Showing 1–50 of 104 results for author: Dine, M

Remarks on the Axion Domain Wall Problem

Authors: Michael Dine

Abstract: Theories in which the Peccei-Quinn phase transition occurs after inflation tend to suffer from problematic domain walls. One possible solution involves a small, explicit breaking ot the symmetry. But this raises other potential issues. We review some aspects of axion domain walls, focussing especially on this proposed solution. We argue, in disagreement with some recent literature, that there is l… ▽ More Theories in which the Peccei-Quinn phase transition occurs after inflation tend to suffer from problematic domain walls. One possible solution involves a small, explicit breaking ot the symmetry. But this raises other potential issues. We review some aspects of axion domain walls, focussing especially on this proposed solution. We argue, in disagreement with some recent literature, that there is little axion radiation from the system until the domains actually collapse. The same applies to gravitational waves and electromagnetic radiation. The final stages of the collapse yields small numbers of extremely energetic axions, which interact only rarely with ordinary matter, and are thus relatively harmless. We then note that, if one accepts a remarkable coincidence, this solution can be acceptable. We consider a possible explanation of the required coincidence △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 12 pages

On the Possibility of Demonstrating Confinement in Non-Supersymmetric Theories by Deforming Confining Supersymmetric Theories

Authors: Michael Dine

Abstract: We review arguments that supersymmetric QCD with $N$ colors and $N_f \ge 0$ massive quarks confines. We explain that this remains the case for small soft breakings and small supersymmetric masses for any quarks. These results continue to hold at large $N$. We then consider these theories with large soft breakings -- real QCD -- describing the problem in terms of the direct computation of the linea… ▽ More We review arguments that supersymmetric QCD with $N$ colors and $N_f \ge 0$ massive quarks confines. We explain that this remains the case for small soft breakings and small supersymmetric masses for any quarks. These results continue to hold at large $N$. We then consider these theories with large soft breakings -- real QCD -- describing the problem in terms of the direct computation of the linear potential between a heavy quark and antiquark. We provide naive arguments that confinement persists, and then give a more general treatment. The features required for the naive arguments are generally believed to hold at large $N$. Extending them to finite $N$ requires only mild assumptions. △ Less

Submitted 24 November, 2023; v1 submitted 30 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 13 pages. Various clairifications, improvements added

Challenges to Obtaining Results for Real QCD from SUSY QCD

Authors: Michael Dine, Yan Yu

Abstract: Recently there have been proposals to understand features of QCD such as confinement and chiral symmetry breaking by considering supersymmetric versions of the theory with various patterns of soft breaking. In this note we recall that with small soft breakings, SUSY QCD is suggestive of observed features of real QCD. But we outline some of the challenges to establishing these features of the theor… ▽ More Recently there have been proposals to understand features of QCD such as confinement and chiral symmetry breaking by considering supersymmetric versions of the theory with various patterns of soft breaking. In this note we recall that with small soft breakings, SUSY QCD is suggestive of observed features of real QCD. But we outline some of the challenges to establishing these features of the theory with large soft breakings. It appears difficult to argue for confinement or chiral symmetry breaking; at best, one can say that {\it if} the non-supersymmetric theory does not confine and/or break chiral symmetry, phase transitions would appear inevitable as one increases the soft breakings. We also discuss, at large N, where confinement would imply chiral symmetry breaking, the challenges to establishing confinement. △ Less

Submitted 9 May, 2022; v1 submitted 29 April, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Comments: 21 pages Footnote and references added

Light Quarks at Large $N$

Authors: Daniel Davies, Michael Dine, Benjamin V. Lehmann

Abstract: Lattice gauge theory simulations are our principal probe of the masses of the light quarks. Results from such computations are the primary evidence against the $m_u=0$ solution to the strong CP problem. The large-$N$ approximation offers an independent approach to light quarks. We extend existing literature, noting that one can determine the parameters of the non-linear sigma model through second… ▽ More Lattice gauge theory simulations are our principal probe of the masses of the light quarks. Results from such computations are the primary evidence against the $m_u=0$ solution to the strong CP problem. The large-$N$ approximation offers an independent approach to light quarks. We extend existing literature, noting that one can determine the parameters of the non-linear sigma model through second order in quark mass, rule out the $m_u=0$ hypothesis, and make predictions for outputs of lattice calculations and phenomenological fits. A crucial feature of this analysis is a Wilsonian effective action at scales above the $η^\prime$ mass. One can self-consistently test the validity of aspects of this framework, and it may well be good to the part-in-three level. We also note consistency with some phenomenological fits and existing lattice results. △ Less

Submitted 1 February, 2022; v1 submitted 14 January, 2022; originally announced January 2022.

Comments: 21 pages, no figures. Contribution to a Festschrift in honor of Peter Suranyi

Low Energy Effective Theory for Axion Strings

Authors: Michael Dine

Abstract: We consider aspects of the low energy description of global cosmic strings. In the non-relativistic limit, we study the extent to which these are described by the combination of the Nambu-Gotto and Kalb-Ramond actions. While in a formal sense this is the case for infiniately long strings, for more realistic situations, the collective coordinates of the system do not provide a complete description… ▽ More We consider aspects of the low energy description of global cosmic strings. In the non-relativistic limit, we study the extent to which these are described by the combination of the Nambu-Gotto and Kalb-Ramond actions. While in a formal sense this is the case for infiniately long strings, for more realistic situations, the collective coordinates of the system do not provide a complete description for more than brief intervals; as time evolves it becomes necessary to include low momentum goldstone excitations as well. △ Less

Submitted 8 August, 2022; v1 submitted 21 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: 11 pages Reference corrected, comments added to clarify that the focus is on the classical effective field theory; matching to simulations would be of interest but is not the subject here

Comments on the Transplanckian Censorship Conjecture

Authors: Michael Dine, Yan Yu

Abstract: We consider some aspects of the Transplanckian Censorship Conjecture, which states that for theories of quantum gravity which yield a quintessence universe, there is a limit on the lifetime of the state not too different than the current Hubble horizon. We consider some aspects of tunneling in the presence of time-varying fields, and note that lifetimes can be parameterically quite large. We consi… ▽ More We consider some aspects of the Transplanckian Censorship Conjecture, which states that for theories of quantum gravity which yield a quintessence universe, there is a limit on the lifetime of the state not too different than the current Hubble horizon. We consider some aspects of tunneling in the presence of time-varying fields, and note that lifetimes can be parameterically quite large. We consider what it might mean to find a quintessence potential in string theory, and argue that such states are likely to have very long lifetimes. △ Less

Submitted 30 October, 2021; v1 submitted 14 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Comments: 11 pages. References added and repaired

Obstacles to Constructing de Sitter Space in String Theory

Authors: Michael Dine, Jamie A. P. Law-Smith, Shijun Sun, Duncan Wood, Yan Yu

Abstract: There have been many attempts to construct de Sitter space-times in string theory. While arguably there have been some successes, this has proven challenging, leading to the de Sitter swampland conjecture: quantum theories of gravity do not admit stable or metastable de Sitter space. Here we explain that, within controlled approximations, one lacks the tools to construct de Sitter space in string… ▽ More There have been many attempts to construct de Sitter space-times in string theory. While arguably there have been some successes, this has proven challenging, leading to the de Sitter swampland conjecture: quantum theories of gravity do not admit stable or metastable de Sitter space. Here we explain that, within controlled approximations, one lacks the tools to construct de Sitter space in string theory. Such approximations would require the existence of a set of (arbitrarily) small parameters, subject to severe constraints. But beyond this one also needs an understanding of big-bang and big-crunch singularities that is not currently accessible to standard approximations in string theory. The existence or non-existence of metastable de Sitter space in string theory remains a matter of conjecture. △ Less

