-
The CosmoVerse White Paper: Addressing observational tensions in cosmology with systematics and fundamental physics
Authors:
Eleonora Di Valentino,
Jackson Levi Said,
Adam Riess,
Agnieszka Pollo,
Vivian Poulin,
Adrià Gómez-Valent,
Amanda Weltman,
Antonella Palmese,
Caroline D. Huang,
Carsten van de Bruck,
Chandra Shekhar Saraf,
Cheng-Yu Kuo,
Cora Uhlemann,
Daniela Grandón,
Dante Paz,
Dominique Eckert,
Elsa M. Teixeira,
Emmanuel N. Saridakis,
Eoin Ó Colgáin,
Florian Beutler,
Florian Niedermann,
Francesco Bajardi,
Gabriela Barenboim,
Giulia Gubitosi,
Ilaria Musella
, et al. (513 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The standard model of cosmology has provided a good phenomenological description of a wide range of observations both at astrophysical and cosmological scales for several decades. This concordance model is constructed by a universal cosmological constant and supported by a matter sector described by the standard model of particle physics and a cold dark matter contribution, as well as very early-t…
▽ More
The standard model of cosmology has provided a good phenomenological description of a wide range of observations both at astrophysical and cosmological scales for several decades. This concordance model is constructed by a universal cosmological constant and supported by a matter sector described by the standard model of particle physics and a cold dark matter contribution, as well as very early-time inflationary physics, and underpinned by gravitation through general relativity. There have always been open questions about the soundness of the foundations of the standard model. However, recent years have shown that there may also be questions from the observational sector with the emergence of differences between certain cosmological probes. In this White Paper, we identify the key objectives that need to be addressed over the coming decade together with the core science projects that aim to meet these challenges. These discordances primarily rest on the divergence in the measurement of core cosmological parameters with varying levels of statistical confidence. These possible statistical tensions may be partially accounted for by systematics in various measurements or cosmological probes but there is also a growing indication of potential new physics beyond the standard model. After reviewing the principal probes used in the measurement of cosmological parameters, as well as potential systematics, we discuss the most promising array of potential new physics that may be observable in upcoming surveys. We also discuss the growing set of novel data analysis approaches that go beyond traditional methods to test physical models. [Abridged]
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2025; v1 submitted 2 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Scalar field dark matter with time-varying equation of state
Authors:
Gaspard Poulot,
Elsa M. Teixeira,
Carsten van de Bruck,
Nelson J. Nunes
Abstract:
We propose a new model of scalar field dark matter interacting with dark energy. Adopting a fluid description of the dark matter field in the regime of rapid oscillations, we find that the equation of state for dark matter is non-zero and even becomes increasingly negative at late times during dark energy domination. Furthermore, the speed of sound of dark matter is non-vanishing at all length sca…
▽ More
We propose a new model of scalar field dark matter interacting with dark energy. Adopting a fluid description of the dark matter field in the regime of rapid oscillations, we find that the equation of state for dark matter is non-zero and even becomes increasingly negative at late times during dark energy domination. Furthermore, the speed of sound of dark matter is non-vanishing at all length scales, and a non-adiabatic pressure contribution arises. The results indicate that there are still unexplored possible interactions within the dark sector that lead to novel background effects and can impact structure formation processes.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Cosmology and fundamental physics with the ELT-ANDES spectrograph
Authors:
C. J. A. P. Martins,
R. Cooke,
J. Liske,
M. T. Murphy,
P. Noterdaeme,
T. M. Schmidt,
J. S. Alcaniz,
C. S. Alves,
S. Balashev,
S. Cristiani,
P. Di Marcantonio,
R. Génova Santos,
R. S. Gonçalves,
J. I. González Hernández,
R. Maiolino,
A. Marconi,
C. M. J. Marques,
M. A. F. Melo e Sousa,
N. J. Nunes,
L. Origlia,
C. Péroux,
S. Vinzl,
A. Zanutta
Abstract:
State-of-the-art 19th century spectroscopy led to the discovery of quantum mechanics, and 20th century spectroscopy led to the confirmation of quantum electrodynamics. State-of-the-art 21st century astrophysical spectrographs, especially ANDES at ESO's ELT, have another opportunity to play a key role in the search for, and characterization of, the new physics which is known to be out there, waitin…
