Showing 1–50 of 167 results for author: Klebanov, I R

Yang-Lee Quantum Criticality in Various Dimensions

Authors: Erick Arguello Cruz, Igor R. Klebanov, Grigory Tarnopolsky, Yuan Xin

Abstract: The Yang-Lee universality class arises when imaginary magnetic field is tuned to its critical value in the paramagnetic phase of the $d<6$ Ising model. In $d=2$, this non-unitary Conformal Field Theory (CFT) is exactly solvable via the $M(2,5)$ minimal model. As found long ago by von Gehlen using Exact Diagonalization, the corresponding real-time, quantum critical behavior arises in the periodic I… ▽ More The Yang-Lee universality class arises when imaginary magnetic field is tuned to its critical value in the paramagnetic phase of the $d<6$ Ising model. In $d=2$, this non-unitary Conformal Field Theory (CFT) is exactly solvable via the $M(2,5)$ minimal model. As found long ago by von Gehlen using Exact Diagonalization, the corresponding real-time, quantum critical behavior arises in the periodic Ising spin chain when the imaginary longitudinal magnetic field is tuned to its critical value from below. Even though the Hamiltonian is not Hermitian, the energy levels are real due to the $PT$ symmetry. In this paper, we explore the analogous quantum critical behavior in higher dimensional non-Hermitian Hamiltonians on regularized spheres $S^{d-1}$. For $d=3$, we use the recently invented, powerful fuzzy sphere method, as well as discretization by the platonic solids cube, icosahedron and dodecaherdron. The low-lying energy levels and structure constants we find are in agreement with expectations from the conformal symmetry. The energy levels are in good quantitative agreement with the high-temperature expansions and with Padé extrapolations of the $6-ε$ expansions in Fisher's $iφ^3$ Euclidean field theory for the Yang-Lee criticality. In the course of this work, we clarify some aspects of matching between operators in this field theory and quasiprimary fields in the $M(2,5)$ minimal model. For $d=4$, we obtain new results by replacing the $S^3$ with the self-dual polytope called the $24$-cell. △ Less

Submitted 4 June, 2025; v1 submitted 9 May, 2025; originally announced May 2025.

Comments: 44 pages, 20 figures. v2: minor improvements, references added. v3: minor improvements

Ginzburg-Landau description of a class of non-unitary minimal models

Authors: Andrei Katsevich, Igor R. Klebanov, Zimo Sun

Abstract: It has been proposed that the Ginzburg-Landau description of the non-unitary conformal minimal model $M(3,8)$ is provided by the Euclidean theory of two real scalar fields with third-order interactions that have imaginary coefficients. The same lagrangian describes the non-unitary model $M(3,10)$, which is a product of two Yang-Lee theories $M(2,5)$, and the Renormalization Group flow from it to… ▽ More It has been proposed that the Ginzburg-Landau description of the non-unitary conformal minimal model $M(3,8)$ is provided by the Euclidean theory of two real scalar fields with third-order interactions that have imaginary coefficients. The same lagrangian describes the non-unitary model $M(3,10)$, which is a product of two Yang-Lee theories $M(2,5)$, and the Renormalization Group flow from it to $M(3,8)$. This proposal has recently passed an important consistency check, due to Y. Nakayama and T. Tanaka, based on the anomaly matching for non-invertible topological lines. In this paper, we elaborate the earlier proposal and argue that the two-field theory describes the $D$ series modular invariants of both $M(3,8)$ and $M(3,10)$. We further propose the Ginzburg-Landau descriptions of the entire class of $D$ series minimal models $M(q, 3q-1)$ and $M(q, 3q+1)$, with odd integer $q$. They involve $PT$ symmetric theories of two scalar fields with interactions of order $q$ multiplied by imaginary coupling constants. △ Less

Submitted 12 February, 2025; v1 submitted 15 October, 2024; originally announced October 2024.

Comments: 16 pages, 5 tables and 1 figure. v4: version to appear in JHEP

More About the Lattice Hamiltonian for Adjoint QCD$_2$

Authors: Ross Dempsey, Silviu S. Pufu, Benjamin T. Søgaard, Igor R. Klebanov

Abstract: In our earlier work arXiv:2311.09334, we introduced a lattice Hamiltonian for Adjoint QCD$_2$ using staggered Majorana fermions. We found the gauge invariant space of states explicitly for the gauge group $\text{SU}(2)$ and used them for numerical calculations of observables, such as the spectrum and the expectation value of the fermion bilinear. In this paper, we carry out a more in-depth study o… ▽ More In our earlier work arXiv:2311.09334, we introduced a lattice Hamiltonian for Adjoint QCD$_2$ using staggered Majorana fermions. We found the gauge invariant space of states explicitly for the gauge group $\text{SU}(2)$ and used them for numerical calculations of observables, such as the spectrum and the expectation value of the fermion bilinear. In this paper, we carry out a more in-depth study of our lattice model, extending it to any compact and simply-connected gauge group $G$. We show how to find the gauge invariant space of states and use it to study various observables. We also use the lattice model to calculate the mixed 't Hooft anomalies of Adjoint QCD$_2$ for arbitrary $G$. We show that the matrix elements of the lattice Hamiltonian can be expressed in terms of the Wigner 6$j$-symbols of $G$. For $G = \text{SU}(3)$, we perform exact diagonalization for lattices of up to six sites and study the low-lying spectrum, the fermion bilinear condensate, and the string tension. We also show how to write the lattice strong coupling expansion for ground state energies and operator expectation values in terms of the Wigner 6$j$-symbols. For $\text{SU}(3)$ we carry this out explicitly and find good agreement with the exact diagonalizations, and for $\text{SU}(4)$ we give expansions that can be compared with future numerical studies. △ Less

Submitted 15 April, 2025; v1 submitted 27 September, 2024; originally announced September 2024.

Comments: 64 pages, 12 figures

Report number: PUPT-2654

Small Circle Expansion for Adjoint QCD$_2$ with Periodic Boundary Conditions

Authors: Ross Dempsey, Igor R. Klebanov, Silviu S. Pufu, Benjamin T. Søgaard

Abstract: We study $1+1$-dimensional $\text{SU}(N)$ gauge theory coupled to one adjoint multiplet of Majorana fermions on a small spatial circle of circumference $L$. Using periodic boundary conditions, we derive the effective action for the quantum mechanics of the holonomy and the fermion zero modes in perturbation theory up to order $(gL)^3$. When the adjoint fermion mass-squared is tuned to… ▽ More We study $1+1$-dimensional $\text{SU}(N)$ gauge theory coupled to one adjoint multiplet of Majorana fermions on a small spatial circle of circumference $L$. Using periodic boundary conditions, we derive the effective action for the quantum mechanics of the holonomy and the fermion zero modes in perturbation theory up to order $(gL)^3$. When the adjoint fermion mass-squared is tuned to $g^2 N/(2π)$, the effective action is found to be an example of supersymmetric quantum mechanics with a nontrivial superpotential. We separate the states into the $\mathbb{Z}_N$ center symmetry sectors (universes) labeled by $p=0, \ldots, N-1$ and show that in one of the sectors the supersymmetry is unbroken, while in the others it is broken spontaneously. These results give us new insights into the $(1,1)$ supersymmetry of adjoint QCD$_2$, which has previously been established using light-cone quantization. When the adjoint mass is set to zero, our effective Hamiltonian does not depend on the fermions at all, so that there are $2^{N-1}$ degenerate sectors of the Hilbert space. This construction appears to provide an explicit realization of the extended symmetry of the massless model, where there are $2^{2N-2}$ operators that commute with the Hamiltonian. We also generalize our results to other gauge groups $G$, for which supersymmetry is found at the adjoint mass-squared $g^2 h^\vee/(2π)$, where $h^\vee$ is the dual Coxeter number of $G$. △ Less

Submitted 24 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Comments: 57 pages, 4 figures

Report number: PUPT-2653

Lattice Hamiltonian for Adjoint QCD$_2$

Authors: Ross Dempsey, Igor R. Klebanov, Silviu S. Pufu, Benjamin T. Søgaard

Abstract: We introduce a Hamiltonian lattice model for the $(1+1)$-dimensional $\text{SU}(N_c)$ gauge theory coupled to one adjoint Majorana fermion of mass $m$. The discretization of the continuum theory uses staggered Majorana fermions. We analyze the symmetries of the lattice model and find lattice analogs of the anomalies of the corresponding continuum theory. An important role is played by the lattice… ▽ More We introduce a Hamiltonian lattice model for the $(1+1)$-dimensional $\text{SU}(N_c)$ gauge theory coupled to one adjoint Majorana fermion of mass $m$. The discretization of the continuum theory uses staggered Majorana fermions. We analyze the symmetries of the lattice model and find lattice analogs of the anomalies of the corresponding continuum theory. An important role is played by the lattice translation by one lattice site, which in the continuum limit involves a discrete axial transformation. On a lattice with periodic boundary conditions, the Hilbert space breaks up into sectors labeled by the $N_c$-ality $p=0, \ldots N_c-1$. Our symmetry analysis implies various exact degeneracies in the spectrum of the lattice model. In particular, it shows that, for $m=0$ and even $N_c$, the sectors $p$ and $p'$ are degenerate if $|p-p'| = N_c/2$. In the $N_c = 2$ case, we explicitly construct the action of the Hamiltonian on a basis of gauge-invariant states, and we perform both a strong coupling expansion and exact diagonalization for lattices of up to $12$ lattice sites. Upon extrapolation of these results, we find good agreement with the spectrum computed previously using discretized light-cone quantization. One of our new results is the first numerical calculation of the fermion bilinear condensate. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2024; v1 submitted 15 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Comments: 47 pages, 5 figures

Report number: PUPT-2649

Boundaries and Interfaces with Localized Cubic Interactions in the $O(N)$ Model

Authors: Sabine Harribey, Igor R. Klebanov, Zimo Sun

Abstract: We explore a new approach to boundaries and interfaces in the $O(N)$ model where we add certain localized cubic interactions. These operators are nearly marginal when the bulk dimension is $4-ε$, and they explicitly break the $O(N)$ symmetry of the bulk theory down to $O(N-1)$. We show that the one-loop beta functions of the cubic couplings are affected by the quartic bulk interactions. For the in… ▽ More We explore a new approach to boundaries and interfaces in the $O(N)$ model where we add certain localized cubic interactions. These operators are nearly marginal when the bulk dimension is $4-ε$, and they explicitly break the $O(N)$ symmetry of the bulk theory down to $O(N-1)$. We show that the one-loop beta functions of the cubic couplings are affected by the quartic bulk interactions. For the interfaces, we find real fixed points up to the critical value $N_{\rm crit}\approx 7$, while for $N> 4$ there are IR stable fixed points with purely imaginary values of the cubic couplings. For the boundaries, there are real fixed points for all $N$, but we don't find any purely imaginary fixed points. We also consider the theories of $M$ pairs of symplectic fermions and one real scalar, which have quartic $OSp(1|2M)$ invariant interactions in the bulk. We then add the $Sp(2M)$ invariant localized cubic interactions. The beta functions for these theories are related to those in the $O(N)$ model via the replacement of $N$ by $1- 2M$. In the special case $M=1$, there are boundary or interface fixed points that preserve the $OSp(1|2)$ symmetry, as well as other fixed points that break it. △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 18 pages, 6 figures

Phase Diagram of the Two-Flavor Schwinger Model at Zero Temperature

Authors: Ross Dempsey, Igor R. Klebanov, Silviu S. Pufu, Benjamin T. Søgaard, Bernardo Zan

Abstract: We examine the phase structure of the two-flavor Schwinger model as a function of the $θ$-angle and the two masses, $m_1$ and $m_2$. In particular, we find interesting effects at $θ=π$: along the $SU(2)$-invariant line $m_1 = m_2 = m$, in the regime where $m$ is much smaller than the charge $g$, the theory undergoes logarithmic RG flow of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless type. As a result, in t… ▽ More We examine the phase structure of the two-flavor Schwinger model as a function of the $θ$-angle and the two masses, $m_1$ and $m_2$. In particular, we find interesting effects at $θ=π$: along the $SU(2)$-invariant line $m_1 = m_2 = m$, in the regime where $m$ is much smaller than the charge $g$, the theory undergoes logarithmic RG flow of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless type. As a result, in this regime there is a non-perturbatively small mass gap $\sim e^{- A g^2/m^2}$. The $SU(2)$-invariant line lies within a region of the phase diagram where the charge conjugation symmetry is spontaneously broken and whose boundaries we determine numerically. Our numerical results are obtained using the Hamiltonian lattice gauge formulation that includes the mass shift $m_\text{lat} = m- g^2 a/4$ dictated by the discrete chiral symmetry. △ Less

