Showing 1–50 of 96 results for author: Lipkin, H J

Entangled symmetries explain without QCD dynamics CP violation in neutral B to Kpi decays; not in charged B decays Unexpected isospin relations in charged and neutral decays,

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Simple flavor symmetry argument without QCD dynamics shows why CP violation observed in neutral $B$ to $Kπ$ decays is absent in charged B decays where tree diagram final state has two $u$ quarks satisfying Pauli principle. Entanglement preserves short range symmetry correlations after separation into two mesons. Pauli principle and symmetries require totally flavor-symmetric tree diagram final sta… ▽ More Simple flavor symmetry argument without QCD dynamics shows why CP violation observed in neutral $B$ to $Kπ$ decays is absent in charged B decays where tree diagram final state has two $u$ quarks satisfying Pauli principle. Entanglement preserves short range symmetry correlations after separation into two mesons. Pauli principle and symmetries require totally flavor-symmetric tree diagram final state. $ππ$ isospin state with I=2 already is flavor symmetric and suffers no symmetry constraint. Strange flavor-symmetric state with V spin V=2 is linear combination of $Kπ$ and $K η$ with probability only (1/4) for $Kπ$. Tree diagram suppression by factor 4 not present in neutral decays explains negligible tree-penguin interference and CP violation in charged decays. Detailed full symmetry analysis shows constraints from space-inversion, charge conjugation, Pauli antisymmetrization and flavor symmetry. Two antiquarks produced at same space point by tree diagram have even parity. Even parity final state requires even parity, even space symmetry and color-spin antisymmetry for two $u$ quarks. Color-singlet spin-singlet final state requires color-spin antisymmetry and therefore flavor symmetry for two-antiquark wave function. Flavor symmetric $\bar u \bar d$ and $\bar u \bar s$ antiquark pairs have isospin I=1 and V-spin V =1. Generalized charge conjugation invariance requires I=2 for $ππ$ tree diagram and V = 2 for $Kπ$. Penguin decays give I = 1/2 final state and no CP violation. Experiments confirm surprising predictions from tree suppression factor not noted in previous analyzes. I=1/2 violations seen only in relation between charged and neutral decays together with no I=3/2 components in each individual decay. Common treatments using $ππ$ data fail to fit $Kπ$ data. △ Less

Submitted 23 July, 2012; v1 submitted 20 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: 18 pages, 3 figures. arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:1105.3443, arXiv:1102.4700, and arXiv:1107.1888

Heavy Baryons and Exotics Spectrum

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin, Nils A. Tornqvist

Abstract: We discuss several highly accurate theoretical predictions for masses of baryons containing the b quark which have been recently confirmed by experimental data. Several predictions are given for additional properties of heavy baryons. We also discuss the two charged exotic resonances Z_b with quantum numbers of a (b bbar u ddbar) tetraquark, very recently reported by Belle in the channel [Upsilon(… ▽ More We discuss several highly accurate theoretical predictions for masses of baryons containing the b quark which have been recently confirmed by experimental data. Several predictions are given for additional properties of heavy baryons. We also discuss the two charged exotic resonances Z_b with quantum numbers of a (b bbar u ddbar) tetraquark, very recently reported by Belle in the channel [Upsilon(nS) π^+, n=1,2,3]. Among possible implications are deeply bound I=0 counterparts of the Z_b-s and existence of a Sigma_b^+ Sigma_b^- dibaryon, a "beauteron". △ Less

Submitted 15 September, 2011; originally announced September 2011.

Comments: Invited talk at Hadron 2011, the XIV International Conference on Hadron Spectroscopy, 13-17 June 2011, Munich, Germany; 8 pages, 1 figure

New Analysis of $B \rightarrow Kπ$ data with Pauli blocking CP violation in $B^o$ decays, not in $B^{\pm}$ SU(3) use of $B \rightarrow ππ$ data invalid for $B \rightarrow Kπ$

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: New data analysis with Pauli blocking explains observation of CP violation in $B^o\rightarrow Kπ$ decays, absence in $B^{\pm} \rightarrow Kπ$ decays and gives new predictions agreeing with experiment. Branching ratio data show pure I=1/2 amplitude predicted by pure penguin transitions for separate relations within charged and neutral B decays, but strong violation of penguin I=1/2 isospin relation… ▽ More New data analysis with Pauli blocking explains observation of CP violation in $B^o\rightarrow Kπ$ decays, absence in $B^{\pm} \rightarrow Kπ$ decays and gives new predictions agreeing with experiment. Branching ratio data show pure I=1/2 amplitude predicted by pure penguin transitions for separate relations within charged and neutral B decays, but strong violation of penguin I=1/2 isospin relation between charged and neutral decays. $B(B^o \rightarrow K^+ π^-) - 2B(B^o\rightarrow K^o π^o) = %(19.4 \pm 0.6)- 2\cdot (9.4 \pm 0.6) = (0.6 \pm 1.3)\cdot 10^-6 \approx 0$ $2B(B^+ \rightarrow K^+ π^o) - B(B^+ \rightarrow K^o π^+) = %(25.8\pm 1.2) - (23.1 \pm 1.0) = (2.7 \pm 1.6)\cdot 10^-6 \approx 0$ ${{τ^o}\over{τ^+}}\cdot 2B(B^+ \rightarrow K^+ π^o) - B(B^o \rightarrow K^+ π^-) = (4.7 \pm 0.82)\cdot 10^-6 \not= 0$ This contrast between pure I=1/2 observed in individual charged and neutral final states and I=1/2 violation in relations between them is unexpected in previous treatments. Pauli blocking predicts this contrast by noting that two identical $u$ quarks in a relative s-wave are Pauli blocked. Tree diagram $\bar b\rightarrow \bar s u \bar u$ for $\bar b$ producing $u$ quark at weak vertex and tree-penguin interference producing CP violation are Pauli suppressed for $B^+$ decays with identical $u$ quark spectator. No suppression in $B^o$ decays with spectator $d$ quark. $B\rightarrow Kπ$ data analysis discards all amplitudes containing two identical $u$ quarks in final state and predicts observed isospin relations by using only Pauli-favored amplitudes ${B_u}\rightarrow \bar s du \bar d$ and ${B_d}\rightarrow \bar s ud \bar u$. Pauli-favored transitions explain dependence on flavor of spectator quark which does not participate in the weak interaction. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2011; originally announced July 2011.

Comments: 9 pages, no figurew

Pauli blocking and entanglement solve $Kπ$ puzzle. CP violation in $B^o \rightarrow Kπ$; not in $B^{\pm} \rightarrow Kπ$decays

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: New data analysis with Pauli blocking and entanglement explains CP violation in $B^o\rightarrow Kπ$ decays, absence in $B^{\pm} \rightarrow Kπ$ decays and predicts unexpected contrast between pure I=1/2 in individual $B^{\pm}$ and $B^o$ final states and I=1/2 violation in relations between them. Analysis of $B\rightarrow Kπ$ data predicts these observed isospin relations and explains dependence on… ▽ More New data analysis with Pauli blocking and entanglement explains CP violation in $B^o\rightarrow Kπ$ decays, absence in $B^{\pm} \rightarrow Kπ$ decays and predicts unexpected contrast between pure I=1/2 in individual $B^{\pm}$ and $B^o$ final states and I=1/2 violation in relations between them. Analysis of $B\rightarrow Kπ$ data predicts these observed isospin relations and explains dependence on spectator quark flavor. $B^+ \rightarrow Kπ$ tree diagram $\bar b u\rightarrow \bar s u \bar u u$ has two identical $u$ quarks from weak vertex and spectator. The Pauli principle requires these quarks at short distances to have wave functions antisymmetric in color or spin. The eigenvalues of conserved symmetries remain entangled in a final state of two separated mesons. This Pauli entanglement suppresses tree-penguin interference and CP violation in $B^+$ decay but not in $B^o$ decay with spectator $d$ quark. The four-body wave function must have two antiquarks with the same symmetry combining with two u-quarks to fragment into a two-pseudoscalar-meson state even under charge conjugation with angular momentum zero. It is classified in the 27-dimensional representation of flavor SU(3) with isospin I=2 for the $ππ$ state and V spin V=2 for the corresponding strange state which is linear combination of $Kπ$ and $Kη_8$. These symmetries remain entangled in four-body wave function even after separation into two mesons. Strong Pauli suppression in tree transitions to $Kπ$ which has only a small V=2 component and is mainly V=1. No Pauli suppression in transitions to I=2 $ππ$ state with also two $u$ quarks but different color-spin couplings. Standard definition of independent color favored and suppressed tree diagrams in $B^\pm\rightarrow Kπ$ decays neglects $uu$ Pauli entanglement. △ Less

Submitted 12 February, 2012; v1 submitted 17 May, 2011; originally announced May 2011.

