-
Taxonomy of branes in infinite distance limits
Authors:
Muldrow Etheredge
Abstract:
I consider flat slices of moduli spaces where the $(-\nabla \log T)$-vectors of particle-towers and branes are constant, and I show that the Emergent String Conjecture constrains these vectors to reside on lattices. In asymptotic limits, this results in exponentially separated, discretized hierarchies of energy scales. I further identify conditions that determine whether a given lattice site must…
▽ More
I consider flat slices of moduli spaces where the $(-\nabla \log T)$-vectors of particle-towers and branes are constant, and I show that the Emergent String Conjecture constrains these vectors to reside on lattices. In asymptotic limits, this results in exponentially separated, discretized hierarchies of energy scales. I further identify conditions that determine whether a given lattice site must be populated, and I show that only a finite set of configurations satisfies these conditions. I classify all such configurations for 0d, 1d, and 2d moduli spaces in theories with 3 to 11 spacetime dimensions, and I argue that 11d is the maximal spacetime dimension compatible with my assumptions. Remarkably, this classification reproduces the detailed particle and brane content of various string theory examples with 32, 16, and 8 supercharges. It also describes some examples where the assumptions I use are violated, suggesting that my assumptions can be relaxed and the scope of this classification can be expanded. It might also predict new branes. For instance, if heterotic string theory is described by this classification, then it must possess non-BPS branes with D-brane-like tensions. Similarly, if this classification applies to the Dark Dimension Scenario with an extra modulus, then it requires the existence of strings with tensions related to the cosmological constant by $T\lesssim Λ^{1/6}$ in 4d Planck units.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2025; v1 submitted 15 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Confined monopoles and failure of the Lattice Weak Gravity Conjecture
Authors:
Muldrow Etheredge,
Ben Heidenreich,
Nicholas Pittman,
Sebastian Rauch,
Matthew Reece,
Tom Rudelius
Abstract:
Almost all known theories of quantum gravity satisfy the Lattice Weak Gravity Conjecture (LWGC), which posits that a consistent theory of quantum gravity must have a superextremal particle at every site in the charge lattice. However, a number of theories have been observed to violate the LWGC; such theories exhibit only a (finite index) sublattice of superextremal particles. This paper aims to id…
▽ More
Almost all known theories of quantum gravity satisfy the Lattice Weak Gravity Conjecture (LWGC), which posits that a consistent theory of quantum gravity must have a superextremal particle at every site in the charge lattice. However, a number of theories have been observed to violate the LWGC; such theories exhibit only a (finite index) sublattice of superextremal particles. This paper aims to identify universal features and patterns associated with LWGC violation across numerous examples in effective field theory, string theory, and M-theory. Some of these examples have appeared previously in the literature, while others are novel. In all such examples, we observe that LWGC failure is accompanied by the existence of fractionally charged monopoles confined by flux tubes, where superextremal particles exist everywhere in the sublattice dual to the superlattice of fractional confined monopole charges. The confining flux tubes become light when the failure of the LWGC becomes more extreme, so monopoles deconfine in the limit where LWGC-violating particles become infinitely massive. We also identify similarities between these confined monopoles, non-invertible symmetries, and the Hanany-Witten effect.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
A Distance Conjecture for Branes
Authors:
Muldrow Etheredge,
Ben Heidenreich,
Tom Rudelius
Abstract:
We use branes to generalize the Distance Conjecture. We conjecture that in any infinite-distance limit in the moduli space of a $d$-dimensional quantum gravity theory, among the set of particle towers and fundamental branes with at most $p_\text{max}\leq d-2$ spacetime dimensions, at least one has mass/tension decreasing exponentially $T\sim \exp(-αΔ)$ with the moduli space distance $Δ$ at a rate…
▽ More
We use branes to generalize the Distance Conjecture. We conjecture that in any infinite-distance limit in the moduli space of a $d$-dimensional quantum gravity theory, among the set of particle towers and fundamental branes with at most $p_\text{max}\leq d-2$ spacetime dimensions, at least one has mass/tension decreasing exponentially $T\sim \exp(-αΔ)$ with the moduli space distance $Δ$ at a rate of at least $α\geq 1/\sqrt{d-p_\text{max}-1}$. Since $p_\text{max}$ can vary, this represents multiple conditions, where the Sharpened Distance Conjecture is the $p_\text{max}=1$ case. This conjecture is a necessary condition imposed on higher-dimensional theories in order for the Sharpened Distance Conjecture to hold in lower-dimensional theories. We test our conjecture in theories with maximal and half-maximal supersymmetry in diverse dimensions, finding that it is satisfied and often saturated. In some cases where it is saturated -- most notably, heterotic string theory in 10 dimensions -- we argue that novel, low-tension non-supersymmetric branes must exist. We also identify patterns relating the rates at which various brane tensions vary in infinite-distance limits and relate these tensions to the species scale.
