-
Model-independent analysis of $b\to d$ processes
Authors:
Rigo Bause,
Hector Gisbert,
Marcel Golz,
Gudrun Hiller
Abstract:
We perform a model-independent analysis of $|Δb|=|Δd|=1$ processes to test the standard model and probe flavor patterns of new physics. Constraints on Wilson coefficients are obtained from global fits to $B^+ \to π^+ \,μ^+μ^-$, $B^0_s\to \bar{K}^{*0}\, μ^+μ^-$, $B^0\toμ^+μ^-$, and radiative $B \to X_d \,γ$ decays data. The fits are consistent with the standard model but leave sizable room for new…
▽ More
We perform a model-independent analysis of $|Δb|=|Δd|=1$ processes to test the standard model and probe flavor patterns of new physics. Constraints on Wilson coefficients are obtained from global fits to $B^+ \to π^+ \,μ^+μ^-$, $B^0_s\to \bar{K}^{*0}\, μ^+μ^-$, $B^0\toμ^+μ^-$, and radiative $B \to X_d \,γ$ decays data. The fits are consistent with the standard model but leave sizable room for new physics. Besides higher-statistics measurements and more data in theory-friendly bins of the dilepton mass, further complementary observables such as angular distributions of $B_s^0 \to \bar{K}^{*0}\,\ell^+ \ell^-$, $B \to ρ\,\ell^+ \ell^-$ or the baryonic modes $Ξ_b \to Σ\,\ell^+ \ell^-$, $Ω_b^- \to Ξ^- \, \ell^+ \ell^-$ are necessary to resolve the significant degeneracy in the fit for the semileptonic four-fermion operators. Assuming minimal quark flavor violation, the $b \to s$ global fit implies tight constraints on the $b \to d$ couplings, and hence allows to test this paradigm with improved data. Another benefit from $|Δb|=|Δd|=1$ processes is to shed light on the $B$-anomalies in $|Δb|=|Δs|=1$ modes from a new angle. Specifically, studies of lepton flavor-specific and dineutrino modes are informative on the lepton flavor structure. Rare $b \to d \, \ell \ell, ν\bar ν$ decays can be studied at high luminosity flavor facilities LHCb, Belle II, and a future $Z$-factory.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2023; v1 submitted 9 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Null test BSM searches with rare charm baryon decays
Authors:
Marcel Golz,
Gudrun Hiller,
Tom Magorsch
Abstract:
Rare $\vert Δc \vert=\vert Δu \vert=1$ processes uniquely probe flavor in the Standard Model and beyond from the up-type quark sector. Opportunities to search for BSM physics in charm arise from the severe GIM suppression which kills SM contributions to leptonic axial-vector contributions and suppresses CP violation. Semileptonic decays of charmed hadrons offer a variety of clean null test observa…
▽ More
Rare $\vert Δc \vert=\vert Δu \vert=1$ processes uniquely probe flavor in the Standard Model and beyond from the up-type quark sector. Opportunities to search for BSM physics in charm arise from the severe GIM suppression which kills SM contributions to leptonic axial-vector contributions and suppresses CP violation. Semileptonic decays of charmed hadrons offer a variety of clean null test observables, featuring new physics effects which are even enhanced by resonance contributions. In particular, angular observables in three- and self-analyzing four-body baryon decays, such as $Λ_c\to p \ell^+\ell^-$ and $Ξ_c^+\toΣ^+(\to pπ^0)\ell^+\ell^-$, $Ξ_c^0\toΛ^0\,(\to p π^-)\ell^+\ell^-$ and $Ω_c^0\toΞ^0\,(\to Λ^{0} π^0)\ell^+\ell^-$ disentangle possible new physics effects in electromagnetic dipole couplings $C_7^{(\prime)}$ and (axial-)vector 4-fermion ones $C^{(\prime)}_{9\,(10)}$. There is sensitivity to BSM couplings as small as $\sim 0.01$.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Pinning down $|Δc|=|Δu|=1$ couplings with rare charm baryon decays
Authors:
Marcel Golz,
Gudrun Hiller,
Tom Magorsch
Abstract:
We study the full angular distribution of semileptonic rare charm baryon decays in which the secondary baryon undergoes weak decay with sizable polarization parameter, $Ξ_c^+\toΣ^+\,(\to pπ^0)\ell^+\ell^-$, $Ξ_c^0\toΛ^0\,(\to p π^-)\ell^+\ell^-$ and $Ω_c^0\toΞ^0\,(\to Λ^{0} π^0)\ell^+\ell^-$. Such self-analyzing decay chains allow for seven additional observables compared to three-body decays such…