Comments: 14 pages. 3 figures. Revision includes entanglement. arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:1102.4700 and arXiv:1107.1888

New $B^{\pm}\to Kπ$ data explain absence of CP violation Tree-penguin interference canceled by Pauli effects

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Observation of CP violation in $B^o\to K^\pmπ^{\mp}$ decays and its absence in $B^+\to K^+π^o$ decays are explained in new improved data analysis of more precise $B\to Kπ$ data. Success of the "Lipkin Sum Rule" indicates that four $B\tow Kπ$ branching ratios are determined by three parameters, the penguin diagram $P$ and two interference terms $P\cdot T$ and $P\cdot S$ between the dominant penguin… ▽ More Observation of CP violation in $B^o\to K^\pmπ^{\mp}$ decays and its absence in $B^+\to K^+π^o$ decays are explained in new improved data analysis of more precise $B\to Kπ$ data. Success of the "Lipkin Sum Rule" indicates that four $B\tow Kπ$ branching ratios are determined by three parameters, the penguin diagram $P$ and two interference terms $P\cdot T$ and $P\cdot S$ between the dominant penguin and two tree diagrams; the color-favored and color suppressed diagrams. Previous analyzes confirmed the model with errors leaving values of interference terms less that two standard deviations from zero. The observation CP violation in $B^o\to K^\pmπ^{\mp}$ decays indicates a finite value for $P\cdot T$. New precise data analysis show $P\cdot T$ and $P\cdot S$ interference contributions well above errors. Their contributions to $B^\pm\to Kπ$ decays are shown to be nearly equal with opposite phase and cancel within experimental errors. This cancelation unexpected in previous analyzes explains the failure to see CP violation in $B^\pm\to Kπ$ decays. It can be due to the Pauli antisymmetry exchange neglected in previous analyzes. Two $B^\pm\to Kπ$ tree diagrams differ by interchange of two identical $u$ quarks. $B^o\to K^\pmπ^{\mp}$ diagrams have no identical quark pairs. This Pauli effect explains the difference produced by changing the flavor of the spectator quark which does not participate in the weak interaction. Our analysis differs from previous analyzes which assume SU(3) flavor symmetry to use input from $B\to ππ$ data and neglect Pauli effects. We use new data, include Pauli effects and strong final state interactions to all orders in QCD with no higher flavor symmetry assumed beyond isospin. We do not use $B\to ππ$ data. △ Less

Submitted 2 April, 2011; v1 submitted 23 February, 2011; originally announced February 2011.

Comments: 21 pages, 3 figurew

Isospin Violation in X(3872): Explanation From a New Tetraquark Model

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: New data for X(3872) production in B decays provide a separation between X production and decay, sharpen several experimental puzzles and impose serious constraints on all models. Both charged and neutral B decays produce a narrow neutral resonant state that decays to both J/ψρand J/ψω, while no charged resonances in the same multiplet are found. This suggests that the X is an isoscalar resonance… ▽ More New data for X(3872) production in B decays provide a separation between X production and decay, sharpen several experimental puzzles and impose serious constraints on all models. Both charged and neutral B decays produce a narrow neutral resonant state that decays to both J/ψρand J/ψω, while no charged resonances in the same multiplet are found. This suggests that the X is an isoscalar resonance whose production conserves isospin, while isospin is violated only in the decay by an electromagnetic interaction allowing the isospin-forbidden J/ψρdecay. A tetraquark isoscalar X model is proposed which agrees with all present data, conserves isospin in its production and breaks isospin only in an electromagnetic X(3872) --> J/ψρ^o decay. The narrow X decay width results from the tiny phase space available for the J/ψωdecay and enables competition with the electromagnetic isospin-forbidden J/ψρdecay which has much larger phase space. Experimental tests are proposed for this isospin production invariance. △ Less

Submitted 4 August, 2010; v1 submitted 1 August, 2010; originally announced August 2010.

Comments: LaTeX, 9 pages

Why do neutrinos with different masses interfere and oscillate? Why are states with different masses but same energy coherent? Overcoming barrier between particle & condensed matter physics

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Neutrino oscillations occur only if it is impossible to determine $ν$ mass by using conservation laws on measurements of nucleon-lepton system absorbing $ν$. No oscillations if $ν$ detector is mass spectrometer. Beam is split into components with different masses entering different counters. For each event only one counter will click and determine $ν$ mass. Condensed matter physics needed to descr… ▽ More Neutrino oscillations occur only if it is impossible to determine $ν$ mass by using conservation laws on measurements of nucleon-lepton system absorbing $ν$. No oscillations if $ν$ detector is mass spectrometer. Beam is split into components with different masses entering different counters. For each event only one counter will click and determine $ν$ mass. Condensed matter physics needed to describe the $ν$ detector, show it is not a mass spectrometer and identify which properties of the incident $ν$ are unobservable. Relativistic quantum field theory can only describe $ν$ wave function entering detector but not large uncertain momentum transfers to detector nor associated energy-momentum asymmetry. Absorption of incident $ν$'s with different momenta but same energy leaves no trace of initial $ν$ momentum difference in finite-size $ν$ detector with effectively infinite mass at rest in laboratory. Undetectable recoil-free momentum is transferred to the detector with negligible energy transfer. The Debye-Waller factor common in X-ray diffraction by crystals gives probability that absorbing $ν$'s with different momenta produce same nucleon-charged-lepton final state. Oscillations in time described in textbooks as interference between $ν$ states with different energies not observable in realistic experiments. Different energy $ν$'s not coherent because energy can be determined by measurements on initial and final states. Experiments detecting $ν$ produced by $πto μν$ decay observe no electrons even though $ν$ mass eigenstates produce electrons. Electron amplitude canceled by interference between amplitudes from different $ν$ mass eigenstates with same energy and different momenta entering massive detector. △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2012; v1 submitted 23 May, 2010; originally announced May 2010.

Comments: 16 pages, no figures, new title and abstract clarification of previous version

Simple quantum mechanics explains GSI Darmstadt oscillations Even with undetected neutrino; Momentum conservation requires Same interference producing oscillations in initial and final states

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: GSI experiment studying oscillations in K-capture decay of radioactive ion investigates neutrino masses and mixing without detecting neutrino. Even when neutrino is not detected quantum mechanics relates initial and final states. The basic physics is very simple. Neutrinos emitted in beta decay are coherent linear combinations of states with different masses, different momenta and same energy. Sin… ▽ More GSI experiment studying oscillations in K-capture decay of radioactive ion investigates neutrino masses and mixing without detecting neutrino. Even when neutrino is not detected quantum mechanics relates initial and final states. The basic physics is very simple. Neutrinos emitted in beta decay are coherent linear combinations of states with different masses, different momenta and same energy. Since the weak interaction producing the neutrino conserves momentum, the initial state before the transition must also contain a coherent linear combination of states with the same momentum difference and a well defined relative magnitude and phase. A one-particle state with a definite momentum difference also has an easily calculated energy difference. In the time interval between creation of the ion and its decay a linear combination of two states with different energies oscillates in time. Measuring the oscillation period gives a value for the difference between squared neutrino masses of the two neutrino mass eigenstates. The value obtained from a crude approximation with no free parameters for this "two-slit" or "which path" experiment in momentum space differs by less than 10% from the result observed in the KAMLAND experiment. Observing only ion disappearance without detecting neutrino avoids signal suppression by low neutrino absorption cross section △ Less

Submitted 13 February, 2012; v1 submitted 21 March, 2010; originally announced March 2010.

Comments: 14pages, no figures. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:0805.0435 and arXiv:0801.1465

About a Possible Nonstrange Cousin of the Theta+ Pentaquark

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: We discuss the implications of the suggested interpretation of the recently reported narrow pi N resonance (width \approx 25 MeV at 1680 MeV) as a pentaquark in the same multiplet as the Theta+. We consider a diquark-triquark pentaquark model involving a recoupling of the five quarks into a diquark-triquark system in non-standard color representations. We estimate the mass using a well-tested si… ▽ More We discuss the implications of the suggested interpretation of the recently reported narrow pi N resonance (width \approx 25 MeV at 1680 MeV) as a pentaquark in the same multiplet as the Theta+. We consider a diquark-triquark pentaquark model involving a recoupling of the five quarks into a diquark-triquark system in non-standard color representations. We estimate the mass using a well-tested simple mass formula. Our rough numerical estimate puts the pi N pentaquark resonance at 1720 MeV, sufficiently close to the reported value of 1680 MeV to indicate that this approach deserves further more accurate investigation. △ Less

Submitted 8 March, 2010; v1 submitted 22 February, 2010; originally announced February 2010.

Comments: Invited talk at International Workshop "Narrow Nucleon Resonances: Predictions, Evidences, Perspectives", Edinburgh, Scotland, June 8--10, 2009. Added references and comments.

Report number: TAUP 2910/10, WIS/04/10-FEB-DPPA

Theoretical Analysis Supports Darmstadt Oscillations Crucial Roles of Wave Function Collapse and Dicke Superradiance

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Darmstadt $ν$ oscillations in decay of radioactive ion can only come from initial state wave function. Causality forbids any influence on transition probability by detection of $ν$ or final state interference after decay. Energy-time uncertainty allows two initial state components with different energies to decay into combination of two orthogonal states with same energy, different momenta and d… ▽ More Darmstadt $ν$ oscillations in decay of radioactive ion can only come from initial state wave function. Causality forbids any influence on transition probability by detection of $ν$ or final state interference after decay. Energy-time uncertainty allows two initial state components with different energies to decay into combination of two orthogonal states with same energy, different momenta and different $ν$ masses. Final amplitudes completely separated at long times have broadened energy spectra overlapping at short times. Their interference produces oscillations between Dicke superradiant and subradiant states having different transition probabilities. Repeated monitoring by interactions with laboratory environment at regular time intervals and same space point in laboratory collapses wave function and destroys entanglement. First-order time dependent perturbation theory gives probability for initial state decay during small interval between two monitoring events. Experiment measures momentum difference between two contributing coherent initial states and obtains information about $ν$ masses without detecting $ν$. Simple model relates observed oscillation to squared $ν$ mass difference and gives value differing by less than factor of three from values calculated from KAMLAND experiment. Monitoring simply expressed in laboratory frame not easily transformed to other frames and missed in Lorentz-covariant descriptions based on relativistic quantum field theory. △ Less

Submitted 20 November, 2009; v1 submitted 27 October, 2009; originally announced October 2009.

