-
Chiral Condensate and Spectral Density at full five-loop and partial six-loop orders of Renormalization Group Optimized Perturbation
Authors:
Jean-Loic Kneur,
André Neveu
Abstract:
We reconsider our former determination of the chiral quark condensate $\langle \bar q q \rangle$ from the related QCD spectral density of the Euclidean Dirac operator, using our Renormalization Group Optimized Perturbation (RGOPT) approach. Thanks to the recently available {\em complete} five-loop QCD RG coefficients, and some other related four-loop results, we can extend our calculations exactly…
▽ More
We reconsider our former determination of the chiral quark condensate $\langle \bar q q \rangle$ from the related QCD spectral density of the Euclidean Dirac operator, using our Renormalization Group Optimized Perturbation (RGOPT) approach. Thanks to the recently available {\em complete} five-loop QCD RG coefficients, and some other related four-loop results, we can extend our calculations exactly to $N^4LO$ (five-loops) RGOPT, and partially to $N^5LO$ (six-loops), the latter within a well-defined approximation accounting for all six-loop contents exactly predictable from five-loops RG properties. The RGOPT results overall show a very good stability and convergence, giving primarily the RG invariant condensate, $\langle \bar q q\rangle^{1/3}_{RGI}(n_f=0) = -(0.840_{-0.016}^{+0.020}) \barΛ_0 $, $\langle\bar q q\rangle^{1/3}_{RGI}(n_f=2) = -(0.781_{-0.009}^{+0.019}) \barΛ_2 $, $\langle\bar q q\rangle^{1/3}_{RGI}(n_f=3) = -(0.751_{-.010}^{+0.019}) \barΛ_3 $, where $\barΛ_{n_f}$ is the basic QCD scale in the \overline{MS} scheme for $n_f$ quark flavors, and the range spanned is our rather conservative estimated theoretical error. This leads {\it e.g.} to $ \langle\bar q q\rangle^{1/3}_{n_f=3}(2\, {\rm GeV}) = -(273^{+7}_{-4}\pm 13)$ MeV, using the latest $\barΛ_3$ values giving the second uncertainties. We compare our results with some other recent determinations. As a by-product of our analysis we also provide complete five-loop and partial six-loop expressions of the perturbative QCD spectral density, that may be useful for other purposes.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Quark Condensate from Renormalization Group Optimized Spectral Density
Authors:
J. -L. Kneur,
A. Neveu
Abstract:
Our renormalization group consistent variant of optimized perturbation, RGOPT, is used to calculate the nonperturbative QCD spectral density of the Dirac operator and the related chiral quark condensate $\langle \bar q q \rangle$, for $n_f=2$ and $n_f=3$ massless quarks. Sequences of approximations at two-, three-, and four-loop orders are very stable and give…
▽ More
Our renormalization group consistent variant of optimized perturbation, RGOPT, is used to calculate the nonperturbative QCD spectral density of the Dirac operator and the related chiral quark condensate $\langle \bar q q \rangle$, for $n_f=2$ and $n_f=3$ massless quarks. Sequences of approximations at two-, three-, and four-loop orders are very stable and give $\langle \bar q q \rangle^{1/3}_{n_f=2}(2\, {\rm GeV}) = -(0.833-0.845) \barΛ_2 $, and $ \langle \bar q q \rangle^{1/3}_{n_f=3}(2\, {\rm GeV}) = -(0.814-0.838) \barΛ_3 $ where the range is our estimated theoretical error and $\barΛ_{n_f}$ the basic QCD scale in the $\rm \bar{MS}$-scheme. We compare those results with other recent determinations (from lattice calculations and spectral sum rules).
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
The chiral condensate from renormalization group optimized perturbation
Authors:
J. -L. Kneur,
A. Neveu
Abstract:
Our recently developed variant of variationnally optimized perturbation (OPT), in particular consistently incorporating renormalization group properties (RGOPT), is adapted to the calculation of the QCD spectral density of the Dirac operator and the related chiral quark condensate $\langle \bar q q \rangle$ in the chiral limit, for $n_f=2$ and $n_f=3$ massless quarks. The results of successive seq…
▽ More
Our recently developed variant of variationnally optimized perturbation (OPT), in particular consistently incorporating renormalization group properties (RGOPT), is adapted to the calculation of the QCD spectral density of the Dirac operator and the related chiral quark condensate $\langle \bar q q \rangle$ in the chiral limit, for $n_f=2$ and $n_f=3$ massless quarks. The results of successive sequences of approximations at two-, three-, and four-loop orders of this modified perturbation, exhibit a remarkable stability. We obtain $\langle \bar q q\rangle^{1/3}_{n_f=2}(2\, {\rm GeV}) = -(0.833-0.845) \barΛ_2 $, and $ \langle\bar q q\rangle^{1/3}_{n_f=3}(2\, {\rm GeV}) = -(0.814-0.838) \barΛ_3 $ where the range spanned by the first and second numbers (respectively four- and three-loop order results) defines our theoretical error, and $\barΛ_{n_f}$ is the basic QCD scale in the $\overline{MS}$-scheme. We obtain a moderate suppression of the chiral condensate when going from $n_f=2$ to $n_f=3$. We compare these results with some other recent determinations from other nonperturbative methods (mainly lattice and spectral sum rules).