Submitted 4 February, 2021; v1 submitted 27 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Comments: 20 pages. v2: references added; v3, v4: typos fixed

Behavior of Cross Sections for Large Numbers of Particles

Authors: Michael Dine, Hiren H. Patel, Jaryd F. Ulbricht

Abstract: It has been suggested that scattering cross sections at very high energies for producing large numbers of Higgs particles may exhibit factorial growth, and that curing this growth might be relevant to other questions in the Standard Model. We point out, first, that the question is inherently non-perturbative; low orders in the formal perturbative expansion do not give a good approximation to the s… ▽ More It has been suggested that scattering cross sections at very high energies for producing large numbers of Higgs particles may exhibit factorial growth, and that curing this growth might be relevant to other questions in the Standard Model. We point out, first, that the question is inherently non-perturbative; low orders in the formal perturbative expansion do not give a good approximation to the scattering amplitude for sufficiently large N for any fixed, small value of the coupling. Focusing on $λφ^{4}$ theory, we argue that there may be a systematic approximation scheme for processes where N particles near threshold scatter to produce N particles, and discuss the leading contributions to the scattering amplitude and cross sections in this limit. Scattering amplitudes do not grow as rapidly as in perturbation theory. Additionally, partial and total cross sections do not show factorial growth. In the case of cross sections for $2 \to N$ particles, there is no systematic large N approximation available. That said, we provide evidence that non-perturbatively, there is no factorial growth in partial or total cross sections. △ Less

Submitted 27 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: 22 pages, 3 figures

Remarks on the Debye Length and the Topological Susceptibilty in Non-Abelian Gauge Theory

Authors: Michael Dine, Di Xu

Abstract: We study the Debye mass, $m_D$, and the topological susceptibility, $χ$, at high temperatures in non-abelian gauge theory. Both exhibit, at some order in the perturbation expansion, infrared sensitivity. As a result, a perturbative analysis can at best provide an estimate of these quantities, subject to some uncertainty. The size of these uncertainties, particularly in the case of $χ$, has been th… ▽ More We study the Debye mass, $m_D$, and the topological susceptibility, $χ$, at high temperatures in non-abelian gauge theory. Both exhibit, at some order in the perturbation expansion, infrared sensitivity. As a result, a perturbative analysis can at best provide an estimate of these quantities, subject to some uncertainty. The size of these uncertainties, particularly in the case of $χ$, has been the subject of some debate. For the perturbative free energy, reframing an analysis of Braaten and Pisarski, the estimate and the associated error, can be understood in terms of a {\it Wilsonian} effective action for the low energy effective three dimensional theory. This action can be obtained completely from a perturbative calculation, which terminates at a finite order. This action provides the desired estimate. The size of the error follows from dimensional analysis in the low energy theory. The Debye length computation and its error can be obtained from a similar study of a non-relativistic effective theory for an adjoint scalar in three dimensions. $χ$ requires a four dimensional analysis involving finite temperature instantons, but again the dominant sources of uncertainty are three dimensional, and we provide a procedure to estimate and an associated error. This uncertainty is of order $g^4 $ relative to the leading semiclassical result, and in situations of interest is small. △ Less

Submitted 27 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Comments: 19 pages, 6 figures

Report number: SCIPP 18/02

Some Remarks on Anthropic Approaches to the Strong CP Problem

Authors: Michael Dine, Laurel Stephenson Haskins, Lorenzo Ubaldi, Di Xu

Abstract: The peculiar value of $θ$ is a challenge to the notion of an anthropic landscape. We briefly review the possibility that a suitable axion might arise from an anthropic requirement of dark matter. We then consider an alternative suggestion of Kaloper and Terning that $θ$ might be correlated with the cosmological constant. We note that in a landscape one expects that $θ$ is determined by the expecta… ▽ More The peculiar value of $θ$ is a challenge to the notion of an anthropic landscape. We briefly review the possibility that a suitable axion might arise from an anthropic requirement of dark matter. We then consider an alternative suggestion of Kaloper and Terning that $θ$ might be correlated with the cosmological constant. We note that in a landscape one expects that $θ$ is determined by the expectation value of one or more axions. We discuss how a discretuum of values of $θ$ might arise with an energy distribution dominated by QCD, and find the requirements to be quite stringent. Given such a discretuum, we find limited circumstances where small $θ$ might be selected by anthropic requirements on the cosmological constant. △ Less

Submitted 17 May, 2018; v1 submitted 10 January, 2018; originally announced January 2018.

Comments: 18 pages, 2 figures

Report number: SCIPP 18/01

$θ$ and the $η^\prime$ in Large $N$ Supersymmetric QCD

Authors: Michael Dine, Patrick Draper, Laurel Stephenson-Haskins, Di Xu

Abstract: We study the large $N$ $θ$ dependence and the $η^\prime$ potential in supersymmetric QCD with small soft SUSY-breaking terms. Known exact results in SUSY QCD are found to reflect a variety of expectations from large $N$ perturbation theory, including the presence of branches and the behavior of theories with matter (both with $N_f \ll N$ and $N_f \sim N$). However, there are also striking departur… ▽ More We study the large $N$ $θ$ dependence and the $η^\prime$ potential in supersymmetric QCD with small soft SUSY-breaking terms. Known exact results in SUSY QCD are found to reflect a variety of expectations from large $N$ perturbation theory, including the presence of branches and the behavior of theories with matter (both with $N_f \ll N$ and $N_f \sim N$). However, there are also striking departures from ordinary QCD and the conventional large $N$ description: instanton effects, when under control, are not exponentially suppressed at large $N$, and branched structure in supersymmetric QCD is always associated with approximate discrete symmetries. We suggest that these differences motivate further study of large $N$ QCD on the lattice. △ Less

Submitted 21 May, 2017; v1 submitted 17 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 20 pages; v2: references updated; v3: expanded introduction, accepted for publication in JHEP

Light Scalars and the Cosmos: Nambu-Goldstone and Otherwise

Authors: Michael Dine

Abstract: This talk focuses on the role of light scalars in cosmology, both Nambu Goldstone bosons and pseudo moduli. The former include QCD axions, which might constitute the dark matter, and more general axions, which, under certain conditions, might play the role of inflatons, implementing {\it natural inflation}. The latter are the actors in (generalized) hybrid inflation. They rather naturally yield la… ▽ More This talk focuses on the role of light scalars in cosmology, both Nambu Goldstone bosons and pseudo moduli. The former include QCD axions, which might constitute the dark matter, and more general axions, which, under certain conditions, might play the role of inflatons, implementing {\it natural inflation}. The latter are the actors in (generalized) hybrid inflation. They rather naturally yield large field inflation, even mimicking chaotic inflation for suitable ranges of parameters. △ Less

Submitted 25 August, 2016; originally announced August 2016.

