-
A species scale-driven breakdown of effective field theory in time-dependent string backgrounds
Authors:
Alek Bedroya,
Hayden Lee,
Paul Steinhardt
Abstract:
We present a novel way in which effective field theory (EFT) can break down in cosmological string backgrounds depending on the behavior of the quantum gravity cutoff in infinite distance limits, known as the species scale $Λ_s$. Namely, EFT can break down if the species scale $Λ_s$ falls off so rapidly as the Friedmann-Robertson-Walker (FRW) scale factor grows from some initial value $a_i$ to som…
▽ More
We present a novel way in which effective field theory (EFT) can break down in cosmological string backgrounds depending on the behavior of the quantum gravity cutoff in infinite distance limits, known as the species scale $Λ_s$. Namely, EFT can break down if the species scale $Λ_s$ falls off so rapidly as the Friedmann-Robertson-Walker (FRW) scale factor grows from some initial value $a_i$ to some final value $a_f$ that the physical momentum of an initial Hubble-sized perturbation $\sim H_i^{-1}$ grows to exceed the species scale. For EFT to remain valid, a new condition $H_i \frac{a_i}{a_f} \ll Λ_{s,f}$ must hold, which is distinct from Trans-Planckian conditions discussed in the literature. Using the universal relation $\frac{\nabla m}{m} \cdot \frac{\nabla Λ_s}{Λ_s} = \frac{1}{d-2}$ in the infinite distance limits of moduli space where $m$ is the mass scale of the lightest tower and $\nabla$ measures variations with respect to the canonical metric on moduli space, we show that spatially flat FRW solutions in the string landscape violate this condition or at best marginally satisfy it. However, we find that sufficiently large negative spatial curvature always avoids a breakdown. To avoid EFT breakdown, we derive an upper bound on the duration of quasi-de Sitter expansion that classically evolves to decelerated expansion. Our bound is proportional to the Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC) bound, with the advantage that it applies to any FRW solution in the string landscape. Finally, we distinguish EFT breakdown from TCC violation, the latter being a quantum gravity constraint rather than an EFT limitation. Perhaps our most surprising finding is that in any flat FRW solution that develops a weakly coupled string at future infinity the EFT inevitably breaks down.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
String stars in $d\geq 7$
Authors:
Alek Bedroya,
David Wu
Abstract:
We raise a thermodynamic puzzle for Horowitz--Polchinski (HP) solutions in the presence of extra compact dimensions and show that it can be resolved by the existence of higher-dimensional string stars. We provide non-trivial evidence for the existence of such string stars in spacetime dimensions $d\geq 7$ as higher-dimensional counterparts of HP solutions in bosonic and type II string theories. In…
▽ More
We raise a thermodynamic puzzle for Horowitz--Polchinski (HP) solutions in the presence of extra compact dimensions and show that it can be resolved by the existence of higher-dimensional string stars. We provide non-trivial evidence for the existence of such string stars in spacetime dimensions $d\geq 7$ as higher-dimensional counterparts of HP solutions in bosonic and type II string theories. In particular, we explicitly construct string star solutions in $d=7$ that are under perturbative control. In $d>7$, at the Hagedorn temperature, we identify these string stars as a specific representative of a new one-parameter bounded family of Euclidean solutions which can be under perturbative control. The higher-order $α'$ corrections play a crucial role in our arguments and, as pointed by other works, nullify the previous arguments against the existence of string stars in $d\geq 7$. The higher-dimensional string stars have non-zero free energy at Hagedorn temperature and their mass and free energy are of the same order as those of a string-sized black hole. In $d>7$, these solutions are string sized, but in $d=7$, the size of these solutions diverges as $\sim (T_{\rm H}-T)^{-1/4}$ near the Hagedorn temperature.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
TCC in the interior of moduli space and its implications for the string landscape and cosmology
Authors:
Alek Bedroya,
Qianshu Lu,
Paul Steinhardt
Abstract:
We consider the classical Friedmann-Robertson-Walker solutions that describe a universe undergoing a transition from an accelerating expansion phase in the past to an eternal decelerating expansion phase in the future, driven by a scalar field evolving in a potential energy landscape. We show that any solution for which the accelerating phase violates the Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC…
▽ More
