Showing 1–45 of 45 results for author: Neill, D

Scattering Neutrinos, Spin Models, and Permutations

Authors: Duff Neill, Hanqing Liu, Joshua Martin, Alessandro Roggero

Abstract: We consider a class of Heisenberg all-to-all coupled spin models inspired by neutrino interactions in a supernova with $N$ degrees of freedom. These models are characterized by a coupling matrix that is relatively simple in the sense that there are only a few, relative to $N$, non-trivial eigenvalues, in distinction to the classic Heisenberg spin-glass models, leading to distinct behavior in both… ▽ More We consider a class of Heisenberg all-to-all coupled spin models inspired by neutrino interactions in a supernova with $N$ degrees of freedom. These models are characterized by a coupling matrix that is relatively simple in the sense that there are only a few, relative to $N$, non-trivial eigenvalues, in distinction to the classic Heisenberg spin-glass models, leading to distinct behavior in both the high-temperature and low-temperature regimes. When the momenta of the neutrinos are uniform and random in directions, we can calculate the large-$N$ partition function for the quantum Heisenberg model. In particular, the high-temperature partition function predicts a non-Gaussian density of states, providing interesting counter-examples showing the limits of general theorems on the density of states for quantum spin models. We can repeat the same argument for classical Heisenberg models, also known as rotor models, and we find the high-temperature expansion is completely controlled by the eigenvalues of the coupling matrix, and again predicts non-Gaussian behavior for the density of states as long as the number of eigenvalues does not scale linearly with $N$. Indeed, we derive the amusing fact that these \emph{thermodynamic} partition functions are essentially the generating function for counting permutations in the high-temperature regime. Finally, for the case relevant to neutrinos in a supernova, we identify the low-temperature phase as a unique state with the direction of the momenta of the neutrino dictating its coherent state in flavor-space, a state we dub the "flavor-momentum-locked" state. △ Less

Submitted 26 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Comments: 26 pg., 3 app, multiple figs

Report number: LA-UR-24-25341

Flavor Fragmentation Function Factorization

Authors: Andrew J. Larkoski, Duff Neill

Abstract: A definition of partonic jet flavor that is both theoretically well-defined and experimentally robust would have profound implications for measurements and predictions especially for heavy flavor applications. Recently, a definition of jet flavor was introduced as the net flavor flowing along the direction of the Winner-Take-All axis of a jet which is soft safe to all orders, but not collinear saf… ▽ More A definition of partonic jet flavor that is both theoretically well-defined and experimentally robust would have profound implications for measurements and predictions especially for heavy flavor applications. Recently, a definition of jet flavor was introduced as the net flavor flowing along the direction of the Winner-Take-All axis of a jet which is soft safe to all orders, but not collinear safe. Here, we exploit the lack of collinear safety and propose a factorization theorem of perturbative flavor fragmentation functions that resum collinear divergences and describe the evolution of flavor from the short distance of jet production to the long distance at which hadronization occurs. Collinear flavor evolution is governed by a small modification of the DGLAP equations. We present a detailed all-orders analysis and identify exact relations that must hold amongst the various anomalous dimensions by probability conservation and the existence of fixed points of the renormalization group flow. We explicitly validate the factorization theorem at one-loop order, and demonstrate its consistency at two loops in particular flavor channels. Starting at two-loops, constraints on phase space imposed by flavor measurements potentially allow for non-trivial soft contributions, but we demonstrate that they are scaleless and so explicitly vanish, ensuring that soft particles are summed inclusively and all divergences are exclusively collinear in nature. This factorization theorem opens the door to precision calculations with identified flavor in the infrared. △ Less

Submitted 3 January, 2024; v1 submitted 2 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 38 pages + appendices, 1 figure; v2: JHEP version, some minor expansions of explanations

Report number: LA-UR-23-31203

Equilibration of quantum many-body fast neutrino flavor oscillations

Authors: Joshua D. Martin, Duff Neill, A. Roggero, Huaiyu Duan, J. Carlson

Abstract: Neutrino gases are expected to form in high density astrophysical environments, and accurately modeling their flavor evolution is critical to understanding such environments. In this work we study a simplified model of such a dense neutrino gas in the regime for which neutrino-neutrino coherent forward scattering is the dominant mechanism contributing to the flavor evolution. We show evidence that… ▽ More Neutrino gases are expected to form in high density astrophysical environments, and accurately modeling their flavor evolution is critical to understanding such environments. In this work we study a simplified model of such a dense neutrino gas in the regime for which neutrino-neutrino coherent forward scattering is the dominant mechanism contributing to the flavor evolution. We show evidence that the generic potential induced by this effect is non-integrable and that the statistics of its energy level spaces are in good agreement with the Wigner surmise. We also find that individual neutrinos rapidly entangle with all of the others present which results in an equilibration of the flavor content of individual neutrinos. We show that the average neutrino flavor content can be predicted utilizing a thermodynamic partition function. A random phase approximation to the evolution gives a simple picture of this equilibration. In the case of neutrinos and antineutrinos, processes like $ν_e {\barν}_e \leftrightarrows ν_μ{\barν_μ} $ yield a rapid equilibrium satisfying $n( ν_e) n({\bar ν}_e) = n( ν_μ) n({\bar ν}_μ) = n( ν_τ) n({\bar ν}_τ)$ in addition to the standard lepton number conservation in regimes where off-diagonal vacuum oscillations are small compared to $ν-ν$ interactions. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2024; v1 submitted 31 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 16 pages, 8 figures, 1 appendix

Report number: LA-UR-23-28635

The case for an EIC Theory Alliance: Theoretical Challenges of the EIC

Authors: Raktim Abir, Igor Akushevich, Tolga Altinoluk, Daniele Paolo Anderle, Fatma P. Aslan, Alessandro Bacchetta, Baha Balantekin, Joao Barata, Marco Battaglieri, Carlos A. Bertulani, Guillaume Beuf, Chiara Bissolotti, Daniël Boer, M. Boglione, Radja Boughezal, Eric Braaten, Nora Brambilla, Vladimir Braun, Duane Byer, Francesco Giovanni Celiberto, Yang-Ting Chien, Ian C. Cloët, Martha Constantinou, Wim Cosyn, Aurore Courtoy , et al. (146 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We outline the physics opportunities provided by the Electron Ion Collider (EIC). These include the study of the parton structure of the nucleon and nuclei, the onset of gluon saturation, the production of jets and heavy flavor, hadron spectroscopy and tests of fundamental symmetries. We review the present status and future challenges in EIC theory that have to be addressed in order to realize thi… ▽ More We outline the physics opportunities provided by the Electron Ion Collider (EIC). These include the study of the parton structure of the nucleon and nuclei, the onset of gluon saturation, the production of jets and heavy flavor, hadron spectroscopy and tests of fundamental symmetries. We review the present status and future challenges in EIC theory that have to be addressed in order to realize this ambitious and impactful physics program, including how to engage a diverse and inclusive workforce. In order to address these many-fold challenges, we propose a coordinated effort involving theory groups with differing expertise is needed. We discuss the scientific goals and scope of such an EIC Theory Alliance. △ Less

Submitted 23 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: 44 pages, ReVTeX, White Paper on EIC Theory Alliance

Small-$x$ Factorization from Effective Field Theory

Authors: Duff Neill, Aditya Pathak, Iain Stewart

Abstract: We derive a factorization theorem that allows for resummation of small-$x$ logarithms by exploiting Glauber operators in the soft collinear effective field theory. Our analysis is carried out for the hadronic tensor $W^{μν}$ in deep inelastic scattering, and leads to the definition of a new gauge invariant soft function $S^{μν}$ that describes quark and gluon emission in the central region. This s… ▽ More We derive a factorization theorem that allows for resummation of small-$x$ logarithms by exploiting Glauber operators in the soft collinear effective field theory. Our analysis is carried out for the hadronic tensor $W^{μν}$ in deep inelastic scattering, and leads to the definition of a new gauge invariant soft function $S^{μν}$ that describes quark and gluon emission in the central region. This soft function provides a new framework for extending resummed calculations for coefficient functions to higher logarithmic orders. Our factorization also defines impact factors by universal collinear functions that are process independent, for instance being identical in small-$x$ DIS and Drell-Yan. △ Less