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Taxonomy of Infinite Distance Limits
Authors:
Muldrow Etheredge,
Ben Heidenreich,
Tom Rudelius,
Ignacio Ruiz,
Irene Valenzuela
Abstract:
The Emergent String Conjecture constrains the possible types of light towers in infinite-distance limits in quantum gravity moduli spaces. In this paper, we use these constraints to restrict the geometry of the scalar charge-to-mass vectors $(-\vec{\nabla}\log m)$ of the light towers and the analogous vector $(-\vec{\nabla}\logΛ_{\text{QG}})$ of the species scale. We derive taxonomic rules that th…
▽ More
The Emergent String Conjecture constrains the possible types of light towers in infinite-distance limits in quantum gravity moduli spaces. In this paper, we use these constraints to restrict the geometry of the scalar charge-to-mass vectors $(-\vec{\nabla}\log m)$ of the light towers and the analogous vector $(-\vec{\nabla}\logΛ_{\text{QG}})$ of the species scale. We derive taxonomic rules that these vectors must satisfy in each duality frame. Under certain assumptions, this allows us to classify the ways in which different duality frames can fit together globally in the moduli space in terms of a finite list of polytopes. Many of these polytopes arise in known string theory compactifications, while others suggest either undiscovered corners of the landscape or new swampland constraints.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Geodesic Gradient Flows in Moduli Space
Authors:
Muldrow Etheredge,
Ben Heidenreich
Abstract:
Geodesics in moduli spaces of string vacua are important objects in string phenomenology. In this paper, we highlight a simple condition that connects brane tensions, including particle masses, with geodesics in moduli spaces. Namely, when a brane's scalar charge-to-tension ratio vector $-\nabla \log T$ has a fixed length, then the gradient flow induced by the logarithm of the brane's tension is a…
▽ More
Geodesics in moduli spaces of string vacua are important objects in string phenomenology. In this paper, we highlight a simple condition that connects brane tensions, including particle masses, with geodesics in moduli spaces. Namely, when a brane's scalar charge-to-tension ratio vector $-\nabla \log T$ has a fixed length, then the gradient flow induced by the logarithm of the brane's tension is a geodesic. We show that this condition is satisfied in many examples in the string landscape.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Constrained Spin Systems and KNdS Black Holes
Authors:
Vivek Chakrabhavi,
Muldrow Etheredge,
Yue Qiu,
Jennie Traschen
Abstract:
Kerr-Newman de Sitter (KNdS) spacetimes have a rich thermodynamic structure that involves multiple horizons, and so differs in key respects from asymptotically flat or AdS black holes. In this paper, we show that certain features of KNdS spacetimes can be reproduced by a constrained system of $N$ non-interacting spins in a magnetic field. Both the KNdS and spin systems have bounded energy and entr…
▽ More
Kerr-Newman de Sitter (KNdS) spacetimes have a rich thermodynamic structure that involves multiple horizons, and so differs in key respects from asymptotically flat or AdS black holes. In this paper, we show that certain features of KNdS spacetimes can be reproduced by a constrained system of $N$ non-interacting spins in a magnetic field. Both the KNdS and spin systems have bounded energy and entropy, a maximum of the entropy in the interior of the energy range, and a symmetry that maps lower energy states to higher energy states with the same entropy. Consequently, both systems have a temperature that can be positive or negative, where the gravitational temperature is defined analogously to that of the spins. We find that the number of spins $N$ corresponds to $1/Λ$ for black holes with very small charge $q$ and rotation parameter $a$, and scales like $\sqrt{(a^2+q^2)/Λ}$ for larger values of $a$ and $q$. By studying constrained spin systems, we provide insight into the thermodynamics of KNdS spacetimes and its quantum mechanical description.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Dense Geodesics, Tower Alignment, and the Sharpened Distance Conjecture