▽ More
State-of-the-art 19th century spectroscopy led to the discovery of quantum mechanics, and 20th century spectroscopy led to the confirmation of quantum electrodynamics. State-of-the-art 21st century astrophysical spectrographs, especially ANDES at ESO's ELT, have another opportunity to play a key role in the search for, and characterization of, the new physics which is known to be out there, waiting to be discovered. We rely on detailed simulations and forecast techniques to discuss four important examples of this point: big bang nucleosynthesis, the evolution of the cosmic microwave background temperature, tests of the universality of physical laws, and a real-time model-independent mapping of the expansion history of the universe (also known as the redshift drift). The last two are among the flagship science drivers for the ELT. We also highlight what is required for the ESO community to be able to play a meaningful role in 2030s fundamental cosmology and show that, even if ANDES only provides null results, such `minimum guaranteed science' will be in the form of constraints on key cosmological paradigms: these are independent from, and can be competitive with, those obtained from traditional cosmological probes.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2024; v1 submitted 27 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Relaxing cosmological constraints on current neutrino masses
Authors:
Vitor da Fonseca,
Tiago Barreiro,
Nelson J. Nunes
Abstract:
We show that a mass-varying neutrino model driven by scalar field dark energy relaxes the existing upper bound on the current neutrino mass to ${\sum m_ν< 0.72}$ eV. We extend the standard $Λ$ cold dark matter model by introducing two parameters: the rate of change of the scalar field with the number of $e$-folds and the coupling between neutrinos and the field. We investigate how they affect the…
▽ More
We show that a mass-varying neutrino model driven by scalar field dark energy relaxes the existing upper bound on the current neutrino mass to ${\sum m_ν< 0.72}$ eV. We extend the standard $Λ$ cold dark matter model by introducing two parameters: the rate of change of the scalar field with the number of $e$-folds and the coupling between neutrinos and the field. We investigate how they affect the matter power spectrum, the cosmic microwave background anisotropies and its lensing potential. The model is tested against Planck observations of temperature, polarization, and lensing, combined with baryon acoustic oscillation measurements that constrain the background evolution. The results indicate that small couplings favor a cosmological constant, while larger couplings favor a dynamical dark energy, weakening the upper bound on current neutrino masses.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2024; v1 submitted 3 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Fundamental physics with ESPRESSO: Constraints on Bekenstein and dark energy models from astrophysical and local probes
Authors:
C. J. A. P. Martins,
S. Cristiani,
G. Cupani,
V. D'Odorico,
R. Génova Santos,
A. C. O. Leite,
C. M. J. Marques,
D. Milaković,
P. Molaro,
Michael T. Murphy,
N. J. Nunes,
Tobias M. Schmidt,
V. Adibekyan,
Y. Alibert,
Paolo Di Marcantonio,
J. I. González Hernández,
D. Mégevand,
E. Palle,
F. A. Pepe,
N. C. Santos,
S. G. Sousa,
A. Sozzetti,
A. Suárez Mascareño,
M. R. Zapatero Osorio
Abstract:
Dynamical scalar fields in an effective four-dimensional field theory are naturally expected to couple to the rest of the theory's degrees of freedom, unless some new symmetry is postulated to suppress these couplings. In particular, a coupling to the electromagnetic sector will lead to spacetime variations of the fine-structure constant, $α$. Astrophysical tests of the space-time stability of…
▽ More
Dynamical scalar fields in an effective four-dimensional field theory are naturally expected to couple to the rest of the theory's degrees of freedom, unless some new symmetry is postulated to suppress these couplings. In particular, a coupling to the electromagnetic sector will lead to spacetime variations of the fine-structure constant, $α$. Astrophysical tests of the space-time stability of $α$ are therefore a powerful probe of new physics. Here we use ESPRESSO and other contemporary measurements of $α$, together with background cosmology data, local laboratory atomic clock and Weak Equivalence Principle measurements, to place stringent constraints on the simplest examples of the two broad classes of varying $α$ models: Bekenstein models and quintessence-type dark energy models, both of which are parametric extensions of the canonical $Λ$CDM model. In both cases, previously reported constraints are improved by more than a factor of ten. This improvement is largely due to the very strong local constraints, but astrophysical measurements can help to break degeneracies between cosmology and fundamental physics parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Most general cubic-order Horndeski Lagrangian allowing for scaling solutions and the application to dark energy
