-
Triple nuclear collisions - a new method to explore the matter properties under new extreme conditions
Authors:
O. V. Vitiuk,
V. M. Pugatch,
K. A. Bugaev,
P. P. Panasiuk,
N. S. Yakovenko,
B. E. Grinyuk,
E. S. Zherebtsova,
M. Bleicher,
L. V. Bravina,
A. V. Taranenko,
E. E. Zabrodin
Abstract:
We suggest to explore an entirely new method to experimentally and theoretically study the phase diagram of strongly interacting matter based on the triple nuclear collisions (TNC). We simulated the TNC using the UrQMD 3.4 model at the beam center-of-mass collision energies $\sqrt{s_{NN}} = 200$ GeV and $\sqrt{s_{NN}} = 2.76$ TeV. It is found that in the most central and simultaneous TNC the initi…
▽ More
We suggest to explore an entirely new method to experimentally and theoretically study the phase diagram of strongly interacting matter based on the triple nuclear collisions (TNC). We simulated the TNC using the UrQMD 3.4 model at the beam center-of-mass collision energies $\sqrt{s_{NN}} = 200$ GeV and $\sqrt{s_{NN}} = 2.76$ TeV. It is found that in the most central and simultaneous TNC the initial baryonic charge density is about 3 times higher than the one achieved in the usual binary nuclear collisions at the same energies. As a consequence, the production of protons and $Λ$-hyperons is increased by a factor of 2 and 1.5, respectively. Using the MIT Bag model equation we study the evolution of the central cell in TNC and demonstrate that for the top RHIC energy of collision the baryonic chemical potential is 2-2.5 times larger than the one achieved in the binary nuclear collision at the same type of reaction. Based on these estimates, we show that TNC offers an entirely new possibility to study the QCD phase diagram at very high baryonic charge densities.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Induced surface and curvature tension equation of state for hadron resonance gas in finite volumes and its relation to morphological thermodynamics
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
O. V. Vitiuk,
B. E. Grinyuk,
P. P. Panasiuk,
N. S. Yakovenko,
E. S. Zherebtsova,
V. V. Sagun,
O. I. Ivanytskyi,
L. V. Bravina,
D. B. Blaschke,
S. Kabana,
S. V. Kuleshov,
A. V. Taranenko,
E. E. Zabrodin,
G. M. Zinovjev
Abstract:
Here we develop an original approach to investigate the grand canonical partition function of the multicomponent mixtures of Boltzmann particles with hard-core interaction in finite and even small systems of the volumes above 20 fm$^3$. The derived expressions of the induced surface tension equation of state are analyzed in details. It is shown that the metastable states, which can emerge in the f…
▽ More
Here we develop an original approach to investigate the grand canonical partition function of the multicomponent mixtures of Boltzmann particles with hard-core interaction in finite and even small systems of the volumes above 20 fm$^3$. The derived expressions of the induced surface tension equation of state are analyzed in details. It is shown that the metastable states, which can emerge in the finite systems with realistic interaction, appear at very high pressures at which the hadron resonance gas, most probably, is not applicable at all. It is shown how and under what conditions the obtained results for finite systems can be generalized to include into a formalism the equation for curvature tension. The applicability range of the obtained equations of induced surface and curvature tensions for finite systems is discussed and their close relations to the equations of the morphological thermodynamics are established. The hadron resonance gas model on the basis of the obtained advanced equation of state is worked out. Also, this model is applied to analyze the chemical freeze-out of hadrons and light nuclei with the number of (anti-)baryons not exceeding 4, including the most problematic ratios of hyper-triton and its antiparticle. Their multiplicities were measured by the ALICE Collaboration in the central lead-lead collisions at the center-of-mass energy $\sqrt{s_{\rm NN}} =$ 2.76 TeV.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Chemical freeze-out of light nuclei in high energy nuclear collisions and resolution of the hyper-triton chemical freeze-out puzzle
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
O. V. Vitiuk,
B. E. Grinyuk,
N. S. Yakovenko,
E. S. Zherebtsova,
V. V. Sagun,
O. I. Ivanytskyi,
D. O. Savchenko,
L. V. Bravina,
D. B. Blaschke,
G. R. Farrar,
S. Kabana,
S. V. Kuleshov,
E. G. Nikonov,
A. V. Taranenko,
E. E. Zabrodin,
G. M. Zinovjev
Abstract:
We present a summary of the recent results obtained with the novel hadron resonance gas model with the multicomponent hard-core repulsion which is extended to describe the mixtures of hadrons and light (anti-, hyper-)nuclei. A very accurate description is obtained for the hadronic and the light nuclei data measured by STAR at the collision energy $\sqrt{s_{NN}} =200$ GeV and by ALICE at…
▽ More
