Showing 1–50 of 112 results for author: Hartnoll, S

Statistical Physics of the Polarised IKKT Matrix Model

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Jun Liu

Abstract: The polarised IKKT matrix model is the worldpoint theory of $N$ D-instantons in a background three-form flux of magnitude $Ω$, and promises to be a highly tractable model of holography. The matrix integral can be viewed as a statistical physics partition function with inverse temperature $Ω^4$. At large $Ω$ the model is dominated by a matrix configuration corresponding to a 'polarised' spherical D… ▽ More The polarised IKKT matrix model is the worldpoint theory of $N$ D-instantons in a background three-form flux of magnitude $Ω$, and promises to be a highly tractable model of holography. The matrix integral can be viewed as a statistical physics partition function with inverse temperature $Ω^4$. At large $Ω$ the model is dominated by a matrix configuration corresponding to a 'polarised' spherical D1-brane. We show that at a critical value of $Ω^2 N$ the model undergoes a first order phase transition, corresponding to tunneling into a collection of well-separated D-instantons. These instantons are the remnant of a competing saddle in the high $Ω$ phase corresponding to spherical $(p,q)$ fivebranes. We use a combination of numerical and analytical arguments to capture the different regimes of the model. △ Less

Submitted 31 May, 2025; v1 submitted 8 April, 2025; originally announced April 2025.

Comments: 20 pages and 6 figures. v2: references added

The Conformal Primon Gas at the End of Time

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Ming Yang

Abstract: The Belinksy-Khalatnikov-Lifshitz dynamics of gravity close to a spacelike singularity can be mapped, at each point in space separately, onto the motion of a particle bouncing within half the fundamental domain of the modular group. We show that the semiclassical quantisation of this motion is a conformal quantum mechanics where the states are constrained to be modular invariant. Each such state d… ▽ More The Belinksy-Khalatnikov-Lifshitz dynamics of gravity close to a spacelike singularity can be mapped, at each point in space separately, onto the motion of a particle bouncing within half the fundamental domain of the modular group. We show that the semiclassical quantisation of this motion is a conformal quantum mechanics where the states are constrained to be modular invariant. Each such state defines an odd automorphic $L$-function. In particular, in a basis of dilatation eigenstates the wavefunction is proportional to the $L$-function along the critical axis and hence vanishes at the nontrivial zeros. We show that the $L$-function along the positive real axis is equal to the partition function of a gas of non-interacting charged oscillators labeled by prime numbers. This generalises Julia's notion of a primon gas. Each state therefore has a corresponding, dual, primon gas with a distinct nontrivial set of chemical potentials that ensure modular invariance. We extract universal features of these theories by averaging the logarithm of the partition function over the chemical potentials. The averaging produces the Witten index of a fermionic primon gas. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2025; v1 submitted 4 February, 2025; originally announced February 2025.

Comments: 36 pages, 6 figures. v2: minor improvements to text

The Polarised IKKT Matrix Model

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Jun Liu

Abstract: We establish a correspondence between a supersymmetric mass deformation of the IKKT matrix integral at large $N$ and a background of Euclidean type IIB string theory. Both sides have sixteen supersymmetries and an $SO(3)\times SO(7)$ symmetry. In the limit of large mass the integral is dominated by a fuzzy sphere saddle point. This saddle corresponds to a Euclidean $D1$-brane in a finite, Euclidea… ▽ More We establish a correspondence between a supersymmetric mass deformation of the IKKT matrix integral at large $N$ and a background of Euclidean type IIB string theory. Both sides have sixteen supersymmetries and an $SO(3)\times SO(7)$ symmetry. In the limit of large mass the integral is dominated by a fuzzy sphere saddle point. This saddle corresponds to a Euclidean $D1$-brane in a finite, Euclidean, ellipsoidal cavity. The cavity is supported by three-form NSNS flux that polarises $N$ $D$-instantons into the $D1$-brane. We furthermore use supersymmetric localisation to show that the deformed matrix integral can be reduced to a moduli space integral, allowing exact results away from the large mass limit. At small mass the $D1$-branes can backreact on the geometry, and we discuss the possible formulation of a `timeless' holography in such regimes. △ Less

Submitted 27 September, 2024; originally announced September 2024.

Comments: 34+29 pages. 3 figures

Minimal Areas from Entangled Matrices

Authors: Jackson R. Fliss, Alexander Frenkel, Sean A. Hartnoll, Ronak M Soni

Abstract: We define a relational notion of a subsystem in theories of matrix quantum mechanics and show how the corresponding entanglement entropy can be given as a minimisation, exhibiting many similarities to the Ryu-Takayanagi formula. Our construction brings together the physics of entanglement edge modes, noncommutative geometry and quantum internal reference frames, to define a subsystem whose reduced… ▽ More We define a relational notion of a subsystem in theories of matrix quantum mechanics and show how the corresponding entanglement entropy can be given as a minimisation, exhibiting many similarities to the Ryu-Takayanagi formula. Our construction brings together the physics of entanglement edge modes, noncommutative geometry and quantum internal reference frames, to define a subsystem whose reduced state is (approximately) an incoherent sum of density matrices, corresponding to distinct spatial subregions. We show that in states where geometry emerges from semiclassical matrices, this sum is dominated by the subregion with minimal boundary area. As in the Ryu-Takayanagi formula, it is the computation of the entanglement that determines the subregion. We find that coarse-graining is essential in our microscopic derivation, in order to control the proliferation of highly curved and disconnected non-geometric subregions in the sum. △ Less

Submitted 30 May, 2025; v1 submitted 9 August, 2024; originally announced August 2024.

Comments: 48+16 pages, 8 figures. v2: minor changes, journal version

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 18, 171 (2025)

Mixmaster chaos in an AdS black hole interior

Authors: Marine De Clerck, Sean A. Hartnoll, Jorge E. Santos

Abstract: We derive gravitational backgrounds that are asymptotically Anti-de Sitter, have a regular black hole horizon and which deep in the interior exhibit mixmaster chaotic dynamics. The solutions are obtained by coupling gravity with a negative cosmological constant to three massive vector fields, within an Ansatz that reduces to ordinary differential equations. At late interior times the equations are… ▽ More We derive gravitational backgrounds that are asymptotically Anti-de Sitter, have a regular black hole horizon and which deep in the interior exhibit mixmaster chaotic dynamics. The solutions are obtained by coupling gravity with a negative cosmological constant to three massive vector fields, within an Ansatz that reduces to ordinary differential equations. At late interior times the equations are identical to those analysed in depth by Misner and by Belinskii-Khalatnikov-Lifshitz fifty years ago. We review and extend known classical and semiclassical results on the interior chaos, formulated as both a dynamical system of `Kasner eras' and as a hyperbolic billiards problem. The volume of the universe collapses doubly-exponentially over each Kasner era. A remarkable feature is the emergence of a conserved energy, and hence a `time-independent' Hamiltonian, at asymptotically late interior times. A quantisation of this Hamiltonian exhibits arithmetic chaos associated with the principal congruence subgroup $Γ(2)$ of the modular group. We compute a large number of eigenvalues numerically to obtain the spectral form factor. While the spectral statistics is anomalous for a chaotic system, the eigenfunctions themselves display random matrix behaviour. △ Less

Submitted 15 May, 2024; v1 submitted 18 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: 74 pages including references and appendices. 18 figures. v2: added reference and a minor clarification. v3: added reference, details on numerics and comment on unitarity bound. v4: minor clarifications and references added

Cosmological quantum states of de Sitter-Schwarzschild are static patch partition functions

Authors: Matthew J. Blacker, Sean A. Hartnoll

Abstract: We solve the Wheeler-DeWitt equation in the 'cosmological interior' (the past causal diamond of future infinity) of four dimensional dS-Schwarzschild spacetimes. Within minisuperspace there is a basis of solutions labelled by a constant $c$, conjugate to the mass of the black hole. We propose that these solutions are in correspondence with partition functions of a dual quantum mechanical theory wh… ▽ More We solve the Wheeler-DeWitt equation in the 'cosmological interior' (the past causal diamond of future infinity) of four dimensional dS-Schwarzschild spacetimes. Within minisuperspace there is a basis of solutions labelled by a constant $c$, conjugate to the mass of the black hole. We propose that these solutions are in correspondence with partition functions of a dual quantum mechanical theory where $c$ plays the role of time. The quantum mechanical theory lives on worldtubes in the 'static patch' of dS-Schwarzschild, and the partition function is obtained by evolving the corresponding Wheeler-DeWitt wavefunction through the cosmological horizon, where a metric component $g_{tt}$ changes sign. We establish that the dual theory admits a symmetry algebra given by a central extension of the Poincaré algebra $\mathfrak{e}(1,1)$ and that the entropy of the dS black hole is encoded as an averaging of the dual partition function over the background $g_{tt}$. △ Less

