-
A short overview on the Black Hole-Tower Correspondence and Species Thermodynamics
Authors:
Alvaro Herráez,
Dieter Lüst,
Joaquin Masias,
Carmine Montella
Abstract:
The breakdown of gravitational effective field theories is intimately connected to the emergence of infinite towers of light states near infinite-distance limits in field space. In string theory, up to duality frame, such towers arise from Kaluza-Klein or weakly-coupled critical string oscillator modes. Motivated by the Black Hole-String Correspondence, we review a broader mechanism whereby black…
▽ More
The breakdown of gravitational effective field theories is intimately connected to the emergence of infinite towers of light states near infinite-distance limits in field space. In string theory, up to duality frame, such towers arise from Kaluza-Klein or weakly-coupled critical string oscillator modes. Motivated by the Black Hole-String Correspondence, we review a broader mechanism whereby black holes undergo a transition into a tower of light states, governed by the Quantum Gravity cutoff -- known as the Species Scale. Building on these developments, the Black Hole-Tower correspondence aims to provide a unified thermodynamic framework that describes black hole entropy in terms of the spectrum of the lightest degrees of freedom across various perturbative regimes of quantum gravity theories. In those regimes, thermodynamic consistency of such transition imposes stringent constraints on the spectrum, in agreement with string theory predictions. This defines the basis of the so-called Species Thermodynamics.
In this review, we emphasize these recent advances and synthesize their implications, offering an overview of how the outlined correspondence, the species scale and related thermodynamic principles enhance our understanding of black hole entropy within the effective field theory framework.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Black Hole Transitions, AdS and the Distance Conjecture
Authors:
Alvaro Herráez,
Dieter Lüst,
Carmine Montella
Abstract:
In this work, we investigate the connection between black hole instabilities and Swampland constraints, presenting new insights into the AdS Distance Conjecture. By examining the scale at which horizon instabilities of Schwarzschild-AdS$_d$ black holes take place$-Λ_{\mathrm{BH}}-$we uncover a universal scaling relation, $Λ_{\mathrm{BH}}\sim |Λ_{\mathrm{AdS}}|^α$, with…
▽ More
In this work, we investigate the connection between black hole instabilities and Swampland constraints, presenting new insights into the AdS Distance Conjecture. By examining the scale at which horizon instabilities of Schwarzschild-AdS$_d$ black holes take place$-Λ_{\mathrm{BH}}-$we uncover a universal scaling relation, $Λ_{\mathrm{BH}}\sim |Λ_{\mathrm{AdS}}|^α$, with $\frac{1}{d}\leq α\leq \frac{1}{2}$, linking the emergence of towers of states directly to instability scales as $Λ_{\mathrm{AdS}}\to 0$. This approach circumvents the explicit dependence on field-space distances, offering a refined formulation of the AdS Distance Conjecture grounded in physical black hole scales. From a top-down perspective, we find that these instability scales correspond precisely to the Gregory-Laflamme and Horowitz-Polchinski transitions, as expected for the flat space limit, and consistently with our proposed bounds. Furthermore, revisiting explicit calculations in type IIB string theory on AdS$_5\times S^5$, we illustrate how higher-derivative corrections may alter these bounds, potentially extending their applicability towards the interior of moduli space. Using also general results about gravitational collapse in AdS, our analysis points towards a possible breakdown of the conjecture in $d>10$, suggesting an intriguing upper limit on the number of non-compact spacetime dimensions. Finally, we briefly discuss parallel considerations and implications for the dS case.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
The Double EFT Expansion in Quantum Gravity
Authors:
José Calderón-Infante,
Alberto Castellano,
Alvaro Herráez
Abstract:
In this work, we aim to characterize the structure of higher-derivative corrections within low-energy Effective Field Theories (EFTs) arising from a UV-complete theory of quantum gravity. To this end, we use string theory as a laboratory and argue that such EFTs should exhibit a $\textit{double EFT expansion}$ involving higher-curvature operators. The $\textit{field-theoretic}$ expansion is govern…
▽ More