Comments: 19 pages, no figures, introduction and abstract revised for clarification

Theory of neutrino oscillations using condensed matter physics Including production process and energy-time uncertainty

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Neutrino scillations cannot arise from an initial isolated one particle state if four-momentum is conserved. The transition matrix element is generally squared and summed over all final states with no interference between orthogonal final states. Lorentz covariant descriptions based on relativistic quantum field theory cannot describe interference between orthogonal states with different $ν$ mas… ▽ More Neutrino scillations cannot arise from an initial isolated one particle state if four-momentum is conserved. The transition matrix element is generally squared and summed over all final states with no interference between orthogonal final states. Lorentz covariant descriptions based on relativistic quantum field theory cannot describe interference between orthogonal states with different $ν$ masses producing neutrino oscillations. Simplified model presents rigorous derivation of handwaving argument about "energy-time uncertainty". Standard time-dependent perturbation theory for decays shows how energy spectrum of final state is much broader than natural line width at times much shorter than decay lifetime. Initial state containing two components with different energies decay into two orthogonal states with different $ν$ masses completely separated at long times with no interference. At short times the broadened energy spectra of the two amplitudes overlap and interfere. "Darmstadt oscillation" experiment attempts to measure the momentum difference between the two contributing coherent initial states and obtain information about $ν$ masses without detecting the $ν$. Simple interpretation gives value for the squared $ν$ mass difference differing by less than a factor of three from values calculated from the KAMLAND experiment. Treatment holds only in laboratory frame with values of energy, time and momentum determined by experimental environment at rest in the laboratory. △ Less

Submitted 8 May, 2009; originally announced May 2009.

Comments: 15 pages, no figures

Difficulties in using the sharp neutrino spectrum at short times

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Final states produced by a decay have a much broader energy spectrum than the natural line width at times much shorter than the decay lifetime. This tends to render impossible the use for neutrino detection of the high value of the resonance absorption cross section at the peak of the resonance. Final states produced by a decay have a much broader energy spectrum than the natural line width at times much shorter than the decay lifetime. This tends to render impossible the use for neutrino detection of the high value of the resonance absorption cross section at the peak of the resonance. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2009; originally announced April 2009.

Comments: 3 pages

The GSI method for studying neutrino mass differences - For Pedestrians

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: A new experiment studying the behavior of a radioactive ion before its weak decay by K-capture suggests that neutrino masses and mixing can be investigated without detecting the neutrino. Every weak decay can be observed, thus avoiding the suppression by the low neutrino absorption cross section of the signal in conventional neutrino oscillation experiments. The normally unobservable long wave l… ▽ More A new experiment studying the behavior of a radioactive ion before its weak decay by K-capture suggests that neutrino masses and mixing can be investigated without detecting the neutrino. Every weak decay can be observed, thus avoiding the suppression by the low neutrino absorption cross section of the signal in conventional neutrino oscillation experiments. The normally unobservable long wave lengths are made observable by having the radioactive source move a long distance circulating around in a storage ring. A new oscillation phenomenon with nonexponential decay arises in this "watched pot" experiment where continous monitoring sets the decay clock back to zero while preserving oscillating phases in the initial state. The initial ion wave packet has a momentum spread required by Heisenberg and contains pairs of components with different momenta and energies. These can produce neutrino amplitudes in two mass eigenstates with different momenta which mix to produce a single $ν_e$ state. In this typical quantum mechanics "two-slit" or "which path" experiment a transition between the same initial and final states can go via two paths in energy-momentum space. Their relative phases change with the propagation of the initial state between the points of entry and decay. The oscillations produced by these phase changes are shown to be consistent with quantum mechanics and causality. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2009; v1 submitted 4 May, 2008; originally announced May 2008.

Comments: 10 pages

The Quark Model and $b$ Baryons

Authors: Marek Karliner, Boaz Keren-Zur, Harry J. Lipkin, Jonathan L. Rosner

Abstract: The recent observation at the Tevatron of $Σ_b^{\pm}$ ($uub$ and $ddb$) baryons within 2 MeV of the predicted $Σ_b - Λ_b$ splitting and of $Ξ_b^-$ $(dsb)$ baryons at the Tevatron within a few MeV of predictions has provided strong confirmation for a theoretical approach based on modeling the color hyperfine interaction. The prediction of $M(Ξ^-_b) = 5790$ to 5800 MeV is reviewed and similar meth… ▽ More The recent observation at the Tevatron of $Σ_b^{\pm}$ ($uub$ and $ddb$) baryons within 2 MeV of the predicted $Σ_b - Λ_b$ splitting and of $Ξ_b^-$ $(dsb)$ baryons at the Tevatron within a few MeV of predictions has provided strong confirmation for a theoretical approach based on modeling the color hyperfine interaction. The prediction of $M(Ξ^-_b) = 5790$ to 5800 MeV is reviewed and similar methods used to predict the masses of the excited states $Ξ_b^\prime$ and $Ξ_b^*$. The main source of uncertainty is the method used to estimate the mass difference $m_b - m_c$ from known hadrons. We verify that corrections due to the details of the interquark potential and to $Ξ_b$--$Ξ_b^\prime$ mixing are small. For S-wave $qqb$ states we predict $M(Ω_b) = 6052.1 \pm 5.6$ MeV, $M(Ω^*_b) = 6082.8 \pm 5.6$ MeV, and $M(Ξ_b^0) = 5786.7 \pm 3.0$ MeV. For states with one unit of orbital angular momentum between the $b$ quark and the two light quarks we predict $M(Λ_{b[1/2]}) = 5929 \pm 2$ MeV, $M(Λ_{b[3/2]}) = 5940 \pm 2$ MeV, $M(Ξ_{b[1/2]}) = 6106 \pm 4$ MeV, and $M(Ξ_{b[3/2]}) = 6115 \pm 4$ MeV. Results are compared with those of other recent approaches. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2008; v1 submitted 9 April, 2008; originally announced April 2008.

Comments: 20 pages, 1 figure, to be published in Annals of Physics. Eq. (58) corrected

Report number: EFI 08-09, TAUP 2875/08, WIS/07/08-Apr-DPP, ANL-HEP-PR-08-20

Journal ref: Annals Phys.324:2-15,2009

Possibility of Exotic States in the Upsilon system

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Recent data from Belle show unusually large partial widths Upsilon(5S) --> Upsilon(1S) pi^+pi^- and Υ(5S) --> Υ(2S) pi^+ pi^-. The Z(4430) narrow resonance also reported by Belle in psi' pi^+ spectrum has the properties expected of a (cbar c u dbar) charged isovector tetraquark T^{+-}_cc The analogous state T^{+-} in the bottom sector might mediate anomalously large cascade decays in the Upsilon… ▽ More Recent data from Belle show unusually large partial widths Upsilon(5S) --> Upsilon(1S) pi^+pi^- and Υ(5S) --> Υ(2S) pi^+ pi^-. The Z(4430) narrow resonance also reported by Belle in psi' pi^+ spectrum has the properties expected of a (cbar c u dbar) charged isovector tetraquark T^{+-}_cc The analogous state T^{+-} in the bottom sector might mediate anomalously large cascade decays in the Upsilon system, Upsilon(mS) --> T^{+-}_bb pi^{-+} --> Upsilon(nS) pi^+ π^-, with a tetraquark-pion intermediate state. We suggest looking for the (bbar b u dbar) tetraquark in these decays as peaks in the invariant mass of Upsilon(1S) pi or Upsilon(2S) pi systems. The (bbar b u sbar) tetraquark can appear in the observed decays Upsilon(5S) --> Upsilon(1S) K^+ K^- as a peak in the invariant mass of Upsilon(1S) K system. We review the model showing that these tetraquarks are below the two heavy meson threshold, but respectively above the Upsilon pi pi and Upsilon K Kbar thresholds. △ Less

Submitted 4 March, 2008; v1 submitted 5 February, 2008; originally announced February 2008.

Comments: LaTex, 5 pages

New method for studying neutrino mixing and mass differences

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Neutrino masses and mixing can be investigated by studying the behavior of a radioactive bare nucleus which decays by emitting an electron into the open atomic K shell BEFORE and DURING its weak decay by neutrino emission. The initial nuclear state has a momentum spread required by Heisenberg. The wave packet contains pairs of components with different momenta which can produce neutrinos in two… ▽ More Neutrino masses and mixing can be investigated by studying the behavior of a radioactive bare nucleus which decays by emitting an electron into the open atomic K shell BEFORE and DURING its weak decay by neutrino emission. The initial nuclear state has a momentum spread required by Heisenberg. The wave packet contains pairs of components with different momenta which can produce neutrinos in two mass eigenstates with exactly the same energy and different momenta. These neutrino amplitudes mix to produce a single electron-neutrino state with the same energy. Since there is no information on which mass eigenstates produced the neutrino this is a typical quantum mechanics "two-slit" or "which path" experiment. A transition between the same initial and a final states can go via two paths with a phase difference producing interference and oscillations. Here the two paths are in momentum space A new oscillation phenomenon providing information about neutrino mixing is obtained by following the nucleus before and during the decay. The analysis starts with Stodolsky's proof that interference between states having different energies cannot be observed in realistic experiments. Results then follow from simple rigorous quantum mechanics without the hand waving and loopholes which have confused many previous neutrino oscillation investigations. △ Less

Submitted 6 March, 2008; v1 submitted 9 January, 2008; originally announced January 2008.