Submitted 13 December, 2023; v1 submitted 7 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: 7 pages, 3 figures; v2 minor improvements, refs added; v3 further minor improvements

Report number: PUPT-2640

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 132, 031603 (2024)

Majorana Scars as Group Singlets

Authors: Z. Sun, F. K. Popov, I. R. Klebanov, K. Pakrouski

Abstract: In some quantum many-body systems, the Hilbert space breaks up into a large ergodic sector and a much smaller scar subspace. It has been suggested [arXiv:2007.00845] that the two sectors may be distinguished by their transformation properties under a large group whose rank grows with the system size (it is not a symmetry of the Hamiltonian). The quantum many-body scars are invariant under this gro… ▽ More In some quantum many-body systems, the Hilbert space breaks up into a large ergodic sector and a much smaller scar subspace. It has been suggested [arXiv:2007.00845] that the two sectors may be distinguished by their transformation properties under a large group whose rank grows with the system size (it is not a symmetry of the Hamiltonian). The quantum many-body scars are invariant under this group, while all other states are not. Here we apply this idea to lattice systems containing $M$ Majorana fermions per site. The Hilbert space for $N$ sites may be decomposed under the action of the O$(N)\times$O$(M)$ group, and the scars are the SO$(N)$ singlets. For any even $M$ there are two families of scars. One of them, which we call the $η$ states, is symmetric under the group O$(N)$. The other, the $ζ$ states, has the SO$(N)$ invariance. For $M=4$, where our construction reduces to spin-$1/2$ fermions on a lattice with local interactions, the former family are the $N+1$ $η$-pairing states, while the latter are the $N+1$ states of maximum spin. We generalize this construction to $M>4$. For $M=6$ we exhibit explicit formulae for the scar states and use them to calculate the bipartite entanglement entropy analytically. For large $N$, it grows logarithmically with the sub-system size. We present a general argument that any group-invariant scars should have the entanglement entropy that is parametrically smaller than that of typical states. The energies of the scars we find are not equidistant in general but can be made so by choosing Hamiltonian parameters. For $M>6$ we find that with local Hamiltonians the scars typically have certain degeneracies. The scar spectrum can be made ergodic by adding a non-local interaction term. We derive the dimension of each scar family and show the scars could have a large contribution to the density of states for small $N$. △ Less

Submitted 6 December, 2023; v1 submitted 22 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Comments: 18 pages, 1 table, 10 figures; v2: changed parameters to improve presentation, added several new results including a bound on entropy for group-invariant scars; v3: version to appear in PRR

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 5, 043208, (2023)

Ginzburg-Landau Description and Emergent Supersymmetry of the $(3,8)$ Minimal Model

Authors: Igor R. Klebanov, Vladimir Narovlansky, Zimo Sun, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: A pair of the 2D non-unitary minimal models $M(2,5)$ is known to be equivalent to a variant of the $M(3,10)$ minimal model. We discuss the RG flow from this model to another non-unitary minimal model, $M(3,8)$. This provides new evidence for its previously proposed Ginzburg-Landau description, which is a $\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetric theory of two scalar fields with cubic interactions. We also point ou… ▽ More A pair of the 2D non-unitary minimal models $M(2,5)$ is known to be equivalent to a variant of the $M(3,10)$ minimal model. We discuss the RG flow from this model to another non-unitary minimal model, $M(3,8)$. This provides new evidence for its previously proposed Ginzburg-Landau description, which is a $\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetric theory of two scalar fields with cubic interactions. We also point out that $M(3,8)$ is equivalent to the $(2,8)$ superconformal minimal model with the diagonal modular invariant. Using the 5-loop results for theories of scalar fields with cubic interactions, we exhibit the $6-ε$ expansions of the dimensions of various operators. Their extrapolations are in quite good agreement with the exact results in 2D. We also use them to approximate the scaling dimensions in $d=3,4,5$ for the theories in the $M(3,8)$ universality class. △ Less

Submitted 1 January, 2023; v1 submitted 13 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 24 pages, 2 figures; v3: additional symmetry constraints pointed out, references added

Adjoint Majorana QCD$_2$ at Finite $N$

Authors: Ross Dempsey, Igor R. Klebanov, Loki L. Lin, Silviu S. Pufu

Abstract: The mass spectrum of $1+1$-dimensional $\mathrm{SU}(N)$ gauge theory coupled to a Majorana fermion in the adjoint representation has been studied in the large $N$ limit using Light-Cone Quantization. Here we extend this approach to theories with small values of $N$, exhibiting explicit results for $N=2, 3$, and $4$. In the context of Discretized Light-Cone Quantization, we develop a procedure base… ▽ More The mass spectrum of $1+1$-dimensional $\mathrm{SU}(N)$ gauge theory coupled to a Majorana fermion in the adjoint representation has been studied in the large $N$ limit using Light-Cone Quantization. Here we extend this approach to theories with small values of $N$, exhibiting explicit results for $N=2, 3$, and $4$. In the context of Discretized Light-Cone Quantization, we develop a procedure based on the Cayley-Hamilton theorem for determining which states of the large $N$ theory become null at finite $N$. For the low-lying bound states, we find that the squared masses divided by $g^2 N$, where $g$ is the gauge coupling, have very weak dependence on $N$. The coefficients of the $1/N^2$ corrections to their large $N$ values are surprisingly small. When the adjoint fermion is massless, we observe exact degeneracies that we explain in terms of a Kac-Moody algebra construction and charge conjugation symmetry. When the squared mass of the adjoint fermion is tuned to $g^2 N / π$, we find evidence that the spectrum exhibits boson-fermion degeneracies, in agreement with the supersymmetry of the model at any value of $N$. △ Less

Submitted 19 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 45 pages, 7 figures

Report number: PUPT-2635

Discrete Chiral Symmetry and Mass Shift in Lattice Hamiltonian Approach to Schwinger Model

Authors: Ross Dempsey, Igor R. Klebanov, Silviu S. Pufu, Bernardo Zan

Abstract: We revisit the lattice formulation of the Schwinger model using the Kogut-Susskind Hamiltonian approach with staggered fermions. This model, introduced by Banks et al., contains the mass term $m_{\rm lat} \sum_{n} (-1)^{n} χ^\dagger_n χ_n$, and setting it to zero is often assumed to provide the lattice regularization of the massless Schwinger model. We instead argue that the relation between the l… ▽ More We revisit the lattice formulation of the Schwinger model using the Kogut-Susskind Hamiltonian approach with staggered fermions. This model, introduced by Banks et al., contains the mass term $m_{\rm lat} \sum_{n} (-1)^{n} χ^\dagger_n χ_n$, and setting it to zero is often assumed to provide the lattice regularization of the massless Schwinger model. We instead argue that the relation between the lattice and continuum mass parameters should be taken as $m_{\rm lat}=m- \frac 18 e^2 a$. The model with $m=0$ is shown to possess a discrete chiral symmetry that is generated by the unit lattice translation accompanied by the shift of the $θ$-angle by $π$. While the mass shift vanishes as the lattice spacing $a$ approaches zero, we find that including this shift greatly improves the rate of convergence to the continuum limit. We demonstrate the faster convergence using both numerical diagonalizations of finite lattice systems, as well as extrapolations of the lattice strong coupling expansions. △ Less

Submitted 7 February, 2023; v1 submitted 10 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

Comments: 14 pages, 7 figures; v2 refs added, minor improvements; v3 minor improvements, journal version

Report number: PUPT-2634

Critical Field Theories with OSp$(1|2M)$ Symmetry

Authors: Igor R. Klebanov

Abstract: In the paper [L. Fei et al., JHEP 09 (2015) 076] a cubic field theory of a scalar field $σ$ and two anticommuting scalar fields, $θ$ and $\bar θ$, was formulated. In $6-ε$ dimensions it has a weakly coupled fixed point with imaginary cubic couplings where the symmetry is enhanced to the supergroup OSp$(1|2)$. This theory may be viewed as a "UV completion" in $2<d<6$ of the non-linear sigma model w… ▽ More In the paper [L. Fei et al., JHEP 09 (2015) 076] a cubic field theory of a scalar field $σ$ and two anticommuting scalar fields, $θ$ and $\bar θ$, was formulated. In $6-ε$ dimensions it has a weakly coupled fixed point with imaginary cubic couplings where the symmetry is enhanced to the supergroup OSp$(1|2)$. This theory may be viewed as a "UV completion" in $2<d<6$ of the non-linear sigma model with hyperbolic target space H$^{0|2}$ described by a pair of intrinsic anticommuting coordinates. It also describes the $q\rightarrow 0$ limit of the critical $q$-state Potts model, which is equivalent to the statistical mechanics of spanning forests on a graph. In this letter we generalize these results to a class of OSp$(1|2M)$ symmetric field theories whose upper critical dimensions are $d_c(M) = 2 \frac{2M+1}{2M-1}$. They contain $2M$ anticommuting scalar fields, $θ^i, \bar θ^i$, and one commuting one, with interaction $g\left (σ^2+ 2θ^i \bar θ^i \right )^{(2M+1)/2}$. In $d_c(M)-ε$ dimensions, we find a weakly coupled IR fixed point at an imaginary value of $g$. We propose that these critical theories are the UV completions of the sigma models with fermionic hyperbolic target spaces H$^{0|2M}$. Of particular interest is the quintic field theory with OSp$(1|4)$ symmetry, whose upper critical dimension is $10/3$. Using this theory, we make a prediction for the critical behavior of the OSp$(1|4)$ lattice system in three dimensions. △ Less

Submitted 13 March, 2022; v1 submitted 24 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: 12 pages; v2: minor improvements, references added; v3: corrections to some beta functions; main conclusions not affected; v4: some anomalous dimension formulae corrected

Group theoretic approach to many-body scar states in fermionic lattice models

Authors: Kiryl Pakrouski, Preethi N. Pallegar, Fedor K. Popov, Igor R. Klebanov

Abstract: It has been shown [arXiv:2007.00845] that three families of highly symmetric states are many-body scars for any spin-1/2 fermionic Hamiltonian of the form $H_0+OT$, where $T$ is a generator of an appropriate Lie group. One of these families consists of the well-known $η$-pairing states. In addition to having the usual properties of scars, these families of states are insensitive to electromagnetic… ▽ More It has been shown [arXiv:2007.00845] that three families of highly symmetric states are many-body scars for any spin-1/2 fermionic Hamiltonian of the form $H_0+OT$, where $T$ is a generator of an appropriate Lie group. One of these families consists of the well-known $η$-pairing states. In addition to having the usual properties of scars, these families of states are insensitive to electromagnetic noise and have advantages for storing and processing quantum information. In this paper we show that a number of well-known coupling terms, such as the Hubbard and the Heisenberg interactions, and the Hamiltonians containing them, are of the required form and support these states as scars without fine-tuning. The explicit $H_0+OT$ decomposition for a number of most commonly used models, including topological ones, is provided. To facilitate possible experimental implementations, we discuss the conditions for the low-energy subspace of these models to be comprised solely of scars. Further, we write down all the generators $T$ that can be used as building blocks for designing new models with scars, most interestingly including the spin-orbit coupled hopping and superconducting pairing terms. We expand this framework to the non-Hermitian open systems and demonstrate that for them the scar subspace continues to undergo coherent time evolution and exhibit the "revivals". A full numerical study of an extended 2D $tJU$ model explicitly illustrates the novel properties of the invariant scars and supports our findings. △ Less

Submitted 1 November, 2021; v1 submitted 18 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: v3: presentation improved, typos corrected, references added

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 3, 043156 (2021)