In this work, we aim to characterize the structure of higher-derivative corrections within low-energy Effective Field Theories (EFTs) arising from a UV-complete theory of quantum gravity. To this end, we use string theory as a laboratory and argue that such EFTs should exhibit a $\textit{double EFT expansion}$ involving higher-curvature operators. The $\textit{field-theoretic}$ expansion is governed by the mass of the lightest (tower of) new degrees of freedom, as expected from standard field theory considerations. Conversely, the $\textit{quantum-gravitational}$ expansion is suppressed relative to the Einstein-Hilbert term by the quantum gravity cutoff, $Λ_{\rm QG}$, above which no local gravitational EFT description remains valid. This structure becomes manifest in the so-called $\textit{asymptotic regime}$, where a hierarchy between the Planck scale and $Λ_{\rm QG}$ emerges, the latter identified herein as the species scale. Most notably, we demonstrate the features of the double EFT expansion through an amplitudes-based approach in (toroidal compactifications of) ten-dimensional Type IIA string theory, and via a detailed analysis of the supersymmetric black hole entropy in 4d $\mathcal{N}=2$ supergravities derived from Type II Calabi-Yau compactifications. We provide further evidence for our proposal across various string theory setups, including Calabi-Yau compactifications of M/F-theory and Type II string theory. Finally, we explore the implications of this framework for the Wilson coefficients of the aforementioned higher-curvature operators, revealing potentially significant constraints in the asymptotic regime and highlighting a remarkable interplay with recent results from the S-matrix bootstrap program.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
On the Origin of Species Thermodynamics and the Black Hole - Tower Correspondence
Authors:
Alvaro Herráez,
Dieter Lüst,
Joaquin Masias,
Marco Scalisi
Abstract:
Species thermodynamics has been proposed in analogy to black hole thermodynamics. The entropy scales like an area and is given by the mere counting of the number of the species. In this work, we $\textit{derive}$ the constitutive relations of species thermodynamics and explain how those $\textit{originate}$ from standard thermodynamics. We consider configurations of species in thermal equilibrium…
▽ More
Species thermodynamics has been proposed in analogy to black hole thermodynamics. The entropy scales like an area and is given by the mere counting of the number of the species. In this work, we $\textit{derive}$ the constitutive relations of species thermodynamics and explain how those $\textit{originate}$ from standard thermodynamics. We consider configurations of species in thermal equilibrium inside a box of size $L$, and show that the temperature $T$ of the system, which plays a crucial role, is always upper bounded above by the species scale $Λ_{\rm sp}$. We highlight three relevant regimes: (i) when $L^{-1}< T<Λ_{\rm sp}$, and gravitational collapse is avoided, the system exhibits standard thermodynamics features, for example, with the entropy scaling like the volume of the box; (ii) in the limit $L^{-1}\simeq T\rightarrow Λ_{\rm sp}$ we recover the rules of species thermodynamics with the entropy scaling like the area of the box; (iii) an intermediate regime with $ L^{-1}\simeq T< Λ_{\rm sp}$ that avoids gravitational collapse and fulfills the Covariant Entropy Bound; this interpolates between the previous two regimes and its entropy is given simply in terms of the counting of the species contributing to the thermodynamic ensemble. This study also allows us to find a novel and independent bottom-up rationale for the Emergent String Conjecture. Finally, we present the $\textit{Black Hole - Tower Correspondence}$ as a generalization of the celebrated Black Hole - String Correspondence. This provides us with a robust framework to interpret the results of our thermodynamic investigation. Moreover, it allows us to qualitatively account for the entropy of black holes in terms of the degrees of freedom of the weakly coupled species in the tower.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2025; v1 submitted 25 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
On the Species Scale, Modular Invariance and the Gravitational EFT expansion
Authors:
Alberto Castellano,
Alvaro Herráez,
Luis E. Ibáñez
Abstract:
The concept of the species scale as the quantum gravity cut-off has been recently emphasised in the context of the Swampland program. Along these lines, we continue the quest for a precise understanding of its role within effective field theories of gravity as well as a global definition of the latter in case there is enough supersymmetry preserved. To do so, we exploit duality symmetries, the fam…
▽ More
The concept of the species scale as the quantum gravity cut-off has been recently emphasised in the context of the Swampland program. Along these lines, we continue the quest for a precise understanding of its role within effective field theories of gravity as well as a global definition of the latter in case there is enough supersymmetry preserved. To do so, we exploit duality symmetries, the familiar asymptotic dependence imposed by the presence of infinite towers of light states and the known behaviour of higher-curvature corrections to the Einstein-Hilbert action in various String Theory setups. In those cases, we obtain a self-consistent result for the identification of the species scale as the quantum gravity cut-off, but also present some puzzles related to the suppression of certain higher-dimensional operators as well as minor ambiguities that may arise in the deep interior of moduli space.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2024; v1 submitted 11 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Entropy Bounds and the Species Scale Distance Conjecture
