-
Black hole mimickers: from theory to observation
Authors:
Cosimo Bambi,
Ramy Brustein,
Vitor Cardoso,
Andrew Chael,
Ulf Danielsson,
Suvendu Giri,
Anuradha Gupta,
Pierre Heidmann,
Luis Lehner,
Steven Liebling,
Andrea Maselli,
Elisa Maggio,
Samir Mathur,
Lia Medeiros,
Alex B. Nielsen,
Héctor R. Olivares-Sánchez,
Paolo Pani,
Nils Siemonsen,
George N. Wong
Abstract:
The black hole paradigm, while remarkably successful, raises fundamental questions-both classical and quantum-about the nature of spacetime, horizons, and singularities. Black hole mimickers, horizonless ultra-compact objects, have emerged as potential alternatives that seek to resolve some of these puzzles while remaining consistent with current observational constraints. Recent breakthroughs in…
▽ More
The black hole paradigm, while remarkably successful, raises fundamental questions-both classical and quantum-about the nature of spacetime, horizons, and singularities. Black hole mimickers, horizonless ultra-compact objects, have emerged as potential alternatives that seek to resolve some of these puzzles while remaining consistent with current observational constraints. Recent breakthroughs in gravitational-wave astronomy and horizon-scale electromagnetic imaging have opened new avenues to test this paradigm-making this an opportune moment to systematically investigate such alternatives.
This vision document presents a snapshot of the field as discussed at the Black Hole Mimickers: From Theory to Observation workshop, where experts from gravitational wave astronomy, very long baseline interferometry, numerical and mathematical relativity, and high-energy physics converged to assess the current frontiers. By highlighting key open questions and proposing concrete pathways forward, this document aims to guide future efforts to probe the nature of compact objects. As the field stands at the crossroads of theoretical innovation and observational breakthroughs, we outline strategies to harness upcoming observational capabilities to fundamentally test the black hole paradigm.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Gravitational waves from black hole emission
Authors:
Tousif Islam,
Gaurav Khanna,
Steven L. Liebling
Abstract:
Using adiabatic point-particle black hole perturbation theory, we simulate plausible gravitational wave~(GW) signatures in two exotic scenarios (i) where a small black hole is emitted by a larger one ('black hole emission') and (ii) where a small black hole is emitted by a larger one and subsequently absorbed back ('black hole absorption'). While such scenarios are forbidden in general relativity!…
▽ More
Using adiabatic point-particle black hole perturbation theory, we simulate plausible gravitational wave~(GW) signatures in two exotic scenarios (i) where a small black hole is emitted by a larger one ('black hole emission') and (ii) where a small black hole is emitted by a larger one and subsequently absorbed back ('black hole absorption'). While such scenarios are forbidden in general relativity!(GR), alternative theories (such as certain quantum gravity scenarios obeying the weak gravity conjecture, white holes, and Hawking radiation) may allow them. By leveraging the phenomenology of black hole emission and absorption signals, we introduce straightforward modifications to existing gravitational waveform models to mimic gravitational radiation associated with these exotic events. We anticipate that these (incomplete but) initial simulations, coupled with the adjusted waveform models, will aid in the development of null tests for GR using GWs.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Accessing the axion via compact object binaries
Authors:
Michael Kavic,
Steven L. Liebling,
Matthew Lippert,
John H. Simonetti
Abstract:
Black holes in binaries with other compact objects can provide natural venues for indirect detection of axions or other ultralight fields. The superradiant instability associated with a rapidly spinning black hole leads to the creation of an axion cloud which carries energy and angular momentum from the black hole. This cloud will then decay via gravitational wave emission. We show that the energy…
▽ More
