-
Is MOND necessarily nonlinear?
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
The iconic, deep-MOND-limit (DML) relation between acceleration and mass, $a\sim (M\mathcal{A}_0)^{1/2}/r$, implies that, in MOND, accelerations cannot be linear in the mass distribution ($\mathcal{A}_0\equiv Ga_0$ is the DML constant, and $a_0$ the MOND acceleration). This leads to important idiosyncracies of MOND, such as a breakdown of the strong equivalence principle, and the resulting ``exter…
▽ More
The iconic, deep-MOND-limit (DML) relation between acceleration and mass, $a\sim (M\mathcal{A}_0)^{1/2}/r$, implies that, in MOND, accelerations cannot be linear in the mass distribution ($\mathcal{A}_0\equiv Ga_0$ is the DML constant, and $a_0$ the MOND acceleration). This leads to important idiosyncracies of MOND, such as a breakdown of the strong equivalence principle, and the resulting ``external-field effect''. I show that the DML axioms are, in themselves, consistent with a, possibly unique, nonrelativistic, action-based, linear formulation of the DML. This model suffers from important drawbacks, which may make it unacceptable as a basis for a full-fledged MOND theory. The model is unique among MOND theories propounded to date not only in being linear -- hence not exhibiting an external-field effect, for example -- but in constituting a modification of both Newtonian inertia and Newtonian gravity. This linear and time-local model inspires and begets several, one-parameter families of models. One family employs nonlinear, time-nonlocal kinetic terms, but still linear gravitational-field equations. Other families generalize the DMLs of AQUAL and QUMOND, modifying gravity as well as inertia. All families employ fractional time derivatives and possibly fractional Laplacians. At present, I cannot base some acceptable MOND theory on these models -- for example, I cannot offer a sensible umbrella theory that interpolates between these DML models and Newtonian dynamics. They are, however, quite useful in elucidating various matter-of-principle aspects of MOND; e.g., they help to understand which predictions follow from only the basic tenets of MOND -- so-called primary predictions -- and which are secondary, i.e., theory dependent. The models may also show the way to a wider class of MOND theories. (Abridged.)
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2025; v1 submitted 10 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Central-surface-densities correlation in general MOND theories
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
It is shown that the foundational axioms of MOND alone predict a strong correlation between a bulk measure of the baryonic surface density, $Σ_B$, and the corresponding dynamical one, $Σ_D$, of an isolated object, such as a galaxy. The correlation is encapsulated by its high- and low-$Σ_B$ behaviors. For $Σ_B\ggΣ_M\equiv a_0/2πG$ ($Σ_M$ is the critical MOND surface density) one has…
▽ More
It is shown that the foundational axioms of MOND alone predict a strong correlation between a bulk measure of the baryonic surface density, $Σ_B$, and the corresponding dynamical one, $Σ_D$, of an isolated object, such as a galaxy. The correlation is encapsulated by its high- and low-$Σ_B$ behaviors. For $Σ_B\ggΣ_M\equiv a_0/2πG$ ($Σ_M$ is the critical MOND surface density) one has $Σ_D\approxΣ_B$. Their difference -- which would be interpreted as the contribution of dark matter -- is $Σ_P=Σ_D-Σ_B\simΣ_M\llΣ_B$. In the deep-MOND limit, $Σ_B\llΣ_M$, one has $Σ_D\sim (Σ_MΣ_B)^{1/2}$. This is a primary prediction of MOND, shared by all theories that embody its basic tenets. Sharper correlations, even strict algebraic relations, $Σ_D(Σ_B)$, are predicted in specific MOND theories, for specific classes of mass distribution -- e.g., pure discs, or spherical systems -- and for specific definitions of the surface densities. I proceed to discuss such tighter correlations for the central surface densities of axisymmetric galactic systems, $Σ^0_B$ and $Σ^0_D$. Past work has demonstrated such relations for pure discs in the AQUAL and QUMOND theories. Here I consider them in broader classes of MOND theories. For most observed systems, $Σ^0_D$ can not be determined directly at present, but, in many cases, a good proxy for it is the acceleration integral $\mathcal{G}\equiv\int_0^\infty g_r d\ln~r$, where $g_r$ is the radial acceleration along a reflection-symmetry plane of a system, such as a disc galaxy. $\mathcal{G}$ can be determined directly from the rotation curve. I discuss the extent to which $\mathcal{G}$ is a good proxy for $Σ^0_D$, and how the relation between them depends on system geometry, from pure discs, through disc-plus-bulge ones, to quasi-spherical systems.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2024; v1 submitted 11 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
MOND as manifestation of modified inertia
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
Practically all the full-fledged MOND theories propounded to date are of the modified-gravity (MG) type: they modify only the Newtonian, Poisson action of the gravitational potential, or the general-relativistic Einstein-Hilbert action, leaving other terms (inertia) intact. Here, I discuss the interpretation of MOND as modified inertia (MI). My main aim is threefold: (a) to advocate exploring MOND…
▽ More
Practically all the full-fledged MOND theories propounded to date are of the modified-gravity (MG) type: they modify only the Newtonian, Poisson action of the gravitational potential, or the general-relativistic Einstein-Hilbert action, leaving other terms (inertia) intact. Here, I discuss the interpretation of MOND as modified inertia (MI). My main aim is threefold: (a) to advocate exploring MOND theories beyond MG, and appreciating their idiosyncrasies, (b) to highlight the fact that secondary predictions of such theories can differ materially from those of MG theories, (c) to demonstrate some of this with specific MI models. I discuss some definitions and generalities concerning MI. I then present instances of MI in physics, and the lessons we can learn from them for MOND. I then concentrate on a specific class of nonrelativistic, MOND, MI models, and contrast their predictions with those of the two workhorse, MG theories -- AQUAL and QUMOND. The MI models predict possibly a stronger external-field effect -- e.g. on low acceleration systems in the solar neighborhood -- such as very wide binary stars -- and on vertical motions in disc galaxies. More generally, the workings of the effect are rather different, and depend in different ways on dimensionless characteristics of the system, such as frequency ratios of the external and internal fields, eccentricity of trajectories, etc. These models predict a {\it much} weaker effect of the Galactic field in the inner Solar System than is predicted by AQUAL/QUMOND. I also show how noncircular motions -- such as those perpendicular to the disc -- modify the standard, algebraic mass-discrepancy-acceleration relation (aka RAR) that is predicted by MI for exactly circular orbits. These differences, and more that are discussed, can potentially offer ways to distinguish between theories.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2023; v1 submitted 22 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Tripotential MOND theories
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
I present a new class of nonrelativistic, modified-gravity MOND theories. The three gravitational degrees of freedom of these ``TRIMOND'' theories are the MOND potential and two auxiliary potentials, one of which emerges as the Newtonian potential. Their Lagrangians involve a function of three acceleration variables -- the gradients of the potentials. So, the transition from the Newtonian to the M…
▽ More
I present a new class of nonrelativistic, modified-gravity MOND theories. The three gravitational degrees of freedom of these ``TRIMOND'' theories are the MOND potential and two auxiliary potentials, one of which emerges as the Newtonian potential. Their Lagrangians involve a function of three acceleration variables -- the gradients of the potentials. So, the transition from the Newtonian to the MOND regime is rather richer than in the aquadratic-Lagrangian theory (AQUAL) and the quasilinear MOND theory (QUMOND), which are special cases of TRIMOND, each defined by a Lagrangian function of a single variable. In particular, unlike AQUAL and QUMOND whose deep-MOND limit (DML) is fully dictated by the required scale invariance, here, the scale-invariant DML still requires specifying a function of two variables. For one-dimensional (e.g., spherical) mass distributions, in all TRIMOND theories the MOND acceleration is a (theory specific, but system independent) function of the Newtonian acceleration; their variety appears in nonsymmetric situations. Also, they all make the salient, primary MOND predictions. For example, they predict the same DML virial relation as AQUAL and QUMOND, and thus the same DML $M-σ$ relation, and the same DML two-body force. Yet they can differ materially on secondary predictions. Such TRIMOND theories may be the nonrelativistic limits of scalar-bimetric relativistic formulations of MOND, such as BIMOND with an added scalar.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2023; v1 submitted 31 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Generalizations of Quasilinear MOND (QUMOND)
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
I present a class of theories that generalize quasilinear MOND (QUMOND). Like QUMOND, these GQUMOND theories require solving only the linear Poisson equation (twice). Unlike QUMOND, their Lagrangian depends on higher derivatives of the Newtonian potential. They thus dictate different "phantom" densities as virtual sources in the Poisson equation for the MOND potential. These theories might open ne…
▽ More
I present a class of theories that generalize quasilinear MOND (QUMOND). Like QUMOND, these GQUMOND theories require solving only the linear Poisson equation (twice). Unlike QUMOND, their Lagrangian depends on higher derivatives of the Newtonian potential. They thus dictate different "phantom" densities as virtual sources in the Poisson equation for the MOND potential. These theories might open new avenues to more fundamental theories, and have much heuristic value. I use them to demonstrate that even within limited classes of modified-gravity formulations of MOND, theories can differ substantially on lower-tier MOND predictions. Such GQUMOND theories force, generically, the introduction of dimensioned constants other than the MOND acceleration, $a_0$, such as a length, a frequency, etc. As a result, some of these theories reduce to QUMOND itself only, e.g., on length scales (or, in other versions, dynamical times) larger than some critical value. But in smaller systems (or, alternatively, in ones with shorter dynamical times), MOND effects are screened, even if their internal accelerations are smaller than $a_0$. In such theories it is possible that MOND (expressed as QUMOND) applies on galactic scales, but its departures from Newtonian dynamics are substantially suppressed in some subgalactic systems -- such as binary stars, and open, or globular star clusters. The same holds for the effect of the galactic field on dynamics in the inner solar system, which can be greatly suppressed compared with what QUMOND predicts. Tidal effects of a galaxy on smaller subsystems are the same as in QUMOND, for the examples I consider. I also describe briefly versions that do not involve dimensioned constants other than $a_0$, and yet differ from QUMOND in important ways.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2023; v1 submitted 2 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Broader view of bimetric MOND
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
All existing treatments of bimetric MOND (BIMOND) -- a class of relativistic versions of MOND -- have dealt with a rather restricted sub-class: The Lagrangian of the interaction between the gravitational degrees of freedom -- the two metrics -- is a function of a certain {\it single} scalar argument built from the difference in connections of the two metrics. I show that the scope of BIMOND is muc…
▽ More