Comments: Talk at Nambu Memorial Symposium, 2016; 17 pages

Perturbation Theory in Supersymmetric QED: Infrared Divergences and Gauge Invariance

Authors: Michael Dine, Patrick Draper, Howard E. Haber, Laurel Stephenson Haskins

Abstract: We study some aspects of perturbation theory in $N=1$ supersymmetric abelian gauge theories with massive charged matter. In general gauges, infrared (IR) divergences and nonlocal behavior arise in 1PI diagrams, associated with a $1/k^4$ term in the propagator for the vector superfield. We examine this structure in supersymmetric QED. The IR divergences are gauge-dependent and must cancel in physic… ▽ More We study some aspects of perturbation theory in $N=1$ supersymmetric abelian gauge theories with massive charged matter. In general gauges, infrared (IR) divergences and nonlocal behavior arise in 1PI diagrams, associated with a $1/k^4$ term in the propagator for the vector superfield. We examine this structure in supersymmetric QED. The IR divergences are gauge-dependent and must cancel in physical quantities like the electron pole mass. We demonstrate that cancellation takes place in a nontrivial way, amounting to a reorganization of the perturbative series from powers of $e^2$ to powers of $e$. We also show how these complications are avoided in cases where a Wilsonian effective action can be defined. △ Less

Submitted 23 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: 28 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 94, 095003 (2016)

Classical and Quantum Stability in Putative Landscapes

Authors: Michael Dine

Abstract: Landscape analyses often assume the existence of large numbers of fields, $N$, with all of the many couplings among these fields (subject to constraints such as local supersymmetry) selected independently and randomly from simple (say Gaussian) distributions. We point out that unitarity and perturbativity place significant constraints on behavior of couplings with $N$, eliminating otherwise puzzli… ▽ More Landscape analyses often assume the existence of large numbers of fields, $N$, with all of the many couplings among these fields (subject to constraints such as local supersymmetry) selected independently and randomly from simple (say Gaussian) distributions. We point out that unitarity and perturbativity place significant constraints on behavior of couplings with $N$, eliminating otherwise puzzling results. In would-be flux compactifications of string theory, we point out that in order that there be large numbers of light fields, the compactification radii must scale as a positive power of $N$; scaling of the radii and couplings with $N$ may also be necessary for perturbativity. We show that in some simple string theory settings with large numbers of fields, for fixed $R$ and string coupling, one can bound certain sums of squares of couplings by order one numbers. This may argue for strong correlations, possibly calling into question the assumption of random distributions. We consider implications of these considerations for classical and quantum stability of states without supersymmetry, with low energy supersymmetry arising from tuning of parameters, and with dynamical breaking of supersymmetry. △ Less

Submitted 21 December, 2016; v1 submitted 26 December, 2015; originally announced December 2015.

Comments: 18 pages. Further modifications added in the interest of clarity and precision

Report number: SCIPP 15/15

Strong CP and SUZ$_2$

Authors: Abdelhamid Albaid, Michael Dine, Patrick Draper

Abstract: Solutions to the strong CP problem typically introduce new scales associated with the spontaneous breaking of symmetries. Absent any anthropic argument for small $\barθ$, these scales require stabilization against ultraviolet corrections. Supersymmetry offers a tempting stabilization mechanism, since it can solve the "big" electroweak hierarchy problem at the same time. One family of solutions to… ▽ More Solutions to the strong CP problem typically introduce new scales associated with the spontaneous breaking of symmetries. Absent any anthropic argument for small $\barθ$, these scales require stabilization against ultraviolet corrections. Supersymmetry offers a tempting stabilization mechanism, since it can solve the "big" electroweak hierarchy problem at the same time. One family of solutions to strong CP, including generalized parity models, heavy axion models, and heavy $η^\prime$ models, introduces $\mathbb{Z}_2$ copies of (part of) the Standard Model and an associated scale of $\mathbb{Z}_2$-breaking. We review why, without additional structure such as supersymmetry, the $\mathbb{Z}_2$-breaking scale is unacceptably tuned. We then study "SUZ$_2$" models, supersymmetric theories with $\mathbb{Z}_2$ copies of the MSSM. We find that the addition of SUSY typically destroys the $\mathbb{Z}_2$ protection of $\barθ=0$, even at tree level, once SUSY and $\mathbb{Z}_2$ are broken. In theories like supersymmetric completions of the twin Higgs, where $\mathbb{Z}_2$ addresses the little hierarchy problem but not strong CP, two axions can be used to relax $\barθ$. △ Less

Submitted 20 October, 2015; v1 submitted 12 October, 2015; originally announced October 2015.

Comments: 18 pp, v2: refs added

Tunneling in Theories with Many Fields

Authors: Michael Dine, Sonia Paban

Abstract: The possibility of a landscape of metastable vacua raises the question of what fraction of vacua are truly long lived. Naively any would-be vacuum state has many nearby decay paths, and all possible decays must be suppressed. An interesting model of this phenomena consists of $N$ scalars with a random potential of fourth order. Here we show that the scaling of the typical minimal bounce action wit… ▽ More The possibility of a landscape of metastable vacua raises the question of what fraction of vacua are truly long lived. Naively any would-be vacuum state has many nearby decay paths, and all possible decays must be suppressed. An interesting model of this phenomena consists of $N$ scalars with a random potential of fourth order. Here we show that the scaling of the typical minimal bounce action with $N$ is readily understood, and differs from statements in the literature. We discuss the extension to more realistic landscape models. △ Less

Submitted 15 September, 2015; v1 submitted 21 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: 15 pages References added, some typos fixed

Report number: SCIPP 15/04,UTTG-08-15

Naturalness Under Stress

Authors: Michael Dine

Abstract: Naturalness has for many years been a guiding principle in the search for physics beyond the Standard Model, particularly for understanding the physics of electroweak symmetry breaking. However, the discovery of the Higgs particle at 125 GeV, accompanied by exclusion of many types of new physics expected in natural models has called the principle into question. In addition, apart from the scale of… ▽ More Naturalness has for many years been a guiding principle in the search for physics beyond the Standard Model, particularly for understanding the physics of electroweak symmetry breaking. However, the discovery of the Higgs particle at 125 GeV, accompanied by exclusion of many types of new physics expected in natural models has called the principle into question. In addition, apart from the scale of weak interactions, there are other quantities in nature which appear unnaturally small and for which we have no proposal for a natural explanation.We first review the principle, and then discuss some of the conjectures which it has spawned. We then turn to some of the challenges to the naturalness idea and consider alternatives. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2015; v1 submitted 5 January, 2015; originally announced January 2015.

Comments: Prepared for Annual Review of Nuclear and Particle Science. 34 pages. Some comments added on effective field theories, alternative hierarch solutions

Report number: SCIPP 14/15

Instanton Effects in Three Flavor QCD

Authors: Michael Dine, Patrick Draper, Guido Festuccia

Abstract: Recently it was shown that in QCD-like theories with $N_f > N$, where $N_f$ is the number of light flavors and $N$ is the number of colors, there are correlation functions that vanish in perturbation theory and at short distances receive dominant, calculable contributions from small instantons. Here we extend the set of such objects to theories with $N_f = N$, which includes real QCD, and discuss… ▽ More Recently it was shown that in QCD-like theories with $N_f > N$, where $N_f$ is the number of light flavors and $N$ is the number of colors, there are correlation functions that vanish in perturbation theory and at short distances receive dominant, calculable contributions from small instantons. Here we extend the set of such objects to theories with $N_f = N$, which includes real QCD, and discuss their application as a calibration of lattice computations at small quark mass. We revisit the related issue of the $u$ quark mass and its additive renormalization by small instantons, and discuss an alternative test of $m_u=0$ on the lattice. △ Less

Submitted 11 October, 2015; v1 submitted 30 October, 2014; originally announced October 2014.

Comments: 22 pages, 2 figures. v3: reordered discussion of finite correlators and low energy constants, version published in PRD. v2: amended discussion of calculable vs incalculable effects for $N_f\leq N$

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 92, 054004 (2015)

Hybrid Inflation with Planck Scale Fields

Authors: Michael Dine, Laurel Stephenson-Haskins

Abstract: The BICEP2 observations, if confirmed, point to a high scale of inflation and large field excursions during the inflationary era. Non-compact string moduli spaces are a suggestive setting for these phenomena. While unlikely to be described by weak coupling models, one can write down plausible effective field theories compatible with known features of cosmology. These models can be viewed as genera… ▽ More The BICEP2 observations, if confirmed, point to a high scale of inflation and large field excursions during the inflationary era. Non-compact string moduli spaces are a suggestive setting for these phenomena. While unlikely to be described by weak coupling models, one can write down plausible effective field theories compatible with known features of cosmology. These models can be viewed as generalizations to a large field regime of hybrid inflation. We note close parallels to small and large field axion models. This paper outlines the requirements for successful modular inflation, and gives examples of effective field theories which satisfy them. The required tunings are readily characterized. These models can also be thought of as models of chaotic inflation, in a way we describe. In the modular framework, one would expect that any would-be Peccei-Quinn symmetry would likely be badly broken during inflation, and the axion would have Hubble scale mass; in this situation, isocurvature fluctuations would be suppressed and the initial misalignment angle would be fixed, rather than being a random variable. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 2015; v1 submitted 31 July, 2014; originally announced August 2014.