▽ More
We study the full angular distribution of semileptonic rare charm baryon decays in which the secondary baryon undergoes weak decay with sizable polarization parameter, $Ξ_c^+\toΣ^+\,(\to pπ^0)\ell^+\ell^-$, $Ξ_c^0\toΛ^0\,(\to p π^-)\ell^+\ell^-$ and $Ω_c^0\toΞ^0\,(\to Λ^{0} π^0)\ell^+\ell^-$. Such self-analyzing decay chains allow for seven additional observables compared to three-body decays such as $Λ_c \to p \ell^+ \ell^-$, with different sensitivities to the $|Δc|=|Δu|=1$ weak couplings. Opportunities to test the standard model in $c \to u$ transitions with standard model null tests and other angular observables are worked out. We show that a joint model-independent analysis of the leptonic $A_{\text{FB}}^\ell$, hadronic $A_{\text{FB}}^{\text{H}}$, and combined forward-backward asymmetry $A_{\text{FB}}^{\ell\text{H}}$ together with the fraction of longitudinally produced leptons, $F_L$, is able to pin down the dipole couplings $C_{7},C^\prime_{7}$ and the semileptonic (axial-) vector ones $C_{10},C^\prime_{9},C^\prime_{10}$. $A_{\text{FB}}^{\text{H}}$ is also accessible with dineutrino $c \to u ν\bar ν$ modes and probes right-handed currents.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Dineutrino modes probing lepton flavor violation
Authors:
Rigo Bause,
Hector Gisbert,
Marcel Golz,
Gudrun Hiller
Abstract:
$SU(2)_L$-invariance links charged dilepton $\bar q\,q^\prime\,\ell^+\,\ell^-$ and dineutrino $\bar q\, q^\prime\, \barν\,ν…
▽ More
$SU(2)_L$-invariance links charged dilepton $\bar q\,q^\prime\,\ell^+\,\ell^-$ and dineutrino $\bar q\, q^\prime\, \barν\,ν$ couplings. This connection can be established using the Standard Model Effective Field Theory framework, and allows to perform complementary experimental tests of lepton universality and charged lepton flavor conservation with flavor-summed dineutrino observables. We present its phenomenological implications for the branching ratios of rare charm decays $c\to u\,ν\,\barν$ and rare $B$ decays $b\to s\,\barν\,ν$ decays.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Null test searches for BSM physics with rare charm decays
Authors:
Marcel Golz
Abstract:
Semileptonic Flavor Changing Neutral Current decays of charmed hadrons uniquely probe the up-sector of the Standard Model. Clean null test observables, such as CP-asymmetries, lepton-universality ratios, missing energy modes, lepton flavor violating modes and angular observables can be studied in a variety of charmed meson and baryon modes. An overview of null test opportunities with rare charm de…
▽ More
Semileptonic Flavor Changing Neutral Current decays of charmed hadrons uniquely probe the up-sector of the Standard Model. Clean null test observables, such as CP-asymmetries, lepton-universality ratios, missing energy modes, lepton flavor violating modes and angular observables can be studied in a variety of charmed meson and baryon modes. An overview of null test opportunities with rare charm decays is presented and similarities and complementarities of different modes are worked out.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Interplay of dineutrino modes with semileptonic rare $\boldsymbol{B}$-decays
Authors:
Rigo Bause,
Hector Gisbert,
Marcel Golz,
Gudrun Hiller
Abstract:
We present a systematic global analysis of dineutrino modes $b \to q \,ν\bar ν$, $q=d,s$, and charged dilepton $b \to q \,\ell^+ \ell^-$ transitions. We derive improved or even entirely new limits on dineutrino branching ratios including decays $B^0 \to (K^0 , X_s)\, ν\bar ν$, $B_s \to φ\,ν\bar ν$ and $B^0 \to (π^0, ρ^0)\, ν\bar ν$ from dineutrino modes which presently are best constrained:…
▽ More