All existing treatments of bimetric MOND (BIMOND) -- a class of relativistic versions of MOND -- have dealt with a rather restricted sub-class: The Lagrangian of the interaction between the gravitational degrees of freedom -- the two metrics -- is a function of a certain {\it single} scalar argument built from the difference in connections of the two metrics. I show that the scope of BIMOND is much richer: The two metrics can couple through several scalars to give theories that all have a "good" nonrelativistic (NR) limit -- one that accounts correctly, a-la MOND, for the dynamics of galactic systems, {\it including gravitational lensing}. This extended-BIMOND framework exhibits a qualitative departure from the way we think of MOND at present, as encapsulated, in all its aspects, by one "interpolating function" of one acceleration variable. After deriving the general field equations, I pinpoint the subclass of theories that satisfy the pivotal requirement of a good NR limit. These involve three independent, quadratic scalar variables. In the NR limit these scalars all reduce to the same acceleration scalar, and the NR theory then does hinge on one function of a {\it a single} acceleration variable -- representing the NR MOND "interpolating function", whose form is largely dictated by the observed NR galactic dynamics. However, these scalars behave differently, in different relativistic contexts. So, the full richness of the multi-variable Lagrangian, as it enters cosmology, for example, is hardly informed by what we learn from observations of galactic dynamics. In this paper, I present the formalism, with some generic examples. I also consider some cosmological solutions where the two metrics are small departures from one Friedman-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker metric. This may offer a framework for describing cosmology within the extended BIMOND.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2022; v1 submitted 23 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Models of modified-inertia formulation of MOND
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
Models of "modified-inertia" formulation of MOND are described and applied to nonrelativistic many-body systems. They involve time-nonlocal equations of motion. Momentum, angular momentum, and energy are (nonlocally) defined, whose total values are conserved for isolated systems. The models make all the salient MOND predictions. Yet, they differ from existing "modified-gravity" formulations in som…
▽ More
Models of "modified-inertia" formulation of MOND are described and applied to nonrelativistic many-body systems. They involve time-nonlocal equations of motion. Momentum, angular momentum, and energy are (nonlocally) defined, whose total values are conserved for isolated systems. The models make all the salient MOND predictions. Yet, they differ from existing "modified-gravity" formulations in some second-tier predictions. The models describe correctly the motion of a composite body in a low-acceleration field even when the internal accelerations of its constituents are high. They exhibit a MOND external field effect (EFE) that shows some important differences from what we have come to expect from modified-gravity versions: In one, simple example of the models, what determines the EFE, in the case of a dominant external field, is $μ(θ\langle a_{ex}\rangle/a_0)$, where $μ(x)$ is the MOND `interpolating function' that describes rotation curves, compared with $μ(a_{ex}/a_0)$ for presently-known modified-gravity formulations. The two main differences are that while $a_{ex}$ is the momentary value of the external acceleration, $\langle a_{ex}\rangle$ is a certain time average of it, and that $θ>1$ is an extra factor that depends on the frequency ratio of the external- and internal-field variations. Only ratios of frequencies enter, and $a_0$ remains the only new dimensioned constant. For a system on a circular orbit in a galaxy (such as the vertical dynamics in a disc galaxy), the first difference disappears, since $\langle a_{ex}\rangle=a_{ex}$. But the $θ$ factor can appreciably enhance the EFE in quenching MOND effects, over what is deduced in modified gravity. Some exact solutions are also described, such as for rotation curves, for an harmonic force, and the general, two-body problem, which in the deep-MOND regime reduces to a single-body problem.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2022; v1 submitted 15 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Fast-rotating galaxies do not depart from the MOND mass-asymptotic-speed relation
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
Ogle et al. have fallaciously argued recently that fast-rotating disc galaxies break with the predictions of MOND: the 6 fastest rotators of the 23 galaxies in their sample appear to have higher rotational speeds than is consistent with the MOND relation between the baryonic mass of a galaxy, $M$, and its `rotational speed', $V$. They interpret this departure as a break in the observed $M-V$ relat…
▽ More
Ogle et al. have fallaciously argued recently that fast-rotating disc galaxies break with the predictions of MOND: the 6 fastest rotators of the 23 galaxies in their sample appear to have higher rotational speeds than is consistent with the MOND relation between the baryonic mass of a galaxy, $M$, and its `rotational speed', $V$. They interpret this departure as a break in the observed $M-V$ relation from a logarithmic slope near the MOND-predicted $4$, to a shallow slope of $\approx 0$. However, Ogle et al. use the MAXIMAL rotational speed of the galaxies, $V_{max}$, not the ASYMPTOTIC one, $V_\infty$, which appears in the MOND prediction, $V_\infty^4=MGa_0$. Plotting their $M$ vs. $V_{max}$ pairs on an $M$ vs. $V_\infty$ plot from Lelli et al. (2016), they arrive erroneously at the above tension with MOND. The $H_α$ rotation curves used by Ogle et al. are far too short reaching to probe the asymptotic regime, and determine $V_\infty$. However, it is well documented for fast rotators with observed, extended, HI rotation curves, that they can have $V_{max}$ considerably larger than the MOND-relevant $V_\infty$ [Noordermeer and Verheijen (NV) (2007) and others]. E.g., the fastest rotator in the NV sample has $V_{max}\approx 490{\rm ~km/s}$, but $V_\infty\approx 250{\rm ~km/s}$. NV also show that in a (MOND-irrelevant) $M-V_{max}$ plot the high-speed galaxies fall off the power-law line defined by the lower-speed ones, creating a break in the $M$ vs. $V$ relation, in just the way claimed by Ogle et al. But, when plotting the MOND-relevant $M$ vs. $V_\infty$ all galaxies fall near the same power-law relation, without a break.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
The $a_0$ -- cosmology connection in MOND
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
I limelight and review a potentially crucial aspect of MOND: The near equality of the MOND acceleration constant, $a_0$ -- as deduced from local, galactic phenomena -- and cosmological parameters. To wit, $a_0\sim c H_0\sim c^2Λ^{1/2}\sim c^2/\ell_U$, where $H_0$ is the present value of the Hubble-Lemaître constant, $Λ$ is the `cosmological constant', and $\ell_U$ is a cosmological characteristic…
▽ More
I limelight and review a potentially crucial aspect of MOND: The near equality of the MOND acceleration constant, $a_0$ -- as deduced from local, galactic phenomena -- and cosmological parameters. To wit, $a_0\sim c H_0\sim c^2Λ^{1/2}\sim c^2/\ell_U$, where $H_0$ is the present value of the Hubble-Lemaître constant, $Λ$ is the `cosmological constant', and $\ell_U$ is a cosmological characteristic length; e.g., the Hubble distance, or the de Sitter radius associated with $Λ$. In itself, this near equality has some important phenomenological consequences, such as the impossibility of black holes, and of cosmological strong lensing, in the MOND regime. More importantly perhaps, this `coincidence' may be a pointer to the `FUNDAMOND' -- the more basic theory underlying MOND phenomenology. The manners in which such a relation emerges in existing, underlying scheme of MOND are also reviewed, interlaced with examples of similar relations in other physical systems, between apparently-fundamental velocity, length, and acceleration constants. Such analogies may point the way to explanation of the MOND `coincidence'.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
MOND vs. dark matter in light of historical parallels
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
MOND is a paradigm that contends to account for the mass discrepancies in the Universe without invoking `dark' components, such as `dark matter' and `dark energy'. It does so by supplanting Newtonian dynamics and General Relativity, departing from them at very low accelerations. Having in mind readers who are historians and philosophers of science, as well as physicists and astronomers, I describe…
▽ More
MOND is a paradigm that contends to account for the mass discrepancies in the Universe without invoking `dark' components, such as `dark matter' and `dark energy'. It does so by supplanting Newtonian dynamics and General Relativity, departing from them at very low accelerations. Having in mind readers who are historians and philosophers of science, as well as physicists and astronomers, I describe in this review the main aspects of MOND -- its statement, its basic tenets, its main predictions, and the tests of these predictions -- contrasting it with the dark-matter paradigm. I then discuss possible wider ramifications of MOND, for example the potential significance of the MOND constant, $a_0$, with possible implications for the roots of MOND in cosmology. Along the way I point to parallels with several historical instances of nascent paradigms. In particular, with the emergence of the Copernican world picture, that of quantum physics, and that of relativity, as regards their initial advent, their development, their schematic structure, and their ramifications. For example, the interplay between theories and their corollary laws, and the centrality of a new constant with converging values as deduced from seemingly unrelated manifestations of these laws. I demonstrate how MOND has already unearthed a number of unsuspected laws of galactic dynamics (to which, indeed, $a_0$ is central) predicting them a priori, and leading to their subsequent verification. I parallel the struggle of the new with the old paradigms, and the appearance of hybrid paradigms at such times of struggle. I also try to identify in the history of those established paradigms a stage that can be likened to that of MOND today.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2020; v1 submitted 10 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Noncovariance at low accelerations as a route to MOND
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
MOND has limelighted the fact that Newtonian dynamics (ND) and general relativity (GR) have not been verified at accelerations below MOND's $a_0$. In particular, we do not know that all the principles underlying ND or GR apply below $a_0$. I discuss possible breakdown of general covariance (GC) in this limit. This resonates well with MOND, which hinges on accelerations. Relaxing GC affords more fr…
▽ More
MOND has limelighted the fact that Newtonian dynamics (ND) and general relativity (GR) have not been verified at accelerations below MOND's $a_0$. In particular, we do not know that all the principles underlying ND or GR apply below $a_0$. I discuss possible breakdown of general covariance (GC) in this limit. This resonates well with MOND, which hinges on accelerations. Relaxing GC affords more freedom in constructing MOND theories. I exemplify this with a simplified theory whose gravitational Lagrangian is $\mathcal{L}_M\propto \ell_M^{-2}\mathcal{F}(\ell_M^{2}\mathcal{R})$, where $\mathcal{R}= g^{μν} (Γ^γ_{μν}Γ^λ_{λγ}-Γ^γ_{μλ} Γ^λ_{νγ})/2$. $Γ^γ_{μν}$ is the Levi-Civita connection of a metric, $g_{μν}$, and $\ell_M=c^2/a_0$ is the MOND length. Requiring $\mathcal{F}(z)\rightarrow z+ζ$, for $z\gg 1$ gives GR with a cosmological constant $ζc^{-4}a_0^2$ for high accelerations. In the MOND limit $\mathcal{F}'(z\ll 1)\propto z^{1/2}$. In the nonrelativistic limit the metric is of the form $g_{μν}\approx η_{μν}-2φδ_{μν}$, as in GR, but the potential $φ$ solves a MOND, nonlinear Poisson analog. This form of $g_{μν}$ also produces gravitational lensing as in GR only with the MOND potential. I show that this theory is a fixed-gauge expression of BIMOND, with the auxiliary metric constrained to be flat. The latter theory is thus a covariantized version of the former a-la Stückelberg. This theory is also a special case of so-called $f(\mathcal{Q})$ theories -- aquadratic generalizations of `symmetric, teleparallel GR', which are, in turn, also equivalent to constrained BIMOND-type theories. (Abridged.)