We present a summary of the recent results obtained with the novel hadron resonance gas model with the multicomponent hard-core repulsion which is extended to describe the mixtures of hadrons and light (anti-, hyper-)nuclei. A very accurate description is obtained for the hadronic and the light nuclei data measured by STAR at the collision energy $\sqrt{s_{NN}} =200$ GeV and by ALICE at $\sqrt{s_{NN}} =2.76$ TeV. The most striking result discussed here is that for the most probable chemical freeze-out scenario for the STAR energy the found parameters allow us to reproduce the values of the experimental ratios $S_3$ and $\overline{S}_3$ without fitting.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Second virial coefficients of light nuclear clusters and their chemical freeze-out in nuclear collisions
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
O. V. Vitiuk,
B. E. Grinyuk,
V. V. Sagun,
N. S. Yakovenko,
O. I. Ivanytskyi,
G. M. Zinovjev,
D. B. Blaschke,
E. G. Nikonov,
L. V. Bravina,
E. E. Zabrodin,
S. Kabana,
S. V. Kuleshov,
G. R. Farrar,
E. S. Zherebtsova,
A. V. Taranenko
Abstract:
Here we develop a new strategy to analyze the chemical freeze-out of light (anti)nuclei produced in high energy collisions of heavy atomic nuclei within an advanced version of the hadron resonance gas model. It is based on two different, but complementary approaches to model the hard-core repulsion between the light nuclei and hadrons. The first approach is based on an approximate treatment of the…
▽ More
Here we develop a new strategy to analyze the chemical freeze-out of light (anti)nuclei produced in high energy collisions of heavy atomic nuclei within an advanced version of the hadron resonance gas model. It is based on two different, but complementary approaches to model the hard-core repulsion between the light nuclei and hadrons. The first approach is based on an approximate treatment of the equivalent hard-core radius of a roomy nuclear cluster and pions, while the second approach is rigorously derived here using a self-consistent treatment of classical excluded volumes of light (anti)nuclei and hadrons. By construction, in a hadronic medium dominated by pions, both approaches should give the same results. Employing this strategy to the analysis of hadronic and light (anti)nuclei multiplicities measured by ALICE at $\sqrt{s_{NN}} =2.76$ TeV and by STAR at $\sqrt{s_{NN}} =200$ GeV, we got rid of the existing ambiguity in the description of light (anti)nuclei data and determined the chemical freeze-out parameters of nuclei with high accuracy and confidence. At ALICE energy the nuclei are frozen prior to the hadrons at the temperature $T = 175.1^{+2.3}_{-3.9}$ MeV, while at STAR energy there is a single freeze-out of hadrons and nuclei at the temperature $T = 167.2 \pm 3.9$ MeV. We argue that the found chemical freeze-out volumes of nuclei can be considered as the volumes of quark-gluon bags that produce the nuclei at the moment of hadronization.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2020; v1 submitted 4 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Classical excluded volumes of loosely bound light (anti)nuclei and their chemical freeze-out in heavy ion collisions
Authors:
B. E. Grinyuk,
K. A. Bugaev,
V. V. Sagun,
O. I. Ivanytskyi,
D. L. Borisyuk,
A. S. Zhokhin,
G. M. Zinovjev,
D. B. Blaschke,
L. V. Bravina,
E. E. Zabrodin,
E. G. Nikonov,
G. Farrar,
S. Kabana,
S. V. Kuleshov,
A. V. Taranenko
Abstract:
From the analysis of light (anti)nuclei multiplicities that were measured recently by the ALICE collaboration in Pb+Pb collisions at the center-of-mass collision energy $\sqrt{s_{NN}} =2.76$ TeV there arose a highly non-trivial question about the excluded volume of composite particles. Surprisingly, the hadron resonance gas model (HRGM) is able to perfectly describe the light (anti)nuclei multipli…
▽ More
From the analysis of light (anti)nuclei multiplicities that were measured recently by the ALICE collaboration in Pb+Pb collisions at the center-of-mass collision energy $\sqrt{s_{NN}} =2.76$ TeV there arose a highly non-trivial question about the excluded volume of composite particles. Surprisingly, the hadron resonance gas model (HRGM) is able to perfectly describe the light (anti)nuclei multiplicities under various assumptions. Thus, one can consider the (anti)nuclei with a vanishing hard-core radius (as the point-like particles) or with the hard-core radius of proton, but the fit quality is the same for these assumptions. It is clear, however, that such assumptions are unphysical. Hence we obtain a formula for the classical excluded volume of loosely bound light nuclei consisting of A baryons. To implement a new formula into the HRGM we have to modify the induced surface tension concept to treat the hadrons and (anti)nuclei on the same footing. We perform a simultaneous analysis of hadronic and (anti)nuclei multiplicities measured by the ALICE collaboration. The HRGM with the induced surface tension allows us to verify different assumptions on the values of hard-core radii and different scenarios of chemical freeze-out of light (anti)nuclei. It is shown that the unprecedentedly high quality of fit $χ^2_{tot}/dof \simeq 0.769$ is achieved, if the chemical freeze-out temperature of hadrons is about $T_h=150$ MeV, while the one for all (anti)nuclei is $T_A=174-175.2$ MeV.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2020; v1 submitted 11 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
On separate chemical freeze-outs of hadrons and light (anti)nuclei in high energy nuclear collisions
