Showing 1–33 of 33 results for author: Stevenson, P M

QCD Perturbation Theory: It's not what you were taught

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: Physical quantities in QCD do not depend upon $α_s(Q)$. There is no way to measure $α_s(Q)$ experimentally. If those statements sound shocking, please read on. They are actually well-known facts, though ones that are constantly being ignored in the QCD literature. Renormalized perturbation theory is not an ordinary power-series expansion; its renormalization-scheme ambiguity is not merely a minor… ▽ More Physical quantities in QCD do not depend upon $α_s(Q)$. There is no way to measure $α_s(Q)$ experimentally. If those statements sound shocking, please read on. They are actually well-known facts, though ones that are constantly being ignored in the QCD literature. Renormalized perturbation theory is not an ordinary power-series expansion; its renormalization-scheme ambiguity is not merely a minor nuisance. Rather, it is a structure in which invariance under redefinitions of the coupling is a fundamental symmetry -- a symmetry that, like any other, deserves respect. I speak bluntly because without a change in mindset perturbative QCD can never become a proper, scientific enterprise. △ Less

Submitted 2 September, 2024; originally announced September 2024.

Comments: 16 pages, 3 figures

Brodsky et al's defence does not work

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: In their defence of "maximum conformality" methods, Brodsky et al make the astonishing claim that any RG transformation a'=a(1+V_1 a + ...) in QCD must have V_1 proportional to b=(33-2n_f)/6. It is well known that this is not true. I emphasize again the correctness and central importance of the Celmaster-Gonsalves relation for the prescription dependence of the Lambda parameter. In their defence of "maximum conformality" methods, Brodsky et al make the astonishing claim that any RG transformation a'=a(1+V_1 a + ...) in QCD must have V_1 proportional to b=(33-2n_f)/6. It is well known that this is not true. I emphasize again the correctness and central importance of the Celmaster-Gonsalves relation for the prescription dependence of the Lambda parameter. △ Less

Submitted 1 November, 2024; v1 submitted 18 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: 8 pages. Main text unaltered, but the Addendum has been revised to meet their objections. The main point, that the PMC result is RS dependent, is unaffected

`Maximal conformality' does not work

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: The so-called "principle of maximal conformality" is ineffective and does nothing to resolve the renormalization-scheme-dependence problem. Some essential facts about that problem are summarized. It is stressed that RG invariance is a symmetry and that any viable method for resolving the scheme-dependence problem should be formulatable in terms of the invariants of that symmetry. The so-called "principle of maximal conformality" is ineffective and does nothing to resolve the renormalization-scheme-dependence problem. Some essential facts about that problem are summarized. It is stressed that RG invariance is a symmetry and that any viable method for resolving the scheme-dependence problem should be formulatable in terms of the invariants of that symmetry. △ Less

Submitted 26 October, 2023; v1 submitted 9 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Comments: 10 pages, no figures

Optimization for factorized quantities in perturbative QCD

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: Perturbative calculations of factorized physical quantities, such as moments of structure functions, suffer from renormalization- and factorization-scheme dependence. The application of the principle of minimal sensitivity to "optimize" the scheme choices is reconsidered, correcting deficiencies in the earlier literature. The proper scheme variables, RG equations, and invariants are identified. Ea… ▽ More Perturbative calculations of factorized physical quantities, such as moments of structure functions, suffer from renormalization- and factorization-scheme dependence. The application of the principle of minimal sensitivity to "optimize" the scheme choices is reconsidered, correcting deficiencies in the earlier literature. The proper scheme variables, RG equations, and invariants are identified. Earlier results of Nakkagawa and Niegawa are recovered, even though their starting point is, at best, unnecessarily complicated. In particular, the optimized coefficients of the coefficient function C are shown to vanish, so that C^opt=1. The resulting simplifications mean that the optimization procedure is as simple as that for purely-perturbative physical quantities. △ Less

Submitted 8 May, 2019; v1 submitted 15 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: 19 pages, no figures

The Banks-Zaks expansion in perturbative QCD: an update

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: The recent QCD calculations of the five-loop beta function and of R(e+e-) to O(alpha_s^4) provide one more term in the Banks-Zaks expansion in (16.5-nf). There is no longer any hope that the expansion could extend, even crudely, to low nf. Above nf=9, however, the results appear to be reasonably consistent from order to order. The recent QCD calculations of the five-loop beta function and of R(e+e-) to O(alpha_s^4) provide one more term in the Banks-Zaks expansion in (16.5-nf). There is no longer any hope that the expansion could extend, even crudely, to low nf. Above nf=9, however, the results appear to be reasonably consistent from order to order. △ Less

Submitted 6 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: 11 pages, 4 figures

Exploring arbitrarily high orders of optimized perturbation theory in QCD with nf -> 16.5