We consider the classical Friedmann-Robertson-Walker solutions that describe a universe undergoing a transition from an accelerating expansion phase in the past to an eternal decelerating expansion phase in the future, driven by a scalar field evolving in a potential energy landscape. We show that any solution for which the accelerating phase violates the Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC), even in the interior of moduli space, never approaches the asymptotic vacuum with zero particles. Based on the assumption that the effective field theory must be valid for the vacuum on the asymptotic boundary, as motivated by holography and string theory, we argue that (multi-field) scalar potentials with such solutions are disallowed, thus strengthening the case for TCC. In particular, the results imply a new set of complex and highly-nonlinear constraints across the entire string landscape which may make realizing inflation impossible.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Density of States, Black Holes and the Emergent String Conjecture
Authors:
Alek Bedroya,
Rashmish K. Mishra,
Max Wiesner
Abstract:
We study universal features of the density of one-particle states $ρ(E)$ in weakly coupled theories of gravity at energies above the quantum gravity cutoff $Λ$, defined as the scale suppressing higher-derivative corrections to the Einstein--Hilbert action. Using thermodynamic properties of black holes, we show that in asymptotically flat spacetimes, certain features of $ρ(E)$ above the black hole…
▽ More
We study universal features of the density of one-particle states $ρ(E)$ in weakly coupled theories of gravity at energies above the quantum gravity cutoff $Λ$, defined as the scale suppressing higher-derivative corrections to the Einstein--Hilbert action. Using thermodynamic properties of black holes, we show that in asymptotically flat spacetimes, certain features of $ρ(E)$ above the black hole threshold $M_{\rm min}$ are an indicator for the existence of large extra dimensions, and cannot be reproduced by any lower-dimensional field theory with finitely many fields satisfying the weak energy condition. Based on the properties of gravitational scattering amplitudes, we argue that there needs to exist a (possibly higher-dimensional) effective description of gravity valid up to the cutoff $Λ$. Combining this with thermodynamic arguments we demonstrate that $ρ(E)$ has to grow exponentially for energies $Λ\ll E \ll M_{\rm min}$. Furthermore we show that the tension of any weakly coupled $p$-brane with $p\geq 1$ is bounded from below by $Λ^{p+1}$. We use this to argue that any tower of weakly coupled states with mass below $Λ$ has to be a Kaluza--Klein (KK) tower. Altogether these results indicate that in gravitational weak-coupling limits the lightest tower of states is either a KK tower, or has an exponentially growing degeneracy thereby resembling a string tower. This provides evidence for the Emergent String Conjecture without explicitly relying on string theory or supersymmetry.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2025; v1 submitted 30 April, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
The Tale of Three Scales: the Planck, the Species, and the Black Hole Scales
Authors:
Alek Bedroya,
Cumrun Vafa,
David H. Wu
Abstract:
Quantum gravity (QG) has a natural cutoff given by the Planck scale $M_{\rm pl}$. However, it is known that the EFT of gravity can break down at a lower scale, the species scale $Λ_s\lesssim M_{\rm pl}$, if there are light species of particles. Here we point out that there is a third scale $Λ_{\rm BH}\lesssim Λ_s\lesssim M_{\rm pl}$, which marks the inverse length (or the temperature) of the small…
▽ More
Quantum gravity (QG) has a natural cutoff given by the Planck scale $M_{\rm pl}$. However, it is known that the EFT of gravity can break down at a lower scale, the species scale $Λ_s\lesssim M_{\rm pl}$, if there are light species of particles. Here we point out that there is a third scale $Λ_{\rm BH}\lesssim Λ_s\lesssim M_{\rm pl}$, which marks the inverse length (or the temperature) of the smallest black hole where the EFT gives a correct description of its entropy and free energy. This latter scale is hard to detect from the viewpoint of EFT as it represents a phase transition to a state with lower free energy. We illustrate this using examples drawn from consistent QG landscape. In particular $Λ_{\rm BH}$ gets related to Gregory--Laflamme transition in the decompactification limits of quantum gravity and to the Horowitz--Polchinski solution in the light perturbative string limits. We propose the existence of $Λ_{\rm BH}$ marking the temperature at which neutral black holes undergo a phase transition, as a new Swampland condition for all consistent quantum theories of gravity. In the asymptotic regimes of field space $Λ_{\rm BH}$ is close to the mass scale of the lightest tower but deviates from it as we move inwards in the moduli space.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2024; v1 submitted 26 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Locality Outside Extremal Black Holes