Exact Symmetries and Threshold States in Two-Dimensional Models for QCD

Authors: Ross Dempsey, Igor R. Klebanov, Silviu S. Pufu

Abstract: Two-dimensional SU$(N)$ gauge theory coupled to a Majorana fermion in the adjoint representation is a nice toy model for higher-dimensional gauge dynamics. It possesses a multitude of "gluinoball" bound states whose spectrum has been studied using numerical diagonalizations of the light-cone Hamiltonian. We extend this model by coupling it to $N_f$ flavors of fundamental Dirac fermions (quarks). T… ▽ More Two-dimensional SU$(N)$ gauge theory coupled to a Majorana fermion in the adjoint representation is a nice toy model for higher-dimensional gauge dynamics. It possesses a multitude of "gluinoball" bound states whose spectrum has been studied using numerical diagonalizations of the light-cone Hamiltonian. We extend this model by coupling it to $N_f$ flavors of fundamental Dirac fermions (quarks). The extended model also contains meson-like bound states, both bosonic and fermionic, which in the large-$N$ limit decouple from the gluinoballs. We study the large-$N$ meson spectrum using the Discretized Light-Cone Quantization (DLCQ). When all the fermions are massless, we exhibit an exact $\mathfrak{osp}(1|4)$ symmetry algebra that leads to an infinite number of degeneracies in the DLCQ approach. More generally, we show that many single-trace states in the theory are threshold bound states that are degenerate with multi-trace states. These exact degeneracies can be explained using the Kac-Moody algebra of the SU$(N)$ current. We also present strong numerical evidence that additional threshold states appear in the continuum limit. Finally, we make the quarks massive while keeping the adjoint fermion massless. In this case too, we observe some exact degeneracies that show that the spectrum of mesons becomes continuous above a certain threshold. This demonstrates quantitatively that the fundamental string tension vanishes in the massless adjoint QCD$_2$. △ Less

Submitted 2 June, 2021; v1 submitted 13 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: 61 pages, 8 figures; v2 Section 8 expanded to include a discussion of screening, minor improvements; v3 minor improvements, ref added

Report number: PUPT-2623

RG Limit Cycles and Unconventional Fixed Points in Perturbative QFT

Authors: Christian B. Jepsen, Igor R. Klebanov, Fedor K. Popov

Abstract: We study quantum field theories with sextic interactions in $3-ε$ dimensions, where the scalar fields $φ^{ab}$ form irreducible representations under the $O(N)^2$ or $O(N)$ global symmetry group. We calculate the beta functions up to four-loop order and find the Renormalization Group fixed points. In an example of large $N$ equivalence, the parent $O(N)^2$ theory and its anti-symmetric projection… ▽ More We study quantum field theories with sextic interactions in $3-ε$ dimensions, where the scalar fields $φ^{ab}$ form irreducible representations under the $O(N)^2$ or $O(N)$ global symmetry group. We calculate the beta functions up to four-loop order and find the Renormalization Group fixed points. In an example of large $N$ equivalence, the parent $O(N)^2$ theory and its anti-symmetric projection exhibit identical large $N$ beta functions which possess real fixed points. However, for projection to the symmetric traceless representation of $O(N)$, the large $N$ equivalence is violated by the appearance of an additional double-trace operator not inherited from the parent theory. Among the large $N$ fixed points of this daughter theory we find complex CFTs. The symmetric traceless $O(N)$ model also exhibits very interesting phenomena when it is analytically continued to small non-integer values of $N$. Here we find unconventional fixed points, which we call "spooky." They are located at real values of the coupling constants $g^i$, but two eigenvalues of the Jacobian matrix $\partial β^i/\partial g^j$ are complex. When these complex conjugate eigenvalues cross the imaginary axis, a Hopf bifurcation occurs, giving rise to RG limit cycles. This crossing occurs for $N_{\rm crit} \approx 4.475$, and for a small range of $N$ above this value we find RG flows which lead to limit cycles. △ Less

Submitted 29 April, 2021; v1 submitted 28 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Comments: v4: typo in eq. (41) corrected and discussion near it improved

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 103, 046015 (2021)

Many Body Scars as a Group Invariant Sector of Hilbert Space

Authors: Kiryl Pakrouski, Preethi N. Pallegar, Fedor K. Popov, Igor R. Klebanov

Abstract: We present a class of Hamiltonians $H$ for which a sector of the Hilbert space invariant under a Lie group $G$, which is not a symmetry of $H$, possesses the essential properties of many-body scar states. These include the absence of thermalization and the "revivals" of special initial states in time evolution. Some of the scar states found in earlier work may be viewed as special cases of our con… ▽ More We present a class of Hamiltonians $H$ for which a sector of the Hilbert space invariant under a Lie group $G$, which is not a symmetry of $H$, possesses the essential properties of many-body scar states. These include the absence of thermalization and the "revivals" of special initial states in time evolution. Some of the scar states found in earlier work may be viewed as special cases of our construction. A particular class of examples concerns interacting spin-1/2 fermions on a lattice consisting of $N$ sites (it includes deformations of the Fermi-Hubbard model as special cases), and we show that it contains two families of $N+1$ scar states. One of these families, which was found in recent literature, is comprised of the well-known $η$-pairing states. We find another family of scar states which is $U(N)$ invariant. Both families and most of the group-invariant scar states produced by our construction in general, give rise to the off-diagonal long range order which survives at high temperatures and is insensitive to the details of the dynamics. Such states could be used for reliable quantum information processing because the information is stored non-locally, and thus cannot be easily erased by local perturbations. In contrast, other scar states we find are product states which could be easily prepared experimentally. The dimension of scar subspace is directly controlled by the choice of group $G$ and can be made exponentially large. △ Less

Submitted 2 December, 2020; v1 submitted 1 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

Comments: v3: restructured, significantly improved readability, version accepted to PRL

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 230602 (2020)

Spontaneous Breaking of $U(1)$ Symmetry in Coupled Complex SYK Models

Authors: Igor R. Klebanov, Alexey Milekhin, Grigory Tarnopolsky, Wenli Zhao

Abstract: As shown in [1], two copies of the large $N$ Majorana SYK model can produce spontaneous breaking of a $Z_2$ symmetry when they are coupled by appropriate quartic terms. In this paper we similarly study two copies of the complex SYK model coupled by a quartic term preserving the $U(1) \times U(1)$ symmetry. We also present a tensor counterpart of this coupled model. When the coefficient $α$ of the… ▽ More As shown in [1], two copies of the large $N$ Majorana SYK model can produce spontaneous breaking of a $Z_2$ symmetry when they are coupled by appropriate quartic terms. In this paper we similarly study two copies of the complex SYK model coupled by a quartic term preserving the $U(1) \times U(1)$ symmetry. We also present a tensor counterpart of this coupled model. When the coefficient $α$ of the quartic term lies in a certain range, the coupled large $N$ theory is nearly conformal. We calculate the scaling dimensions of fermion bilinear operators as functions of $α$. We show that the operator $c_{1i}^\dagger c_{2i}$, which is charged under the axial $U(1)$ symmetry, acquires a complex dimension outside of the line of fixed points. We derive the large $N$ Dyson-Schwinger equations and show that, outside the fixed line, this $U(1)$ symmetry is spontaneously broken at low temperatures because this operator acquires an expectation value. We support these findings by exact diagonalizations extrapolated to large $N$. △ Less

Submitted 26 October, 2020; v1 submitted 12 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 36 pages, 16 figures; v2: some improvements; v3: version to appear in JHEP

Hagedorn Temperature in Large $N$ Majorana Quantum Mechanics

Authors: Gabriel Gaitan, Igor R. Klebanov, Kiryl Pakrouski, Preethi N. Pallegar, Fedor K. Popov

Abstract: We discuss two types of quantum mechanical models that couple large numbers of Majorana fermions and have orthogonal symmetry groups. In models of vector type, only one of the symmetry groups has a large rank. The large $N$ limit is taken keeping $gN=λ$ fixed, where $g$ multiplies the quartic Hamiltonian. We introduce a simple model with $O(N)\times SO(4)$ symmetry, whose energies are expressed in… ▽ More We discuss two types of quantum mechanical models that couple large numbers of Majorana fermions and have orthogonal symmetry groups. In models of vector type, only one of the symmetry groups has a large rank. The large $N$ limit is taken keeping $gN=λ$ fixed, where $g$ multiplies the quartic Hamiltonian. We introduce a simple model with $O(N)\times SO(4)$ symmetry, whose energies are expressed in terms of the quadratic Casimirs of the symmetry groups. This model may be deformed so that the symmetry is $O(N)\times O(2)^2$, and the Hamiltonian reduces to that studied in arXiv:1802.10263. We find analytic expressions for the large $N$ density of states and free energy. In both vector models, the large $N$ density of states varies approximately as $e^{-|E|/λ}$ for a wide range of energies. This gives rise to critical behavior as the temperature approaches the Hagedorn temperature $T_{\rm H} = λ$. In the formal large $N$ limit, the specific heat blows up as $(T_H- T)^{-2}$, which implies that $T_H$ is the limiting temperature. However, at any finite $N$, it is possible to reach arbitrarily large temperatures. Thus, the finite $N$ effects smooth out the Hagedorn transition. We also study models of matrix type, which have two $O(N)$ symmetry groups with large rank. An example is provided by the Majorana matrix model with $O(N)^2\times O(2)$ symmetry, which was studied in arXiv:1802.10263. In contrast with the vector models, the density of states is smooth and nearly Gaussian near the middle of the spectrum. △ Less

Submitted 7 April, 2020; v1 submitted 5 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: 27 pages, 8 figures, v3: minor improvements, references added

Report number: PUPT-2610

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 101, 126002 (2020)

The $O(N)$ Model in $4<d<6$: Instantons and Complex CFTs

Authors: Simone Giombi, Richard Huang, Igor R. Klebanov, Silviu S. Pufu, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: We revisit the scalar $O(N)$ model in the dimension range $4<d<6$ and study the effects caused by its metastability. As shown in previous work, this model formally possesses a fixed point where, perturbatively in the $1/N$ expansion, the operator scaling dimensions are real and above the unitarity bound. Here, we further show that these scaling dimensions do acquire small imaginary parts due to th… ▽ More We revisit the scalar $O(N)$ model in the dimension range $4<d<6$ and study the effects caused by its metastability. As shown in previous work, this model formally possesses a fixed point where, perturbatively in the $1/N$ expansion, the operator scaling dimensions are real and above the unitarity bound. Here, we further show that these scaling dimensions do acquire small imaginary parts due to the instanton effects. In $d$ dimensions and for large $N$, we find that they are of order $e^{-N f(d)}$, where, remarkably, the function $f(d)$ equals the sphere free energy of a conformal scalar in $d-2$ dimensions. The non-perturbatively small imaginary parts also appear in other observables, such as the sphere free energy and two and three-point function coefficients, and we present some of their calculations. Therefore, at sufficiently large $N$, the $O(N)$ models in $4<d<6$ may be thought of as complex CFTs. When $N$ is large enough for the imaginary parts to be numerically negligible, the five-dimensional $O(N)$ models may be studied using the techniques of numerical bootstrap. △ Less

Submitted 21 July, 2020; v1 submitted 6 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: 56 pages, 4 figures; v2: refs added, minor improvements; v3: minor changes, journal version

Report number: PUPT-2599

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 101, 045013 (2020)

Majorana Fermion Quantum Mechanics for Higher Rank Tensors

Authors: Igor R. Klebanov, Preethi N. Pallegar, Fedor K. Popov

Abstract: We study quantum mechanical models in which the dynamical degrees of freedom are real fermionic tensors of rank five and higher. They are the non-random counterparts of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) models where the Hamiltonian couples six or more fermions. For the tensors of rank five, there is a unique $O(N)^5$ symmetric sixth-order Hamiltonian leading to a solvable large $N$ limit dominated by th… ▽ More We study quantum mechanical models in which the dynamical degrees of freedom are real fermionic tensors of rank five and higher. They are the non-random counterparts of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) models where the Hamiltonian couples six or more fermions. For the tensors of rank five, there is a unique $O(N)^5$ symmetric sixth-order Hamiltonian leading to a solvable large $N$ limit dominated by the melonic diagrams. We solve for the complete energy spectrum of this model when $N=2$ and deduce exact expressions for all the eigenvalues. The subset of states which are gauge invariant exhibit degeneracies related to the discrete symmetries of the gauged model. We also study quantum chaos properties of the tensor model and compare them with those of the $q=6$ SYK model. For $q>6$ there is a rapidly growing number of $O(N)^{q-1}$ invariant tensor interactions. We focus on those of them that are maximally single-trace - their stranded diagrams stay connected when any set of $q-3$ colors is erased. We present a general discussion of why the tensor models with maximally single-trace interactions have large $N$ limits dominated by the melonic diagrams. We solve the large $N$ Schwinger-Dyson equations for the higher rank Majorana tensor models and show that they match those of the corresponding SYK models exactly. We also study other gauge invariant operators present in the tensor models. △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2019; v1 submitted 15 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: 36 pages, 19 figures, 2 tables, v3: some clarifications and references added