Submitted 13 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Comments: 24 pages with references, one figure

Emergent Area Laws from Entangled Matrices

Authors: Alexander Frenkel, Sean A. Hartnoll

Abstract: We consider a wavefunction of large $N$ matrices supported close to an emergent classical fuzzy sphere geometry. The $SU(N)$ Gauss law of the theory enforces correlations between the matrix degrees of freedom associated to a geometric subregion and their complement. We call this `Gauss law entanglement'. We show that the subregion degrees of freedom transform under a single dominant, low rank repr… ▽ More We consider a wavefunction of large $N$ matrices supported close to an emergent classical fuzzy sphere geometry. The $SU(N)$ Gauss law of the theory enforces correlations between the matrix degrees of freedom associated to a geometric subregion and their complement. We call this `Gauss law entanglement'. We show that the subregion degrees of freedom transform under a single dominant, low rank representation of $SU(N)$. The corresponding Gauss law entanglement entropy is given by the logarithm of the dimension of this dominant representation. It is found that, after coarse-graining in momentum space, the $SU(N)$ Gauss law entanglement entropy is proportional to the geometric area bounding the subregion. The constant of proportionality goes like the inverse of an emergent Maxwell coupling constant, reminiscent of gravitational entropy. △ Less

Submitted 6 January, 2023; v1 submitted 3 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Comments: 32 pages including appendices and references. 4 figures. v2: corrected intermediate formula

Snowmass Theory Frontier: Effective Field Theory

Authors: Matthew Baumgart, Fady Bishara, Tomas Brauner, Joachim Brod, Giovanni Cabass, Timothy Cohen, Nathaniel Craig, Claudia de Rham, Patrick Draper, A. Liam Fitzpatrick, Martin Gorbahn, Sean Hartnoll, Mikhail Ivanov, Pavel Kovtun, Sandipan Kundu, Matthew Lewandowski, Hong Liu, Xiaochuan Lu, Mark Mezei, Mehrdad Mirbabayi, Ulserik Moldanazarova, Alberto Nicolis, Riccardo Penco, Walter Goldberger, Matthew Reece , et al. (12 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We summarize recent progress in the development, application, and understanding of effective field theories and highlight promising directions for future research. This Report is prepared as the TF02 "Effective Field Theory" topical group summary for the Theory Frontier as part of the Snowmass 2021 process. We summarize recent progress in the development, application, and understanding of effective field theories and highlight promising directions for future research. This Report is prepared as the TF02 "Effective Field Theory" topical group summary for the Theory Frontier as part of the Snowmass 2021 process. △ Less

Submitted 6 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 12 pages

TF1 Snowmass Report: Quantum gravity, string theory, and black holes

Authors: Daniel Harlow, Shamit Kachru, Juan Maldacena, Ibrahima Bah, Mike Blake, Raphael Bousso, Mirjam Cvetic, Xi Dong, Netta Engelhardt, Tom Faulkner, Raphael Flauger, Dan Freed, Victor Gorbenko, Yingfei Gu, Jim Halverson, Tom Hartman, Sean Hartnoll, Andreas Karch, Hong Liu, Andy Lucas, Emil Martinec, Liam McAllister, Greg Moore, Nikita Nekrasov, Sabrina Pasterski , et al. (13 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We give an overview of the field of quantum gravity, string theory and black holes summarizing various white papers in this subject that were submitted as part of the Snowmass process. We give an overview of the field of quantum gravity, string theory and black holes summarizing various white papers in this subject that were submitted as part of the Snowmass process. △ Less

Submitted 16 November, 2022; v1 submitted 4 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 21 pages; v2, minor changes

AdS Black Holes with a Bouncing Interior

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Navonil Neogi

Abstract: We construct planar black hole solutions of AdS gravity minimally coupled to a scalar field with an even, super-exponential potential. We show that the evolution of the black hole interior exhibits an infinite sequence of Kasner epochs, as the scalar field rolls back and forth in its potential. We obtain an analytic expression for the `bounces' between each Kasner epoch and also give an explicit f… ▽ More We construct planar black hole solutions of AdS gravity minimally coupled to a scalar field with an even, super-exponential potential. We show that the evolution of the black hole interior exhibits an infinite sequence of Kasner epochs, as the scalar field rolls back and forth in its potential. We obtain an analytic expression for the `bounces' between each Kasner epoch and also give an explicit formula for the times and strengths of the bounces at late interior times, thereby fully characterizing the interior evolution. In this way we show that the interior geometry approaches the Schwarzschild singularity at late times, even as the scalar field is driven higher up its potential with each bounce. △ Less

Submitted 27 December, 2022; v1 submitted 26 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: 18 pages. 6 figures. v2: References added. v3: minor changes

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 14, 074 (2023)

Wheeler-DeWitt states of the AdS-Schwarzschild interior

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll

Abstract: We solve the Wheeler-DeWitt equation for the planar AdS-Schwarzschild interior in a minisuperspace approximation involving the volume and spatial anisotropy of the interior. A Gaussian wavepacket is constructed that is peaked on the classical interior solution. Simple observables are computed using this wavepacket, demonstrating the freedom to a choose a relational notion of `clock' in the interio… ▽ More We solve the Wheeler-DeWitt equation for the planar AdS-Schwarzschild interior in a minisuperspace approximation involving the volume and spatial anisotropy of the interior. A Gaussian wavepacket is constructed that is peaked on the classical interior solution. Simple observables are computed using this wavepacket, demonstrating the freedom to a choose a relational notion of `clock' in the interior and characterizing the approach to the spacelike singularity. The Wheeler-DeWitt equation may be extended out through the horizon, where it describes the holographic renormalization group flow of the black hole exterior. This amounts to the Hamilton-Jacobi evolution of the metric component $g_{tt}$ from positive interior values to negative exterior values. The interior Gaussian wavepacket is shown to evolve into the Lorentizan partition function of the boundary conformal field theory over a microcanonical energy window. △ Less

Submitted 24 December, 2022; v1 submitted 8 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Comments: 31 pages. 1 figure. v2 minor improvements. v3 minor improvements

Snowmass White Paper: Effective Field Theories for Condensed Matter Systems

Authors: Tomas Brauner, Sean A. Hartnoll, Pavel Kovtun, Hong Liu, Márk Mezei, Alberto Nicolis, Riccardo Penco, Shu-Heng Shao, Dam Thanh Son

Abstract: We review recent progress and a number of future directions for applications of effective field theory methods to condensed matter systems broadly defined. Our emphasis is on areas that have allowed a fertile exchange of ideas between high energy physics and many-body theory. We discuss developments in the effective field theory of spontaneous symmetry breaking, of hydrodynamics and non-equilibriu… ▽ More We review recent progress and a number of future directions for applications of effective field theory methods to condensed matter systems broadly defined. Our emphasis is on areas that have allowed a fertile exchange of ideas between high energy physics and many-body theory. We discuss developments in the effective field theory of spontaneous symmetry breaking, of hydrodynamics and non-equilibrium dynamics more generally, fracton phases of matter, and dualities between 2+1 dimensional field theories. We furthermore discuss the application of effective field theory to non-Fermi liquids, the dynamics of entanglement entropy and to condensed matter aspects of cosmology. △ Less

Submitted 18 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: Contribution to Snowmass 2021; 13 + 20 pages; 1 figure

Snowmass White Paper: New ideas for many-body quantum systems from string theory and black holes

Authors: Mike Blake, Yingfei Gu, Sean A. Hartnoll, Hong Liu, Andrew Lucas, Krishna Rajagopal, Brian Swingle, Beni Yoshida

Abstract: During the last two decades many new insights into the dynamics of strongly coupled quantum many-body systems have been obtained using gauge/gravity duality, with black holes often playing a universal role. In this white paper we summarize the results obtained and offer some outlook for future developments, including the ongoing mutually beneficial feedback loop with the study of more general, not… ▽ More During the last two decades many new insights into the dynamics of strongly coupled quantum many-body systems have been obtained using gauge/gravity duality, with black holes often playing a universal role. In this white paper we summarize the results obtained and offer some outlook for future developments, including the ongoing mutually beneficial feedback loop with the study of more general, not necessarily holographic, quantum many-body systems. △ Less