Authors:
Noemi Frusciante,
Ryotaro Kase,
Nelson J. Nunes,
Shinji Tsujikawa
Abstract:
In cubic-order Horndeski theories where a scalar field $φ$ is coupled to nonrelativistic matter with a field-dependent coupling $Q(φ)$, we derive the most general Lagrangian having scaling solutions on the isotropic and homogenous cosmological background. For constant $Q$ including the case of vanishing coupling, the corresponding Lagrangian reduces to the form $L=Xg_2(Y)-g_3(Y)\square φ$, where…
▽ More
In cubic-order Horndeski theories where a scalar field $φ$ is coupled to nonrelativistic matter with a field-dependent coupling $Q(φ)$, we derive the most general Lagrangian having scaling solutions on the isotropic and homogenous cosmological background. For constant $Q$ including the case of vanishing coupling, the corresponding Lagrangian reduces to the form $L=Xg_2(Y)-g_3(Y)\square φ$, where $X=-\partial_μφ\partial^μφ/2$ and $g_2, g_3$ are arbitrary functions of $Y=Xe^{λφ}$ with constant $λ$. We obtain the fixed points of the scaling Lagrangian for constant $Q$ and show that the $φ$-matter-dominated-epoch ($φ$MDE) is present for the cubic coupling $g_3(Y)$ containing inverse power-law functions of $Y$. The stability analysis around the fixed points indicates that the $φ$MDE can be followed by a stable critical point responsible for the cosmic acceleration. We propose a concrete dark energy model allowing for such a cosmological sequence and show that the ghost and Laplacian instabilities can be avoided even in the presence of the cubic coupling.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2018; v1 submitted 18 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Fundamental Cosmology from Precision Spectroscopy: I. Varying Couplings
Authors:
A. C. O. Leite,
C. J. A. P. Martins,
P. O. J. Pedrosa,
N. J. Nunes
Abstract:
The observational evidence for the acceleration of the universe demonstrates that canonical theories of cosmology and particle physics are incomplete, if not incorrect, and that new physics is out there, waiting to be discovered. Forthcoming high-resolution ultra-stable spectrographs will play a crucial role in this quest for new physics, by enabling a new generation of precision consistency tests…
▽ More
The observational evidence for the acceleration of the universe demonstrates that canonical theories of cosmology and particle physics are incomplete, if not incorrect, and that new physics is out there, waiting to be discovered. Forthcoming high-resolution ultra-stable spectrographs will play a crucial role in this quest for new physics, by enabling a new generation of precision consistency tests. Here we focus on astrophysical tests of the stability of nature's fundamental couplings, and by using Principal Component Analysis techniques further calibrated by existing VLT data we discuss how the improvements that can be expected with ESPRESSO and ELT-HIRES will impact on fundamental cosmology. In particular we show that a 20 to 30 night program on ELT-HIRES will allow it to play a leading role in fundamental cosmology.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Mass freezing in growing neutrino quintessence
Authors:
Nelson J. Nunes,
Lily Schrempp,
Christof Wetterich
Abstract:
Growing neutrino quintessence solves the coincidence problem for dark energy by a growing cosmological value of the neutrino mass which emerges from a cosmon-neutrino interaction stronger than gravity. The cosmon-mediated attraction between neutrinos induces the formation of large scale neutrino lumps in a recent cosmological epoch. We argue that the non-linearities in the cosmon field equations s…
▽ More
Growing neutrino quintessence solves the coincidence problem for dark energy by a growing cosmological value of the neutrino mass which emerges from a cosmon-neutrino interaction stronger than gravity. The cosmon-mediated attraction between neutrinos induces the formation of large scale neutrino lumps in a recent cosmological epoch. We argue that the non-linearities in the cosmon field equations stop the further increase of the neutrino mass within sufficiently dense and large lumps. As a result, we find the neutrino induced gravitational potential to be substantially reduced when compared to linear extrapolations. We furthermore demonstrate that inside a lump the possible time variation of fundamental constants is much smaller than their cosmological evolution. This feature may reconcile current geophysical bounds with claimed cosmological variations of the fine structure constant.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2011; v1 submitted 8 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Moduli evolution in the presence of thermal corrections
