-
How Much NEC Breaking Can the Universe Endure?
Authors:
Elly Moghtaderi,
Brayden R. Hull,
Jerome Quintin,
Ghazal Geshnizjani
Abstract:
Quantum fields can notoriously violate the null energy condition (NEC). In a cosmological context, NEC violation can lead to, e.g., dark energy at late times with an equation-of-state parameter smaller than $-1$ and nonsingular bounces at early times. However, it is expected that there should still be a limit in semiclasssical gravity to how much `negative energy' can accumulate over time and in s…
▽ More
Quantum fields can notoriously violate the null energy condition (NEC). In a cosmological context, NEC violation can lead to, e.g., dark energy at late times with an equation-of-state parameter smaller than $-1$ and nonsingular bounces at early times. However, it is expected that there should still be a limit in semiclasssical gravity to how much `negative energy' can accumulate over time and in space as a result of quantum effects. In the course of formulating quantum-motivated energy conditions, the smeared null energy condition has emerged as a recent proposal. This condition conjectures the existence of a semilocal bound on negative energy along null geodesics, which is expected to hold in semiclassical gravity. In this work, we show how the smeared null energy condition translates into theoretical constraints on NEC-violating cosmologies. Specifically, we derive the implied bounds on dark energy equation-of-state parameters and an inequality between the duration of a bouncing phase and the growth rate of the Hubble parameter at the bounce. In the case of dark energy, we identify the parameter space over which the smeared null energy condition is consistent with the recent constraints from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI).
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Cuscuton Bounce Beyond the Linear Regime: Bispectrum and Strong Coupling Constraints
Authors:
Amir Dehghani,
Ghazal Geshnizjani,
Jerome Quintin
Abstract:
Cuscuton Gravity is characterized as a scalar field that can be added to general relativity without introducing any new dynamical degrees of freedom on a cosmological background. Yet, it modifies gravity such that spacetime singularities can be avoided. This has led to the Cuscuton bounce, a nonsingular cosmology that has been shown to be linearly stable, which is a rare feat. Upon introducing mec…
▽ More
Cuscuton Gravity is characterized as a scalar field that can be added to general relativity without introducing any new dynamical degrees of freedom on a cosmological background. Yet, it modifies gravity such that spacetime singularities can be avoided. This has led to the Cuscuton bounce, a nonsingular cosmology that has been shown to be linearly stable, which is a rare feat. Upon introducing mechanisms known to generate a near-scale-invariant power spectrum of isocurvature perturbations in the prebounce contracting phase, we perform an extensive linear analysis of all scalar perturbations as they evolve through the Cuscuton bounce, both analytically and numerically. Then, after deriving the third-order perturbed action for our theory, we compare the magnitude of its terms (on shell) to those in the second-order action. We show that perturbativity is maintained in the infrared throughout the evolution, including through the bounce. In the ultraviolet, we show that a hierarchy of scales is maintained, with the strong coupling scale well above the relevant background energy scale at all times. We reconfirm these results by computing the three-point functions in various limits and demonstrate that the models do not have any strong coupling problems and furthermore that there is negligible non-Gaussianities on observable scales. Consequently, the primary potential source of observable non-Gaussianities may only arise from the conversion of isocurvature perturbations to curvature perturbations. The whole scenario is thus a robust, stable, weakly coupled nonsingular cosmological model, consistent with observations.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2025; v1 submitted 3 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Non-Gaussianities in the Extended EFT of Inflation
Authors:
Amjad Ashoorioon,
Ghazal Geshnizjani,
Hyung J. Kim
Abstract:
In earlier works, we studied the validity of Extended Effective Field Theory of Inflation (EEFToI) in the regime where initial conditions are set with dispersion relations $ω^2 \propto k^6$. We had also evaluated and examined the power spectrum for some interesting corners of the parameter space. In this paper, we compute the bispectrum in the EEFToI, take a closer look at the strong coupling cons…
▽ More