Comments: 12 pages -Revised in view of announcement of new experiment on K-capture

Possibility of Narrow High-Mass Exotic States

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Narrow high-mass states can arise despite large phase space when two nearly degenerate states are coupled to the same dominant decay mode. Mixing via a final-state interaction loop diagram can produce one very broad state and one narrow state. Such a situation is generic in exotic hadrons where a color singlet with given flavor and spin quantum numbers can be constructed with two distinct intern… ▽ More Narrow high-mass states can arise despite large phase space when two nearly degenerate states are coupled to the same dominant decay mode. Mixing via a final-state interaction loop diagram can produce one very broad state and one narrow state. Such a situation is generic in exotic hadrons where a color singlet with given flavor and spin quantum numbers can be constructed with two distinct internal color couplings of quarks. The simplest realization of this idea are the (Q Qbar q qbar) tetraquarks containing two heavy and two light quarks. We discuss possible experimental implications, including recent data from Belle. △ Less

Submitted 22 October, 2007; originally announced October 2007.

Comments: LaTeX, 7 pages, 2 figures

Report number: TAUP 2865/07, WIS/17/07-OCT-DPP, ANL-HEP-PR-707-88

Predictions for masses of bottom baryons

Authors: Marek Karliner, Boaz Keren-Zur, Harry J. Lipkin, Jonathan L. Rosner

Abstract: The recent observation of Sigma_b^{+-} (uub and ddb) and Xi_b^- (dsb) baryons at the Tevatron within 2 MeV of our theoretical predictions provides a strong motivation for applying the same theoretical approach, based on modeling the color hyperfine interaction, to predict the masses of other bottom baryons which might be observed in the foreseeable future. For S-wave qqb states we predict M(Omeg… ▽ More The recent observation of Sigma_b^{+-} (uub and ddb) and Xi_b^- (dsb) baryons at the Tevatron within 2 MeV of our theoretical predictions provides a strong motivation for applying the same theoretical approach, based on modeling the color hyperfine interaction, to predict the masses of other bottom baryons which might be observed in the foreseeable future. For S-wave qqb states we predict M(Omega_b) = 6052.1+-5.6 MeV, M(Omega^*_b) = 6082.8+-5.6 MeV, and M(Xi_b^0) = 5786.7 +- 3.0 MeV. For states with one unit of orbital angular momentum between the b quark and the two light quarks we predict M(Lambda_{b[1/2]}) = 5929+-2 MeV, M(Lambda_{b[3/2]}) = 5940+-2 MeV, M(Xi_{b[1/2]}) = 6106+-4 MeV, and M(Xi_{b[3/2]}) = 6115+-4 MeV. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2007; originally announced August 2007.

Comments: LaTeX, 11 pages, no figures

Report number: EFI 07-23, TAUP 2863/07, WIS/14/07-AUG-DPP, ANL-HEP-PR-07-58

Predictions for masses of Xi_b baryons

Authors: Marek Karliner, Boaz Keren-Zur, Harry J. Lipkin, Jonathan L. Rosner

Abstract: The recent observation by CDF of Sigma_b^{+-} (uub and ddb) baryons within 2 MeV of the predicted Sigma_b - Lambda_b splitting has provided strong confirmation for the theoretical approach based on modeling the color hyperfine interaction. We now apply this approach to predict the masses of the Xi_b family of baryons with quark content usb and dsb - the ground state Xi_b at 5790 to 5800 MeV, and… ▽ More The recent observation by CDF of Sigma_b^{+-} (uub and ddb) baryons within 2 MeV of the predicted Sigma_b - Lambda_b splitting has provided strong confirmation for the theoretical approach based on modeling the color hyperfine interaction. We now apply this approach to predict the masses of the Xi_b family of baryons with quark content usb and dsb - the ground state Xi_b at 5790 to 5800 MeV, and the excited states Xi_b^' and Xi_b^*. The main source of uncertainty is the method used to estimate the mass difference m_b - m_c from known hadrons. We verify that corrections due to the details of the interquark potential and to Xi_b-Xi_b^' mixing are small. △ Less

Submitted 23 June, 2007; v1 submitted 14 June, 2007; originally announced June 2007.

Comments: Figure annotation amended

Report number: EFI 07-16, TAUP 2857/07, WIS/09/07-JUNE-DPP, ANL-HEP-PR-07-4

New systematics in charmless strange $B^+ \to VP$ decays

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Latest data on charmless strange vector-pseudoscalar $B^+$ decays now including $B^+\to ρ^+ K^o$ confirm a simple penguin model in which the gluon $G$ in an initial $\bar s u G$ state fragments equally into $u \bar u$, $d \bar d$ and $s \bar s$ and all form factors are equal. A search for possible additional contributions shows only a few signals not obscured by experimental errors whose implica… ▽ More Latest data on charmless strange vector-pseudoscalar $B^+$ decays now including $B^+\to ρ^+ K^o$ confirm a simple penguin model in which the gluon $G$ in an initial $\bar s u G$ state fragments equally into $u \bar u$, $d \bar d$ and $s \bar s$ and all form factors are equal. A search for possible additional contributions shows only a few signals not obscured by experimental errors whose implications are discussed. The experimental value of $0.25 \pm 0.11$ for the ratio of the branching ratios $BR(B^+ \to K^{*+}η)$ to $BR(B^+\to K^{*+}η')$ confirms the parity selection rule prediction 0.32. Large violations arise in a new sum rule for the sum of these branching ratios, analogous to the similar pseudoscalar sum rule including $K^+η$ and $K^+η'$. Indications for either an electroweak penguin contribution or additional admixtures like instrinsic charm in the $η-η'$ system remain to be clarified. An alternative symmetry description with new predictive power clarifies the simple penguin approximation and presents new predictions which can be tested experimentally. The fragmentation of the $\bar s u G$ state into two mesons is described by a strong interaction S-matrix dominated by nonexotic hadron resonances in multiparticle intermediate states. △ Less

Submitted 17 May, 2007; originally announced May 2007.

Comments: 12 pages

Exotic Hadrons in the Constituent Quark Model

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Exotic hadrons are important because their existence or absence can provide important clues to understanding how QCD makes hadrons from quarks and gluons. The first experimentally confirmed exotic will be the first hadron containing both $qq$ and $\bar q q$ pairs and the first hadron containing color sextet and color octet pairs. Theoretical models are not very useful because there is no accepte… ▽ More Exotic hadrons are important because their existence or absence can provide important clues to understanding how QCD makes hadrons from quarks and gluons. The first experimentally confirmed exotic will be the first hadron containing both $qq$ and $\bar q q$ pairs and the first hadron containing color sextet and color octet pairs. Theoretical models are not very useful because there is no accepted model for multiquark systems with color-space correlations. The constituent quark model is the only phenomenological model with predictive power that has given experimentally tested universal predictions for both mesons and baryons. This paper reviews its explanation for why there are no bound exotics and its guidance to the search for heavy-flavored exotic tetraquarks and pentaquarks. A possible supersymmetry between mesons and baryons leading to meson-baryon mass relations not easily obtained otherwise is discussed. △ Less

Submitted 18 March, 2007; originally announced March 2007.

Comments: 8 pages

Report number: WIS/05/07-MARCH-DPP, TAUP 2851/07,ANL-HEP-CP-07-16

Journal ref: Prog.Theor.Phys.Suppl.168:15-22,2007

From Sakata Model to Goldberg-Ne'eman Quarks and Nambu QCD Phenomenology and "Right" and "Wrong" experiments

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: The basic theoretical milestones were the Sakata SU(3) symmetry, the Goldberg-Ne'eman composite model with SU(3) triplets having baryon number (1/3) and the Nambu color gauge Lagrangian. The transition was led in right and wrong directions by experiments interpreted by phenomenology. A "good" experiment on $\bar p p$ annihilation at rest showed that the Sakata model predictions disagreed with ex… ▽ More The basic theoretical milestones were the Sakata SU(3) symmetry, the Goldberg-Ne'eman composite model with SU(3) triplets having baryon number (1/3) and the Nambu color gauge Lagrangian. The transition was led in right and wrong directions by experiments interpreted by phenomenology. A "good" experiment on $\bar p p$ annihilation at rest showed that the Sakata model predictions disagreed with experiment. A "bad" experiment prevented the use of the Goldberg-Ne'eman triplet model to predict the existence and masses of the of the $Ξ^*$ and $Ω^-$. More "good" experiments revealed the existence and mass of the $Ξ^*$ and the $Ω^-$ and the absence of positive strangeness baryon resonances, thus confirming the "tenfold way". Further "good experiments" revealed the existence of the vector meson nonet, SU(3) breaking with singlet-octet mixing and the suppression of the $φ\to ρπ$ decay. These led to the quark triplet model. The paradox of peculiar statistics then arose as the $Δ^{++}$ and $Ω^-$ contained three identical spin-1/2 fermions coupled symmetrically to spin (3/2). This led to color and the Nambu QCD. The book "Lie Groups for Pedestrians" used the Sakata model with the name "sakaton" for the $pnΛ$ triplet to teach the algebra of SU(3) to particle physicists in the U.S. and Europe who knew no group theory. The Sakata model had a renaissance in hypernuclear physics in the 1970's. △ Less

Submitted 31 January, 2007; v1 submitted 4 January, 2007; originally announced January 2007.