We present a systematic global analysis of dineutrino modes $b \to q \,ν\bar ν$, $q=d,s$, and charged dilepton $b \to q \,\ell^+ \ell^-$ transitions. We derive improved or even entirely new limits on dineutrino branching ratios including decays $B^0 \to (K^0 , X_s)\, ν\bar ν$, $B_s \to φ\,ν\bar ν$ and $B^0 \to (π^0, ρ^0)\, ν\bar ν$ from dineutrino modes which presently are best constrained: $B^+ \to (K^+,π^+, ρ^+) \,ν\bar ν$ and $B^0 \to K^{*0} \,ν\bar ν$. Using SMEFT we obtain new flavor constraints from the dineutrino modes, which are stronger than the corresponding ones from charged dilepton rare $b$-decay or Drell-Yan data, for $e τ$ and $ττ$ final states, as well as for $μτ$ ones in $b \to s$ processes. The method also allows to put novel constraints on semileptonic four-fermion operators with top quarks. Implications for ditau modes $b \to s \, τ^+ τ^-$ and $b \to d \, τ^+ τ^-$ are worked out. Furthermore, the interplay between dineutrinos and charged dileptons allows for concrete, novel tests of lepton universality in rare $B$-decays. Performing a global fit to $b \to s \,μ^+ μ^-, \,s γ$ transitions we find that lepton universality predicts the ratio of the $B^0 \to K^{*0} \,ν\bar ν$ to $B^0 \to K^0 \,ν\bar ν$ ($B^+ \to K^+ \,ν\bar ν$) branching fractions to be within 1.7 to 2.6 (1.6 to 2.4) at $1\,σ$, a region that includes the standard model, and that can be narrowed with improved charged dilepton data. There is sizable room outside this region where universality is broken and that can be probed with the Belle II experiment. Using results of a fit to $B^0 \to μ^+ μ^-$, $B^0_s\to \bar{K}^{\ast 0}\,μ^+μ^-$ and $ B^+ \to π^+\, μ^+ μ^-$ data we obtain an analogous relation for $|Δb|=|Δd|=1$ transitions.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2021; v1 submitted 3 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Probing for New Physics with Rare Charm Baryon ($Λ_c$, $Ξ_c$, $Ω_c$) Decays
Authors:
Marcel Golz,
Gudrun Hiller,
Tom Magorsch
Abstract:
We analyze rare charm baryon decays within the standard model and beyond. We identify all null test observables in unpolarized $Λ_c \to p \ell^+ \ell^-$, $\ell=e, μ$ decays, and study the new physics sensitivities. We find that the longitudinal dilepton polarization fraction $F_L$ is sensitive to electromagnetic dipole couplings $C_{7}^{(\prime)}$, and to the right-handed 4-fermion vector coupling…
▽ More
We analyze rare charm baryon decays within the standard model and beyond. We identify all null test observables in unpolarized $Λ_c \to p \ell^+ \ell^-$, $\ell=e, μ$ decays, and study the new physics sensitivities. We find that the longitudinal dilepton polarization fraction $F_L$ is sensitive to electromagnetic dipole couplings $C_{7}^{(\prime)}$, and to the right-handed 4-fermion vector coupling $C_{9}^\prime$. The forward-backward asymmetry, $A_{\rm FB}$, due to the GIM-suppression a standard model null test already, probes the left-handed axialvector 4-fermion coupling $C_{10}$; its CP-asymmetry, $A_{\rm FB}^{\rm CP}$, probes CP-violating phases in $C_{10}$. Physics beyond the standard model can induce branching ratios of dineutrino modes $Λ_c \to p ν\bar ν$ up to a few times $10^{-5}$, and one order of magnitude smaller if lepton flavor universality is assumed, while standard model rates are negligible. Charged lepton flavor violation allows for striking signals into $e^\pm μ^\mp$ final states, up to $10^{-6}$ branching ratios model-independently, and up to order $10^{-8}$ in leptoquark models. Related three-body baryon decays $Ξ_c \to Σ\ell \ell$, $Ξ_c \to Λ\ell \ell$ and $Ω_c \to Ξ\ell \ell$ offer similar opportunities to test the standard model with $|Δc|=|Δu|=1$ transitions.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2022; v1 submitted 27 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Physics reach of ${D}_{(s)}\to π(K) \ell\ell$ and other charming null test opportunities
Authors:
Marcel Golz
Abstract:
We discuss possibilities to test physics beyond the Standard Model in $\vertΔc\vert=\vertΔu\vert= 1$ semileptonic, hadronic and missing energy decay modes. Clean null test observables such as angular observables, CP-asymmetries and lepton universality tests are presented and model-independent correlations as well as details within flavorful, anomaly-free $Z^\prime$ models are worked out.