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: Perturbative QCD with nf flavours of massless quarks becomes simple in the hypothetical limit nf -> 16.5, where the leading beta-function coefficient vanishes. The Banks-Zaks (BZ) expansion in a0=(8/321)(16.5-nf) is straightforward to obtain from perturbative results in MSbar or any renormalization scheme (RS) whose nf dependence is `regular.' However, `irregular' RS's are perfectly permissible an… ▽ More Perturbative QCD with nf flavours of massless quarks becomes simple in the hypothetical limit nf -> 16.5, where the leading beta-function coefficient vanishes. The Banks-Zaks (BZ) expansion in a0=(8/321)(16.5-nf) is straightforward to obtain from perturbative results in MSbar or any renormalization scheme (RS) whose nf dependence is `regular.' However, `irregular' RS's are perfectly permissible and should ultimately lead to the same BZ results. We show here that the `optimal' RS determined by the Principle of Minimal Sensitivity does yield the same BZ-expansion results when all orders of perturbation theory are taken into account. The BZ limit provides an arena for exploring optimized perturbation theory at arbitrarily high orders. These explorations are facilitated by a `master equation' expressing the optimization conditions in the fixed-point limit. We find an intriguing strong/weak coupling duality a -> a*^2/a about the fixed point a*. △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2016; originally announced June 2016.

Comments: 32 pages, 4 figures

The effective exponent gamma(Q) and the slope of the beta function

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: The slope of the beta function at a fixed point is commonly thought to be RG invariant and to be the critical exponent gamma* that governs the approach of any physical quantity R to its fixed-point limit: R*-R proportional to Q^gamma*. Chyla has shown that this is not quite true. Here we define a proper RG invariant, the "effective exponent" gamma(Q), whose fixed-point limit is the true gamma*. The slope of the beta function at a fixed point is commonly thought to be RG invariant and to be the critical exponent gamma* that governs the approach of any physical quantity R to its fixed-point limit: R*-R proportional to Q^gamma*. Chyla has shown that this is not quite true. Here we define a proper RG invariant, the "effective exponent" gamma(Q), whose fixed-point limit is the true gamma*. △ Less

Submitted 1 September, 2016; v1 submitted 22 June, 2016; originally announced June 2016.

Comments: 8 pages, no figures. Minor improvements

Fixed and Unfixed Points: Infrared limits in optimized QCD perturbation theory

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: Perturbative QCD, when optimized by the principle of minimal sensitivity at fourth order, yields finite results for R(e+e-)(Q) down to Q=0. For two massless flavours (n_f=2) this occurs because the couplant "freezes" at a fixed point of the optimized beta function. However, for larger n_f's, between 6.7 and 15.2, the infrared limit arises by a novel mechanism in which the evolution of the optimize… ▽ More Perturbative QCD, when optimized by the principle of minimal sensitivity at fourth order, yields finite results for R(e+e-)(Q) down to Q=0. For two massless flavours (n_f=2) this occurs because the couplant "freezes" at a fixed point of the optimized beta function. However, for larger n_f's, between 6.7 and 15.2, the infrared limit arises by a novel mechanism in which the evolution of the optimized beta function with energy Q is crucial. The evolving beta function develops a minimum that, as Q -> 0, just touches the axis at a_p (the "pinch point"), while the infrared limit of the optimized couplant is at a larger value, a^star (the "unfixed point"). This phenomenon results in R approaching its infrared limit not as a power law, but as R -> R^star-const./|ln Q|^2. Implications for the phase structure of QCD as a function of n_f are briefly considered. △ Less

Submitted 10 June, 2013; originally announced June 2013.

Comments: 22 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: Nucl. Phys. B 875 (2013) 63

Optimization of QCD Perturbation Theory: Results for R(e+e-) at fourth order

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: Physical quantities in QCD are independent of renormalization scheme (RS), but that exact invariance is spoiled by truncations of the perturbation series. "Optimization" corresponds to making the perturbative approximant, at any given order, locally invariant under small RS changes. A solution of the resulting optimization equations is presented. It allows an efficient algorithm for finding the op… ▽ More Physical quantities in QCD are independent of renormalization scheme (RS), but that exact invariance is spoiled by truncations of the perturbation series. "Optimization" corresponds to making the perturbative approximant, at any given order, locally invariant under small RS changes. A solution of the resulting optimization equations is presented. It allows an efficient algorithm for finding the optimized result. Example results for R(e+e-)=3(Sum q_i^2)(1+R) to fourth order (NNNLO) are given that show nice convergence, even down to arbitrarily low energies. The Q=0 "freezing" behaviour, R=0.3+/-0.3, found at third order is confirmed and made more precise; R=0.2+/-0.1. Low-energy results in the MS-bar scheme, by contrast, show the typical pathologies of a non-convergent asymptotic series. △ Less

Submitted 12 November, 2012; v1 submitted 25 October, 2012; originally announced October 2012.

