-
1-loop renormalisability of integrable sigma-models from 4d Chern-Simons theory
Authors:
Sylvain Lacroix,
Nat Levine,
Anders Wallberg
Abstract:
Large families of integrable 2d sigma-models have been constructed at the classical level, partly motivated by the utility of integrability on the string worldsheet. It is natural to ask whether these theories are renormalisable at the quantum level, and whether they define quantum integrable field theories. By considering examples, a folk theorem has emerged: the classically integrable sigma-mode…
▽ More
Large families of integrable 2d sigma-models have been constructed at the classical level, partly motivated by the utility of integrability on the string worldsheet. It is natural to ask whether these theories are renormalisable at the quantum level, and whether they define quantum integrable field theories. By considering examples, a folk theorem has emerged: the classically integrable sigma-models always turn out to be renormalisable, at least at 1-loop order. We prove this theorem for a large class of models engineered on surface defects in the 4d Chern-Simons theory by Costello and Yamazaki. We derive the flow of the 'twist 1-form' (a 4d coupling constant that distinguishes different 2d models), proving earlier conjectures and extending previous results. Our approach is general, using the 'universal' form of 2d integrable models' UV divergences in terms of their Lax connection and reinterpreting the result in the language of 4d Chern-Simons. These results apply equally to rational, trigonometric and elliptic models.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Demystifying integrable QFTs in AdS: No-go theorems for higher-spin charges
Authors:
António Antunes,
Nat Levine,
Marco Meineri
Abstract:
Higher-spin conserved currents and charges feature prominently in integrable 2d QFTs in flat space. Motivated by the question of integrable field theories in AdS space, we consider the consequences of higher-spin currents for QFTs in AdS$_2$, and find that their effect is much more constraining than in flat space. Specifically, it is impossible to preserve: (a)~any higher-spin charges when deformi…
▽ More
Higher-spin conserved currents and charges feature prominently in integrable 2d QFTs in flat space. Motivated by the question of integrable field theories in AdS space, we consider the consequences of higher-spin currents for QFTs in AdS$_2$, and find that their effect is much more constraining than in flat space. Specifically, it is impossible to preserve: (a)~any higher-spin charges when deforming a massive free field by interactions, or (b)~any spin-4 charges when deforming a CFT by a Virasoro primary. Therefore, in these settings, there are no integrable theories in AdS with higher-spin conserved charges. Along the way, we explain how higher-spin charges lead to integer spacing in the spectrum of primaries, sum rules on the OPE data, and constraints on correlation functions. We also explain a key difference between AdS and flat space: in AdS one cannot `partially' conserve a higher-spin current along particular directions, since the AdS isometries imply full conservation.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Bootstrapping bulk locality. Part II: Interacting functionals
Authors:
Nat Levine,
Miguel F. Paulos
Abstract:
Locality of bulk operators in AdS imposes stringent constraints on their description in terms of the boundary CFT. These constraints are encoded as sum rules on the bulk-to-boundary expansion coefficients. In this paper, we construct families of sum rules that are (i) complete and (ii) `dual' to sparse CFT spectra. The sum rules trivialise the reconstruction of bulk operators in strongly interacti…
▽ More
Locality of bulk operators in AdS imposes stringent constraints on their description in terms of the boundary CFT. These constraints are encoded as sum rules on the bulk-to-boundary expansion coefficients. In this paper, we construct families of sum rules that are (i) complete and (ii) `dual' to sparse CFT spectra. The sum rules trivialise the reconstruction of bulk operators in strongly interacting QFTs in AdS space and allow us to write down explicit, exact, interacting solutions to the locality problem. Technically, we characterise `completeness' of a set of sum rules by constructing Schauder bases for a certain space of real-analytic functions. In turn, this allows us to prove a Paley-Weiner type theorem characterising the space of sum rules. Remarkably, with control over this space, it is possible to write down closed-form `designer sum rules', dual to a chosen spectrum of CFT operators meeting certain criteria. We discuss the consequences of our results for both analytic and numerical bootstrap applications.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2025; v1 submitted 1 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Equivalence of 1-loop RG flows in 4d Chern-Simons and integrable 2d sigma-models
Authors:
Nat Levine
Abstract:
We argue for the matching of 1-loop divergences between 4d Chern-Simons theory with Disorder defects and the corresponding integrable 2d sigma-models of non-ultralocal type. Starting from the 4d path integral, we show under general assumptions that the 1-loop divergences localise to the 2d defects. They match the 'universal' formulae developed in [arXiv:2209.05502] for the 1-loop RG flows of integ…
▽ More
We argue for the matching of 1-loop divergences between 4d Chern-Simons theory with Disorder defects and the corresponding integrable 2d sigma-models of non-ultralocal type. Starting from the 4d path integral, we show under general assumptions that the 1-loop divergences localise to the 2d defects. They match the 'universal' formulae developed in [arXiv:2209.05502] for the 1-loop RG flows of integrable 2d sigma-models. Our argument uses an alternate path integral representation for the 1-loop effective action and the known classical equivalence between the 4d and 2d theories.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Bootstrapping bulk locality. Part I: Sum rules for AdS form factors
