-
Comments on "Can quantum statistics help distinguish Dirac from Majorana neutrinos?" (arXiv:2402.05172 [hep-ph])
Authors:
C. S. Kim,
M. V. N. Murthy,
Dibyakrupa Sahoo
Abstract:
In a recent article arXiv:2402.05172 [hep-ph], the authors discuss the question "whether quantum statistics can help distinguish between Dirac and Majorana neutrinos." The paper contains, among other things, an unsubstantiated critique of the results derived in our papers arXiv:2106.11785 [hep-ph] and arXiv:2307.05654 [hep-ph]. One of the criticisms is related to our expression for differential de…
▽ More
In a recent article arXiv:2402.05172 [hep-ph], the authors discuss the question "whether quantum statistics can help distinguish between Dirac and Majorana neutrinos." The paper contains, among other things, an unsubstantiated critique of the results derived in our papers arXiv:2106.11785 [hep-ph] and arXiv:2307.05654 [hep-ph]. One of the criticisms is related to our expression for differential decay rate for the back-to-back neutrino-antineutrino configuration in the decay $B^0 \to μ^- \, μ^+ \, ν_μ\, \overlineν_μ$. We show that the claim is wrong and point out how the correct result was obtained. The second criticism is related to the implementation of the anti-symmetrization as dictated by quantum statistics for Majorana neutrinos and antineutrinos (which are identical, by definition). Any direct observation of the neutrinos, as done in Ref. \cite{Akhmedov:2024}, would project the neutrinos into distinguishable helicity states, thus nullifying all observable effects of quantum statistics. They have missed the point that our procedure holds when the neutrino and antineutrino remain undetected by the detector. In the back-to-back kinematic configuration, one can infer the neutrino energies without directly detecting their identities. This smartly ensures that the quantum statistical effects are not erased. Their overriding assertion that our papers arXiv:2106.11785 [hep-ph] and arXiv:2307.05654 [hep-ph] are incorrect fails to recognize that in both arXiv:2106.11785 [hep-ph] and arXiv:2307.05654 [hep-ph] we also point out generic conditions under which the practical Dirac-Majorana confusion theorem holds. "Clearly there is no confusion over confusion theorem."
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2024; v1 submitted 17 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Comments on "On the Dirac-Majorana neutrinos distinction in four-body decays" (arXiv:2305.14140 [hep-ph], Phys. Rev. D 109, no.3, 033005 (2024))
Authors:
C. S. Kim,
M. V. N. Murthy,
Dibyakrupa Sahoo
Abstract:
In arXiv:2305.14140 [hep-ph] the authors analyze the radiative leptonic decay $\ell^- \to ν_\ell \, \overlineν_{\ell'} \, \ell^{\prime -} \, γ$ to distinguish between Dirac and Majorana nature of neutrinos. They utilize the back-to-back kinematics for this purpose, a special kinematic configuration which we first proposed in our paper arXiv:2106.11785 [hep-ph]. Here we point out how and why their…
▽ More
In arXiv:2305.14140 [hep-ph] the authors analyze the radiative leptonic decay $\ell^- \to ν_\ell \, \overlineν_{\ell'} \, \ell^{\prime -} \, γ$ to distinguish between Dirac and Majorana nature of neutrinos. They utilize the back-to-back kinematics for this purpose, a special kinematic configuration which we first proposed in our paper arXiv:2106.11785 [hep-ph]. Here we point out how and why their analysis of the back-to-back configuration is incorrect. This makes their conclusion and comments invalid and untenable.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2024; v1 submitted 16 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Inferring the nature of active neutrinos: Dirac or Majorana?