Submitted 9 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: 18+24 pages

Joule heating in bad and slow metals

Authors: Paolo Glorioso, Sean A. Hartnoll

Abstract: Heat supplied to a metal is absorbed by the electrons and then transferred to the lattice. In conventional metals energy is released to the lattice by phonons emitted from the Lindhard continuum. However in a `bad' metal, with short mean free path, the low energy Lindhard continuum is destroyed. Furthermore in a `slow' metal, with Fermi velocity less than the sound velocity, particle-hole pairs ar… ▽ More Heat supplied to a metal is absorbed by the electrons and then transferred to the lattice. In conventional metals energy is released to the lattice by phonons emitted from the Lindhard continuum. However in a `bad' metal, with short mean free path, the low energy Lindhard continuum is destroyed. Furthermore in a `slow' metal, with Fermi velocity less than the sound velocity, particle-hole pairs are kinematically unable to emit phonons. To describe energy transfer to the lattice in these cases we obtain a general Kubo formula for the energy relaxation rate in terms of the electronic density spectral weight $\text{Im} \, G^R_{nn}(ω_k,k)$ evaluated on the phonon dispersion $ω_k$. We apply our Kubo formula to the high temperature Hubbard model, using recent data from quantum Monte Carlo and experiments in ultracold atoms to characterize $\text{Im} \, G^R_{nn}(ω_k,k)$. We furthermore use recent data from electron energy-loss spectroscopy to estimate the energy relaxation rate of the cuprate strange metal to a high energy optical phonon. As a second, distinct, application of our formalism we consider `slow' metals. These are defined to have Fermi velocity less than the sound velocity, so that particle-hole pairs are kinematically unable to emit phonons. We obtain an expression for the energy relaxation rate of a slow metal in terms of the optical conductivity. △ Less

Submitted 29 August, 2022; v1 submitted 1 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: 21+9 pages, 8 figures; v2: minor clarifications

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 13, 095 (2022)

Entanglement in the Quantum Hall Matrix Model

Authors: Alexander Frenkel, Sean A. Hartnoll

Abstract: Characterizing the entanglement of matrix degrees of freedom is essential for understanding the holographic emergence of spacetime. The Quantum Hall Matrix Model is a gauged $U(N)$ matrix quantum mechanics with two matrices whose ground state is known exactly and describes an emergent spatial disk with incompressible bulk dynamics. We define and compute an entanglement entropy in the ground state… ▽ More Characterizing the entanglement of matrix degrees of freedom is essential for understanding the holographic emergence of spacetime. The Quantum Hall Matrix Model is a gauged $U(N)$ matrix quantum mechanics with two matrices whose ground state is known exactly and describes an emergent spatial disk with incompressible bulk dynamics. We define and compute an entanglement entropy in the ground state associated to a cut through the disk. There are two contributions. A collective field describing the eigenvalues of one of the matrices gives a gauge-invariant chiral boundary mode leading to an expected logarithmic entanglement entropy. Further, the cut through the bulk splits certain 'off-diagonal' matrix elements that must be duplicated and associated to both sides of the cut. Sewing these duplicated modes together in a gauge-invariant way leads to a bulk 'area law' contribution to the entanglement entropy. All of these entropies are regularized by finite $N$. △ Less

Submitted 19 November, 2021; v1 submitted 10 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: 53 pages including appendices. 7 figures. v2: references added and discussion of Chern-Simons entanglement corrected

Planckian Dissipation in Metals

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Andrew P. Mackenzie

Abstract: We review the appearance of the Planckian time $τ_\text{Pl} = \hbar/(k_B T)$ in both conventional and unconventional metals. We give a pedagogical discussion of the various different timescales (quasiparticle, transport, many-body) that characterize metals, emphasizing conditions under which these times are the same or different. Throughout, we have attempted to clear up aspects of the problem tha… ▽ More We review the appearance of the Planckian time $τ_\text{Pl} = \hbar/(k_B T)$ in both conventional and unconventional metals. We give a pedagogical discussion of the various different timescales (quasiparticle, transport, many-body) that characterize metals, emphasizing conditions under which these times are the same or different. Throughout, we have attempted to clear up aspects of the problem that had been confusing us, in the hope that this helps the reader as well. We discuss the possibility of a Planckian bound on dissipation from both a quasiparticle and a many-body perspective. Planckian quasiparticles can arise naturally from a combination of inelastic scattering and mass renormalization. Many-body dynamics, on the other hand, is constrained by the basic time- and length- scales of local thermalization. △ Less

Submitted 18 June, 2022; v1 submitted 16 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: 43 pages + references and appendices. v2: references added and minor improvements to presentation made. v3: further minor improvements to presentation throughout

Phonons, electrons and thermal transport in Planckian high T$_c$ materials

Authors: Connie H. Mousatov, Sean A. Hartnoll

Abstract: The room temperature thermal diffusivity of high T$_c$ materials is dominated by phonons. This allows the scattering of phonons by electrons to be discerned. We argue that the measured strength of this scattering suggests a converse Planckian scattering of electrons by phonons across the room temperature phase diagram of these materials. Consistent with this conclusion, the temperature derivative… ▽ More The room temperature thermal diffusivity of high T$_c$ materials is dominated by phonons. This allows the scattering of phonons by electrons to be discerned. We argue that the measured strength of this scattering suggests a converse Planckian scattering of electrons by phonons across the room temperature phase diagram of these materials. Consistent with this conclusion, the temperature derivative of the resistivity of strongly overdoped cuprates is noted to show a kink at a little below 200 K that we argue should be understood as the onset of a high temperature Planckian $T$-linear scattering of electrons by classical phonons. This kink continuously disappears towards optimal doping, even while strong scattering of phonons by electrons remains visible in the thermal diffusivity, sharpening the long-standing puzzle of the lack of a feature in the $T$-linear resistivity at optimal doping associated to onset of phonon scattering. △ Less

Submitted 26 July, 2021; v1 submitted 20 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: 12 pages plus references and appendices. 7 figures. v2 minor improvements

Diving into a holographic superconductor

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Gary T. Horowitz, Jorrit Kruthoff, Jorge E. Santos

Abstract: Charged black holes in anti-de Sitter space become unstable to forming charged scalar hair at low temperatures $T < T_\text{c}$. This phenomenon is a holographic realization of superconductivity. We look inside the horizon of these holographic superconductors and find intricate dynamical behavior. The spacetime ends at a spacelike Kasner singularity, and there is no Cauchy horizon. Before reaching… ▽ More Charged black holes in anti-de Sitter space become unstable to forming charged scalar hair at low temperatures $T < T_\text{c}$. This phenomenon is a holographic realization of superconductivity. We look inside the horizon of these holographic superconductors and find intricate dynamical behavior. The spacetime ends at a spacelike Kasner singularity, and there is no Cauchy horizon. Before reaching the singularity, there are several intermediate regimes which we study both analytically and numerically. These include strong Josephson oscillations in the condensate and possible 'Kasner inversions' in which after many e-folds of expansion, the Einstein-Rosen bridge contracts towards the singularity. Due to the Josephson oscillations, the number of Kasner inversions depends very sensitively on $T$, and diverges at a discrete set of temperatures $\{T_n\}$ that accumulate at $T_c$. Near these $T_n$, the final Kasner exponent exhibits fractal-like behavior. △ Less

Submitted 15 January, 2021; v1 submitted 28 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Comments: 23 pages, 10 figures

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 10, 009 (2021)

Gravitational duals to the grand canonical ensemble abhor Cauchy horizons

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Gary T. Horowitz, Jorrit Kruthoff, Jorge E. Santos

Abstract: The gravitational dual to the grand canonical ensemble of a large $N$ holographic theory is a charged black hole. These spacetimes -- for example Reissner-Nordström-AdS -- can have Cauchy horizons that render the classical gravitational dynamics of the black hole interior incomplete. We show that a (spatially uniform) deformation of the CFT by a neutral scalar operator generically leads to a black… ▽ More The gravitational dual to the grand canonical ensemble of a large $N$ holographic theory is a charged black hole. These spacetimes -- for example Reissner-Nordström-AdS -- can have Cauchy horizons that render the classical gravitational dynamics of the black hole interior incomplete. We show that a (spatially uniform) deformation of the CFT by a neutral scalar operator generically leads to a black hole with no inner horizon. There is instead a spacelike Kasner singularity in the interior. For relevant deformations, Cauchy horizons never form. For certain irrelevant deformations, Cauchy horizons can exist at one specific temperature. We show that the scalar field triggers a rapid collapse of the Einstein-Rosen bridge at the would-be Cauchy horizon. Finally, we make some observations on the interior of charged dilatonic black holes where the Kasner exponent at the singularity exhibits an attractor mechanism in the low temperature limit. △ Less