Report number: PUPT-2585

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 100, 086003 (2019)

Symmetry Breaking in Coupled SYK or Tensor Models

Authors: Jaewon Kim, Igor R. Klebanov, Grigory Tarnopolsky, Wenli Zhao

Abstract: We study a large $N$ tensor model with $O(N)^3$ symmetry containing two flavors of Majorana fermions, $ψ_1^{abc}$ and $ψ_2^{abc}$. We also study its random counterpart consisting of two coupled Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev models, each one containing $N_{\rm SYK}$ Majorana fermions. In these models we assume tetrahedral quartic Hamiltonians which depend on a real coupling parameter $α$. We find a duality rel… ▽ More We study a large $N$ tensor model with $O(N)^3$ symmetry containing two flavors of Majorana fermions, $ψ_1^{abc}$ and $ψ_2^{abc}$. We also study its random counterpart consisting of two coupled Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev models, each one containing $N_{\rm SYK}$ Majorana fermions. In these models we assume tetrahedral quartic Hamiltonians which depend on a real coupling parameter $α$. We find a duality relation between two Hamiltonians with different values of $α$, which allows us to restrict the model to the range of $-1\leq α\leq 1/3$. The scaling dimension of the fermion number operator $Q=iψ_1^{abc} ψ_2^{abc}$ is complex and of the form $1/2 +i f(α)$ in the range $-1\leq α<0$, indicating an instability of the conformal phase. Using Schwinger-Dyson equations to solve for the Green functions, we show that in the true low-temperature phase this operator acquires an expectation value. This demonstrates the breaking of an anti-unitary particle-hole symmetry and other discrete symmetries. We also calculate spectra of the coupled SYK models for values of $N_{\rm SYK}$ where exact diagonalizations are possible. For negative $α$ we find a gap separating the two lowest energy states from the rest of the spectrum; this leads to exponential decay of the zero-temperature correlation functions. For $N_{\rm SYK}$ divisible by $4$, the two lowest states have a small splitting. They become degenerate in the large $N_{\rm SYK}$ limit, as expected from the spontaneous breaking of a $\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetry. △ Less

Submitted 29 April, 2019; v1 submitted 6 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: 37 pages, v2: some improvements, references added. v3: added a discussion of separation of spectra into sectors and an Appendix on zero-energy states. The version to appear in Physical Review X

Report number: PUPT-2581

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. X 9, 021043 (2019)

TASI Lectures on Large $N$ Tensor Models

Authors: Igor R. Klebanov, Fedor Popov, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: The first part of these lecture notes is mostly devoted to a comparative discussion of the three basic large $N$ limits, which apply to fields which are vectors, matrices, or tensors of rank three and higher. After a brief review of some physical applications of large $N$ limits, we present a few solvable examples in zero space-time dimension. Using models with fields in the fundamental representa… ▽ More The first part of these lecture notes is mostly devoted to a comparative discussion of the three basic large $N$ limits, which apply to fields which are vectors, matrices, or tensors of rank three and higher. After a brief review of some physical applications of large $N$ limits, we present a few solvable examples in zero space-time dimension. Using models with fields in the fundamental representation of $O(N)$, $O(N)^2$, or $O(N)^3$ symmetry, we compare their combinatorial properties and highlight a competition between the snail and melon diagrams. We exhibit the different methods used for solving the vector, matrix, and tensor large $N$ limits. In the latter example we review how the dominance of melonic diagrams follows when a special "tetrahedral" interaction is introduced. The second part of the lectures is mostly about the fermionic quantum mechanical tensor models, whose large $N$ limits are similar to that in the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model. The minimal Majorana model with $O(N)^3$ symmetry and the tetrahedral Hamiltonian is reviewed in some detail; it is the closest tensor counterpart of the SYK model. Also reviewed are generalizations to complex fermionic tensors, including a model with $SU(N)^2\times O(N)\times U(1)$ symmetry, which is a tensor counterpart of the complex SYK model. The bosonic large $N$ tensor models, which are formally tractable in continuous spacetime dimension, are reviewed briefly at the end. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2018; v1 submitted 28 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Comments: 43 pages, 31 figures. This is an extended write-up of lectures given at TASI 2017. v2: minor improvements, references added

Spectrum of Majorana Quantum Mechanics with $O(4)^3$ Symmetry

Authors: Kiryl Pakrouski, Igor R. Klebanov, Fedor Popov, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: We study the quantum mechanics of 3-index Majorana fermions $ψ^{abc}$ governed by a quartic Hamiltonian with $O(N)^3$ symmetry. Similarly to the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model, this tensor model has a solvable large $N$ limit dominated by the melonic diagrams. For $N=4$ the total number of states is $2^{32}$, but they naturally break up into distinct sectors according to the charges under the… ▽ More We study the quantum mechanics of 3-index Majorana fermions $ψ^{abc}$ governed by a quartic Hamiltonian with $O(N)^3$ symmetry. Similarly to the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model, this tensor model has a solvable large $N$ limit dominated by the melonic diagrams. For $N=4$ the total number of states is $2^{32}$, but they naturally break up into distinct sectors according to the charges under the $U(1)\times U(1)$ Cartan subgroup of one of the $O(4)$ groups. The biggest sector has vanishing charges and contains over $165$ million states. Using a Lanczos algorithm, we determine the spectrum of the low-lying states in this and other sectors. We find that the absolute ground state is non-degenerate. If the $SO(4)^3$ symmetry is gauged, it is known from earlier work that the model has $36$ states and a residual discrete symmetry. We study the discrete symmetry group in detail; it gives rise to degeneracies of some of the gauge singlet energies. We find all the gauge singlet energies numerically and use the results to propose exact analytic expressions for them. △ Less

Submitted 11 February, 2019; v1 submitted 22 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Comments: 15 pages, 1 figure, 3 tables; v2: minor improvements, a reference added; v3: minor revisions, journal version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 011601 (2019)

Prismatic Large $N$ Models for Bosonic Tensors

Authors: Simone Giombi, Igor R. Klebanov, Fedor Popov, Shiroman Prakash, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: We study the $O(N)^3$ symmetric quantum field theory of a bosonic tensor $φ^{abc}$ with sextic interactions. Its large $N$ limit is dominated by a positive-definite operator, whose index structure has the topology of a prism. We present a large $N$ solution of the model using Schwinger-Dyson equations to sum the leading diagrams, finding that for $2.81 < d < 3$ and for $d<1.68$ the spectrum of bil… ▽ More We study the $O(N)^3$ symmetric quantum field theory of a bosonic tensor $φ^{abc}$ with sextic interactions. Its large $N$ limit is dominated by a positive-definite operator, whose index structure has the topology of a prism. We present a large $N$ solution of the model using Schwinger-Dyson equations to sum the leading diagrams, finding that for $2.81 < d < 3$ and for $d<1.68$ the spectrum of bilinear operators has no complex scaling dimensions. We also develop perturbation theory in $3-ε$ dimensions including eight $O(N)^3$ invariant operators necessary for the renormalizability. For sufficiently large $N$, we find a "prismatic" fixed point of the renormalization group, where all eight coupling constants are real. The large $N$ limit of the resulting $ε$ expansions of various operator dimensions agrees with the Schwinger-Dyson equations. Furthermore, the $ε$ expansion allows us to calculate the $1/N$ corrections to operator dimensions. The prismatic fixed point in $3-ε$ dimensions survives down to $N\approx 53.65$, where it merges with another fixed point and becomes complex. We also discuss the $d=1$ model where our approach gives a slightly negative scaling dimension for $φ$, while the spectrum of bilinear operators is free of complex dimensions. △ Less

Submitted 21 August, 2019; v1 submitted 13 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Comments: 37 pages, 13 figures, v2: version which appeared in Physical Review D

Report number: PUPT-2568

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 98, 105005 (2018)

Spectra of Eigenstates in Fermionic Tensor Quantum Mechanics

Authors: Igor R. Klebanov, Alexey Milekhin, Fedor Popov, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: We study the $O(N_1)\times O(N_2)\times O(N_3)$ symmetric quantum mechanics of 3-index Majorana fermions. When the ranks $N_i$ are all equal, this model has a large $N$ limit which is dominated by the melonic Feynman diagrams. We derive an integral formula which computes the number of $SO(N_1)\times SO(N_2)\times SO(N_3)$ invariant states for any set of $N_i$. For equal ranks the number of singlet… ▽ More We study the $O(N_1)\times O(N_2)\times O(N_3)$ symmetric quantum mechanics of 3-index Majorana fermions. When the ranks $N_i$ are all equal, this model has a large $N$ limit which is dominated by the melonic Feynman diagrams. We derive an integral formula which computes the number of $SO(N_1)\times SO(N_2)\times SO(N_3)$ invariant states for any set of $N_i$. For equal ranks the number of singlets is non-vanishing only when $N$ is even, and it exhibits rapid growth: it jumps from $36$ in the $O(4)^3$ model to $595354780$ in the $O(6)^3$ model. We derive bounds on the values of energy, which show that they scale at most as $N^3$ in the large $N$ limit, in agreement with expectations. We also show that the splitting between the lowest singlet and non-singlet states is of order $1/N$. For $N_3=1$ the tensor model reduces to $O(N_1)\times O(N_2)$ fermionic matrix quantum mechanics, and we find a simple expression for the Hamiltonian in terms of the quadratic Casimir operators of the symmetry group. A similar expression is derived for the complex matrix model with $SU(N_1)\times SU(N_2)\times U(1)$ symmetry. Finally, we study the $N_3=2$ case of the tensor model, which gives a more intricate complex matrix model whose symmetry is only $O(N_1)\times O(N_2)\times U(1)$. All energies are again integers in appropriate units, and we derive a concise formula for the spectrum. The fermionic matrix models we studied possess standard 't Hooft large $N$ limits where the ground state energies are of order $N^2$, while the energy gaps are of order $1$. △ Less

Submitted 30 July, 2018; v1 submitted 28 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Comments: 42 pages, 1 figure. v2: minor improvements, references added. v3: minor corrections. v4: minor improvements

Report number: PUPT-2552

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 97, 106023 (2018)

Spectra of Operators in Large $N$ Tensor Models

Authors: Ksenia Bulycheva, Igor R. Klebanov, Alexey Milekhin, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: We study the operators in the large $N$ tensor models, focusing mostly on the fermionic quantum mechanics with $O(N)^3$ symmetry which may be either global or gauged. In the model with global symmetry we study the spectra of bilinear operators, which are in either the symmetric traceless or the antisymmetric representation of one of the $O(N)$ groups. In the symmetric traceless case, the spectrum… ▽ More We study the operators in the large $N$ tensor models, focusing mostly on the fermionic quantum mechanics with $O(N)^3$ symmetry which may be either global or gauged. In the model with global symmetry we study the spectra of bilinear operators, which are in either the symmetric traceless or the antisymmetric representation of one of the $O(N)$ groups. In the symmetric traceless case, the spectrum of scaling dimensions is the same as in the SYK model with real fermions; it includes the $h=2$ zero-mode. For the operators anti-symmetric in the two indices, the scaling dimensions are the same as in the additional sector found in the complex tensor and SYK models; the lowest $h=0$ eigenvalue corresponds to the conserved $O(N)$ charges. A class of singlet operators may be constructed from contracted combinations of $m$ symmetric traceless or antisymmetric two-particle operators. Their two-point functions receive contributions from $m$ melonic ladders. Such multiple ladders are a new phenomenon in the tensor model, which does not seem to be present in the SYK model. The more typical $2k$-particle operators do not receive any ladder corrections and have quantized large $N$ scaling dimensions $k/2$. We construct pictorial representations of various singlet operators with low $k$. For larger $k$ we use available techniques to count the operators and show that their number grows as $2^k k!$. As a consequence, the theory has a Hagedorn phase transition at the temperature which approaches zero in the large $N$ limit. We also study the large $N$ spectrum of low-lying operators in the Gurau-Witten model, which has $O(N)^6$ symmetry. We argue that it corresponds to one of the generalized SYK models constructed by Gross and Rosenhaus. Our paper also includes studies of the invariants in large $N$ tensor integrals with various symmetries. △ Less