Comments: 8 pages

Journal ref: Prog.Theor.Phys.Suppl.167:155-162,2007

The New Sigma_b multiplet, heavy baryon mass predictions, meson-baryon universality and magnetic moments of Lambda_c and Lambda_b

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: The recent measurement by CDF M(Sigma_b)-M(Lambda_b)=192 MeV is in striking agreement with our theoretical prediction M(Sigma_b)-M(Lambda_b) = 194 MeV. In addition, the measured splitting M(Sigma_b*)-M(Sigma_b) = 21 MeV agrees well with the predicted splitting of 22 MeV. We point out the connection between these predictions and an effective supersymmetry between mesons and baryons related by rep… ▽ More The recent measurement by CDF M(Sigma_b)-M(Lambda_b)=192 MeV is in striking agreement with our theoretical prediction M(Sigma_b)-M(Lambda_b) = 194 MeV. In addition, the measured splitting M(Sigma_b*)-M(Sigma_b) = 21 MeV agrees well with the predicted splitting of 22 MeV. We point out the connection between these predictions and an effective supersymmetry between mesons and baryons related by replacing a light antiquark by a light diquark. We discuss the theoretical framework behind these predictions and use it to provide additional predictions for the masses of spin-1/2 and spin-3/2 baryons containing heavy quarks, as well as magnetic moments of Lambda_b and Lambda_c. △ Less

Submitted 3 September, 2007; v1 submitted 24 November, 2006; originally announced November 2006.

Comments: Updated section on doubly strange diquarks

Report number: TAUP 2841/06, WIS/17/06-NOV-DPP, ANL-HEP-PR-06-86

Journal ref: Phys.Lett.B660:539-544,2008

CP violation difference in $B^o$ and $B^\pm$ decays explained No tree-penguin interference in $B^+ \to K^+π^o$

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: A new experimental analysis of $B\to Kπ$ decays provides finite experimental values for the contributions from interference terms between the dominant penguin amplitude and the color-favored and color-suppressed tree amplitudes. These results can explain the puzzling failure to see CP violation in $B^\pm\to Kπ$ decays. Tree-penguin interference contributions are commonly believed to be the sourc… ▽ More A new experimental analysis of $B\to Kπ$ decays provides finite experimental values for the contributions from interference terms between the dominant penguin amplitude and the color-favored and color-suppressed tree amplitudes. These results can explain the puzzling failure to see CP violation in $B^\pm\to Kπ$ decays. Tree-penguin interference contributions are commonly believed to be the source of the observed direct CP violation in $B^o\to K^\pmπ^\mp$ decays. The data show that the color-favored and color-suppressed tree contributions interfere destructively in $B^\pm\to K^\pmπ^o$ decays and nearly cancel. This suprising cancellation is not predicted by present theory. There is also no prediction for any difference produced by changing the flavor of the spectator quark. Isospin and Pauli effects that change with spectator quark flavor are examined and show using group theory and the color-spun SU(6) algebra how they produce both the near cancellation and the dependence on spectator quark flavor. The standard $B\to Kπ$ analysis which treats tree-penguin interference only in first order has three parameters overdetermined by four experimental branching ratios. Previous analyses confirmed the model but with large errors leaving the values of tree-penguin interference contributions less that two standard deviations from zero. The new analysis finds interference contributions well above the errors. △ Less

Submitted 25 September, 2006; v1 submitted 25 August, 2006; originally announced August 2006.

Comments: 10 pages

Report number: WIS/14/06-SEPT-DPP,TAUP 2834/06,ANL-HEP-PR-06-63

New Quark Relations for Hadron Masses and Magnetic Moments - A Challenge for Explanation from QCD

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Prompted by the recent surprising results in QCD spectroscopy, we extend the treatment of the constituent quark model showing that mass differences and ratios have the same values when obtained from mesons and baryons. We obtain several new successful relations involving hadrons containing two and three strange quarks and hadrons containing heavy quarks and give a new prediction regarding spin s… ▽ More Prompted by the recent surprising results in QCD spectroscopy, we extend the treatment of the constituent quark model showing that mass differences and ratios have the same values when obtained from mesons and baryons. We obtain several new successful relations involving hadrons containing two and three strange quarks and hadrons containing heavy quarks and give a new prediction regarding spin splitting between doubly charmed baryons. We provide numerical evidence for an effective supersymmetry between mesons and baryons related by replacing a light antiquark by a light diquark. We also obtain new relations between quark magnetic moments and hadron masses. Limits of validity of this approach and disagreements with experiment in properties of the Sigma and Xi baryons are discussed as possible clues to a derivation from QCD. △ Less

Submitted 4 May, 2007; v1 submitted 1 August, 2006; originally announced August 2006.

Comments: Presentation improved, references added, typos corrected

Report number: TAUP 2829/06, WIS/07/06-JULY-DPP, ANL-HEP-PR-06-56

Journal ref: Phys.Lett.B650:185-192,2007

A tetraquark model for the new X(1576) K+ K- resonance

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: We discuss the likely tetraquark interpretation of the X(1576) K+ K- isovector resonance recently reported by BES with J^{PC}=1^{--}. We point out that if this interpretation as a four-quark state is correct, the (s u sbar dbar) tetraquark decays might have striking signatures. We also provide predictions for possible analogous tetraquarks involving heavy quarks - (c q cbar qbar) and (b q bbar q… ▽ More We discuss the likely tetraquark interpretation of the X(1576) K+ K- isovector resonance recently reported by BES with J^{PC}=1^{--}. We point out that if this interpretation as a four-quark state is correct, the (s u sbar dbar) tetraquark decays might have striking signatures. We also provide predictions for possible analogous tetraquarks involving heavy quarks - (c q cbar qbar) and (b q bbar qbar). △ Less

Submitted 13 July, 2006; v1 submitted 9 July, 2006; originally announced July 2006.

Comments: Removed some forbidden decay channels which were discussed in first version

Report number: TAUP 2827/06, WIS/06/06-JULY-DPP, ANL-HEP-PR-06-52

Diquarks and antiquarks in exotics: a menage a trois and a menage a quatre

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: A menage a trois is very different from an ordinary family. Similarly, exotic hadrons with both qq and qbar q pairs have important color-space correlations that are completely absent in ordinary mesons and baryons. The presence of both types of pairs requires attention to the basic QCD physics that the q qbar interaction is much stronger than the qq interaction. This new physics in multiquark sy… ▽ More A menage a trois is very different from an ordinary family. Similarly, exotic hadrons with both qq and qbar q pairs have important color-space correlations that are completely absent in ordinary mesons and baryons. The presence of both types of pairs requires attention to the basic QCD physics that the q qbar interaction is much stronger than the qq interaction. This new physics in multiquark systems produces color structures totally different from those of normal hadrons, for example the ud system is utterly unlike the ud diquark in the uds Lambda baryon. The color-space correlations produce unusual experimental properties in tetraquarks with heavy quark pairs which may be relevant for newly discovered mesons like the X(3872) resonance. Tetraquark masses can be below the two-meson threshold for sufficiently high quark masses. A simple model calculation shows the b q bbar ubar and b q cbar qbar tetraquarks below the B Bbar and B Dbar thresholds. Some of these states have exotic electric charge and their decays might have striking signatures involving monoenergetic photons and/or pions. △ Less

Submitted 17 May, 2006; v1 submitted 23 January, 2006; originally announced January 2006.

Comments: Journal version (PLB)

Report number: TAUP 2817-05, WIS/01/06-JAN-DPP, ANL-HEP-PR-06-4

Journal ref: Phys.Lett.B638:221-228,2006

Analysis of new charmless strange B decay data leaves high $B\to Kη'$ and $B\to Kη' X$ still unexplained

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: The question of whether the anomalously large $B \to Kη' $ and $B \to Kη' X $ (inclusive) branching ratios are consistent with the standard model or a sign of new physics is still open and in the experimental court. The nature of the extra hadron $X$ in $B \to Kη' X $ is completely unknown. Directions for investigation and analysis of inclusive data are suggested as well as for comparable inclus… ▽ More The question of whether the anomalously large $B \to Kη' $ and $B \to Kη' X $ (inclusive) branching ratios are consistent with the standard model or a sign of new physics is still open and in the experimental court. The nature of the extra hadron $X$ in $B \to Kη' X $ is completely unknown. Directions for investigation and analysis of inclusive data are suggested as well as for comparable inclusive data on $B \to KηX $. New data confirming the prediction $BR(K^\pm ρ^o) = BR(K^\pm ω)$ support flavor-topology $B \to VP$ sum rules based on the OZI rule and emphasize the sharp contrast with the failure of the analogous $B \to PP $ sum rule due to the anomalously large $BR(B \to Kη')$. Confirmation of OZI validity in B-decay analyses for VP final states suggests improving data on the analogous neutral decay difference $BR(B^o \to K^o ρ^o) - BR(B^o \to K^o ω)$ which measures tree-penguin interference and possible direct CP violation. A successful approximate isospin sum rule is rearranged and reinterpreted to pinpoint tree-penguin interference in $B \to K π$ and $B \to K ρ$ transitions. The magnitude of the interference is shown to still be at the statistical noise level with present data. △ Less

Submitted 14 December, 2005; v1 submitted 19 July, 2005; originally announced July 2005.

Comments: 11 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: Phys.Lett.B633:540-544,2006

Isospin Analysis of pentaquark production forbids gamma p --> Theta^+ K_s and allows gamma n --> Theta^+ K^-

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: The discrepancy between Theta^+ photoproduction on proton vs. deuteron can be resolved if the photon couples much more strongly to K^+K^- than to K0 K0bar as indicated by the experimentally observed asymmetry between gamma p --> Lambda(1520) K^+ and gamma n --> Lambda(1520) K_s. Significant signal-background interference effects can occur in experiments like gamma N --> Kbar Theta^+ which search… ▽ More The discrepancy between Theta^+ photoproduction on proton vs. deuteron can be resolved if the photon couples much more strongly to K^+K^- than to K0 K0bar as indicated by the experimentally observed asymmetry between gamma p --> Lambda(1520) K^+ and gamma n --> Lambda(1520) K_s. Significant signal-background interference effects can occur in experiments like gamma N --> Kbar Theta^+ which search for the Theta^+ as a narrow I=0 resonance in a definite final state against a nonresonant background, with an experimental resolution coarser than the expected resonance width. We show that when the signal and background have roughly the same magnitude, destructive interference can easily combine with a limited experimental resolution to completely destroy the resonance signal. Whether or not this actually occurs depends critically on the yet unknown relative phase of the I=0 and I=1 amplitudes. We discuss the implications for some specific experiments. △ Less

Submitted 16 June, 2005; v1 submitted 8 June, 2005; originally announced June 2005.