In earlier works, we studied the validity of Extended Effective Field Theory of Inflation (EEFToI) in the regime where initial conditions are set with dispersion relations $ω^2 \propto k^6$. We had also evaluated and examined the power spectrum for some interesting corners of the parameter space. In this paper, we compute the bispectrum in the EEFToI, take a closer look at the strong coupling constraints and calculate the size of the non-Gaussianities in those regions of parameter space. We also investigate the shape of triangles that contribute to the enhancement of non-Gaussianities in this regime. We find that there are allowed parts of parameter spaces where EEFToI description with initial conditions set with $ω^2 \propto k^6$ is sensible and interesting.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2023; v1 submitted 12 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Keeping an Eye on DBI: Power-counting for small-$c_s$ Cosmology
Authors:
Ivana Babic,
C. P. Burgess,
Ghazal Geshnizjani
Abstract:
Inflationary mechanisms for generating primordial fluctuations ultimately compute them as the leading contributions in a derivative expansion, with corrections controlled by powers of derivatives like the Hubble scale over Planck mass: $H/M_p$. At face value this derivative expansion breaks down for models with a small sound speed, $c_s$, to the extent that $c_s \ll 1$ is obtained by having higher…
▽ More
Inflationary mechanisms for generating primordial fluctuations ultimately compute them as the leading contributions in a derivative expansion, with corrections controlled by powers of derivatives like the Hubble scale over Planck mass: $H/M_p$. At face value this derivative expansion breaks down for models with a small sound speed, $c_s$, to the extent that $c_s \ll 1$ is obtained by having higher-derivative interactions like $\mathfrak{L}_{\rm eff} \sim (\partial Φ)^4$ compete with lower-derivative propagation. This concern arises more generally for models whose lagrangian is given as a function $P(X)$ for $X = -\partial_μΦ\partial^μΦ$ --- including in particular DBI models for which $P(X) \propto \sqrt{1-kX}$ --- since these keep all orders in $\partial Φ$ while dropping $\partial^n Φ$ for $n > 1$. We here find a sensible power-counting scheme for DBI models that gives a controlled expansion in powers of three types of small parameters: $H/M_p$, slow-roll parameters (possibly) and $c_s \ll 1$. We do not find a similar expansion framework for generic small-$c_s$ or $P(X)$ models. Our power-counting result quantifies the theoretical error for any prediction (such as for inflationary correlation functions) by fixing the leading power of these small parameters that is dropped when not computing all graphs (such as by restricting to the classical approximation); a prerequisite for meaningful comparisons with observations. The new power-counting regime arises because small $c_s$ alters the kinematics of free fluctuations in a way that changes how interactions scale at low energies, in particular allowing $1-c_s$ to be larger than derivative-measuring quantities like $(H/M_p)^2$.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Getting Super-Excited with Modified Dispersion Relations
Authors:
Amjad Ashoorioon,
Roberto Casadio,
Ghazal Geshnizjani,
Hyung J. Kim
Abstract:
We demonstrate that in some regions of parameter space, modified dispersion relations can lead to highly populated excited states, which we dub as "super-excited" states. In order to prepare such super-excited states, we invoke dispersion relations that have negative slope in an interim sub-horizon phase at high momenta. This behaviour of quantum fluctuations can lead to large corrections relative…
▽ More
We demonstrate that in some regions of parameter space, modified dispersion relations can lead to highly populated excited states, which we dub as "super-excited" states. In order to prepare such super-excited states, we invoke dispersion relations that have negative slope in an interim sub-horizon phase at high momenta. This behaviour of quantum fluctuations can lead to large corrections relative to the Bunch-Davies power spectrum, which mimics highly excited initial conditions. We identify the Bogolyubov coefficients that can yield these power spectra. In the course of this computation, we also point out the shortcomings of the gluing method for evaluating the power spectrum and the Bogolyubov coefficients. As we discuss, there are other regions of parameter space, where the power spectrum does not get modified. Therefore, modified dispersion relations can also lead to so-called "calm excited states" as well. We conclude by commenting on the possibility of obtaining these modified dispersion relations within the Effective Field Theory of Inflation.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2018; v1 submitted 20 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Can non-local or higher derivative theories provide alternatives to inflation?