Submitted 23 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: 43 pgs

Report number: MIT-CTP/5529, DESY-23-024, UWThPh 2023-3

Snowmass 2021 White Paper: Electron Ion Collider for High Energy Physics

Authors: R. Abdul Khalek, U. D'Alesio, M. Arratia, A. Bacchetta, M. Battaglieri, M. Begel, M. Boglione, R. Boughezal, R. Boussarie, G. Bozzi, S. V. Chekanov, F. G. Celiberto, G. Chirilli, T. Cridge, R. Cruz-Torres, R. Corliss, C. Cotton, H. Davoudiasl, A. Deshpande, X. Dong, A. Emmert, S. Fazio, S. Forte, Y. Furletova, C. Gal , et al. (83 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: Electron Ion Collider (EIC) is a particle accelerator facility planned for construction at Brookhaven National Laboratory on Long Island, New York by the United States Department of Energy. EIC will provide capabilities of colliding beams of polarized electrons with polarized beams of proton and light ions. EIC will be one of the largest and most sophisticated new accelerator facilities worldwide,… ▽ More Electron Ion Collider (EIC) is a particle accelerator facility planned for construction at Brookhaven National Laboratory on Long Island, New York by the United States Department of Energy. EIC will provide capabilities of colliding beams of polarized electrons with polarized beams of proton and light ions. EIC will be one of the largest and most sophisticated new accelerator facilities worldwide, and the only new large-scale accelerator facility planned for construction in the United States in the next few decades. The versatility, resolving power and intensity of EIC will present many new opportunities to address some of the crucial and fundamental open scientific questions in particle physics. This document provides an overview of the science case of EIC from the perspective of the high energy physics community. △ Less

Submitted 17 October, 2022; v1 submitted 24 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: Submitted to the Proceedings of the US Community Study on the Future of Particle Physics (Snowmass 2021)

Snowmass 2021 White Paper: Resummation for future colliders

Authors: Melissa van Beekveld, Sebastian Jaskiewicz, Tao Liu, Xiaohui Liu, Duff Neill, Alexander Penin, Felix Ringer, Robert Szafron, Leonardo Vernazza, Gherardo Vita, Jian Wang

Abstract: Resummation techniques are essential for high-precision phenomenology at current and future high-energy collider experiments. Perturbative computations of cross sections often suffer from large logarithmic corrections, which must be resummed to all orders to restore the reliability of predictions from first principles. The precise understanding of the all-order structure of field theories allows f… ▽ More Resummation techniques are essential for high-precision phenomenology at current and future high-energy collider experiments. Perturbative computations of cross sections often suffer from large logarithmic corrections, which must be resummed to all orders to restore the reliability of predictions from first principles. The precise understanding of the all-order structure of field theories allows for fundamental tests of the Standard Model and new physics searches. In this white paper, we review recent progress in modern resummation techniques and outline future directions. In particular, we focus on the resummation beyond leading power, the joint resummation of different classes of logarithms relevant for jets and their substructure, small-$x$ resummation in the high-energy regime and the QCD fragmentation process in the small-$z_h$ limit. △ Less

Submitted 9 May, 2022; v1 submitted 15 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: Contribution to Snowmass 2021

Report number: IPPP/22/11, SLAC-PUB-17664, YITP-SB-2022-06

Energy-Energy Correlators for Precision QCD

Authors: Duff Neill, Gherardo Vita, Ivan Vitev, Hua Xing Zhu

Abstract: In this contribution to the Proceedings of the US Community Study on the Future of Particle Physics (Snowmass 2021) we review recent progress in the evaluation and application of the Energy-Energy Correlator (EEC) event shape observable in $e^+e^-$ annihilation, hadronic collisions, and deep inelastic scattering. The importance of EEC as a precision probe of the perturbative and non perturbative a… ▽ More In this contribution to the Proceedings of the US Community Study on the Future of Particle Physics (Snowmass 2021) we review recent progress in the evaluation and application of the Energy-Energy Correlator (EEC) event shape observable in $e^+e^-$ annihilation, hadronic collisions, and deep inelastic scattering. The importance of EEC as a precision probe of the perturbative and non perturbative aspects of QCD dynamics is emphasized. It can be used to extract the strong coupling constant and to constrain TMD distribution functions. Closely related energy-correlation shape variables have also been used to tag boosted objects produced in high energy collisions. The opportunities to study EEC at the future Electron-Ion Collider are also highlighted. △ Less

Submitted 14 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: 18 pages, 10 figures. Submitted to the Proceedings of the US Community Study on the Future of Particle Physics (Snowmass 2021)

Leading jets and energy loss

Authors: Duff Neill, Felix Ringer, Nobuo Sato

Abstract: The formation and evolution of leading jets can be described by jet functions which satisfy non-linear DGLAP-type evolution equations. Different than for inclusive jets, the leading jet functions constitute normalized probability densities for the leading jet to carry a longitudinal momentum fraction relative to the initial fragmenting parton. We present a parton shower algorithm which allows for… ▽ More The formation and evolution of leading jets can be described by jet functions which satisfy non-linear DGLAP-type evolution equations. Different than for inclusive jets, the leading jet functions constitute normalized probability densities for the leading jet to carry a longitudinal momentum fraction relative to the initial fragmenting parton. We present a parton shower algorithm which allows for the calculation of leading-jet cross sections where logarithms of the jet radius and threshold logarithms are resummed to next-to-leading logarithmic (NLL$'$) accuracy. By calculating the mean of the leading jet distribution, we are able to quantify the average out-of-jet radiation, the so-called jet energy loss. When an additional reference scale is measured, we are able to determine the energy loss of leading jets at the cross section level which is identical to parton energy loss at leading-logarithmic accuracy. We identify several suitable cross sections for an extraction of the jet energy loss and we present numerical results for leading subjets at the LHC. In addition, we consider hemisphere and event-wide leading jets in electron-positron annihilation similar to measurements performed at LEP. Besides the average energy loss, we also consider its variance and other statistical quantities such as the KL divergence which quantifies the difference between quark and gluon jet energy loss. We expect that our results will be particularly relevant for quantifying the energy loss of quark and gluon jets that propagate through hot or cold nuclear matter. △ Less

Submitted 30 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 58 pages, 20 figures

Report number: JLAB-THY-21-3339, LA-UR-21-22574

Explainable machine learning of the underlying physics of high-energy particle collisions

Authors: Yue Shi Lai, Duff Neill, Mateusz Płoskoń, Felix Ringer

Abstract: We present an implementation of an explainable and physics-aware machine learning model capable of inferring the underlying physics of high-energy particle collisions using the information encoded in the energy-momentum four-vectors of the final state particles. We demonstrate the proof-of-concept of our White Box AI approach using a Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) which learns from a DGLAP-b… ▽ More We present an implementation of an explainable and physics-aware machine learning model capable of inferring the underlying physics of high-energy particle collisions using the information encoded in the energy-momentum four-vectors of the final state particles. We demonstrate the proof-of-concept of our White Box AI approach using a Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) which learns from a DGLAP-based parton shower Monte Carlo event generator. We show, for the first time, that our approach leads to a network that is able to learn not only the final distribution of particles, but also the underlying parton branching mechanism, i.e. the Altarelli-Parisi splitting function, the ordering variable of the shower, and the scaling behavior. While the current work is focused on perturbative physics of the parton shower, we foresee a broad range of applications of our framework to areas that are currently difficult to address from first principles in QCD. Examples include nonperturbative and collective effects, factorization breaking and the modification of the parton shower in heavy-ion, and electron-nucleus collisions. △ Less

Submitted 11 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: 11 pages, 4 figures

The Fragmentation Spectrum from Space-Time Reciprocity

Authors: Duff Neill

Abstract: Analyzing the single inclusive annihilation spectrum of charged hadrons in $e^+e^-$ collisions, I confront the hadronization hypothesis of local parton-hadron duality with a systematic resummation of the dependence on the small energy fraction. This resummation is based on the reciprocity between time-like and space-like splitting processes in $4-2ε$-dimensions, which I extend to resum all the sof… ▽ More Analyzing the single inclusive annihilation spectrum of charged hadrons in $e^+e^-$ collisions, I confront the hadronization hypothesis of local parton-hadron duality with a systematic resummation of the dependence on the small energy fraction. This resummation is based on the reciprocity between time-like and space-like splitting processes in $4-2ε$-dimensions, which I extend to resum all the soft terms of the cross-section for inclusive jet production. Under the local-parton-hadron duality hypothesis, the resulting distribution of jets essentially determines the spectrum of hadrons as the jet radius goes to zero. Thus I take the resummed perturbative jet function as the non-perturbative fragmentation function with an effective infra-red coupling. I find excellent agreement with data, and comment on the mixed leading log approximation previously used to justify local parton-hadron duality. △ Less

Submitted 22 December, 2020; v1 submitted 6 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Comments: 24 pgs. 15 figs, v3 corrected more typos, improved notation. Added more plots for large momentum region