Submitted 30 July, 2020; v1 submitted 17 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 27 pages, 7 figures. v2: Minor comments added and minor improvement made to discussion of Einstein-Rosen bridge collapse

Bootstrapping Matrix Quantum Mechanics

Authors: Xizhi Han, Sean A. Hartnoll, Jorrit Kruthoff

Abstract: Large $N$ matrix quantum mechanics is central to holographic duality but not solvable in the most interesting cases. We show that the spectrum and simple expectation values in these theories can be obtained numerically via a `bootstrap' methodology. In this approach, operator expectation values are related by symmetries -- such as time translation and $SU(N)$ gauge invariance -- and then bounded w… ▽ More Large $N$ matrix quantum mechanics is central to holographic duality but not solvable in the most interesting cases. We show that the spectrum and simple expectation values in these theories can be obtained numerically via a `bootstrap' methodology. In this approach, operator expectation values are related by symmetries -- such as time translation and $SU(N)$ gauge invariance -- and then bounded with certain positivity constraints. We first demonstrate how this method efficiently solves the conventional quantum anharmonic oscillator. We then reproduce the known solution of large $N$ single matrix quantum mechanics. Finally, we present new results on the ground state of large $N$ two matrix quantum mechanics. △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2020; v1 submitted 21 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: 11 pages. 3 figures. v2: more details of numerical methods and minor additions. code available online: https://github.com/hanxzh94/matrix-bootstrap

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 041601 (2020)

Holographic flows from CFT to the Kasner universe

Authors: Alexander Frenkel, Sean A. Hartnoll, Jorrit Kruthoff, Zhengyan D. Shi

Abstract: The Schwarzschild singularity is known to be classically unstable. We demonstrate a simple holographic consequence of this fact, focusing on a perturbation that is uniform in boundary space and time. Deformation of the thermal state of the dual CFT by a relevant operator triggers a nonzero temperature holographic renormalization group flow in the bulk. This flow continues smoothly through the hori… ▽ More The Schwarzschild singularity is known to be classically unstable. We demonstrate a simple holographic consequence of this fact, focusing on a perturbation that is uniform in boundary space and time. Deformation of the thermal state of the dual CFT by a relevant operator triggers a nonzero temperature holographic renormalization group flow in the bulk. This flow continues smoothly through the horizon and, at late interior time, deforms the Schwarzschild singularity into a more general Kasner universe. We show that the deformed near-singularity, trans-horizon Kasner exponents determine specific non-analytic corrections to the thermal correlation functions of heavy operators in the dual CFT, in the analytically continued `near-singularity' regime. △ Less

Submitted 2 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: 21 pages, 5 figures

Topological order in matrix Ising models

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Edward A. Mazenc, Zhengyan D. Shi

Abstract: We study a family of models for an $N_1 \times N_2$ matrix worth of Ising spins $S_{aB}$. In the large $N_i$ limit we show that the spins soften, so that the partition function is described by a bosonic matrix integral with a single `spherical' constraint. In this way we generalize the results of [1] to a wide class of Ising Hamiltonians with $O(N_1,\mathbb{Z})\times O(N_2,\mathbb{Z})$ symmetry. T… ▽ More We study a family of models for an $N_1 \times N_2$ matrix worth of Ising spins $S_{aB}$. In the large $N_i$ limit we show that the spins soften, so that the partition function is described by a bosonic matrix integral with a single `spherical' constraint. In this way we generalize the results of [1] to a wide class of Ising Hamiltonians with $O(N_1,\mathbb{Z})\times O(N_2,\mathbb{Z})$ symmetry. The models can undergo topological large $N$ phase transitions in which the thermal expectation value of the distribution of singular values of the matrix $S_{aB}$ becomes disconnected. This topological transition competes with low temperature glassy and magnetically ordered phases. △ Less

Submitted 19 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 1+28 pages. 3 figures

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 7, 081 (2019)

Deep Quantum Geometry of Matrices

Authors: Xizhi Han, Sean A. Hartnoll

Abstract: We employ machine learning techniques to provide accurate variational wavefunctions for matrix quantum mechanics, with multiple bosonic and fermionic matrices. Variational quantum Monte Carlo is implemented with deep generative flows to search for gauge invariant low energy states. The ground state, and also long-lived metastable states, of an $\mathrm{SU}(N)$ matrix quantum mechanics with three b… ▽ More We employ machine learning techniques to provide accurate variational wavefunctions for matrix quantum mechanics, with multiple bosonic and fermionic matrices. Variational quantum Monte Carlo is implemented with deep generative flows to search for gauge invariant low energy states. The ground state, and also long-lived metastable states, of an $\mathrm{SU}(N)$ matrix quantum mechanics with three bosonic matrices, as well as its supersymmetric `mini-BMN' extension, are studied as a function of coupling and $N$. Known semiclassical fuzzy sphere states are recovered, and the collapse of these geometries in more strongly quantum regimes is probed using the variational wavefunction. We then describe a factorization of the quantum mechanical Hilbert space that corresponds to a spatial partition of the emergent geometry. Under this partition, the fuzzy sphere states show a boundary-law entanglement entropy in the large $N$ limit. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2020; v1 submitted 20 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: 36+26 pages. 16 Figs. v2: added results on small nu limit. Code available online: https://github.com/hanxzh94/matrix-model

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. X 10, 011069 (2020)

Theory of the collective magnetophonon resonance and melting of the field-induced Wigner solid

Authors: Luca V. Delacrétaz, Blaise Goutéraux, Sean A. Hartnoll, Anna Karlsson

Abstract: Electron solid phases of matter are revealed by characteristic vibrational resonances. Sufficiently large magnetic fields can overcome the effects of disorder, leading to a weakly pinned collective mode called the magnetophonon. Consequently, in this regime it is possible to develop a tightly constrained hydrodynamic theory of pinned magnetophonons. The behavior of the magnetophonon resonance acro… ▽ More Electron solid phases of matter are revealed by characteristic vibrational resonances. Sufficiently large magnetic fields can overcome the effects of disorder, leading to a weakly pinned collective mode called the magnetophonon. Consequently, in this regime it is possible to develop a tightly constrained hydrodynamic theory of pinned magnetophonons. The behavior of the magnetophonon resonance across thermal and quantum melting transitions has been experimentally characterized in two-dimensional electron systems. Applying our theory to these transitions we explain several key features of the data: (i) violation of the Fukuyama-Lee sum rule as the transition is approached is directly tied to the non-Lorentzian form taken by the resonance and (ii) the non-Lorentzian shape is caused by characteristic dissipative channels that become especially important close to melting: proliferating dislocations and uncondensed charge carriers. △ Less

Submitted 9 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: 20+4 pages. 4 figures

Report number: CPHT-RR016.042019

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 100, 085140 (2019)

Quantum Scrambling and State Dependence of the Butterfly Velocity

Authors: Xizhi Han, Sean A. Hartnoll

Abstract: Operator growth in spatially local quantum many-body systems defines a scrambling velocity. We prove that this scrambling velocity bounds the state dependence of the out-of-time-ordered correlator in local lattice models. We verify this bound in simulations of the thermal mixed-field Ising spin chain. For scrambling operators, the butterfly velocity shows a crossover from a microscopic high temper… ▽ More Operator growth in spatially local quantum many-body systems defines a scrambling velocity. We prove that this scrambling velocity bounds the state dependence of the out-of-time-ordered correlator in local lattice models. We verify this bound in simulations of the thermal mixed-field Ising spin chain. For scrambling operators, the butterfly velocity shows a crossover from a microscopic high temperature value to a distinct value at temperatures below the energy gap. △ Less

Submitted 13 August, 2019; v1 submitted 18 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Comments: 13 pages + appendices, 3 + 6 figures. v3: improved presentation

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 7, 045 (2019)