Authors:
Muldrow Etheredge
Abstract:
The Sharpened Distance Conjecture and Tower Scalar Weak Gravity Conjecture are closely related but distinct conjectures, neither one implying the other. Motivated by examples, I propose that both are consequences of two new conjectures: 1. The infinite distance geodesics passing through an arbitrary point $φ$ in the moduli space populate a dense set of directions in the tangent space at $φ$. 2. Al…
▽ More
The Sharpened Distance Conjecture and Tower Scalar Weak Gravity Conjecture are closely related but distinct conjectures, neither one implying the other. Motivated by examples, I propose that both are consequences of two new conjectures: 1. The infinite distance geodesics passing through an arbitrary point $φ$ in the moduli space populate a dense set of directions in the tangent space at $φ$. 2. Along any infinite distance geodesic, there exists a tower of particles whose scalar-charge-to-mass ratio ($-\nabla \log m$) projection everywhere along the geodesic is greater than or equal to $1/\sqrt{d-2}$. I perform several nontrivial tests of these new conjectures in maximal and half-maximal supergravity examples. I also use the Tower Scalar Weak Gravity Conjecture to conjecture a sharp bound on exponentially heavy towers that accompany infinite distance limits.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Running Decompactification, Sliding Towers, and the Distance Conjecture
Authors:
Muldrow Etheredge,
Ben Heidenreich,
Jacob McNamara,
Tom Rudelius,
Ignacio Ruiz,
Irene Valenzuela
Abstract:
We study towers of light particles that appear in infinite-distance limits of moduli spaces of 9-dimensional $\mathcal{N}=1$ string theories, some of which notably feature decompactification limits with running string coupling. The lightest tower in such decompactification limits consists of the non-BPS Kaluza-Klein modes of Type I$'$ string theory, whose masses depend nontrivially on the moduli o…
▽ More
We study towers of light particles that appear in infinite-distance limits of moduli spaces of 9-dimensional $\mathcal{N}=1$ string theories, some of which notably feature decompactification limits with running string coupling. The lightest tower in such decompactification limits consists of the non-BPS Kaluza-Klein modes of Type I$'$ string theory, whose masses depend nontrivially on the moduli of the theory. We work out the moduli-dependence by explicit computation, finding that despite the running decompactification the Distance Conjecture remains satisfied with an exponential decay rate $α\ge \frac{1}{\sqrt{d-2}}$ in accordance with the sharpened Distance Conjecture. The related sharpened Convex Hull Scalar Weak Gravity Conjecture also passes stringent tests. Our results non-trivially test the Emergent String Conjecture, while highlighting the important subtlety that decompactification can lead to a running solution rather than to a higher-dimensional vacuum.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Branes and symmetries for $\mathcal N=3$ S-folds
Authors:
Muldrow Etheredge,
Iñaki García Etxebarria,
Ben Heidenreich,
Sebastian Rauch
Abstract:
We describe the higher-form and non-invertible symmetries of 4d $\mathcal N= 3$ S-folds using the brane dynamics of their holographic duals. In cases with enhancement to $\mathcal N=4$ supersymmetry, our analysis reproduces the known field theory results of Aharony, Seiberg and Tachikawa, and is compatible with the effective action recently given by Bergman and Hirano. Likewise, for two specific…
▽ More