Authors:
Nat Levine,
Miguel F. Paulos
Abstract:
The problem of constructing local bulk observables from boundary CFT data is of paramount importance in holography. In this work, we begin addressing this question from a modern bootstrap perspective. Our main tool is the boundary operator expansion (BOE), which holds for any QFT in AdS. Following Kabat and Lifschytz, we argue that the BOE is strongly constrained by demanding locality of correlato…
▽ More
The problem of constructing local bulk observables from boundary CFT data is of paramount importance in holography. In this work, we begin addressing this question from a modern bootstrap perspective. Our main tool is the boundary operator expansion (BOE), which holds for any QFT in AdS. Following Kabat and Lifschytz, we argue that the BOE is strongly constrained by demanding locality of correlators involving bulk fields. Focusing on 'AdS form factors' of one bulk and two boundary insertions, we reformulate these locality constraints as a complete set of sum rules on the BOE data. We show that these sum rules lead to a manifestly local representation of form factors in terms of 'local blocks'. The sum rules are valid non-perturbatively, but are especially well-adapted for perturbative computations in AdS where they allow us to bootstrap the BOE data in a systematic fashion. Finally, in the flat space limit, we show that the AdS form factor reduces to an ordinary QFT form factor. We provide a phase shift formula for it in terms of the BOE and CFT data. In two dimensions, this formula makes manifest Watson's equations for integrable form factors under certain extremality assumptions on the CFT. We discuss the eventual modifications of our formalism to account for dressed operators in AdS.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2023; v1 submitted 11 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Bi-$η$ and bi-$λ$ deformations of $\mathbb{Z}_4$ permutation supercosets
Authors:
Ben Hoare,
Nat Levine,
Fiona K. Seibold
Abstract:
Integrable string sigma models on AdS$_3$ backgrounds with 16 supersymmetries have the distinguishing feature that their superisometry group is a direct product. As a result the deformation theory of these models is particularly rich since the two supergroups in the product can be deformed independently. We construct bi-$η$ and bi-$λ$ deformations of two classes of $\mathbb{Z}_4$ permutation super…
▽ More
Integrable string sigma models on AdS$_3$ backgrounds with 16 supersymmetries have the distinguishing feature that their superisometry group is a direct product. As a result the deformation theory of these models is particularly rich since the two supergroups in the product can be deformed independently. We construct bi-$η$ and bi-$λ$ deformations of two classes of $\mathbb{Z}_4$ permutation supercoset sigma models, which describe sectors of the Green-Schwarz and pure-spinor string worldsheet theories on type II AdS$_3$ backgrounds with pure R-R flux. We discuss an important limit of these models when one supergroup is undeformed. The associated deformed supergravity background should preserve 8 supersymmetries and is expected to have better properties than the full bi-deformation. As a step towards investigating the quantum properties of these models, we study the two-loop RG flow of the bosonic truncation of the bi-$λ$ deformation.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2023; v1 submitted 16 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Universal 1-loop divergences for integrable sigma models
Authors:
Nat Levine
Abstract:
We present a simple, new method for the 1-loop renormalization of integrable $σ$-models. By treating equations of motion and Bianchi identities on an equal footing, we derive 'universal' formulae for the 1-loop on-shell divergences, generalizing case-by-case computations in the literature. Given a choice of poles for the classical Lax connection, the divergences take a theory-independent form in t…
▽ More
We present a simple, new method for the 1-loop renormalization of integrable $σ$-models. By treating equations of motion and Bianchi identities on an equal footing, we derive 'universal' formulae for the 1-loop on-shell divergences, generalizing case-by-case computations in the literature. Given a choice of poles for the classical Lax connection, the divergences take a theory-independent form in terms of the Lax currents (the residues of the poles), assuming a 'completeness' condition on the zero-curvature equations. We compute these divergences for a large class of theories with simple poles in the Lax connection. We also show that $Z_T$ coset models of 'pure-spinor' type and their recently constructed $η$- and $λ$-deformations are 1-loop renormalizable, and 1-loop scale-invariant when the Killing form vanishes.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2023; v1 submitted 12 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Integrability and RG flow in 2d sigma models
Authors:
Nat Levine
Abstract:
Motivated by the search for solvable string theories, we consider the problem of classifying the integrable bosonic 2d $σ$-models. We include non-conformal $σ$-models, which have historically been a good arena for discovering integrable models that were later generalized to Weyl-invariant ones. General $σ$-models feature a quantum RG flow, given by a 'generalized Ricci flow' of the target-space ge…
▽ More
Motivated by the search for solvable string theories, we consider the problem of classifying the integrable bosonic 2d $σ$-models. We include non-conformal $σ$-models, which have historically been a good arena for discovering integrable models that were later generalized to Weyl-invariant ones. General $σ$-models feature a quantum RG flow, given by a 'generalized Ricci flow' of the target-space geometry.