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2019; v1 submitted 5 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
MOND in galaxy groups: a superior sample
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
Intermediate-richness galaxy groups are an important test ground for MOND. First, they constitute a distinct type of galactic systems, with their own evolution histories and underlying physical processes; secondly, they probe little-chartered regions of parameter space, as they have baryonic masses similar to massive galaxies, and similar velocity dispersions, but much larger sizes -- similar to c…
▽ More
Intermediate-richness galaxy groups are an important test ground for MOND. First, they constitute a distinct type of galactic systems, with their own evolution histories and underlying physical processes; secondly, they probe little-chartered regions of parameter space, as they have baryonic masses similar to massive galaxies, and similar velocity dispersions, but much larger sizes -- similar to cluster cores (or even to clusters), but much lower dispersions. Importantly in the context of MOND, they have the lowest internal accelerations reachable inside galactic systems. I analyze a sample of 56 medium-richness groups having a large number ($\ge 15$) of members with measured velocities. The groups obey the deep-MOND, baryonic-mass-velocity-dispersion relation, $M_MGa_0=(81/4)σ^4$, with individual, MOND $M_M/L_K$ ratios of order $1$ solar unit, with $(M_M/L_K)_{median}=0.7$ s.u. compared with the much larger Newtonian $M_d/L_K$ -- several tens s.u., and $(M_d/L_K)_{median}=37$ s.u. The same MOND relation describes dwarf spheroidals -- 2-3 orders smaller in size, and 7-8 orders lower in mass. The groups conformation to the MOND relation is equivalent to their lying on the deep-MOND branch of the `acceleration-discrepancy relation', $g\approx (g_N a_0)^{1/2}$, for $g$ as low as a few percents of $a_0$ ($g_N$ is the baryonic, Newtonian, gravitational acceleration, and $g$ the actual one). This argues against a breakdown of MOND at extremely low accelerations. This conformation also argues against the hypothesis that the remaining MOND conundrum in cluster cores bespeaks a breakdown of MOND on large-distance scales; our groups are as large as cluster cores, but do not show obvious disagreement with MOND. I also discuss the possible presence of the idiosyncratic, MOND external-field effect.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2019; v1 submitted 29 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
MOND in galaxy groups
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
Galaxy groups, which have hardly been looked at in MOND, afford probing the acceleration discrepancies in regions of system-parameter space that are not accessible in well-studied galactic systems, such as galaxies, galaxy clusters, and dwarf-spheroidal satellites of galaxies. Groups are typically the size of galaxy-cluster cores, but have masses typically only a few times that of a single galaxy.…
▽ More
Galaxy groups, which have hardly been looked at in MOND, afford probing the acceleration discrepancies in regions of system-parameter space that are not accessible in well-studied galactic systems, such as galaxies, galaxy clusters, and dwarf-spheroidal satellites of galaxies. Groups are typically the size of galaxy-cluster cores, but have masses typically only a few times that of a single galaxy. Accelerations in groups get far below those in galaxies, and far below the MOND acceleration. So much so, that many groups might be affected by the external-field effect, which is unique to MOND, due to background accelerations. Here, I analyze the MOND dynamics of 53 galaxy groups, recently catalogued in 3 lists. Their Newtonian, K-band, dynamical $M/L$ ratios are a few tens to several hundreds solar units, with $\langle{M_d/L_K}\rangle= (56, 25, 30)~M_{\odot}/L_{\odot}$, respectively for the 3 lists; thus evincing very large acceleration discrepancies. I find here that MOND requires dynamical $M_M/L_K$ values of order $1~M_{\odot}/L_{\odot}$, with $\langle{M_M/L_K}\rangle=(0.8, 0.56, 1.0) ~M_{\odot}/L_{\odot}$, for the 3 lists, which are in good agreement with population-synthesis stellar values, and with those found in individual galaxies. MOND thus accounts for the observed dynamics in those groups with baryons alone, and no need for dark matter -- an important extension of MOND analysis from galaxies to galactic systems, which, to boot, have characteristic sizes of several hundred kiloparsecs, and accelerations much lower than probed before -- only a few percent of MOND's $a_0$. The acceleration discrepancies evinced by these groups thus conform to the deep-MOND prediction: $g\approx (g_Na_0)^{1/2}$, down to these very low accelerations ($g$ is the measured, and $g_N$ the baryonic, Newtonian acceleration).
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2018; v1 submitted 7 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
MOND from a brane-world picture
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
I describe a heuristic model where MOND dynamics emerge in a universe viewed as a nearly spherical brane embedded in a higher-dimensional flat space. The brane, described by $ξ(Ω)$, is of density $σ$ ($ξ$ and $Ω$ are the radial and angular coordinates in the embedding space). The brane and matter -- confined to the brane and of density $ρ(Ω)\llσ$ -- are coupled to a potential $\varepsilon(ξ)$. I r…
▽ More
I describe a heuristic model where MOND dynamics emerge in a universe viewed as a nearly spherical brane embedded in a higher-dimensional flat space. The brane, described by $ξ(Ω)$, is of density $σ$ ($ξ$ and $Ω$ are the radial and angular coordinates in the embedding space). The brane and matter -- confined to the brane and of density $ρ(Ω)\llσ$ -- are coupled to a potential $\varepsilon(ξ)$. I restrict myself to shallow perturbations, $ξ(Ω)=\ell_0+ζ(Ω)$, $|ζ|\ll\ell_0$. A balanced brane implies $\hat a_0\equiv\varepsilon'(\ell_0)\sim T/σ\ell_0$, $T$ is the brane tension, yielding for the velocity of small brane perturbations $c^2\sim T/σ\sim \ell_0\hat a_0$. But, $\hat a_0$ plays the role of the MOND acceleration constant in local gravitational dynamics; so $\hat a_0\sim c^2/\ell_0$. What we, in the brane, perceive as the gravitational potential is $φ\equiv\varepsilon[ξ(Ω)]\approx φ_0+\hat a_0ζ$. Aspects of MOND that may emerge naturally as geometrical properties are: a. The special role of acceleration in MOND, and why it is an acceleration, $a_0$, that marks the transition from the standard dynamics much above $a_0$ to scale-invariant dynamics much below $a_0$. b. The intriguing connection of $a_0$ with cosmology. c. The Newtonian limit corresponds to local departure $|ζ|\ll\ell_0$; i.e., $φ-φ_0\sim a_0ζ\ll a_0\ell_0\sim c^2$ - whereas relativity enters when $|ζ|\not\ll\ell_0$. The model also opens new vistas for extension, e.g., it points to possible dependence of $a_0$ on $φ$, and to $a_0$ losing its status and meaning altogether in the relativistic regime. The required global balance of the brane might solve the `old' cosmological-constant problem. I discuss possible connections with the nearly-de-Sitter nature of our Universe. (Abridged.)