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2015; v1 submitted 24 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
A new determination of $α_S$ from Renormalization Group Optimized Perturbation
Authors:
J-L. Kneur,
A. Neveu
Abstract:
A new version of the so-called optimized perturbation (OPT), implementing consistently renormalization group properties, is used to calculate the nonperturbative ratio $F_π/\overlineΛ$ of the pion decay constant and the basic QCD scale in the $\overline{MS}$ scheme. Using the experimental $F_π$ input value it provides a new determination of $\overlineΛ$ for $n_f=2$ and $n_f=3$, and of the QCD coup…
▽ More
A new version of the so-called optimized perturbation (OPT), implementing consistently renormalization group properties, is used to calculate the nonperturbative ratio $F_π/\overlineΛ$ of the pion decay constant and the basic QCD scale in the $\overline{MS}$ scheme. Using the experimental $F_π$ input value it provides a new determination of $\overlineΛ$ for $n_f=2$ and $n_f=3$, and of the QCD coupling constant $\overlineα_S $ at various scales once combined with a standard perturbative evolution. The stability and empirical convergence properties of the RGOPT modified series is demonstrated up to the third order. We examine the difference sources of theoretical uncertainties and obtain $\overlineα_S (m_Z) =0.1174 ^{+.0010}_{-.0005} \pm .001 \pm .0005_{evol}$, where the first errors are estimates of the intrinsic theoretical uncertainties of our method, and the second errors come from present uncertainties in $F_π/F_0$, where $F_0$ is $F_π$ in the exact chiral $SU(3)$ limit.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
α_S from $F_π$ and Renormalization Group Optimized Perturbation
Authors:
J. -L. Kneur,
A. Neveu
Abstract:
A variant of variationally optimized perturbation, incorporating renormalization group properties in a straightforward way, uniquely fixes the variational mass interpolation in terms of the anomalous mass dimension. It is used at three successive orders to calculate the nonperturbative ratio $F_π/Λ$ of the pion decay constant and the basic QCD scale in the MSbar scheme. We demonstrate the good sta…
▽ More
A variant of variationally optimized perturbation, incorporating renormalization group properties in a straightforward way, uniquely fixes the variational mass interpolation in terms of the anomalous mass dimension. It is used at three successive orders to calculate the nonperturbative ratio $F_π/Λ$ of the pion decay constant and the basic QCD scale in the MSbar scheme. We demonstrate the good stability and (empirical) convergence properties of this modified perturbative series for this quantity, and provide simple and generic cures to previous problems of the method, principally the generally non-unique and non-real optimal solutions beyond lowest order. Using the experimental $F_π$ input value we determine Λ^{n_f=2}\simeq 359^{+38}_{-25} \pm 5 MeV and Λ^{n_f=3}=317^{+14}_{-7} \pm 13 MeV, where the first quoted errors are our estimate of theoretical uncertainties of the method, which we consider conservative. The second uncertainties come from the present uncertainties in F_π/F and F_π/F_0, where F (F_0) is $F_π$ in the exact chiral SU(2) (SU(3)) limits. Combining the Λ^{n_f=3} results with a standard perturbative evolution provides a new independent determination of the strong coupling constant at various relevant scales, in particular α_S (m_Z) =0.1174 ^{+.0010}_{-.0005} \pm .001 \pm .0005_{evol} and α_S^{n_f=3}(m_τ)= 0.308 ^{+.007}_{-.004} \pm .007 \pm .002_{evol}. A less conservative interpretation of our prescriptions favors central values closer to the upper limits of the first uncertainties. The theoretical accuracy is well comparable to the most precise recent {\em single} determinations of α_S, including some very recent lattice simulation determinations with fully dynamical quarks.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2013; v1 submitted 29 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Lambda^{QCD}_{MS} from Renormalization Group Optimized Perturbation
Authors:
J. -L. Kneur,
A. Neveu
Abstract:
A recent extension of a variationally optimized perturbation, combined with renormalization group properties in a straightforward way, can provide approximations to nonperturbative quantities such as the chiral symmetry breaking order parameters typically. We apply this to evaluate, up to third order in this modified perturbation, the ratio Fpi/Lambda, where Fpi is the pion decay constant and Lamb…
▽ More