Comments: New version. Uses experimentally observed strong p/n asymmetry in gamma N --> Lambda(1520) K to explain n/p asymmetry in gamma N --> Theta^+ K and absence of gamma p --> Theta^+ K_s. Added microscopic derivation of selection rule and unitarity argument that solves the K* problem. References added and typos corrected

Report number: Cavendish-HEP-05/09, TAUP 2807/05, ANL-HEP-PR-05-47

Quantum Theory of Neutrino Oscillations for Pedestrians - Simple Answers to Confusing Questions

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Why are different mass states coherent? What is the correct formula for the oscillation phase? How can textbook formulas for oscillations in time describe experiments which never measure time? How can we treat the different velocities and different transit times of different mass eigenstates and avoid incorrect factors of two? How can textbook forumulas which describe coherence between energy st… ▽ More Why are different mass states coherent? What is the correct formula for the oscillation phase? How can textbook formulas for oscillations in time describe experiments which never measure time? How can we treat the different velocities and different transit times of different mass eigenstates and avoid incorrect factors of two? How can textbook forumulas which describe coherence between energy states be justified when Stodolsky's theorem states there is no coherence between different energies? Is covariant relativistic quantum field theory necessary to describe neutrino oscillations? How important is the detector, which is at rest in the laboratory and cannot be Lorentz tranformed to other frames? These questions are answered by a simple rigorous calculation which includes the quantum fluctuations in the position of the detector and in the transit time between source and detector. The commonly used standard formula for neutrino oscillation phases is confirmed. An "ideal" detector which measures precisely the energy and momentum of the neutrino destroys all phases in the initial wave packet and cannot observe oscillations. A realistic detector preserves the phase differences between neutrinos having the same energy and different momenta and confirms the standard formula. Whether phase differences between neutrinos with different energies are observable or destroyed by the detector is irrelevant. △ Less

Submitted 28 September, 2006; v1 submitted 16 May, 2005; originally announced May 2005.

Comments: 10 pages, Introduction expanded to explain sources of confusion in detail

Report number: WIS/11/05-May-DPP,TAUP 2804-05,ANL-HEP-PR-05-30

Journal ref: Phys.Lett.B642:366-371,2006

Is observed direct CP violation in $B_d \to K^+ π^-$ due to new physics? Check standard model prediction of equal violation in $B_s \to K^- π^+$

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: The recently observed direct CP violation in $B_d \to K^+ π^-$ has raised suggestions of possible new physics. A robust test of the standard model vs. new physics is its prediction of equal direct CP violation in $B_s \to K^- π^+$ decay. CPT invariance requires the observed CP violation to arise from the interference between the dominant penguin amplitude and another amplitude with a different w… ▽ More The recently observed direct CP violation in $B_d \to K^+ π^-$ has raised suggestions of possible new physics. A robust test of the standard model vs. new physics is its prediction of equal direct CP violation in $B_s \to K^- π^+$ decay. CPT invariance requires the observed CP violation to arise from the interference between the dominant penguin amplitude and another amplitude with a different weak phase and a different strong phase. The penguin contribution to $B_d \to K^+ π^-$ is known to be reduced by a CKM factor in $B_s \to K^- π^+$. Thus the two branching ratios are very different and a different CP violation is expected. But in the standard model a miracle occurs and the interfering tree diagram is enhanced by the same CKM factor that reduces the penguin to give the predicted equality. This miracle is not expected in new physics; thus a search for and measurement of the predicted CP violation in $B_s \to K^- π^+$ decay is a sensitive test for a new physics contribution. A detailed analysis shows this prediction to be robust and insensitive to symmetry breaking effects and possible additional contributions. △ Less

Submitted 19 April, 2005; v1 submitted 2 March, 2005; originally announced March 2005.

Comments: 9 pages

Report number: WIS/06/05-FEB-DPP, TAUP 2798-05, ANL-HEP-PR-05-11

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. B621 (2005) 126-132

Why pentaquarks are seen in some experiments and not in others

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: The $Θ^+$ Pentaquark is a Very narrow $Γ\approx 1$ MeV KN Resonance. Why do some experiments see it and others do not? The lowest quark configuration that can describe it is exotic $uudd \bar s$. Why have no exotics been seen before? Is this the beginning of a new spectroscopy? Can it help toteach us about How QCD makes hadrons from quarks and gluons? The $Θ^+$ Pentaquark is a Very narrow $Γ\approx 1$ MeV KN Resonance. Why do some experiments see it and others do not? The lowest quark configuration that can describe it is exotic $uudd \bar s$. Why have no exotics been seen before? Is this the beginning of a new spectroscopy? Can it help toteach us about How QCD makes hadrons from quarks and gluons? △ Less

Submitted 23 January, 2005; originally announced January 2005.

Comments: 4 pages

Report number: TAUP 2785-04; ANL-HEP-CP-04-102

New tests for experiments producing pentaquarks

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: The distribution of the squared momentum difference |P_A|^2 - |P_B|^2 between the momenta in the laboratory system of two experimentally observed particles A and B provides a test for whether an observed mass peak indicates a real resonance rather than nonresonant background or kinematic reflection. The angular distribution of the relative momenta in the center-of-mass system exhibits a forward-… ▽ More The distribution of the squared momentum difference |P_A|^2 - |P_B|^2 between the momenta in the laboratory system of two experimentally observed particles A and B provides a test for whether an observed mass peak indicates a real resonance rather than nonresonant background or kinematic reflection. The angular distribution of the relative momenta in the center-of-mass system exhibits a forward-backward symmetry in the production and decay of any resonance with a definite parity. This symmetry is not expected in other nonresonant processes and can be expressed without needing angular distributions in terms of the easily measured momenta in the laboratory frame that are already measured and used to calculate the invariant mass of the system. Our test is especially useful for low statistics experiments where the full angular distribution cannot be determined. It can be applied to both fixed-target and collider searches for the Theta^+ and Theta_c pentaquarks. △ Less

Submitted 24 January, 2005; v1 submitted 20 January, 2005; originally announced January 2005.

Comments: Following readers' comments, stressing applicability to both fixed target and collider exps, in both Theta^+ and Theta_c searches, especially with low stats; reflected also in title change

Report number: Cavendish-HEP-05/04, TAUP 2794-05, WIS/1/05-JAN-DPP, ANL-HEP-PR-05-5

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. B616 (2005) 191-195

On a possible tetraquark cousin of the Theta^+

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: If a narrow Theta^+ pentaquark exists, it is likely that a ud\bar s-ud triquark-diquark configuration is a significant component of its wave function. If so, the mechanism responsible for the binding of a triquark and a diquark is also likely to bind the triquark to an \bar s antiquark. We discuss the expected properties of such a ud\bar s-\bar s tetraquark meson. In particular, we point out tha… ▽ More If a narrow Theta^+ pentaquark exists, it is likely that a ud\bar s-ud triquark-diquark configuration is a significant component of its wave function. If so, the mechanism responsible for the binding of a triquark and a diquark is also likely to bind the triquark to an \bar s antiquark. We discuss the expected properties of such a ud\bar s-\bar s tetraquark meson. In particular, we point out that for a 0^+ isoscalar ud\bar s\bar s meson the lowest allowed decay mode is a four-body K K pi pi channel with a small phase space and a distinctive experimental signature. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2005; v1 submitted 9 November, 2004; originally announced November 2004.

Comments: Expanded discussion of allowed and forbidden decay modes

Report number: Cavendish-HEP-04/30, TAUP 2788-04, WIS/25/04-SEPT-DPP, ANL-HEP-PR-04-113

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. B612 (2005) 197-200

History and new ideas for exotic particles

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Basic 1966 physics of Sakharov, Zeldovich and Nambu updated by QCD with constituent-quark quasiparticles having effective masses fits all masses and magnetic moments of ground state meson and baryons having no more than one strange or heavy quark Flavor antisymmetry explains absence of low-lying exotics and suggests diquark-triquark model and two-state model for $Θ^+$ pentaquark. Variational app… ▽ More Basic 1966 physics of Sakharov, Zeldovich and Nambu updated by QCD with constituent-quark quasiparticles having effective masses fits all masses and magnetic moments of ground state meson and baryons having no more than one strange or heavy quark Flavor antisymmetry explains absence of low-lying exotics and suggests diquark-triquark model and two-state model for $Θ^+$ pentaquark. Variational approach gives mass bounds for other pentaquarks. △ Less

Submitted 14 October, 2004; originally announced October 2004.

Comments: 15 pages, PNTA04 Conference at SPring-8, Japan

Report number: ANL-HEP-CP-04-103

The theory of pentaquarks

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Is there a theory or good experimental evidence? Bj's question: Pentaquark is created by $e^+e^-$. $2q + q \to$ Baryon $; ~ ~ ~ 2q + \bar q \to $ Triquark$ ; ~ ~ ~ 2q + $Triquark $ \to $Pentaquark Does it live long onough to be observable? Basic physics of constituent quarks and flavor antisymmetry. Report of $Θ^+$ violating flavor antisymmetry indicates need for two-cluster model.. Ball in Ex… ▽ More Is there a theory or good experimental evidence? Bj's question: Pentaquark is created by $e^+e^-$. $2q + q \to$ Baryon $; ~ ~ ~ 2q + \bar q \to $ Triquark$ ; ~ ~ ~ 2q + $Triquark $ \to $Pentaquark Does it live long onough to be observable? Basic physics of constituent quarks and flavor antisymmetry. Report of $Θ^+$ violating flavor antisymmetry indicates need for two-cluster model.. Ball in Experimental Court - Some experiments see $Θ^+$; others don't. Possible production mechanisms present in some experiments, absent in others; e.g. via $N^*(2.3 \rm{GeV}) \to Θ^+ + \bar K$? △ Less

Submitted 29 September, 2004; originally announced September 2004.