We describe the higher-form and non-invertible symmetries of 4d $\mathcal N= 3$ S-folds using the brane dynamics of their holographic duals. In cases with enhancement to $\mathcal N=4$ supersymmetry, our analysis reproduces the known field theory results of Aharony, Seiberg and Tachikawa, and is compatible with the effective action recently given by Bergman and Hirano. Likewise, for two specific $\mathcal N=3$ theories for which Zafrir has conjectured $\mathcal N=1$ Lagrangians our results agree with those implied by the Lagrangian description. In all other cases, our results imply novel predictions about the symmetries of the corresponding $\mathcal N=3$ field theories.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Derivative Corrections to Extremal Black Holes with Moduli
Authors:
Muldrow Etheredge,
Ben Heidenreich
Abstract:
We derive formulas for the leading mass, entropy, and long-range self-force corrections to extremal black holes due to higher-derivative operators. These formulas hold for black holes with arbitrary couplings to gauge fields and moduli, provided that the leading-order solutions are static, spherically-symmetric, extremal, and have nonzero horizon area. To use these formulas, both the leading-order…
▽ More
We derive formulas for the leading mass, entropy, and long-range self-force corrections to extremal black holes due to higher-derivative operators. These formulas hold for black holes with arbitrary couplings to gauge fields and moduli, provided that the leading-order solutions are static, spherically-symmetric, extremal, and have nonzero horizon area. To use these formulas, both the leading-order black hole solution and the higher-derivative effective action must be known, but there is no need to solve the derivative-corrected equations of motion. We demonstrate that the mass, entropy and self-force corrections involve linearly-independent combinations of the higher-derivative couplings at any given point in the moduli space, and comment on their relations to various swampland conjectures.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Sharpening the Distance Conjecture in Diverse Dimensions
Authors:
Muldrow Etheredge,
Ben Heidenreich,
Sami Kaya,
Yue Qiu,
Tom Rudelius
Abstract:
The Distance Conjecture holds that any infinite-distance limit in the scalar field moduli space of a consistent theory of quantum gravity must be accompanied by a tower of light particles whose masses scale exponentially with proper field distance $\Vertφ\Vert$ as $m \sim \exp(- λ\Vertφ\Vert)$, where $λ$ is order-one in Planck units. While the evidence for this conjecture is formidable, there is a…
▽ More
The Distance Conjecture holds that any infinite-distance limit in the scalar field moduli space of a consistent theory of quantum gravity must be accompanied by a tower of light particles whose masses scale exponentially with proper field distance $\Vertφ\Vert$ as $m \sim \exp(- λ\Vertφ\Vert)$, where $λ$ is order-one in Planck units. While the evidence for this conjecture is formidable, there is at present no consensus on which values of $λ$ are allowed. In this paper, we propose a sharp lower bound for the lightest tower in a given infinite-distance limit in $d$ dimensions: $λ\geq 1/\sqrt{d-2}$. In support of this proposal, we show that (1) it is exactly preserved under dimensional reduction, (2) it is saturated in many examples of string/M-theory compactifications, including maximal supergravity in $d= \text{4 - 10}$ dimensions, and (3) it is saturated in many examples of minimal supergravity in $d= \text{4 - 10}$ dimensions, assuming appropriate versions of the Weak Gravity Conjecture. We argue that towers with $λ< 1/\sqrt{d-2}$ discussed previously in the literature are always accompanied by even lighter towers with $λ\geq 1/\sqrt{d-2}$, thereby satisfying our proposed bound. We discuss connections with and implications for the Emergent String Conjecture, the Scalar Weak Gravity Conjecture, the Repulsive Force Conjecture, large-field inflation, and scalar field potentials in quantum gravity. In particular, we argue that if our proposed bound applies beyond massless moduli spaces to scalar fields with potentials, then accelerated cosmological expansion cannot occur in asymptotic regimes of scalar field space in quantum gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