Calculating the energy loss of leading jets

Authors: Duff Neill, Felix Ringer, Nobuo Sato

Abstract: The energy loss mechanism of jets plays a central role in nuclear and high energy physics. We propose direct measurements of the energy loss of leading jets and perform a calculation at next-to-leading logarithmic (NLL$'$) accuracy in the vacuum. The formation of leading jets can be described by jet functions which constitute probability densities and thus allow for a perturbative calculation of t… ▽ More The energy loss mechanism of jets plays a central role in nuclear and high energy physics. We propose direct measurements of the energy loss of leading jets and perform a calculation at next-to-leading logarithmic (NLL$'$) accuracy in the vacuum. The formation of leading jets can be described by jet functions which constitute probability densities and thus allow for a perturbative calculation of the average the energy loss. We identify the following three criteria for a direct measurement of jet energy loss at the cross section level. $i)$ We measure a well defined object, the leading jet, where the formation process can be expressed in terms of a probability density. $ii)$ In addition, we need a measurement of a hard reference scale with respect to which jet energy loss is defined. $iii)$ At leading logarithmic accuracy, we require that the jet energy loss can be identified with parton energy loss. We discuss suitable observables and present numerical results including threshold corrections by making use of a parton shower Monte Carlo approach. △ Less

Submitted 21 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Comments: 7 pages, 3 figures, 10th International Conference on Hard and Electromagnetic Probes of High-Energy Nuclear Collisions

Asymmetric jet clustering in deep-inelastic scattering

Authors: Miguel Arratia, Yiannis Makris, Duff Neill, Felix Ringer, Nobuo Sato

Abstract: We propose a new jet algorithm for deep-inelastic scattering (DIS) that accounts for the forward-backward asymmetry in the Breit frame. The Centauro algorithm is longitudinally invariant and can cluster jets with Born kinematics, which enables novel studies of transverse-momentum-dependent observables. Furthermore, we show that spherically-invariant algorithms in the Breit frame give access to low… ▽ More We propose a new jet algorithm for deep-inelastic scattering (DIS) that accounts for the forward-backward asymmetry in the Breit frame. The Centauro algorithm is longitudinally invariant and can cluster jets with Born kinematics, which enables novel studies of transverse-momentum-dependent observables. Furthermore, we show that spherically-invariant algorithms in the Breit frame give access to low-energy jets from current fragmentation. We propose novel studies in unpolarized, polarized, and nuclear DIS at the future Electron-Ion Collider. △ Less

Submitted 12 February, 2021; v1 submitted 18 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 7 pages and 7 figures

Report number: JLAB-THY-20-3209

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 104, 034005 (2021)

Soft Fragmentation on the Celestial Sphere

Authors: Duff Neill, Felix Ringer

Abstract: We develop two approaches to the problem of soft fragmentation of hadrons in a gauge theory for high energy processes. The first approach directly adapts the standard resummation of the parton distribution function's anomalous dimension (that of twist-two local operators) in the forward scattering regime, using $k_T$-factorization and BFKL theory, to the case of the fragmentation function by explo… ▽ More We develop two approaches to the problem of soft fragmentation of hadrons in a gauge theory for high energy processes. The first approach directly adapts the standard resummation of the parton distribution function's anomalous dimension (that of twist-two local operators) in the forward scattering regime, using $k_T$-factorization and BFKL theory, to the case of the fragmentation function by exploiting the mapping between the dynamics of eikonal lines on transverse-plane to the celestial-sphere. Critically, to correctly resum the anomalous dimension of the fragmentation function under this mapping, one must pay careful attention to the role of regularization, despite the manifest collinear or infra-red finiteness of the BFKL equation. The anomalous dependence on energy in the celestial case, arising due to the mismatch of dimensionality between positions and angles, drives the differences between the space-like and time-like anomalous dimension of parton densities, even in a conformal theory. The second approach adapts an angular-ordered evolution equation, but working in 4-2$ε$ dimensions at all angles. The two approaches are united by demanding that the anomalous dimension in 4-2$ε$ dimensions for the parton distribution function determines the kernel for the angular-ordered evolution to all orders. △ Less

Submitted 1 July, 2020; v1 submitted 4 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Comments: 41 pgs, 1 fig, fixed typos, journal version

A New Heavy Flavor Program for the Future Electron-Ion Collider

Authors: Xuan Li, Ivan Vitev, Melynda Brooks, Lukasz Cincio, J. Matthew Durham, Michael Graesser, Ming X. Liu, Astrid Morreale, Duff Neill, Cesar da Silva, Walter E. Sondheim, Boram Yoon

Abstract: The proposed high-energy and high-luminosity Electron-Ion Collider (EIC) will provide one of the cleanest environments to precisely determine the nuclear parton distribution functions (nPDFs) in a wide $x$-$Q^{2}$ range. Heavy flavor production at the EIC provides access to nPDFs in the poorly constrained high Bjorken-$x$ region, allows us to study the quark and gluon fragmentation processes, and… ▽ More The proposed high-energy and high-luminosity Electron-Ion Collider (EIC) will provide one of the cleanest environments to precisely determine the nuclear parton distribution functions (nPDFs) in a wide $x$-$Q^{2}$ range. Heavy flavor production at the EIC provides access to nPDFs in the poorly constrained high Bjorken-$x$ region, allows us to study the quark and gluon fragmentation processes, and constrains parton energy loss in cold nuclear matter. Scientists at the Los Alamos National Laboratory are developing a new physics program to study heavy flavor production, flavor tagged jets, and heavy flavor hadron-jet correlations in the nucleon/nucleus going direction at the future EIC. The proposed measurements will provide a unique way to explore the flavor dependent fragmentation functions and energy loss in a heavy nucleus. They will constrain the initial-state effects that are critical for the interpretation of previous and ongoing heavy ion measurements at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider and the Large Hadron Collider. We show an initial conceptual design of the proposed Forward Silicon Tracking (FST) detector at the EIC, which is essential to carry out the heavy flavor measurements. We further present initial feasibility studies/simulations of heavy flavor hadron reconstruction using the proposed FST. △ Less

Submitted 14 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures, proceedings for the XLIX International Symposium on Multiparticle Dynamics (ISMD2019) (9-13 September 2019) conference

Report number: LANL report number: LA-UR-20-21411

Journal ref: EPJ Web of Conferences 235, 04002 (2020)

Calculating the angle between jet axes

Authors: Pedro Cal, Duff Neill, Felix Ringer, Wouter J. Waalewijn

Abstract: We study the angle between i) the standard jet axis, ii) the axis of a jet which has been groomed using soft drop, with reduced sensitivity to soft radiation, iii) the jet axis obtained with the winner-take-all recombination scheme, which is insensitive to soft radiation at leading power. We calculate the distributions for these angles at next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy, including non-global… ▽ More We study the angle between i) the standard jet axis, ii) the axis of a jet which has been groomed using soft drop, with reduced sensitivity to soft radiation, iii) the jet axis obtained with the winner-take-all recombination scheme, which is insensitive to soft radiation at leading power. We calculate the distributions for these angles at next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy, including non-global logarithms. The angle between the standard and groomed jet axis directly probes soft wide-angle radiation, leading to a novel factorization formula. This angle is also very sensitive to nonperturbative physics, which is directly connected to nonperturbative contribution to the rapidity anomalous dimension for transverse momentum distributions. Comparing our predictions to Pythia we find good agreement, and we foresee applications to jet substructure in proton-proton and heavy ion collisions. △ Less

Submitted 9 May, 2022; v1 submitted 15 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: 39 pages, 13 figures

Report number: NIKHEF 2019-052

The soft drop groomed jet radius at NLL

Authors: Zhong-Bo Kang, Kyle Lee, Xiaohui Liu, Duff Neill, Felix Ringer

Abstract: We present results for the soft drop groomed jet radius $R_g$ at next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy. The radius of a groomed jet which corresponds to the angle between the two branches passing the soft drop criterion is one of the characteristic observables relevant for the precise understanding of groomed jet substructure. We establish a factorization formalism that allows for the resummation o… ▽ More We present results for the soft drop groomed jet radius $R_g$ at next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy. The radius of a groomed jet which corresponds to the angle between the two branches passing the soft drop criterion is one of the characteristic observables relevant for the precise understanding of groomed jet substructure. We establish a factorization formalism that allows for the resummation of all relevant large logarithms, which is based on demonstrating the all order equivalence to a jet veto in the region between the boundaries of the groomed and ungroomed jet. Non-global logarithms including clustering effects due to the Cambridge/Aachen algorithm are resummed to all orders using a suitable Monte Carlo algorithm. We perform numerical calculations and find a very good agreement with Pythia 8 simulations. We provide theoretical predictions for the LHC and RHIC. △ Less

Submitted 5 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 32 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: JHEP 02, 054 (2020)

