-
Light Scalars in the Extended Georgi-Machacek Model
Authors:
Poulami Mondal,
Subrata Samanta
Abstract:
We perform global fits of the CP-conserving Georgi-Machacek (GM) and extended Georgi-Machacek (eGM) models, incorporating a light CP-even beyond the Standard Model (BSM) scalar within the mass range of $90$ GeV to $100$ GeV. These fits combine the Higgs signal strengths and direct search limits from ATLAS and CMS at $\sqrt{s} = 8$ and $13$ TeV, $B$-physics observables, and theoretical constraints…
▽ More
We perform global fits of the CP-conserving Georgi-Machacek (GM) and extended Georgi-Machacek (eGM) models, incorporating a light CP-even beyond the Standard Model (BSM) scalar within the mass range of $90$ GeV to $100$ GeV. These fits combine the Higgs signal strengths and direct search limits from ATLAS and CMS at $\sqrt{s} = 8$ and $13$ TeV, $B$-physics observables, and theoretical constraints arising from next-to-leading order (NLO) unitarity and BFB constraints. From the global fit, we show that the LHC diphoton and LEP $b\bar{b}$ excesses around $95$ GeV are well compatible with the $125$ GeV Higgs data. Whereas the CMS ditau excess is incompatible with the $125$ GeV Higgs signal strength data in both the CP-conserving GM and eGM models. We present the results from the combined fit, including the $95$ GeV Higgs signal strength data. In the eGM model, the triplet VEV cannot exceed $12$ GeV for additional BSM scalar masses below $160$ GeV and approximately $25$ GeV for additional BSM scalar masses above $160$ GeV. The masses of additional BSM scalars cannot exceed $600$ GeV. The maximum mass splitting is of around $120$ GeV within the members of each custodial multiplet, and up to $250$ GeV between the members of different multiplets. In the GM model, these constraints become more stringent: the triplet VEV is limited to below $15$ GeV, which tightens to $4$ GeV once the BSM scalar masses are below $160$ GeV. Masses of the quintet $m_5$ and the triplet $m_3$ are restricted to be below $530$ GeV and $320$ GeV, respectively. A mass hierarchy, $m_5 > m_3$, is favoured in the high-mass region, with the mass splitting constrained to be less than $210$ GeV.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Resonances all over the place?
Authors:
Anirban Kundu,
Poulami Mondal,
Gilbert Moultaka
Abstract:
We provide a possible interpretation of excesses reported by ATLAS and CMS at around 95GeV, 650GeV and possibly 320GeV, in terms of CP-even scalars. In particular, the combined {\sl global} statistical significances of independent indications for a 650GeV object reach the $4σ$ level! While this seems sufficient incentive for a further investigation, this object cannot be fitted in tradional single…
▽ More
We provide a possible interpretation of excesses reported by ATLAS and CMS at around 95GeV, 650GeV and possibly 320GeV, in terms of CP-even scalars. In particular, the combined {\sl global} statistical significances of independent indications for a 650GeV object reach the $4σ$ level! While this seems sufficient incentive for a further investigation, this object cannot be fitted in tradional singlet or doublet extensions of the Standard Model. It requires by itself a larger extension with doubly-charged scalars, that naturally fits the two other excesses on top of the SM-like 125~GeV Higgs. We describe the minimal model and give some numerical illustrations.