Authors:
Hessamaddin Arfaei,
Alek Bedroya,
Mahdi Torabian
Abstract:
Motivated by string theory, we propose that non-local quantum corrections to large extremal black holes must be suppressed by local higher-derivative terms (classical corrections). We show that this condition implies the species bound in all even dimensions, is motivated by Weak Gravity Conjecture, and is necessary for the mild form of the Weak Gravity Conjecture in supersymmetric theories with mo…
▽ More
Motivated by string theory, we propose that non-local quantum corrections to large extremal black holes must be suppressed by local higher-derivative terms (classical corrections). We show that this condition implies the species bound in all even dimensions, is motivated by Weak Gravity Conjecture, and is necessary for the mild form of the Weak Gravity Conjecture in supersymmetric theories with more than supercharges.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Dualities from Swampland principles
Authors:
Alek Bedroya,
Yuta Hamada
Abstract:
We initiate the program of bottom-up derivation of string theory dualities using Swampland principles. In particular, we clarify the relation between Swampland arguments and all the string theory dualities in $d\geq9$ dimensional supersymmetric theories. Our arguments center around the sharpened distance conjecture and rely on various other Swampland principles.
We initiate the program of bottom-up derivation of string theory dualities using Swampland principles. In particular, we clarify the relation between Swampland arguments and all the string theory dualities in $d\geq9$ dimensional supersymmetric theories. Our arguments center around the sharpened distance conjecture and rely on various other Swampland principles.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Non-BPS path to the string lamppost
Authors:
Alek Bedroya,
Sanjay Raman,
Houri-Christina Tarazi
Abstract:
We provide further motivation for the string lamppost principle in 9d supergravities. Using a blend of ideas which includes Swampland conjectures, finiteness of black hole entropy, and classification of SCFTs, we show that infinite distance limits that keep BPS states heavy must decompactify to type IIA supergravity on an interval. Without relying on string theory, we provide bottom-up explanation…
▽ More
We provide further motivation for the string lamppost principle in 9d supergravities. Using a blend of ideas which includes Swampland conjectures, finiteness of black hole entropy, and classification of SCFTs, we show that infinite distance limits that keep BPS states heavy must decompactify to type IIA supergravity on an interval. Without relying on string theory, we provide bottom-up explanations for various UV features of the theory, such as the physics near the orientifold branes and the worldvolume theories of different stacks of non-perturbative 8-branes. We also provide a Swampland argument for the countability of the number of inequivalent string limits up to dualities which is a strong result with applications beyond this work.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2023; v1 submitted 23 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Lectures on the string landscape and the Swampland
Authors:
Nathan Benjamin Agmon,
Alek Bedroya,
Monica Jinwoo Kang,
Cumrun Vafa
Abstract:
We provide an overview of the string landscape and the Swampland program. Our review of the string landscape covers the worldsheet and spacetime perspectives, including vacua and string dualities. We then review and motivate the Swampland program from the lessons learned from the string landscape. These lecture notes are aimed to be self-contained and thus can serve as a starting point for researc…
▽ More
We provide an overview of the string landscape and the Swampland program. Our review of the string landscape covers the worldsheet and spacetime perspectives, including vacua and string dualities. We then review and motivate the Swampland program from the lessons learned from the string landscape. These lecture notes are aimed to be self-contained and thus can serve as a starting point for researchers interested in exploring these ideas.
These notes are an expanded version of two courses "The String Landscape and the Swampland" taught by C.~Vafa at Harvard University in 2018 with a focus on the landscape, written by M.~J.~Kang with additional material from N.~B.~Agmon, and in 2022 with a focus on the Swampland, written by A.~Bedroya.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2023; v1 submitted 12 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
High energy scattering and string/black hole transition
Authors:
Alek Bedroya
Abstract:
We give a short review of high energy scattering in string theory, thermal properties of strings, explain the connection between the two and how they all tie together with the string/black hole transition.