The Entropy of a Jet

Authors: Duff Neill, Wouter J. Waalewijn

Abstract: Scattering processes often inevitably include the production of infrared states, which are highly correlated with the hard scattering event, and decohere the hard states. This can be described using the entropy of the hard reduced density matrix, which is obtained from tracing over infrared states. We determine this entropy for an asymptotically-free gauge theory by separating the Hilbert space in… ▽ More Scattering processes often inevitably include the production of infrared states, which are highly correlated with the hard scattering event, and decohere the hard states. This can be described using the entropy of the hard reduced density matrix, which is obtained from tracing over infrared states. We determine this entropy for an asymptotically-free gauge theory by separating the Hilbert space into hard and infrared states, and calculate it in a leading-logarithmic approximation for jets. We find that the entropy increases when the resolution scales defining the hard radiation are lowered, that this entropy is related to the subjet multiplicity, and explore connections to using jet images for machine learning, and the forward-scattering density matrix of partons in a nucleon probed in deep-inelastic scattering. △ Less

Submitted 13 September, 2019; v1 submitted 2 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: 7 pages, 1 figure, v2: journal version

Report number: Nikhef 2018-052

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 142001 (2019)

Phenomenology with a recoil-free jet axis: TMD fragmentation and the jet shape

Authors: Duff Neill, Andreas Papaefstathiou, Wouter J. Waalewijn, Lorenzo Zoppi

Abstract: We study the phenomenology of recoil-free jet axes using analytic calculations and Monte Carlo simulations. Our focus is on the average energy as function of the angle with the jet axis (the jet shape), and the energy and transverse momenta of hadrons in a jet (TMD fragmentation). We find that the dependence on the angle (or transverse momentum) is governed by a power law, in contrast to the doubl… ▽ More We study the phenomenology of recoil-free jet axes using analytic calculations and Monte Carlo simulations. Our focus is on the average energy as function of the angle with the jet axis (the jet shape), and the energy and transverse momenta of hadrons in a jet (TMD fragmentation). We find that the dependence on the angle (or transverse momentum) is governed by a power law, in contrast to the double-logarithmic dependence for the standard jet axis. The effects of the jet radius, jet algorithm, angular resolution and grooming are investigated. TMD fragmentation is important for constraining the structure of the proton through semi-inclusive deep-inelastic scattering. These observables are also of interest to the LHC, for example to constrain $α_s$ from precision jet measurements, or probe the quark-gluon plasma in heavy-ion collisions. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2019; v1 submitted 30 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 26 pages, 16 figures, version 2: matches Journal version

Non-Global and Clustering Effects for Groomed Multi-Prong Jet Shapes

Authors: Duff Neill

Abstract: We present a resummation valid to next-to leading logarithmic accuracy of the non-global and clustering effects in groomed (with modified mass drop tagger) multi-pronged observables. These effects are universal in the sense that they depend only on the flavor structure of the $1\to 2$ splitting forming the multi-pronged subjets and the opening angle of the splitting, being insensitive to the under… ▽ More We present a resummation valid to next-to leading logarithmic accuracy of the non-global and clustering effects in groomed (with modified mass drop tagger) multi-pronged observables. These effects are universal in the sense that they depend only on the flavor structure of the $1\to 2$ splitting forming the multi-pronged subjets and the opening angle of the splitting, being insensitive to the underlying hard process or underlying event. The differential spectra with and without the non-global and clustering effects are presented, and the change in the spectra is found to be small. △ Less

Submitted 4 February, 2019; v1 submitted 14 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Comments: v2, 16 pgs., 7 figs. References added, introduction expanded, discussion of sources of NGLs in x-sec expanded, added plots of shower cutoff dependence and statistical uncertainties. version accepted for publication

Precise QCD Description of the Higgs Boson Transverse Momentum Spectrum

Authors: Xuan Chen, Thomas Gehrmann, E. W. Nigel Glover, Alexander Huss, Ye Li, Duff Neill, Markus Schulze, Iain W. Stewart, Hua Xing Zhu

Abstract: The transverse momentum ($p_T$) distribution of Higgs bosons at hadron colliders enables a detailed probe of its production dynamics and is a key ingredient to precision studies of Higgs boson properties, but receives very large QCD corrections. We obtain a precision prediction for the $p_T$ spectrum by matching second-order (NNLO) QCD corrections at large $p_T$ with resummation of third-order log… ▽ More The transverse momentum ($p_T$) distribution of Higgs bosons at hadron colliders enables a detailed probe of its production dynamics and is a key ingredient to precision studies of Higgs boson properties, but receives very large QCD corrections. We obtain a precision prediction for the $p_T$ spectrum by matching second-order (NNLO) QCD corrections at large $p_T$ with resummation of third-order logarithmic (N$^3$LL) corrections at small $p_T$. We achieve significantly improved results for $p_T< 35\,{\rm GeV}$ with perturbative uncertainties $\lesssim \pm 6\%$, and thus a convergent perturbative series for all values of $p_T$. △ Less

Submitted 4 December, 2018; v1 submitted 2 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: 6 pages, 3 figures

Report number: IPPP/18/28, ZU-TH 16/18, CERN-TH-2018-108, MIT-CTP 5013, HU-EP-18/14

Journal ref: Physics Letters B 788 (2019) 425

Soft evolution after a hard scattering process

Authors: Duff Neill, Varun Vaidya

Abstract: The dynamical cascade of momentum, spin, charge, and other quantum numbers from an ultra-violet process into the infra-red is a fundamental concern for asymptotically free or conformal gauge field theories. It is also a practical concern for any high energy scattering experiment with energies above tens of GeV. We present a formulation of the evolution equation that governs this cascade, the Banfi… ▽ More The dynamical cascade of momentum, spin, charge, and other quantum numbers from an ultra-violet process into the infra-red is a fundamental concern for asymptotically free or conformal gauge field theories. It is also a practical concern for any high energy scattering experiment with energies above tens of GeV. We present a formulation of the evolution equation that governs this cascade, the Banfi-Marchesini-Smye equation, from both an effective field theory point of view and a direct diagrammatic argument. The equation uses exact momentum conservation, and is applicable to both scattering with initial and final state hard partons. The direct diagrammatic formulation is organized by constructing a generating functional. This functional is also automatically realized with soft wilson lines and collinear field operators coupled to external currents. The two approaches are directly connected by reverse engineering the Lehman-Symanzik-Zimmermann reduction procedure to insert states within the soft and collinear matrix elements. At leading order, the cascade is completely controlled by the soft anomalous dimension. By decomposing the anomalous dimension into on-shell and off-shell regions as would be realized in the effective field theory approach with a Glauber mediating potential, we are forced to choose a transverse momentum ordering in order to trivialize the overlap between Glauber potential contributions and the pure soft region. The evolution equation then naturally incorporates factorization violating effects driven by off-shell exchanges for active partons. Finally, we examine the consequences of abandoning exact momentum conservation as well as terminating the evolution at the largest inclusive scale, procedures often used to simplify the analysis of the cascade. △ Less

Submitted 14 March, 2018; v1 submitted 6 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: 56 pages, 0 figures

Probing Transverse-Momentum Dependent Evolution With Groomed Jets

Authors: Yiannis Makris, Duff Neill, Varun Vaidya

Abstract: We propose an observable which involves measuring the properties (transverse momentum $p_{h\perp}$ and energy fraction $z_h$) of an identified hadron inside a groomed jet. The jet is identified with an anti-kT/CA algorithm and is groomed by implementing the modified mass drop procedure with an energy cut-off parameter $z_{cut}$. The transverse momentum of the hadron inside the jet is measured with… ▽ More We propose an observable which involves measuring the properties (transverse momentum $p_{h\perp}$ and energy fraction $z_h$) of an identified hadron inside a groomed jet. The jet is identified with an anti-kT/CA algorithm and is groomed by implementing the modified mass drop procedure with an energy cut-off parameter $z_{cut}$. The transverse momentum of the hadron inside the jet is measured with respect to the groomed jet axis. We obtain a factorization theorem in the framework of Soft Collinear Effective Theory (SCET), to define a Transverse Momentum Dependent Fragmenting Jet Function (TMDFJF). The TMDFJF is factorized into collinear and collinear soft modes by matching onto SCET$_+$. We resum large logarithms in $E_J/p_{h\perp}$, where $E_J$ is the ungroomed jet energy, to NLL accuracy and apply this formalism for computing the shape of the $p_{h\perp}$ distribution of a pion produced in an $e^+ +e^-$ collision. We observe that the introduction of grooming makes this observable insensitive to non-global logarithms and particularly sensitive to non-perturbative physics of the transverse momentum dependent evolution at low values of $p_{h\perp}$, which can be probed in the variation of the cut-off parameter $z_{cut}$ of the groomer. We discuss how this observable can be used to distinguish between non-perturbative models that describe universal TMD evolution and provide a window into the three dimensional structure of hadrons. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2018; v1 submitted 20 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: 23 pages, 4 figures