Comments: 21 pages, latex, citations added; role of BICEP2 in discussion modified in light of joint Planck/BICEP2 analysis. Some clarification as to nature of the models considered, supersymmetric effective action during inflation, additional references

Report number: SCIPP 14/11

Monodromy Inflation in SUSY QCD

Authors: Michael Dine, Patrick Draper, Angelo Monteux

Abstract: The discovery of a large tensor-to-scalar ratio by the BICEP2 experiment points to large field excursions during inflation. One framework that predicts large $r$ is monodromy inflation. While discussed mainly in the context of string theory, the phenomenon can be illustrated and studied in the well-understood framework of SUSY QCD with a large number of colors. We discuss the requirements for viab… ▽ More The discovery of a large tensor-to-scalar ratio by the BICEP2 experiment points to large field excursions during inflation. One framework that predicts large $r$ is monodromy inflation. While discussed mainly in the context of string theory, the phenomenon can be illustrated and studied in the well-understood framework of SUSY QCD with a large number of colors. We discuss the requirements for viable inflation as well as various difficulties for model building, including tunneling, tuning, and the species problem. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2014; originally announced May 2014.

Comments: 15 pages, 1 figure

(Non-)Decoupled Supersymmetric Field Theories

Authors: Lorenzo Di Pietro, Michael Dine, Zohar Komargodski

Abstract: We study some consequences of coupling supersymmetric theories to (super)gravity. To linear order, the couplings are determined by the energy-momentum supermultiplet. At higher orders, the couplings are determined by contact terms in correlation functions of the energy-momentum supermultiplet. We focus on the couplings of one particular field in the supergravity multiplet, the auxiliary field $M$.… ▽ More We study some consequences of coupling supersymmetric theories to (super)gravity. To linear order, the couplings are determined by the energy-momentum supermultiplet. At higher orders, the couplings are determined by contact terms in correlation functions of the energy-momentum supermultiplet. We focus on the couplings of one particular field in the supergravity multiplet, the auxiliary field $M$. We discuss its linear and quadratic (seagull) couplings in various supersymmetric theories. In analogy to the local renormalization group formalism, we provide a prescription for how to fix the quadratic couplings. They generally arise at two-loops in perturbation theory. We check our prescription by explicitly computing these couplings in several examples such as mass-deformed ${\cal N}$ = 4 and in the Coulomb phase of some theories. These couplings affect the Lagrangians of rigid supersymmetric theories in curved space. In addition, our analysis leads to a transparent derivation of the phenomenon known as Anomaly Mediation. In contrast to previous approaches, we obtain both the gaugino and scalar masses of Anomaly Mediation by relying just on classical, minimal supergravity and a manifestly local and supersymmetric Wilsonian point of view. Our discussion naturally incorporates the connection between Anomaly Mediation and supersymmetric $AdS_4$ Lagrangians. This note can be read without prior familiarity with Anomaly Mediated Supersymmetry Breaking (AMSB). △ Less

Submitted 14 February, 2014; originally announced February 2014.

Comments: 35 pages, 3 figures

Planning the Future of U.S. Particle Physics (Snowmass 2013): Chapter 1: Summary

Authors: J. L. Rosner, M. Bardeen, W. Barletta, L. A. T. Bauerdick, R. H. Bernstein, R. Brock, D. Cronin-Hennessy, M. Demarteau, M. Dine, J. L. Feng, M. Gilchriese, S. Gottlieb, N. Graf, N. Hadley, J. L. Hewett, R. Lipton, P. McBride, H. Nicholson, M. E. Peskin, P. Ramond, S. Ritz, I. Shipsey, N. Varelas, H. Weerts, K. Yurkewicz

Abstract: These reports present the results of the 2013 Community Summer Study of the APS Division of Particles and Fields ("Snowmass 2013") on the future program of particle physics in the U.S. Chapter 1 contains the Executive Summary and the summaries of the reports of the nine working groups. These reports present the results of the 2013 Community Summer Study of the APS Division of Particles and Fields ("Snowmass 2013") on the future program of particle physics in the U.S. Chapter 1 contains the Executive Summary and the summaries of the reports of the nine working groups. △ Less

Submitted 23 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Comments: 51 pages

The Future of U.S. Particle Theory: Report of the DPF Theory Panel

Authors: M. Dine, K. Babu, C. Csaki, S. Dawson, L. Dixon, S. Gottlieb, J. Harvey, D. Whiteson

Abstract: This report summarizes the findings of the DPF Theory Panel which was formed with a goal of understanding the scientific problems and opportunities of the next decade, as well as the challenges involved in sustaining a first-class program in theoretical particle physics research in the United States. This report summarizes the findings of the DPF Theory Panel which was formed with a goal of understanding the scientific problems and opportunities of the next decade, as well as the challenges involved in sustaining a first-class program in theoretical particle physics research in the United States. △ Less

Submitted 26 January, 2014; v1 submitted 23 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: 23 pages, LaTeX, Chapter 5 of the report "Planning the Future of U.S. Particle Physics (Snowmass 2013)"

Small Field Inflation and the Spectral Index

Authors: Milton Bose, Michael Dine, Angelo Monteux, Laurel Stephenson Haskins

Abstract: It is sometimes stated that $n_s = 0.98$ in hybrid inflation; sometimes that it predicts $n_s >1$. A number of authors have consider aspects of Planck scale corrections and argued that they affect these predictions. Here we consider these systematically, describing the situations which can yield $n_s =0.96$, and the extent to which this result requires additional tuning. It is sometimes stated that $n_s = 0.98$ in hybrid inflation; sometimes that it predicts $n_s >1$. A number of authors have consider aspects of Planck scale corrections and argued that they affect these predictions. Here we consider these systematically, describing the situations which can yield $n_s =0.96$, and the extent to which this result requires additional tuning. △ Less

Submitted 9 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: 12 pages, 1 figure

Report number: SCIPP 13/15

Anomaly Mediation in Local Effective Theories

Authors: Michael Dine, Patrick Draper

Abstract: The phenomenon known as ``anomaly mediation" can be understood in a variety of ways. Rather than an anomaly, certain gaugino bilinear terms are required by local supersymmetry and gauge invariance (the derivation of these terms is in some cases related to anomalies in scale invariance or $R$ symmetries). We explain why the gaugino bilinear is required in supersymmetric gauge theories with varying… ▽ More The phenomenon known as ``anomaly mediation" can be understood in a variety of ways. Rather than an anomaly, certain gaugino bilinear terms are required by local supersymmetry and gauge invariance (the derivation of these terms is in some cases related to anomalies in scale invariance or $R$ symmetries). We explain why the gaugino bilinear is required in supersymmetric gauge theories with varying number of colors and flavors. By working in the Higgs phase, gauging a flavor group, or working below the scale of gaugino condensation, each of these theories has a local effective description in which we can identify the bilinear term, establishing its necessity in the microscopic theory. For example, in theories that exhibit gaugino condensation, the potential in the very low energy theory is supersymmetric precisely due to the relation between the nonperturbative superpotential and the gaugino bilinear terms. Similarly, the gravitino mass appears from its coupling to the gaugino bilinear. △ Less

Submitted 21 February, 2014; v1 submitted 8 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: 13 pg. v2: minor typos corrected; v3: references added, accepted for publication in JHEP

Moduli or Not

Authors: Milton Bose, Michael Dine, Patrick Draper

Abstract: Supersymmetry and string theory suggest the existence of light moduli. Their presence, or absence, controls the realization of supersymmetry at low energies. If there are no such fields, or if all such fields are fixed in a supersymmetric fashion, the conventional thermal production of LSP dark matter is possible, as is an anomaly-mediated ("mini-split") spectrum. On the other hand, the axion solu… ▽ More Supersymmetry and string theory suggest the existence of light moduli. Their presence, or absence, controls the realization of supersymmetry at low energies. If there are no such fields, or if all such fields are fixed in a supersymmetric fashion, the conventional thermal production of LSP dark matter is possible, as is an anomaly-mediated ("mini-split") spectrum. On the other hand, the axion solution to the strong CP problem is not operative, and slow roll inflation appears difficult to implement. If there are light moduli, a mini-split spectrum is less generic, WIMP dark matter appears atypical, and the supersymmetry scale is likely tens of TeV or higher. △ Less

Submitted 19 July, 2013; v1 submitted 5 May, 2013; originally announced May 2013.