Submitted 11 February, 2018; v1 submitted 28 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 39 pages, 23 figures. v2: minor improvements, references added. v3: minor improvements, references added

Report number: PUPT-2531

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 97, 026016 (2018)

Bosonic Tensor Models at Large $N$ and Small $ε$

Authors: Simone Giombi, Igor R. Klebanov, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: We study the spectrum of the large $N$ quantum field theory of bosonic rank-$3$ tensors, whose quartic interactions are such that the perturbative expansion is dominated by the melonic diagrams. We use the Schwinger-Dyson equations to determine the scaling dimensions of the bilinear operators of arbitrary spin. Using the fact that the theory is renormalizable in $d=4$, we compare some of these res… ▽ More We study the spectrum of the large $N$ quantum field theory of bosonic rank-$3$ tensors, whose quartic interactions are such that the perturbative expansion is dominated by the melonic diagrams. We use the Schwinger-Dyson equations to determine the scaling dimensions of the bilinear operators of arbitrary spin. Using the fact that the theory is renormalizable in $d=4$, we compare some of these results with the $4-ε$ expansion, finding perfect agreement. This helps elucidate why the dimension of operator $φ^{abc}φ^{abc}$ is complex for $d<4$: the large $N$ fixed point in $d=4-ε$ has complex values of the couplings for some of the $O(N)^3$ invariant operators. We show that a similar phenomenon holds in the $O(N)^2$ symmetric theory of a matrix field $φ^{ab}$, where the double-trace operator has a complex coupling in $4-ε$ dimensions. We also study the spectra of bosonic theories of rank $q-1$ tensors with $φ^q$ interactions. In dimensions $d>1.93$ there is a critical value of $q$, above which we have not found any complex scaling dimensions. The critical value is a decreasing function of $d$, and it becomes $6$ in $d\approx 2.97$. This raises a possibility that the large $N$ theory of rank-$5$ tensors with sextic potential has an IR fixed point which is free of perturbative instabilities for $2.97<d<3$. This theory may be studied using renormalized perturbation theory in $d=3-ε$. △ Less

Submitted 6 August, 2017; v1 submitted 12 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 20 pages, 3 figures, v2: minor corrections, references added

Report number: PUPT-2528

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 96, 106014 (2017)

On Large $N$ Limit of Symmetric Traceless Tensor Models

Authors: Igor R. Klebanov, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: For some theories where the degrees of freedom are tensors of rank $3$ or higher, there exist solvable large $N$ limits dominated by the melonic diagrams. Simple examples are provided by models containing one rank-$3$ tensor in the tri-fundamental representation of the $O(N)^3$ symmetry group. When the quartic interaction is assumed to have a special tetrahedral index structure, the coupling const… ▽ More For some theories where the degrees of freedom are tensors of rank $3$ or higher, there exist solvable large $N$ limits dominated by the melonic diagrams. Simple examples are provided by models containing one rank-$3$ tensor in the tri-fundamental representation of the $O(N)^3$ symmetry group. When the quartic interaction is assumed to have a special tetrahedral index structure, the coupling constant $g$ must be scaled as $N^{-3/2}$ in the melonic large $N$ limit. In this paper we consider the combinatorics of a large $N$ theory of one fully symmetric and traceless rank-$3$ tensor with the tetrahedral quartic interaction; this model has a single $O(N)$ symmetry group. We explicitly calculate all the vacuum diagrams up to order $g^8$, as well as some diagrams of higher order, and find that in the large $N$ limit where $g^2 N^3$ is held fixed only the melonic diagrams survive. While some non-melonic diagrams are enhanced in the $O(N)$ symmetric theory compared to the $O(N)^3$ one, we have not found any diagrams where this enhancement is strong enough to make them comparable with the melonic ones. Motivated by these results, we conjecture that the model of a real rank-$3$ symmetric traceless tensor possesses a smooth large $N$ limit where $g^2 N^3$ is held fixed and all the contributing diagrams are melonic. A feature of the symmetric traceless tensor models is that some vacuum diagrams containing odd numbers of vertices are suppressed only by $N^{-1/2}$ relative to the melonic graphs. △ Less

Submitted 10 August, 2017; v1 submitted 2 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: 18 pages, 12 figures; v2: minor improvements, references added

Report number: PUPT-2525

Uncolored Random Tensors, Melon Diagrams, and the SYK Models

Authors: Igor R. Klebanov, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: Certain models with rank-$3$ tensor degrees of freedom have been shown by Gurau and collaborators to possess a novel large $N$ limit, where $g^2 N^3$ is held fixed. In this limit the perturbative expansion in the quartic coupling constant, $g$, is dominated by a special class of "melon" diagrams. We study "uncolored" models of this type, which contain a single copy of real rank-$3$ tensor. Its thr… ▽ More Certain models with rank-$3$ tensor degrees of freedom have been shown by Gurau and collaborators to possess a novel large $N$ limit, where $g^2 N^3$ is held fixed. In this limit the perturbative expansion in the quartic coupling constant, $g$, is dominated by a special class of "melon" diagrams. We study "uncolored" models of this type, which contain a single copy of real rank-$3$ tensor. Its three indexes are distinguishable; therefore, the models possess $O(N)^3$ symmetry with the tensor field transforming in the tri-fundamental representation. Such uncolored models also possess the large $N$ limit dominated by the melon diagrams. The quantum mechanics of a real anti-commuting tensor therefore has a similar large $N$ limit to the model recently introduced by Witten as an implementation of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model which does not require disorder. Gauging the $O(N)^3$ symmetry in our quantum mechanical model removes the non-singlet states; therefore, one can search for its well-defined gravity dual. We point out, however, that the model possesses a vast number of gauge-invariant operators involving higher powers of the tensor field, suggesting that the complete gravity dual will be intricate. We also discuss the quantum mechanics of a complex 3-index anti-commuting tensor, which has $U(N)^2\times O(N)$ symmetry and argue that it is equivalent in the large $N$ limit to a version of SYK model with complex fermions. Finally, we discuss similar models of a commuting tensor in dimension $d$. While the quartic interaction is not positive definite, we construct the large $N$ Schwinger-Dyson equation for the two-point function and show that its solution is consistent with conformal invariance. We carry out a perturbative check of this result using the $4-ε$ expansion. △ Less

Submitted 31 January, 2017; v1 submitted 27 November, 2016; originally announced November 2016.

Comments: 26 pages, 16 figures, v2: sections 3 and 5 expanded, minor corrections, references added, v3: minor corrections, a reference added, v4: minor corrections, v5: spectrum of the complex model corrected; a note added about "uncolored" higher rank tensors

Report number: PUPT-2514

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 95, 046004 (2017)

The ABC of Higher-Spin AdS/CFT

Authors: Simone Giombi, Igor R. Klebanov, Zhong Ming Tan

Abstract: In recent literature one-loop tests of the higher-spin AdS$_{d+1}$/CFT$_d$ correspondences were carried out. Here we extend these results to a more general set of theories in $d>2$. First, we consider the Type B higher spin theories, which have been conjectured to be dual to CFTs consisting of the singlet sector of $N$ free fermion fields. In addition to the case of $N$ Dirac fermions, we carefull… ▽ More In recent literature one-loop tests of the higher-spin AdS$_{d+1}$/CFT$_d$ correspondences were carried out. Here we extend these results to a more general set of theories in $d>2$. First, we consider the Type B higher spin theories, which have been conjectured to be dual to CFTs consisting of the singlet sector of $N$ free fermion fields. In addition to the case of $N$ Dirac fermions, we carefully study the projections to Weyl, Majorana, symplectic, and Majorana-Weyl fermions in the dimensions where they exist. Second, we explore theories involving elements of both Type A and Type B theories, which we call Type AB. Their spectrum includes fields of every half-integer spin, and they are expected to be related to the $U(N)/O(N)$ singlet sector of the CFT of $N$ free complex/real scalar and fermionic fields. Finally, we explore the Type C theories, which have been conjectured to be dual to the CFTs of $p$-form gauge fields, where $p=\frac d 2 -1$. In most cases we find that the free energies at $O(N^0)$ either vanish or give contributions proportional to the free-energy of a single free field in the conjectured dual CFT. Interpreting these non-vanishing values as shifts of the bulk coupling constant $G_N\sim 1/(N-k)$, we find the values $k=-1, -1/2, 0, 1/2, 1, 2$. Exceptions to this rule are the Type B and AB theories in odd $d$; for them we find a mismatch between the bulk and boundary free energies that has a simple structure, but does not follow from a simple shift of the bulk coupling constant. △ Less

Submitted 26 August, 2016; originally announced August 2016.

Comments: 64 pages

Report number: PUPT-2505

Yukawa CFTs and Emergent Supersymmetry

Authors: Lin Fei, Simone Giombi, Igor R. Klebanov, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: We study conformal field theories with Yukawa interactions in dimensions between 2 and 4; they provide UV completions of the Nambu-Jona-Lasinio and Gross-Neveu models which have four-fermion interactions. We compute the sphere free energy and certain operator scaling dimensions using dimensional continuation. In the Gross-Neveu CFT with $N$ fermion degrees of freedom we obtain the first few terms… ▽ More We study conformal field theories with Yukawa interactions in dimensions between 2 and 4; they provide UV completions of the Nambu-Jona-Lasinio and Gross-Neveu models which have four-fermion interactions. We compute the sphere free energy and certain operator scaling dimensions using dimensional continuation. In the Gross-Neveu CFT with $N$ fermion degrees of freedom we obtain the first few terms in the $4-ε$ expansion using the Gross-Neveu-Yukawa model, and the first few terms in the $2+ε$ expansion using the four-fermion interaction. We then apply Pade approximants to produce estimates in $d=3$. For $N=1$, which corresponds to one 2-component Majorana fermion, it has been suggested that the Yukawa theory flows to a ${\cal N}=1$ supersymmetric CFT. We provide new evidence that the $4-ε$ expansion of the $N=1$ Gross-Neveu-Yukawa model respects the supersymmetry. Our extrapolations to $d=3$ appear to be in good agreement with the available results obtained using the numerical conformal bootstrap. Continuation of this CFT to $d=2$ provides evidence that the Yukawa theory flows to the tri-critical Ising model. We apply a similar approach to calculate the sphere free energy and operator scaling dimensions in the Nambu-Jona-Lasinio-Yukawa model, which has an additional $U(1)$ global symmetry. For $N=2$, which corresponds to one 2-component Dirac fermion, this theory has an emergent supersymmetry with 4 supercharges, and we provide new evidence for this. △ Less

Submitted 28 March, 2017; v1 submitted 18 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: 45 pages, 7 figures. v3: version published in PTEP

Report number: PUPT-2504

On $C_{J}$ and $C_{T}$ in Conformal QED

Authors: Simone Giombi, Grigory Tarnopolsky, Igor R. Klebanov

Abstract: QED with a large number $N$ of massless fermionic degrees of freedom has a conformal phase in a range of space-time dimensions. We use a large $N$ diagrammatic approach to calculate the leading corrections to $C_T$, the coefficient of the two-point function of the stress-energy tensor, and $C_J$, the coefficient of the two-point function of the global symmetry current. We present explicit formulae… ▽ More QED with a large number $N$ of massless fermionic degrees of freedom has a conformal phase in a range of space-time dimensions. We use a large $N$ diagrammatic approach to calculate the leading corrections to $C_T$, the coefficient of the two-point function of the stress-energy tensor, and $C_J$, the coefficient of the two-point function of the global symmetry current. We present explicit formulae as a function of $d$ and check them versus the expectations in 2 and $4-ε$ dimensions. Using our results in higher even dimensions we find a concise formula for $C_T$ of the conformal Maxwell theory with higher derivative action $F_{μν} (-\nabla^2)^{\frac{d}{2}-2} F^{μν}$. In $d=3$, QED has a topological symmetry current, and we calculate the correction to its two-point function coefficient, $C^{\textrm{top}}_{J}$. We also show that some RG flows involving QED in $d=3$ obey $C_T^{\rm UV} > C_T^{\rm IR}$ and discuss possible implications of this inequality for the symmetry breaking at small values of $N$. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 2016; v1 submitted 2 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Comments: 29 pages, 9 figures. v3: minor improvements, references added