Convolved Substructure: Analytically Decorrelating Jet Substructure Observables

Authors: Ian Moult, Benjamin Nachman, Duff Neill

Abstract: A number of recent applications of jet substructure, in particular searches for light new particles, require substructure observables that are decorrelated with the jet mass. In this paper we introduce the Convolved SubStructure (CSS) approach, which uses a theoretical understanding of the observable to decorrelate the complete shape of its distribution. This decorrelation is performed by convolut… ▽ More A number of recent applications of jet substructure, in particular searches for light new particles, require substructure observables that are decorrelated with the jet mass. In this paper we introduce the Convolved SubStructure (CSS) approach, which uses a theoretical understanding of the observable to decorrelate the complete shape of its distribution. This decorrelation is performed by convolution with a shape function whose parameters and mass dependence are derived analytically. We consider in detail the case of the $D_2$ observable and perform an illustrative case study using a search for a light hadronically decaying $Z'$. We find that the CSS approach completely decorrelates the $D_2$ observable over a wide range of masses. Our approach highlights the importance of improving the theoretical understanding of jet substructure observables to exploit increasingly subtle features for performance. △ Less

Submitted 14 January, 2019; v1 submitted 18 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 20 pages, 11 figures. v2. Corrected typo in legend in Figure 5. Updated Figure 11, minor modification to conclusions on discrimination power. v3. Updated to published version. Minor typos corrected

Factorization and Resummation for Groomed Multi-Prong Jet Shapes

Authors: Andrew J. Larkoski, Ian Moult, Duff Neill

Abstract: Observables which distinguish boosted topologies from QCD jets are playing an increasingly important role at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). These observables are often used in conjunction with jet grooming algorithms, which reduce contamination from both theoretical and experimental sources. In this paper we derive factorization formulae for groomed multi-prong substructure observables, focusing… ▽ More Observables which distinguish boosted topologies from QCD jets are playing an increasingly important role at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). These observables are often used in conjunction with jet grooming algorithms, which reduce contamination from both theoretical and experimental sources. In this paper we derive factorization formulae for groomed multi-prong substructure observables, focusing in particular on the groomed $D_2$ observable, which is used to identify boosted hadronic decays of electroweak bosons at the LHC. Our factorization formulae allow systematically improvable calculations of the perturbative $D_2$ distribution and the resummation of logarithmically enhanced terms in all regions of phase space using renormalization group evolution. They include a novel factorization for the production of a soft subjet in the presence of a grooming algorithm, in which clustering effects enter directly into the hard matching. We use these factorization formulae to draw robust conclusions of experimental relevance regarding the universality of the $D_2$ distribution in both $e^+e^-$ and $pp$ collisions. In particular, we show that the only process dependence is carried by the relative quark vs. gluon jet fraction in the sample, no non-global logarithms from event-wide correlations are present in the distribution, hadronization corrections are controlled by the perturbative mass of the jet, and all global color correlations are completely removed by grooming, making groomed $D_2$ a theoretically clean QCD observable even in the LHC environment. We compute all ingredients to one-loop accuracy, and present numerical results at next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy for $e^+e^-$ collisions, comparing with parton shower Monte Carlo simulations. Results for $pp$ collisions, as relevant for phenomenology at the LHC, are presented in a companion paper. △ Less

Submitted 29 September, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 66 pages, 18 figures

Analytic Boosted Boson Discrimination at the Large Hadron Collider

Authors: Andrew J. Larkoski, Ian Moult, Duff Neill

Abstract: Jet substructure is playing a central role at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) probing the Standard Model in extreme regions of phase space and providing innovative ways to search for new physics. Analytic calculations of experimentally successful observables are a primary catalyst driving developments in jet substructure, allowing for a deeper understanding of observables and for the exploitation… ▽ More Jet substructure is playing a central role at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) probing the Standard Model in extreme regions of phase space and providing innovative ways to search for new physics. Analytic calculations of experimentally successful observables are a primary catalyst driving developments in jet substructure, allowing for a deeper understanding of observables and for the exploitation of increasingly subtle features of jets. In this paper we present a field theoretic framework enabling systematically improvable calculations of groomed multi-prong substructure observables, which builds on recent developments in multi-scale effective theories. We use this framework to compute for the first time the full spectrum for groomed tagging observables at the LHC, carefully treating both perturbative and non-perturbative contributions in all regions. Our analysis enables a precision understanding which we hope will improve the reach and sophistication of jet substructure techniques at the LHC. △ Less

Submitted 22 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: 5 pages

Soft Functions for Generic Jet Algorithms and Observables at Hadron Colliders

Authors: Daniele Bertolini, Daniel Kolodrubetz, Duff Neill, Piotr Pietrulewicz, Iain W. Stewart, Frank J. Tackmann, Wouter J. Waalewijn

Abstract: We introduce a method to compute one-loop soft functions for exclusive $N$-jet processes at hadron colliders, allowing for different definitions of the algorithm that determines the jet regions and of the measurements in those regions. In particular, we generalize the $N$-jettiness hemisphere decomposition of [Jouttenus 2011] in a manner that separates the dependence on the jet boundary from the o… ▽ More We introduce a method to compute one-loop soft functions for exclusive $N$-jet processes at hadron colliders, allowing for different definitions of the algorithm that determines the jet regions and of the measurements in those regions. In particular, we generalize the $N$-jettiness hemisphere decomposition of [Jouttenus 2011] in a manner that separates the dependence on the jet boundary from the observables measured inside the jet and beam regions. Results are given for several factorizable jet definitions, including anti-$k_T$, XCone, and other geometric partitionings. We calculate explicitly the soft functions for angularity measurements, including jet mass and jet broadening, in $pp \to L + 1$ jet and explore the differences for various jet vetoes and algorithms. This includes a consistent treatment of rapidity divergences when applicable. We also compute analytic results for these soft functions in an expansion for a small jet radius $R$. We find that the small-$R$ results, including corrections up to $\mathcal{O}(R^2)$, accurately capture the full behavior over a large range of $R$. △ Less

Submitted 7 October, 2017; v1 submitted 26 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: 33 pages + appendices, 17 figures, v2: journal version, v3: fixed typo in eq.(4.37)

Jet axes and universal transverse-momentum-dependent fragmentation

Authors: Duff Neill, Ignazio Scimemi, Wouter J. Waalewijn

Abstract: We study the transverse momentum spectrum of hadrons in jets. By measuring the transverse momentum with respect to a judiciously chosen axis, we find that this observable is insensitive to (the recoil of) soft radiation. Furthermore, for small transverse momenta we show that the effects of the jet boundary factorize, leading to a new transverse-momentum-dependent (TMD) fragmentation function. In c… ▽ More We study the transverse momentum spectrum of hadrons in jets. By measuring the transverse momentum with respect to a judiciously chosen axis, we find that this observable is insensitive to (the recoil of) soft radiation. Furthermore, for small transverse momenta we show that the effects of the jet boundary factorize, leading to a new transverse-momentum-dependent (TMD) fragmentation function. In contrast to the usual TMD fragmentation functions, it does not involve rapidity divergences and is universal in the sense that it is independent of the type of process and number of jets. These results directly apply to sub-jets instead of hadrons. We discuss potential applications, which include studying nuclear modification effects in heavy-ion collisions and identifying boosted heavy resonances. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2019; v1 submitted 14 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 27 pages, 4 figures; v2: journal version, fixed matching coefficients in (4.2) - (4.5) and (4.13); v3: fixed typos in gg anomalous dimension in (C.3)

Report number: NIKHEF 2016-051

The Asymptotic Form of Non-Global Logarithms, Black Disc Saturation, and Gluonic Deserts

Authors: Duff Neill

Abstract: We develop an asymptotic perturbation theory for the large logarithmic behavior of the non-linear integro-differential equation describing the soft correlations of QCD jet measurements, the Banfi-Marchesini-Smye (BMS) equation. This equation captures the late-time evolution of radiating color dipoles after a hard collision. This allows us to prove that at large values of the control variable (the… ▽ More We develop an asymptotic perturbation theory for the large logarithmic behavior of the non-linear integro-differential equation describing the soft correlations of QCD jet measurements, the Banfi-Marchesini-Smye (BMS) equation. This equation captures the late-time evolution of radiating color dipoles after a hard collision. This allows us to prove that at large values of the control variable (the non-global logarithm, a function of the infra-red energy scales associated with distinct hard jets in an event), the distribution has a gaussian tail. We compute the decay width analytically, giving a closed form expression, and find it to be jet geometry independent, up to the number of legs of the dipole in the active jet. Enabling the asymptotic expansion is the correct perturbative seed, where we perturb around an anzats encoding formally no real emissions, an intuition motivated by the buffer region found in jet dynamics. This must be supplemented with the correct application of the BFKL approximation to the BMS equation in collinear limits. Comparing to the asymptotics of the conformally related evolution equation encountered in small-x physics, the Balitisky-Kovchegov (BK) equation, we find that the asymptotic form of the non-global logarithms directly maps to the black-disc unitarity limit of the BK equation, despite the contrasting physical pictures. Indeed, we recover the equations of saturation physics in the final state dynamics of QCD. △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2017; v1 submitted 6 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Comments: Fixed factor of 2 in BFKL and corrected comparison to MC (another factor of 2 mistake in fits). Clarified discussion. Conclusions unchanged. Version submitted to JHEP

