-
Monte Carlo challenges for strong field quantum electrodynamics
Authors:
Anthony Hartin
Abstract:
The assisted Schwinger effect, which is predicted to display non-perturbative quantum tunnelling, is expected to be produced in precision lab experiments with electron beams and intense lasers. Indeed, many novel effects predicted by a theory which incorporates the laser field exactly, can be probed experimentally with the proper application of theory and simulation. Among predicted first order ef…
▽ More
The assisted Schwinger effect, which is predicted to display non-perturbative quantum tunnelling, is expected to be produced in precision lab experiments with electron beams and intense lasers. Indeed, many novel effects predicted by a theory which incorporates the laser field exactly, can be probed experimentally with the proper application of theory and simulation. Among predicted first order effects are a rest mass shift and harmonic Compton scattering. Higher order effects include resonant transition rates which become apparent when scanned over specific kinematic parameters. The underpinning of the theory and experiment is a Monte Carlo simulation tool which precisely links experimental realities to the expected theoretical transition rates. We report on the progress of such a tool here.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2025;
originally announced September 2025.
-
LUXE-NPOD: new physics searches with an optical dump at LUXE
Authors:
Zhaoyu Bai,
Thomas Blackburn,
Oleksandr Borysov,
Oz Davidi,
Anthony Hartin,
Beate Heinemann,
Teng Ma,
Gilad Perez,
Arka Santra,
Yotam Soreq,
Noam Tal Hod
Abstract:
We propose a novel way to search for feebly interacting massive particles, exploiting two properties of systems involving collisions between high energy electrons and intense laser pulses. The first property is that the electron-intense-laser collision results in a large flux of hard photons, as the laser behaves effectively as a thick medium. The second property is that the emitted photons free-s…
▽ More
We propose a novel way to search for feebly interacting massive particles, exploiting two properties of systems involving collisions between high energy electrons and intense laser pulses. The first property is that the electron-intense-laser collision results in a large flux of hard photons, as the laser behaves effectively as a thick medium. The second property is that the emitted photons free-stream inside the laser and thus for them the laser behaves effectively as a very thin medium. Combining these two features implies that the electron-intense-laser collision is an apparatus which can efficiently convert UV electrons to a large flux of hard, co-linear photons. We further propose to direct this unique large and hard flux of photons onto a physical dump which in turn is capable of producing feebly interacting massive particles, in a region of parameters that has never been probed before. We denote this novel apparatus as ``optical dump'' or NPOD (new physics search with optical dump). The proposed LUXE experiment at Eu.XFEL has all the required basic ingredients of the above experimental concept. We discuss how this concept can be realized in practice by adding a detector after the last physical dump of the experiment to reconstruct the two-photon decay product of a new spin-0 particle. We show that even with a relatively short dump, the search can still be background free. Remarkably, even with a 40 TW laser, which corresponds to the initial run, and definitely with a 350 TW laser, of the main run with one year of data taking, LUXE-NPOD will be able to probe uncharted territory of both models of pseudo-scalar and scalar fields, and in particular probe natural of scalar theories for masses above 100 MeV.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Conceptual Design Report for the LUXE Experiment
Authors:
Halina Abramowicz,
Uwe Hernandez Acosta,
Massimo Altarelli,
Ralph Assmann,
Zhaoyu Bai,
Ties Behnke,
Yan Benhammou,
Thomas Blackburn,
Stewart Boogert,
Oleksandr Borysov,
Maryna Borysova,
Reinhard Brinkmann,
Marco Bruschi,
Florian Burkart,
Karsten Büßer,
Niall Cavanagh,
Oz Davidi,
Winfried Decking,
Umberto Dosselli,
Nina Elkina,
Alexander Fedotov,
Miroslaw Firlej,
Tomasz Fiutowski,
Kyle Fleck,
Mikhail Gostkin
, et al. (66 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This Conceptual Design Report describes LUXE (Laser Und XFEL Experiment), an experimental campaign that aims to combine the high-quality and high-energy electron beam of the European XFEL with a powerful laser to explore the uncharted terrain of quantum electrodynamics characterised by both high energy and high intensity. We will reach this hitherto inaccessible regime of quantum physics by analys…
▽ More
This Conceptual Design Report describes LUXE (Laser Und XFEL Experiment), an experimental campaign that aims to combine the high-quality and high-energy electron beam of the European XFEL with a powerful laser to explore the uncharted terrain of quantum electrodynamics characterised by both high energy and high intensity. We will reach this hitherto inaccessible regime of quantum physics by analysing high-energy electron-photon and photon-photon interactions in the extreme environment provided by an intense laser focus. The physics background and its relevance are presented in the science case which in turn leads to, and justifies, the ensuing plan for all aspects of the experiment: Our choice of experimental parameters allows (i) effective field strengths to be probed at and beyond the Schwinger limit and (ii) a precision to be achieved that permits a detailed comparison of the measured data with calculations. In addition, the high photon flux predicted will enable a sensitive search for new physics beyond the Standard Model. The initial phase of the experiment will employ an existing 40 TW laser, whereas the second phase will utilise an upgraded laser power of 350 TW. All expectations regarding the performance of the experimental set-up as well as the expected physics results are based on detailed numerical simulations throughout.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2021; v1 submitted 3 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Summary Report of Physics Beyond Colliders at CERN