Report number: PUPT-2499

On $C_J$ and $C_T$ in the Gross-Neveu and $O(N)$ Models

Authors: Kenan Diab, Lin Fei, Simone Giombi, Igor R. Klebanov, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: We apply large $N$ diagrammatic techniques for theories with double-trace interactions to the leading corrections to $C_J$, the coefficient of a conserved current two-point function, and $C_T$, the coefficient of the stress-energy tensor two-point function. We study in detail two famous conformal field theories in continuous dimensions, the scalar $O(N)$ model and the Gross-Neveu model. For the… ▽ More We apply large $N$ diagrammatic techniques for theories with double-trace interactions to the leading corrections to $C_J$, the coefficient of a conserved current two-point function, and $C_T$, the coefficient of the stress-energy tensor two-point function. We study in detail two famous conformal field theories in continuous dimensions, the scalar $O(N)$ model and the Gross-Neveu model. For the $O(N)$ model, where the answers for the leading large $N$ corrections to $C_J$ and $C_T$ were derived long ago using analytic bootstrap, we show that the diagrammatic approach reproduces them correctly. We also carry out a new perturbative test of these results using the $O(N)$ symmetric cubic scalar theory in $6-ε$ dimensions. We go on to apply the diagrammatic method to the Gross-Neveu model, finding explicit formulae for the leading corrections to $C_J$ and $C_T$ as a function of dimension. We check these large $N$ results using regular perturbation theory for the Gross-Neveu model in $2+ε$ dimensions and the Gross-Neveu-Yukawa model in $4-ε$ dimensions. For small values of $N$, we use Pade approximants based on the $4-ε$ and $2+ε$ expansions to estimate the values of $C_J$ and $C_T$ in $d=3$. For the $O(N)$ model our estimates are close to those found using the conformal bootstrap. For the GN model, our estimates suggest that, even when $N$ is small, $C_T$ differs by no more than $2\%$ from that in the theory of free fermions. We find that the inequality $C_T^{\textrm{UV}} > C_T^{\textrm{IR}}$ applies both to the GN and the scalar $O(N)$ models in $d=3$. △ Less

Submitted 12 February, 2016; v1 submitted 26 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Comments: 62 pages, 34 figures. v2: minor improvements, references added

Report number: PUPT-2496

Conformal QED$_d$, $F$-Theorem and the $ε$ Expansion

Authors: Simone Giombi, Igor R. Klebanov, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: We calculate the free energies $F$ for $U(1)$ gauge theories on the $d$ dimensional sphere of radius $R$. For the theory with free Maxwell action we find the exact result as a function of $d$; it contains the term $\frac{d-4}{2} \log R$ consistent with the lack of conformal invariance in dimensions other than 4. When the $U(1)$ gauge theory is coupled to a sufficient number $N_f$ of massless 4 com… ▽ More We calculate the free energies $F$ for $U(1)$ gauge theories on the $d$ dimensional sphere of radius $R$. For the theory with free Maxwell action we find the exact result as a function of $d$; it contains the term $\frac{d-4}{2} \log R$ consistent with the lack of conformal invariance in dimensions other than 4. When the $U(1)$ gauge theory is coupled to a sufficient number $N_f$ of massless 4 component fermions, it acquires an interacting conformal phase, which in $d<4$ describes the long distance behavior of the model. The conformal phase can be studied using large $N_f$ methods. Generalizing the $d=3$ calculation in arXiv:1112.5342, we compute its sphere free energy as a function of $d$, ignoring the terms of order $1/N_f$ and higher. For finite $N_f$, following arXiv:1409.1937 and arXiv:1507.01960, we develop the $4-ε$ expansion for the sphere free energy of conformal QED$_d$. Its extrapolation to $d=3$ shows very good agreement with the large $N_f$ approximation for $N_f>3$. For $N_f$ at or below some critical value $N_{\rm crit}$, the $SU(2N_f)$ symmetric conformal phase of QED$_3$ is expected to disappear or become unstable. By using the $F$-theorem and comparing the sphere free energies in the conformal and broken symmetry phases, we show that $N_{\rm crit}\leq 4$. As another application of our results, we calculate the one loop beta function in conformal QED$_6$, where the gauge field has a 4-derivative kinetic term. We show that this theory coupled to $N_f$ massless fermions is asymptotically free. △ Less

Submitted 29 October, 2015; v1 submitted 25 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Comments: v3: 33 pages, 6 figures. Some improvements, references added

Report number: PUPT-2484

Accidental Symmetries and the Conformal Bootstrap

Authors: Shai M. Chester, Simone Giombi, Luca V. Iliesiu, Igor R. Klebanov, Silviu S. Pufu, Ran Yacoby

Abstract: We study an ${\cal N} = 2$ supersymmetric generalization of the three-dimensional critical $O(N)$ vector model that is described by $N+1$ chiral superfields with superpotential $W = g_1 X \sum_i Z_i^2 + g_2 X^3$. By combining the tools of the conformal bootstrap with results obtained through supersymmetric localization, we argue that this model exhibits a symmetry enhancement at the infrared super… ▽ More We study an ${\cal N} = 2$ supersymmetric generalization of the three-dimensional critical $O(N)$ vector model that is described by $N+1$ chiral superfields with superpotential $W = g_1 X \sum_i Z_i^2 + g_2 X^3$. By combining the tools of the conformal bootstrap with results obtained through supersymmetric localization, we argue that this model exhibits a symmetry enhancement at the infrared superconformal fixed point due to $g_2$ flowing to zero. This example is special in that the existence of an infrared fixed point with $g_1,g_2\neq 0$, which does not exhibit symmetry enhancement, does not generally lead to any obvious unitarity violations or other inconsistencies. We do show, however, that the $F$-theorem excludes the models with $g_1,g_2\neq 0$ for $N>5$. The conformal bootstrap provides a stronger constraint and excludes such models for $N>2$. We provide evidence that the $g_2=0$ models, which have the enhanced $O(N)\times U(1)$ symmetry, come close to saturating the bootstrap bounds. We extend our analysis to fractional dimensions where we can motivate the nonexistence of the $g_1,g_2\neq 0$ models by studying them perturbatively in the $4-ε$ expansion. △ Less

Submitted 15 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: 26 pages, 5 figures

Report number: PUPT-2483

Generalized $F$-Theorem and the $ε$ Expansion

Authors: Lin Fei, Simone Giombi, Igor R. Klebanov, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: Some known constraints on Renormalization Group flow take the form of inequalities: in even dimensions they refer to the coefficient $a$ of the Weyl anomaly, while in odd dimensions to the sphere free energy $F$. In recent work arXiv:1409.1937 it was suggested that the $a$- and $F$-theorems may be viewed as special cases of a Generalized $F$-Theorem valid in continuous dimension. This conjecture s… ▽ More Some known constraints on Renormalization Group flow take the form of inequalities: in even dimensions they refer to the coefficient $a$ of the Weyl anomaly, while in odd dimensions to the sphere free energy $F$. In recent work arXiv:1409.1937 it was suggested that the $a$- and $F$-theorems may be viewed as special cases of a Generalized $F$-Theorem valid in continuous dimension. This conjecture states that, for any RG flow from one conformal fixed point to another, $\tilde F_{\rm UV} > \tilde F_{\rm IR}$, where $\tilde F=\sin (πd/2)\log Z_{S^d}$. Here we provide additional evidence in favor of the Generalized $F$-Theorem. We show that it holds in conformal perturbation theory, i.e. for RG flows produced by weakly relevant operators. We also study a specific example of the Wilson-Fisher $O(N)$ model and define this CFT on the sphere $S^{4-ε}$, paying careful attention to the beta functions for the coefficients of curvature terms. This allows us to develop the $ε$ expansion of $\tilde F$ up to order $ε^5$. Pade extrapolation of this series to $d=3$ gives results that are around $2-3\%$ below the free field values for small $N$. We also study RG flows which include an anisotropic perturbation breaking the $O(N)$ symmetry; we again find that the results are consistent with $\tilde F_{\rm UV} > \tilde F_{\rm IR}$. △ Less

Submitted 15 October, 2015; v1 submitted 7 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: 41 pages, 7 figures. v3: minor improvements

Report number: PUPT-2481

Critical $Sp(N)$ Models in $6-ε$ Dimensions and Higher Spin dS/CFT

Authors: Lin Fei, Simone Giombi, Igor R. Klebanov, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: Theories of anti-commuting scalar fields are non-unitary, but they are of interest both in statistical mechanics and in studies of the higher spin de Sitter/Conformal Field Theory correspondence. We consider an $Sp(N)$ invariant theory of $N$ anti-commuting scalars and one commuting scalar, which has cubic interactions and is renormalizable in 6 dimensions. For any even $N$ we find an IR stable fi… ▽ More Theories of anti-commuting scalar fields are non-unitary, but they are of interest both in statistical mechanics and in studies of the higher spin de Sitter/Conformal Field Theory correspondence. We consider an $Sp(N)$ invariant theory of $N$ anti-commuting scalars and one commuting scalar, which has cubic interactions and is renormalizable in 6 dimensions. For any even $N$ we find an IR stable fixed point in $6-ε$ dimensions at imaginary values of coupling constants. Using calculations up to three loop order, we develop $ε$ expansions for several operator dimensions and for the sphere free energy $F$. The conjectured $F$-theorem is obeyed in spite of the non-unitarity of the theory. The $1/N$ expansion in the $Sp(N)$ theory is related to that in the corresponding $O(N)$ symmetric theory by the change of sign of $N$. Our results point to the existence of interacting non-unitary 5-dimensional CFTs with $Sp(N)$ symmetry, where operator dimensions are real. We conjecture that these CFTs are dual to the minimal higher spin theory in 6-dimensional de Sitter space with Neumann future boundary conditions on the scalar field. For $N=2$ we show that the IR fixed point possesses an enhanced global symmetry given by the supergroup $OSp(1|2)$. This suggests the existence of $OSp(1|2)$ symmetric CFTs in dimensions smaller than 6. We show that the $6-ε$ expansions of the scaling dimensions and sphere free energy in our $OSp(1|2)$ model are the same as in the $q \rightarrow 0$ limit of the $q$-state Potts model. △ Less

Submitted 16 June, 2015; v1 submitted 25 February, 2015; originally announced February 2015.

Comments: 16 pages, 3 figures. v3: added relation to the q=0 Potts model. Some improvements and references added

Report number: PUPT-2478

Three Loop Analysis of the Critical $O(N)$ Models in $6-ε$ Dimensions

Authors: Lin Fei, Simone Giombi, Igor R. Klebanov, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: We continue the study, initiated in arXiv:1404.1094, of the $O(N)$ symmetric theory of $N+1$ massless scalar fields in $6-ε$ dimensions. This theory has cubic interaction terms $\frac{1}{2}g_1 σ(φ^i)^2 + \frac{1}{6}g_2 σ^3$. We calculate the 3-loop beta functions for the two couplings and use them to determine certain operator scaling dimensions at the IR stable fixed point up to order $ε^3$. We a… ▽ More We continue the study, initiated in arXiv:1404.1094, of the $O(N)$ symmetric theory of $N+1$ massless scalar fields in $6-ε$ dimensions. This theory has cubic interaction terms $\frac{1}{2}g_1 σ(φ^i)^2 + \frac{1}{6}g_2 σ^3$. We calculate the 3-loop beta functions for the two couplings and use them to determine certain operator scaling dimensions at the IR stable fixed point up to order $ε^3$. We also use the beta functions to determine the corrections to the critical value of $N$ below which there is no fixed point at real couplings. The result suggests a very significant reduction in the critical value as the dimension is decreased to $5$. We also study the theory with $N=1$, which has a $Z_2$ symmetry under $φ\rightarrow -φ$. We show that it possesses an IR stable fixed point at imaginary couplings which can be reached by flow from a nearby fixed point describing a pair of $N=0$ theories. We calculate certain operator scaling dimensions at the IR fixed point of the $N=1$ theory and suggest that, upon continuation to two dimensions, it describes a non-unitary conformal minimal model. △ Less

Submitted 12 December, 2014; v1 submitted 4 November, 2014; originally announced November 2014.