The Analytic Structure of Non-Global Logarithms: Convergence of the Dressed Gluon Expansion

Authors: Andrew J. Larkoski, Ian Moult, Duff Neill

Abstract: Non-global logarithms (NGLs) are the leading manifestation of correlations between distinct phase space regions in QCD and gauge theories and have proven a challenge to understand using traditional resummation techniques. Recently, the dressed gluon expansion was introduced that enables an expansion of the NGL series in terms of a "dressed gluon" building block, defined by an all-orders factorizat… ▽ More Non-global logarithms (NGLs) are the leading manifestation of correlations between distinct phase space regions in QCD and gauge theories and have proven a challenge to understand using traditional resummation techniques. Recently, the dressed gluon expansion was introduced that enables an expansion of the NGL series in terms of a "dressed gluon" building block, defined by an all-orders factorization theorem. Here, we clarify the nature of the dressed gluon expansion, and prove that it has an infinite radius of convergence as a solution to the leading logarithmic and large-$N_c$ master equation for NGLs, the Banfi-Marchesini-Smye (BMS) equation. The dressed gluon expansion therefore provides an expansion of the NGL series that can be truncated at any order, with reliable uncertainty estimates. In contrast, manifest in the results of the fixed-order expansion of the BMS equation up to 12-loops is a breakdown of convergence at a finite value of $α_s$log. We explain this finite radius of convergence using the dressed gluon expansion, showing how the dynamics of the buffer region, a region of phase space near the boundary of the jet that was identified in early studies of NGLs, leads to large contributions to the fixed order expansion. We also use the dressed gluon expansion to discuss the convergence of the next-to-leading NGL series, and the role of collinear logarithms that appear at this order. Finally, we show how an understanding of the analytic behavior obtained from the dressed gluon expansion allows us to improve the fixed order NGL series using conformal transformations to extend the domain of analyticity. This allows us to calculate the NGL distribution for all values of $α_s$log from the coefficients of the fixed order expansion. △ Less

Submitted 13 September, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Comments: 37 pages + Appendices, 11 figures

Report number: MIT-CTP 4821, LA-UR-16-26925

An Exponential Regulator for Rapidity Divergences

Authors: Ye Li, Duff Neill, Hua Xing Zhu

Abstract: Finding an efficient and compelling regularization of soft and collinear degrees of freedom at the same invariant mass scale, but separated in rapidity is a persistent problem in high-energy factorization. In the course of a calculation, one encounters divergences unregulated by dimensional regularization, often called rapidity divergences. Once regulated, a general framework exists for their reno… ▽ More Finding an efficient and compelling regularization of soft and collinear degrees of freedom at the same invariant mass scale, but separated in rapidity is a persistent problem in high-energy factorization. In the course of a calculation, one encounters divergences unregulated by dimensional regularization, often called rapidity divergences. Once regulated, a general framework exists for their renormalization, the rapidity renormalization group (RRG), leading to fully resummed calculations of transverse momentum (to the jet axis) sensitive quantities. We examine how this regularization can be implemented via a multi-differential factorization of the soft-collinear phase-space, leading to an (in principle) alternative non-perturbative regularization of rapidity divergences. As an example, we examine the fully-differential factorization of a color singlet's momentum spectrum in a hadron-hadron collision at threshold. We show how this factorization acts as a mother theory to both traditional threshold and transverse momentum resummation, recovering the classical results for both resummations. Examining the refactorization of the transverse momentum beam functions in the threshold region, we show that one can directly calculate the rapidity renormalized function, while shedding light on the structure of joint resummation. Finally, we show how using modern bootstrap techniques, the transverse momentum spectrum is determined by an expansion about the threshold factorization, leading to a viable higher loop scheme for calculating the relevant anomalous dimensions for the transverse momentum spectrum. △ Less

Submitted 1 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

The Edge of Jets and Subleading Non-Global Logs

Authors: Duff Neill

Abstract: A persistent and fascinating problem at the high energy colliders are jets. Often trying to observe physics underlying the hard interactions at colliders requires experimental cuts in phase space, defining several jet or beam regions. QCD being a gauge theory that readily decays into infra-red modes, correlations between jet regions is almost inevitable, spoiling the predictivity of fixed order QC… ▽ More A persistent and fascinating problem at the high energy colliders are jets. Often trying to observe physics underlying the hard interactions at colliders requires experimental cuts in phase space, defining several jet or beam regions. QCD being a gauge theory that readily decays into infra-red modes, correlations between jet regions is almost inevitable, spoiling the predictivity of fixed order QCD calculations. One is faced with the task of calculating the evolution of a reduced density matrix, where successively less energetic (jet) regions are integrated out, to gain control of the calculation. I relate the decay rates governing the flow into the IR to an effective field theory expansion in soft jets, allowing a systematic and resummed calculation of these rates, while further relating them to physically observable features of the QCD cascade. To demonstrate the utility of the soft jet expansion, I present a factorization theorem for a soft subjet collinearly splitting in and out of a parent fat jet. Using the resummation properties of this factorization theorem, I elucidate the structure of the subleading non-global logs (encoding the jet correlations) in the hemisphere jet mass distribution, as well as give a collinear improvement of the leading order resummation equation, the BMS equation. I compare to other approaches to subleading resummation of NGLs, and find the collinear improvement of the leading order equation removes the need for kinematic-dependent corrections in the IR averaging procedure of the reduced density matrix, so that no further large logs can be generated in the IR. Finally I end with speculation about connections with collinear improvements of the NLO B-JIMWLK hierarchy for small-$x$ resummation. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Comments: 3 figs. 37 pgs

Analytic Boosted Boson Discrimination

Authors: Andrew J. Larkoski, Ian Moult, Duff Neill

Abstract: Observables which discriminate boosted topologies from massive QCD jets are of great importance for the success of the jet substructure program at the Large Hadron Collider. Such observables, while both widely and successfully used, have been studied almost exclusively with Monte Carlo simulations. In this paper we present the first all-orders factorization theorem for a two-prong discriminant bas… ▽ More Observables which discriminate boosted topologies from massive QCD jets are of great importance for the success of the jet substructure program at the Large Hadron Collider. Such observables, while both widely and successfully used, have been studied almost exclusively with Monte Carlo simulations. In this paper we present the first all-orders factorization theorem for a two-prong discriminant based on a jet shape variable, $D_2$, valid for both signal and background jets. Our factorization theorem simultaneously describes the production of both collinear and soft subjets, and we introduce a novel zero-bin procedure to correctly describe the transition region between these limits. By proving an all orders factorization theorem, we enable a systematically improvable description, and allow for precision comparisons between data, Monte Carlo, and first principles QCD calculations for jet substructure observables. Using our factorization theorem, we present numerical results for the discrimination of a boosted $Z$ boson from massive QCD background jets. We compare our results with Monte Carlo predictions which allows for a detailed understanding of the extent to which these generators accurately describe the formation of two-prong QCD jets, and informs their usage in substructure analyses. Our calculation also provides considerable insight into the discrimination power and calculability of jet substructure observables in general. △ Less

Submitted 18 May, 2016; v1 submitted 10 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: 135 pages, 34 figures v2. Fixed bug in parton level Herwig analysis in Fig. 13 v3. Additional discussion on zero-bin procedure and hadronization corrections v4. removed mention of angular veto in Pythia8 v5. JHEP version; removed discussion of comparing parton-level Monte Carlo to analytics

Report number: MIT-CTP 4681

The Higgs Transverse Momentum Distribution at NNLL and its Theoretical Errors

Authors: Duff Neill, Ira Z. Rothstein, Varun Vaidya

Abstract: In this letter, we present the NNLL-NNLO transverse momentum Higgs distribution arising from gluon fusion. In the regime $p_\perp\ll m_H$ we include the resummation of the large logs at next to next-to leading order and then match on to the $α_s^2$ fixed order result near $p_\perp \sim m_h$. By utilizing the rapidity renormalization group (RRG) we are able to smoothly match between the resummed, s… ▽ More In this letter, we present the NNLL-NNLO transverse momentum Higgs distribution arising from gluon fusion. In the regime $p_\perp\ll m_H$ we include the resummation of the large logs at next to next-to leading order and then match on to the $α_s^2$ fixed order result near $p_\perp \sim m_h$. By utilizing the rapidity renormalization group (RRG) we are able to smoothly match between the resummed, small $p_\perp$ regime and the fixed order regime. We give a detailed discussion of the scale dependence of the result including an analysis of the rapidity scale dependence. Our central value differs from previous results, in the transition region as well as the tail, by an amount which is outside the error band. This difference is due to the fact that the RRG profile allows us to smoothly turn off the resummation. △ Less

Submitted 27 February, 2015; originally announced March 2015.

