2002;
originally announced February 2002.
-
Finite Size Effects in Integrable Quantum Field Theories
Authors:
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
The study of Finite Size Effects in Quantum Field Theory allows the extraction of precious perturbative and non-perturbative information. The use of scaling functions can connect the particle content (scattering theory formulation) of a QFT to its ultraviolet Conformal Field Theory content. If the model is integrable, a method of investigation through a nonlinear integral equation equivalent to…
▽ More
The study of Finite Size Effects in Quantum Field Theory allows the extraction of precious perturbative and non-perturbative information. The use of scaling functions can connect the particle content (scattering theory formulation) of a QFT to its ultraviolet Conformal Field Theory content. If the model is integrable, a method of investigation through a nonlinear integral equation equivalent to Bethe Ansatz and deducible from a light-cone lattice regularization is available. It allows to reconstruct the S-matrix and to understand the locality properties in terms of Bethe root configurations, thanks to the link to ultraviolet CFT guaranteed by the exact determination of scaling function. This method is illustrated in practice for Sine-Gordon / massive Thirring models, clarifying their locality structure and the issues of equivalence between the two models. By restriction of the Sine-Gordon model it is also possible to control the scaling functions of minimal models perturbed by Phi_1,3
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2001;
originally announced February 2001.
-
Nonlinear Integral Equation and Finite Volume Spectrum of Minimal Models Perturbed by $Φ_{(1,3)}$
Authors:
G. Feverati,
F. Ravanini,
G. Takacs
Abstract:
We describe an extension of the nonlinear integral equation (NLIE) method to Virasoro minimal models perturbed by the relevant operator $Φ_{(1,3)$. Along the way, we also complete our previous studies of the finite volume spectrum of sine-Gordon theory by considering the attractive regime and more specifically, breather states. For the minimal models, we examine the states with zero topological…
▽ More
We describe an extension of the nonlinear integral equation (NLIE) method to Virasoro minimal models perturbed by the relevant operator $Φ_{(1,3)$. Along the way, we also complete our previous studies of the finite volume spectrum of sine-Gordon theory by considering the attractive regime and more specifically, breather states. For the minimal models, we examine the states with zero topological charge in detail, and give numerical comparison to TBA and TCS results. We think that the evidence presented strongly supports the validity of the NLIE description of perturbed minimal models.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 1999; v1 submitted 6 September, 1999;
originally announced September 1999.
-
Scaling Functions in the Odd Charge Sector of Sine-Gordon/Massive Thirring Theory
Authors:
G. Feverati,
F. Ravanini,
G. Takacs
Abstract:
A non-linear integral equation (NLIE) governing the finite size effects of excited states of even topological charge in the sine-Gordon (sG) / massive Thirring (mTh) field theory, deducible from a light-cone lattice formulation of the model, has been known for some time. In this letter we conjecture an extension of this NLIE to states with odd topological charge, thus completing the spectrum of…
▽ More
A non-linear integral equation (NLIE) governing the finite size effects of excited states of even topological charge in the sine-Gordon (sG) / massive Thirring (mTh) field theory, deducible from a light-cone lattice formulation of the model, has been known for some time. In this letter we conjecture an extension of this NLIE to states with odd topological charge, thus completing the spectrum of the theory. The scaling functions obtained as solutions to our conjectured NLIE are compared successfully with Truncated Conformal Space data and the construction is shown to be compatible with all other facts known about the local Hilbert spaces of sG and mTh models. With the present results we have achieved a full control over the finite size behaviour of energy levels of sG/mTh theory.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 1998; v1 submitted 21 July, 1998;
originally announced July 1998.