Comments: v2: references added, correction to fig 1, conclusions unchanged. version accepted for publication in PRD

Discrete R Symmetries and Anomalies

Authors: Michael Dine, Angelo Monteux

Abstract: We comment on aspects of discrete anomaly conditions focussing particularly on $R$ symmetries. We review the Green-Schwarz cancellation of discrete anomalies, providing a heuristic explanation why, in the heterotic string, only the "model-independent dilaton" transforms non-linearly under discrete symmetries; this argument suggests that, in other theories, multiple fields might play a role in anom… ▽ More We comment on aspects of discrete anomaly conditions focussing particularly on $R$ symmetries. We review the Green-Schwarz cancellation of discrete anomalies, providing a heuristic explanation why, in the heterotic string, only the "model-independent dilaton" transforms non-linearly under discrete symmetries; this argument suggests that, in other theories, multiple fields might play a role in anomaly cancellations, further weakening any anomaly constraints at low energies. We provide examples in open string theories of non-universal discrete anomalies at low energies. We then consider the fact that $R$ symmetries are necessarily broken at low energies. We exhibit dynamical models, in which fields charged under the Standard Model gauge group (for example, a doublet and a triplet) gain roughly equal masses, but where the doublet and the triplet possess different discrete charges and the low-energy anomaly conditions fail. △ Less

Submitted 10 January, 2014; v1 submitted 18 December, 2012; originally announced December 2012.

Comments: 13 pages; matches version published in JHEP; references added, expanded discussion about anomaly universality and gauge coupling unification

Report number: SCIPP 12/15

Journal ref: JHEP 01 (2014) 011

Discrete Symmetries/Discrete Theories

Authors: Milton Bose, Michael Dine

Abstract: Dynamical, metastable supersymmetry breaking appears to be a generic phenomena in supersymmetric field theories. It's simplest implementation is within the so-called "retrofitted O'Raifeartaigh Models". While seemingly flexible, model building in these theories is significantly constrained. In gauge-mediated versions, if the approximate $R$ symmetry of the theory is spontaneously broken, the messe… ▽ More Dynamical, metastable supersymmetry breaking appears to be a generic phenomena in supersymmetric field theories. It's simplest implementation is within the so-called "retrofitted O'Raifeartaigh Models". While seemingly flexible, model building in these theories is significantly constrained. In gauge-mediated versions, if the approximate $R$ symmetry of the theory is spontaneously broken, the messenger scale is fixed; if explicitly broken by retrofitted couplings, a very small dimensionless number is required; if supergravity corrections are responsible for the symmetry breaking, at least two moderately small couplings are required, and there is a large range of possible messenger scales. In gravity mediated versions, achieving $m_{3/2} \approx M_Z$ is a problem of discrete tuning. With plausible assumptions, one can't achieve this to better than a factor of 100, perhaps accounting for a {\it little hierarchy} and the surprisingly large value of the Higgs mass. △ Less

Submitted 18 December, 2012; originally announced December 2012.

Comments: 15 pages

Report number: SCIPP 12/16

Gravity Mediation Retrofitted

Authors: Milton Bose, Michael Dine

Abstract: Most discussion of metastable dynamical supersymmetry breaking (MDSB) has focussed on low energy breaking, as in gauge mediation. It is of interest to consider possible implications for intermediate scale breaking ("gravity mediation"), especially as the early LHC results suggest the possibility that supersymmetry, if broken at relatively low energies, might be tuned. A somewhat high scale for sus… ▽ More Most discussion of metastable dynamical supersymmetry breaking (MDSB) has focussed on low energy breaking, as in gauge mediation. It is of interest to consider possible implications for intermediate scale breaking ("gravity mediation"), especially as the early LHC results suggest the possibility that supersymmetry, if broken at relatively low energies, might be tuned. A somewhat high scale for susy breaking could ameliorate the usual flavor problems of gravity mediation, resolve the question of cosmological moduli, and account for a Higgs with mass well above $M_Z$. We study MDSB in gravity mediation, especially retrofitted models in which discrete $R$ symmetries play an important role, considering questions including implications of symmetries for $B$ and $A$ terms, and the genericity of split supersymmetry. △ Less

Submitted 6 February, 2013; v1 submitted 12 September, 2012; originally announced September 2012.

Comments: 16 pages. Notational errors fixed, references added

Report number: SCIPP 12/12

Deformed Bubbles and Lorentz Invariance in Vacuum Decay

Authors: Michael Dine, Patrick Draper, Chang-Soon Park

Abstract: Recently, questions have been raised about the role of Lorentz invariance in false vacuum decay. It has been argued that infinities may arise in an integration over Lorentz-boosted final states. This suggestion motivates a Minkowski-space analysis of the decay rate. We attempt to illuminate features of the amplitude computation, and argue that the total rate including excitations is both finite an… ▽ More Recently, questions have been raised about the role of Lorentz invariance in false vacuum decay. It has been argued that infinities may arise in an integration over Lorentz-boosted final states. This suggestion motivates a Minkowski-space analysis of the decay rate. We attempt to illuminate features of the amplitude computation, and argue that the total rate including excitations is both finite and Lorentz invariant. △ Less

Submitted 26 June, 2012; originally announced June 2012.

Comments: 23 pages

Studies in Small Field Inflation

Authors: Michael Dine, Lawrence Pack

Abstract: We explore some issues in slow roll inflation in situations where field excursions are small compared to $M_p$. We argue that for small field inflation, minimizing fine tuning requires low energy supersymmetry and a tightly constrained structure. Hybrid inflation is {\it almost} an inevitable outcome. The resulting theory can be described in terms of a supersymmetric low energy effective action an… ▽ More We explore some issues in slow roll inflation in situations where field excursions are small compared to $M_p$. We argue that for small field inflation, minimizing fine tuning requires low energy supersymmetry and a tightly constrained structure. Hybrid inflation is {\it almost} an inevitable outcome. The resulting theory can be described in terms of a supersymmetric low energy effective action and inflation completely characterized in terms of a small number of parameters. Demanding slow roll inflation significantly constrains these parameters. In this context, the generic level of fine tuning can be described as a function of the number of light fields, there is an upper bound on the scale of inflation, and an (almost) universal prediction for the spectral index. Models of this type need not suffer from a cosmological moduli problem. △ Less

Submitted 28 May, 2012; v1 submitted 9 September, 2011; originally announced September 2011.