Black holes in binaries with other compact objects can provide natural venues for indirect detection of axions or other ultralight fields. The superradiant instability associated with a rapidly spinning black hole leads to the creation of an axion cloud which carries energy and angular momentum from the black hole. This cloud will then decay via gravitational wave emission. We show that the energy lost as a result of this process tends toward an outspiraling of the binary orbit. A given binary system is sensitive to a narrow range of axion masses, determined by the mass of the black hole. Pulsar-black hole binaries, once detected in the electromagnetic band, will allow high-precision measurements of black hole mass loss via timing measurements of the companion pulsar. This avenue of investigation is particularly promising in light of the recent preliminary announcements of two candidate black hole-neutron star mergers by LIGO/VIRGO (#S190814bv and #S190426c). We demonstrate that for such a binary system with a typical millisecond pulsar and a 3-solar-mass black hole, axions with masses between $2.7 \times 10^{-12}$ eV and $3.2 \times 10^{-12}$ eV are detectable. Recent gravitational wave observations by LIGO/VIRGO of binary black hole mergers imply that, for these binaries, gravitational radiation from the rotating quadrupole moment is a dominant effect, causing an inspiraling orbit. With some reasonable assumptions about the period of the binary when it formed and the spins of the black holes, these observations rule out possible axion masses between $3 \times 10^{-13}$ eV and $6 \times 10^{-13}$ eV. Future binary black hole observations, for example by LISA, are expected to provide more robust bounds. In some circumstances, neutron stars may also undergo superradiant instabilities, and binary pulsars could be used to exclude axions with certain masses and matter couplings.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2020; v1 submitted 15 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Neutron star mergers as a probe of modifications of general relativity with finite-range scalar forces
Authors:
Laura Sagunski,
Jun Zhang,
Matthew C. Johnson,
Luis Lehner,
Mairi Sakellariadou,
Steven L. Liebling,
Carlos Palenzuela,
David Neilsen
Abstract:
Observations of gravitational radiation from compact binary systems provide an unprecedented opportunity to test General Relativity in the strong field dynamical regime. In this paper, we investigate how future observations of gravitational radiation from binary neutron star mergers might provide constraints on finite-range forces from a universally coupled massive scalar field. Such scalar degree…
▽ More
Observations of gravitational radiation from compact binary systems provide an unprecedented opportunity to test General Relativity in the strong field dynamical regime. In this paper, we investigate how future observations of gravitational radiation from binary neutron star mergers might provide constraints on finite-range forces from a universally coupled massive scalar field. Such scalar degrees of freedom are a characteristic feature of many extensions of General Relativity. For concreteness, we work in the context of metric $f(R)$ gravity, which is equivalent to General Relativity and a universally coupled scalar field with a non-linear potential whose form is fixed by the choice of $f(R)$. In theories where neutron stars (or other compact objects) obtain a significant scalar charge, the resulting attractive finite-range scalar force has implications for both the inspiral and merger phases of binary systems. We first present an analysis of the inspiral dynamics in Newtonian limit, and forecast the constraints on the mass of the scalar and charge of the compact objects for the Advanced LIGO gravitational wave observatory. We then perform a comparative study of binary neutron star mergers in General Relativity with those of a one-parameter model of $f(R)$ gravity using fully relativistic hydrodynamical simulations. These simulations elucidate the effects of the scalar on the merger and post-merger dynamics. We comment on the utility of the full waveform (inspiral, merger, post-merger) to probe different regions of parameter space for both the particular model of $f(R)$ gravity studied here and for finite-range scalar forces more generally.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2018; v1 submitted 19 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Dynamical Boson Stars
Authors:
Steven L. Liebling,
Carlos Palenzuela
Abstract:
The idea of stable, localized bundles of energy has strong appeal as a model for particles. In the 1950s John Wheeler envisioned such bundles as smooth configurations of electromagnetic energy that he called {\em geons}, but none were found. Instead, particle-like solutions were found in the late 1960s with the addition of a scalar field, and these were given the name {\em boson stars}. Since then…
▽ More