Authors:
T. Barreiro,
B. de Carlos,
E. J. Copeland,
N. J. Nunes
Abstract:
We study the effect of thermal corrections on the evolution of moduli in effective Supergravity models. This is motivated by previous results in the literature suggesting that these corrections could alter and, even, erase the presence of a minimum in the zero temperature potential, something that would have disastrous consequences in these particular models. We show that, in a representative sa…
▽ More
We study the effect of thermal corrections on the evolution of moduli in effective Supergravity models. This is motivated by previous results in the literature suggesting that these corrections could alter and, even, erase the presence of a minimum in the zero temperature potential, something that would have disastrous consequences in these particular models. We show that, in a representative sample of flux compactification constructions, this need not be the case, although we find that the inclusion of thermal corrections can dramatically decrease the region of initial conditions for which the moduli are stabilised. Moreover, the bounds on the reheating temperature coming from demanding that the full, finite temperature potential, has a minimum can be considerably relaxed given the slow pace at which the evolution proceeds.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2008; v1 submitted 14 December, 2007;
originally announced December 2007.
-
On the stability of field-theoretical regularizations of negative tension branes
Authors:
N. J. Nunes,
Marco Peloso
Abstract:
Any attempt to regularize a negative tension brane through a bulk scalar requires that this field is a ghost. One can try to improve in this aspect in a number of ways. For instance, it has been suggested to employ a field whose kinetic term is not sign definite, in the hope that the background may be overall stable. We show that this is not the case; the physical perturbations (gravity included…
▽ More
Any attempt to regularize a negative tension brane through a bulk scalar requires that this field is a ghost. One can try to improve in this aspect in a number of ways. For instance, it has been suggested to employ a field whose kinetic term is not sign definite, in the hope that the background may be overall stable. We show that this is not the case; the physical perturbations (gravity included) of the system do not extend across the zeros of the kinetic term; hence, all the modes are entirely localized either where the kinetic term is positive, or where it is negative; this second type of modes are ghosts. We show that this conclusion does not depend on the specific choice for the kinetic and potential functions for the bulk scalar.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2005;
originally announced June 2005.
-
Moduli evolution in the presence of flux compactifications
Authors:
T. Barreiro,
B. de Carlos,
E. J. Copeland,
N. J. Nunes
Abstract:
We study the cosmological evolution of the volume moduli in a class of recently proposed Inflationary Universe models arising out of Type IIB string theory, where a number of the moduli fields have been stabilised through flux compactifications. Developing an approach initially introduced in [3] we show, in agreement with [4], how the presence of extra sources of matter act so as to provide addi…
▽ More
We study the cosmological evolution of the volume moduli in a class of recently proposed Inflationary Universe models arising out of Type IIB string theory, where a number of the moduli fields have been stabilised through flux compactifications. Developing an approach initially introduced in [3] we show, in agreement with [4], how the presence of extra sources of matter act so as to provide additional friction, slowing the modulus field as it evolves down its potential, thereby vastly increasing the region of parameter space which leads to the eventual stabilisation of these fields. Extending the case to include both the real and imaginary parts of the volume modulus, we show how the parameter space of inital conditions is modified and comment on the impact for these inflationary models arising out of flux type compactifications.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2005; v1 submitted 6 June, 2005;
originally announced June 2005.