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
B. E. Grinyuk,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
V. V. Sagun,
D. O. Savchenko,
G. M. Zinovjev,
E. G. Nikonov,
L. V. Bravina,
E. E. Zabrodin,
D. B. Blaschke,
S. Kabana,
A. V. Taranenko
Abstract:
The multiplicities of light (anti)nuclei were measured recently by the ALICE collaboration in Pb+Pb collisions at the center-of-mass collision energy $\sqrt{s_{NN}} =2.76$ TeV. Surprisingly, the hadron resonance gas model is able to perfectly describe their multiplicities under various assumptions. For instance, one can consider the (anti)nuclei with a vanishing hard-core radius (as the point-like…
▽ More
The multiplicities of light (anti)nuclei were measured recently by the ALICE collaboration in Pb+Pb collisions at the center-of-mass collision energy $\sqrt{s_{NN}} =2.76$ TeV. Surprisingly, the hadron resonance gas model is able to perfectly describe their multiplicities under various assumptions. For instance, one can consider the (anti)nuclei with a vanishing hard-core radius (as the point-like particles) or with the hard-core radius of proton, but the fit quality is the same for these assumptions. In this paper we assume the hard-core radius of nuclei consisting of $A$ baryons or antibaryons to follow the simple law $R(A) = R_b (A)^\frac{1}{3}$, where $R_b$ is the hard-core radius of nucleon. To implement such a relation into the hadron resonance gas model we employ the induced surface tension concept and analyze the hadronic and (anti)nuclei multiplicities measured by the ALICE collaboration. The hadron resonance gas model with the induced surface tension allows us to verify different scenarios of chemical freeze-out of (anti)nuclei. It is shown that the most successful description of hadrons can be achieved at the chemical freeze-out temperature $T_h=150$ MeV, while the one for all (anti)nuclei is $T_A=168.5$ MeV. Possible explanations of this high temperature of (anti)nuclei chemical freeze-out are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Hard-core Radius of Nucleons within the Induced Surface Tension Approach
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
V. V. Sagun,
B. E. Grinyuk,
D. O. Savchenko,
G. M. Zinovjev,
E. G. Nikonov,
L. V. Bravina,
E. E. Zabrodin,
D. B. Blaschke,
A. V. Taranenko,
L. Turko
Abstract:
In this work we discuss a novel approach to model the hadronic and nuclear matter equations of state using the induced surface tension concept. Since the obtained equations of state, classical and quantum, are among the most successful ones in describing the properties of low density phases of strongly interacting matter, they set strong restrictions on the possible value of the hard-core radius o…
▽ More
In this work we discuss a novel approach to model the hadronic and nuclear matter equations of state using the induced surface tension concept. Since the obtained equations of state, classical and quantum, are among the most successful ones in describing the properties of low density phases of strongly interacting matter, they set strong restrictions on the possible value of the hard-core radius of nucleons. Therefore, we perform a detailed analysis of its value which follows from hadronic and nuclear matter properties and find the most trustworthy range of its values: the hard-core radius of nucleons is 0.30--0.36 fm. A comparison with the phenomenology of neutron stars implies that the hard-core radius of nucleons has to be temperature and density dependent.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2018; v1 submitted 30 September, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Threshold Collision Energy of the QCD Phase Diagram Tricritical Endpoint
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
R. Emaus,
V. V. Sagun,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
L. V. Bravina,
D. B. Blaschke,
E. G. Nikonov,
A. V. Taranenko,
E. E. Zabrodin,
G. M. Zinovjev
Abstract:
Using the most advanced formulation of the hadron resonance gas model we analyze the two sets of irregularities found at chemical freeze-out of central nuclear-nuclear collisions at the center of mass energies 3.8-4.9 GeV and 7.6-9.2 GeV. In addition to previously reported irregularities at the collision energies 4.9 GeV and 9.2 GeV we found sharp peaks of baryonic charge density. Also we analyze…
▽ More
Using the most advanced formulation of the hadron resonance gas model we analyze the two sets of irregularities found at chemical freeze-out of central nuclear-nuclear collisions at the center of mass energies 3.8-4.9 GeV and 7.6-9.2 GeV. In addition to previously reported irregularities at the collision energies 4.9 GeV and 9.2 GeV we found sharp peaks of baryonic charge density. Also we analyze the collision energy dependence of the modified Wroblewski factor and the strangeness suppression factor. Based on the thermostatic properties of the mixed phase of a 1-st order phase transition and the ones of the Hagedorn mass spectrum we explain, respectively, the reason of observed chemical equilibration of strangeness at the collision energy 4.9 GeV and above 8.7 GeV. It is argued that the both sets of irregularities possibly evidence for two phase transitions, namely, the 1-st order transition at lower energy range and the 2-nd order transition at higher one. In combination with a recent analysis of the light nuclei number fluctuations we conclude that the center of mass collision energy range 8.8-9.2 GeV may be in the nearest vicinity of the QCD tricritical endpoint. The properties of the phase existing between two phase transitions are revealed and discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2018; v1 submitted 15 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Hadron Resonance Gas Model with Induced Surface Tension