We give a short review of high energy scattering in string theory, thermal properties of strings, explain the connection between the two and how they all tie together with the string/black hole transition.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Holographic origin of TCC and the Distance Conjecture
Authors:
Alek Bedroya
Abstract:
One of the unique features of quantum gravity is the lack of local observables and the completeness of boundary observables. We show that the existence of boundary observables for particles with mass $\lim\limits_{t\rightarrow\infty}\frac{m}{H}=\infty$ in scalar field cosmologies where $a(t)\sim t^{p}$ is equivalent to TCC, which implies $p\leq 1$. Moreover, the mass of weakly-coupled particles mu…
▽ More
One of the unique features of quantum gravity is the lack of local observables and the completeness of boundary observables. We show that the existence of boundary observables for particles with mass $\lim\limits_{t\rightarrow\infty}\frac{m}{H}=\infty$ in scalar field cosmologies where $a(t)\sim t^{p}$ is equivalent to TCC, which implies $p\leq 1$. Moreover, the mass of weakly-coupled particles must decay like $m\lesssim t^{1-2p}$ to ensure that they yield non-trivial boundary observables. This condition can be expressed in terms of the scalar field that drives the cosmology as $m\lesssim\exp(-cφ)$ where $c$ depends on the scalar potential. The strongest bound we find is achieved for $V\sim \exp(-2φ/\sqrt{d-2})$ where $c=1/\sqrt{d-2}$. These results connect some of the most phenomenologically interesting Swampland conjectures to the most basic version of holography.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2024; v1 submitted 16 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Compactness of Brane Moduli and the String Lamppost Principle in $d>6$
Authors:
Alek Bedroya,
Yuta Hamada,
Miguel Montero,
Cumrun Vafa
Abstract:
We demonstrate the validity of the String Lamppost Principle-that all consistent theories of quantum gravity are in the String Landscape-for supersymmetric theories in $d>6$ using compactness and connectedness of the moduli space of small instantons, as well as the classification of the associated Coulomb branch.
We demonstrate the validity of the String Lamppost Principle-that all consistent theories of quantum gravity are in the String Landscape-for supersymmetric theories in $d>6$ using compactness and connectedness of the moduli space of small instantons, as well as the classification of the associated Coulomb branch.
△ Less
Submitted 26 December, 2021; v1 submitted 19 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
de Sitter Complementarity, TCC, and the Swampland
Authors:
Alek Bedroya
Abstract:
Motivated by the coincidence of scrambling time in de Sitter and maximum lifetime given by the $\textit{Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture}$ (TCC), we study the relation between the de Sitter complementarity and the Swampland conditions. We study thermalization in de Sitter space from different perspectives and show that TCC implies de Sitter space cannot live long enough to be considered a the…
▽ More
Motivated by the coincidence of scrambling time in de Sitter and maximum lifetime given by the $\textit{Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture}$ (TCC), we study the relation between the de Sitter complementarity and the Swampland conditions. We study thermalization in de Sitter space from different perspectives and show that TCC implies de Sitter space cannot live long enough to be considered a thermal background. We also revisit $α$-vacua in light of this work and show that TCC imposes multiple initial condition/fine-tuning problems on any conventional inflationary scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2020; v1 submitted 19 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
de Sitter Bubbles and the Swampland
Authors:
Alek Bedroya,
Miguel Montero,
Cumrun Vafa,
Irene Valenzuela
Abstract:
A number of Swampland conjectures and in particular the Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC) suggest that de Sitter space is highly unstable if it exists at all. In this paper we construct effective theories of scalars rolling on potentials which are dual to a chain of short-lived dS spaces decaying from one to the next through a cascade of non-perturbative nucleation of bubbles. We find co…
▽ More
A number of Swampland conjectures and in particular the Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC) suggest that de Sitter space is highly unstable if it exists at all. In this paper we construct effective theories of scalars rolling on potentials which are dual to a chain of short-lived dS spaces decaying from one to the next through a cascade of non-perturbative nucleation of bubbles. We find constraints on the effective potential resulting from various swampland criteria, including TCC, Weak Gravity Conjecture and Distance Conjecture. Surprisingly we find that TCC essentially incorporates all the other ones, and leads to a subclass of possible dual effective potentials. These results marginally rule out emergence of eternal inflation in the dual effective theory. We discuss some cosmological implications of our observations.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2021; v1 submitted 17 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Trans-Planckian Censorship and Inflationary Cosmology