△ Less
Submitted 29 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Indications for new scalar resonances at the LHC and a possible interpretation
Authors:
Anirban Kundu,
Poulami Mondal,
Gilbert Moultaka
Abstract:
There have been indications of several new resonances at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). Two of them, at about 95 GeV and 650 GeV, have been indicated by more than one experiments and have reached statistical significance worthy of a serious investigation. Conservatively using only the numbers given by the experimental collaborations, we find combined global significances around 3$σ$ and 4$σ$ res…
▽ More
There have been indications of several new resonances at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). Two of them, at about 95 GeV and 650 GeV, have been indicated by more than one experiments and have reached statistical significance worthy of a serious investigation. Conservatively using only the numbers given by the experimental collaborations, we find combined global significances around 3$σ$ and 4$σ$ respectively for the 95 GeV and 650 GeV putative resonances. There are some more which may soon become very significant. We show that the data on only the 650 GeV resonance, assuming they stand the test of time, predict the existence of a doubly-charged scalar, and make the extensions of the scalar sector like those by gauge singlet scalars, the 2-Higgs doublet models or the Georgi-Machacek model, highly disfavored. We provide the readers with a minimalistic model that can explain all the indications. Such a model can also accommodate the hints of a singly charged scalar at about 375 GeV, and a doubly charged scalar at about 450 GeV, as found by both the major LHC Collaborations, the combined global significance for each of them being above $2.5σ$. Our analysis comes with the obvious caveat that the allowed parameter space that we find depends on the available data on all the new resonances, and may change in future.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Next-to-Leading Order Unitarity Fits in the Extended Georgi-Machacek Model
Authors:
Debtosh Chowdhury,
Poulami Mondal,
Subrata Samanta
Abstract:
The Georgi-Machacek (GM) model is a triplet scalar extension of the Standard Model (SM) that preserves custodial symmetry (CS) due to an explicit global $SU(2)_L\otimes SU(2)_R$ symmetry in the scalar potential at tree-level. However, it is also possible to construct a triplet extended scalar sector of the SM without imposing this global symmetry in the potential while still maintaining CS at tree…
▽ More
The Georgi-Machacek (GM) model is a triplet scalar extension of the Standard Model (SM) that preserves custodial symmetry (CS) due to an explicit global $SU(2)_L\otimes SU(2)_R$ symmetry in the scalar potential at tree-level. However, it is also possible to construct a triplet extended scalar sector of the SM without imposing this global symmetry in the potential while still maintaining CS at tree-level. This is referred to as the extended GM (eGM) model. We compute one-loop corrections to all $2\to2$ bosonic scattering amplitudes in both models and place next-to-leading order (NLO) unitarity bounds on the quartic couplings. Further, we derive the bounded-from-below (BFB) conditions on the quartic couplings demanding the stability of the scalar potential in the field subspaces. We show that the 3-field BFB conditions provide a very good approximation of the 13-field BFB conditions for both models and are computationally more efficient. With these theoretical constraints, we perform a global fit of both models to the latest Higgs signal strength results from the $13$ TeV Large Hadron Collider. We observe that the global fit disfavors the regions where $κ_V > 1.05$, $κ_V < 0.95$, and $κ_f > 1.05$, $κ_f< 0.92$ at a $95.4\%$ CL for both models. The global fit results demonstrate that NLO unitarity and stability bounds play a significant role in constraining the allowed parameter space of both models. We obtain an upper limit on the absolute values of the scalar quartic couplings to be $1.91\:(2.51)$ in the GM (eGM) model. We find that in both models, the absolute mass differences between the heavy Higgs bosons are less than $410$ GeV if their masses are below $1.1$ TeV. The maximal mass difference among the members of each CS multiplet is less than $210$ GeV in the eGM model.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2025; v1 submitted 29 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Troubles mounting for multipolar dark matter
Authors:
Debajit Bose,
Debtosh Chowdhury,
Poulami Mondal,
Tirtha Sankar Ray
Abstract:
In this paper, we revisit the experimental constraints on the multipolar dark matter that has derivative coupling to the visible sector mediated by the Standard Model photon. The momentum dependent interaction enables them to be captured efficiently within massive celestial bodies boosted by their steep gravitational potential. This phenomena makes compact celestial bodies as an efficient target t…
▽ More
In this paper, we revisit the experimental constraints on the multipolar dark matter that has derivative coupling to the visible sector mediated by the Standard Model photon. The momentum dependent interaction enables them to be captured efficiently within massive celestial bodies boosted by their steep gravitational potential. This phenomena makes compact celestial bodies as an efficient target to probe such type of dark matter candidates. We demonstrate that a synergy of the updated direct detection results from DarkSide-50 and LUX-ZEPLIN together with IceCube bounds on high energy solar neutrinos from dark matter capture disfavour the viable parameter space of the dipolar dark matter scenario. Whereas, for the anapole dark matter scenario, a narrow window survives that lies within the reach of prospective heating signals due to the capture of dark matter at cold neutron stars.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2024; v1 submitted 8 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Mass and infinite dimensional geometry