Authors:
José Calderón-Infante,
Alberto Castellano,
Alvaro Herráez,
Luis E. Ibáñez
Abstract:
The Swampland Distance Conjecture (SDC) states that, as we move towards an infinite distance point in moduli space, a tower of states becomes exponentially light with the geodesic distance in any consistent theory of Quantum Gravity. Although this fact has been tested in large sets of examples, it is fair to say that a bottom-up justification that explains both the geodesic requirement and the exp…
▽ More
The Swampland Distance Conjecture (SDC) states that, as we move towards an infinite distance point in moduli space, a tower of states becomes exponentially light with the geodesic distance in any consistent theory of Quantum Gravity. Although this fact has been tested in large sets of examples, it is fair to say that a bottom-up justification that explains both the geodesic requirement and the exponential behavior has been missing so far. In the present paper we address this issue by making use of the Covariant Entropy Bound as applied to the EFT. When applied to backgrounds of the Dynamical Cobordism type in theories with a moduli space, we are able to recover these main features of the SDC. Moreover, this naturally leads to universal lower and upper bounds on the 'decay rate' parameter $λ_{\text{sp}}$ of the species scale, that we propose as a convex hull condition under the name of Species Scale Distance Conjecture (SSDC). This is in contrast to already proposed universal bounds, that apply to the SDC parameter of the lightest tower. We also extend the analysis to the case in which asymptotically exponential potentials are present, finding a nice interplay with the asymptotic de Sitter conjecture. To test the SSDC, we study the convex hull that encodes the (asymptotic) moduli dependence of the species scale. In this way, we show that the SSDC is the strongest bound on the species scale exponential rate which is preserved under dimensional reduction and we verify it in M-theory toroidal compactifications.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2024; v1 submitted 28 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Towers and Hierarchies in the Standard Model from Emergence in Quantum Gravity
Authors:
Alberto Castellano,
Álvaro Herráez,
Luis E. Ibáñez
Abstract:
Based on Quantum Gravity arguments, it has been suggested that all kinetic terms of light particles below the UV cut-off could arise in the IR via quantum (loop) corrections. These loop corrections involve infinite towers of states becoming light (e.g. Kaluza-Klein or string towers). We study implications of this Emergence Proposal for fundamental scales in the Standard Model (SM). In this scheme…
▽ More
Based on Quantum Gravity arguments, it has been suggested that all kinetic terms of light particles below the UV cut-off could arise in the IR via quantum (loop) corrections. These loop corrections involve infinite towers of states becoming light (e.g. Kaluza-Klein or string towers). We study implications of this Emergence Proposal for fundamental scales in the Standard Model (SM). In this scheme all Yukawa couplings are of order one in the UV and small Yukawas for lighter generations appear via large anomalous dimensions induced by the towers of states. Thus, the observed hierarchies of quark and lepton masses are a reflection of the structure of towers of states that lie below the Quantum Gravity scale, $Λ_{\text{QG}}$. Small Dirac neutrino masses consistent with experimental observation appear due to the existence of a tower of SM singlet states of mass $m_{0}\simeq Y_{ν_3}M_p\simeq 7\times 10^5$ GeV, opening up a new extra dimension, while the UV cut-off occurs at $Λ_{\text{QG}}\lesssim 10^{14}$ GeV. Additional constraints relating the Electro-Weak (EW) and cosmological constant (c.c.) scales (denoted $M_{\text{EW}}$ and $V_0$) appear if the Swampland condition $m_{ν_1}\lesssim V_0^{1/4}$ is imposed (with $ν_1$ denoting the lightest neutrino), which itself arises upon applying the AdS non-SUSY Conjecture or the AdS/dS Distance Conjecture to the 3d vacua from circle compactifications of the SM. In particular, the EW scale and that of the extra dimension fulfill ${m_0 \, M_{\text{EW}}\lesssim 10^{2}\, V_0^{1/4}M_p}$, thus relating the EW hierarchy problem to that of the c.c. Hence, all fundamental scales may be written as powers of the c.c., i.e. $m_{\bullet}\sim V_0^δM_p^{1-4δ}$. The scale of SUSY breaking is $m_{3/2}\lesssim 7\times 10^5$ GeV, which favours a Mini-Split scenario that could be possibly tested at LHC and/or FCC.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2023; v1 submitted 31 January, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