Comments: 23 pages, 10 figures

Non-Global Logarithms, Factorization, and the Soft Substructure of Jets

Authors: Andrew J. Larkoski, Ian Moult, Duff Neill

Abstract: An outstanding problem in QCD and jet physics is the factorization and resummation of logarithms that arise due to phase space constraints, so-called non-global logarithms (NGLs). In this paper, we show that NGLs can be factorized and resummed down to an unresolved infrared scale by making sufficiently many measurements on a jet or other restricted phase space region. Resummation is accomplished b… ▽ More An outstanding problem in QCD and jet physics is the factorization and resummation of logarithms that arise due to phase space constraints, so-called non-global logarithms (NGLs). In this paper, we show that NGLs can be factorized and resummed down to an unresolved infrared scale by making sufficiently many measurements on a jet or other restricted phase space region. Resummation is accomplished by renormalization group evolution of the objects in the factorization theorem and anomalous dimensions can be calculated to any perturbative accuracy and with any number of colors. To connect with the NGLs of more inclusive measurements, we present a novel perturbative expansion which is controlled by the volume of the allowed phase space for unresolved emissions. Arbitrary accuracy can be obtained by making more and more measurements so to resolve lower and lower scales. We find that even a minimal number of measurements produces agreement with Monte Carlo methods for leading-logarithmic resummation of NGLs at the sub-percent level over the full dynamical range relevant for the Large Hadron Collider. We also discuss other applications of our factorization theorem to soft jet dynamics and how to extend to higher-order accuracy. △ Less

Submitted 22 September, 2015; v1 submitted 19 January, 2015; originally announced January 2015.

Comments: 46 pages + appendices, 10 figures. v2: added current figures 4 and 5, as well as corrected several typos in appendices. v3: corrected some typos, added current figure 9, and added more discussion of fixed-order versus dressed gluon expansions. v4: fixed an error in numerics of two-dressed gluon; corrected figure 8, modified comparison to BMS. Conclusions unchanged. v5: fixed minor typo

Report number: MIT--CTP 4635

Soft Theorems from Effective Field Theory

Authors: Andrew J. Larkoski, Duff Neill, Iain W. Stewart

Abstract: The singular limits of massless gauge theory amplitudes are described by an effective theory, called soft-collinear effective theory (SCET), which has been applied most successfully to make all-orders predictions for observables in collider physics and weak decays. At tree-level, the emission of a soft gauge boson at subleading order in its energy is given by the Low-Burnett-Kroll theorem, with th… ▽ More The singular limits of massless gauge theory amplitudes are described by an effective theory, called soft-collinear effective theory (SCET), which has been applied most successfully to make all-orders predictions for observables in collider physics and weak decays. At tree-level, the emission of a soft gauge boson at subleading order in its energy is given by the Low-Burnett-Kroll theorem, with the angular momentum operator acting on a lower-point amplitude. For well separated particles at tree-level, we prove the Low-Burnett-Kroll theorem using matrix elements of subleading SCET Lagrangian and operator insertions which are individually gauge invariant. These contributions are uniquely determined by gauge invariance and the reparametrization invariance (RPI) symmetry of SCET. RPI in SCET is connected to the infinite-dimensional asymptotic symmetries of the S-matrix. The Low-Burnett-Kroll theorem is generically spoiled by on-shell corrections, including collinear loops and collinear emissions. We demonstrate this explicitly both at tree-level and at one-loop. The effective theory correctly describes these configurations, and we generalize the Low-Burnett-Kroll theorem into a new one-loop subleading soft theorem for amplitudes. Our analysis is presented in a manner that illustrates the wider utility of using effective theory techniques to understand the perturbative S-matrix. △ Less

Submitted 27 May, 2015; v1 submitted 9 December, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Comments: Plenty of pages, 9 figures; v2: updated discussion of fusion terms in the one-loop soft theorem, added appendix with several explicit, worked examples of the application of the one-loop soft theorem

Report number: MIT-CTP 4568

Building a Better Boosted Top Tagger

Authors: Andrew J. Larkoski, Ian Moult, Duff Neill

Abstract: Distinguishing hadronically decaying boosted top quarks from massive QCD jets is an important challenge at the Large Hadron Collider. In this paper we use the power counting method to study jet substructure observables designed for top tagging, and gain insight into their performance. We introduce a powerful new family of discriminants formed from the energy correlation functions which outperform… ▽ More Distinguishing hadronically decaying boosted top quarks from massive QCD jets is an important challenge at the Large Hadron Collider. In this paper we use the power counting method to study jet substructure observables designed for top tagging, and gain insight into their performance. We introduce a powerful new family of discriminants formed from the energy correlation functions which outperform the widely used N-subjettiness. These observables take a highly non-trivial form, demonstrating the importance of a systematic approach to their construction. △ Less

Submitted 22 June, 2016; v1 submitted 3 November, 2014; originally announced November 2014.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures; v2: updated references; v3: added more detail about the dominant kinematics, PRD version v4: typo in Eq 5 fixed

Report number: MIT--CTP 4595

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 91, 034035 (2015)

Power Counting to Better Jet Observables

Authors: Andrew J. Larkoski, Ian Moult, Duff Neill

Abstract: Optimized jet substructure observables for identifying boosted topologies will play an essential role in maximizing the physics reach of the Large Hadron Collider. Ideally, the design of discriminating variables would be informed by analytic calculations in perturbative QCD. Unfortunately, explicit calculations are often not feasible due to the complexity of the observables used for discrimination… ▽ More Optimized jet substructure observables for identifying boosted topologies will play an essential role in maximizing the physics reach of the Large Hadron Collider. Ideally, the design of discriminating variables would be informed by analytic calculations in perturbative QCD. Unfortunately, explicit calculations are often not feasible due to the complexity of the observables used for discrimination, and so many validation studies rely heavily, and solely, on Monte Carlo. In this paper we show how methods based on the parametric power counting of the dynamics of QCD, familiar from effective theory analyses, can be used to design, understand, and make robust predictions for the behavior of jet substructure variables. As a concrete example, we apply power counting for discriminating boosted Z bosons from massive QCD jets using observables formed from the n-point energy correlation functions. We show that power counting alone gives a definite prediction for the observable that optimally separates the background-rich from the signal-rich regions of phase space. Power counting can also be used to understand effects of phase space cuts and the effect of contamination from pile-up, which we discuss. As these arguments rely only on the parametric scaling of QCD, the predictions from power counting must be reproduced by any Monte Carlo, which we verify using Pythia8 and Herwig++. We also use the example of quark versus gluon discrimination to demonstrate the limits of the power counting technique. △ Less

Submitted 22 September, 2014; originally announced September 2014.

Comments: 35 pages, 15 figures

Report number: MIT--CTP 4588

Toward Multi-Differential Cross Sections: Measuring Two Angularities on a Single Jet

Authors: Andrew J. Larkoski, Ian Moult, Duff Neill

Abstract: The analytic study of differential cross sections in QCD has typically focused on individual observables, such as mass or thrust, to great success. Here, we present a first study of double differential jet cross sections considering two recoil-free angularities measured on a single jet. By analyzing the phase space defined by the two angularities and using methods from soft-collinear effective the… ▽ More The analytic study of differential cross sections in QCD has typically focused on individual observables, such as mass or thrust, to great success. Here, we present a first study of double differential jet cross sections considering two recoil-free angularities measured on a single jet. By analyzing the phase space defined by the two angularities and using methods from soft-collinear effective theory, we prove that the double differential cross section factorizes at the boundaries of the phase space. We also show that the cross section in the bulk of the phase space cannot be factorized using only soft and collinear modes, excluding the possibility of a global factorization theorem in soft-collinear effective theory. Nevertheless, we are able to define a simple interpolation procedure that smoothly connects the factorization theorem at one boundary to the other. We present an explicit example of this at next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy and show that the interpolation is unique up to $α_s^4$ order in the exponent of the cross section, under reasonable assumptions. This is evidence that the interpolation is sufficiently robust to account for all logarithms in the bulk of phase space to the accuracy of the boundary factorization theorem. We compare our analytic calculation of the double differential cross section to Monte Carlo simulation and find qualitative agreement. Because our arguments rely on general structures of the phase space, we expect that much of our analysis would be relevant for the study of phenomenologically well-motivated observables, such as $N$-subjettiness, energy correlation functions, and planar flow. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2014; v1 submitted 17 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Comments: 43 pages plus appendices, 8 figures. v2 as published in JHEP. minor typos corrected