This thesis is based on the conjecture that integrable $σ$-models are renormalizable, or stable under the RG flow. It is widely understood that classically integrable theories are stable at the leading 1-loop order with only a few parameters running. Here we address what happens at higher-loop orders. We find that integrable $σ$-models generally remain RG-stable at higher-loops provided they receive a particular choice of finite counterterms, or quantum ($α'$) corrections to the target-space geometry.
We explicitly construct these quantum corrections for examples of integrable $η$- and $λ$-deformed $σ$-models. We then reformulate the $λ$-models as $σ$-models on a "tripled" $G \times G \times G$ configuration space, where they become automatically renormalizable due to manifest symmetries and a decoupling of some fields. We also consider the integrable $G \times G$ and $G \times G/H$ models and construct a new class of integrable $G \times G/H$ models with abelian $H$.
We then present a new and different link between integrability and the RG flow in the context of $σ$-models with 'local couplings' depending explicitly on 2d time. Such models are naturally obtained in the light-cone gauge in string theory, pointing to the possibility of a large, new class of solvable string models.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2022; v1 submitted 7 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Integrability vs. RG flow in $G \times G$ and $G \times G /H$ sigma models
Authors:
Nat Levine,
Arkady A. Tseytlin
Abstract:
We consider a class of 2d $σ$-models on products of group spaces that provide new examples of a close connection between integrability and stability under the RG flow. We first study the integrable $G \times G$ model derived from the affine Gaudin construction (for which the 1-loop $β$-functions were found in arXiv:2010.07879) and show that its condition of integrability is preserved also by the 2…
▽ More
We consider a class of 2d $σ$-models on products of group spaces that provide new examples of a close connection between integrability and stability under the RG flow. We first study the integrable $G \times G$ model derived from the affine Gaudin construction (for which the 1-loop $β$-functions were found in arXiv:2010.07879) and show that its condition of integrability is preserved also by the 2-loop RG flow. We then investigate the RG flow in the gauged $G \times G /H$ model, in particular the integrable $T^{1,1}$ model found in arXiv:2010.05573. We also construct a new class of integrable $G \times G /H$ models in the case when the subgroup $H$ is abelian. In the simplest case of $G=SU_2$, $H=U_1$ this leads to an integrable $σ$-model on the $T^{1,q}$ space (with a particular $B$-field). This model is also shown to be stable under the 2-loop RG flow, and we relate this property to its invariance under T-duality in an isometric $U_1$ direction. This $T^{1,q}$ model may be interpreted as an integrable deformation of the GMM model (of two coupled WZW theories with generic levels) away from the conformal point.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2022; v1 submitted 18 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Sigma models with local couplings: a new integrability -- RG flow connection
Authors:
Ben Hoare,
Nat Levine,
Arkady A. Tseytlin
Abstract:
We consider several classes of $σ$-models (on groups and symmetric spaces, $η$-models, $λ$-models) with local couplings that may depend on the 2d coordinates, e.g. on time $τ$. We observe that (i) starting with a classically integrable 2d $σ$-model, (ii) formally promoting its couplings $h_α$ to functions $h_α(τ)$ of 2d time, and (iii) demanding that the resulting time-dependent model also admits…
▽ More
We consider several classes of $σ$-models (on groups and symmetric spaces, $η$-models, $λ$-models) with local couplings that may depend on the 2d coordinates, e.g. on time $τ$. We observe that (i) starting with a classically integrable 2d $σ$-model, (ii) formally promoting its couplings $h_α$ to functions $h_α(τ)$ of 2d time, and (iii) demanding that the resulting time-dependent model also admits a Lax connection implies that $h_α(τ)$ must solve the 1-loop RG equations of the original theory with $τ$ interpreted as RG time. This provides a novel example of an 'integrability - RG flow' connection. The existence of a Lax connection suggests that these time-dependent $σ$-models may themselves be understood as integrable. We investigate this question by studying the possibility of constructing non-local and local conserved charges. Such $σ$-models with $D$-dimensional target space and time-dependent couplings subject to the RG flow naturally appear in string theory upon fixing the light-cone gauge in a $(D+2)$-dimensional conformal $σ$-model with a metric admitting a covariantly constant null Killing vector and a dilaton linear in the null coordinate.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2020; v1 submitted 3 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Integrable sigma models and 2-loop RG flow
Authors:
Ben Hoare,
Nat Levine,
Arkady A. Tseytlin
Abstract:
Following arXiv:1907.04737, we continue our investigation of the relation between the renormalizability (with finitely many couplings) and integrability in 2d $σ$-models. We focus on the "$λ$-model," an integrable model associated to a group or symmetric space and containing as special limits a (gauged) WZW model and an "interpolating model" for non-abelian duality. The parameters are the WZ level…
▽ More
Following arXiv:1907.04737, we continue our investigation of the relation between the renormalizability (with finitely many couplings) and integrability in 2d $σ$-models. We focus on the "$λ$-model," an integrable model associated to a group or symmetric space and containing as special limits a (gauged) WZW model and an "interpolating model" for non-abelian duality. The parameters are the WZ level $k$ and the coupling $λ$, and the fields are $g$, valued in a group $G$, and a 2d vector $A_\pm$ in the corresponding algebra. We formulate the $λ$-model as a $σ$-model on an extended $G \times G \times G$ configuration space $(g, h, \bar{h})$, defining $h $ and $\bar{h}$ by $A_+ = h \partial_+ h^{-1}$, $A_- = \bar{h} \partial_- \bar{h}^{-1}$. Our central observation is that the model on this extended configuration space is renormalizable without any deformation, with only $λ$ running. This is in contrast to the standard $σ$-model found by integrating out $A_\pm$, whose 2-loop renormalizability is only obtained after the addition of specific finite local counterterms, resulting in a quantum deformation of the target space geometry. We compute the 2-loop $β$-function of the $λ$-model for general group and symmetric spaces, and illustrate our results on the examples of $SU(2)/U(1)$ and $SU(2)$. Similar conclusions apply in the non-abelian dual limit implying that non-abelian duality commutes with the RG flow. We also find the 2-loop $β$-function of a "squashed" principal chiral model.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2019; v1 submitted 1 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Integrable 2d sigma models: quantum corrections to geometry from RG flow
Authors:
Ben Hoare,
Nat Levine,
Arkady A. Tseytlin
Abstract:
Classically integrable $σ$-models are known to be solutions of the 1-loop RG equations, or "Ricci flow", with only a few couplings running. In some of the simplest examples of integrable deformations we find that in order to preserve this property at 2 (and higher) loops the classical $σ$-model should be corrected by quantum counterterms. The pattern is similar to that of effective $σ$-models asso…
▽ More
Classically integrable $σ$-models are known to be solutions of the 1-loop RG equations, or "Ricci flow", with only a few couplings running. In some of the simplest examples of integrable deformations we find that in order to preserve this property at 2 (and higher) loops the classical $σ$-model should be corrected by quantum counterterms. The pattern is similar to that of effective $σ$-models associated to gauged WZW theories. We consider in detail the examples of the $η$-deformation of $S^2$ ("sausage model") and $H^2$, as well as the closely related $λ$-deformation of the $SO(1,2)/SO(2)$ coset. We also point out that similar counterterms are required in order for non-abelian duality to commute with RG flow beyond the 1-loop order.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2019; v1 submitted 10 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
On the massless tree-level S-matrix in 2d sigma models
Authors:
Ben Hoare,
Nat Levine,
Arkady A. Tseytlin
Abstract:
Motivated by the search for new integrable string models, we study the properties of massless tree-level S-matrices for 2d sigma models expanded near the trivial vacuum. We find that, in contrast to the standard massive case, there is no apparent link between massless S-matrices and integrability: in well-known integrable models the tree-level massless S-matrix fails to factorize and exhibits part…
▽ More
Motivated by the search for new integrable string models, we study the properties of massless tree-level S-matrices for 2d sigma models expanded near the trivial vacuum. We find that, in contrast to the standard massive case, there is no apparent link between massless S-matrices and integrability: in well-known integrable models the tree-level massless S-matrix fails to factorize and exhibits particle production. Such tree-level particle production is found in several classically integrable models: the principal chiral model, its classically equivalent "pseudo-dual" model, its non-abelian dual model and also the SO(N+1)/SO(N) coset model. The connection to integrability may, in principle, be restored if one expands near a non-trivial vacuum with massive excitations. We discuss IR ambiguities in 2d massless tree-level amplitudes and their resolution using either a small mass parameter or the i epsilon-regularization. In general, these ambiguities can lead to anomalies in the equivalence of the S-matrix under field redefinitions, and may be linked to the observed particle production in integrable models. We also comment on the transformation of massless S-matrices under sigma model T-duality, comparing the standard and the "doubled" formulations (with T-duality covariance built into the latter).
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2019; v1 submitted 6 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