The Emergence Proposal in Quantum Gravity and the Species Scale
Authors:
Alberto Castellano,
Alvaro Herráez,
Luis E. Ibáñez
Abstract:
In the Emergence Proposal in QG it is conjectured that all light-particle kinetic terms are absent in the fundamental UV theory and are generated by quantum corrections in the IR. It has been argued that this may provide for some microscopic understanding of the WGC and SDC. In the present paper we take the first steps towards a systematic study of Emergence in the context of string theory. We emp…
▽ More
In the Emergence Proposal in QG it is conjectured that all light-particle kinetic terms are absent in the fundamental UV theory and are generated by quantum corrections in the IR. It has been argued that this may provide for some microscopic understanding of the WGC and SDC. In the present paper we take the first steps towards a systematic study of Emergence in the context of string theory. We emphasize the crucial role of the species scale in any EFT coupled to gravity, and discuss its computation in string theory and general systems with light towers of states. We then introduce the notion of Emergence and show how kinetic terms for moduli, gauge bosons and fermions may be generated. One-loop computations play an important role in Emergence, so we present detailed calculations in $d$ spacetime dimensions for the wave-function renormalization of scalars, vectors and fermions. We extend and check the Emergence Proposal in a number string vacua, including 4d $\mathcal{N}=2$ theories arising from type IIA on a CY$_3$, where the towers at strong coupling are comprised by D0 and (wrapped) D2-branes, and also elaborate on how instanton corrections would fit within the emergence picture. Higher dimensional examples are also discussed, including 6d and 7d models arising from F-/M-theory on an elliptic CY$_3$ or a $K3$ surface. We also consider 10d string theories and study in some detail the emergence mechanism in type IIA. We show as well how the flux potential in 4d may be obtained from the emergence prescription, by analyzing the corresponding decompactification limits to M-theory. We find that the required kinetic terms for the dual 3-form fields can arise upon integrating out towers of massive gravitini (and bosonic superpartners). Our analysis renders support to the Emergence Proposal, and to the idea that infinite distance singularities may arise in QG as an intrinsic IR phenomenon.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2023; v1 submitted 7 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Affine Algebras at Infinite Distance Limits in the Heterotic String
Authors:
Veronica Collazuol,
Mariana Graña,
Alvaro Herráez,
Héctor Parra De Freitas
Abstract:
We analyze the boundaries of the moduli spaces of compactifications of the heterotic string on $T^d$, making particular emphasis on $d=2$ and its F-theory dual. We compute the OPE algebras as we approach all the infinite distance limits that correspond to (possibly partial) decompactification limits in some dual frame. When decompactifying $k$ directions, we find infinite towers of states becoming…
▽ More
We analyze the boundaries of the moduli spaces of compactifications of the heterotic string on $T^d$, making particular emphasis on $d=2$ and its F-theory dual. We compute the OPE algebras as we approach all the infinite distance limits that correspond to (possibly partial) decompactification limits in some dual frame. When decompactifying $k$ directions, we find infinite towers of states becoming light that enhance the algebra arising at a given point in the moduli space of the $T^{d-k}$ compactification to its $k$-loop version, where the central extensions are given by the $k$ KK vectors. For $T^2$ compactifications, we reproduce all the affine algebras that arise in the F-theory dual, and show all the towers explicitly, including some that are not manifest in the F-theory counterparts. Furthermore, we construct the affine $SO(32)$ algebra arising in the full decompactification limit, both in the heterotic and in the F-theory sides, showing that not only affine algebras of exceptional type arise in the latter.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
The Tadpole Conjecture in Asymptotic Limits
Authors:
Mariana Graña,
Thomas W. Grimm,
Damian van de Heisteeg,
Alvaro Herraez,
Erik Plauschinn
Abstract:
The tadpole conjecture suggests that the complete stabilization of complex structure deformations in Type IIB and F-theory flux compactifications is severely obstructed by the tadpole bound on the fluxes. More precisely, it states that the stabilization of a large number of moduli requires a flux background with a tadpole that scales linearly in the number of stabilized fields. Restricting to the…