Comments: 10 pages

Report number: ANL-HEP-CP-04-81

Journal ref: Frascati Phys.Ser. 35 (2004) 177-186

Why the Theta+ is seen in some experiments and not in others - a possible explanation

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: The contradiction between evidence for and against the existence of the Theta+ pentaquark might be resolved if it only appears as a result of a particular production mechanism which is present in some experiments and absent in others. We examine the implications of Theta+ production via decay of a cryptoexotic N* resonance with a mass of about 2.4 GeV corresponding to a peak in the experimental… ▽ More The contradiction between evidence for and against the existence of the Theta+ pentaquark might be resolved if it only appears as a result of a particular production mechanism which is present in some experiments and absent in others. We examine the implications of Theta+ production via decay of a cryptoexotic N* resonance with a mass of about 2.4 GeV corresponding to a peak in the experimental data for the invariant mass of the (Theta+,K-) system. Further experimental checks are suggested. △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2004; v1 submitted 3 May, 2004; originally announced May 2004.

Comments: An experimental reference added. 8 pages, LaTeX, no figures

Report number: Cavendish-HEP-04/15, TAUP 2769-4, WIS/11/04-May-DPP, ANL-HEP-PR-04-45

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. B597 (2004) 309-313

A Diquark-Triquark Model for the KN Pentaquark

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: We propose a model for the recently discovered Theta^+ exotic KN resonance as a novel kind of a pentaquark with an unusual color structure: a color triplet (ud) diquark, coupled to a color anti-triplet (ud s-bar) triquark in a relative P-wave. The state has J^P=1/2^+, I=0 and is an antidecuplet of SU(3)_f. A rough mass estimate of this pentaquark is close to experiment. We propose a model for the recently discovered Theta^+ exotic KN resonance as a novel kind of a pentaquark with an unusual color structure: a color triplet (ud) diquark, coupled to a color anti-triplet (ud s-bar) triquark in a relative P-wave. The state has J^P=1/2^+, I=0 and is an antidecuplet of SU(3)_f. A rough mass estimate of this pentaquark is close to experiment. △ Less

Submitted 24 February, 2004; originally announced February 2004.

Comments: A condensed and amended version of hep-ph/0307243, as published in PLB, to include pentaquark analysis only, with a revised title and some additional discussion of the Xi states in the 10-bar

Journal ref: Phys.Lett.B575:249-255,2003

A Mass Inequality for the $Ξ^*$ and $Θ^+$ Pentaquarks

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry. J. Lipkin

Abstract: We derive an upper bound on the mass difference between the $Ξ^*$ and $Θ^+$ pentaquarks which are the manifestly exotic members of the $SU(3)_f$ antidecuplet. The derivation is based on simple assumptions about $SU(3)_f$ symmetry breaking and uses the standard quantum mechanical variational method. The resulting rather robust bound is more than 20 MeV below the experimentally reported $Ξ^*-Θ^+$… ▽ More We derive an upper bound on the mass difference between the $Ξ^*$ and $Θ^+$ pentaquarks which are the manifestly exotic members of the $SU(3)_f$ antidecuplet. The derivation is based on simple assumptions about $SU(3)_f$ symmetry breaking and uses the standard quantum mechanical variational method. The resulting rather robust bound is more than 20 MeV below the experimentally reported $Ξ^*-Θ^+$ mass difference, emphasizing the need for confirmation of the experimental mass values and placing strong constraints on quark models of the pentaquark structure. △ Less

Submitted 22 April, 2004; v1 submitted 31 January, 2004; originally announced February 2004.

Comments: revtex, 5 pages, no figures; added discussion of spin-orbit effects and recent experimental references

Report number: Cavendish-HEP-04/08, TAUP 2763-04, WIS/04/04-JAN-DPP, ANL-HEP-PR-04-5

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. B594 (2004) 273-276

The narrow width of the Θ^+ - a possible explanation

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: The narrow width of the exotic narrow baryon resonance $Θ^+$ might be explained by mixing between the two nearly degenerate states that arise in models with two diquarks and an antiquark. The only open $Θ^+$ decay channel is $KN$. When two states both coupled to a single dominant decay mode are mixed by the loop diagram via this decay mode, diagonalization of the loop diagram decouples one mass… ▽ More The narrow width of the exotic narrow baryon resonance $Θ^+$ might be explained by mixing between the two nearly degenerate states that arise in models with two diquarks and an antiquark. The only open $Θ^+$ decay channel is $KN$. When two states both coupled to a single dominant decay mode are mixed by the loop diagram via this decay mode, diagonalization of the loop diagram decouples one mass eigenstate from this decay mode as in some treatments of the $ρ-π$ decay from the mixed singlet-octet $ω-φ$ system, the $K^* -π$ decay of the strange axial vector mesons and the $NK$ couplings of some baryons. This mechanism can explain the narrow width and weak coupling of $Θ^+ \to KN$ while allowing a relatively large production cross section from $K^*$ exchange. Interesting tests are suggested in $K^-p$ reactions where backward kaon production must go by exotic baryon exchange. △ Less

Submitted 23 January, 2004; v1 submitted 11 January, 2004; originally announced January 2004.

Comments: 6 pages, 1 figure, RevTeX; refs added

Report number: Cavendish-HEP-04/03, TAUP 2759-04, WIS/03/04-JAN-DPP, ANL-HEP-PR-04-02

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. B586 (2004) 303-306

Quantum Mechanics of Neutrino Detectors Determine Coherence and Phases in Oscillation Experiments

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: The apparent symmetry between energy and momentum found in all covariant descriptions of neutrino oscillations is destroyed in the neutrino detector, a quantum mechanical system described by a density matrix diagonal in energy but not in momentum. The off diagonal matrix elements between states of different momenta and the same energy produce the coherence and interference between mass eigenstat… ▽ More The apparent symmetry between energy and momentum found in all covariant descriptions of neutrino oscillations is destroyed in the neutrino detector, a quantum mechanical system described by a density matrix diagonal in energy but not in momentum. The off diagonal matrix elements between states of different momenta and the same energy produce the coherence and interference between mass eigenstates having the same energy and different momenta that produce oscillations. △ Less

Submitted 20 December, 2003; originally announced December 2003.

Comments: 4 pages

Nonleptonic $Λ_b$ decays to $D_s(2317)$, $D_s(2460)$ and other final states in Factorization

Authors: Alakabha Datta, Harry J. Lipkin, Patrick J O'Donnell

Abstract: We consider nonleptonic Cabibbo--allowed $Λ_b$ decays in the factorization approximation. We calculate nonleptonic decays of the type $ Λ_b \to Λ_c P $ and $ Λ_b \to Λ_c V $ relative to $\bar{B}_d \to D^+ P$ and $\bar{B}_d \to D^+ V$ where we include among the pseudoscalar states(P) and the vector states(V) the newly discovered $D_s$ resonances, $D_s(2317)$ and $D_s(2460)$. In the ratio of… ▽ More We consider nonleptonic Cabibbo--allowed $Λ_b$ decays in the factorization approximation. We calculate nonleptonic decays of the type $ Λ_b \to Λ_c P $ and $ Λ_b \to Λ_c V $ relative to $\bar{B}_d \to D^+ P$ and $\bar{B}_d \to D^+ V$ where we include among the pseudoscalar states(P) and the vector states(V) the newly discovered $D_s$ resonances, $D_s(2317)$ and $D_s(2460)$. In the ratio of $Λ_b$ decays to $D_s(2317)$ and $D_s(2460)$ relative to the $\bar{B}_d$ decays to these states, the poorly known decay constants of $D_s(2317)$ and $D_s(2460)$ cancel leading to predictions that can shed light on the nature of these new states. In general, we predict the $Λ_b$ decays to be larger than the corresponding $\bar{B}_d$ decays and in particular we find the branching ratio for $Λ_b \to Λ_c D_s(2460)$ can be between four to five times the branching ratio for $\bar{B}_d \to D^+ D_s(2460)$. This enhancement of $Λ_b$ branching ratios follows primarily from the fact that more partial waves contribute in $Λ_b$ decays than in $\bar{B}_d$ decays. Our predictions are largely independent of model calculations of hadronic inputs like form factors and decay constants. △ Less

Submitted 11 December, 2003; originally announced December 2003.

Comments: 16 pages LaTeX

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D69:094002,2004

The anticharmed exotic baryon Theta_c and its relatives

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Motivated by the recent discovery of the exotic S=+1 narrow baryon resonance Theta^+ at 1540 MeV, with quark content {uudd sbar}, we conjecture the existence of its anti-charmed analogue Theta_c, with quark content {uudd cbar}, and compute its likely properties. We rely on the recently constructed model of a novel kind of a pentaquark with an unusual color structure which provides a good approxi… ▽ More Motivated by the recent discovery of the exotic S=+1 narrow baryon resonance Theta^+ at 1540 MeV, with quark content {uudd sbar}, we conjecture the existence of its anti-charmed analogue Theta_c, with quark content {uudd cbar}, and compute its likely properties. We rely on the recently constructed model of a novel kind of a pentaquark with an unusual color structure which provides a good approximation to the Theta^+ mass. We expect that Theta_c is an isosinglet with J^P=1/2^+ and estimate its mass at 2985 \pm 50 MeV. We also discuss another possible exotic baryon resonance containing heavy quarks, the Theta_b^+, a {uudd bbar} state, and estimate m_{Theta_b^+}=6398 \pm 50 MeV. These states should appear as unexpectedly narrow peaks in D^-p, Dbar^0 n, B^0 p and B^+ n mass distributions. △ Less

Submitted 10 August, 2003; v1 submitted 28 July, 2003; originally announced July 2003.