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2019; v1 submitted 16 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
MOND and the dynamics of NGC1052-DF2
Authors:
B. Famaey,
S. McGaugh,
M. Milgrom
Abstract:
The dwarf galaxy NGC1052-DF2 has recently been identified as potentially lacking dark matter. If correct, this could be a challenge for MOND, which predicts that low surface brightness galaxies should evince large mass discrepancies. However, the correct prediction of MOND depends on both the internal field of the dwarf and the external field caused by its proximity to the giant elliptical NGC1052…
▽ More
The dwarf galaxy NGC1052-DF2 has recently been identified as potentially lacking dark matter. If correct, this could be a challenge for MOND, which predicts that low surface brightness galaxies should evince large mass discrepancies. However, the correct prediction of MOND depends on both the internal field of the dwarf and the external field caused by its proximity to the giant elliptical NGC1052. Taking both into consideration under plausible assumptions, we find $σ_{\rm MOND} = 13.4^{+4.8}_{-3.7}\;\mathrm{km}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}$. This is only marginally higher than the claimed 90\% upper limit on the velocity dispersion ($σ< 10.5\;\mathrm{km}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}$), and compares well with the observed root mean square velocity dispersion ($σ= 14.3\;\mathrm{km}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}$). We also discuss a few caveats on both the observational and theoretical side. On the theory side, the internal virialization time in this dwarf may be longer that the time scale of variation of the external field. On the observational side, the paucity of data and their large uncertainties call for further analysis of the velocity dispersion of NGC1052-DF2, to check whether it poses a challenge to MOND or is a success thereof.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
MOND and the dynamics of NGC 628
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
Aniyan et al. (2018) have recently published direct measurements of the baryonic mass distribution and the rotation curve of the almost-face-on disc galaxy NGC 628. While its very low inclination makes this galaxy anything but ideal for rotation-curve analysis, these new results, taken at face value, have interesting ramifications for MOND. The methods employed afford a direct determination of the…
▽ More
Aniyan et al. (2018) have recently published direct measurements of the baryonic mass distribution and the rotation curve of the almost-face-on disc galaxy NGC 628. While its very low inclination makes this galaxy anything but ideal for rotation-curve analysis, these new results, taken at face value, have interesting ramifications for MOND. The methods employed afford a direct determination of the stellar mass in the disc, which, in turn, affords a parameter-free MOND prediction of the rotation curve, which I show. In comparison, the dark-matter fits that Aniyan et al. present have two free parameters. To boot, these results further negate an earlier claim deleterious to MOND. It is that stellar $M/L$ ratios deduced from vertical velocity dispersions in disc galaxies are rather lower than what is required by MOND fits to rotation curves. Specifically, it was claimed that even high-surface-density discs are, by and large, sub maximal; viz., that they show substantial mass discrepancies near their center. This is contrary to the prediction of MOND that in such high-acceleration regions only small discrepancies should appear, if any to speak of. Such claims of low $M/L$ values have been rebutted before, and the fallacy that may have led to them pointed out. The new results strongly buttress these rebuttals.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Perspective on MOND emergence from Verlinde's "emergent gravity" and its recent test by weak lensing
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom,
Robert H. Sanders
Abstract:
We highlight phenomenological aspects of Verlinde's recent proposal to account for the mass anomalies in galactic systems without dark matter -- in particular in their relation to MOND. Welcome addition to the MOND lore as it is, this approach have reproduced, so far, only a small fraction of MOND phenomenology, and is still rather tentative, both in its theoretical foundations and in its phenomen…
▽ More
We highlight phenomenological aspects of Verlinde's recent proposal to account for the mass anomalies in galactic systems without dark matter -- in particular in their relation to MOND. Welcome addition to the MOND lore as it is, this approach have reproduced, so far, only a small fraction of MOND phenomenology, and is still rather tentative, both in its theoretical foundations and in its phenomenology. What Verlinde has extracted from this approach, so far, is a formula -- of rather limited applicability, and with no road to generalization in sight -- for the effective gravitational field of a spherical, isolated, static baryonic system. This formula cannot be used to calculate the gravitational field of disk galaxies, with their rich MOND phenomenology. Notably, it cannot predict their rotation curves, except asymptotically. It does not apply to the few-, or many-body problem; so, it cannot give, e.g., the two-body force between two galaxies, or be used to conduct N-body calculations of galaxy formation, evolution, and interactions. The formula cannot be applied to the internal dynamics of a system embedded in an external field, where MOND predicts important consequences. etc. MOND is backed by full-fledged, Lagrangian theories that can be, and are, routinely applied to all the above phenomena, and more. Verlinde's formula, as it now stands, strongly conflicts with solar-system and possibly earth-surface constraints, and cannot fully account for the mass anomalies in the cores of galaxy clusters (a standing conundrum in MOND). The recent weak-lensing test of the formula is, in fact, testing a cornerstone prediction of MOND, one that the formula does reproduce, and which has been tested before in the very same way.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2017; v1 submitted 30 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
MOND impact on and of the recently updated mass-discrepancy-acceleration relation
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
McGaugh et al. (2016) have used their extensive SPARC sample to update the well-known mass-discrepancy-acceleration relation (MDAR), which is one of the major predicted "MOND laws". This is not a newly discovered relation. Rather, it improves on the many previous studies of it, with more and better data. Like its precedents, it bears crucial ramifications for the observed dynamical anomalies in di…
▽ More
McGaugh et al. (2016) have used their extensive SPARC sample to update the well-known mass-discrepancy-acceleration relation (MDAR), which is one of the major predicted "MOND laws". This is not a newly discovered relation. Rather, it improves on the many previous studies of it, with more and better data. Like its precedents, it bears crucial ramifications for the observed dynamical anomalies in disc galaxies, and, in particular, on their resolution by the MOND paradigm. Their result, indeed, constitute a triumph for MOND. However, unlike previous analyses of the MDAR, McGaugh et al. have chosen to obfuscate the MOND roots of their analysis, and its connection with, and implications for, this paradigm. For example, the fitting formula they use, seemingly as a result of some unexplained inspiration, follows in its salient properties from the basic tenets of MOND, and has already been used in the past in several MOND analyses. No other possible origin for such a function is known. Given that this formula had already been shown to reproduce correctly the observed rotation curves from the baryon distribution (as a MOND effect), it must have been clear, a priory, that it should describe correctly the MDAR, which is but a summary of rotation curves. The present paper corrects these oversights -- bringing to light the deep connections with MOND, suppressed by McGaugh et al. It also gives due credit to previous works, and discusses some new, important, but less known, aspects of this MOND relation. (Substantially abridged.)
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2016; v1 submitted 21 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Universal MOND relation between the baryonic and `dynamical' central surface densities of disc galaxies
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
I derive a new MOND relation for pure-disc galaxies: The `dynamical' central surface density, $Σ^0_D$, deduced from the measured velocities, is a universal function of only the true, `baryonic' central surface density, $Σ^0_B$: $Σ^0_D=Σ_M \mathcal{S}(Σ^0_B/Σ_M)$, where $Σ_M\equiv a_0/2πG$ is the MOND surface density constant. This surprising result is shown to hold in both existing, nonrelativisti…
▽ More
I derive a new MOND relation for pure-disc galaxies: The `dynamical' central surface density, $Σ^0_D$, deduced from the measured velocities, is a universal function of only the true, `baryonic' central surface density, $Σ^0_B$: $Σ^0_D=Σ_M \mathcal{S}(Σ^0_B/Σ_M)$, where $Σ_M\equiv a_0/2πG$ is the MOND surface density constant. This surprising result is shown to hold in both existing, nonrelativistic MOND theories. $\mathcal{S}(y)$ is derived: $\mathcal{S}(y)=\int_0^yν(y')dy'$, with $ν(y)$ the interpolating function of the theory. The relation aymptotes to $Σ^0_D=Σ^0_B$ for $Σ^0_B\ggΣ_M$, and to $Σ^0_D=(4Σ_MΣ^0_B)^{1/2}$ for $Σ^0_B\llΣ_M$. This study was prompted by the recent finding of a correlation between related attributes of disc galaxies by Lelli et al. (2016). The MOND central-surface-densities relation agrees very well with these results.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2016; v1 submitted 18 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Scale Invariance at low accelerations (aka MOND) and the dynamical anomalies in the Universe
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
Galactic systems, and the Universe at large, exhibit large dynamical anomalies: The observed matter in them falls very short of providing enough gravity to account for their dynamics. The mainstream response to this conundrum is to invoke large quantities of `dark matter' -- which purportedly supplies the needed extra gravity -- and also of `dark energy', to account for further anomalies in cosmol…
▽ More
Galactic systems, and the Universe at large, exhibit large dynamical anomalies: The observed matter in them falls very short of providing enough gravity to account for their dynamics. The mainstream response to this conundrum is to invoke large quantities of `dark matter' -- which purportedly supplies the needed extra gravity -- and also of `dark energy', to account for further anomalies in cosmology, such as the observed, accelerated expansion. The MOND paradigm offers a different solution: a breakdown of standard dynamics (gravity and/or inertia) in the limit of low accelerations -- below some acceleration $a_0$. In this limit, dynamics become space-time scale invariant, and is controlled by a gravitational constant $\mathcal{A}_0\equiv Ga_0$, which replaces Newton's $G$. With the new dynamics, the various detailed manifestations of the anomalies in galaxies are predicted with no need for dark matter. The cosmological anomalies could, but need not have to do with small accelerations. For example, the need for dark matter in accounting for the expansion history of the Universe is eliminated if the relevant gravitational constant is $\approx 2πG$. Such a `renormalization' of $G$ could be a dimensionless parameter of a MOND theory. The constant $a_0$ turns out to carry cosmological connotations, in that $2πa_0\approx cH_0\approx c^2(Λ/3)^{1/2}$, where $H_0$ is the present expansion rate of the Universe, and $Λ$ the measured `cosmological constant'. There are MOND theories in which this `coincidence' is natural. I draw on enlightening historical and conceptual analogies from quantum theory to limelight aspects of MOND. I also explain how MOND may have strong connections with effects of the quantum vacuum on local dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2016; v1 submitted 24 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Critical take on "Mass models of disk galaxies from the DiskMass Survey in MOND"
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
Angus et al. (2015) have recently faulted MOND as follows: Studying thirty disc galaxies from the DiskMass survey, they derive the profiles of velocity dispersion perpendicular to the discs as predicted by MOND, $σ_M(r)$, and compare them with $σ(r)$, measured as part of the DiskMass project. This is a new test of MOND, different from rotation-curve analysis. A nontrivial accomplishment of MOND --…
▽ More
Angus et al. (2015) have recently faulted MOND as follows: Studying thirty disc galaxies from the DiskMass survey, they derive the profiles of velocity dispersion perpendicular to the discs as predicted by MOND, $σ_M(r)$, and compare them with $σ(r)$, measured as part of the DiskMass project. This is a new test of MOND, different from rotation-curve analysis. A nontrivial accomplishment of MOND -- not discussed by Angus et al. -- is that the shapes of $σ_M$ and $σ$ agree very well, i.e, $η(r)\equivσ_M(r)/σ(r)$ is well consistent with being $r$-independent (while $σ$ and $σ_M$ are strongly $r$ dependent). The fault found with MOND was that $η$ is systematically above 1 (with an average of about 1.3). I have suggested to Angus et al. that the fault may lie with the DiskMass dispersions, which may well be too low for the purpose at hand: Being based on population-integrated line profiles, they may be overweighed by younger populations, known to have much smaller dispersions, and scale heights, than the older populations, which weigh more heavily on the light distributions. I discuss independent evidence that supports this view, and show, besides, that if the DiskMas dispersions are underestimates by only 25 %, on average, the MOND predictions are in full agreement with the data, in shape and magnitude. Now, Aniyan et al. (2015) have questioned the DiskMass $σ$ on the same basis. They show for the solar column in the Milky Way that: " Combining the (single) measured velocity dispersion of the total young + old disc population... with the scale height estimated for the older population would underestimate the disc surface density by a factor of $\sim 2.$" If this mismatch found for the Milky Way is typical, correcting for it would bring the measured DiskMass $σ(r)$ to a remarkable agreement with the predicted MOND $σ_M(r)$.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2016; v1 submitted 25 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Ultra-diffuse cluster galaxies as key to the MOND cluster conundrum
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
MOND reduces greatly the mass discrepancy in clusters of galaxies, but does leave a consistent global discrepancy of about a factor of two. It has been proposed, within the minimalist and purist MOND, that clusters harbor some indigenous, yet-undetected, cluster baryonic (dark) matter (CBDM). Its total amount has to be comparable with that of the observed hot gas. Following an initial discovery by…
▽ More
MOND reduces greatly the mass discrepancy in clusters of galaxies, but does leave a consistent global discrepancy of about a factor of two. It has been proposed, within the minimalist and purist MOND, that clusters harbor some indigenous, yet-undetected, cluster baryonic (dark) matter (CBDM). Its total amount has to be comparable with that of the observed hot gas. Following an initial discovery by van Dokkum & al. (2015a), Koda & al. (2015) have recently identified more than a thousand ultra-diffuse galaxy-like objects (UDGs) in the Coma cluster. Robustness of the UDGs to tidal disruption seems to require, within Newtonian dynamics, that they are much more massive than their observed stellar component. Here, I propound that a considerable fraction of the CBDM is internal to UDGs, which endows them with robustness. The rest of the CBDM objects formed in now-disrupted kin of the UDGs, and is dispersed in the intracluster medium. While the discovery of cluster UDGs is not in itself a resolution of the MOND cluster conundrum, it lends greater qualitative plausibility to CBDM as its resolution, for reasons I discuss. Alternatively, if the UDGs are only now falling into Coma, their large size and very low surface brightness could result from the adiabatic inflation due to the MOND external-field effect, as described in Brada & Milgrom (2000). I also consider briefly solutions to the conundrum that invoke more elaborate extensions of purist MOND, e.g., that in clusters, the MOND constant takes up larger-than-canonical values of the MOND constant.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2015; v1 submitted 17 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
The road to MOND--a novel perspective
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
Accepting that galactic mass discrepancies are due to modified dynamics, I show why it is specifically the MOND paradigm that is pointed to cogently. MOND is thus discussed here as a special case of a larger class of modified dynamics theories whereby galactic systems with large mass discrepancies are described by scale-invariant dynamics. This is a novel presentation that uses more recent, after-…
▽ More
Accepting that galactic mass discrepancies are due to modified dynamics, I show why it is specifically the MOND paradigm that is pointed to cogently. MOND is thus discussed here as a special case of a larger class of modified dynamics theories whereby galactic systems with large mass discrepancies are described by scale-invariant dynamics. This is a novel presentation that uses more recent, after-the-fact insights and data (largely predicted beforehand by MOND). Starting from a purist set of tenets, I follow the path that leads specifically to the MOND basic tenets. The main signposts are: (i) Space-time scale invariance underlies the dynamics of systems with large mass discrepancies. (ii) In these dynamics, $G$ must be replaced by a single "scale-invariant" gravitational constant, Q0 (in MOND, Q0=A0=Ga0, where a0 is MOND's acceleration constant). (iii) Universality of free fall points to the constant q0=Q0/G as the boundary between the G-controlled, standard dynamics, and the Q0-controlled, scale-invariant dynamics (in MOND, q0=a0). (iv) Data clinches the case for q0 being an acceleration (MOND).