-
Nonlinear Integral Equation and Finite Volume Spectrum of Sine-Gordon Theory
Authors:
G. Feverati,
F. Ravanini,
G. Takacs
Abstract:
We examine the connection between the nonlinear integral equation (NLIE) derived from light-cone lattice and sine-Gordon quantum field theory, considered as a perturbed c=1 conformal field theory. After clarifying some delicate points of the NLIE deduction from the lattice, we compare both analytic and numerical predictions of the NLIE to previously known results in sine-Gordon theory. To provid…
▽ More
We examine the connection between the nonlinear integral equation (NLIE) derived from light-cone lattice and sine-Gordon quantum field theory, considered as a perturbed c=1 conformal field theory. After clarifying some delicate points of the NLIE deduction from the lattice, we compare both analytic and numerical predictions of the NLIE to previously known results in sine-Gordon theory. To provide the basis for the numerical comparison we use data from Truncated Conformal Space method. Together with results from analysis of infrared and ultraviolet asymptotics, we find evidence that it is necessary to change the rule of quantization proposed by Destri and de Vega to a new one which includes as a special case that of Fioravanti et al. This way we find strong evidence for the validity of the NLIE as a description of the finite size effects of sine-Gordon theory.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 1998; v1 submitted 19 May, 1998;
originally announced May 1998.
-
Truncated Conformal Space at c=1, Nonlinear Integral Equation and Quantization Rules for Multi-Soliton States
Authors:
G. Feverati,
F. Ravanini,
G. Takacs
Abstract:
We develop Truncated Conformal Space (TCS) technique for perturbations of c=1 Conformal Field Theories. We use it to give the first numerical evidence of the validity of the non-linear integral equation (NLIE) derived from light-cone lattice regularization at intermediate scales. A controversy on the quantization of Bethe states is solved by this numerical comparison and by using the locality pr…
▽ More
We develop Truncated Conformal Space (TCS) technique for perturbations of c=1 Conformal Field Theories. We use it to give the first numerical evidence of the validity of the non-linear integral equation (NLIE) derived from light-cone lattice regularization at intermediate scales. A controversy on the quantization of Bethe states is solved by this numerical comparison and by using the locality principle at the ultra- violet fixed point. It turns out that the correct quantization for pure hole states is the one with half-integer quantum numbers originally proposed by Mariottini et al. Once the correct rule is imposed, the agreement between TCS and NLIE for pure hole states turns out to be impressive.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 1998; v1 submitted 12 March, 1998;
originally announced March 1998.
-
Excited State Destri - De Vega Equation for Sine-Gordon and Restricted Sine-Gordon Models
Authors:
D. Fioravanti,
A. Mariottini,
E. Quattrini,
F. Ravanini
Abstract:
We derive a generalization of the Destri - De Vega equation governing the scaling functions of some excited states in the Sine-Gordon theory. In particular configurations with an even number of holes and no strings are analyzed and their UV limits found to match some of the conformal dimensions of the corresponding compactified massless free boson. Quantum group reduction allows to interpret som…
▽ More
We derive a generalization of the Destri - De Vega equation governing the scaling functions of some excited states in the Sine-Gordon theory. In particular configurations with an even number of holes and no strings are analyzed and their UV limits found to match some of the conformal dimensions of the corresponding compactified massless free boson. Quantum group reduction allows to interpret some of our results as scaling functions of excited states of Restricted Sine-Gordon theory, i.e. minimal models perturbed by phi_13 in their massive regime. In particular we are able to reconstruct the scaling functions of the off-critical deformations of all the scalar primary states on the diagonal of the Kac-table.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 1996;
originally announced August 1996.
-
Infrared Behaviour of Massless Integrable Flows entering the Minimal Models from phi_31
Authors:
G. Feverati,
E. Quattrini,
F. Ravanini
Abstract:
It is known that any minimal model M_p receives along its phi_31 irrelevant direction *two* massless integrable flows: one from M_{p+1} perturbed by phi_{13}, the other from Z_{p-1} parafermionic model perturbed by its generating parafermion field. By comparing Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz data and ``predictions'' of infrared Conformal Perturbation Theory we show that these two flows are received…
▽ More
It is known that any minimal model M_p receives along its phi_31 irrelevant direction *two* massless integrable flows: one from M_{p+1} perturbed by phi_{13}, the other from Z_{p-1} parafermionic model perturbed by its generating parafermion field. By comparing Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz data and ``predictions'' of infrared Conformal Perturbation Theory we show that these two flows are received by M_p with opposite coupling constants of the phi_31 irrelevant perturbation. Some comments on the massless S matrices of these two flows are added.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 1996; v1 submitted 14 December, 1995;
originally announced December 1995.