Comments: 16 pages. issues with single field inflation identified and clarified; role of discrete R symmetries clarified; error in discussion of a non-hybrid model corrected

Supersymmetric QCD: Exact Results and Strong Coupling

Authors: Michael Dine, Guido Festuccia, Lawrence Pack, Chang-Soon Park, Lorenzo Ubaldi, Weitao Wu

Abstract: We revisit two longstanding puzzles in supersymmetric gauge theories. The first concerns the question of the holomorphy of the coupling, and related to this the possible definition of an exact (NSVZ) beta function. The second concerns instantons in pure gluodynamics, which appear to give sensible, exact results for certain correlation functions, which nonetheless differ from those obtained using s… ▽ More We revisit two longstanding puzzles in supersymmetric gauge theories. The first concerns the question of the holomorphy of the coupling, and related to this the possible definition of an exact (NSVZ) beta function. The second concerns instantons in pure gluodynamics, which appear to give sensible, exact results for certain correlation functions, which nonetheless differ from those obtained using systematic weak coupling expansions. For the first question, we extend an earlier proposal of Arkani-Hamed and Murayama, showing that if their regulated action is written suitably, the holomorphy of the couplings is manifest, and it is easy to determine the renormalization scheme for which the NSVZ formula holds. This scheme, however, is seen to be one of an infinite class of schemes, each leading to an exact beta function; the NSVZ scheme, while simple, is not selected by any compelling physical consideration. For the second question, we explain why the instanton computation in the pure supersymmetric gauge theory is not reliable, even at short distances. The semiclassical expansion about the instanton is purely formal; if infrared divergences appear, they spoil arguments based on holomorphy. We demonstrate that infrared divergences do not occur in the perturbation expansion about the instanton, but explain that there is no reason to think this captures all contributions from the sector with unit topological charge. That one expects additional contributions is illustrated by dilute gas corrections. These are infrared divergent, and so difficult to define, but if non-zero give order one, holomorphic, corrections to the leading result. Exploiting an earlier analysis of Davies et al, we demonstrate that in the theory compactified on a circle of radius beta, due to infrared effects, finite contributions indeed arise which are not visible in the formal limit that beta goes to infinity. △ Less

Submitted 11 April, 2011; v1 submitted 4 April, 2011; originally announced April 2011.

Comments: 28 pages, two references added, one typo corrected

Report number: SCIPP 11/03

Supersymmetry from the Top Down

Authors: Michael Dine

Abstract: If supersymmetry turns out to be a symmetry of nature at low energies, the first order of business to measure the soft breaking parameters. But one will also want to understand the symmetry, and its breaking, more microscopically. Two aspects of this problem constitute the focus of these lectures. First, what sorts of dynamics might account for supersymmetry breaking, and its manifestation at low… ▽ More If supersymmetry turns out to be a symmetry of nature at low energies, the first order of business to measure the soft breaking parameters. But one will also want to understand the symmetry, and its breaking, more microscopically. Two aspects of this problem constitute the focus of these lectures. First, what sorts of dynamics might account for supersymmetry breaking, and its manifestation at low energies. Second, how might these features fit into string theory (or whatever might be the underlying theory in the ultraviolet). The last few years have seen a much improved understanding of the first set of questions, and at least a possible pathway to address the second. △ Less

Submitted 16 February, 2011; originally announced February 2011.

Comments: Lectures for the 2010 TASI summer school

Supersymmetry and Its Dynamical Breaking

Authors: Michael Dine, John D. Mason

Abstract: This article reviews the subject of supersymmetry and its breaking. The emphasis is on recent developments in metastable, dynamical supersymmetry breaking, which permit the construction of promising models of particle physics. This article reviews the subject of supersymmetry and its breaking. The emphasis is on recent developments in metastable, dynamical supersymmetry breaking, which permit the construction of promising models of particle physics. △ Less

Submitted 13 December, 2010; originally announced December 2010.

Comments: Review article prepared for Reports on Progress in Physics, 53 pages

Axions in the Landscape and String Theory

Authors: Michael Dine, Guido Festuccia, John Kehayias, Weitao Wu

Abstract: While axions seem ubiquitous in critical string theories, whether they might survive in any string theoretic description of nature is a difficult question. With some mild assumptions, one can frame the issues in the case that there is an approximate supersymmetry below the underlying string scale. The problem of axions is then closely tied to the question of how moduli are fixed. We consider, from… ▽ More While axions seem ubiquitous in critical string theories, whether they might survive in any string theoretic description of nature is a difficult question. With some mild assumptions, one can frame the issues in the case that there is an approximate supersymmetry below the underlying string scale. The problem of axions is then closely tied to the question of how moduli are fixed. We consider, from this viewpoint, the possibility that supersymmetry is broken at an intermediate scale, as in "gravity mediation," at a low scale, as in gauge mediation, and at a very high scale, to model the possibility that there is no low energy supersymmetry. Putative mechanisms for moduli fixing can then be systematically classified, and at least for intermediate and high scale breaking, light axions appear plausible. In the course of this work, we are lead to consider aspects of moduli fixing and supersymmetry breaking, and we revisit the possibility of very large extra dimensions. △ Less

Submitted 3 November, 2010; v1 submitted 22 October, 2010; originally announced October 2010.

Comments: 18 pages; v2, updated and added references

Report number: SCIPP 10/07

Journal ref: JHEP 1101:012,2011

Discrete R Symmetries and Domain Walls

Authors: Michael Dine, Fuminobu Takahashi, Tsutomu T. Yanagida

Abstract: Discrete R symmetries are interesting from a variety of points of view. They raise the specter, however, of domain walls, which may be cosmologically problematic. In this note, we describe some of the issues. In many schemes for supersymmetry breaking, as we explain, satisfying familiar constraints such as suppression of gravitino production, insures that the domain walls are readily inflated away… ▽ More Discrete R symmetries are interesting from a variety of points of view. They raise the specter, however, of domain walls, which may be cosmologically problematic. In this note, we describe some of the issues. In many schemes for supersymmetry breaking, as we explain, satisfying familiar constraints such as suppression of gravitino production, insures that the domain walls are readily inflated away. However, in others, they form after inflation. In these cases, it is necessary that they annihilate. We discuss possible breaking mechanisms for the discrete symmetries, and the constraints they must satisfy so that the walls annihilate effectively. △ Less

Submitted 20 May, 2010; originally announced May 2010.

Comments: 13 pages

Report number: SCIPP-10/06, IPMU10-0073

Journal ref: JHEP 1007:003,2010

Reliable Semiclassical Computations in QCD

Authors: Michael Dine, Guido Festuccia, Lawrence Pack, Weitao Wu

Abstract: We revisit the question of whether or not one can perform reliable semiclassical QCD computations at zero temperature. We study correlation functions with no perturbative contributions, and organize the problem by means of the operator product expansion, establishing a precise criterion for the validity of a semiclassical calculation. For $N_f>N$, a systematic computation is possible; for… ▽ More We revisit the question of whether or not one can perform reliable semiclassical QCD computations at zero temperature. We study correlation functions with no perturbative contributions, and organize the problem by means of the operator product expansion, establishing a precise criterion for the validity of a semiclassical calculation. For $N_f>N$, a systematic computation is possible; for $N_f<N$, it is not. $N_f=N$ is a borderline case. In our analysis, we see explicitly the exponential suppression of instanton effects at large $N$. As an application, we describe a test of QCD lattice gauge theory computations in the chiral limit. △ Less

Submitted 5 May, 2010; v1 submitted 29 April, 2010; originally announced April 2010.

Comments: 16 pages

Report number: SCIPP-2010/04

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D82:065015,2010

A Bound on the Superpotential

Authors: Michael Dine, Guido Festuccia, Zohar Komargodski

Abstract: We prove a general bound on the superpotential in theories with broken supersymmetry and broken R-symmetry, 2|W|< f_a F, where f_a and F are the R-axion and Goldstino decay constants, respectively. The bound holds for weakly coupled as well as strongly coupled theories, thereby providing an exact result in theories with broken supersymmetry. We briefly discuss several possible applications. We prove a general bound on the superpotential in theories with broken supersymmetry and broken R-symmetry, 2|W|< f_a F, where f_a and F are the R-axion and Goldstino decay constants, respectively. The bound holds for weakly coupled as well as strongly coupled theories, thereby providing an exact result in theories with broken supersymmetry. We briefly discuss several possible applications. △ Less

Submitted 14 October, 2009; originally announced October 2009.