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Cosmological variation of the MOND constant: secular effects on galactic systems
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
The proximity of the MOND acceleration constant with cosmological accelerations -- for example, a0 cH0/2pi -- points to its possibly decreasing with cosmic time. I begin to consider the secular changes induced in galactic systems by such presumed variations, assumed adiabatic. It is important to understand these effects, in isolation from other evolutionary influences, in order to identify or con…
▽ More
The proximity of the MOND acceleration constant with cosmological accelerations -- for example, a0 cH0/2pi -- points to its possibly decreasing with cosmic time. I begin to consider the secular changes induced in galactic systems by such presumed variations, assumed adiabatic. It is important to understand these effects, in isolation from other evolutionary influences, in order to identify or constrain a0 variations by detection of induced effects, or lack thereof. I find that as long as the system is fully in the deep-MOND regime -- as applies to many galactic systems -- the adiabatic response of the system obeys simple scaling laws. For example, in a system that would be stationary for fixed a0, the system expands homologously as a0^{-1/4}, while internal velocities decrease uniformly as a0^{1/4}. If a0 is proportional to cH at all relevant times, this change amounts to a factor of ~ 2.5 since redshift 10. For a system stationary in a rotating frame, the angular frequency decreases as a0^{1/2}. The accelerations increase relative to a0 as a0^{-1/4}, pushing the system towards the Newtonian regime. All this follows from the appearance of a0 in MOND and the scale invariance of the deep-MOND limit -- two basic tenets of MOND. More complicated evolution ensues when parts of the system become Newtonian, or are so from inception. For example, these parts may become unstable, not being protected by MOND's stabilizing effects. The existence of such regions also modifies the MONDian regime, since they affect the potential everywhere, and since constituents might migrate between the Newtonian and MONDian regimes. Studying these last effects would require detailed numerical calculations.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2015; v1 submitted 14 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
MOND theory
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
A general account of MOND theory is given. I start with the basic tenets of MOND, which posit departure from standard dynamics in the limit of low acceleration -- below an acceleration constant a0 -- where dynamics become scale invariant. I list some of the salient predictions of these tenets. The special role of a0 and its significance are then discussed. In particular, I stress its coincidence w…
▽ More
A general account of MOND theory is given. I start with the basic tenets of MOND, which posit departure from standard dynamics in the limit of low acceleration -- below an acceleration constant a0 -- where dynamics become scale invariant. I list some of the salient predictions of these tenets. The special role of a0 and its significance are then discussed. In particular, I stress its coincidence with cosmologically relevant accelerations. The deep-MOND limit and the consequences of its scale invariance are considered in some detail.
General aspects of MOND theories are then described, after which I list briefly presently known theories, both nonrelativistic and relativistic. Most full-fledged theories modify the gravitational action, hinge on a0, introduce an interpolating function between the low and high accelerations, and obey MOND requirements in the opposite limits. These theories have much heuristic value as proofs of various concepts (e.g., that covariant MOND theories can be written with correct gravitational lensing). But, probably, they are, at best, effective theories of limited applicability.
I then outline several other promising approaches to constructing MOND theories that strive to obtain MOND as an effective theory from deeper concepts, for example, by modifying inertia and/or gravity as a result of interactions with some omnipresent agent.
Some theories do enjoy a natural appearance of a cosmological-constant-like contribution that, furthermore, exhibits the observed connection with a0. However, none were shown to address fully the mass discrepancies in cosmology and structure formation that are otherwise explained by cosmological dark matter.
We have no clues as to whether and how MOND aspects enter non-gravitational phenomena, but I discuss briefly some possibilities.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2014; v1 submitted 30 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
General virial theorem for modified-gravity MOND
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
An important and useful relation is known to hold in two specific MOND theories. It pertains to low-acceleration, isolated systems of pointlike masses, m_p, at positions r_p, subject to gravitational forces F_p. It reads sum_p r_p.F_p=-(2/3)(Ga0)^{1/2}[(\sum_p m_p)^{3/2}-\sum_p m_p^{3/2}]; a0 is the MOND acceleration constant. Here I show that this relation holds in the nonrelativistic limit of an…
▽ More
An important and useful relation is known to hold in two specific MOND theories. It pertains to low-acceleration, isolated systems of pointlike masses, m_p, at positions r_p, subject to gravitational forces F_p. It reads sum_p r_p.F_p=-(2/3)(Ga0)^{1/2}[(\sum_p m_p)^{3/2}-\sum_p m_p^{3/2}]; a0 is the MOND acceleration constant. Here I show that this relation holds in the nonrelativistic limit of any modified-gravity MOND theory. It follows from only the basic tenets of MOND (as applied to such theories): departure from standard dynamics at accelerations below a0, and space-time scale invariance in the nonrelativistic, low-acceleration limit. This implies space-dilatation invariance of the static, gravitational-field equations, which, in turn, leads to the above point-mass virial relation. Thus, the various MOND predictions and tests based on this relation hold in any modified-gravity MOND theory. Since we do not know that any of the existing MOND theories point in the right direction, it is important to identify such predictions that hold in a much larger class of theories. Among these predictions are the MOND two-body force for arbitrary masses, and a general mass-velocity-dispersion relation of the form sigma^2=(2/3)(MGa0)^{1/2}[1-\sum_p (m_p/M)^{3/2}], where M is the total mass.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2014; v1 submitted 11 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
MOND and its bimetric formulation
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
I first give a succinct account of the MOND paradigm--emphasizing the centrality of scale invariance in the nonrelativistic, deep-MOND limit--and describing rudiments of its phenomenology. I then present my credo, and some generalities, concerning existing MOND theories. Then I concentrate on one relativistic formulation of MOND in the form of a bimetric theory (BIMOND). I describe its various lim…
▽ More
I first give a succinct account of the MOND paradigm--emphasizing the centrality of scale invariance in the nonrelativistic, deep-MOND limit--and describing rudiments of its phenomenology. I then present my credo, and some generalities, concerning existing MOND theories. Then I concentrate on one relativistic formulation of MOND in the form of a bimetric theory (BIMOND). I describe its various limits: the weak field, with application to gravitational waves, the nonrelativistic limit, and their further deep-MOND (low acceleration) limits, which are scale invariant. Other aspects of BIMOND that have been explored are aspects of cosmology, matter fluctuations in cosmology, and matter-twin-matter interactions. BIMOND remains largely unexplored, despite its promise in several regards: It tends to GR for a0 goes to 0 (a0 is the MOND constant); it has a simple nonrelativistic limit; it describes gravitational lensing correctly; and, it has a generic appearance of a cosmological-constant term that is of order a0^2/c^4, as observed.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Gravitational waves in bimetric MOND
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
I consider the weak field limit (WFL) of bimetric MOND (BIMOND): the lowest order in the small departures Hmn and H'mn from double Minkowski space-time. In particular, I look at propagating solutions, for a favorite subclass of BIMOND. The WFL splits into two sectors for two linear combinations, Hmn+ and Hmn-, of Hmn and H'mn. The Hmn+ sector is equivalent to the WFL of general relativity (GR), wi…
▽ More
I consider the weak field limit (WFL) of bimetric MOND (BIMOND): the lowest order in the small departures Hmn and H'mn from double Minkowski space-time. In particular, I look at propagating solutions, for a favorite subclass of BIMOND. The WFL splits into two sectors for two linear combinations, Hmn+ and Hmn-, of Hmn and H'mn. The Hmn+ sector is equivalent to the WFL of general relativity (GR), with its gauge freedom, and has the same vacuum gravitational waves. The Hmn- sector is fully nonlinear even for the weakest Hmn-, and inherits none of the coordinate gauge freedom. The equations of motion are scale invariant in the deep-MOND limit of purely gravitational systems. In these last two regards, the BIMOND WFL is greatly different from that of other bimetric theories studied to date. Despite the strong nonlinearity, an arbitrary pair of harmonic GR wave packets of Hmn and H'mn moving in the same direction, is a solution of the (vacuum) BIMOND WFL.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2014; v1 submitted 25 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Testing the MOND Paradigm of Modified Dynamics with Galaxy-Galaxy Gravitational Lensing
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
MOND predicts that the asymptotic gravitational potential of an isolated, bounded (baryonic) mass, M, is phi(r)=(MGa0)^{1/2}ln(r); a0 is the MOND constant. Relativistic MOND theories predict that the lensing effects of M are dictated by phi(r) as general-relativity lensing is dictated by the Newtonian potential. Thus, MOND predicts that the asymptotic Newtonian potential deduced from galaxy-galaxy…
▽ More
MOND predicts that the asymptotic gravitational potential of an isolated, bounded (baryonic) mass, M, is phi(r)=(MGa0)^{1/2}ln(r); a0 is the MOND constant. Relativistic MOND theories predict that the lensing effects of M are dictated by phi(r) as general-relativity lensing is dictated by the Newtonian potential. Thus, MOND predicts that the asymptotic Newtonian potential deduced from galaxy-galaxy gravitational lensing will have: (1) a logarithmic r dependence, and (2) a normalization (parametrized standardly as 2s^2) that depends only on M: s=(MGa0/4)^{1/4}. I compare these predictions with recent results of galaxy-galaxy lensing, and find agreement on all counts. For the "blue"-lenses subsample ("spiral" galaxies) MOND reproduces the observations well with an r'-band M/L of 1-3 solar units, and for "red" lenses ("elliptical" galaxies) with M/L of 3-6 solar units, both consistent with baryons only. In contradistinction, Newtonian analysis requires, typically, M/L values of about 130 solar units, bespeaking a mass discrepancy of a factor of about 40. Compared with the staple, rotation-curve tests, MOND is here tested in a wider population of galaxies, through a different phenomenon, using relativistic test objects, and is probed to several-times-lower accelerations--as low as a few percent of a0.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2013; v1 submitted 15 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
The failures of the standard model of cosmology require a new paradigm
Authors:
Pavel Kroupa,
Marcel Pawlowski,
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
Cosmological models that invoke warm or cold dark matter can not explain observed regularities in the properties of dwarf galaxies, their highly anisotropic spatial distributions, nor the correlation between observed mass discrepancies and acceleration. These problems with the standard model of cosmology have deep implications, in particular in combination with the observation that the data are ex…
▽ More