Authors:
R. Alemany,
C. Burrage,
H. Bartosik,
J. Bernhard,
J. Boyd,
M. Brugger,
M. Calviani,
C. Carli,
N. Charitonidis,
D. Curtin,
A. Dainese,
A. de Roeck,
M. Diehl,
B. Döbrich,
L. Evans,
J. L. Feng,
M. Ferro-Luzzi,
L. Gatignon,
S. Gilardoni,
S. Gninenko,
G. Graziani,
E. Gschwendtner,
B. Goddard,
A. Hartin,
I. Irastorza
, et al. (39 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Physics Beyond Colliders is an exploratory study aimed at exploiting the full scientific potential of CERN's accelerator complex and its scientific infrastructure in the next two decades through projects complementary to the LHC, HL-LHC and other possible future colliders. These projects should target fundamental physics questions that are similar in spirit to those addressed by high-energy collid…
▽ More
Physics Beyond Colliders is an exploratory study aimed at exploiting the full scientific potential of CERN's accelerator complex and its scientific infrastructure in the next two decades through projects complementary to the LHC, HL-LHC and other possible future colliders. These projects should target fundamental physics questions that are similar in spirit to those addressed by high-energy colliders, but that require different types of beams and experiments. A kick-off workshop held in September 2016 identified a number of areas of interest and working groups have been set-up to study and develop these directions. All projects currently under consideration are presented including physics motivation, a brief outline of the experimental set-up and the status of the corresponding beam and detector technological studies. The proposals are also put in context of the worldwide landscape and their implementation issues are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Physics Beyond Colliders at CERN: Beyond the Standard Model Working Group Report
Authors:
J. Beacham,
C. Burrage,
D. Curtin,
A. De Roeck,
J. Evans,
J. L. Feng,
C. Gatto,
S. Gninenko,
A. Hartin,
I. Irastorza,
J. Jaeckel,
K. Jungmann,
K. Kirch,
F. Kling,
S. Knapen,
M. Lamont,
G. Lanfranchi,
C. Lazzeroni,
A. Lindner,
F. Martinez-Vidal,
M. Moulson,
N. Neri,
M. Papucci,
I. Pedraza,
K. Petridis
, et al. (8 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Physics Beyond Colliders initiative is an exploratory study aimed at exploiting the full scientific potential of the CERN's accelerator complex and scientific infrastructures through projects complementary to the LHC and other possible future colliders. These projects will target fundamental physics questions in modern particle physics. This document presents the status of the proposals presen…
▽ More
The Physics Beyond Colliders initiative is an exploratory study aimed at exploiting the full scientific potential of the CERN's accelerator complex and scientific infrastructures through projects complementary to the LHC and other possible future colliders. These projects will target fundamental physics questions in modern particle physics. This document presents the status of the proposals presented in the framework of the Beyond the Standard Model physics working group, and explore their physics reach and the impact that CERN could have in the next 10-20 years on the international landscape.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2019; v1 submitted 20 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Exact solutions of the bound Dirac and Klein Gordon equations in non co propagating electromagnetic plane waves
Authors:
A. Hartin
Abstract:
A new class of exact solutions of the bound Dirac and bound Klein Gordon equations in non co propagating plane waves is found. The solutions are based on the physical principle of maintaining local gauge invariance in the Furry picture Lagrangian when N external fields can undergo independent gauge transformations. The solutions can be expressed in terms of the Hamilton Jacobi action and a gauge i…
▽ More
A new class of exact solutions of the bound Dirac and bound Klein Gordon equations in non co propagating plane waves is found. The solutions are based on the physical principle of maintaining local gauge invariance in the Furry picture Lagrangian when N external fields can undergo independent gauge transformations. The solutions can be expressed in terms of the Hamilton Jacobi action and a gauge invariant effective particle momentum in the ensemble of external fields. Rotations of the effective particle momentum, which preserve local gauge invariance, are introduced into the action using matrix calculus. The set of such rotations provides the class of new solutions constituting a family of Volkov like solutions for one external field. When applied to two or more non co propagating external fields, the rotational symmetry provides counter terms which decouple the fields. The bound state equations of motion become solvable for any number of non co propagating external fields. Through angular spectral decomposition, which represents electromagnetic fields of any form as a spatial Fourier series of non co propagating plane waves, the new solutions described here can be applied to strong field physics problems in any external electromagnetic field.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Measuring the Boiling Point of the Vacuum of Quantum Electrodynamics