Authors:
C. S. Kim,
M. V. N. Murthy,
Dibyakrupa Sahoo
Abstract:
The nature of a neutrino, whether it is a Dirac type or Majorana type, may be comprehensively probed using their quantum statistical properties. If the neutrino is a Majorana fermion, then by definition it is identical and indistinguishable from the corresponding antineutrino. When a Majorana neutrino and antineutrino are pair produced, the corresponding state has to obey the Pauli principle unlik…
▽ More
The nature of a neutrino, whether it is a Dirac type or Majorana type, may be comprehensively probed using their quantum statistical properties. If the neutrino is a Majorana fermion, then by definition it is identical and indistinguishable from the corresponding antineutrino. When a Majorana neutrino and antineutrino are pair produced, the corresponding state has to obey the Pauli principle unlike in the Dirac case. We use this property to distinguish between the two cases using the process $B^0 \to μ^-\,μ^+\,ν_μ\,\barν_μ$. We show that the two cases differ dramatically in a special kinematic scenario where, in the rest frame of the parent $B$ meson, the muons fly away back-to-back (i.e. fly with 3-momenta of equal magnitudes but opposite directions), and so do the neutrino and antineutrino. Unlike any other scenario, we know the energies and magnitudes of $3$-momenta of both the neutrino and the antineutrino in this back-to-back configuration without even directly measuring them. This provides a way of avoiding the constraint imposed by the `practical Dirac-Majorana confusion theorem', as one need not fully integrate over neutrino and antineutrino in this case. As a true signature of the universal principle of quantum statistics which does not depend on the size of the mass of the particle but its spin, the difference between Dirac and Majorana cases in this special kinematic configuration does survive independent of the neutrino mass as long as neutrino mass is nonzero. The analysis presented here is applicable immediately to several other processes with the same final state as in the case of $B^0$ decay without any major change.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2022; v1 submitted 22 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Hierarchy independent sensitivity to leptonic δ_CP with atmospheric neutrinos
Authors:
D Indumathi,
M V N Murthy,
Lakshmi S. Mohan
Abstract:
The Dirac leptonic CP phase δ_CP is one of the crucial unknown parameters in neutrino oscillation physics. In this paper we explore the possibility of using low energy atmospheric neutrino events to probe δ_CP . We show that at sub GeV energies, when the events are binned as a function of the energy and direction of the final state leptons, a consistent distinction between various true δ_CP values…
▽ More
The Dirac leptonic CP phase δ_CP is one of the crucial unknown parameters in neutrino oscillation physics. In this paper we explore the possibility of using low energy atmospheric neutrino events to probe δ_CP . We show that at sub GeV energies, when the events are binned as a function of the energy and direction of the final state leptons, a consistent distinction between various true δ_CP values is obtained. We also show that at these energies there is no sensitivity to the mass ordering/hierarchy, so that δ_CP can be measured without hierarchy ambiguity. In addition a preliminary \c{hi}^2 analysis of the sensitivity to δ_CP using atmospheric neutrinos assuming a generic detector with perfect separation between charged current ν_μ , \bar{ν}_μ , ν_e and \bar{ν}_e events is given.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2019; v1 submitted 31 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Schottky Anomaly and Hadronic Spectrum
Authors:
Aritra Biswas,
M V N Murthy,
Nita Sinha
Abstract:
We show that the hadronic "heat capacity" calculated as a function of temperature may be used to infer the possible presence of different scales underlying the dynamical structure of hadronic resonances using the phenomenon of Schottky anomaly. We first demonstrate this possibility with well known meson spectrum in various channels and comment on the possibility of using this method as a diagnosti…
▽ More
We show that the hadronic "heat capacity" calculated as a function of temperature may be used to infer the possible presence of different scales underlying the dynamical structure of hadronic resonances using the phenomenon of Schottky anomaly. We first demonstrate this possibility with well known meson spectrum in various channels and comment on the possibility of using this method as a diagnostic to distinguish the exotic states.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Stable or Unstable Light Dark Matter
Authors:
Ernest Ma,
M. V. N. Murthy,
G. Rajasekaran
Abstract:
We consider the case of light dark matter ($\sim 10$ GeV). We discuss a simple $Z_2$ model of scalar self-interacting dark matter, as well as a related model of unstable long-lived dark matter which can explain the anomalous Kolar events observed decades ago.