Comments: LaTeX, 12 pages, no figures; typo corrected

Report number: TAUP-2744-03, WIS/21/03-JULY-DPP

The Constituent Quark Model Revisited - Quark Masses, New Predictions for Hadron Masses and KN Pentaquark

Authors: Marek Karliner, Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Prompted by the recent surprising results in QCD spectroscopy, we extend to heavy flavors the hadron mass relations showing that the constituent quark mass differences and ratios have the same values when obtained from mesons and baryons. We obtain several new successful relations involving heavy quarks and provide some related predictions. We discuss in detail the apparent sharp decrease in m_s… ▽ More Prompted by the recent surprising results in QCD spectroscopy, we extend to heavy flavors the hadron mass relations showing that the constituent quark mass differences and ratios have the same values when obtained from mesons and baryons. We obtain several new successful relations involving heavy quarks and provide some related predictions. We discuss in detail the apparent sharp decrease in m_s and m_c, when a light partner quark in a meson is replaced by a heavy one and construct a potential model which qualitatively reproduces this pattern through wave function effects. We apply these ideas to the recently discovered theta^+ exotic KN resonance and propose its interpretation as a novel kind of a pentaquark with an unusual color structure, J^P=1/2^+, I=0 and an antidecuplet of SU(3)_f. A rough mass estimate of this pentaquark is close to experiment. △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2003; v1 submitted 18 July, 2003; originally announced July 2003.

Comments: LaTeX, 25 pages, no figures, typos corrected

Report number: TAUP 2735-03

New Predictions for Multiquark Hadron Masses

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: The recent reported charmed-strange resonance at 2.32 GeV/c suggests a possible multiquark state. Three types of multiquark bound states are reviewed. A previous model-independent variational approach considers a tetraquark with two heavy antiquarks and two light quarks as a heavy antidiquark with the color field of a quark bound to the two light quarks with a wave function like that of a heavy… ▽ More The recent reported charmed-strange resonance at 2.32 GeV/c suggests a possible multiquark state. Three types of multiquark bound states are reviewed. A previous model-independent variational approach considers a tetraquark with two heavy antiquarks and two light quarks as a heavy antidiquark with the color field of a quark bound to the two light quarks with a wave function like that of a heavy baryon. Results indicate that a charmed-strange tetraquark $\bar c \bar s u d$ or a bottom-strange tetraquark $\bar b \bar s u d$ with this "diquark-heavy-baryion" wave function is not bound, in contrast to "molecular-type" $D-K$ and $B-K$ wave functions. However, a charmed-bottom tetraquark $\bar c \bar b u d$ might be bound with a very narrow weak decay mode. A "molecular-type" $D-B$ state can have an interesting $B_c π$ decay with a high energy pion, △ Less

Submitted 22 June, 2003; originally announced June 2003.

Comments: 8 pages

Journal ref: Phys.Lett.B580:50-53,2004

Implications of a DK Molecule at 2.32 GeV

Authors: T. Barnes, F. E. Close, H. J. Lipkin

Abstract: We discuss the implications of a possible quasinuclear DK bound state at 2.32 GeV. Evidence for such a state was recently reported in D_s^+pi^o by the BaBar Collaboration. We first note that a conventional quark model c-sbar assignment is implausible, and then consider other options involving multiquark systems. An I=0 c sbar n nbar baryonium assignment is one possibility. We instead favor a DK… ▽ More We discuss the implications of a possible quasinuclear DK bound state at 2.32 GeV. Evidence for such a state was recently reported in D_s^+pi^o by the BaBar Collaboration. We first note that a conventional quark model c-sbar assignment is implausible, and then consider other options involving multiquark systems. An I=0 c sbar n nbar baryonium assignment is one possibility. We instead favor a DK meson molecule assignment, which can account for the mass and quantum numbers of this state. The higher-mass scalar c-sbar state expected at 2.48 GeV is predicted to have a very large DK coupling, which would encourage formation of an I=0 DK molecule. Isospin mixing is expected in hadron molecules, and a dominantly I=0 DK state with some I=1 admixture could explain both the narrow total width of the 2.32 GeV state as well as the observed decay to D_s^+ pi^o. Additional measurements that can be used to test this and related scenarios are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 2 May, 2003; originally announced May 2003.

Comments: 6 pages, 1 figure

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D68:054006,2003

What is coherent in neutrino oscillations

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Simple rigorous quantum mechanics with no hand waving nor loopholes clarifies the confusion between three contradictory descriptions of neutrino oscillations: (1)The time oscillations shown in standard textbooks produced by neutrino eigenstates with different masses and different energies. (2) That time oscillations and interference between states having different energies cannot be observed in… ▽ More Simple rigorous quantum mechanics with no hand waving nor loopholes clarifies the confusion between three contradictory descriptions of neutrino oscillations: (1)The time oscillations shown in standard textbooks produced by neutrino eigenstates with different masses and different energies. (2) That time oscillations and interference between states having different energies cannot be observed in realistic experiments. (3) That interference between different neutrino mass eigenstates is not observable in "missing mass" experiments where information determining the neutrino mass is available from other particles measured in production or detection vertices. Quantum-mechanical ignorance of the neutrino momentum is rigorously shown to be imposed by all realistic detectors and to produce coherence between amplitudes from neutrino states with the same energy and different masses. Conditions are precisely formulated for the loss of coherence when mass eigenstate wave packets moving with different velocities separate. The example of Bragg scattering shows how quantum-mechanically imposed ignorance produces coherence. △ Less

Submitted 14 October, 2003; v1 submitted 20 April, 2003; originally announced April 2003.

Comments: 13 pages, Abstract and text of original contribution completely revised

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. B579 (2004) 355-360

Experimental Challenges for QCD - The past and the future

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: The past leaves the surprising experimental successes of the simple constituent quark model to be expained by QCD. Surprising agreement with experiment from simple Sakharov-Zeldovich model (1966) having quarks with effective masses and hyperfine interaction. Nambu's (1966) Colored quarks with gauge gluons gave mass spectrum with only $qqq$ and $\bar q$ bound states. The future opens the way to n… ▽ More The past leaves the surprising experimental successes of the simple constituent quark model to be expained by QCD. Surprising agreement with experiment from simple Sakharov-Zeldovich model (1966) having quarks with effective masses and hyperfine interaction. Nambu's (1966) Colored quarks with gauge gluons gave mass spectrum with only $qqq$ and $\bar q$ bound states. The future opens the way to new insight into QCD from heavy flavor experiments △ Less

Submitted 2 January, 2003; v1 submitted 31 December, 2002; originally announced December 2002.

Comments: 19 pages, typo in e-mail address corrected

Stodolsky's Theorem and Neutrino Oscillation Phases -- for pedestrians

Authors: Harry J. Lipkin

Abstract: Neutrino oscillations are experimentally observable only as a result of interference between neutrino states with different masses and THE SAME ENERGY. All interference effects between neutrino states having different energies are destroyed by the intereaction between the incident neutrino and the neutrino detector. Erroneous results are frequently obtained by neglecting the neutrino-detector in… ▽ More Neutrino oscillations are experimentally observable only as a result of interference between neutrino states with different masses and THE SAME ENERGY. All interference effects between neutrino states having different energies are destroyed by the intereaction between the incident neutrino and the neutrino detector. Erroneous results are frequently obtained by neglecting the neutrino-detector interactions. △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 2003; v1 submitted 5 December, 2002; originally announced December 2002.

Comments: 6 pages, Two paragraphs of discussion on possible time measurements added at end

Puzzles in Hyperon, Charm and Beauty Physics

Authors: Harry. J. Lipkin

Abstract: Puzzles awaiting better experiments and better theory include: (1) the contradiction between good and bad SU(3) baryon wave functions in fitting Cabibbo theory for hyperon decays, strangeness suppression in the sea and the violation of the Gottfried Sum rule - no model fits all; (2) Anomalously enhanced Cabibbo-suppressed $D^+ \to K^{*+}(s\bar d)$ decays; (3) anomalously enhanced and suppressed… ▽ More Puzzles awaiting better experiments and better theory include: (1) the contradiction between good and bad SU(3) baryon wave functions in fitting Cabibbo theory for hyperon decays, strangeness suppression in the sea and the violation of the Gottfried Sum rule - no model fits all; (2) Anomalously enhanced Cabibbo-suppressed $D^+ \to K^{*+}(s\bar d)$ decays; (3) anomalously enhanced and suppressed $B \to η' X$ decays; (4) the OZI rule in weak decays; (5) Vector dominance ($W \to π, ρ, a_1, D_s, D^*_s $) in weak decays (6) Puzzles in doubly-cabibbo-suppressed charm decays.(7) Problems in obtaining $Λ$ spin structure from polarization measurements of produced $Λ$'s. △ Less

Submitted 10 October, 2002; originally announced October 2002.

Comments: 5 pages

Report number: ANL-HEP-CP-02-072

Journal ref: Nucl.Phys.Proc.Suppl. 115 (2003) 117-121