Comments: 36 pages, 7 eps figures. LaTeX. Mathematica notebook file available. Referencess added

Journal ref: Nucl. Phys. B 868 (2013) 38

The long-range interaction in massless (lambda Phi^4)_4 theory

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: Does massless (lambda Phi^4)_4 theory exhibit spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB)? The raw 1-loop result implies that it does, but the "RG-improved" result implies the opposite. I argue that the appropriate "low-energy effective theory" is a nonlocal field theory involving an attractive, long-range interaction Phi^2(x) Phi^2(y)/z^4, where z=|x-y|. RG improvement then requires running couplings f… ▽ More Does massless (lambda Phi^4)_4 theory exhibit spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB)? The raw 1-loop result implies that it does, but the "RG-improved" result implies the opposite. I argue that the appropriate "low-energy effective theory" is a nonlocal field theory involving an attractive, long-range interaction Phi^2(x) Phi^2(y)/z^4, where z=|x-y|. RG improvement then requires running couplings for both this interaction and the original pointlike interaction. A crude calculation in this framework yields SSB even after "RG improvement" and closely agrees with the raw 1-loop result. △ Less

Submitted 23 June, 2008; v1 submitted 23 June, 2008; originally announced June 2008.

Comments: 13 pages, LaTeX, 5 figures (.eps)

Journal ref: Mod.Phys.Lett.A24:261-271,2009

Comparison of perturbative RG theory with lattice data for the 4d Ising model

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: Predictions for (phi^4)_4 theory from renormalization-group-improved perturbation theory, as formulated by Luescher and Weisz, are compared to published (and some unpublished) data from lattice Monte-Carlo simulations of the 4-dimensional Ising model. Good agreement is found in all but one respect:-- the change in the wavefunction-renormalization constant Z_R across the phase transition is signi… ▽ More Predictions for (phi^4)_4 theory from renormalization-group-improved perturbation theory, as formulated by Luescher and Weisz, are compared to published (and some unpublished) data from lattice Monte-Carlo simulations of the 4-dimensional Ising model. Good agreement is found in all but one respect:-- the change in the wavefunction-renormalization constant Z_R across the phase transition is significantly greater than predicted. A related observation is that propagator data in the broken phase show deviations from free-propagator form -- deviations that become larger, not smaller, closer to the continuum limit. More data closer to the critical point are needed to clarify the situation. △ Less

Submitted 11 September, 2005; v1 submitted 27 July, 2005; originally announced July 2005.

Comments: 23 pages, 12 figures

Journal ref: Nucl.Phys. B729 (2005) 542-557

Hydrodynamics of the Vacuum

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: Hydrodynamics is the appropriate "effective theory" for describing any fluid medium at sufficiently long length scales. This paper treats the vacuum as such a medium and derives the corresponding hydrodynamic equations. Unlike a normal medium the vacuum has no linear sound-wave regime; disturbances always "propagate" nonlinearly. For an "empty vacuum" the hydrodynamic equations are familiar ones… ▽ More Hydrodynamics is the appropriate "effective theory" for describing any fluid medium at sufficiently long length scales. This paper treats the vacuum as such a medium and derives the corresponding hydrodynamic equations. Unlike a normal medium the vacuum has no linear sound-wave regime; disturbances always "propagate" nonlinearly. For an "empty vacuum" the hydrodynamic equations are familiar ones (shallow water-wave equations) and they describe an experimentally observed phenomenon -- the spreading of a clump of zero-temperature atoms into empty space. The "Higgs vacuum" case is much stranger; pressure and energy density, and hence time and space, exchange roles. The speed of sound is formally infinite, rather than zero as in the empty vacuum. Higher-derivative corrections to the vacuum hydrodynamic equations are also considered. In the empty-vacuum case the corrections are of quantum origin and the post-hydrodynamic description corresponds to the Gross-Pitaevskii equation. I conjecture the form of the post-hydrodynamic corrections in the Higgs case. In the 1+1-dimensional case the equations possess remarkable `soliton' solutions and appear to constitute a new exactly integrable system. △ Less

Submitted 30 July, 2005; v1 submitted 24 September, 2004; originally announced September 2004.

Comments: 31 pages, 6 .eps figures. Minor changes. More general multi-solition solution in Sect. 9

Report number: DE-FG05-97ER41031-57

Journal ref: Int.J.Mod.Phys. A21 (2006) 2877-2904

How do sound waves in a Bose-Einstein condensate move so fast?

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: Low-momentum excitations of a dilute Bose-Einstein condensate behave as phonons and move at a finite velocity v_s. Yet the atoms making up the phonon excitation each move very slowly; v_a = p/m --> 0. A simple "cartoon picture" is suggested to understand this phenomenon intuitively. It implies a relation v_s/v_a = N_ex, where N_ex is the number of excited atoms making up the phonon. This relatio… ▽ More Low-momentum excitations of a dilute Bose-Einstein condensate behave as phonons and move at a finite velocity v_s. Yet the atoms making up the phonon excitation each move very slowly; v_a = p/m --> 0. A simple "cartoon picture" is suggested to understand this phenomenon intuitively. It implies a relation v_s/v_a = N_ex, where N_ex is the number of excited atoms making up the phonon. This relation does indeed follow from the standard Bogoliubov theory. △ Less

Submitted 29 August, 2003; v1 submitted 13 June, 2003; originally announced June 2003.