The idea of stable, localized bundles of energy has strong appeal as a model for particles. In the 1950s John Wheeler envisioned such bundles as smooth configurations of electromagnetic energy that he called {\em geons}, but none were found. Instead, particle-like solutions were found in the late 1960s with the addition of a scalar field, and these were given the name {\em boson stars}. Since then, boson stars find use in a wide variety of models as sources of dark matter, as black hole mimickers, in simple models of binary systems, and as a tool in finding black holes in higher dimensions with only a single killing vector. We discuss important varieties of boson stars, their dynamic properties, and some of their uses, concentrating on recent efforts.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2023; v1 submitted 26 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Critical Phenomena in Nonlinear Sigma Models
Authors:
Steven L. Liebling,
Eric W. Hirschmann,
James Isenberg
Abstract:
We consider solutions to the nonlinear sigma model (wave maps) with target space S^3 and base space 3+1 Minkowski space, and we find critical behavior separating singular solutions from nonsingular solutions. For families of solutions with localized spatial support a self-similar solution is found at the boundary. For other families, we find that a static solution appears to sit at the boundary.…
▽ More
We consider solutions to the nonlinear sigma model (wave maps) with target space S^3 and base space 3+1 Minkowski space, and we find critical behavior separating singular solutions from nonsingular solutions. For families of solutions with localized spatial support a self-similar solution is found at the boundary. For other families, we find that a static solution appears to sit at the boundary. This behavior is compared to the black hole critical phenomena found by Choptuik.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2000; v1 submitted 13 November, 1999;
originally announced November 1999.
-
Critical Phenomena Inside Global Monopoles
Authors:
Steven L. Liebling
Abstract:
The gravitational collapse of a triplet scalar field is examined assuming a hedgehog ansatz for the scalar field. Whereas the seminal work by Choptuik with a single, strictly spherically symmetric scalar field found a discretely self-similar (DSS) solution at criticality with echoing period $Δ=3.44$, here a new DSS solution is found with period $Δ=0.46$. This new critical solution is also observ…
▽ More
The gravitational collapse of a triplet scalar field is examined assuming a hedgehog ansatz for the scalar field. Whereas the seminal work by Choptuik with a single, strictly spherically symmetric scalar field found a discretely self-similar (DSS) solution at criticality with echoing period $Δ=3.44$, here a new DSS solution is found with period $Δ=0.46$. This new critical solution is also observed in the presence of a symmetry breaking potential as well as within a global monopole. The triplet scalar field model contains Choptuik's original model in a certain region of parameter space, and hence his original DSS solution is also a solution. However, the choice of a hedgehog ansatz appears to exclude the original DSS.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 1999;
originally announced April 1999.
-
Pair Production in the Collapse of a Hopf Texture
Authors:
Eric W. Hirschmann,
Steven L. Liebling
Abstract:
We consider the collapse of a global "Hopf" texture and examine the conjecture, disputed in the literature, that monopole-antimonopole pairs can be formed in the process. We show that such monopole-antimonopole pairs can indeed be nucleated in the course of texture collapse given appropriate initial conditions. The subsequent dynamics include the recombination and annihilation of the pair in a b…
▽ More
We consider the collapse of a global "Hopf" texture and examine the conjecture, disputed in the literature, that monopole-antimonopole pairs can be formed in the process. We show that such monopole-antimonopole pairs can indeed be nucleated in the course of texture collapse given appropriate initial conditions. The subsequent dynamics include the recombination and annihilation of the pair in a burst of outgoing scalar radiation.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 1998;
originally announced August 1998.
-
Black Hole Criticality in the Brans-Dicke Model
Authors:
Steven L. Liebling,
Matthew W. Choptuik
Abstract:
We study the collapse of a free scalar field in the Brans-Dicke model of gravity. At the critical point of black hole formation, the model admits two distinctive solutions dependent on the value of the coupling parameter. We find one solution to be discretely self-similar and the other to exhibit continuous self-similarity.
We study the collapse of a free scalar field in the Brans-Dicke model of gravity. At the critical point of black hole formation, the model admits two distinctive solutions dependent on the value of the coupling parameter. We find one solution to be discretely self-similar and the other to exhibit continuous self-similarity.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 1996;
originally announced June 1996.