Theory of diffusive fluctuations

Authors: Xinyi Chen-Lin, Luca V. Delacrétaz, Sean A. Hartnoll

Abstract: The recently developed effective field theory of fluctuations around thermal equilibrium is used to compute late-time correlation functions of conserved densities. Specializing to systems with a single conservation law, we find that the diffusive pole is shifted in the presence of non-linear hydrodynamic self-interactions, and that the density-density Green's function acquires a branch point half… ▽ More The recently developed effective field theory of fluctuations around thermal equilibrium is used to compute late-time correlation functions of conserved densities. Specializing to systems with a single conservation law, we find that the diffusive pole is shifted in the presence of non-linear hydrodynamic self-interactions, and that the density-density Green's function acquires a branch point half way to the diffusive pole, at frequency $ω= -\frac{i}{2}Dk^2$. We discuss the relevance of diffusive fluctuations for strongly correlated transport in condensed matter and cold atomic systems. △ Less

Submitted 22 December, 2019; v1 submitted 29 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: 8+15 pages, 5 figures; v2: small correction to figure 2; v3: published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 091602 (2019)

Locality Bound for Dissipative Quantum Transport

Authors: Xizhi Han, Sean A. Hartnoll

Abstract: We prove an upper bound on the diffusivity of a general local and translation invariant quantum Markovian spin system: $D \leq D_0 + \left(α\, v_\text{LR} τ+ β\, ξ\right) v_\text{C}$. Here $v_\text{LR}$ is the Lieb-Robinson velocity, $v_\text{C}$ is a velocity defined by the current operator, $τ$ is the decoherence time, $ξ$ is the range of interactions, $D_0$ is a microscopically determined diffu… ▽ More We prove an upper bound on the diffusivity of a general local and translation invariant quantum Markovian spin system: $D \leq D_0 + \left(α\, v_\text{LR} τ+ β\, ξ\right) v_\text{C}$. Here $v_\text{LR}$ is the Lieb-Robinson velocity, $v_\text{C}$ is a velocity defined by the current operator, $τ$ is the decoherence time, $ξ$ is the range of interactions, $D_0$ is a microscopically determined diffusivity and $α$ and $β$ are precisely defined dimensionless coefficients. The bound constrains quantum transport by quantities that can either be obtained from the microscopic interactions ($D_0, v_\text{LR}, v_\text{C},ξ$) or else determined from independent local non-transport measurements ($τ,α,β$). We illustrate the general result with the case of a spin half XXZ chain with on-site dephasing. Our result generalizes the Lieb-Robinson bound to constrain the sub-ballistic diffusion of conserved densities in a dissipative setting. △ Less

Submitted 4 October, 2018; v1 submitted 5 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Comments: 5 pages, 1 figure, revised for PRL

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 170601 (2018)

Thermalization, Viscosity and the Averaged Null Energy Condition

Authors: Luca V. Delacrétaz, Thomas Hartman, Sean A. Hartnoll, Aitor Lewkowycz

Abstract: We explore the implications of the averaged null energy condition for thermal states of relativistic quantum field theories. A key property of such thermal states is the thermalization length. This lengthscale generalizes the notion of a mean free path beyond weak coupling, and allows finite size regions to independently thermalize. Using the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis, we show that ther… ▽ More We explore the implications of the averaged null energy condition for thermal states of relativistic quantum field theories. A key property of such thermal states is the thermalization length. This lengthscale generalizes the notion of a mean free path beyond weak coupling, and allows finite size regions to independently thermalize. Using the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis, we show that thermal fluctuations in finite size `fireballs' can produce states that violate the averaged null energy condition if the thermalization length is too short or if the shear viscosity is too large. These bounds become very weak with a large number N of degrees of freedom but can constrain real-world systems, such as the quark-gluon plasma. △ Less

Submitted 10 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: 28 pages, 3 figures

Kinetic theory of transport for inhomogeneous electron fluids

Authors: Andrew Lucas, Sean A. Hartnoll

Abstract: The interplay between electronic interactions and disorder is neglected in the conventional Boltzmann theory of transport, yet can play an essential role in determining the resistivity of unconventional metals. When quasiparticles are long-lived, one can account for these intertwined effects by solving spatially inhomogeneous Boltzmann equations. Assuming smooth disorder and neglecting umklapp sca… ▽ More The interplay between electronic interactions and disorder is neglected in the conventional Boltzmann theory of transport, yet can play an essential role in determining the resistivity of unconventional metals. When quasiparticles are long-lived, one can account for these intertwined effects by solving spatially inhomogeneous Boltzmann equations. Assuming smooth disorder and neglecting umklapp scattering, we solve these inhomogeneous kinetic equations and compute the electrical resistivity across the ballistic-to-hydrodynamic transition. An important consequence of electron-electron interactions is the modification of the momentum relaxation time; this effect is ignored in the conventional theory. We characterize precisely when interactions enhance the momentum scattering rate, and when they decrease it. Our approach unifies existing semiclassical theories of transport and reveals novel transport mechanisms. In particular, we explain how the resistivity can be proportional to the rate of momentum-conserving collisions. We compare this result with existing transport mysteries, including the disorder-independent $T^2$ resistivity of many Fermi liquids, and the linear-in-$T$ "Planckian-limited" resistivity of many strange metals. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2018; v1 submitted 14 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: 1+37+15 pages; 9 figures. v2: minor changes. v3: published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 97, 045105 (2018)

An upper bound on transport

Authors: Thomas Hartman, Sean A. Hartnoll, Raghu Mahajan

Abstract: The linear growth of operators in local quantum systems leads to an effective lightcone even if the system is non-relativistic. We show that consistency of diffusive transport with this lightcone places an upper bound on the diffusivity: $D \lesssim v^2 τ_\text{eq}$. The operator growth velocity $v$ defines the lightcone and $τ_\text{eq}$ is the local equilibration timescale, beyond which the dyna… ▽ More The linear growth of operators in local quantum systems leads to an effective lightcone even if the system is non-relativistic. We show that consistency of diffusive transport with this lightcone places an upper bound on the diffusivity: $D \lesssim v^2 τ_\text{eq}$. The operator growth velocity $v$ defines the lightcone and $τ_\text{eq}$ is the local equilibration timescale, beyond which the dynamics of conserved densities is diffusive. We verify that the bound is obeyed in various weakly and strongly interacting theories. In holographic models this bound establishes a relation between the hydrodynamic and leading non-hydrodynamic quasinormal modes of planar black holes. Our bound relates transport data --- including the electrical resistivity and the shear viscosity --- to the local equilibration time, even in the absence of a quasiparticle description. In this way, the bound sheds light on the observed $T$-linear resistivity of many unconventional metals, the shear viscosity of the quark-gluon plasma and the spin transport of unitary fermions. △ Less

Submitted 26 June, 2017; v1 submitted 31 May, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: 6 pages. 1 figure. v2 streamlined and improved presentation

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 141601 (2017)

Resistivity bound for hydrodynamic bad metals

Authors: Andrew Lucas, Sean A. Hartnoll

Abstract: We obtain a rigorous upper bound on the resistivity $ρ$ of an electron fluid whose electronic mean free path is short compared to the scale of spatial inhomogeneities. When such a hydrodynamic electron fluid supports a non-thermal diffusion process -- such as an imbalance mode between different bands -- we show that the resistivity bound becomes $ρ\lesssim A \, Γ$. The coefficient $A$ is independe… ▽ More We obtain a rigorous upper bound on the resistivity $ρ$ of an electron fluid whose electronic mean free path is short compared to the scale of spatial inhomogeneities. When such a hydrodynamic electron fluid supports a non-thermal diffusion process -- such as an imbalance mode between different bands -- we show that the resistivity bound becomes $ρ\lesssim A \, Γ$. The coefficient $A$ is independent of temperature and inhomogeneity lengthscale, and $Γ$ is a microscopic momentum-preserving scattering rate. In this way we obtain a unified and novel mechanism -- without umklapp -- for $ρ\sim T^2$ in a Fermi liquid and the crossover to $ρ\sim T$ in quantum critical regimes. This behavior is widely observed in transition metal oxides, organic metals, pnictides and heavy fermion compounds and has presented a longstanding challenge to transport theory. Our hydrodynamic bound allows phonon contributions to diffusion constants, including thermal diffusion, to directly affect the electrical resistivity. △ Less

Submitted 24 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: 1 + 11 + 9 pages; 1 figure

Journal ref: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 114, 11344 (2017)

Theory of hydrodynamic transport in fluctuating electronic charge density wave states