Report number: MIT-CTP 4525

Jet Shapes with the Broadening Axis

Authors: Andrew J. Larkoski, Duff Neill, Jesse Thaler

Abstract: Broadening is a classic jet observable that probes the transverse momentum structure of jets. Traditionally, broadening has been measured with respect to the thrust axis, which is aligned along the (hemisphere) jet momentum to minimize the vector sum of transverse momentum within a jet. In this paper, we advocate measuring broadening with respect to the "broadening axis", which is the direction th… ▽ More Broadening is a classic jet observable that probes the transverse momentum structure of jets. Traditionally, broadening has been measured with respect to the thrust axis, which is aligned along the (hemisphere) jet momentum to minimize the vector sum of transverse momentum within a jet. In this paper, we advocate measuring broadening with respect to the "broadening axis", which is the direction that minimizes the scalar sum of transverse momentum within a jet. This approach eliminates many of the calculational complexities arising from recoil of the leading parton, and observables like the jet angularities become recoil-free when measured using the broadening axis. We derive a simple factorization theorem for broadening-axis observables which smoothly interpolates between the thrust-like and broadening-like regimes. We argue that the same factorization theorem holds for two-point energy correlation functions as well as for jet shapes based on a "winner-take-all axis". Using kinked broadening axes, we calculate event-wide angularities in e+e- collisions with next-to-leading logarithmic resummation. Defining jet regions using the broadening axis, we also calculate the global logarithms for angularities within a single jet. We find good agreement comparing our calculations both to showering Monte Carlo programs and to automated resummation tools. We give a brief historical perspective on the broadening axis and suggest ways that broadening-axis observables could be used in future jet substructure studies at the Large Hadron Collider. △ Less

Submitted 9 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Comments: 32 pages + appendices, 11 figures

Report number: MIT--CTP 4512

Classical Space-Times from the S Matrix

Authors: Duff Neill, Ira Z. Rothstein

Abstract: We show that classical space-times can be derived directly from the S-matrix for a theory of massive particles coupled to a massless spin two particle. As an explicit example we derive the Schwarzchild space-time as a series in $G_N$. At no point of the derivation is any use made of the Einstein-Hilbert action or the Einstein equations. The intermediate steps involve only on-shell S-matrix element… ▽ More We show that classical space-times can be derived directly from the S-matrix for a theory of massive particles coupled to a massless spin two particle. As an explicit example we derive the Schwarzchild space-time as a series in $G_N$. At no point of the derivation is any use made of the Einstein-Hilbert action or the Einstein equations. The intermediate steps involve only on-shell S-matrix elements which are generated via BCFW recursion relations and unitarity sewing techniques. The notion of a space-time metric is only introduced at the end of the calculation where it is extracted by matching the potential determined by the S-matrix to the geodesic motion of a test particle. Other static space-times such as Kerr follow in a similar manner. Furthermore, given that the procedure is action independent and depends only upon the choice of the representation of the little group, solutions to Yang-Mills (YM) theory can be generated in the same fashion. Moreover, the squaring relation between the YM and gravity three point functions shows that the seeds that generate solutions in the two theories are algebraically related. From a technical standpoint our methodology can also be utilized to calculate quantities relevant for the binary inspiral problem more efficiently than the more traditional Feynman diagram approach. △ Less

Submitted 26 April, 2013; originally announced April 2013.

A Formalism for the Systematic Treatment of Rapidity Logarithms in Quantum Field Theory

Authors: Jui-yu Chiu, Ambar Jain, Duff Neill, Ira Z. Rothstein

Abstract: Many observables in QCD rely upon the resummation of perturbation theory to retain predictive power. Resummation follows after one factorizes the cross section into the rele- vant modes. The class of observables which are sensitive to soft recoil effects are particularly challenging to factorize and resum since they involve rapidity logarithms. In this paper we will present a formalism which allow… ▽ More Many observables in QCD rely upon the resummation of perturbation theory to retain predictive power. Resummation follows after one factorizes the cross section into the rele- vant modes. The class of observables which are sensitive to soft recoil effects are particularly challenging to factorize and resum since they involve rapidity logarithms. In this paper we will present a formalism which allows one to factorize and resum the perturbative series for such observables in a systematic fashion through the notion of a "rapidity renormalization group". That is, a Collin-Soper like equation is realized as a renormalization group equation, but has a more universal applicability to observables beyond the traditional transverse momentum dependent parton distribution functions (TMDPDFs) and the Sudakov form factor. This formalism has the feature that it allows one to track the (non-standard) scheme dependence which is inherent in any scenario where one performs a resummation of rapidity divergences. We present a pedagogical introduction to the formalism by applying it to the well-known massive Sudakov form factor. The formalism is then used to study observables of current interest. A factorization theorem for the transverse momentum distribution of Higgs production is presented along with the result for the resummed cross section at NLL. Our formalism allows one to define gauge invariant TMDPDFs which are independent of both the hard scattering amplitude and the soft function, i.e. they are uni- versal. We present details of the factorization and resummation of the jet broadening cross section including a renormalization in pT space. We furthermore show how to regulate and renormalize exclusive processes which are plagued by endpoint singularities in such a way as to allow for a consistent resummation. △ Less

Submitted 3 December, 2013; v1 submitted 3 February, 2012; originally announced February 2012.

Comments: Typos in Appendix C corrected, as well as a typo in eq. 5.62

Report number: INT-PUB-11-057, CALT 68-2864

The Rapidity Renormalization Group

Authors: Jui-yu Chiu, Ambar Jain, Duff Neill, Ira Z. Rothstein

Abstract: We introduce a systematic approach for the resummation of perturbative series which involve large logarithms not only due to large invariant mass ratios but large rapidities as well. Series of this form can appear in a variety of gauge theory observables. The formalism is utilized to calculate the jet broadening event shape in a systematic fashion to next to leading logarithmic order. An operator… ▽ More We introduce a systematic approach for the resummation of perturbative series which involve large logarithms not only due to large invariant mass ratios but large rapidities as well. Series of this form can appear in a variety of gauge theory observables. The formalism is utilized to calculate the jet broadening event shape in a systematic fashion to next to leading logarithmic order. An operator definition of the factorized cross section as well as a closed form of the next-to leading log cross section are presented. The result agrees with the data to within errors. △ Less

Submitted 5 April, 2011; originally announced April 2011.

Comments: 4 pages, 3 figures

Analytic Virtual Corrections for Higgs Transverse Momentum Spectrum at $O(α_s^2/m_t^3)$ via Unitarity Methods

Authors: Duff Neill

Abstract: Utilizing the Higgs Effective Theory, including dimension eight operators, in conjuction with spinor-helicity and unitarity methods, I present analytic expressions for the virtual corrections for $gg\to Hg$ and $q\overline{q}\to Hg$ amplitudes at order $α_s^2/m_t^3$. These contributions become enhanced as the invariant final state mass increases. Utilizing the Higgs Effective Theory, including dimension eight operators, in conjuction with spinor-helicity and unitarity methods, I present analytic expressions for the virtual corrections for $gg\to Hg$ and $q\overline{q}\to Hg$ amplitudes at order $α_s^2/m_t^3$. These contributions become enhanced as the invariant final state mass increases. △ Less

Submitted 16 November, 2009; originally announced November 2009.

Two-Loop Matching onto Dimension Eight Operators in the Higgs-Glue Sector

Authors: Duff Neill

Abstract: This letter presents results for the two-loop matching coefficients for the dimension eight operators that contribute to Higgs production via gluon fusion. The coefficients can be used to calculate the first correction to the infinite top mass limit to Higgs production with large transverse momentum at two loops. To date such processes have been studied at two loop order only in the leading term i… ▽ More This letter presents results for the two-loop matching coefficients for the dimension eight operators that contribute to Higgs production via gluon fusion. The coefficients can be used to calculate the first correction to the infinite top mass limit to Higgs production with large transverse momentum at two loops. To date such processes have been studied at two loop order only in the leading term in the top mass expansion. These corrections become enhanced in processes with large final state invariant mass, typical of multijet processes. △ Less

Submitted 15 November, 2013; v1 submitted 11 August, 2009; originally announced August 2009.

Comments: Added references; corrected typos; Corrected a mistake in the matching, see note added