-
Generalized KdV and Quantum Inverse Scattering Description of Conformal Minimal Models
Authors:
Davide Fioravanti,
Francesco Ravanini,
Marian Stanishkov
Abstract:
We propose an alternative description of 2 dimensional Conformal Field Theory in terms of Quantum Inverse Scattering. It is based on the generalized KdV systems attached to $A_2^{(2)}$, yielding the classical limit of Virasoro as Poisson bracket structure. The corresponding T-system is shown to coincide with the one recently proposed by Kuniba and Suzuki. We classify the primary operators of the…
▽ More
We propose an alternative description of 2 dimensional Conformal Field Theory in terms of Quantum Inverse Scattering. It is based on the generalized KdV systems attached to $A_2^{(2)}$, yielding the classical limit of Virasoro as Poisson bracket structure. The corresponding T-system is shown to coincide with the one recently proposed by Kuniba and Suzuki. We classify the primary operators of the minimal models that commute with all the Integrals of Motion, and that are therefore candidates to perturb the model by keeping the conservation laws. For our $A_2^{(2)}$ structure these happen to be $φ_{1,2},φ_{2,1},φ_{1,5}$, in contrast to the $A_1^{(1)}$ case, studied by Bazhanov, Lukyanov and Zamolodchikov~\cite{BLZ}, related to $φ_{1,3}$.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 1995; v1 submitted 9 October, 1995;
originally announced October 1995.
-
Integrable perturbations of CFT with complex parameter: the $M_{3/5}$ model and its generalizations
Authors:
F. Ravanini,
M. Stanishkov,
R. Tateo
Abstract:
We give evidence, by use of the Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz approach, of the existence of both massive and massless behaviours for the $φ_{2,1}$ perturbation of the $M_{3,5}$ non-unitary minimal model, thus resolving apparent contradictions in the previous literature. The two behaviours correspond to changing the perturbing bare coupling constant from real values to imaginary ones. Generalization…
▽ More
We give evidence, by use of the Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz approach, of the existence of both massive and massless behaviours for the $φ_{2,1}$ perturbation of the $M_{3,5}$ non-unitary minimal model, thus resolving apparent contradictions in the previous literature. The two behaviours correspond to changing the perturbing bare coupling constant from real values to imaginary ones. Generalizations of this picture to the whole class of non-unitary minimal models $M_{p,2p\pm 1}$, perturbed by their least relevant operator lead to a cascade of flows similar to that of unitary minimal models perturbed by $φ_{1,3}$. Various aspects and generalizations of this phenomenon and the links with the Izergin-Korepin model are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 1994;
originally announced November 1994.
-
Integrable QFT(2) Encoded on Products of Dynkin Diagrams
Authors:
E. Quattrini,
F. Ravanini,
R. Tateo
Abstract:
A large class of Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz equations governing the Renormalization Group evolution of the Casimir energy of the vacuum on the cylinder for an integrable two-dimensional field theory, can often be encoded on a tensor product of two graphs. We demonstrate here that in this case the two graphs can only be of $ADE$ type. We also give strong numerical evidence for a new large set of…
▽ More
A large class of Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz equations governing the Renormalization Group evolution of the Casimir energy of the vacuum on the cylinder for an integrable two-dimensional field theory, can often be encoded on a tensor product of two graphs. We demonstrate here that in this case the two graphs can only be of $ADE$ type. We also give strong numerical evidence for a new large set of Dilogarithm sum Rules connected to $ADE\times ADE$ and a simple formula for the ultraviolet perturbing operator conformal dimensions only in terms of rank and Coxeter numbers of $ADE\times ADE$. We conclude with some remarks on the curious case $ADE\times D$. [Talk given by F.R. at the Cargese Workshop "New Developments in String Theory, Conformal Models and Topological Field Theory" (May 1993)]
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 1993;
originally announced November 1993.
-
Generalising the staircase models
Authors:
Patrick Dorey,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
Systems of integral equations are proposed which generalise those previously encountered in connection with the so-called staircase models. Under the assumption that these equations describe the finite-size effects of relativistic field theories via the Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz, analytical and numerical evidence is given for the existence of a variety of new roaming renormalisation group traje…
▽ More
Systems of integral equations are proposed which generalise those previously encountered in connection with the so-called staircase models. Under the assumption that these equations describe the finite-size effects of relativistic field theories via the Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz, analytical and numerical evidence is given for the existence of a variety of new roaming renormalisation group trajectories. For each positive integer $k$ and $s=0,\dots, k-1$, there is a one-parameter family of trajectories, passing close by the coset conformal field theories $G^{(k)}\times G^{(nk+s)}/G^{((n+1)k+s)}$ before finally flowing to a massive theory for $s=0$, or to another coset model for $s \neq 0$.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 1992;
originally announced November 1992.