Comments: 6 pages, 2 figures (.eps), LaTeX2e. More introductory discussion added

Report number: DE-FG05-97ER41031-56

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. A68 (2003) 055601

Vacuum Hydrodynamics

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: The Higgs vacuum -- with its constant background field -- is not `empty' but is a kind of medium. Any ordinary medium, viewed at sufficiently long length scales, has a hydrodynamic description and can propagate sound waves. The vacuum medium is unusual; the speed of sound is formally infinite and there is no linear sound-wave regime. Instead, long-wavelength disturbances are described by some in… ▽ More The Higgs vacuum -- with its constant background field -- is not `empty' but is a kind of medium. Any ordinary medium, viewed at sufficiently long length scales, has a hydrodynamic description and can propagate sound waves. The vacuum medium is unusual; the speed of sound is formally infinite and there is no linear sound-wave regime. Instead, long-wavelength disturbances are described by some intrinsically nonlinear hydrodynamic equations. △ Less

Submitted 3 June, 2002; originally announced June 2002.

Comments: 9 pages, 1 eps figure (included)

Report number: DE-FG05-97ER41031-54

Are There Pressure Waves in the Vacuum?

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: The Higgs vacuum is a kind of medium. In any medium one generally expects sound waves for sufficiently long wavelengths (>> mean free path). I briefly describe how the broken-symmetry vacuum can be viewed as a Bose-Einstein condensate of `phion' particles. This picture yields a natural notion of the `mean free path'. I speculate that this is at the millimeter-centimeter scale. The Higgs vacuum is a kind of medium. In any medium one generally expects sound waves for sufficiently long wavelengths (>> mean free path). I briefly describe how the broken-symmetry vacuum can be viewed as a Bose-Einstein condensate of `phion' particles. This picture yields a natural notion of the `mean free path'. I speculate that this is at the millimeter-centimeter scale. △ Less

Submitted 21 September, 2001; originally announced September 2001.

Comments: 6 pages. Contribution to CPT01 conference, Indiana U., August 2001

Report number: DE-FG05-97ER41031-52

Physical mechanisms generating spontaneous symmetry breaking and a hierarchy of scales

Authors: M. Consoli, P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: We discuss the phase transition in 3+1 dimensional lambda Phi^4 theory from a very physical perspective. The particles of the symmetric phase (`phions') interact via a hard-core repulsion and an induced, long-range -1/r^3 attraction. If the phion mass is sufficiently small, the lowest-energy state is not the `empty' state with no phions, but is a state with a non-zero density of phions Bose-Eins… ▽ More We discuss the phase transition in 3+1 dimensional lambda Phi^4 theory from a very physical perspective. The particles of the symmetric phase (`phions') interact via a hard-core repulsion and an induced, long-range -1/r^3 attraction. If the phion mass is sufficiently small, the lowest-energy state is not the `empty' state with no phions, but is a state with a non-zero density of phions Bose-Einstein condensed in the zero-momentum mode. The condensate corresponds to the spontaneous-symmetry-breaking vacuum with <Phi> neq 0 and its excitations ("phonons" in atomic-physics language) correspond to Higgs particles. The phase transition happens when the phion's physical mass m is still positive; it does not wait until m^2 passes through zero and becomes negative. However, at and near the phase transition, m is much, much less than the Higgs mass M_h. This interesting physics coexists with `triviality;' all scattering amplitudes vanish in the continuum limit, but the vacuum condensate becomes infinitely dense. The ratio m/M_h, which goes to zero in the continuum limit, can be viewed as a measure of non-locality in the regularized theory. An intricate hierarchy of length scales naturally arises. We speculate about the possible implications of these ideas for gravity and inflation. △ Less

Submitted 20 May, 1999; originally announced May 1999.

Comments: 27 pages plus 2 files of figures

Report number: DE-FG05-92ER41031-50

Journal ref: Int.J.Mod.Phys. A15 (2000) 133

Further lattice evidence for a large re-scaling of the Higgs condensate

Authors: P. Cea, M. Consoli, L. Cosmai, P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: Using a high-statistics lattice simulation of the Ising limit of $(λΦ^4)_4$ theory, we have measured the susceptibility and propagator in the broken phase. We confirm our earlier finding of a discrepancy between the field re-scaling implied by the propagator data and that implied by the susceptibility. The discrepancy becomes {\it worse} as one goes closer to the continuum limit; thus, it cannot… ▽ More Using a high-statistics lattice simulation of the Ising limit of $(λΦ^4)_4$ theory, we have measured the susceptibility and propagator in the broken phase. We confirm our earlier finding of a discrepancy between the field re-scaling implied by the propagator data and that implied by the susceptibility. The discrepancy becomes {\it worse} as one goes closer to the continuum limit; thus, it cannot be explained by residual perturbative effects. The data are consistent with an unconventional description of symmetry breaking and ``triviality'' in which the re-scaling factor for the finite-momentum fluctuations tends to unity, but the re-scaling factor for the condensate becomes larger and larger as one approaches the continuum limit. In the Standard Model this changes the interpretation of the Fermi-constant scale and its relation to the Higgs mass. △ Less

Submitted 6 September, 1999; v1 submitted 15 February, 1999; originally announced February 1999.