We discuss possibilities to test physics beyond the Standard Model in $\vertΔc\vert=\vertΔu\vert= 1$ semileptonic, hadronic and missing energy decay modes. Clean null test observables such as angular observables, CP-asymmetries and lepton universality tests are presented and model-independent correlations as well as details within flavorful, anomaly-free $Z^\prime$ models are worked out.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Theoretical and experimental status of rare charm decays
Authors:
Hector Gisbert,
Marcel Golz,
Dominik Stefan Mitzel
Abstract:
Rare charm decays offer the unique possibility to explore flavour-changing neutral-currents in the up-sector within the Standard Model and beyond. Due to the lack of effective methods to reliably describe its low energy dynamics, rare charm decays have been considered as less promising for long. However, this lack does not exclude the possibility to perform promising searches for New Physics per s…
▽ More
Rare charm decays offer the unique possibility to explore flavour-changing neutral-currents in the up-sector within the Standard Model and beyond. Due to the lack of effective methods to reliably describe its low energy dynamics, rare charm decays have been considered as less promising for long. However, this lack does not exclude the possibility to perform promising searches for New Physics per se, but a different philosophy of work is required. Exact or approximate symmetries of the Standard Model allow to construct clean null-test observables, yielding an excellent road to the discovery of New Physics, complementing the existing studies in the down-sector. In this review, we summarize the theoretical and experimental status of rare charm $|Δc|=|Δu|=1$ transitions, as well as opportunities for current and future experiments such as LHCb, Belle II, BES III, the FCC-ee and proposed tau-charm factories. We also use the most recent experimental results to report updated limits on lepton-flavour conserving and lepton-flavour violating Wilson coefficients.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2021; v1 submitted 18 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Rare charm $\boldsymbol{c\to u\,ν\barν}$ dineutrino null tests for $\boldsymbol{e^+e^-}$-machines
Authors:
Rigo Bause,
Hector Gisbert,
Marcel Golz,
Gudrun Hiller
Abstract:
Rare $|Δc|=|Δu|=1$ transitions into dineutrinos are strongly GIM-suppressed and constitute excellent null tests of the standard model. While branching ratios of $D \to P \,ν\bar ν$, $D \to P^+ P^- \, ν\bar ν$, $P=π, K$, baryonic $Λ_c^+ \to p \,ν\bar ν$, and $Ξ_c^+ \to Σ^+ \, ν\bar ν$ and inclusive $D \to X ν\bar ν$ decays are experimentally unconstrained, signals of new physics can be just around…
▽ More
Rare $|Δc|=|Δu|=1$ transitions into dineutrinos are strongly GIM-suppressed and constitute excellent null tests of the standard model. While branching ratios of $D \to P \,ν\bar ν$, $D \to P^+ P^- \, ν\bar ν$, $P=π, K$, baryonic $Λ_c^+ \to p \,ν\bar ν$, and $Ξ_c^+ \to Σ^+ \, ν\bar ν$ and inclusive $D \to X ν\bar ν$ decays are experimentally unconstrained, signals of new physics can be just around the corner. We provide model-independent upper limits on branching ratios reaching few $\times 10^{-5}$ in the most general case of arbitrary lepton flavor structure, $\sim 10^{-5}$ for scenarios with charged lepton conservation and few $\times 10^{-6}$ assuming lepton universality. We also give upper limits in $Z^\prime$ and leptoquark models. The presence of light right-handed neutrinos can affect these limits, a possibility that can occur for lepton number violation at a TeV, and that can be excluded with an improved bound on $\mathcal{B}(D^0 \to \text{invisibles})$ at the level of $\sim 10^{-6}$, about two orders of magnitude better than the present one. Signatures of $c \to u ν\bar ν$ modes contain missing energy and are suited for experimental searches at $e^+ e^-$-facilities, such as BES III, Belle II and future $e^+ e^-$-colliders, such as the FCC-ee running at the $Z$.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2021; v1 submitted 5 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Lepton universality and lepton flavor conservation tests with dineutrino modes
Authors:
Rigo Bause,
Hector Gisbert,
Marcel Golz,
Gudrun Hiller
Abstract:
$SU(2)_L$-invariance links charged dilepton and dineutrino couplings. Phenomenological implications are worked out for flavor changing neutral currents involving strange, charm, beauty and top quark transitions in a model-independent way. We put forward novel tests of lepton universality and lepton flavor conservation in $|Δc|= |Δu|=1$ and $|Δb|= |Δq|=1$, $q=d,s…
▽ More
$SU(2)_L$-invariance links charged dilepton and dineutrino couplings. Phenomenological implications are worked out for flavor changing neutral currents involving strange, charm, beauty and top quark transitions in a model-independent way. We put forward novel tests of lepton universality and lepton flavor conservation in $|Δc|= |Δu|=1$ and $|Δb|= |Δq|=1$, $q=d,s$, transitions suitable for the experiments Belle II and BES III. Single top production plus dileptons uniquely probes semileptonic four-fermion $|Δt|= |Δq'|=1$, $q'=u,c$, couplings and further study at the LHC is encouraged. Tests with single top production associated with dileptons and missing energy are suitable for study at future $e^+ e^-$ or muon colliders.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2022; v1 submitted 9 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Exploiting CP-asymmetries in rare charm decays
Authors:
Rigo Bause,
Hector Gisbert,
Marcel Golz,
Gudrun Hiller
Abstract:
We analyze patterns from CP-violating new physics (NP) in hadronic and semileptonic rare charm $\vert Δc \vert=\vert Δu\vert=1$ transitions. Observation of direct CP-violation in hadronic decays, as in $ΔA_{\text{CP}}$, provides opportunities for $c \to u \,\ell^+ \ell^-$, $\ell=e,μ$ transitions, and vice versa. For the concrete case of flavorful, anomaly-free $Z^\prime$-models a NP-interpretation…
▽ More
We analyze patterns from CP-violating new physics (NP) in hadronic and semileptonic rare charm $\vert Δc \vert=\vert Δu\vert=1$ transitions. Observation of direct CP-violation in hadronic decays, as in $ΔA_{\text{CP}}$, provides opportunities for $c \to u \,\ell^+ \ell^-$, $\ell=e,μ$ transitions, and vice versa. For the concrete case of flavorful, anomaly-free $Z^\prime$-models a NP-interpretation of $ΔA_{\text{CP}}$ suggests measurable CP-asymmetries in semileptonic decays such as $D \to π\, \ell^+ \ell^-$ or $D \to ππ\, \ell^+ \ell^-$. Conversely, an observation of CP-violation in $c \to u\, e^+ e^-$ or $c \to u\, μ^+ μ^-$ decays supports a NP--interpretation of $ΔA_{\text{CP}}$. Flavorful $U(1)^\prime$-extensions provide explicit U--spin and isospin breaking which can be probed in patterns of hadronic decays of charm mesons. We work out signatures for CP-asymmetries in $D^0 \to π^+ π^-$, $D^0 \to K^+ K^-$ and $D^0 \to π^0 π^0$, $D^+ \to π^+ π^0$ decays, which can be probed in the future at LHCb and Belle II and provide further informative cross checks.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
The New Physics Reach of Null Tests with $D \to π\ell \ell$ and $D_s \to K \ell \ell $ Decays
Authors:
Rigo Bause,
Marcel Golz,
Gudrun Hiller,
Andrey Tayduganov
Abstract:
$|Δc|=|Δu|=1$ processes are unique probes of flavor physics in the up-sector within and beyond the Standard Model (SM). SM tests with rare semileptonic charm meson decays are based on an approximate CP--symmetry, a superior GIM--mechanism, angular distributions, lepton-universality and lepton flavor conservation. We analyze the complete set of null test observables in $D \to π\ell \ell^{(\prime)}…
▽ More
$|Δc|=|Δu|=1$ processes are unique probes of flavor physics in the up-sector within and beyond the Standard Model (SM). SM tests with rare semileptonic charm meson decays are based on an approximate CP--symmetry, a superior GIM--mechanism, angular distributions, lepton-universality and lepton flavor conservation. We analyze the complete set of null test observables in $D \to π\ell \ell^{(\prime)}$ and $D_s \to K \ell \ell^{(\prime)}$ decays, $\ell^{(\prime)}=e, μ$, and find large room for new physics safely above the SM contribution. We identify signatures of supersymmetry, leptoquarks and anomaly-free $U(1)^\prime$-models with generation-dependent charges, for which we provide explicit examples. $Z^\prime$-effects in $c \to u \ell \ell^{(\prime)}$ transitions can be sizable if both left-handed and right-handed couplings to quarks are present.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2021; v1 submitted 24 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