Cosmological models that invoke warm or cold dark matter can not explain observed regularities in the properties of dwarf galaxies, their highly anisotropic spatial distributions, nor the correlation between observed mass discrepancies and acceleration. These problems with the standard model of cosmology have deep implications, in particular in combination with the observation that the data are excellently described by Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND). MOND is a classical dynamics theory which explains the mass discrepancies in galactic systems, and in the universe at large, without invoking dark entities. MOND introduces a new universal constant of nature with the dimensions of acceleration, a0, such that the pre-MONDian dynamics is valid for accelerations a >> a0, and the deep MONDian regime is obtained for a << a0, where space-time scale invariance is invoked. Remaining challenges for MOND are (i) explaining fully the observed mass discrepancies in galaxy clusters, and (ii) the development of a relativistic theory of MOND that will satisfactorily account for cosmology. The universal constant a0 turns out to have an intriguing connection with cosmology: \bar a0 == 2 pi a0 \approx c H_0 \approx c^2(Lambda/3)^{1/2}. This may point to a deep connection between cosmology and internal dynamics of local systems.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Andromeda Dwarfs in Light of MOND
Authors:
Stacy McGaugh,
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
We compare the recently published velocity dispersions for seventeen Andromeda dwarf spheroidals with estimates of the MOND predictions, based on the luminosities of these dwarfs, with reasonable stellar M/L values, and no dark matter. We find that the two are consistent within the uncertainties. We further predict the velocity dispersions of another ten dwarfs for which only photometric data are…
▽ More
We compare the recently published velocity dispersions for seventeen Andromeda dwarf spheroidals with estimates of the MOND predictions, based on the luminosities of these dwarfs, with reasonable stellar M/L values, and no dark matter. We find that the two are consistent within the uncertainties. We further predict the velocity dispersions of another ten dwarfs for which only photometric data are currently available.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2013; v1 submitted 4 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
MOND laws of galactic dynamics
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
MOND predicts a number of laws that galactic systems should obey irrespective of their complicated, haphazard, and mostly unknowable histories -- as Kepler's laws are obeyed by planetary systems. The main purpose of this work is to show how, and to what extent, these MOND laws follow from only the paradigm's basic tenets: departure from standard dynamics at accelerations a<~a0, and space-time scal…
▽ More
MOND predicts a number of laws that galactic systems should obey irrespective of their complicated, haphazard, and mostly unknowable histories -- as Kepler's laws are obeyed by planetary systems. The main purpose of this work is to show how, and to what extent, these MOND laws follow from only the paradigm's basic tenets: departure from standard dynamics at accelerations a<~a0, and space-time scale invariance in the limit a<<a0. Such predictions will be shared by all MOND theories that embody these premises. This is important because we do not know which of the existing MOND theories, if any, is a step in the right direction. In the Newtonian-dynamics-plus-dark-matter paradigm, the validity of such clear-cut laws -- which tightly constrain baryons, `dark matter', and their mutual relations -- is contrary to expectations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2013; v1 submitted 11 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Global Deep-MOND Parameter as a Theory Discriminant
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
Different formulations of MOND predict somewhat different rotation curves for the same mass distribution. Here I consider a global attribute of the rotation curve that might provide a convenient discriminant between theories when applied to isolated, pure-disk galaxies that are everywhere deep in the MOND regime. This parameter is Q=<V^2>/V0^2, where <V^2> is the mean squared rotational speed of t…
▽ More
Different formulations of MOND predict somewhat different rotation curves for the same mass distribution. Here I consider a global attribute of the rotation curve that might provide a convenient discriminant between theories when applied to isolated, pure-disk galaxies that are everywhere deep in the MOND regime. This parameter is Q=<V^2>/V0^2, where <V^2> is the mean squared rotational speed of the galaxy, and V0 is the asymptotic (constant) rotational speed. The comparison between the observed and predicted values of Q is oblivious to the distance, the inclination, the mass, and the size of the disk, and to the form of the interpolating function. For the known modified-gravity theories Q is predicted to be a universal constant (independent of the mass distribution in the disk): Q=2/3. The predicted Q value for modified-inertia theories does depend on the mass distribution. However, surprisingly, I find here that it varies only little among a very wide range of mass distributions, Q=0.73+-0.01. While the difference between the theories amounts to only about 5 percent in the predicted RMS velocity, a good enough sample of galaxies may provide the first discerning test between the two classes of theories.
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2012; v1 submitted 20 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Testing MOND Over a Wide Acceleration Range in X-Ray Ellipticals
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
The gravitational fields of two isolated ellipticals, NGC 720 and NGC 1521, have been recently measured to very large galactic radii (~100 and ~200 kpc), assuming hydrostatic balance of the hot gas enshrouding them. They afford, for the first time to my knowledge, testing MOND in ellipticals with force and quality that, arguably, approach those of rotation-curve tests in disk galaxies. In the cont…
▽ More
The gravitational fields of two isolated ellipticals, NGC 720 and NGC 1521, have been recently measured to very large galactic radii (~100 and ~200 kpc), assuming hydrostatic balance of the hot gas enshrouding them. They afford, for the first time to my knowledge, testing MOND in ellipticals with force and quality that, arguably, approach those of rotation-curve tests in disk galaxies. In the context of MOND, it is noteworthy that the measured accelerations span a wide range, from more than 10a0 to about a0/10, unprecedented in individual ellipticals. I find that MOND predicts correctly the measured dynamical mass runs (apart from a possible minor tension in the inner few kpc of NGC 720, which might be due to departure from hydrostatic equilibrium): The predicted mass discrepancy increases outward from none, near the center, to ~10 at the outermost radii. The implications for the MOND-vs-dark-matter controversy go far beyond the simple fact of two more galaxies conforming to MOND.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2012; v1 submitted 7 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
MOND--particularly as modified inertia
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
After a succinct review of the MOND paradigm--with its phenomenology, and its various underlying theories--I concentrate on so called modified inertia (MI) formulations of MOND, which have so far received only little attention. These share with all MOND theories the salient MOND predictions, such as asymptotically flat rotation curves, and the universal mass-asymptotic-speed relation. My emphasis…
▽ More
After a succinct review of the MOND paradigm--with its phenomenology, and its various underlying theories--I concentrate on so called modified inertia (MI) formulations of MOND, which have so far received only little attention. These share with all MOND theories the salient MOND predictions, such as asymptotically flat rotation curves, and the universal mass-asymptotic-speed relation. My emphasis here is, however, on the fact that MI theories can differ substantially from their "modified-gravity" (MG) kin in predicting other phenomena. Because MI theories are non local in time, MOND effects depend on the full trajectory of a system, not only on its instantaneous state, as in MG theories. This may lead to rather different predictions for, e.g., the external-field effect (EFE): A subsystem, such as a globular cluster or a dwarf galaxy, moving in the field of a mother galaxy, or a galaxy in a cluster, may be subject to an EFE that depends on the accelerations all along its orbit, not only on the instantaneous value. And, it is even possible to construct MI theories with practically no EFE. Other predictions that may differ are also discussed. Since we do not yet have a full fledged, modified-inertia formulation, simple, heuristic models have been used to demonstrate these points.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
MOND and the unique void galaxy KK246
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
MOND predictions are compared with the mass discrepancy, Gamma (the dynamical-to-baryon mass ratio) deduced from the recently measured rotation curve, for the gas-rich, dwarf galaxy KK246, "the only galaxy observed in the local void". KK246 is special in at least two regards: a. It is, to my knowledge, the record holder for the largest mass discrepancy deduced from a rotation curve, Gamma= 15. b.…
▽ More
MOND predictions are compared with the mass discrepancy, Gamma (the dynamical-to-baryon mass ratio) deduced from the recently measured rotation curve, for the gas-rich, dwarf galaxy KK246, "the only galaxy observed in the local void". KK246 is special in at least two regards: a. It is, to my knowledge, the record holder for the largest mass discrepancy deduced from a rotation curve, Gamma= 15. b. It is very isolated, residing in a large, very empty void. I also discuss another extreme case: Andromeda IV, a dwarf considered here for the first time in light of MOND, with a very large mass discrepancy, Gamma =12, also conforming accurately to the MOND prediction. In both cases, MOND predicts Gamma, or the total dynamical mass at the last observed radius, from only the knowledge of the small mass of baryons. If MOND is accepted as the root of the mass discrepancy, these are just two more expected, albeit reassuring, conformities. However, in the framework of the dark-matter paradigm--where the mass discrepancy is strongly dependent on the buildup history of a galaxy--every new such conformity with a tight law is another difficult-to-understand surprise, and does carry a new import: What, in the LCDM paradigm, would prevent such galactic baryons from residing in a halo of half, or twice, the observed rotational velocities, instead of selecting exactly the velocities predicted by MOND? This conundrum is especially poignant for KK246, whose great isolation points to a relatively unique buildup history. This note underscores the individual importance of each galaxy as a new test, as opposed to the view of them all as a statistical ensemble.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Gravitational Cherenkov losses in MOND theories
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
Survival of high-energy cosmic rays (HECRs) against gravitational Cherenkov losses is shown not to cast strong constraints on MOND theories that are compatible with general relativity (GR): theories that coincide with GR in the high-acceleration limit. The energy-loss rate, L, is shown to be many orders smaller than those derived in the literature for theories with no extra scale. The gravitationa…
▽ More
Survival of high-energy cosmic rays (HECRs) against gravitational Cherenkov losses is shown not to cast strong constraints on MOND theories that are compatible with general relativity (GR): theories that coincide with GR in the high-acceleration limit. The energy-loss rate, L, is shown to be many orders smaller than those derived in the literature for theories with no extra scale. The gravitational acceleration produced by a HECR in its vicinity is much higher than the MOND acceleration a0. So, modification to GR, which underlies L, enters only beyond the MOND radius of the particle, within which GR holds sway: r_M=sqrt(Gp/c a0). The spectral cutoff, which enters L quadratically, is thus 1/r_M, not the particle's, much larger, de Broglie wavenumber: k_{dB}= p/hbar. Thus, L is smaller than published rates, which use k_{dB}, by a factor (r_M k_{dB})^2~10^{39}(cp/3.10^{11}Gev)^3. With 1/r_M as cutoff, the distance a HECR can travel without major losses is q l_M, where l_M=c^2/a0 is the MOND length, and q is a dimensionless function of parameters of the problem. Since l_M is ~2 pi times the Hubble distance, survival of HECRs does not strongly constrain GR-compatible, MOND theories. Such theories also easily satisfy existing preferred-frame limits, inasmuch as these limits are gotten in high-acceleration systems. I exemplify the results with MOND adaptations of Einstein-Aether theories.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2011; v1 submitted 9 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