Comments: 21 pages, 9 figures, 3 tables, LaTeX2e. Revised version with substantial changes and new data

Report number: BARI-TH 329/99 ; DE-FG05-92ER41031-49

Journal ref: Mod.Phys.Lett. A14 (1999) 1673-1688

lambda Phi^4 Theory From a Particle-Gas Viewpoint

Authors: M. Consoli, P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: We discuss the physics of the 3+1 dimensional lambda Phi^4 quantum field theory in terms of the statistical mechanics of a gas of particles (`atoms') that interact via a -1/r^3-plus-hard-core potential. The hard-core potential, delta^(3)(r), arises from the bare vertex diagram, while the attractive, long-range -1/r^3 potential is due to exchange of a particle pair via the t,u-channel "fish" diag… ▽ More We discuss the physics of the 3+1 dimensional lambda Phi^4 quantum field theory in terms of the statistical mechanics of a gas of particles (`atoms') that interact via a -1/r^3-plus-hard-core potential. The hard-core potential, delta^(3)(r), arises from the bare vertex diagram, while the attractive, long-range -1/r^3 potential is due to exchange of a particle pair via the t,u-channel "fish" diagram. (Higher-order diagrams preserve this form of the interparticle potential.) For sufficiently small atom mass, the lowest-energy state is not the `empty' state with no atoms, but a state with a non-zero density of spontaneously created atoms, Bose-condensed in the zero-momentum mode. This corresponds to the spontaneous-symmetry-breaking phase transition, and the `phonon' excitations of the Bose condensate correspond to Higgs particles. The important point is that the phase transition happens while the atom's physical mass m is still positive: it does not wait until m^2 passes through zero and becomes negative, contrary to the assumption of a second-order transition, on which renormalization-group-improved perturbation theory is based. △ Less

Submitted 24 November, 1997; originally announced November 1997.

Comments: 40 pages, no figures, LaTeX

Report number: DE-FG05-92ER40717-46

The Banks-Zaks Expansion and "Freezing" in Perturbative QCD

Authors: S. A. Caveny, P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: The recent calculation of the four-loop beta function in QCD provides further evidence that the Banks-Zaks expansion in 16half-n_f is sufficiently well behaved to be useful even for n_f=2 light flavours. This expansion inherently predicts "freezing" of the QCD couplant at low energies as a perturbative effect. We consider the e+e- and Bjorken-sum-rule cases as examples. The recent calculation of the four-loop beta function in QCD provides further evidence that the Banks-Zaks expansion in 16half-n_f is sufficiently well behaved to be useful even for n_f=2 light flavours. This expansion inherently predicts "freezing" of the QCD couplant at low energies as a perturbative effect. We consider the e+e- and Bjorken-sum-rule cases as examples. △ Less

Submitted 14 May, 1997; originally announced May 1997.

Comments: 19 pages, LaTeX, including 3 figures using epsf

Report number: DOE/ER/40717-45

A lattice test of alternative interpretations of ``triviality'' in $(λΦ^4)_4$ theory

Authors: A. Agodi, G. Andronico, P. Cea, M. Consoli, L. Cosmai, R. Fiore, P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: There are two physically different interpretations of ``triviality'' in $(λΦ^4)_4$ theories. The conventional description predicts a second-order phase transition and that the Higgs mass $m_h$ must vanish in the continuum limit if $v$, the physical v.e.v, is held fixed. An alternative interpretation, based on the effective potential obtained in ``triviality-compatible'' approximations (in which… ▽ More There are two physically different interpretations of ``triviality'' in $(λΦ^4)_4$ theories. The conventional description predicts a second-order phase transition and that the Higgs mass $m_h$ must vanish in the continuum limit if $v$, the physical v.e.v, is held fixed. An alternative interpretation, based on the effective potential obtained in ``triviality-compatible'' approximations (in which the shifted `Higgs' field $h(x)\equiv Φ(x)-<Φ>$ is governed by an effective quadratic Hamiltonian) predicts a phase transition that is very weakly first-order and that $m_h$ and $v$ are both finite, cutoff-independent quantities. To test these two alternatives, we have numerically computed the effective potential on the lattice. Three different methods were used to determine the critical bare mass for the chosen bare coupling value. All give excellent agreement with the literature value. Two different methods for obtaining the effective potential were used, as a control on the results. Our lattice data are fitted very well by the predictions of the unconventional picture, but poorly by the conventional picture. △ Less

Submitted 26 February, 1997; v1 submitted 24 February, 1997; originally announced February 1997.

Comments: 16 pages, LaTeX, 2 eps figures (acknowledgements added in the replaced version)

Report number: BARI-TH 261/97

Journal ref: Mod.Phys.Lett. A12 (1997) 1011-1024

Response to Tarrach's "Mode Dependent Field Renormalization and Trivialty"

Authors: M. Consoli, P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: We respond to Tarrach's criticisms (hep-th/9511034) of our work on lambda Phi^4 theory. Tarrach does not discuss the same renormalization procedure that we do. He also relies on results from perturbation theory that are not valid. There is no "infrared divergence" or unphysical behaviour associated with the zero-momentum limit of our effective action. We respond to Tarrach's criticisms (hep-th/9511034) of our work on lambda Phi^4 theory. Tarrach does not discuss the same renormalization procedure that we do. He also relies on results from perturbation theory that are not valid. There is no "infrared divergence" or unphysical behaviour associated with the zero-momentum limit of our effective action. △ Less

Submitted 17 May, 1996; originally announced May 1996.