Authors:
Anthony Hartin,
Andreas Ringwald,
Natalia Tapia
Abstract:
It is a long-standing non-trivial prediction of quantum electrodynamics that its vacuum is unstable in the background of a static, spatially uniform electric field and, in principle, sparks with spontaneous emission of electron-positron pairs. However, an experimental verification of this prediction seems out of reach because a sizeable rate for spontaneous pair production requires an extraordinar…
▽ More
It is a long-standing non-trivial prediction of quantum electrodynamics that its vacuum is unstable in the background of a static, spatially uniform electric field and, in principle, sparks with spontaneous emission of electron-positron pairs. However, an experimental verification of this prediction seems out of reach because a sizeable rate for spontaneous pair production requires an extraordinarily strong electric field strength $|\mathbf E|$ of order the Schwinger critical field, ${\rm E}_c=m_e^2/e\simeq 1.3\times 10^{18}\ {\rm V/m}$, where $m_e$ is the electron mass and $e$ is its charge. Here, we show that the measurement of the rate of pair production due to the decays of high-energy bremsstrahlung photons in a high-intensity laser field allows for the experimental determination of the Schwinger critical field and thus the boiling point of the vacuum of quantum electrodynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2019; v1 submitted 27 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Strong field QED in lepton colliders and electron/laser interactions
Authors:
Anthony Hartin
Abstract:
Studies of strong field particle physics processes in electron/laser interactions and lepton collider interaction points are reviewed. These processes are defined by the high intensity of the electromagnetic fields involved and the need to take them into account as fully as possible. The main theoretical framework considered is the Furry picture. In this framework, the influence of a background el…
▽ More
Studies of strong field particle physics processes in electron/laser interactions and lepton collider interaction points are reviewed. These processes are defined by the high intensity of the electromagnetic fields involved and the need to take them into account as fully as possible. The main theoretical framework considered is the Furry picture. In this framework, the influence of a background electromagnetic field in the Lagrangian is calculated non perturbatively, involving exact solutions for quantised charged particles in the background field. These "dressed" particles go on to interact perturbatively with other particles. The background field starts to polarise the vacuum, in effect rendering it a dispersive medium. Particles encountering this dispersive vacuum obtain a lifetime, either radiating or decaying into pair particles at a rate dependent on the intensity of the background field. In fact, the intensity of the background field enters into the coupling constant of the strong field QED Lagrangian, influencing all particle processes. A number of new phenomena occur. Particles gain an intensity dependent rest mass shift that accounts for their presence in the dispersive vacuum. Multi photon events involving more than one external field photon occur at each vertex. Higher order processes which exchange a virtual strong field particle, resonate via the lifetimes of the unstable strong field states. Two main arenas of strong field physics are reviewed; those occurring in relativistic electron interactions with intense laser beams, and those occurring in the beam beam physics at the interaction point of colliders. This review outlines the theory, describes its significant novel phenomenology and details the experimental schema required to detect strong field effects and the simulation programs required to model them.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2018; v1 submitted 9 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Enhanced, high energy photon production from resonant Compton scattering in a strong external field
Authors:
A. Hartin
Abstract:
A theoretical and phenomenological consideration is given to higher order, strong field effects in electron/laser interactions. A consistent strong field theory is the Furry interaction picture of intense field quantum field theory. In this theory, fermions are embedded in the strong laser field and the Volkov wavefunction solutions that result, are exact with respect to the strong field. When the…
▽ More
A theoretical and phenomenological consideration is given to higher order, strong field effects in electron/laser interactions. A consistent strong field theory is the Furry interaction picture of intense field quantum field theory. In this theory, fermions are embedded in the strong laser field and the Volkov wavefunction solutions that result, are exact with respect to the strong field. When these Volkov fermions interact with individual photons from other sources, the transition probability is enhanced in a series of resonances when the kinematics allow the virtual fermion to go on-shell. An experiment is proposed in which, for the first time, resonances could be used to generate high energy photons from relativistic electrons at rates orders of magnitude in excess of usual mechanisms.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Second Order QED Processes in an Intense Electromagnetic Field