-
A New Family of Diagonal Ade-Related Scattering Theories
Authors:
F. Ravanini,
R. Tateo,
A. Valleriani
Abstract:
We propose the factorizable S-matrices of the massive excitations of the non-unitary minimal model $M_{2,11}$ perturbed by the operator $Φ_{1,4}$. The massive excitations and the whole set of two particle S-matrices of the theory is simply related to the $E_8$ unitary minimal scattering theory. The counting argument and the Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz (TBA) are applied to this scattering theory i…
▽ More
We propose the factorizable S-matrices of the massive excitations of the non-unitary minimal model $M_{2,11}$ perturbed by the operator $Φ_{1,4}$. The massive excitations and the whole set of two particle S-matrices of the theory is simply related to the $E_8$ unitary minimal scattering theory. The counting argument and the Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz (TBA) are applied to this scattering theory in order to support this interpretation. Generalizing this result, we describe a new family of NON UNITARY and DIAGONAL $ADE$-related scattering theories. A further generalization suggests the magnonic TBA for a large class of non-unitary $\G\otimes\G/\G$ coset models ($\G=A_{odd},D_n,E_{6,7,8}$) perturbed by $Φ_{id,id,adj}$, described by non-diagonal S-matrices.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 1992;
originally announced July 1992.
-
Dynkin TBA's
Authors:
F. Ravanini,
R. Tateo,
A. Valleriani
Abstract:
We prove a useful identity valid for all $ADE$ minimal S-matrices, that clarifies the transformation of the relative thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz (TBA) from its standard form into the universal one proposed by Al.B.Zamolodchikov. By considering the graph encoding of the system of functional equations for the exponentials of the pseudoenergies, we show that any such system having the same form as t…
▽ More
We prove a useful identity valid for all $ADE$ minimal S-matrices, that clarifies the transformation of the relative thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz (TBA) from its standard form into the universal one proposed by Al.B.Zamolodchikov. By considering the graph encoding of the system of functional equations for the exponentials of the pseudoenergies, we show that any such system having the same form as those for the $ADE$ TBA's, can be encoded on $A,D,E,A/Z_2$ only. This includes, besides the known $ADE$ diagonal scattering, the set of all $SU(2)$ related {\em magnonic} TBA's. We explore this class sistematically and find some interesting new massive and massless RG flows. The generalization to classes related to higher rank algebras is briefly presented and an intriguing relation with level-rank duality is signalled.
△ Less
Submitted 13 July, 1992;
originally announced July 1992.
-
Staircase Models from Affine Toda Field Theory
Authors:
Patrick Dorey,
Francesco Ravanini
Abstract:
We propose a class of purely elastic scattering theories generalising the staircase model of Al. B. Zamolodchikov, based on the affine Toda field theories for simply-laced Lie algebras g=A,D,E at suitable complex values of their coupling constants. Considering their Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz equations, we give analytic arguments in support of a conjectured renormalisation group flow visiting th…
▽ More
We propose a class of purely elastic scattering theories generalising the staircase model of Al. B. Zamolodchikov, based on the affine Toda field theories for simply-laced Lie algebras g=A,D,E at suitable complex values of their coupling constants. Considering their Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz equations, we give analytic arguments in support of a conjectured renormalisation group flow visiting the neighbourhood of each W_g minimal model in turn.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 1992;
originally announced June 1992.