Comments: 34 pages, 9 figures. Some improvements and references added

Report number: PUPT-2474

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 91, 045011 (2015)

Interpolating between $a$ and $F$

Authors: Simone Giombi, Igor R. Klebanov

Abstract: We study the dimensional continuation of the sphere free energy in conformal field theories. In continuous dimension $d$ we define the quantity $\tilde F=\sin (πd/2)\log Z$, where $Z$ is the path integral of the Euclidean CFT on the $d$-dimensional round sphere. $\tilde F$ smoothly interpolates between $(-1)^{d/2}π/2$ times the $a$-anomaly coefficient in even $d$, and $(-1)^{(d+1)/2}$ times the sp… ▽ More We study the dimensional continuation of the sphere free energy in conformal field theories. In continuous dimension $d$ we define the quantity $\tilde F=\sin (πd/2)\log Z$, where $Z$ is the path integral of the Euclidean CFT on the $d$-dimensional round sphere. $\tilde F$ smoothly interpolates between $(-1)^{d/2}π/2$ times the $a$-anomaly coefficient in even $d$, and $(-1)^{(d+1)/2}$ times the sphere free energy $F$ in odd $d$. We calculate $\tilde F$ in various examples of unitary CFT that can be continued to non-integer dimensions, including free theories, double-trace deformations at large $N$, and perturbative fixed points in the $ε$ expansion. For all these examples $\tilde F$ is positive, and it decreases under RG flow. Using perturbation theory in the coupling, we calculate $\tilde F$ in the Wilson-Fisher fixed point of the $O(N)$ vector model in $d=4-ε$ to order $ε^4$. We use this result to estimate the value of $F$ in the 3-dimensional Ising model, and find that it is only a few percent below $F$ of the free conformally coupled scalar field. We use similar methods to estimate the $F$ values for the $U(N)$ Gross-Neveu model in $d=3$ and the $O(N)$ model in $d=5$. Finally, we carry out the dimensional continuation of interacting theories with 4 supercharges, for which we suggest that $\tilde F$ may be calculated exactly using an appropriate version of localization on $S^d$. Our approach provides an interpolation between the $a$-maximization in $d=4$ and the $F$-maximization in $d=3$. △ Less

Submitted 5 May, 2015; v1 submitted 5 September, 2014; originally announced September 2014.

Comments: 41 pages, 4 figures. v4: Eqs. (1.6), (4.13) and (5.37) corrected; footnote 9 added discussing the Euler density counterterm

Report number: PUPT-2472

Critical $O(N)$ Models in $6-ε$ Dimensions

Authors: Lin Fei, Simone Giombi, Igor R. Klebanov

Abstract: We revisit the classic $O(N)$ symmetric scalar field theories in $d$ dimensions with interaction $(φ^i φ^i)^2$. For $2<d<4$ these theories flow to the Wilson-Fisher fixed points for any $N$. A standard large $N$ Hubbard-Stratonovich approach also indicates that, for $4<d<6$, these theories possess unitary UV fixed points. We propose their alternate description in terms of a theory of $N+1$ massles… ▽ More We revisit the classic $O(N)$ symmetric scalar field theories in $d$ dimensions with interaction $(φ^i φ^i)^2$. For $2<d<4$ these theories flow to the Wilson-Fisher fixed points for any $N$. A standard large $N$ Hubbard-Stratonovich approach also indicates that, for $4<d<6$, these theories possess unitary UV fixed points. We propose their alternate description in terms of a theory of $N+1$ massless scalars with the cubic interactions $σφ^i φ^i$ and $σ^3$. Our one-loop calculation in $6-ε$ dimensions shows that this theory has an IR stable fixed point at real values of the coupling constants for $N>1038$. We show that the $1/N$ expansions of various operator scaling dimensions match the known results for the critical $O(N)$ theory continued to $d=6-ε$. These results suggest that, for sufficiently large $N$, there are 5-dimensional unitary $O(N)$ symmetric interacting CFT's; they should be dual to the Vasiliev higher-spin theory in AdS$_6$ with alternate boundary conditions for the bulk scalar. Using these CFT's we provide a new test of the 5-dimensional $F$-theorem, and also find a new counterexample for the $C_T$ theorem. △ Less

Submitted 11 August, 2014; v1 submitted 3 April, 2014; originally announced April 2014.

Comments: 40 pages, 8 figures. Minor corrections, references added

Report number: PUPT-2463

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 90, 025018 (2014)

Partition Functions and Casimir Energies in Higher Spin AdS_{d+1}/CFT_d

Authors: Simone Giombi, Igor R. Klebanov, Arkady A. Tseytlin

Abstract: Recently, the one-loop free energy of higher spin (HS) theories in Euclidean AdS_{d+1} was calculated and matched with the order N^0 term in the free energy of the large N "vectorial" scalar CFT on the S^d boundary. Here we extend this matching to the boundary theory defined on S^1 x S^{d-1}, where the length of S^1 may be interpreted as the inverse temperature. It has been shown that the large N… ▽ More Recently, the one-loop free energy of higher spin (HS) theories in Euclidean AdS_{d+1} was calculated and matched with the order N^0 term in the free energy of the large N "vectorial" scalar CFT on the S^d boundary. Here we extend this matching to the boundary theory defined on S^1 x S^{d-1}, where the length of S^1 may be interpreted as the inverse temperature. It has been shown that the large N limit of the partition function on S^1 x S^2 in the U(N) singlet sector of the CFT of N free complex scalars matches the one-loop thermal partition function of the Vasiliev theory in AdS_4, while in the O(N) singlet sector of the CFT of N real scalars it matches the minimal theory containing even spins only. We extend this matching to all dimensions d. We also calculate partition functions for the singlet sectors of free fermion CFT's in various dimensions and match them with appropriately defined higher spin theories, which for d>3 contain massless gauge fields with mixed symmetry. In the zero-temperature case R x S^{d-1} we calculate the Casimir energy in the scalar or fermionic CFT and match it with the one-loop correction in the global AdS_{d+1}. For any odd-dimensional CFT the Casimir energy must vanish on general grounds, and we show that the HS duals obey this. In the U(N) symmetric case, we exhibit the vanishing of the regularized 1-loop Casimir energy of the dual HS theory in AdS_{d+1}. In the minimal HS theory the vacuum energy vanishes for odd d while for even d it is equal to the Casimir energy of a single conformal scalar in R x S^{d-1} which is again consistent with AdS/CFT, provided the minimal HS coupling constant is ~ 1/(N-1). We demonstrate analogous results for singlet sectors of theories of N Dirac or Majorana fermions. We also discuss extensions to CFT's containing N_f flavors in the fundamental representation of U(N) or O(N). △ Less

Submitted 9 September, 2014; v1 submitted 21 February, 2014; originally announced February 2014.

Comments: 43 pages. v3: minor changes, references added. Version published in PRD

Report number: PUTP-2460, Imperial-TP-AT-2014-01

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 90, 024048 (2014)

Higher Spin AdS$_{d+1}$/CFT$_d$ at One Loop

Authors: Simone Giombi, Igor R. Klebanov, Benjamin R. Safdi

Abstract: Following arXiv:1308.2337, we carry out one loop tests of higher spin AdS$_{d+1}$/CFT$_d$ correspondences for $d\geq 2$. The Vasiliev theories in AdS$_{d+1}$, which contain each integer spin once, are related to the $U(N)$ singlet sector of the $d$-dimensional CFT of $N$ free complex scalar fields; the minimal theories containing each even spin once -- to the $O(N)$ singlet sector of the CFT of… ▽ More Following arXiv:1308.2337, we carry out one loop tests of higher spin AdS$_{d+1}$/CFT$_d$ correspondences for $d\geq 2$. The Vasiliev theories in AdS$_{d+1}$, which contain each integer spin once, are related to the $U(N)$ singlet sector of the $d$-dimensional CFT of $N$ free complex scalar fields; the minimal theories containing each even spin once -- to the $O(N)$ singlet sector of the CFT of $N$ free real scalar fields. Using analytic continuation of higher spin zeta functions, which naturally regulate the spin sums, we calculate one loop vacuum energies in Euclidean AdS$_{d+1}$. In even $d$ we compare the result with the $O(N^0)$ correction to the $a$-coefficient of the Weyl anomaly; in odd $d$ -- with the $O(N^0)$ correction to the free energy $F$ on the $d$-dimensional sphere. For the theories of integer spins, the correction vanishes in agreement with the CFT of $N$ free complex scalars. For the minimal theories, the correction always equals the contribution of one real conformal scalar field in $d$ dimensions. As explained in arXiv:1308.2337, this result may agree with the $O(N)$ singlet sector of the theory of $N$ real scalar fields, provided the coupling constant in the higher spin theory is identified as $G_N\sim 1/(N-1)$. Our calculations in even $d$ are closely related to finding the regularized $a$-anomalies of conformal higher spin theories. In each even $d$ we identify two such theories with vanishing $a$-anomaly: a theory of all integer spins, and a theory of all even spins coupled to a complex conformal scalar. We also discuss an interacting UV fixed point in $d=5$ obtained from the free scalar theory via an irrelevant double-trace quartic interaction. This interacting large $N$ theory is dual to the Vasiliev theory in AdS$_6$ where the bulk scalar is quantized with the alternate boundary condition. △ Less

Submitted 5 February, 2014; v1 submitted 4 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Comments: 35 pages. v2: minor improvements

Report number: PUPT-2458

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 89, 084004 (2014)

One Loop Tests of Higher Spin AdS/CFT

Authors: Simone Giombi, Igor R. Klebanov

Abstract: Vasiliev's type A higher spin theories in AdS4 have been conjectured to be dual to the U(N) or O(N) singlet sectors in 3-d conformal field theories with N-component scalar fields. We compare the O(N^0) correction to the 3-sphere free energy F in the CFTs with corresponding calculations in the higher spin theories. This requires evaluating a regularized sum over one loop vacuum energies of an infin… ▽ More Vasiliev's type A higher spin theories in AdS4 have been conjectured to be dual to the U(N) or O(N) singlet sectors in 3-d conformal field theories with N-component scalar fields. We compare the O(N^0) correction to the 3-sphere free energy F in the CFTs with corresponding calculations in the higher spin theories. This requires evaluating a regularized sum over one loop vacuum energies of an infinite set of massless higher spin gauge fields in Euclidean AdS4. For the Vasiliev theory including fields of all integer spin and a scalar with Delta=1 boundary condition, we show that the regularized sum vanishes. This is in perfect agreement with the vanishing of subleading corrections to F in the U(N) singlet sector of the theory of N free complex scalar fields. For the minimal Vasiliev theory including fields of only even spin, the regularized sum remarkably equals the value of F for one free real scalar field. This result may agree with the O(N) singlet sector of the theory of N real scalar fields, provided the coupling constant in the Vasiliev theory is identified as G_N ~ 1/(N-1). Similarly, consideration of the USp(N) singlet sector for N complex scalar fields, which we conjecture to be dual to the husp(2;0|4) Vasiliev theory, requires G_N ~ 1/(N+1). We also test the higher spin AdS3/CFT2 conjectures by calculating the regularized sum over one loop vacuum energies of higher spin fields in AdS3. We match the result with the O(N^0) term in the central charge of the W_N minimal models; this requires a certain truncation of the CFT operator spectrum so that the bulk theory contains two real scalar fields with the same boundary conditions. △ Less

Submitted 17 December, 2013; v1 submitted 10 August, 2013; originally announced August 2013.