▽ More
The tadpole conjecture suggests that the complete stabilization of complex structure deformations in Type IIB and F-theory flux compactifications is severely obstructed by the tadpole bound on the fluxes. More precisely, it states that the stabilization of a large number of moduli requires a flux background with a tadpole that scales linearly in the number of stabilized fields. Restricting to the asymptotic regions of the complex structure moduli space, we give the first conceptual argument that explains this linear scaling setting and clarifies why it sets in only for a large number of stabilized moduli. Our approach relies on the use of asymptotic Hodge theory. In particular, we use the fact that in each asymptotic regime an orthogonal sl(2)-block structure emerges that allows us to group fluxes into sl(2)-representations and decouple complex structure directions. We show that the number of stabilized moduli scales with the number of sl(2)-representations supported by fluxes, and that each representation fixes a single modulus. Furthermore, we find that for Calabi-Yau four-folds all but one representation can be identified with representations occurring on two-folds. This allows us to discuss moduli stabilization explicitly and establish the relevant scaling constraints for the tadpole.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2022; v1 submitted 11 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
$E_9$ symmetry in the Heterotic String on $S^1$ and the Weak Gravity Conjecture
Authors:
Veronica Collazuol,
Mariana Graña,
Alvaro Herráez
Abstract:
We show that compactifications of the heterotic string on a circle exhibit at the boundary of moduli space ($R\to 0$, or equivalently the decompactification limit $R \to \infty$) a tower of winding or momentum modes that enhance the $E_8 \times E_8$ or $SO(32)$ gauge symmetry to the affine algebras $(E_9 \oplus E_9)/\sim$ (the identification means that the two copies of $E_9$ share the same centra…
▽ More
We show that compactifications of the heterotic string on a circle exhibit at the boundary of moduli space ($R\to 0$, or equivalently the decompactification limit $R \to \infty$) a tower of winding or momentum modes that enhance the $E_8 \times E_8$ or $SO(32)$ gauge symmetry to the affine algebras $(E_9 \oplus E_9)/\sim$ (the identification means that the two copies of $E_9$ share the same central extension) and $\hat{D}_{16}$, respectively. We also prove that these towers of modes satisfy the lattice Weak Gravity and Repulsive Force Conjectures.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
IR/UV Mixing, Towers of Species and Swampland Conjectures
Authors:
Alberto Castellano,
Alvaro Herráez,
Luis E. Ibáñez
Abstract:
By applying the Covariant Entropy Bound (CEB) to an EFT in a box of size $1/Λ_{\text{IR}}$ one obtains that the UV and IR cut-offs of the EFT are necessarily correlated. We argue that in a theory of Quantum Gravity (QG) one should identify the UV cutoff with the `species scale', and give a general algorithm to calculate it in the case of multiple towers becoming light. One then obtains an upper bo…
▽ More
By applying the Covariant Entropy Bound (CEB) to an EFT in a box of size $1/Λ_{\text{IR}}$ one obtains that the UV and IR cut-offs of the EFT are necessarily correlated. We argue that in a theory of Quantum Gravity (QG) one should identify the UV cutoff with the `species scale', and give a general algorithm to calculate it in the case of multiple towers becoming light. One then obtains an upper bound on the characteristic mass scale of the tower in terms of the IR cut-off, given by $M_{\text{tower}}\lesssim (Λ_{\text{IR}})^{2α_D}$ in Planck units, with $α_D=(D-2+p)/2p(D-1)$, where $p$ depends on the density of states. Identifying the IR cut-off with a (non-vanishing) curvature in AdS one reproduces the statement of the AdS Distance Conjecture (ADC), also giving an explicit lower bound for the $α$ exponent. In particular, we find that the CEB implies $α\geq1/2$ in any dimension if there is a single KK tower, both in AdS and dS vacua. However values $α<1/2$ are allowed if the particle tower is multiple or has a string component. We also consider the CKN constraint coming from avoiding gravitational collapse which further requires in general $α\geq 1/D$ for the lightest tower. We analyse the case of the DGKT-CFI class of Type IIA orientifold models and show it has both particle and string towers below the species scale, so that a careful analysis of how the ADC is defined is needed. We find that this class of models obey but do not saturate the CEB. The UV/IR constraints found apply to both AdS and dS vacua. We comment on possible applications of these ideas to the dS Swampland conjecture as well as to the observed dS phase of the universe.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2022; v1 submitted 20 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