-
Reconstructing the dark energy equation of state with varying alpha
Authors:
N. J. Nunes,
James E. Lidsey
Abstract:
The possibility of reconstructing the dark energy equation of state from variations in the fine structure constant is investigated for a class of models where the quintessence field is non-minimally coupled to the electromagnetic field. For given classes of couplings and quintessence interaction potentials, it is typically found that variations in alpha would need to be measured to within an acc…
▽ More
The possibility of reconstructing the dark energy equation of state from variations in the fine structure constant is investigated for a class of models where the quintessence field is non-minimally coupled to the electromagnetic field. For given classes of couplings and quintessence interaction potentials, it is typically found that variations in alpha would need to be measured to within an accuracy of at least $5 \times 10^{-7}$ to obtain a reconstructed equation of state with less than a twenty per cent deviation from the true equation of state between redshifts 0 and 3. In this case, it is argued that the sign of the first derivative of the equation of state can be uncovered from the reconstruction, thus providing unique information on how the universe developed into its present dark energy dominated phase independent of high redshift surveys. Such information would complement future observations anticipated from the Supernova Acceleration Probe.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2004; v1 submitted 30 October, 2003;
originally announced October 2003.
-
Models of quintessence coupled to the electromagnetic field and the cosmological evolution of alpha
Authors:
E. J. Copeland,
N. J. Nunes,
M. Pospelov
Abstract:
We study the change of the effective fine structure constant in the cosmological models of a scalar field with a non-vanishing coupling to the electromagnetic field. Combining cosmological data and terrestrial observations we place empirical constraints on the size of the possible coupling and explore a large class of models that exhibit tracking behavior. The change of the fine structure consta…
▽ More
We study the change of the effective fine structure constant in the cosmological models of a scalar field with a non-vanishing coupling to the electromagnetic field. Combining cosmological data and terrestrial observations we place empirical constraints on the size of the possible coupling and explore a large class of models that exhibit tracking behavior. The change of the fine structure constant implied by the quasar absorption spectra together with the requirement of tracking behavior impose a lower bound of the size of this coupling. Furthermore, the transition to the quintessence regime implies a narrow window for this coupling around $10^{-5}$ in units of the inverse Planck mass. We also propose a non-minimal coupling between electromagnetism and quintessence which has the effect of leading only to changes of alpha determined from atomic physics phenomena, but leaving no observable consequences through nuclear physics effects. In doing so we are able to reconcile the claimed cosmological evidence for a changing fine structure constant with the tight constraints emerging from the Oklo natural nuclear reactor.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2003; v1 submitted 24 July, 2003;
originally announced July 2003.
-
Applications of scalar attractor solutions to Cosmology
Authors:
S. C. C. Ng,
N. J. Nunes,
F. Rosati
Abstract:
We develop a framework to study the phase space of a system consisting of a scalar field rolling down an arbitrary potential with varying slope and a background fluid, in a cosmological setting. We give analytical approximate solutions of the field evolution and discuss applications of its features to the issues of quintessence, moduli stabilisation and quintessential inflation.
We develop a framework to study the phase space of a system consisting of a scalar field rolling down an arbitrary potential with varying slope and a background fluid, in a cosmological setting. We give analytical approximate solutions of the field evolution and discuss applications of its features to the issues of quintessence, moduli stabilisation and quintessential inflation.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2001;
originally announced July 2001.
-
Moduli Evolution in Heterotic Scenarios
Authors:
T. Barreiro,
B. de Carlos,
N. J. Nunes
Abstract:
We discuss several aspects of the cosmological evolution of moduli fields in heterotic string/M-theory scenarios. In particular we study the equations of motion of both the dilaton and overall modulus of these theories in the presence of an expanding Universe and under different assumptions. First we analyse the impact of their couplings to matter fields, which turns out to be negligible in the…
▽ More
We discuss several aspects of the cosmological evolution of moduli fields in heterotic string/M-theory scenarios. In particular we study the equations of motion of both the dilaton and overall modulus of these theories in the presence of an expanding Universe and under different assumptions. First we analyse the impact of their couplings to matter fields, which turns out to be negligible in the string and M-theory scenarios. Then we examine in detail the possibility of scaling in M-theory, i.e. how the moduli would evolve naturally to their minima instead of rolling past them in the presence of a dominating background. In this case we find interesting and positive results, and we compare them to the analogous situation in the heterotic string.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2001; v1 submitted 10 October, 2000;
originally announced October 2000.