We consider the case of light dark matter ($\sim 10$ GeV). We discuss a simple $Z_2$ model of scalar self-interacting dark matter, as well as a related model of unstable long-lived dark matter which can explain the anomalous Kolar events observed decades ago.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Physics Potential of the ICAL detector at the India-based Neutrino Observatory (INO)
Authors:
The ICAL Collaboration,
Shakeel Ahmed,
M. Sajjad Athar,
Rashid Hasan,
Mohammad Salim,
S. K. Singh,
S. S. R. Inbanathan,
Venktesh Singh,
V. S. Subrahmanyam,
Shiba Prasad Behera,
Vinay B. Chandratre,
Nitali Dash,
Vivek M. Datar,
V. K. S. Kashyap,
Ajit K. Mohanty,
Lalit M. Pant,
Animesh Chatterjee,
Sandhya Choubey,
Raj Gandhi,
Anushree Ghosh,
Deepak Tiwari,
Ali Ajmi,
S. Uma Sankar,
Prafulla Behera,
Aleena Chacko
, et al. (67 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The upcoming 50 kt magnetized iron calorimeter (ICAL) detector at the India-based Neutrino Observatory (INO) is designed to study the atmospheric neutrinos and antineutrinos separately over a wide range of energies and path lengths. The primary focus of this experiment is to explore the Earth matter effects by observing the energy and zenith angle dependence of the atmospheric neutrinos in the mul…
▽ More
The upcoming 50 kt magnetized iron calorimeter (ICAL) detector at the India-based Neutrino Observatory (INO) is designed to study the atmospheric neutrinos and antineutrinos separately over a wide range of energies and path lengths. The primary focus of this experiment is to explore the Earth matter effects by observing the energy and zenith angle dependence of the atmospheric neutrinos in the multi-GeV range. This study will be crucial to address some of the outstanding issues in neutrino oscillation physics, including the fundamental issue of neutrino mass hierarchy. In this document, we present the physics potential of the detector as obtained from realistic detector simulations. We describe the simulation framework, the neutrino interactions in the detector, and the expected response of the detector to particles traversing it. The ICAL detector can determine the energy and direction of the muons to a high precision, and in addition, its sensitivity to multi-GeV hadrons increases its physics reach substantially. Its charge identification capability, and hence its ability to distinguish neutrinos from antineutrinos, makes it an efficient detector for determining the neutrino mass hierarchy. In this report, we outline the analyses carried out for the determination of neutrino mass hierarchy and precision measurements of atmospheric neutrino mixing parameters at ICAL, and give the expected physics reach of the detector with 10 years of runtime. We also explore the potential of ICAL for probing new physics scenarios like CPT violation and the presence of magnetic monopoles.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2017; v1 submitted 27 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Anomalous Kolar events revisited: Dark Matter?
Authors:
M V N Murthy,
G Rajasekaran
Abstract:
The possibility of the unexplained Kolar events, recorded in the 70's and 80's, being due to the decays of dark matter particles of mass in the range of 5--10 GeV is pointed out.
The possibility of the unexplained Kolar events, recorded in the 70's and 80's, being due to the decays of dark matter particles of mass in the range of 5--10 GeV is pointed out.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2014; v1 submitted 13 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Group velocity of neutrino waves
Authors:
D. Indumathi,
Romesh K. Kaul,
M. V. N. Murthy,
G. Rajasekaran
Abstract:
We follow up on the analysis of Mecozzi and Bellini (arXiv:1110:1253v1) where they showed, in principle, the possibility of superluminal propagation of neutrinos, as indicated by the recent OPERA result. We refine the analysis by introducing wave packets for the superposition of energy eigenstates and discuss the implications of their results with realistic values for the mixing and mass parameter…
▽ More
We follow up on the analysis of Mecozzi and Bellini (arXiv:1110:1253v1) where they showed, in principle, the possibility of superluminal propagation of neutrinos, as indicated by the recent OPERA result. We refine the analysis by introducing wave packets for the superposition of energy eigenstates and discuss the implications of their results with realistic values for the mixing and mass parameters in a full three neutrino mixing scenario. Our analysis shows the possibility of superluminal propagation of neutrino flavour in a very narrow range of neutrino parameter space. Simultaneously this reduces the number of observable events drastically. Therefore, the OPERA result cannot be explained in this frame-work.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2011; v1 submitted 25 October, 2011;
originally announced October 2011.