Authors:
Puskar Mondal
Abstract:
I unravel an elegant geometric meaning of the mass of the lowest energy excited state of a renormalizable quantized field theory by studying the weighted geometry of the classical configuration space of the theory. A suitably defined regularized Bakry-Emery Ricci curvature of these infinite dimensional spaces controls the spectra of the corresponding quantum Hamiltonians. The Ricci curvature part…
▽ More
I unravel an elegant geometric meaning of the mass of the lowest energy excited state of a renormalizable quantized field theory by studying the weighted geometry of the classical configuration space of the theory. A suitably defined regularized Bakry-Emery Ricci curvature of these infinite dimensional spaces controls the spectra of the corresponding quantum Hamiltonians. The Ricci curvature part of the full Bakry-Emery Ricci curvature appears to be purely quantum in nature. This geometric contribution to the spectra in the context of quantum field theory has not been studied previously to my knowledge. Assuming the existence of rigorous quantization, I present a few problems starting from massive free particles to the non-abelian Yang-Mills theory. A remarkable property is observed in the large $N$ Yang-Mills theory, where a non-trivial mass gap is preserved. This occurs due to the fact that the regularized Bakry-Emery Ricci curvature that is responsible for the gap of the configuration space scales as $g^{2}_{YM}N=λ$ ('t Hooft coupling) that remains invariant.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
A Geometric Approach to the Yang-Mills Mass Gap
Authors:
Puskar Mondal
Abstract:
I provide a new idea based on geometric analysis to obtain a positive mass gap in pure non-abelian renormalizable Yang-Mills theory. The orbit space, that is the space of connections of Yang-Mills theory modulo gauge transformations, is equipped with a Riemannian metric that naturally arises from the kinetic part of reduced classical action and admits a positive definite sectional curvature. The c…
▽ More
I provide a new idea based on geometric analysis to obtain a positive mass gap in pure non-abelian renormalizable Yang-Mills theory. The orbit space, that is the space of connections of Yang-Mills theory modulo gauge transformations, is equipped with a Riemannian metric that naturally arises from the kinetic part of reduced classical action and admits a positive definite sectional curvature. The corresponding regularized \textit{Bakry-Émery} Ricci curvature (if positive) is shown to produce a mass gap for $2+1$ and $3+1$ dimensional Yang-Mills theory assuming the existence of a quantized Yang-Mills theory on $(\mathbb{R}^{1+2},η)$ and $(\mathbb{R}^{1+3},η)$, respectively. My result on the gap calculation, described at least as a heuristic one, applies to non-abelian Yang-Mills theory with any compact semi-simple Lie group in the aforementioned dimensions. In $2+1$ dimensions, the square of the Yang-Mils coupling constant $g^{2}_{YM}$ has the dimension of mass, and therefore the spectral gap of the Hamiltonian is essentially proportional to $g^{2}_{YM}$ with proportionality constant being purely numerical as expected. Due to the dimensional restriction on $3+1$ dimensional Yang-Mills theory, it seems one ought to introduce a length scale to obtain an energy scale. It turns out that a certain `trace' operation on the infinite-dimensional geometry naturally introduces a length scale that has to be fixed by measuring the energy of the lowest glu-ball state. However, this remains to be understood in a rigorous way.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2023; v1 submitted 17 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Searches for scalars at LHC and interpretation of the findings
Authors:
Anirban Kundu,
Alain Le Yaouanc,
Poulami Mondal,
François Richard
Abstract:
In view of the future Higgs factories, this work presents the status of scalar searches at the LHC with an emphasis on the H(650) resonance which has been observed in WW, ZZ and h(95)h(125) channels, with a cumulative evidence of about 7 s.d. global significance. Its interpretation in models, restricted to extension of the scalar sector by SU(2) singlets and doublets, is clearly excluded, while it…
▽ More
In view of the future Higgs factories, this work presents the status of scalar searches at the LHC with an emphasis on the H(650) resonance which has been observed in WW, ZZ and h(95)h(125) channels, with a cumulative evidence of about 7 s.d. global significance. Its interpretation in models, restricted to extension of the scalar sector by SU(2) singlets and doublets, is clearly excluded, while its interpretation in models with additional triplets requires an extension with respect to the conventional Georgi-Machacek model. A general picture of these searches is updated, showing that h(95) is also reaching a similar level of evidence while two other candidates, A(400) and h(151), although less prominent, are above the 4 s.d. global evidence.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Enhancement of the $\textbf{W}$ boson mass in the Georgi-Machacek model
Authors:
Poulami Mondal
Abstract:
The recent CDF-II measurement of the mass of the $W$ boson shows a significant tension with the Standard Model (SM) expectation, even when averaged with earlier measurements. The tension can be explained in the framework of any beyond-SM dynamics that contributes substantially to the oblique $S$ and $T$ parameters. As a typical example of such beyond-SM physics, we try to explain the tension in th…
▽ More
The recent CDF-II measurement of the mass of the $W$ boson shows a significant tension with the Standard Model (SM) expectation, even when averaged with earlier measurements. The tension can be explained in the framework of any beyond-SM dynamics that contributes substantially to the oblique $S$ and $T$ parameters. As a typical example of such beyond-SM physics, we try to explain the tension in the framework of the Georgi-Machacek model that keeps $ρ=1$ at the tree-level, and explore the parameter space that can accommodate the $W$ mass shift. We find that a sizeable split between the custodial triplet and 5-plet of scalars can help alleviate the tension to a large extent, and raise the $W$-mass by about 30 MeV over its SM value.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2022; v1 submitted 16 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Custodial symmetry, Georgi-Machacek model, and other scalar extensions