MD or DM? Modified dynamics at low accelerations vs dark matter
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
The MOND paradigm posits a departure from standard Newtonian dynamics, and from General Relativity, in the limit of small accelerations. The resulting modified dynamics aim to account for the mass discrepancies in the universe without non-baryonic dark matter. I briefly review this paradigm with its basic tenets, and its underlying theories--nonrelativistic and relativistic--including a novel, bim…
▽ More
The MOND paradigm posits a departure from standard Newtonian dynamics, and from General Relativity, in the limit of small accelerations. The resulting modified dynamics aim to account for the mass discrepancies in the universe without non-baryonic dark matter. I briefly review this paradigm with its basic tenets, and its underlying theories--nonrelativistic and relativistic--including a novel, bimetric MOND gravity theory. I also comment on MOND's possible connection to, and origin in, the cosmological state of the universe at large. Some of its main predictions, achievements, and remaining desiderata are listed. I then succinctly pit MOND against the competing paradigm of standard dynamics with cold, dark matter. (Abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2011;
originally announced January 2011.
-
Cosmological fluctuation growth in bimetric MOND
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
I look at the growth of weak density inhomogeneities of nonrelativistic matter, in bimetric-MOND (BIMOND) cosmology. I concentrate on matter-twin-matter-symmetric versions of BIMOND, and assume that, on average, the universe is symmetrically populated in the two sectors. MOND effects are absent in an exactly symmetric universe, apart from the appearance of a cosmological constant, Lambda~(a0/c)^2.…
▽ More
I look at the growth of weak density inhomogeneities of nonrelativistic matter, in bimetric-MOND (BIMOND) cosmology. I concentrate on matter-twin-matter-symmetric versions of BIMOND, and assume that, on average, the universe is symmetrically populated in the two sectors. MOND effects are absent in an exactly symmetric universe, apart from the appearance of a cosmological constant, Lambda~(a0/c)^2. MOND effects-local and cosmological-do enter when density inhomogeneities that differ in the two sectors appear and develop. MOND later takes its standard form in systems that are islands dominated by pure matter. I derive the nonrelativistic equations governing small-scale fluctuation growth. The equations split into two uncoupled systems, one for the sum, the other for the difference, of the fluctuations in the two sectors. The former is governed strictly by Newtonian dynamics. The latter is governed by MOND dynamics, which entails stronger gravity, and nonlinearity even for the smallest of perturbations. These cause the difference to grow faster than the sum, conducing to matter-twin-matter segregation. The nonlinearity also causes interaction between nested perturbations on different scales. Because matter and twin matter (TM) repel each other in the MOND regime, matter inhomogeneities grow not only by their own self gravity, but also through shepherding by flanking TM overdensitie. The relative importance of gravity and pressure in the MOND system depends also on the strength of the perturbation. The development of structure in the universe, in either sector, thus depends crucially on two initial fluctuation spectra: that of matter alone and that of the matter-TM difference. I also discuss the back reaction on cosmology of BIMOND effects that appear as "phantom matter" resulting from inhomogeneity differences between the two sectors.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2010; v1 submitted 18 June, 2010;
originally announced June 2010.
-
Matter and twin matter in bimetric MOND
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
Bimetric MOND (BIMOND) theories, propounded recently, predict peculiar gravitational interactions between matter and twin matter (TM). Twin matter is hypothetical matter that might couple directly only to the second metric of the theory. Considerations of cosmology in the BIMOND framework suggest that such TM might exist and copy matter in its attributes. Here I investigate the indirect interact…
▽ More
Bimetric MOND (BIMOND) theories, propounded recently, predict peculiar gravitational interactions between matter and twin matter (TM). Twin matter is hypothetical matter that might couple directly only to the second metric of the theory. Considerations of cosmology in the BIMOND framework suggest that such TM might exist and copy matter in its attributes. Here I investigate the indirect interactions that BIMOND theories predict between nonrelativistic masses of matter and TM. The most salient result is that in the deep-MOND regime of the matter-TM-symmetric theories, TM behaves as if it has a negative gravitational mass. To wit, interaction within each sector is attractive MOND gravity, but between matter and TM it is repulsive MOND gravity. In the high-acceleration regime, the interaction depends on a parameter, beta. For the favored value beta=1, matter and TM do not interact in this regime; for beta<1 they attract; and for beta>1 they repel each other. Such interactions may have substantial ramifications for all aspects of structure formation, such as matter distribution, peculiar velocities, and effects on the CMB. The repulsive interactions probably lead to segregation of matter and TM structures, leading, in turn, to intermeshing of the respective cosmic webs, with high-density nodes of one sector residing in the voids of the other (possibly conducing to efficient evacuation of the voids). Weak lensing by TM seems the best way to constrain its attributes. In the MOND regime a TM body acts on matter photons as a diverging lens. Strong lensing occurs in the high acceleration regime, and thus depends on the value of beta. For beta=1 no strong lensing effects of TM are expected. I also discuss briefly asymmetric theories (abridged).
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2010; v1 submitted 25 January, 2010;
originally announced January 2010.
-
New Physics at Low Accelerations (MOND): an Alternative to Dark Matter
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
I describe the MOND paradigm, which posits a departure from standard physics below a certain acceleration scale. This acceleration as deduced from the dynamics in galaxies is found mysteriously to agree with the cosmic acceleration scales defined by the present day expansion rate and by the density of `dark energy'. I put special emphasis on phenomenology and on critical comparison with the compet…
▽ More
I describe the MOND paradigm, which posits a departure from standard physics below a certain acceleration scale. This acceleration as deduced from the dynamics in galaxies is found mysteriously to agree with the cosmic acceleration scales defined by the present day expansion rate and by the density of `dark energy'. I put special emphasis on phenomenology and on critical comparison with the competing paradigm based on classical dynamics plus cold dark matter. I also describe briefly nonrelativistic and relativistic MOND theories.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2010; v1 submitted 14 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
Bimetric MOND gravity
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
A new relativistic formulation of MOND is advanced, involving two metrics as independent degrees of freedom: the MOND metric g_mn, to which alone matter couples, and an auxiliary metric g*_mn. The main idea hinges on the fact that we can form tensors from the difference, C^a_bc, of the Levi-Civita connections of the two metrics, and these act like gravitational accelerations. In the context of M…
▽ More
A new relativistic formulation of MOND is advanced, involving two metrics as independent degrees of freedom: the MOND metric g_mn, to which alone matter couples, and an auxiliary metric g*_mn. The main idea hinges on the fact that we can form tensors from the difference, C^a_bc, of the Levi-Civita connections of the two metrics, and these act like gravitational accelerations. In the context of MOND we can form dimensionless `acceleration' scalars, and functions thereof, from contractions of C^a_bc/a0. I look at a class of bimetric MOND theories governed by an action with the gravitational Lagrangian density b sqrt(g)R+a sqrt(g*) R* -2(gg*)^{1/4}f(k)a0^2M(U/a0^2), and with matter actions I(g_mn,psi)+I*(g*_mn,chi), with U a scalar quadratic in the C^a_bc, k=(g/g*)^{1/4}, and allowing for the existence of twin matter, chi, that couples to g*_mn alone. In particular, I concentrate on one interesting and simple choice of the scalar U. This theory introduces only one new constant, a0; it tends simply to General Relativity in the limit a0 goes to 0, and to a phenomenologically valid MOND theory in the nonrelativistic limit. The theory naturally gives MOND and "dark energy" effects from the same term in the action, both controlled by the MOND constant a0. As regards gravitational lensing by nonrelativistic systems--a holy grail for relativistic MOND theories--the theory predicts that the same potential that controls massive-particle motion also dictates lensing in the same way as in GR. This last result can be modified with other choices of U, but lensing is still enhanced and MOND-like, with an effective logarithmic potential.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2010; v1 submitted 4 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
The MOND limit from space-time scale invariance
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
The MOND limit is shown to follow from a requirement of space-time scale invariance of the equations of motion for nonrelativistic, purely gravitational systems; i.e., invariance of the equations of motion under (t,r) goes to (qt,qr), in the limit a0 goes to infinity. It is suggested that this should replace the definition of the MOND limit based on the low-acceleration behavior of a Newtonian-M…
▽ More
The MOND limit is shown to follow from a requirement of space-time scale invariance of the equations of motion for nonrelativistic, purely gravitational systems; i.e., invariance of the equations of motion under (t,r) goes to (qt,qr), in the limit a0 goes to infinity. It is suggested that this should replace the definition of the MOND limit based on the low-acceleration behavior of a Newtonian-MOND interpolating function. In this way, the salient, deep-MOND results--asymptotically flat rotation curves, the mass-rotational-speed relation (baryonic Tully-Fisher relation), the Faber-Jackson relation, etc.--follow from a symmetry principle. For example, asymptotic flatness of rotation curves reflects the fact that radii change under scaling, while velocities do not. I then comment on the interpretation of the deep-MOND limit as one of "zero mass": Rest masses, whose presence obstructs scaling symmetry, become negligible compared to the "phantom", dynamical masses--those that some would attribute to dark matter. Unlike the former masses, the latter transform in a way that is consistent with the symmetry. Finally, I discuss the putative MOND-cosmology connection in light of another, previously known symmetry of the deep-MOND limit. In particular, it is suggested that MOND is related to the asymptotic de Sitter geometry of our universe. It is conjectured, for example, that in an exact de Sitter cosmos, deep-MOND physics would exactly apply to local systems. I also point out, in this connection, the possible relevance of a de Sitter-conformal-field-theory (dS/CFT) duality.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2009; v1 submitted 22 October, 2008;
originally announced October 2008.