Authors: Luca V. Delacrétaz, Blaise Goutéraux, Sean A. Hartnoll, Anna Karlsson

Abstract: We describe the collective hydrodynamic motion of an incommensurate charge density wave state in a clean electronic system. Our description simultaneously incorporates the effects of both pinning due to weak disorder and also phase relaxation due to proliferating dislocations. We show that the interplay between these two phenomena has important consequences for charge and momentum transport. For i… ▽ More We describe the collective hydrodynamic motion of an incommensurate charge density wave state in a clean electronic system. Our description simultaneously incorporates the effects of both pinning due to weak disorder and also phase relaxation due to proliferating dislocations. We show that the interplay between these two phenomena has important consequences for charge and momentum transport. For instance, it can lead to metal-insulator transitions. We furthermore identify signatures of fluctuating density waves in frequency and spatially resolved conductivities. Phase disordering is well known to lead to a large viscosity. We derive a precise formula for the phase relaxation rate in terms of the viscosity in the dislocation cores. We thereby determine the viscosity of the superconducting state of BSCCO from the observed melting dynamics of Abrikosov lattices and show that the result is consistent with dissipation into Bogoliubov quasiparticles. △ Less

Submitted 25 September, 2017; v1 submitted 16 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: 1+24+10 pages + refs, 6 figures; v2, extended discussion of phase relaxation; v3, moved detailed discussion of review material to appendices to shorten main text; v4, presentation improved and shortened

Report number: NORDITA-2017-16

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 96, 195128 (2017)

Holographic quantum matter

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Andrew Lucas, Subir Sachdev

Abstract: We present a review of theories of states of quantum matter without quasiparticle excitations. Solvable examples of such states are provided through a holographic duality with gravitational theories in an emergent spatial dimension. We review the duality between gravitational backgrounds and the various states of quantum matter which live on the boundary. We then describe quantum matter at a fixed… ▽ More We present a review of theories of states of quantum matter without quasiparticle excitations. Solvable examples of such states are provided through a holographic duality with gravitational theories in an emergent spatial dimension. We review the duality between gravitational backgrounds and the various states of quantum matter which live on the boundary. We then describe quantum matter at a fixed commensurate density (often described by conformal field theories), and also compressible quantum matter with variable density, providing an extensive discussion of transport in both cases. We present a unified discussion of the holographic theory of transport with memory matrix and hydrodynamic methods, allowing a direct connection to experimentally realized quantum matter. We also explore other important challenges in non-quasiparticle physics, including symmetry broken phases such as superconductors and non-equilibrium dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 20 March, 2018; v1 submitted 21 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 178 pages, 43 figures; Draft of a review article for hep-th and cond-mat readers, comments welcome; (v2) added clarifications and references; expanded version, with exercises, published as a book by MIT Press: https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/holographic-quantum-matter

Bad Metals from Fluctuating Density Waves

Authors: Luca V. Delacrétaz, Blaise Goutéraux, Sean A. Hartnoll, Anna Karlsson

Abstract: Bad metals have a large resistivity without being strongly disordered. In many bad metals the Drude peak moves away from zero frequency as the resistivity becomes large at increasing temperatures. We catalogue the position and width of the `displaced Drude peak' in the observed optical conductivity of several families of bad metals, showing that $ω_\text{peak} \sim Δω\sim k_BT/\hbar$. This is the… ▽ More Bad metals have a large resistivity without being strongly disordered. In many bad metals the Drude peak moves away from zero frequency as the resistivity becomes large at increasing temperatures. We catalogue the position and width of the `displaced Drude peak' in the observed optical conductivity of several families of bad metals, showing that $ω_\text{peak} \sim Δω\sim k_BT/\hbar$. This is the same quantum critical timescale that underpins the $T$-linear dc resistivity of many of these materials. We provide a unified theoretical description of the optical and dc transport properties of bad metals in terms of the hydrodynamics of short range quantum critical fluctuations of incommensurate density wave order. Within hydrodynamics, pinned translational order is essential to obtain the nonzero frequency peak. △ Less

Submitted 1 September, 2017; v1 submitted 13 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 8+4+5 pages. 3 figures. v2: references added, discussion improved. v3: presentation revamped to emphasize main points. v4: minor tweaks to presentation and data points for more materials added. v5: minor revised version for SciPost

Report number: SITP 16/24, NORDITA-2016-132

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 3, 025 (2017)

Anomalous Thermal Diffusivity in Underdoped YBa$_2$Cu$_3$O$_{6+x}$

Authors: J. -C. Zhang, E. M. Levenson-Falk, B. J. Ramshaw, D. A. Bonn, R. Liang, W. N. Hardy, S. A. Hartnoll, A. Kapitulnik

Abstract: We present local optical measurements of thermal diffusivity in the $ab$ plane of underdoped YBCO crystals. We find that the diffusivity anisotropy is comparable to reported values of the electrical resistivity anisotropy, suggesting that the anisotropies have the same origin. The anisotropy drops sharply below the charge order transition. We interpret our results through a strong electron-phonon… ▽ More We present local optical measurements of thermal diffusivity in the $ab$ plane of underdoped YBCO crystals. We find that the diffusivity anisotropy is comparable to reported values of the electrical resistivity anisotropy, suggesting that the anisotropies have the same origin. The anisotropy drops sharply below the charge order transition. We interpret our results through a strong electron-phonon scattering picture and find that both electronic and phononic contributions to the diffusivity saturate a proposed bound. Our results suggest that neither well-defined electron nor phonon quasiparticles are present in this material. △ Less

Submitted 15 May, 2017; v1 submitted 18 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Comments: 8 pages + 4 pages supporting information

Matrix Quantum Mechanics from Qubits

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Liza Huijse, Edward A. Mazenc

Abstract: We introduce a transverse field Ising model with order N^2 spins interacting via a nonlocal quartic interaction. The model has an O(N,Z), hyperoctahedral, symmetry. We show that the large N partition function admits a saddle point in which the symmetry is enhanced to O(N). We further demonstrate that this `matrix saddle' correctly computes large N observables at weak and strong coupling. The matri… ▽ More We introduce a transverse field Ising model with order N^2 spins interacting via a nonlocal quartic interaction. The model has an O(N,Z), hyperoctahedral, symmetry. We show that the large N partition function admits a saddle point in which the symmetry is enhanced to O(N). We further demonstrate that this `matrix saddle' correctly computes large N observables at weak and strong coupling. The matrix saddle undergoes a continuous quantum phase transition at intermediate couplings. At the transition the matrix eigenvalue distribution becomes disconnected. The critical excitations are described by large N matrix quantum mechanics. At the critical point, the low energy excitations are waves propagating in an emergent 1+1 dimensional spacetime. △ Less

Submitted 17 August, 2016; originally announced August 2016.

Comments: 28 pages + Appendices and References. 3 Figures

Transport in Chern-Simons-Matter Theories

Authors: Guy Gur-Ari, Sean A. Hartnoll, Raghu Mahajan

Abstract: The frequency-dependent longitudinal and Hall conductivities --- $σ_{xx}$ and $σ_{xy}$ --- are dimensionless functions of $ω/T$ in 2+1 dimensional CFTs at nonzero temperature. These functions characterize the spectrum of charged excitations of the theory and are basic experimental observables. We compute these conductivities for large $N$ Chern-Simons theory with fermion matter. The computation is… ▽ More The frequency-dependent longitudinal and Hall conductivities --- $σ_{xx}$ and $σ_{xy}$ --- are dimensionless functions of $ω/T$ in 2+1 dimensional CFTs at nonzero temperature. These functions characterize the spectrum of charged excitations of the theory and are basic experimental observables. We compute these conductivities for large $N$ Chern-Simons theory with fermion matter. The computation is exact in the 't Hooft coupling $λ$ at $N = \infty$. We describe various physical features of the conductivity, including an explicit relation between the weight of the delta function at $ω= 0$ in $σ_{xx}$ and the existence of infinitely many higher spin conserved currents in the theory. We also compute the conductivities perturbatively in Chern-Simons theory with scalar matter and show that the resulting functions of $ω/T$ agree with the strong coupling fermionic result. This provides a new test of the conjectured 3d bosonization duality. In matching the Hall conductivities we resolve an outstanding puzzle by carefully treating an extra anomaly that arises in the regularization scheme used. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2016; v1 submitted 3 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Comments: 27 pages + appendices

Report number: SU-ITP-16/09

Hydrodynamic theory of quantum fluctuating superconductivity

Authors: Richard A. Davison, Luca V. Delacrétaz, Blaise Goutéraux, Sean A. Hartnoll