Authors:
A. Hartin
Abstract:
Some non linear, second order QED processes in the presence of intense plane electromagnetic waves are investigated. Analytic expressions with general kinematics are derived for Compton scattering and $e^+e^-$ pair production in a circularly polarised external electromagnetic field. The differential cross sections were investigated numerically for photon energies up to 50 MeV, external field inten…
▽ More
Some non linear, second order QED processes in the presence of intense plane electromagnetic waves are investigated. Analytic expressions with general kinematics are derived for Compton scattering and $e^+e^-$ pair production in a circularly polarised external electromagnetic field. The differential cross sections were investigated numerically for photon energies up to 50 MeV, external field intensity parameter $ν^2$ to value 2, and all scattering angles. The variation of full cross sections with respect to external field intensity was also established. The presence of the external field led to resonances in the Compton scattering and pair production differential cross sections. These resonances were investigated by calculating the electron self energy in the presence of the external field. At resonance the differential cross sections were enhanced by several orders of magnitude. The resonances occurred for values of external field intensity parameter $ν^2 <1$, lowering the limit of $ν^2 \sim 1$ at which point non linear effects in first order external field QED processes become important. Generally, full cross sections increased with increasing external field intensity, though peaking sharply for Compton scattering and levelling off for pair production. An application was made to non linear background studies at $e^+e^-$ linear colliders. The pair production process and electron self energy were studied for the case of a constant crossed electromagnetic field. It was found that previous analytic expressions required the external field to be azimuthally symmetric. New analytic expressions for the more general non azimuthally symmetric case were developed and a numerical parameter range equivalent to that proposed for future linear collider designs was considered.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Resonant transitions induced in particle processes by the non-perturbative treatment of strong laser fields
Authors:
A. Hartin
Abstract:
Intense field quantum field theory (IFQFT) is used to determine new phenomenological predictions arising from Compton scattering and pair production in a strong laser field. This theory utilizes exact solutions of fermions embedded in external plane waves which carry over to a strong field fermion propagator. When these strong field fermions also interact with probe photons, the transition probabi…
▽ More
Intense field quantum field theory (IFQFT) is used to determine new phenomenological predictions arising from Compton scattering and pair production in a strong laser field. This theory utilizes exact solutions of fermions embedded in external plane waves which carry over to a strong field fermion propagator. When these strong field fermions also interact with probe photons, the transition probability is enhanced in a series of resonances when the kinematics allow the virtual fermion to go on-shell. An analysis of parameters shows that contemporary experiments could already produce these predicted resonances. With appropriate tuning, resonances can be made arbitrarily sharp, leading to precision calculations of resonance locations and widths, and the runing of coupling constants in strong background fields. New tests of QED could be performed leading to ramifications for our understanding of the quantum vacuum. Such tests extend to QFT in background potentials in general, which may throw light on BSM theories such as QFT in curved space-times.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Fierz relations for Volkov spinors and the simplification of Furry picture traces
Authors:
A. Hartin
Abstract:
Transition probability calculations of strong field particle processes in the Furry picture, typically use fermion Volkov solutions. These solutions have a relatively complicated spinor due to the interaction of the electron spin with a strong external field, which in turn leads to unwieldy trace calculations. The simplification of these calculations would aid theoretical studies of strong field p…
▽ More
Transition probability calculations of strong field particle processes in the Furry picture, typically use fermion Volkov solutions. These solutions have a relatively complicated spinor due to the interaction of the electron spin with a strong external field, which in turn leads to unwieldy trace calculations. The simplification of these calculations would aid theoretical studies of strong field phenomena such as the predicted resonance behaviour of higher order Furry picture processes. Here, Fierz transformations of Volkov spinors are developed and applied to a 1st order and a 2nd order Furry picture process. Combined with symmetry properties, the techniques presented here are generally applicable and lead to considerable simplification of Furry picture analytic calculations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2016; v1 submitted 23 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Furry picture transition rates in the intense fields at a lepton collider interaction point
Authors:
Anthony Hartin
Abstract:
The effect on particle physics processes by intense electromagnetic fields in the charge bunch collisions at future lepton colliders is considered. Since the charge bunch fields are tied to massive sources (the $e^{+}e^{-}$ charges), a reference frame is chosen in which the fields appear to be co-propagating. Solutions of the Dirac equation minimally coupled to the electromagnetic fields reasonabl…
▽ More
The effect on particle physics processes by intense electromagnetic fields in the charge bunch collisions at future lepton colliders is considered. Since the charge bunch fields are tied to massive sources (the $e^{+}e^{-}$ charges), a reference frame is chosen in which the fields appear to be co-propagating. Solutions of the Dirac equation minimally coupled to the electromagnetic fields reasonably associated with two intense overlapping charge bunches are obtained and found to be a Volkov solution with respect to a null 4-vector whose 3-vector part lies in the common propagation direction. These solutions are used within the Furry interaction picture to calculate the beamstrahlung transition rate for electron radiation due to interaction with the electromagnetic fields of two colliding charge bunches. New analytic expressions are obtained and compared numerically with the beamstrahlung in the electromagnetic field of one charge bunch. The techniques developed will be applied to other collider physics processes in due course.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
Testing nonlinear-QED at the future linear collider with an intense laser
Authors:
A. Hartin,
S. Porto,
G. Moortgat-Pick
Abstract:
The future linear collider will collide dense $e^+e^-$ bunches at high energies up to 1 TeV, generating very intense electromagnetic fields at the interaction point (IP). These fields are strong enough to lead to nonlinear effects which affect all IP processes and which are described by strong field physics theory. In order to test this theory, we propose an experiment that will focus an intense l…
▽ More
The future linear collider will collide dense $e^+e^-$ bunches at high energies up to 1 TeV, generating very intense electromagnetic fields at the interaction point (IP). These fields are strong enough to lead to nonlinear effects which affect all IP processes and which are described by strong field physics theory. In order to test this theory, we propose an experiment that will focus an intense laser on the LC electron beam post-IP. Similar experiments at SLAC E144 have investigated nonlinear Compton scattering, Breit-Wheeler pair production using an electron beam of 46.6 GeV. The higher beam energies available at the future LC would allow more precise studies of these phenomena. Mass-shift and spin-dependent effects could also be investigated.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Methods for evaluating physical processes in strong external fields at e+e- colliders: Furry picture and quasi-classical approach
Authors:
Stefano Porto,
Anthony Hartin,
Gudrid Moortgat-Pick
Abstract:
Future linear colliders designs, ILC and CLIC, are expected to be powerful machines for the discovery of Physics Beyond the Standard Model and subsequent precision studies. However, due to the intense beams (high luminosity, high energy), strong electromagnetic fields occur in the beam-beam interaction region. In the context of precision high energy physics, the presence of such strong fields may…
▽ More
Future linear colliders designs, ILC and CLIC, are expected to be powerful machines for the discovery of Physics Beyond the Standard Model and subsequent precision studies. However, due to the intense beams (high luminosity, high energy), strong electromagnetic fields occur in the beam-beam interaction region. In the context of precision high energy physics, the presence of such strong fields may yield sensitive corrections to the observed electron-positron processes. The Furry picture of quantum states gives a conceptually simple tool to treat physics processes in an external field. A generalization of the quasi-classical operator method (QOM) as an approximation is considered too.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Strong field effects on physics processes at the Interaction Point of future linear colliders
Authors:
A. Hartin,
G. Moortgat-Pick,
S. Porto
Abstract:
Future lepton colliders will be precision machines whose physics program includes close study of the Higgs sector and searches for new physics via polarised beams. The luminosity requirements of such machines entail very intense lepton bunches at the interaction point with associated strong electromagnetic fields. These strong fields not only lead to obvious phenomena such as beamstrahlung, but al…
▽ More
Future lepton colliders will be precision machines whose physics program includes close study of the Higgs sector and searches for new physics via polarised beams. The luminosity requirements of such machines entail very intense lepton bunches at the interaction point with associated strong electromagnetic fields. These strong fields not only lead to obvious phenomena such as beamstrahlung, but also potentially affect every particle physics process via virtual exchange with the bunch fields. For precision studies, strong field effects have to be understood to the sub-percent level. Strong external field effects can be taken into account exactly via the Furry Picture or, in certain limits, via the Quasi-classical Operator method . Significant theoretical development is in progress and here we outline the current state of play.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