The Swampland Conjectures: A bridge from Quantum Gravity to Particle Physics
Authors:
Mariana Graña,
Alvaro Herráez
Abstract:
The swampland is the set of seemingly consistent low-energy effective field theories that cannot be consistently coupled to quantum gravity. In this review we cover some of the conjectural properties that effective theories should possess in order not to fall in the swampland, and we give an overview of their main applications to particle physics. The latter include predictions on neutrino masses,…
▽ More
The swampland is the set of seemingly consistent low-energy effective field theories that cannot be consistently coupled to quantum gravity. In this review we cover some of the conjectural properties that effective theories should possess in order not to fall in the swampland, and we give an overview of their main applications to particle physics. The latter include predictions on neutrino masses, bounds on the cosmological constant, the electroweak and QCD scales, the photon mass, the Higgs potential and some insights about supersymmetry.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2021; v1 submitted 30 June, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
A Gravitino Distance Conjecture
Authors:
Alberto Castellano,
Anamaría Font,
Alvaro Herraez,
Luis E. Ibáñez
Abstract:
We conjecture that in a consistent supergravity theory with non-vanishing gravitino mass, the limit $m_{3/2}\rightarrow 0$ is at infinite distance. In particular one can write $M_{\mathrm{tower}} \sim m_{3/2}^δ$ so that as the gravitino mass goes to zero, a tower of KK states as well as emergent strings becomes tensionless. This conjecture may be motivated from the Weak Gravity Conjecture as appli…
▽ More
We conjecture that in a consistent supergravity theory with non-vanishing gravitino mass, the limit $m_{3/2}\rightarrow 0$ is at infinite distance. In particular one can write $M_{\mathrm{tower}} \sim m_{3/2}^δ$ so that as the gravitino mass goes to zero, a tower of KK states as well as emergent strings becomes tensionless. This conjecture may be motivated from the Weak Gravity Conjecture as applied to strings and membranes and implies in turn the AdS Distance Conjecture. We test this proposal in classical 4d type IIA orientifold vacua in which one obtains a range of values $\tfrac13 \le δ\le 1$. The parameter $δ$ is related to the scale decoupling exponent in AdS vacua and to the $α$ exponent in the Swampland Distance Conjecture for the type IIA complex structure. We present a general analysis of the gravitino mass in the limits of moduli space in terms of limiting Mixed Hodge Structures and study in some detail the case of two-moduli F-theory settings. Moreover, we obtain general lower bounds $δ\, \geq \, \frac{1}{3}, \, \frac{1}{4}$ for Calabi--Yau threefolds and fourfolds, respectively. The conjecture has important phenomenological implications. In particular we argue that low-energy supersymmetry of order 1 TeV is only obtained if there is a tower of KK states at an intermediate scale, of order $10^8$ GeV. One also has an upper bound for the Hubble constant upon inflation $H \lesssim m_{3/2}^δM^{(1-δ)}_{\text{P}}$.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2021; v1 submitted 20 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
A Note on Membrane Interactions and the Scalar potential
Authors:
Alvaro Herraez
Abstract:
We compute the tree-level potential between two parallel $p$-branes due to the exchange of scalars, gravitons and $(p+1)$-forms. In the case of BPS membranes in 4d $\mathcal{N}=1$ supergravity, this provides an interesting reinterpretation of the classical Cremmer et al. formula for the F-term scalar potential in terms of scalar, graviton and 3-form exchange. In this way, we present a corresponden…
▽ More
We compute the tree-level potential between two parallel $p$-branes due to the exchange of scalars, gravitons and $(p+1)$-forms. In the case of BPS membranes in 4d $\mathcal{N}=1$ supergravity, this provides an interesting reinterpretation of the classical Cremmer et al. formula for the F-term scalar potential in terms of scalar, graviton and 3-form exchange. In this way, we present a correspondence between the scalar potential at every point in scalar field space and a system of two interacting BPS membranes. This could potentially lead to interesting implications for the swampland program by providing a concrete way to relate conjectures about the form of scalar potentials with conjectures regarding the spectrum of charged objects.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2020; v1 submitted 1 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
On scale separation in type II AdS flux vacua
Authors:
Anamaría Font,
Alvaro Herráez,
Luis E. Ibáñez
Abstract:
We study the separation of AdS and Kaluza-Klein (KK) scales in type II 4d AdS orientifold vacua. We first address this problem in toroidal/orbifold type IIA vacua with metric fluxes, corresponding to compactifications in twisted tori, both from the 4d and 10d points of view. We show how the naive application of the effective 4d theory leads to results which violate the AdS distance conjecture, in…
▽ More
We study the separation of AdS and Kaluza-Klein (KK) scales in type II 4d AdS orientifold vacua. We first address this problem in toroidal/orbifold type IIA vacua with metric fluxes, corresponding to compactifications in twisted tori, both from the 4d and 10d points of view. We show how the naive application of the effective 4d theory leads to results which violate the AdS distance conjecture, in a class of $\mathcal{N}=1$ supersymmetric models which have a 10d lifting to a compactification on $S^3\times S^3$. We show how using KK scales properly modified by the compact metric leads to no separation of scales with $M^2_{\text{KK}} = \mathfrak{c} |Λ|$, with $\mathfrak{c}$ a numerical constant independent of fluxes. This applies with no need to keep non-leading fluxes fixed. We also consider a class of IIB models with non-geometric fluxes in which the effective field theory analysisseems to lead to a naive separation of scales and a violation of the AdS distance conjecture. It has a T-dual which again may be understood as a 10d type IIA theory compactified on $S^3\times S^3$. In this geometric dual one again observes that the strong AdS distance conjecture is obeyed with $M^2_{\text{KK}} = \mathfrak{c}' |Λ|$, if one takes into account the curvature in the internal space. These findings seem to suggest that all toroidal/orbifold models with fluxes in this class obey $M^2_{\text{KK}} = \mathfrak{c} |Λ|$ with $\mathfrak{c}$ a flux-independent numerical constant.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2020; v1 submitted 6 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
The Swampland Distance Conjecture and Towers of Tensionless Branes
Authors:
Anamaría Font,
Alvaro Herráez,
Luis E. Ibáñez
Abstract:
The Swampland Distance Conjecture states that at infinite distance in the scalar moduli space an infinite tower of particles become exponentially massless. We study this issue in the context of 4d type IIA and type IIB Calabi-Yau compactifications. We find that for large moduli not only towers of particles but also domain walls and strings become tensionless. We study in detail the case of type II…
▽ More
The Swampland Distance Conjecture states that at infinite distance in the scalar moduli space an infinite tower of particles become exponentially massless. We study this issue in the context of 4d type IIA and type IIB Calabi-Yau compactifications. We find that for large moduli not only towers of particles but also domain walls and strings become tensionless. We study in detail the case of type IIA and IIB ${\cal N}=1$ CY orientifolds and show how for infinite Kähler and/or complex structure moduli towers of domain walls and strings become tensionless, depending on the particular direction in moduli space. For the type IIA case we construct the monodromy orbits of domain walls in detail. We study the structure of mass scales in these limits and find that these towers may occur at the same scale as the fundamental string scale or the KK scale making sometimes difficult an effective field theory description. The structure of IIA and IIB towers are consistent with mirror symmetry, as long as towers of exotic domain walls associated to non-geometric fluxes also appear. We briefly discuss the issue of emergence within this context and the possible implications for 4d vacua.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
AdS-phobia, the WGC, the Standard Model and Supersymmetry
Authors:
Eduardo Gonzalo,
Alvaro Herráez,
Luis E. Ibáñez
Abstract:
It has been recently argued that an embedding of the SM into a consistent theory of quantum gravity may imply important constraints on the mass of the lightest neutrino and the cosmological constant $Λ_{4}$. The constraints come from imposing the absence of any non-SUSY AdS stable vacua obtained from any consistent compactification of the SM to 3 or 2 dimensions. This condition comes as a corollar…
▽ More
It has been recently argued that an embedding of the SM into a consistent theory of quantum gravity may imply important constraints on the mass of the lightest neutrino and the cosmological constant $Λ_{4}$. The constraints come from imposing the absence of any non-SUSY AdS stable vacua obtained from any consistent compactification of the SM to 3 or 2 dimensions. This condition comes as a corollary of a recent extension of the Weak Gravity Conjecture (WGC) by Ooguri and Vafa. In this paper we study $T^2/Z_N$ compactifications of the SM to two dimensions in which SM Wilson lines are projected out, leading to a considerable simplification. We analyze in detail a $T^ 2/Z_4$ compactification of the SM in which both complex structure and Wilson line