Authors:
Anirban Kundu,
Poulami Mondal,
Palash B. Pal
Abstract:
In an SU(2) gauge theory, if the gauge bosons turn out to be degenerate after spontaneous symmetry breaking, obviously these mass terms are invariant under a global SU(2) symmetry that is unbroken. The pure gauge terms are also invariant under this symmetry. This symmetry is called the {\em custodial symmetry} (CS). In $\rm SU(2)\times U(1)$ gauge theories, CS implies a mass relation between the…
▽ More
In an SU(2) gauge theory, if the gauge bosons turn out to be degenerate after spontaneous symmetry breaking, obviously these mass terms are invariant under a global SU(2) symmetry that is unbroken. The pure gauge terms are also invariant under this symmetry. This symmetry is called the {\em custodial symmetry} (CS). In $\rm SU(2)\times U(1)$ gauge theories, CS implies a mass relation between the $W$ and the $Z$ bosons. The Standard Model (SM), as well as various extensions of it in the scalar sector, possess such a symmetry. In this paper, we critically examine the notion of CS and show that there may be three different classes of CS, depending on the gauge couplings and self-couplings of the scalars. Among old models that preserve CS, we discuss the Two-Higgs Doublet Model and the one doublet plus two triplet model by Georgi and Machacek. We show that for two-triplet extensions, the Georgi-Machacek model is not the most general possibility with CS. Rather, we find, as the most general extension, a new model with more parameters and hence a richer phenomenology. Some of the consequences of this new model have also been discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2022; v1 submitted 28 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Hierarchy problem and dimension-six effective operators
Authors:
Ambalika Biswas,
Anirban Kundu,
Poulami Mondal
Abstract:
Without any mechanism to protect its mass, the self-energy of the Higgs boson diverges quadratically, leading to the hierarchy or fine-tuning problem. One bottom-up solution is to postulate some yet-to-be-discovered symmetry which forces the sum of the quadratic divergences to be zero, or almost negligible; this is known as the Veltman condition. Even if one assumes the existence of some new physi…
▽ More
Without any mechanism to protect its mass, the self-energy of the Higgs boson diverges quadratically, leading to the hierarchy or fine-tuning problem. One bottom-up solution is to postulate some yet-to-be-discovered symmetry which forces the sum of the quadratic divergences to be zero, or almost negligible; this is known as the Veltman condition. Even if one assumes the existence of some new physics at a high scale, the fine-tuning problem is not eradicated, although it is softer than what it would have been with a Planck scale momentum cut-off. We study such divergences in an effective theory framework, and construct the Veltman condition with dimension-six operators. We show that there are two classes of diagrams, the one-loop and the two-loop ones, that contribute to quadratic divergences, but the contribution of the latter is suppressed by a loop factor of $1/16π^2$. There are only six dimension-six operators that contribute to the one-loop category, and the Wilson coefficients of these operators play an important role towards softening the fine-tuning problem. We find the parameter space for the Wilson coefficients that satisfies the extended Veltman condition, and also discuss why one need not bother about the $d>6$ operators. The parameter space is consistent with the theoretical and experimental bounds of the Wilson coefficients, and should act as a guide to the model builders.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2020; v1 submitted 24 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
A 96 GeV scalar tagged to dark matter models
Authors:
Anirban Kundu,
Suvam Maharana,
Poulami Mondal
Abstract:
Recently, the CMS Collaboration observed the hint of a resonance decaying to two photons at about 96 GeV with a local significance of $2.8σ$. While it is too early to say whether this will stand the test of time, such a resonance can easily be accommodated in many extensions of the Standard Model (SM). The more challenging part is to tune such an extension so that the required number of diphoton e…
▽ More
Recently, the CMS Collaboration observed the hint of a resonance decaying to two photons at about 96 GeV with a local significance of $2.8σ$. While it is too early to say whether this will stand the test of time, such a resonance can easily be accommodated in many extensions of the Standard Model (SM). The more challenging part is to tune such an extension so that the required number of diphoton events is reproduced. Assuming that the new resonance is a scalar, we propose that the signal may come either from an ultraviolet complete model with vectorial quarks, or a model involving gluon-scalar and photon-scalar effective operators. We then incorporate this portal to several extensions of the SM that include one or more cold dark matter candidates, and try to investigate how the existence of such a scalar resonance affects the parameter space of such models. As expected, we find that with such a scalar, the parameter space gets more constrained and hence, more tractable. We show how significant constraints can be placed on the parameter space, not only from direct dark matter searches or LHC data but also from theoretical considerations like scattering unitarity or stability of the potential, and discuss some novel features of the allowed parameter space.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2020; v1 submitted 30 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