Abstract: A hydrodynamic theory of transport in quantum mechanically phase-disordered superconductors is possible when supercurrent relaxation can be treated as a slow process. We obtain general results for the frequency-dependent conductivity of such a regime. With time-reversal invariance, the conductivity is characterized by a Drude-like peak, with width given by the supercurrent relaxation rate. Using t… ▽ More A hydrodynamic theory of transport in quantum mechanically phase-disordered superconductors is possible when supercurrent relaxation can be treated as a slow process. We obtain general results for the frequency-dependent conductivity of such a regime. With time-reversal invariance, the conductivity is characterized by a Drude-like peak, with width given by the supercurrent relaxation rate. Using the memory matrix formalism, we obtain a formula for this width (and hence also the dc resistivity) when the supercurrent is relaxed by short range Coulomb interactions. This leads to a new -- effective field theoretic and fully quantum -- derivation of a classic result on flux flow resistance. With strong breaking of time-reversal invariance, the optical conductivity exhibits what we call a `hydrodynamic supercyclotron' resonance. We obtain the frequency and decay rate of this resonance for the case of supercurrent relaxation due to an emergent Chern-Simons gauge field. The supercurrent decay rate in this `topologically ordered superfluid vortex liquid' is determined by the conductivities of the normal component of the liquid. Our work gives a controlled framework for low temperature metallic phases arising from phase-disordered superconductivity. △ Less

Submitted 2 August, 2017; v1 submitted 25 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Comments: 1 + 44 pages. 2 figures. v2 discussion improved in places. v3 sign errors fixed in section 4

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 94, 054502 (2016)

Entropy production, viscosity bounds and bumpy black holes

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, David M. Ramirez, Jorge E. Santos

Abstract: The ratio of shear viscosity to entropy density, $η/s$, is computed in various holographic geometries that break translation invariance (but are isotropic). The shear viscosity does not have a hydrodynamic interpretation in such backgrounds, but does quantify the rate of entropy production due to a strain. Fluctuations of the metric components $δg_{xy}$ are massive about these backgrounds, leading… ▽ More The ratio of shear viscosity to entropy density, $η/s$, is computed in various holographic geometries that break translation invariance (but are isotropic). The shear viscosity does not have a hydrodynamic interpretation in such backgrounds, but does quantify the rate of entropy production due to a strain. Fluctuations of the metric components $δg_{xy}$ are massive about these backgrounds, leading to $η/s < 1/(4π)$ at all finite temperatures (even in Einstein gravity). As the temperature is taken to zero, different behaviors are possible. If translation symmetry breaking is irrelevant in the far IR, then $η/s$ tends to a constant at $T=0$. This constant can be parametrically small. If the translation symmetry is broken in the far IR (which nonetheless develops emergent scale invariance), then $η/s \sim T^{2 ν}$ as $T \to 0$, with $ν\leq 1$ in all cases we have considered. While these results violate simple bounds on $η/s$, we note that they are consistent with a possible bound on the rate of entropy production due to strain. △ Less

Submitted 5 February, 2016; v1 submitted 12 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Comments: 1 + 22 pages + appendices. 7 figures. v2 references added

Thermal conductivity at a disordered quantum critical point

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, David M. Ramirez, Jorge E. Santos

Abstract: Strongly disordered and strongly interacting quantum critical points are difficult to access with conventional field theoretic methods. They are, however, both experimentally important and theoretically interesting. In particular, they are expected to realize universal incoherent transport. Such disordered quantum critical theories have recently been constructed holographically by deforming a CFT… ▽ More Strongly disordered and strongly interacting quantum critical points are difficult to access with conventional field theoretic methods. They are, however, both experimentally important and theoretically interesting. In particular, they are expected to realize universal incoherent transport. Such disordered quantum critical theories have recently been constructed holographically by deforming a CFT by marginally relevant disorder. In this paper we find additional disordered fixed points via relevant disordered deformations of a holographic CFT. Using recently developed methods in holographic transport, we characterize the thermal conductivity in both sets of theories in 1+1 dimensions. The thermal conductivity is found to tend to a constant at low temperatures in one class of fixed points, and to scale as $T^{0.3}$ in the other. Furthermore, in all cases the thermal conductivity exhibits discrete scale invariance, with logarithmic in temperature oscillations superimposed on the low temperature scaling behavior. At no point do we use the replica trick. △ Less

Submitted 18 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Comments: 1+28 pages. 6 figures

Incoherent transport in clean quantum critical metals

Authors: Richard A. Davison, Blaise Goutéraux, Sean A. Hartnoll

Abstract: In a clean quantum critical metal, and in the absence of umklapp, most d.c. conductivities are formally infinite due to momentum conservation. However, there is a particular combination of the charge and heat currents which has a finite, universal conductivity. In this paper, we describe the physics of this conductivity $σ_Q$ in quantum critical metals obtained by charge doping a strongly interact… ▽ More In a clean quantum critical metal, and in the absence of umklapp, most d.c. conductivities are formally infinite due to momentum conservation. However, there is a particular combination of the charge and heat currents which has a finite, universal conductivity. In this paper, we describe the physics of this conductivity $σ_Q$ in quantum critical metals obtained by charge doping a strongly interacting conformal field theory. We show that it satisfies an Einstein relation and controls the diffusivity of a conserved charge in the metal. We compute $σ_Q$ in a class of theories with holographic gravitational duals. Finally, we show how the temperature scaling of $σ_Q$ depends on certain critical exponents characterizing the quantum critical metal. The holographic results are found to be reproduced by the scaling analysis, with the charge density operator becoming marginal in the emergent low energy quantum critical theory. △ Less

Submitted 25 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: v1: 1 + 16 pages + references

Report number: SU-ITP-15/11

Journal ref: JHEP 1510 (2015) 112

Entanglement entropy in two dimensional string theory

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Edward Mazenc

Abstract: To understand an emergent spacetime is to understand the emergence of locality. Entanglement entropy is a powerful diagnostic of locality, because locality leads to a large amount of short distance entanglement. Two dimensional string theory is among the very simplest instances of an emergent spatial dimension. We compute the entanglement entropy in the large $N$ matrix quantum mechanics dual to t… ▽ More To understand an emergent spacetime is to understand the emergence of locality. Entanglement entropy is a powerful diagnostic of locality, because locality leads to a large amount of short distance entanglement. Two dimensional string theory is among the very simplest instances of an emergent spatial dimension. We compute the entanglement entropy in the large $N$ matrix quantum mechanics dual to two dimensional string theory, in the semiclassical limit of weak string coupling. We isolate a logarithmically large, but finite, contribution that corresponds to the short distance entanglement of the tachyon field in the emergent spacetime. From the spacetime point of view, the entanglement is regulated by a nonperturbative `graininess' of space. △ Less

Submitted 29 April, 2015; originally announced April 2015.

Comments: 1+15 pages

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 121602 (2015)

Emergent scale invariance of disordered horizons

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, David M. Ramirez, Jorge E. Santos

Abstract: We construct planar black hole solutions in AdS_3 and AdS_4 in which the boundary CFT is perturbed by marginally relevant quenched disorder. We show that the entropy density of the horizon has the scaling temperature dependence s \sim T^{(d-1)/z} (with d=2,3). The dynamical critical exponent z is computed numerically and, at weak disorder, analytically. These results lend support to the claim that… ▽ More We construct planar black hole solutions in AdS_3 and AdS_4 in which the boundary CFT is perturbed by marginally relevant quenched disorder. We show that the entropy density of the horizon has the scaling temperature dependence s \sim T^{(d-1)/z} (with d=2,3). The dynamical critical exponent z is computed numerically and, at weak disorder, analytically. These results lend support to the claim that the perturbed CFT flows to a disordered quantum critical theory in the IR. △ Less

Submitted 13 April, 2015; originally announced April 2015.

Comments: 1+22 pages. 4 figures

Scaling theory of the cuprate strange metals

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Andreas Karch

Abstract: We show that the anomalous temperature scaling of five distinct transport quantities in the strange metal regime of the cuprate superconductors can be reproduced with only two nontrivial critical exponents. The quantities are: (i) the electrical resistivity, (ii) the Hall angle, (iii) the Hall Lorenz ratio, (iv) the magnetoresistance and (v) the thermopower. The exponents are the dynamical critica… ▽ More We show that the anomalous temperature scaling of five distinct transport quantities in the strange metal regime of the cuprate superconductors can be reproduced with only two nontrivial critical exponents. The quantities are: (i) the electrical resistivity, (ii) the Hall angle, (iii) the Hall Lorenz ratio, (iv) the magnetoresistance and (v) the thermopower. The exponents are the dynamical critical exponent z = 4/3 and an anomalous scaling dimension Phi = -2/3 for the charge density operator. △ Less

Submitted 27 January, 2015; v1 submitted 13 January, 2015; originally announced January 2015.