Comments: 5 pages. No figures. LaTeX

Report number: DOE/ER/40717-28

The lambda Phi^4 Miracle: lattice data and the zero-point potential

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: Recent lattice data for the effective potential of lambda Phi^4 theory fits the massless one-loop formula with amazing precision. Any corrections are at least 100 times smaller than is reasonable, perturbatively. This is strong evidence for the "exactness conjecture" of Consoli and Stevenson. Recent lattice data for the effective potential of lambda Phi^4 theory fits the massless one-loop formula with amazing precision. Any corrections are at least 100 times smaller than is reasonable, perturbatively. This is strong evidence for the "exactness conjecture" of Consoli and Stevenson. △ Less

Submitted 25 July, 1995; originally announced July 1995.

Comments: 6 pages, LaTeX

Report number: DE-FG05-92ER40717-15

"TRIVIALITY" MADE EASY: the real (lambda Phi^4)_4 story

Authors: M. Consoli, P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: The real meaning of `triviality' of (lambda Phi^4)_4 theory is outlined. Assuming `triviality' leads to an effective potential that is just the classical potential plus the zero-point energy of the free-field fluctuations. This V_{eff} gives spontaneous symmetry breaking. Its proper renormalization has the consequence that all scattering amplitudes vanish, self-consistently validating the origin… ▽ More The real meaning of `triviality' of (lambda Phi^4)_4 theory is outlined. Assuming `triviality' leads to an effective potential that is just the classical potential plus the zero-point energy of the free-field fluctuations. This V_{eff} gives spontaneous symmetry breaking. Its proper renormalization has the consequence that all scattering amplitudes vanish, self-consistently validating the original assumption. Nevertheless, the theory is physically distinguishable from a free field theory; it has a symmetry-restoring phase transition at a finite critical temperature. △ Less

Submitted 19 July, 1994; originally announced July 1994.

Comments: 7 pages, LaTeX, DE-FG05-92ER40717-14

Triviality" and the Perturbative Expansion in $λΦ^4$ Theory

Authors: M. Consoli, P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: The "triviality" of $(λΦ^4)_4$ quantum field theory means that the renormalized coupling $λ_R$ vanishes for infinite cutoff. That result inherently conflicts with the usual perturbative approach, which begins by postulating a non-zero, cutoff-independent $λ_R$. We show how a "trivial" solution $λ_R=0$ can be compatible with the known structure of perturbation theory to arbitrarily high orders, b… ▽ More The "triviality" of $(λΦ^4)_4$ quantum field theory means that the renormalized coupling $λ_R$ vanishes for infinite cutoff. That result inherently conflicts with the usual perturbative approach, which begins by postulating a non-zero, cutoff-independent $λ_R$. We show how a "trivial" solution $λ_R=0$ can be compatible with the known structure of perturbation theory to arbitrarily high orders, by a simple re-arrangement of the expansion. The "trivial" solution reproduces the result obtained by non-perturbative renormalization of the effective potential. The physical mass is finite, while the renormalized coupling strength vanishes: the two are NOT proportional. The classically scale-invariant $λΦ^4$ theory coupled to the Standard Model predicts a 2.2 TeV Higgs, but does NOT imply strong interactions in the scalar sector. △ Less

Submitted 16 March, 1994; originally announced March 1994.

Comments: 10 pages, LaTeX, no figures, DE-FG05-92ER40717-13, MAD/TH/94-4

The 16\half-N_f Expansion and the Infrared Fixed Point in Perturbative QCD

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: In QCD with 16\half-epsilon massless quark flavours there is an infrared fixed point with alpha_s/pi = (8/321)epsilon in the limit epsilon -> 0+. I develop the idea of Banks and Zaks to expand about N_f=16\half. This expansion is certainly useful for N_f=16, 15, 14, ..., and arguably it can reach the phenomenologically interesting case N_f=2, where it suggests that alpha_s/pi "freezes" to a valu… ▽ More In QCD with 16\half-epsilon massless quark flavours there is an infrared fixed point with alpha_s/pi = (8/321)epsilon in the limit epsilon -> 0+. I develop the idea of Banks and Zaks to expand about N_f=16\half. This expansion is certainly useful for N_f=16, 15, 14, ..., and arguably it can reach the phenomenologically interesting case N_f=2, where it suggests that alpha_s/pi "freezes" to a value of order of magnitude 0.4 in the infrared. △ Less

Submitted 3 May, 1994; v1 submitted 12 February, 1994; originally announced February 1994.