-
The MOND paradigm
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
I review briefly different aspects of the MOND paradigm, with emphasis on phenomenology, epitomized here by many MOND laws of galactic motion--analogous to Kepler's laws of planetary motion. I then comment on the possible roots of MOND in cosmology, possibly the deepest and most far reaching aspect of MOND. This is followed by a succinct account of existing underlying theories. I also reflect on…
▽ More
I review briefly different aspects of the MOND paradigm, with emphasis on phenomenology, epitomized here by many MOND laws of galactic motion--analogous to Kepler's laws of planetary motion. I then comment on the possible roots of MOND in cosmology, possibly the deepest and most far reaching aspect of MOND. This is followed by a succinct account of existing underlying theories. I also reflect on the implications of MOND's successes for the dark matter (DM) paradigm: MOND predictions imply that baryons alone accurately determine the full field of each and every individual galactic object. This conflicts with the expectations in the DM paradigm because of the haphazard formation and evolution of galactic objects and the very different influences that baryons and DM are subject to during the evolution, as evidenced, e.g., by the very small baryon-to-DM fraction in galaxies (compared with the cosmic value). All this should disabuse DM advocates of the thought that DM will someday be able to reproduce MOND: It is inconceivable that the modicum of baryons left over in galaxies can be made to determine everything if a much heavier DM component is present.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2008; v1 submitted 21 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Pair Winds in Schwarzschild Spacetime with Application to Strange Stars
Authors:
A. G. Aksenov,
M. Milgrom,
V. V. Usov
Abstract:
We present the results of numerical simulations of stationary, spherically outflowing, electron-positron pair winds, with total luminosities in the range 10^{34}--10^{42} ergs/s. In the concrete example described here, the wind injection source is a hot, bare, strange star, predicted to be a powerful source of pairs created by the Coulomb barrier at the quark surface. We find that photons domina…
▽ More
We present the results of numerical simulations of stationary, spherically outflowing, electron-positron pair winds, with total luminosities in the range 10^{34}--10^{42} ergs/s. In the concrete example described here, the wind injection source is a hot, bare, strange star, predicted to be a powerful source of pairs created by the Coulomb barrier at the quark surface. We find that photons dominate in the emerging emission, and the emerging photon spectrum is rather hard and differs substantially from the thermal spectrum expected from a neutron star with the same luminosity. This might help distinguish the putative bare strange stars from neutron stars.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2007;
originally announced January 2007.
-
Structure of pair winds from compact objects with application to emission from hot bare strange stars
Authors:
A. G. Aksenov,
M. Milgrom,
V. V. Usov
Abstract:
We consider a stationary, spherically outflowing wind consisting of electron-positron pairs and photons. We do not assume thermal equilibrium, and include the two-body processes that occur in such a wind: Moller and Bhaba scattering of pairs, Compton scattering, two-photon pair annihilation, and two-photon pair production, together with their radiative three-body variants: bremsstrahlung, double…
▽ More
We consider a stationary, spherically outflowing wind consisting of electron-positron pairs and photons. We do not assume thermal equilibrium, and include the two-body processes that occur in such a wind: Moller and Bhaba scattering of pairs, Compton scattering, two-photon pair annihilation, and two-photon pair production, together with their radiative three-body variants: bremsstrahlung, double Compton scattering, and three-photon pair annihilation, with their inverse processes. In the concrete example described here, the wind injection source is a hot, bare, strange star. Such stars are thought to be powerful sources of pairs created by the Coulomb barrier at the quark surface. We present a new, finite-difference scheme for solving the relativistic kinetic Boltzmann equations for pairs and photons. Using this method we study the kinetics of the wind particles and the emerging emission for total luminosities of L=10^{34}-10^{42} ergs/s. We find the rates of particle number and energy outflows, outflow velocities, number densities, energy spectra, and other parameters for both photons and pairs as functions of the distance. We find that for L>2x10^{35} ergs/s, photons dominate the emerging emission. As L increases from ~ 10^{34} to 10^{42} ergs/s, the mean energy of emergent photons decreases from ~400-500 keV to 40 keV, as the spectrum changes in shape from that of a wide annihilation line to nearly a blackbody spectrum with a high energy (> 100 keV) tail. These results are pertinent to the deduction of the outside appearance of hot bare strange stars, which might help discern them from neutron stars.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2004; v1 submitted 31 August, 2003;
originally announced September 2003.
-
MOND--theoretical aspects
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom
Abstract:
I discuss open theoretical questions pertaining to the modified dynamics (MOND)--a proposed alternative to dark matter, which posits a breakdown of Newtonian dynamics in the limit of small accelerations. In particular, I point the reasons for thinking that MOND is an effective theory--perhaps, despite appearance, not even in conflict with GR. I then contrast the two interpretations of MOND as mo…
▽ More
I discuss open theoretical questions pertaining to the modified dynamics (MOND)--a proposed alternative to dark matter, which posits a breakdown of Newtonian dynamics in the limit of small accelerations. In particular, I point the reasons for thinking that MOND is an effective theory--perhaps, despite appearance, not even in conflict with GR. I then contrast the two interpretations of MOND as modified gravity and as modified inertia. I describe two mechanical models that are described by potential theories similar to (non-relativistic) MOND: a potential-flow model, and a membrane model. These might shed some light on a possible origin of MOND. The possible involvement of vacuum effects is also speculated on.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2002; v1 submitted 11 July, 2002;
originally announced July 2002.
-
Gamma-ray bursters as sources of cosmic rays
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom,
Vladimir Usov
Abstract:
The little we do know of the physical conditions in gamma-ray bursters makes them conducive to the acceleration of high-energy cosmic rays, especially if they are at cosmological distances. We find that, with the observed statistics and fluxes of gamma-ray bursts, cosmological bursters may be an important source of cosmic rays in two regions of the observed spectrum: 1. At the very-high-energy e…
▽ More
The little we do know of the physical conditions in gamma-ray bursters makes them conducive to the acceleration of high-energy cosmic rays, especially if they are at cosmological distances. We find that, with the observed statistics and fluxes of gamma-ray bursts, cosmological bursters may be an important source of cosmic rays in two regions of the observed spectrum: 1. At the very-high-energy end (E>10^{19} eV), where cosmic rays must be of extragalactic origin. 2. Around and above the spectral feature that has been described as a bump and/or a knee, which occurs around 10^{15} eV, and starts at about 10^{14} eV. The occasional bursters that occur inside the Galaxy--about once in a few hundred thousand years if burst emission is isotropic; more often, if it is beamed--could maintain the density of galactic cosmic rays at the observed level in this range. These two energy ranges might correspond to two typical energy scales expected from bursters: one pertinent to acceleration due to interaction of a magnetized-fireball front with an ambient medium; the other to acceleration in the fireball itself (e.g. shock acceleration).
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 1995;
originally announced June 1995.
-
Possible association of ultra-high-energy cosmic-ray events with strong gamma-ray bursts
Authors:
Mordehai Milgrom,
Vladimir Usov
Abstract:
We point out that each of the error boxes of the two highest-energy cosmic-ray shower events known, overlaps with that of a strong gamma-ray burst (GRB). The GRBs precede the cosmic rays by 5.5, and 11 months respectively. In one case the strongest known cosmic ray is paired with the strongest gamma-ray burst in the BATSE catalogue. The probability of this to have occurred by chance seems rather…
▽ More
We point out that each of the error boxes of the two highest-energy cosmic-ray shower events known, overlaps with that of a strong gamma-ray burst (GRB). The GRBs precede the cosmic rays by 5.5, and 11 months respectively. In one case the strongest known cosmic ray is paired with the strongest gamma-ray burst in the BATSE catalogue. The probability of this to have occurred by chance seems rather small. Without building on post-factum statistics, we think the above is remarkable enough to suggest that the cosmic ray and gamma-ray burst were produced by the same outburst. A time delay (and a small positional disparity) is expected, since the trajectory of a charged cosmic-ray particle is wriggled by intervening magnetic fields. We estimate that the Galaxy's field alone may produce a delay of the order observed. We discuss some of the implications that follow if such an association is confirmed. For example, the upper limit on the distance to the cosmic-ray source, combined with a much-better-determined position of the gamma-ray burst source, narrows greatly the volume in which to look for an optical counterpart. There is also useful information in the time delay regarding, e.g., intergalactic magnetic fields.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 1995;
originally announced May 1995.