-
Neutrino oscillation probabilities: Sensitivity to parameters
Authors:
D. Indumathi,
M. V. N. Murthy,
G. Rajasekaran,
Nita Sinha
Abstract:
We study in detail the sensitivity of neutrino oscillation probabilities to the fundamental neutrino parameters and their possible determination through experiments. The first part of the paper is devoted to the broad theme of isolating regions in the neutrino (and anti-neutrino) energy and propagation length that are sensitive to the oscillation parameters. Such a study is relevant to neutrinos…
▽ More
We study in detail the sensitivity of neutrino oscillation probabilities to the fundamental neutrino parameters and their possible determination through experiments. The first part of the paper is devoted to the broad theme of isolating regions in the neutrino (and anti-neutrino) energy and propagation length that are sensitive to the oscillation parameters. Such a study is relevant to neutrinos both from the Earth's atmosphere or from a neutrino factory. For completeness we discuss the sensitivity, however small, to the parameters involved in a three-generation framework, and to the Earth matter density profile. We then study processes relevant to atmospheric neutrinos which are sensitive to and allow precision measurements of the mixing angle theta_23 and mass-squared difference delta_32 apart from the mixing angle theta_13. Crucial to this analysis is charge identification; detectors having this capability can isolate these matter effects. In particular, we address the issue of using matter effects to determine whether the mixing angle theta_23 is maximal, and, if not, to explore how well its octant can be determined. When realistic detector resolutions are included, we find that deviations of about 15% (20%) from a maximal value of sin^2 theta_23=1/2 can be measured at 95% (99%) CL provided theta_13 is non-zero, sin^2 theta_13 >= 0.015, and the neutrino mass ordering is normal, with fairly large exposures of 1000 kton-years.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2006; v1 submitted 31 March, 2006;
originally announced March 2006.
-
A question of hierarchy: matter effects with atmospheric neutrinos and anti-neutrinos
Authors:
D. Indumathi,
M. V. N. Murthy
Abstract:
It is by now established that neutrinos mix, have (different) non-zero masses, and therefore oscillate. The oscillation parameters themselves, however, are not all well-known. An open problem is that of the neutrino mass hierarchy. We study the possibility of determining the neutrino mass hierarchy with atmospheric neutrinos using an iron calorimeter detector capable of charge identification suc…
▽ More
It is by now established that neutrinos mix, have (different) non-zero masses, and therefore oscillate. The oscillation parameters themselves, however, are not all well-known. An open problem is that of the neutrino mass hierarchy. We study the possibility of determining the neutrino mass hierarchy with atmospheric neutrinos using an iron calorimeter detector capable of charge identification such as the proposed MONOLITH and ICAL/INO detectors. We find that such detectors are sensitive to the sign of the mass-squared difference, δ_{32} = m_3^2 - m_2^2, provided the as-yet unknown mixing angle between the first and third generations, θ_{13}, is greater than 6 degrees (\sin^2 2θ_{13} > 0.04). A result with a significance greater than 90% CL requires large exposures (more than 500 kton-years) as well as good energy and angular resolution of the detected muons (better than 15%), especially for small θ_{13}. Hence obtaining definitive results with such a detector is difficult, unless θ_{13} turns out to be large. In contrast, such detectors can establish a clear oscillation pattern in atmospheric neutrinos in about 150 kton-years, therefore determining the absolute value of δ_{32} and \sin^2 2 θ_{23} to within 10%.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2004; v1 submitted 29 July, 2004;
originally announced July 2004.