Authors:
Alek Bedroya,
Robert Brandenberger,
Marilena Loverde,
Cumrun Vafa
Abstract:
We study the implications of the recently proposed Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC) for early universe cosmology and in particular inflationary cosmology. The TCC leads to the conclusion that if we want inflationary cosmology to provide a successful scenario for cosmological structure formation, the energy scale of inflation has to be lower than $10^9$ GeV. Demanding the correct amplitu…
▽ More
We study the implications of the recently proposed Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC) for early universe cosmology and in particular inflationary cosmology. The TCC leads to the conclusion that if we want inflationary cosmology to provide a successful scenario for cosmological structure formation, the energy scale of inflation has to be lower than $10^9$ GeV. Demanding the correct amplitude of the cosmological perturbations then forces the generalized slow-roll parameter $ε$ of the model to be very small ($<10^{-31}$). This leads to the prediction of a negligible amplitude of primordial gravitational waves. For slow-roll inflation models, it also leads to severe fine tuning of initial conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2019; v1 submitted 24 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Trans-Planckian Censorship and the Swampland
Authors:
Alek Bedroya,
Cumrun Vafa
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose a new Swampland condition, the Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC), based on the idea that in a consistent quantum theory of gravity sub-Planckian quantum fluctuations should remain quantum and never become larger than the Hubble horizon and freeze in an expanding universe. TCC leads to conditions that are similar to the refined dS Swampland conjecture. For exampl…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose a new Swampland condition, the Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC), based on the idea that in a consistent quantum theory of gravity sub-Planckian quantum fluctuations should remain quantum and never become larger than the Hubble horizon and freeze in an expanding universe. TCC leads to conditions that are similar to the refined dS Swampland conjecture. For example, applied to the case of cosmologies driven only by a scalar field, the TCC imposes an upper bound of $2/\sqrt{d-2}$ on the asymptotic value of $|V'|/V$. Additionally, it implies that a monotonically decreasing potential across $[φ_1,φ_2]$ satisfies $V(φ_2)\leq A\cdot\exp(-2(φ_2-φ_1))/\sqrt{(d-1)(d-2)})$ for some $\mathcal{O}(1)$ constant $A$. Like the dS Swampland conjecture, the TCC forbids long-lived meta-stable dS spaces, but allows sufficiently short-lived ones.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2023; v1 submitted 24 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Anomaly induced quantum correction to charged black holes; geometry and thermodynamics
Authors:
Jahed Abedi,
Hessamaddin Arfaei,
Alek Bedroya,
Aida Mehin-Rasuliani,
Milad Noorikuhani,
Kamran Salehi-Vaziri
Abstract:
We consider the corrections due to quantum fluctuations of fields on charged black holes induced from the energy-momentum trace anomaly. Although the number of horizons stays unchanged and their positions receive only finite corrections, the geometry, thermodynamics and formation of RN black holes change seriously in particular for small ones. The entropy receives a logarithmic correction. The lin…
▽ More
We consider the corrections due to quantum fluctuations of fields on charged black holes induced from the energy-momentum trace anomaly. Although the number of horizons stays unchanged and their positions receive only finite corrections, the geometry, thermodynamics and formation of RN black holes change seriously in particular for small ones. The entropy receives a logarithmic correction. The line $Q=M$, separating naked singularities from physical solutions is corrected, putting a lower limit on the mass and an upper limit on the temperature of the black hole as a function of its charge. The modifications are highly significant in the cases of near-extremal and small black holes. We also show that for black holes with small mass can stay in thermal equilibrium without any constraint on the volume of the container. This result is in contrast to the large black holes that need a finite volume container for thermal equilibrium. The minimum of the mass lower limits occurs at zero charge, resulting in the extremal Schwarzschild black hole with a specific mass of the order of $M_{p}$ and zero temperature. This state which has only gravitational interaction will be the final stage of Hawking radiation. Stability and lack of any interaction but gravitational, makes the extremal Schwarzschild black hole a serious candidate for dark matter particle.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2017; v1 submitted 9 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