Comments: 1 + 15 pages + references. 1 figure. v2 improved discussion, references added

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 91, 155126 (2015)

Large N matrices from a nonlocal spin system

Authors: Dionysios Anninos, Sean A. Hartnoll, Liza Huijse, Victoria L. Martin

Abstract: Large N matrices underpin the best understood models of emergent spacetime. We suggest that large N matrices can themselves be emergent from simple quantum mechanical spin models with finite dimensional Hilbert spaces. We exhibit the emergence of large N matrices in a nonlocal statistical physics model of order N^2 Ising spins. The spin partition function is shown to admit a large N saddle describ… ▽ More Large N matrices underpin the best understood models of emergent spacetime. We suggest that large N matrices can themselves be emergent from simple quantum mechanical spin models with finite dimensional Hilbert spaces. We exhibit the emergence of large N matrices in a nonlocal statistical physics model of order N^2 Ising spins. The spin partition function is shown to admit a large N saddle described by a matrix integral, which we solve. The matrix saddle is dominant at high temperatures, metastable at intermediate temperatures and ceases to exist below a critical order one temperature. The matrix saddle is disordered in a sense we make precise and competes with ordered low energy states. We verify our analytic results by Monte Carlo simulation of the spin system. △ Less

Submitted 2 December, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Comments: 25 pages, 6 figures, 1 appendix

Holographic mutual information and distinguishability of Wilson loop and defect operators

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Raghu Mahajan

Abstract: The mutual information of disconnected regions in large $N$ gauge theories with holographic gravity duals can undergo phase transitions. These occur when connected and disconnected bulk Ryu-Takayanagi surfaces exchange dominance. That is, the bulk `soap bubble' snaps as the boundary regions are drawn apart. We give a gauge-theoretic characterization of this transition: States with and without a ce… ▽ More The mutual information of disconnected regions in large $N$ gauge theories with holographic gravity duals can undergo phase transitions. These occur when connected and disconnected bulk Ryu-Takayanagi surfaces exchange dominance. That is, the bulk `soap bubble' snaps as the boundary regions are drawn apart. We give a gauge-theoretic characterization of this transition: States with and without a certain defect operator insertion -- the defect separates the entangled spatial regions -- are shown to be perfectly distinguishable if and only if the Ryu-Takayanagi surface is connected. Meanwhile, states with and without a certain Wilson loop insertion -- the Wilson loop nontrivially threads the spatial regions -- are perfectly distinguishable if and only if the Ryu-Takayanagi surface is disconnected. The quantum relative entropy of two perfectly distinguishable states is infinite. The results are obtained by relating the soap bubble transition to Hawking-Page (deconfinement) transitions in the Renyi entropies, where defect operators and Wilson loops are known to act as order parameters. △ Less

Submitted 30 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: 1+21 pages. 11 figures

Theory of universal incoherent metallic transport

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll

Abstract: In an incoherent metal, transport is controlled by the collective diffusion of energy and charge rather than by quasiparticle or momentum relaxation. We explore the possibility of a universal bound $D \gtrsim \hbar v_F^2/(k_B T)$ on the underlying diffusion constants in an incoherent metal. Such a bound is loosely motivated by results from holographic duality, the uncertainty principle and from me… ▽ More In an incoherent metal, transport is controlled by the collective diffusion of energy and charge rather than by quasiparticle or momentum relaxation. We explore the possibility of a universal bound $D \gtrsim \hbar v_F^2/(k_B T)$ on the underlying diffusion constants in an incoherent metal. Such a bound is loosely motivated by results from holographic duality, the uncertainty principle and from measurements of diffusion in strongly interacting non-metallic systems. Metals close to saturating this bound are shown to have a linear in temperature resistivity with an underlying dissipative timescale matching that recently deduced from experimental data on a wide range of metals. This bound may be responsible for the ubiquitous appearance of high temperature regimes in metals with $T$-linear resistivity, motivating direct probes of diffusive processes and measurements of charge susceptibilities. △ Less

Submitted 23 July, 2014; v1 submitted 14 May, 2014; originally announced May 2014.

Comments: 1+17 pages + references. 2 figures, v2 minor improvements to discussion, v3 improved presentation and discussion

Cold planar horizons are floppy

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Jorge E. Santos

Abstract: Extremal planar black holes of four dimensional Einstein-Maxwell theory with a negative cosmological constant have an AdS$_2 \times \R^2$ near horizon geometry. We show that this near horizon geometry admits a deformation to a two parameter family of extremal geometries with inhomogeneous, spatially periodic horizons. At a linear level, static inhomogeneous perturbations of AdS$_2 \times \R^2$ dec… ▽ More Extremal planar black holes of four dimensional Einstein-Maxwell theory with a negative cosmological constant have an AdS$_2 \times \R^2$ near horizon geometry. We show that this near horizon geometry admits a deformation to a two parameter family of extremal geometries with inhomogeneous, spatially periodic horizons. At a linear level, static inhomogeneous perturbations of AdS$_2 \times \R^2$ decay towards the horizon and thus appear irrelevant under the holographic RG flow. However we have found numerically that nonlinear effects lead to inhomogeneous near horizon geometries. A consequence of these observations is that an arbitrarily small periodic deformation of the boundary theory at nonzero charge density does not flow to AdS$_2 \times \R^2$ in the IR, but rather to an inhomogeneous horizon. These results shed light on existing numerical studies of low temperature periodically modulated black holes and also offer a new mechanism for holographic metal-insulator crossovers or transitions. △ Less

Submitted 3 April, 2014; v1 submitted 18 March, 2014; originally announced March 2014.

Comments: 1+16 pages. 6 figures. v2 incorrect perturbative argument removed

Disordered horizons: Holography of randomly disordered fixed points

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Jorge E. Santos

Abstract: We deform conformal field theories with classical gravity duals by marginally relevant random disorder. We show that the disorder generates a flow to IR fixed points with a finite amount of disorder. The randomly disordered fixed points are characterized by a dynamical critical exponent $z>1$ that we obtain both analytically (via resummed perturbation theory) and numerically (via a full simulation… ▽ More We deform conformal field theories with classical gravity duals by marginally relevant random disorder. We show that the disorder generates a flow to IR fixed points with a finite amount of disorder. The randomly disordered fixed points are characterized by a dynamical critical exponent $z>1$ that we obtain both analytically (via resummed perturbation theory) and numerically (via a full simulation of the disorder). The IR dynamical critical exponent increases with the magnitude of disorder, probably tending to $z \to \infty$ in the limit of infinite disorder. △ Less

Submitted 12 February, 2014; v1 submitted 4 February, 2014; originally announced February 2014.

Comments: v2: typos fixed, refs added, 19 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 231601 (2014)

Transport near the Ising-nematic quantum critical point of metals in two dimensions

Authors: Sean A. Hartnoll, Raghu Mahajan, Matthias Punk, Subir Sachdev

Abstract: We consider two-dimensional metals near a Pomeranchuk instability which breaks 90$^\circ$ lattice rotation symmetry. Such metals realize strongly-coupled non-Fermi liquids with critical fluctuations of an Ising-nematic order. At low temperatures, impurity scattering provides the dominant source of momentum relaxation, and hence a non-zero electrical resistivity. We use the memory matrix method to… ▽ More We consider two-dimensional metals near a Pomeranchuk instability which breaks 90$^\circ$ lattice rotation symmetry. Such metals realize strongly-coupled non-Fermi liquids with critical fluctuations of an Ising-nematic order. At low temperatures, impurity scattering provides the dominant source of momentum relaxation, and hence a non-zero electrical resistivity. We use the memory matrix method to compute the resistivity of this non-Fermi liquid to second order in the impurity potential, without assuming the existence of quasiparticles. Impurity scattering in the $d$-wave channel acts as a random "field" on the Ising-nematic order. We find contributions to the resistivity with a nearly linear temperature dependence, along with more singular terms; the most singular is the random-field contribution which diverges in the limit of zero temperature. △ Less

Submitted 2 April, 2014; v1 submitted 27 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Comments: 31 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 89, 155130 (2014)