-
Implications of recent solar neutrino observations: an analysis of charged current data
Authors:
C. V. K. Baba,
D. Indumathi,
M. V. N. Murthy
Abstract:
We have analysed the recent results from the observation of charged current ν_e d \to e^- p p events from solar neutrinos by the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory SNO assuming neutrino oscillations with three active flavours. The data seem to prefer a low mass-squared difference and large mixing angle solution (the so-called LOW solution) in (12) parameter space. However, when combined with the Galli…
▽ More
We have analysed the recent results from the observation of charged current ν_e d \to e^- p p events from solar neutrinos by the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory SNO assuming neutrino oscillations with three active flavours. The data seem to prefer a low mass-squared difference and large mixing angle solution (the so-called LOW solution) in (12) parameter space. However, when combined with the Gallium charged current interaction data from Gallex and GNO, distinct (1σ) allowed regions corresponding to the large mixing angle (LMA) and small mixing angle (SMA) appear while the LOW solution is disfavoured upto 3σstandard deviation. The physical electron neutrino survival probability corresponding to these best fit solutions are then determined and analysed for their energy dependence.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2002; v1 submitted 7 January, 2002;
originally announced January 2002.
-
Discussion on a possible neutrino detector located in India
Authors:
M. V. N. Murthy,
U. A. Yajnik
Abstract:
We have identified some important and worthwhile physics opportunitites with a possible neutrino detector located in India. Particular emphasis is placed on the geographical advantage with a stress on the complimentary aspects with respect to other neutrino detectors already in operation.
We have identified some important and worthwhile physics opportunitites with a possible neutrino detector located in India. Particular emphasis is placed on the geographical advantage with a stress on the complimentary aspects with respect to other neutrino detectors already in operation.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2001;
originally announced December 2001.
-
Neutrinos from Stellar Collapse: Comparison of signatures in water and heavy water detectors
Authors:
Gautam Dutta,
D. Indumathi,
M. V. N. Murthy,
G. Rajasekaran
Abstract:
Signatures of neutrino and antineutrino signals from stellar collapse in heavy water detectors are contrasted with those in water detectors. The effects of mixing, especially due to the highly dense matter in the supernova core, are studied. The mixing parameters used are those sets allowed by current understanding of available neutrino data: from solar, atmospheric and laboratory neutrino exper…
▽ More
Signatures of neutrino and antineutrino signals from stellar collapse in heavy water detectors are contrasted with those in water detectors. The effects of mixing, especially due to the highly dense matter in the supernova core, are studied. The mixing parameters used are those sets allowed by current understanding of available neutrino data: from solar, atmospheric and laboratory neutrino experiments. Signals at a heavy water detector, especially the dominant charged current reactions on deuteron, are very sensitive to some of these sets of allowed mixing parameters. Theoretical uncertainties on supernova neutrino spectra notwithstanding, a combination of supernova measurements with water and heavy water detectors may be able to distinguish many of these mixing possibilities and thus help in ruling out many of them.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2001; v1 submitted 10 January, 2001;
originally announced January 2001.
-
Neutrinos from Stellar Collapse: Comparison of the effects of three and four flavour mixings
Authors:
Gautam Dutta,
D. Indumathi,
M. V. N. Murthy,
G. Rajasekaran
Abstract:
We study the effect of non-vanishing masses and mixings among neutrino flavours on the detection of neutrinos from stellar collapse by a water Cerenkov detector. We consider a frame-work in which there are four neutrino flavours, including a sterile neutrino, whose mass squared differences and mixings are constrained by the present understanding of solar, atmospheric and laboratory neutrino dete…
▽ More
We study the effect of non-vanishing masses and mixings among neutrino flavours on the detection of neutrinos from stellar collapse by a water Cerenkov detector. We consider a frame-work in which there are four neutrino flavours, including a sterile neutrino, whose mass squared differences and mixings are constrained by the present understanding of solar, atmospheric and laboratory neutrino detection. We also include the effects of high density matter within the supernova core. Unlike in the three flavour scenario, we find that the number of events due to the dominant process involving electron-antineutrinos changes dramatically for some allowed mixing parameters. Furthermore, contributions from charged-current scattering off oxygen nuclei in the detector can be considerably enhanced due to flavour mixing. We also present a comparison between the two possible scenarios, namely, when only three active neutrino flavours are present and when they are accompanied by a fourth sterile neutrino.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2000;
originally announced June 2000.