Comments: 10 pages, LaTeX. 3 figures (see top of file). Revised version; some extra discussion. (To appear in Phys. Lett. B.) DE-FG05-92ER40717-12

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. B331 (1994) 187-192

The Non-Trivial Effective Potential of the `Trivial' lambda Phi^4 Theory: A Lattice Test

Authors: M. Consoli, P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: The strong evidence for the `triviality' of (lambda Phi^4)_4 theory is not incompatible with spontaneous symmetry breaking. Indeed, for a `trivial' theory the effective potential should be given exactly by the classical potential plus the free-field zero-point energy of the shifted field; i.e., by the one-loop effective potential. When this is renormalized in a simple, but nonperturbative way, o… ▽ More The strong evidence for the `triviality' of (lambda Phi^4)_4 theory is not incompatible with spontaneous symmetry breaking. Indeed, for a `trivial' theory the effective potential should be given exactly by the classical potential plus the free-field zero-point energy of the shifted field; i.e., by the one-loop effective potential. When this is renormalized in a simple, but nonperturbative way, one finds, self-consistently, that the shifted field does become non-interacting in the continuum limit. For a classically scale-invariant (CSI) lambda Phi^4 theory one finds m_h^2 = 8 pi^2 v^2, predicting a 2.2 TeV Higgs boson. Here we extend our earlier work in three ways: (i) we discuss the analogy with the hard-sphere Bose gas; (ii) we extend the analysis from the CSI case to the general case; and (iii) we propose a test of the predicted shape of the effective potential that could be tested in a lattice simulation. △ Less

Submitted 22 October, 1993; originally announced October 1993.

Comments: 22 pages, LaTeX, DE-FG05-92ER40717-9

Journal ref: Z.Phys. C63 (1994) 427-436

Optimization of R(e+e-) and "Freezing" of the QCD Couplant at Low Energies

Authors: A. C. Mattingly, P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: The new result for the third-order QCD corrections to R_{e^+e^-}, unlike the old, incorrect result, is nicely compatible with the principle-of-minimal-sensitivity optimization method. Moreover, it leads to infrared fixed-point behaviour: the optimized couplant, alpha_s/pi, for R(e+e-) does not diverge at low energies, but "freezes" to a value 0.26 below about 300 MeV. This provides some direct t… ▽ More The new result for the third-order QCD corrections to R_{e^+e^-}, unlike the old, incorrect result, is nicely compatible with the principle-of-minimal-sensitivity optimization method. Moreover, it leads to infrared fixed-point behaviour: the optimized couplant, alpha_s/pi, for R(e+e-) does not diverge at low energies, but "freezes" to a value 0.26 below about 300 MeV. This provides some direct theoretical evidence, purely from perturbation theory, for the "freezing" of the couplant -- an idea that has long been a popular and successful phenomenological hypothesis. We use the "smearing" method of Poggio, Quinn, and Weinberg to compare the resulting theoretical prediction for R(e+e-) with experimental data down to the lowest energies, and find excellent agreement. △ Less

Submitted 13 July, 1993; originally announced July 1993.

Comments: 27 pages, LaTeX, 8 uuencoded figures, DE-FG05-92ER40717-7

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D49 (1994) 437-450

Resolution of the lambda Phi^4 Puzzle and a 2 Tev Higgs Boson

Authors: M. Consoli, P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: We argue that massless (lambda Phi^4)_4 is "trivial" without being entirely trivial. It has a non-trivial effective potential which leads to spontaneous symmetry breaking, but the particle excitations above the broken vacuum are non-interacting. The key to this picture is the realization that the constant background field (the mode with zero 4-momentum) renormalizes differently from the fluctuat… ▽ More We argue that massless (lambda Phi^4)_4 is "trivial" without being entirely trivial. It has a non-trivial effective potential which leads to spontaneous symmetry breaking, but the particle excitations above the broken vacuum are non-interacting. The key to this picture is the realization that the constant background field (the mode with zero 4-momentum) renormalizes differently from the fluctuation field (the finite-momentum modes). This picture reconciles rigorous results and lattice calculations with one-loop and Gaussian-approximation analyses. Because of "triviality", these latter two methods should be effectively exact. Indeed, they yield the same renormalized effective potential and the same relation m_h^2 = 8 pi^2 v^2 between the particle mass and the physical vacuum expectation value. This relation predicts a Higgs mass m_h about 2 TeV in the standard model. The non-interacting nature of the scalar sector implies, by the equivalence theorem, that Higgs and gauge bosons interact only weakly, through their gauge and Yukawa couplings. △ Less

Submitted 3 August, 1993; v1 submitted 14 March, 1993; originally announced March 1993.

Comments: (Revised and expanded version) 18 pages, LaTeX, DE-FG05-92ER40717-5

Applying Optimized Perturbation Theory to QCD at Low Energies

Authors: A. C. Mattingly, P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: We discuss the use of the optimization procedure based on the Principle of Minimal Sensitivity to the third-order calculation of {\mbox{${R_{e^+e^-}}$}}. The effective coupling constant remains finite allowing us to apply the Poggio-Quinn-Weinberg smearing method down to energies below 1 GeV, where we find good agreement between theory and experiment. The couplant freezes to a value of… ▽ More We discuss the use of the optimization procedure based on the Principle of Minimal Sensitivity to the third-order calculation of {\mbox{${R_{e^+e^-}}$}}. The effective coupling constant remains finite allowing us to apply the Poggio-Quinn-Weinberg smearing method down to energies below 1 GeV, where we find good agreement between theory and experiment. The couplant freezes to a value of $α_s/π= 0.26$ at zero energy which is in remarkable concordance with values obtained phenomenologically. △ Less

Submitted 7 December, 1992; originally announced December 1992.