-
Quintessence models in Supergravity
Authors:
E. J. Copeland,
N. J. Nunes,
F. Rosati
Abstract:
Scalar field models of quintessence typically require that the expectation value of the field today is of order the Planck mass, if we want them to explain the observed acceleration of the Universe. This suggests that we should be considering models in the context of supergravity. We discuss a particular class of supergravity models and analyze their behavior under different choices of the Kahle…
▽ More
Scalar field models of quintessence typically require that the expectation value of the field today is of order the Planck mass, if we want them to explain the observed acceleration of the Universe. This suggests that we should be considering models in the context of supergravity. We discuss a particular class of supergravity models and analyze their behavior under different choices of the Kahler metric.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2000; v1 submitted 22 May, 2000;
originally announced May 2000.
-
Generalized Assisted Inflation
Authors:
E. J. Copeland,
Anupam Mazumdar,
N. J. Nunes
Abstract:
We obtain a new class of exact cosmological solutions for multi-scalar fields with exponential potentials. We generalize the assisted inflation solutions previously obtained, and demonstrate how they are modified when there exist cross-couplings between the fields, such as occur in supergravity inspired cosmological models.
We obtain a new class of exact cosmological solutions for multi-scalar fields with exponential potentials. We generalize the assisted inflation solutions previously obtained, and demonstrate how they are modified when there exist cross-couplings between the fields, such as occur in supergravity inspired cosmological models.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 1999;
originally announced April 1999.
-
Measurements of Omega and Lambda from 42 High-Redshift Supernovae
Authors:
S. Perlmutter,
G. Aldering,
G. Goldhaber,
R. A. Knop,
P. Nugent,
P. G. Castro,
S. Deustua,
S. Fabbro,
A. Goobar,
D. E. Groom,
I. M. Hook,
A. G. Kim,
M. Y. Kim,
J. C. Lee,
N. J. Nunes,
R. Pain,
C. R. Pennypacker,
R. Quimby,
C. Lidman,
R. S. Ellis,
M. Irwin,
R. G. McMahon,
P. Ruiz-Lapuente,
N. Walton,
B. Schaefer
, et al. (7 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We report measurements of the mass density, Omega_M, and cosmological-constant energy density, Omega_Lambda, of the universe based on the analysis of 42 Type Ia supernovae discovered by the Supernova Cosmology Project. The magnitude-redshift data for these SNe, at redshifts between 0.18 and 0.83, are fit jointly with a set of SNe from the Calan/Tololo Supernova Survey, at redshifts below 0.1, to…
▽ More
We report measurements of the mass density, Omega_M, and cosmological-constant energy density, Omega_Lambda, of the universe based on the analysis of 42 Type Ia supernovae discovered by the Supernova Cosmology Project. The magnitude-redshift data for these SNe, at redshifts between 0.18 and 0.83, are fit jointly with a set of SNe from the Calan/Tololo Supernova Survey, at redshifts below 0.1, to yield values for the cosmological parameters. All SN peak magnitudes are standardized using a SN Ia lightcurve width-luminosity relation. The measurement yields a joint probability distribution of the cosmological parameters that is approximated by the relation 0.8 Omega_M - 0.6 Omega_Lambda ~= -0.2 +/- 0.1 in the region of interest (Omega_M <~ 1.5). For a flat (Omega_M + Omega_Lambda = 1) cosmology we find Omega_M = 0.28{+0.09,-0.08} (1 sigma statistical) {+0.05,-0.04} (identified systematics). The data are strongly inconsistent with a Lambda = 0 flat cosmology, the simplest inflationary universe model. An open, Lambda = 0 cosmology also does not fit the data well: the data indicate that the cosmological constant is non-zero and positive, with a confidence of P(Lambda > 0) = 99%, including the identified systematic uncertainties. The best-fit age of the universe relative to the Hubble time is t_0 = 14.9{+1.4,-1.1} (0.63/h) Gyr for a flat cosmology. The size of our sample allows us to perform a variety of statistical tests to check for possible systematic errors and biases. We find no significant differences in either the host reddening distribution or Malmquist bias between the low-redshift Calan/Tololo sample and our high-redshift sample. The conclusions are robust whether or not a width-luminosity relation is used to standardize the SN peak magnitudes.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 1998;
originally announced December 1998.