A recent extension of a variationally optimized perturbation, combined with renormalization group properties in a straightforward way, can provide approximations to nonperturbative quantities such as the chiral symmetry breaking order parameters typically. We apply this to evaluate, up to third order in this modified perturbation, the ratio Fpi/Lambda, where Fpi is the pion decay constant and Lambda the basic QCD scale in the modified MS scheme. Using experimental Fpi input value we obtain Lambda(nf=2) ~ 255_{-15}^{+40} MeV, where quoted errors are estimates of theoretical uncertainties of the method. This compares reasonably well with some recent lattice simulation results. We briefly discuss prospects (and obstacles) for extrapolation to alpha_S(mu) at perturbative mu values.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
-
Renormalization Group Improved Optimized Perturbation Theory: Revisiting the Mass Gap of the O(2N) Gross-Neveu Model
Authors:
J. -L. Kneur,
A. Neveu
Abstract:
We introduce an extension of a variationally optimized perturbation method, by combining it with renormalization group properties in a straightforward (perturbative) form. This leads to a very transparent and efficient procedure, with a clear improvement of the non-perturbative results with respect to previous similar variational approaches. This is illustrated here by deriving optimized results…
▽ More
We introduce an extension of a variationally optimized perturbation method, by combining it with renormalization group properties in a straightforward (perturbative) form. This leads to a very transparent and efficient procedure, with a clear improvement of the non-perturbative results with respect to previous similar variational approaches. This is illustrated here by deriving optimized results for the mass gap of the O(2N) Gross-Neveu model, compared with the exactly know results for arbitrary N. At large N, the exact result is reproduced already at the very first order of the modified perturbation using this procedure. For arbitrary values of N, using the original perturbative information only known at two-loop order, we obtain a controllable percent accuracy or less, for any N value, as compared with the exactly known result for the mass gap from the thermodynamical Bethe Ansatz. The procedure is very general and can be extended straightforwardly to any renormalizable Lagrangian model, being systematically improvable provided that a knowledge of enough perturbative orders of the relevant quantities is available.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2010; v1 submitted 27 April, 2010;
originally announced April 2010.
-
Chiral Symmetry Breaking in QCD: A Variational Approach
Authors:
C. Arvanitis,
F. Geniet,
J. -L. Kneur,
A. Neveu
Abstract:
We develop a "variational mass" expansion approach, recently introduced in the Gross--Neveu model, to evaluate some of the order parameters of chiral symmetry breakdown in QCD. The method relies on a reorganization of the usual perturbation theory with the addition of an "arbitrary quark mass $m$, whose non-perturbative behaviour is inferred partly from renormalization group properties, and from…
▽ More
We develop a "variational mass" expansion approach, recently introduced in the Gross--Neveu model, to evaluate some of the order parameters of chiral symmetry breakdown in QCD. The method relies on a reorganization of the usual perturbation theory with the addition of an "arbitrary quark mass $m$, whose non-perturbative behaviour is inferred partly from renormalization group properties, and from analytic continuation in $m$ properties. The resulting ansatz can be optimized, and in the chiral limit $m \to 0$ we estimate the dynamical contribution to the "constituent" masses of the light quarks $M_{u,d,s}$; the pion decay constant $F_π$ and the quark condensate $< \bar q q >$.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 1996;
originally announced September 1996.
-
Variational Solution of the Gross-Neveu Model: finite $N$ and Renormalization
Authors:
C. Arvanitis,
F. Geniet,
M. Iacomi,
J. -L. Kneur,
A. Neveu
Abstract:
We show how to perform systematically improvable variational calculations in the $O(2N)$ Gross-Neveu model for generic $N$, in such a way that all infinities usually plaguing such calculations are accounted for in a way compatible with the perturbative renormalization group . The final point is a general framework for the calculation of non-perturbative quantities like condensates, masses etc…
▽ More
We show how to perform systematically improvable variational calculations in the $O(2N)$ Gross-Neveu model for generic $N$, in such a way that all infinities usually plaguing such calculations are accounted for in a way compatible with the perturbative renormalization group . The final point is a general framework for the calculation of non-perturbative quantities like condensates, masses etc$\ldots$, in an asymptotically free field theory. For the Gross-Neveu model, the numerical results obtained from a ``2-loop'' down to low values of $N$.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 1996; v1 submitted 14 November, 1995;
originally announced November 1995.