Comments: 20 pages

Journal ref: JHEP 1003:011,2010

Discrete R Symmetries and Low Energy Supersymmetry

Authors: Michael Dine, John Kehayias

Abstract: If nature exhibits low energy supersymmetry, discrete (non-$Z_2$) R symmetries may well play an important role. In this paper, we explore such symmetries. We generalize gaugino condensation, constructing large classes of models which are classically scale invariant, and which spontaneously break discrete R symmetries (but not supersymmetry). The order parameters for the breaking include chiral sin… ▽ More If nature exhibits low energy supersymmetry, discrete (non-$Z_2$) R symmetries may well play an important role. In this paper, we explore such symmetries. We generalize gaugino condensation, constructing large classes of models which are classically scale invariant, and which spontaneously break discrete R symmetries (but not supersymmetry). The order parameters for the breaking include chiral singlets. These simplify construction of models with metastable dynamical supersymmetry breaking. We explain that in gauge mediation, the problem of the cosmological constant makes "retrofitting" particularly natural -- almost imperative. We describe new classes of models, with interesting scales for supersymmetry breaking, and which allow simple solutions of the $μ$ problem. We argue that models exhibiting such R symmetries can readily solve not only the problem of dimension four operators and proton decay, but also dimension five operators. On the other hand, in theories of "gravity mediation", the breaking of R symmetry is typically of order $M_p$, R parity is required to suppress dimension four $B$ and $L$ violating operators, and dimension five operators remain problematic. △ Less

Submitted 18 September, 2010; v1 submitted 8 September, 2009; originally announced September 2009.

Comments: 17 pages, latex; references to earlier work added; typos fixed, minor corrections and revisions, journal version

Report number: SCIPP 09/12

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D82:055014,2010

Axions in Gauge Mediation

Authors: Linda M. Carpenter, Michael Dine, Guido Festuccia, Lorenzo Ubaldi

Abstract: In supersymmetric theories, the presence of axions usually implies the existence of a non-compact, (pseudo)moduli space. In gauge mediated models, the axion would seem a particularly promising dark matter candidate. The cosmology of the moduli then constrains the gravitino mass and the axion decay constant; the former can't be much below 10 MeV; the latter can't be much larger than 10^{13} GeV.… ▽ More In supersymmetric theories, the presence of axions usually implies the existence of a non-compact, (pseudo)moduli space. In gauge mediated models, the axion would seem a particularly promising dark matter candidate. The cosmology of the moduli then constrains the gravitino mass and the axion decay constant; the former can't be much below 10 MeV; the latter can't be much larger than 10^{13} GeV. Axinos, when identifiable, are typically heavy and do not play an important role in cosmology. △ Less

Submitted 14 January, 2010; v1 submitted 26 June, 2009; originally announced June 2009.

Comments: final version published in Phys Rev D, 22 pages, 3 figures

Report number: SCIPP 2009/09

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D80:125023,2009

Dynamics of the Peccei Quinn Scale

Authors: Linda M. Carpenter, Michael Dine, Guido Festuccia

Abstract: Invoking the Peccei-Quinn (PQ) solution to the strong CP problem substitutes the puzzle of why $θ_{qcd}$ is so small with the puzzle of why the PQ symmetry is of such high quality. Cosmological and astrophysical considerations raise further puzzles. This paper explores this issues in several contexts: string theory and field theory, and theories without and with low energy supersymmetry. Among t… ▽ More Invoking the Peccei-Quinn (PQ) solution to the strong CP problem substitutes the puzzle of why $θ_{qcd}$ is so small with the puzzle of why the PQ symmetry is of such high quality. Cosmological and astrophysical considerations raise further puzzles. This paper explores this issues in several contexts: string theory and field theory, and theories without and with low energy supersymmetry. Among the questions studied are whether requiring axion dark matter can account for the quality of the PQ symmetry, to which the answer is sometimes yes. In non-supersymmetric theories, we find $f_a = 10^{12}$ GeV is quite plausible. In gauge mediation, cosmological constraints on pseudomoduli place $f_a$ in this range, and require that the gravitino mass be of order an MeV. △ Less

Submitted 9 July, 2009; v1 submitted 6 June, 2009; originally announced June 2009.

Comments: 17 pages, 1 figure

Report number: SCIPP 2009/05

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D80:125017,2009

The Fate of Nearly Supersymmetric Vacua

Authors: Michael Dine, Guido Festuccia, Alexander Morisse

Abstract: Supersymmetric vacua are stable. It is interesting to ask: how long-lived are vacua which are nearly supersymmetric? This question is relevant if our universe is approximately supersymmetric. It is also of importance for a number of issues of the physics of the landscape and eternal inflation. In this note, we distinguish a variety of cases. In all of them the decay is slow. For a flat space the… ▽ More Supersymmetric vacua are stable. It is interesting to ask: how long-lived are vacua which are nearly supersymmetric? This question is relevant if our universe is approximately supersymmetric. It is also of importance for a number of issues of the physics of the landscape and eternal inflation. In this note, we distinguish a variety of cases. In all of them the decay is slow. For a flat space theory decaying to a deep AdS vacuum, the leading behavior of the decay amplitude, if a thin wall approximation is valid, is ${\cal A} = γe^{-2 π^2/({\rm Re} m_{3/2})^2}$ (where the phase of $m_{3/2}$ is defined in the text) for ${\rm Re} m_{3/2}>0$, and zero otherwise. Metastable supersymmetry breaking generally yields parametrically more rapid decays. For nearly supersymmetric decays, we will see that it is necessary to compute subleading terms in the exponential to extraordinarily high accuracy before one can meaningfully discuss the prefactor. △ Less

Submitted 9 January, 2009; originally announced January 2009.

Comments: 19 pages

Report number: SCIPP-2008/15

Journal ref: JHEP 0909:013,2009

Symmetric Points in the Landscape as Cosmological Attractors

Authors: M. Dine, G. Festuccia, A. Morisse

Abstract: In the landscape, if there is to be any prospect of scientific prediction, it is crucial that there be states which are distinguished in some way. The obvious candidates are states which exhibit symmetries. Here we focus on states which exhibit discrete symmetries. Such states are rare, but one can speculate that they are cosmological attractors. We investigate the problem in model landscapes an… ▽ More In the landscape, if there is to be any prospect of scientific prediction, it is crucial that there be states which are distinguished in some way. The obvious candidates are states which exhibit symmetries. Here we focus on states which exhibit discrete symmetries. Such states are rare, but one can speculate that they are cosmological attractors. We investigate the problem in model landscapes and cosmologies which capture some of the features of candidate flux landscapes. In non-supersymmetric theories we find no evidence that such states might be cosmologically favored. In supersymmetric theories, simple arguments suggest that states which exhibit $R$ symmetries might be. Our considerations lead us to raise questions about some popular models of eternal inflation. △ Less

Submitted 27 September, 2008; v1 submitted 12 September, 2008; originally announced September 2008.