Comments: Talk presented at DPF 92 Meeting, Fermilab, Nov. 1992. 3 pages Latex and dpf92 math macros, uufile encoded ps files (name fig3.psf). DE-FG05-92ER40717-1

Response to Brodsky and Lu's Letter "On the Self-Consistency of Scale-Setting Methods

Authors: P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: The claim that the Principle of Minimal Sensitivity is "disfavored" because it does not satisfy certain "self-consistency requirements" is meaningless, and shows a basic misunderstanding of the renormalization-scheme-dependence problem. The claim that the Principle of Minimal Sensitivity is "disfavored" because it does not satisfy certain "self-consistency requirements" is meaningless, and shows a basic misunderstanding of the renormalization-scheme-dependence problem. △ Less

Submitted 30 November, 1992; v1 submitted 27 November, 1992; originally announced November 1992.

Comments: 4 pages, LaTeX

Report number: DE-FG05-92ER40717-2

Gaussian Effective Potential for the U(1) Higgs Model

Authors: R. Ibanez-Meier, I. Stancu, P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: In order to investigate the Higgs mechanism nonperturbatively, we compute the Gaussian effective potential (GEP) of the U(1) Higgs model ("scalar electrodynamics"). We show that the same simple result is obtained in three different formalisms. A general covariant gauge is used, with Landau gauge proving to be optimal. The renormalization generalizes the "autonomous" renormalization for lambda-ph… ▽ More In order to investigate the Higgs mechanism nonperturbatively, we compute the Gaussian effective potential (GEP) of the U(1) Higgs model ("scalar electrodynamics"). We show that the same simple result is obtained in three different formalisms. A general covariant gauge is used, with Landau gauge proving to be optimal. The renormalization generalizes the "autonomous" renormalization for lambda-phi^4 theory and requires a particular relationship between the bare gauge coupling e_B and the bare scalar self- coupling lambda_B. When both couplings are small, then lambda is proportional to e^4 and the scalar/vector mass-squared ratio is of order e^2, as in the classic 1-loop analysis of Coleman and Weinberg. However, as lambda increases, e reaches a maximum value and then decreases, and in this "nonperturbative" regime the Higgs scalar can be much heavier than the vector boson. We compare our results to the autonomously renormalized 1-loop effective potential, finding many similarities. The main phenomenological implication is a Higgs mass of about 2 TeV. △ Less

Submitted 31 July, 1992; originally announced July 1992.

Comments: 24 pages, DOE/ER/05096-51, 5 figures (see top of LaTeX file)

Journal ref: Z.Phys. C70 (1996) 307-320

Autonomous Renormalization of the One-Loop Effective Potential and a 2 Tev Higgs in SU(2)xU(1)

Authors: R. Ibanez-Meier, P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: Branchina et al and Consoli have recently shown that the one-loop effective potential (1LEP) of massless lambda-phi**4 theory can be renormalized in two distinct ways. One of these is the conventional renormalization of Coleman and Weinberg. The other requires an infinite wavefunction renormalization, and is very similar to the "autonomous" renormalization of the Gaussian effective potential. We… ▽ More Branchina et al and Consoli have recently shown that the one-loop effective potential (1LEP) of massless lambda-phi**4 theory can be renormalized in two distinct ways. One of these is the conventional renormalization of Coleman and Weinberg. The other requires an infinite wavefunction renormalization, and is very similar to the "autonomous" renormalization of the Gaussian effective potential. We apply the "autonomous" renormalization to the 1LEP of the SU(2)x U(1) electroweak theory with zero bare Higgs mass. The predicted physical Higgs mass is 1.9 TeV. △ Less

Submitted 26 August, 1992; v1 submitted 15 July, 1992; originally announced July 1992.

Comments: 10 pages, LaTeX, (Revision includes additional discussion) DOE-ER-05096-52

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. B297 (1992) 144-150

QCD Perturbation Theory at Low Energies

Authors: A. C. Mattingly, P. M. Stevenson

Abstract: We apply the optimization procedure based on the Principle of Minimal Sensitivity to the third-order calculation of $\R$. The effective couplant remains finite, freezing to a value $α_s/π= 0.26$ at low energies. Using Poggio-Quinn-Weinberg smearing we find good agreement between theory and experiment right down to zero energy. We apply the optimization procedure based on the Principle of Minimal Sensitivity to the third-order calculation of $\R$. The effective couplant remains finite, freezing to a value $α_s/π= 0.26$ at low energies. Using Poggio-Quinn-Weinberg smearing we find good agreement between theory and experiment right down to zero energy. △ Less

Submitted 9 July, 1992; originally announced July 1992.

Comments: 11 pages including 3 Postscript Figures using Epsf.tex, LaTex

Report number: DOE/ER/05096-50

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.Lett. 69 (1992) 1320-1323