-
Neutrinos from Stellar Collapse: Effects of flavour mixing
Authors:
Gautam Dutta,
D. Indumathi,
M. V. N. Murthy,
G. Rajasekaran
Abstract:
We study the effect of non-vanishing masses and mixings among neutrino flavours on the detection of neutrinos from stellar collapse by a water Cerenkov detector. We consider a realistic framework in which there are three neutrino flavours whose mass squared differences and mixings are constrained by the present understanding of solar and atmospheric neutrinos. We also include the effects of high…
▽ More
We study the effect of non-vanishing masses and mixings among neutrino flavours on the detection of neutrinos from stellar collapse by a water Cerenkov detector. We consider a realistic framework in which there are three neutrino flavours whose mass squared differences and mixings are constrained by the present understanding of solar and atmospheric neutrinos. We also include the effects of high dense matter within the supernova core. We find that the number of events due to the dominant process involving electron-antineutrinos may change dramatically for some allowed mixing parameters. Furthermore, contributions from charged-current scattering off oxygen atoms in the detector can be considerably enhanced due to flavour mixing; such events have a distinct experimental signature since they are backward-peaked. Hence, mixing has a non-trivial effect on the signature of neutrinos (and antineutrinos) from stellar collapse.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 1999; v1 submitted 15 July, 1999;
originally announced July 1999.
-
Solar and atmospheric neutrino oscillations with three flavours
Authors:
Mohan Narayan,
M. V. N. Murthy,
G. Rajasekaran,
S. Uma Sankar
Abstract:
We analyze the solar and the atmospheric neutrino problems in the context of three flavour neutrino oscillations. We assume a mass hierarchy in the vacuum mass eigenvalues $μ_3^2 \gg μ_2^2 \geq μ_1^2$, but make no approximation regarding the magnitudes of the mixing angles. We find that there are small but continuous bands in the parameter space where the constraints imposed by the current measu…
▽ More
We analyze the solar and the atmospheric neutrino problems in the context of three flavour neutrino oscillations. We assume a mass hierarchy in the vacuum mass eigenvalues $μ_3^2 \gg μ_2^2 \geq μ_1^2$, but make no approximation regarding the magnitudes of the mixing angles. We find that there are small but continuous bands in the parameter space where the constraints imposed by the current measurements of $ \ {}^{71} Ga$, ${}^{37} Cl$ and Kamiokande experiments are satisfied at $1 σ$ level. The allowed parameter space increases dramatically if the error bars are enlarged to $1.6 σ$. The electron neutrino survival probability has different energy dependence in different regions of the parameter space. Measurement of the recoil electron energy spectrum in detectors that use $ν- e$ scattering may distinguish between some of the allowed regions of parameter space. Finally we use the results for the parameter space admitted by the solar neutrinos as an input for the atmospheric neutrino problem and show that there exists a substantial region of parameter space in which both problems can be solved.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 1995;
originally announced May 1995.
-
Haldane Exclusion Statistics and the Boltzmann Equation
Authors:
R. K. Bhaduri,
R. S. Bhalerao,
M. V. N. Murthy
Abstract:
We generalize the collision term in the one-dimensional Boltzmann-Nordheim transport equation for quasiparticles that obey the Haldane exclusion statistics. For the equilibrium situation, this leads to the ``golden rule'' factor for quantum transitions. As an application of this, we calculate the density response function of a one-dimensional electron gas in a periodic potential, assuming that t…
▽ More
We generalize the collision term in the one-dimensional Boltzmann-Nordheim transport equation for quasiparticles that obey the Haldane exclusion statistics. For the equilibrium situation, this leads to the ``golden rule'' factor for quantum transitions. As an application of this, we calculate the density response function of a one-dimensional electron gas in a periodic potential, assuming that the particle-hole excitations are quasiparticles obeying the new statistics. We also calculate the relaxation time of a nuclear spin in a metal using the modified golden rule.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 1995; v1 submitted 28 November, 1994;
originally announced November 1994.