Comments: 27 pages, latex, minor typo corrected

Report number: SCIPP-2008/06

Journal ref: JHEP 0912:013,2009

Implementing General Gauge Mediation

Authors: Linda M. Carpenter, Michael Dine, Guido Festuccia, John D. Mason

Abstract: Recently there has been much progress in building models of gauge mediation, often with predictions different than those of minimal gauge mediation. Meade, Seiberg, and Shih have characterized the most general spectrum which can arise in gauge mediated models. We discuss some of the challenges of building models of General Gauge Mediation, especially the problem of messenger parity and issues co… ▽ More Recently there has been much progress in building models of gauge mediation, often with predictions different than those of minimal gauge mediation. Meade, Seiberg, and Shih have characterized the most general spectrum which can arise in gauge mediated models. We discuss some of the challenges of building models of General Gauge Mediation, especially the problem of messenger parity and issues connected with R symmetry breaking and CP violation. We build a variety of viable, weakly coupled models which exhibit some or all of the possible low energy parameters. △ Less

Submitted 21 May, 2008; v1 submitted 19 May, 2008; originally announced May 2008.

Comments: 21 pages, 2 Figures Minor Corrections

Report number: SCIPP-08/04

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D79:035002,2009

Metastable Domains of the Landscape

Authors: Michael Dine, Guido Festuccia, Alexander Morisse, Korneel van den Broek

Abstract: We argue that the vast majority of flux vacua with small cosmological constant are unstable to rapid decay to a big crunch. Exceptions are states with large compactification volume and supersymmetric and approximately supersymmetric states. Neither weak string coupling, warping, or the existence of very light particles are, by themselves, enough to render states reasonably metastable. We specula… ▽ More We argue that the vast majority of flux vacua with small cosmological constant are unstable to rapid decay to a big crunch. Exceptions are states with large compactification volume and supersymmetric and approximately supersymmetric states. Neither weak string coupling, warping, or the existence of very light particles are, by themselves, enough to render states reasonably metastable. We speculate, as well, about states which might be cosmological attractors. △ Less

Submitted 10 December, 2007; originally announced December 2007.

Comments: 20 pages

Report number: SCIPP 07/17, RUNHETC-2007-24

Journal ref: JHEP0806:014,2008

Comments on Quantum Effects in Supergravity Theories

Authors: Michael Dine, Nathan Seiberg

Abstract: We elucidate the physics underlying ``anomaly mediation'', giving several alternative derivations of the formulas for gaugino and scalar masses. We stress that this phenomenon is of a type familiar in field theory, and does not represent an anomaly, nor does it depend on supersymmetry breaking and its mediation. Analogous phenomena are common in QFT and this particular phenomenon occurs also in… ▽ More We elucidate the physics underlying ``anomaly mediation'', giving several alternative derivations of the formulas for gaugino and scalar masses. We stress that this phenomenon is of a type familiar in field theory, and does not represent an anomaly, nor does it depend on supersymmetry breaking and its mediation. Analogous phenomena are common in QFT and this particular phenomenon occurs also in supersymmetric theories without gravity. △ Less

Submitted 3 January, 2007; originally announced January 2007.

Comments: 21 pages

Report number: SCIPP-2006/14, UCI-TR-2006-14

Journal ref: JHEP 0703:040,2007

IIA moduli stabilization with badly broken supersymmetry

Authors: Michael Dine, Alexander Morisse, Assaf Shomer, Zheng Sun

Abstract: Scherk-Schwarz compactification in string theory can be defined as orbifolding by an R symmetry, a symmetry that acts differently on bosons and fermions. Such a symmetry can arise in many situations, including toroidal and orbifold compactifications, as well as smooth Calabi-Yau spaces. If the symmetry acts freely then for large radius there are no tachyons in the spectrum. We focus mainly on st… ▽ More Scherk-Schwarz compactification in string theory can be defined as orbifolding by an R symmetry, a symmetry that acts differently on bosons and fermions. Such a symmetry can arise in many situations, including toroidal and orbifold compactifications, as well as smooth Calabi-Yau spaces. If the symmetry acts freely then for large radius there are no tachyons in the spectrum. We focus mainly on stabilization by fluxes, and give examples with all moduli stabilized where the coupling is small and the internal manifold is large. Such models appear to be perturbatively stable with supersymmetry broken at the Kaluza-Klein scale. These are interesting laboratories for a variety of theoretical questions and provide models of a non-supersymmetric landscape. △ Less

Submitted 30 December, 2006; v1 submitted 18 December, 2006; originally announced December 2006.

Comments: 18 pages, LATEX, no figures. several refs added to earlier literature on Scherk Schwarz in string theory, discussion of smooth CY made more precise

Journal ref: JHEP0807:070,2008

Gauge Mediation in Metastable Vacua

Authors: Michael Dine, John Mason

Abstract: Until recently, dynamical supersymmetry breaking seemed an exceptional phenomenon, involving chiral gauge theories with a special structure. Recently it has become clear that requiring only metastable states with broken supersymmetry leads to a far broader class of theories. In this paper, we extend these constructions still further, finding new classes which, unlike earlier theories, do not hav… ▽ More Until recently, dynamical supersymmetry breaking seemed an exceptional phenomenon, involving chiral gauge theories with a special structure. Recently it has become clear that requiring only metastable states with broken supersymmetry leads to a far broader class of theories. In this paper, we extend these constructions still further, finding new classes which, unlike earlier theories, do not have unbroken, approximate $R$ symmetries. This allows construction of new models with direct gauge mediation. These theories permit a relatively compact solution to the $μ$ problem. △ Less

Submitted 6 October, 2007; v1 submitted 24 November, 2006; originally announced November 2006.

Comments: 11 pages, latex. Issues of metastability further elaborated

Report number: SCIPP-2006/13

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D77:016005,2008

Retrofitting O'Raifeartaigh Models with Dynamical Scales

Authors: Michael Dine, Jonathan L. Feng, Eva Silverstein

Abstract: We provide a method for obtaining simple models of supersymmetry breaking, with all small mass scales generated dynamically, and illustrate it with explicit examples. We start from models of perturbative supersymmetry breaking, such as O'Raifeartaigh and Fayet models, that would respect an $R$ symmetry if their small input parameters transformed as the superpotential does. By coupling the system… ▽ More We provide a method for obtaining simple models of supersymmetry breaking, with all small mass scales generated dynamically, and illustrate it with explicit examples. We start from models of perturbative supersymmetry breaking, such as O'Raifeartaigh and Fayet models, that would respect an $R$ symmetry if their small input parameters transformed as the superpotential does. By coupling the system to a pure supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory (or a more general supersymmetric gauge theory with dynamically small vacuum expectation values), these parameters are replaced by powers of its dynamical scale in a way that is naturally enforced by the symmetry. We show that supersymmetry breaking in these models may be straightforwardly mediated to the supersymmetric Standard Model, obtain complete models of direct gauge mediation, and comment on related model building strategies that arise in this simple framework. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2006; v1 submitted 23 August, 2006; originally announced August 2006.

Comments: 15 pages, harvmac big

Report number: SU-ITP-06/22,SLAC-PUB-12059,UCI-TR-2006-14

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D74:095012,2006

On Witten's Instability and Winding Tachyons

Authors: Michael Dine, Assaf Shomer, Zheng Sun

Abstract: We investigate, from a spacetime perspective, some aspects of Horowitz's recent conjecture that black strings may catalyze the decay of Kaluza-Klein spacetimes into a bubble of nothing. We identify classical configurations that interpolate between flat space and the bubble, and discuss the energetics of the transition. We investigate the effects of winding tachyons on the size and shape of the b… ▽ More We investigate, from a spacetime perspective, some aspects of Horowitz's recent conjecture that black strings may catalyze the decay of Kaluza-Klein spacetimes into a bubble of nothing. We identify classical configurations that interpolate between flat space and the bubble, and discuss the energetics of the transition. We investigate the effects of winding tachyons on the size and shape of the barrier and find no evidence at large compactification radius that tachyons enhance the tunneling rate. For the interesting radii, of order the string scale, the question is difficult to answer due to the failure of the $α^\prime$ expansion. △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2006; originally announced July 2006.

Comments: 15 pages, 2 figures, Latex

Journal ref: JHEP0612:013,2006