scalars are fixed and the potential is only a function of the area of the torus $a^2$. We find that the SM is not robust against the appearance of AdS vacua in 2D and hence would be by itself inconsistent with quantum gravity. On the contrary, if the SM is embedded at some scale $M_{SS}$ into a SUSY version like the MSSM, the AdS vacua present in the non-SUSY case disappear or become unstable. This means that WGC arguments favor a SUSY version of the SM, independently of the usual hierarchy problem arguments. In a $T^2/Z_4$ compactification in which the orbifold action is embedded into the $B-L$ symmetry the bounds on neutrino masses and the cosmological constant are recovered. This suggests that the MSSM should be extended with a $U(1)_{B-L}$ gauge group. In other families of vacua the spectrum of SUSY particles is further constrained in order to avoid the appearance of new AdS vacua or instabilities. We discuss a possible understanding of the little hierarchy problem in this context.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2018; v1 submitted 22 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
The Type IIA Flux Potential, 4-forms and Freed-Witten anomalies
Authors:
Alvaro Herraez,
Luis E. Ibanez,
Fernando Marchesano,
Gianluca Zoccarato
Abstract:
We compute the full classical 4d scalar potential of type IIA Calabi-Yau orientifolds in the presence of fluxes and D6-branes. We show that it can be written as a bilinear form $V = Z^{AB} ρ_Aρ_B$, where the $ρ_A$ are in one-to-one correspondence with the 4-form fluxes of the 4d effective theory. The $ρ_A$ only depend on the internal fluxes, the axions and the topological data of the compactificat…
▽ More
We compute the full classical 4d scalar potential of type IIA Calabi-Yau orientifolds in the presence of fluxes and D6-branes. We show that it can be written as a bilinear form $V = Z^{AB} ρ_Aρ_B$, where the $ρ_A$ are in one-to-one correspondence with the 4-form fluxes of the 4d effective theory. The $ρ_A$ only depend on the internal fluxes, the axions and the topological data of the compactification, and are fully determined by the Freed-Witten anomalies of branes that appear as 4d string defects. The quadratic form $Z^{AB}$ only depends on the saxionic partners of these axions. In general, the $ρ_A$ can be seen as the basic invariants under the discrete shift symmetries of the 4d effective theory, and therefore the building blocks of any flux-dependent quantity. All these polynomials may be obtained by derivation from one of them, associated to a universal 4-form. The standard N=1 supergravity flux superpotential is uniquely determined from this {\it master polynomial}, and vice versa.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2018; v1 submitted 15 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
An Axion-induced SM/MSSM Higgs Landscape and the Weak Gravity Conjecture
Authors:
Alvaro Herraez,
Luis E. Ibanez
Abstract:
We construct models in which the SM Higgs mass scans in a landscape. This is achieved by coupling the SM to a monodromy axion field through Minkowski 3-forms. The Higgs mass scans with steps given by delta(m_H^2)= eta mu f, where mu and f are the axion mass and periodicity respectively, and eta measures the coupling of the Higgs to the associated 3-form. The observed Higgs mass scale could then be…
▽ More
We construct models in which the SM Higgs mass scans in a landscape. This is achieved by coupling the SM to a monodromy axion field through Minkowski 3-forms. The Higgs mass scans with steps given by delta(m_H^2)= eta mu f, where mu and f are the axion mass and periodicity respectively, and eta measures the coupling of the Higgs to the associated 3-form. The observed Higgs mass scale could then be selected on anthropic grounds. The monodromy axion may have a mass mu in a very wide range depending on the value of eta, and the axion periodity f. For eta=1 and f = 10^10 GeV, one has 10^{-3}eV < mu < 10^3 eV, but ultralight axions with e.g. mu = 10^{-17} eV are also possible. In a different realization we consider landscape models coupled to the MSSM. In the context of SUSY, 4-forms appear as being part of the auxiliary fields of SUSY multiplets. The scanning in the 4-forms thus translate into a landscape of vevs for the N=1 auxiliary fields and hence as a landscape for the soft terms. This could provide a rationale for the MSSM fine-tuning suggested by LHC data. In all these models there are 3-forms coupling to membranes which induce transitions between different vacua through bubble nucleation. The Weak Gravity Conjecture (WGC) set limits on the tension of these membranes and implies new physics thresholds well below the Planck scale. More generaly, we argue that in the case of string SUSY vacua in which the Goldstino multiplet contains a monodromy axion the WGC suggests a lower bound on the SUSY breaking scale m_{3/2} > M_s^2/M_p.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