Authors:
V. V. Sagun,
K. A. Bugaev,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
I. P. Yakimenko,
E. G. Nikonov,
A. V. Taranenko,
C. Greiner,
D. B. Blaschke,
G. M. Zinovjev
Abstract:
Here we present a physically transparent generalization of the multicomponent Van der Waals equation of state in the grand canonical ensemble. For the one-component case the third and fourth virial coefficients are calculated analytically. It is shown that an adjustment of a single model parameter allows us to reproduce the third and fourth virial coefficients of the gas of hard spheres with small…
▽ More
Here we present a physically transparent generalization of the multicomponent Van der Waals equation of state in the grand canonical ensemble. For the one-component case the third and fourth virial coefficients are calculated analytically. It is shown that an adjustment of a single model parameter allows us to reproduce the third and fourth virial coefficients of the gas of hard spheres with small deviations from their exact values. A thorough comparison of the compressibility factor and speed of sound of the developed model with the one and two component Carnahan-Starling equation of state is made. It is shown that the model with the induced surface tension is able to reproduce the results of the Carnahan-Starling equation of state up to the packing fractions 0.2-0.22 at which the usual Van der Waals equation of state is inapplicable. At higher packing fractions the developed equation of state is softer than the gas of hard spheres and, hence, it breaks causality in the domain where the hadronic description is expected to be inapplicable. Using this equation of state we develop an entirely new hadron resonance gas model and apply it to a description of the hadron yield ratios measured at AGS, SPS, RHIC and ALICE energies of nuclear collisions. The achieved quality of the fit per degree of freedom is about 1.08. We confirm that the strangeness enhancement factor has a peak at low AGS energies, while at and above the highest SPS energy of collisions the chemical equilibrium of strangeness is observed. We argue that the chemical equilibrium of strangeness, i.e. $γ_s \simeq 1$, observed above the center of mass collision energy 4.3 GeV may be related to the hadronization of quark gluon bags which have the Hagedorn mass spectrum, and, hence, it may be a new signal for the onset of deconfinement.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2017; v1 submitted 28 February, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Hadron Resonance Gas Model for An Arbitrarily Large Number of Different Hard-Core Radii
Authors:
K. A. Bugaev,
V. V. Sagun,
A. I. Ivanytskyi,
I. P. Yakimenko,
E. G. Nikonov,
A. V. Taranenko,
G. M. Zinovjev
Abstract:
We develop a novel formulation of the hadron-resonance gas model which, besides a hard-core repulsion, explicitly accounts for the surface tension induced by the interaction between the particles. Such an equation of state allows us to go beyond the Van der Waals approximation for any number of different hard-core radii. A comparison with the Carnahan-Starling equation of state shows that the new…
▽ More
We develop a novel formulation of the hadron-resonance gas model which, besides a hard-core repulsion, explicitly accounts for the surface tension induced by the interaction between the particles. Such an equation of state allows us to go beyond the Van der Waals approximation for any number of different hard-core radii. A comparison with the Carnahan-Starling equation of state shows that the new model is valid for packing fractions 0.2-0.22, while the usual Van der Waals model is inapplicable at packing fractions above 0.1-0.11. Moreover, it is shown that the equation of state with induced surface tension is softer than the one of hard spheres and remains causal at higher particle densities. The great advantage of our model is that there are only two equations to be solved and it does not depend on the various values of the hard-core radii used for different hadronic resonances. Using this novel equation of state we obtain a high-quality fit of the ALICE hadron multiplicities measured at center-of-mass energies of 2.76 TeV per nucleon. Furthermore, using the traditional hadron-resonance gas model with multi-component hard-core repulsion and the novel one we investigate the recently suggested model in which the proper volume of a hadron is proportional to its mass. We find that the high-temperature maximum of $χ^2/ndf$ observed in the latter model always appears in the region located far above the limit of its applicability.
△ Less
Submitted 31 December, 2016; v1 submitted 20 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