Comments: 20 pages. v3: minor corrections, version published in JHEP

Report number: PUTP-2451

AdS Description of Induced Higher-Spin Gauge Theory

Authors: Simone Giombi, Igor R. Klebanov, Silviu S. Pufu, Benjamin R. Safdi, Grigory Tarnopolsky

Abstract: We study deformations of three-dimensional large N CFTs by double-trace operators constructed from spin s single-trace operators of dimension Δ. These theories possess UV fixed points, and we calculate the change of the 3-sphere free energy δF= F_{UV}- F_{IR}. To describe the UV fixed point using the dual AdS_4 space we modify the boundary conditions on the spin s field in the bulk; this approach… ▽ More We study deformations of three-dimensional large N CFTs by double-trace operators constructed from spin s single-trace operators of dimension Δ. These theories possess UV fixed points, and we calculate the change of the 3-sphere free energy δF= F_{UV}- F_{IR}. To describe the UV fixed point using the dual AdS_4 space we modify the boundary conditions on the spin s field in the bulk; this approach produces δF in agreement with the field theory calculations. If the spin s operator is a conserved current, then the fixed point is described by an induced parity invariant conformal spin s gauge theory. The low spin examples are QED_3 (s=1) and the 3-d induced conformal gravity (s=2). When the original CFT is that of N conformal complex scalar or fermion fields, the U(N) singlet sector of the induced 3-d gauge theory is dual to Vasiliev's theory in AdS_4 with alternate boundary conditions on the spin s massless gauge field. We test this correspondence by calculating the leading term in δF for large N. We show that the coefficient of (1/2)\log N in δF is equal to the number of spin s-1 gauge parameters that act trivially on the spin s gauge field. We discuss generalizations of these results to 3-d gauge theories including Chern-Simons terms and to theories where s is half-integer. We also argue that the Weyl anomaly a-coefficients of conformal spin s theories in even dimensions d, such as that of the Weyl-squared gravity in d=4, can be efficiently calculated using massless spin s fields in AdS_{d+1} with alternate boundary conditions. Using this method we derive a simple formula for the Weyl anomaly a-coefficients of the d=4 Fradkin-Tseytlin conformal higher-spin gauge fields. Similarly, using alternate boundary conditions in AdS_3 we reproduce the well-known central charge c=-26 of the bc ghosts in 2-d gravity, as well as its higher-spin generalizations. △ Less

Submitted 23 September, 2013; v1 submitted 21 June, 2013; originally announced June 2013.

Comments: 62 pages, 1 figure; v2 refs added, minor improvements; v3 refs added, minor improvements

Report number: MIT-CTP-4471

A Crack in the Conformal Window

Authors: Benjamin R. Safdi, Igor R. Klebanov, Jeongseog Lee

Abstract: In {\cal N} = 2 superconformal three-dimensional field theory the R-symmetry is determined by locally maximizing the free energy F on the three-sphere. Using F-maximization, we study the {\cal N} = 2 supersymmetric U(N_c) gauge theory coupled to N_f pairs of fundamental and anti-fundamental superfields in the Veneziano large N_c limit, where x = N_f / N_c is kept fixed. This theory has a superconf… ▽ More In {\cal N} = 2 superconformal three-dimensional field theory the R-symmetry is determined by locally maximizing the free energy F on the three-sphere. Using F-maximization, we study the {\cal N} = 2 supersymmetric U(N_c) gauge theory coupled to N_f pairs of fundamental and anti-fundamental superfields in the Veneziano large N_c limit, where x = N_f / N_c is kept fixed. This theory has a superconformal window 1 \leq x \leq \infty, while for x < 1 supersymmetry is broken. As we reduce x we find "a crack in the superconformal window" - a critical value x_c \approx 1.45 where the monopole operators reach the unitarity bound. To continue the theory to x < x_c we assume that the monopoles become free fields, leading to an accidental global symmetry. Using the Aharony dual description of the theory for x < x_c allows us to determine the R-charges and F for 1 \leq x < x_c. Adding a Chern-Simons term removes the transition at x_c. In these more general theories we study the scaling dimensions of meson operators as functions of x and κ= |k| / N_c. We find that there is an interesting transition in behavior at κ= 1. △ Less

Submitted 29 January, 2013; v1 submitted 18 December, 2012; originally announced December 2012.

Comments: 36 pages, 13 figures; v2 refs added, minor improvements, section 2.5 added on RG flows and the F-theorem; v3 refs added, minor improvements

Report number: PUPT-2434

Is Renormalized Entanglement Entropy Stationary at RG Fixed Points?

Authors: Igor R. Klebanov, Tatsuma Nishioka, Silviu S. Pufu, Benjamin R. Safdi

Abstract: The renormalized entanglement entropy (REE) across a circle of radius R has been proposed as a c-function in Poincaré invariant (2+1)-dimensional field theory. A proof has been presented of its monotonic behavior as a function of R, based on the strong subadditivity of entanglement entropy. However, this proof does not directly establish stationarity of REE at conformal fixed points of the renorma… ▽ More The renormalized entanglement entropy (REE) across a circle of radius R has been proposed as a c-function in Poincaré invariant (2+1)-dimensional field theory. A proof has been presented of its monotonic behavior as a function of R, based on the strong subadditivity of entanglement entropy. However, this proof does not directly establish stationarity of REE at conformal fixed points of the renormalization group. In this note we study the REE for the free massive scalar field theory near the UV fixed point described by a massless scalar. Our numerical calculation indicates that the REE is not stationary at the UV fixed point. △ Less

Submitted 13 July, 2012; originally announced July 2012.

Comments: 15 pages, 4 figures

Report number: PUPT-2423; MIT-CTP-4378

Strange Metals in One Spatial Dimension

Authors: Rajesh Gopakumar, Akikazu Hashimoto, Igor R. Klebanov, Subir Sachdev, Kareljan Schoutens

Abstract: We consider 1+1 dimensional SU(N) gauge theory coupled to a multiplet of massive Dirac fermions transforming in the adjoint representation of the gauge group. The only global symmetry of this theory is a U(1) associated with the conserved Dirac fermion number, and we study the theory at variable, non-zero densities. The high density limit is characterized by a deconfined Fermi surface state with F… ▽ More We consider 1+1 dimensional SU(N) gauge theory coupled to a multiplet of massive Dirac fermions transforming in the adjoint representation of the gauge group. The only global symmetry of this theory is a U(1) associated with the conserved Dirac fermion number, and we study the theory at variable, non-zero densities. The high density limit is characterized by a deconfined Fermi surface state with Fermi wavevector equal to that of free gauge-charged fermions. Its low energy fluctuations are described by a coset conformal field theory with central charge c=(N^2-1)/3 and an emergent N=(2,2) supersymmetry: the U(1) fermion number symmetry becomes an R-symmetry. We determine the exact scaling dimensions of the operators associated with Friedel oscillations and pairing correlations. For N>2, we find that the symmetries allow relevant perturbations to this state. We discuss aspects of the N->infty limit, and its possible dual description in AdS3 involving string theory or higher-spin gauge theory. We also discuss the low density limit of the theory by computing the low lying bound state spectrum of the large N gauge theory numerically at zero density, using discretized light cone quantization. △ Less

Submitted 20 June, 2012; originally announced June 2012.

Comments: 40 pages, 4 figures

Report number: PUPT-2419; MAD-TH-12-06

Journal ref: Physical Review D 86, 066003 (2012)

On Shape Dependence and RG Flow of Entanglement Entropy

Authors: Igor R. Klebanov, Tatsuma Nishioka, Silviu S. Pufu, Benjamin R. Safdi

Abstract: We use a mix of field theoretic and holographic techniques to elucidate various properties of quantum entanglement entropy. In (3+1)-dimensional conformal field theory we study the divergent terms in the entropy when the entangling surface has a conical or a wedge singularity. In (2+1)-dimensional field theory with a mass gap we calculate, for an arbitrary smooth entanglement contour, the expansio… ▽ More We use a mix of field theoretic and holographic techniques to elucidate various properties of quantum entanglement entropy. In (3+1)-dimensional conformal field theory we study the divergent terms in the entropy when the entangling surface has a conical or a wedge singularity. In (2+1)-dimensional field theory with a mass gap we calculate, for an arbitrary smooth entanglement contour, the expansion of the entropy in inverse odd powers of the mass. We show that the shape-dependent coefficients that arise are even powers of the extrinsic curvature and its derivatives. A useful dual construction of a (2+1)-dimensional theory, which allows us to exhibit these properties, is provided by the CGLP background. This smooth warped throat solution of 11-dimensional supergravity describes renormalization group flow from a conformal field theory in the UV to a gapped one in the IR. For this flow we calculate the recently introduced renormalized entanglement entropy and confirm that it is a monotonic function. △ Less

Submitted 11 July, 2012; v1 submitted 18 April, 2012; originally announced April 2012.

Comments: 30 pages, 8 figures; v2 refs added, minor improvements; v3 minor improvements, JHEP version

Report number: PUPT-2411; MIT-CTP-4357

Journal ref: JHEP 1207 (2012) 001

Entanglement Entropy of 3-d Conformal Gauge Theories with Many Flavors

Authors: Igor R. Klebanov, Silviu S. Pufu, Subir Sachdev, Benjamin R. Safdi

Abstract: Three-dimensional conformal field theories (CFTs) of deconfined gauge fields coupled to gapless flavors of fermionic and bosonic matter describe quantum critical points of condensed matter systems in two spatial dimensions. An important characteristic of these CFTs is the finite part of the entanglement entropy across a circle. The negative of this quantity is equal to the finite part of the free… ▽ More Three-dimensional conformal field theories (CFTs) of deconfined gauge fields coupled to gapless flavors of fermionic and bosonic matter describe quantum critical points of condensed matter systems in two spatial dimensions. An important characteristic of these CFTs is the finite part of the entanglement entropy across a circle. The negative of this quantity is equal to the finite part of the free energy of the Euclidean CFT on the three-sphere, and it has been proposed to satisfy the so called F-theorem, which states that it decreases under RG flow and is stationary at RG fixed points. We calculate the three-sphere free energy of non-supersymmetric gauge theory with a large number N_F of bosonic and/or fermionic flavors to the first subleading order in 1/N_F. We also calculate the exact free energies of the analogous chiral and non-chiral {\cal N} = 2 supersymmetric theories using localization, and find agreement with the 1/N_F expansion. We analyze some RG flows of supersymmetric theories, providing further evidence for the F-theorem. △ Less

Submitted 1 March, 2012; v1 submitted 22 December, 2011; originally announced December 2011.

Comments: 31 pages, 2 figures; v2 refs added, minor changes

Journal ref: JHEP 1205 (2012) 036

Renyi Entropies for Free Field Theories

Authors: Igor R. Klebanov, Silviu S. Pufu, Subir Sachdev, Benjamin R. Safdi

Abstract: Renyi entropies S_q are useful measures of quantum entanglement; they can be calculated from traces of the reduced density matrix raised to power q, with q>=0. For (d+1)-dimensional conformal field theories, the Renyi entropies across S^{d-1} may be extracted from the thermal partition functions of these theories on either (d+1)-dimensional de Sitter space or R x H^d, where H^d is the d-dimensiona… ▽ More Renyi entropies S_q are useful measures of quantum entanglement; they can be calculated from traces of the reduced density matrix raised to power q, with q>=0. For (d+1)-dimensional conformal field theories, the Renyi entropies across S^{d-1} may be extracted from the thermal partition functions of these theories on either (d+1)-dimensional de Sitter space or R x H^d, where H^d is the d-dimensional hyperbolic space. These thermal partition functions can in turn be expressed as path integrals on branched coverings of the (d+1)-dimensional sphere and S^1 x H^d, respectively. We calculate the Renyi entropies of free massless scalars and fermions in d=2, and show how using zeta-function regularization one finds agreement between the calculations on the branched coverings of S^3 and on S^1 x H^2. Analogous calculations for massive free fields provide monotonic interpolating functions between the Renyi entropies at the Gaussian and the trivial fixed points. Finally, we discuss similar Renyi entropy calculations in d>2. △ Less

Submitted 1 March, 2012; v1 submitted 27 November, 2011; originally announced November 2011.

Comments: 35 pages, 4 figures; v2 refs added, minor changes

Journal ref: JHEP 1204 (2012) 074