-
Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz for G_k x G_l / G_{k+l} Coset Models Perturbed by Their φ_{1,1,Adj} Operator
Authors:
F. Ravanini
Abstract:
We propose a Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz (TBA) for G_k x G_l / G_{k+l} conformal coset models (G any simply-laced Lie algebra) perturbed by their operator φ_{1,1,Adj}. An interesting adjacency structure appears and can be depicted in a sort of ``product'' of Dynkin diagrams of G and A_{k+l-1}. UV and IR limits are computed and reproduce the expected values for the central charges. For k->\infty,…
▽ More
We propose a Thermodynamic Bethe Ansatz (TBA) for G_k x G_l / G_{k+l} conformal coset models (G any simply-laced Lie algebra) perturbed by their operator φ_{1,1,Adj}. An interesting adjacency structure appears and can be depicted in a sort of ``product'' of Dynkin diagrams of G and A_{k+l-1}. UV and IR limits are computed and reproduce the expected values for the central charges. For k->\infty, l fixed we obtain the TBA of the G_l WZW model perturbed by J_a\bar{J}_a, and for k,l->\infty, k-l fixed, that of Principal Chiral model with WZ term at level k-l.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 1992;
originally announced February 1992.
-
Towards a Classification of Fusion Rule Algebras in Rational Conformal Field Theories
Authors:
M. Caselle,
G. Ponzano,
F. Ravanini
Abstract:
We review the main topics concerning Fusion Rule Algebras (FRA) of Rational Conformal Field Theories. After an exposition of their general properties, we examine known results on the complete classification for low number of fields ($\leq 4$). We then turn our attention to FRA's generated polynomially by one (real) fundamental field, for which a classification is known. Attempting to generalize…
▽ More
We review the main topics concerning Fusion Rule Algebras (FRA) of Rational Conformal Field Theories. After an exposition of their general properties, we examine known results on the complete classification for low number of fields ($\leq 4$). We then turn our attention to FRA's generated polynomially by one (real) fundamental field, for which a classification is known. Attempting to generalize this result, we describe some connections between FRA's and Graph Theory. The possibility to get new results on the subject following this ``graph'' approach is briefly discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 1991;
originally announced November 1991.
-
RG flows of non-diagonal minimal models perturbed by $φ_{1,3}$
Authors:
F. Ravanini
Abstract:
Studying perturbatively, for large m, the torus partition function of both (A,A) and (A,D) series of minimal models in the Cappelli, Itzykson, Zuber classification, deformed by the least relevant operator $φ_{(1,3)}$, we disentangle the structure of $φ_{1,3}$ flows. The results are conjectured on reasonable ground to be valid for all m. They show that (A,A) models always flow to (A,A) and (A,D)…
▽ More
Studying perturbatively, for large m, the torus partition function of both (A,A) and (A,D) series of minimal models in the Cappelli, Itzykson, Zuber classification, deformed by the least relevant operator $φ_{(1,3)}$, we disentangle the structure of $φ_{1,3}$ flows. The results are conjectured on reasonable ground to be valid for all m. They show that (A,A) models always flow to (A,A) and (A,D) ones to (A,D). No hopping between the two series is possible. Also, we give arguments that there exist 3 isolated flows (E,A)-->(A,E) that, together with the two series, should exhaust all the possible $φ_{1,3}$ flows. Conservation (and symmetry breaking) of non-local currents along the flows is discussed and put in relation to the A,D,E classification.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 1991;
originally announced October 1991.
-
On the possibility of $Z_N$ exotic supersymmetry in two dimensional Conformal Field Theory
Authors:
F. Ravanini
Abstract:
We investigate the possibility to construct extended parafermionic conformal algebras whose generating current has spin $1+\frac{1}{K}$, generalizing the superconformal (spin 3/2) and the Fateev Zamolodchikov (spin 4/3) algebras. Models invariant under such algebras would possess $Z_K$ exotic supersymmetries satisfying (supercharge)$^K$ = (momentum). However, we show that for $K=4$ this new alge…
▽ More
We investigate the possibility to construct extended parafermionic conformal algebras whose generating current has spin $1+\frac{1}{K}$, generalizing the superconformal (spin 3/2) and the Fateev Zamolodchikov (spin 4/3) algebras. Models invariant under such algebras would possess $Z_K$ exotic supersymmetries satisfying (supercharge)$^K$ = (momentum). However, we show that for $K=4$ this new algebra allows only for models at $c=1$, for $K=5$ it is a trivial rephrasing of the ordinary $Z_5$ parafermionic model, for $K=6,7$ (and, requiring unitarity, for all larger $K$) such algebras do not exist. Implications of this result for existence of exotic supersymmetry in two dimensional field theory are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 1991;
originally announced September 1991.