Authors:
Ghazal Geshnizjani,
Nahid Ahmadi
Abstract:
The standard mechanism for producing the observed scale-invariant power spectrum from adiabatic vacuum fluctuations relies on first order derivative of fields in the action for curvature perturbations. It has been proven \cite{Geshnizjani:2011dk} that, under this ansatz, any theory of early universe that matches cosmological observations should include a phase of accelerated expansion (i.e. inflat…
▽ More
The standard mechanism for producing the observed scale-invariant power spectrum from adiabatic vacuum fluctuations relies on first order derivative of fields in the action for curvature perturbations. It has been proven \cite{Geshnizjani:2011dk} that, under this ansatz, any theory of early universe that matches cosmological observations should include a phase of accelerated expansion (i.e. inflation) or it has to break at least one of the following tenets of classical general relativity: Null Energy Conditions (NEC), subluminal signal propagation, or sub-Planckian energy densities. We extend this proof to a large class of theories with higher (spatial) derivative or non-local terms in the action. Interestingly, only theories in the neighborhood of Lifshitz points with $ω_k \propto k^0$ and $k^3$ remain viable.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2013; v1 submitted 18 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Effect of extra dimensions on gravitational waves from cosmic strings
Authors:
Eimear O'Callaghan,
Sarah Chadburn,
Ghazal Geshnizjani,
Ruth Gregory,
Ivonne Zavala
Abstract:
We show how taking into account the kinematical effect of extra dimensions can have a significant impact on the gravity wave emission from cosmic strings. Additional dimensions both round off cusps, as well as reduce the probability of their formation. We recompute the cusp gravity wave burst with these factors and find a significant dimension dependent damping of the gravity waves.
We show how taking into account the kinematical effect of extra dimensions can have a significant impact on the gravity wave emission from cosmic strings. Additional dimensions both round off cusps, as well as reduce the probability of their formation. We recompute the cusp gravity wave burst with these factors and find a significant dimension dependent damping of the gravity waves.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2010; v1 submitted 23 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
-
Observational Evidence for Cosmological-Scale Extra Dimensions
Authors:
Niayesh Afshordi,
Ghazal Geshnizjani,
Justin Khoury
Abstract:
We present a case that current observations may already indicate new gravitational physics on cosmological scales. The excess of power seen in the Lyman-alpha forest and small-scale CMB experiments, the anomalously large bulk flows seen both in peculiar velocity surveys and in kinetic SZ, and the higher ISW cross-correlation all indicate that structure may be more evolved than expected from LCDM…
▽ More
We present a case that current observations may already indicate new gravitational physics on cosmological scales. The excess of power seen in the Lyman-alpha forest and small-scale CMB experiments, the anomalously large bulk flows seen both in peculiar velocity surveys and in kinetic SZ, and the higher ISW cross-correlation all indicate that structure may be more evolved than expected from LCDM. We argue that these observations find a natural explanation in models with infinite-volume (or, at least, cosmological-size) extra dimensions, where the graviton is a resonance with a tiny width. The longitudinal mode of the graviton mediates an extra scalar force which speeds up structure formation at late times, thereby accounting for the above anomalies. The required graviton Compton wavelength is relatively small compared to the present Hubble radius, of order 300-600 Mpc. Moreover, with certain assumptions about the behavior of the longitudinal mode on super-Hubble scales, our modified gravity framework can also alleviate the tension with the low quadrupole and the peculiar vanishing of the CMB correlation function on large angular scales, seen both in COBE and WMAP. This relies on a novel mechanism that cancels a late-time ISW contribution against the primordial Sachs-Wolfe amplitude.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2009; v1 submitted 12 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
-
Reconstructing a general inflationary action
Authors:
Rachel Bean,
Daniel J. H. Chung,
Ghazal Geshnizjani
Abstract:
If inflation is to be considered in an unbiased way, as possibly originating from one of a wide range of underlying theories, then observations need not be simply applied to reconstructing the inflaton potential, V(φ), or a specific kinetic term, as in DBI inflation, but rather to reconstruct the inflationary action in its entirety. We discuss the constraints that can be placed on a general sing…
▽ More
If inflation is to be considered in an unbiased way, as possibly originating from one of a wide range of underlying theories, then observations need not be simply applied to reconstructing the inflaton potential, V(φ), or a specific kinetic term, as in DBI inflation, but rather to reconstruct the inflationary action in its entirety. We discuss the constraints that can be placed on a general single field action from measurements of the primordial scalar and tensor fluctuation power spectra and non-Gaussianities. We also present the flow equation formalism for reconstructing a general inflationary Lagrangian, L(X,φ), with X={1/2}\partial_μφ\partial^μφ, in a general gauge, that reduces to canonical and DBI inflation in the specific gauge \partial L/\partial X = c_s^{-1}.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2008; v1 submitted 4 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Cuscuton Cosmology: Dark Energy meets Modified Gravity
Authors:
Niayesh Afshordi,
Daniel J. H. Chung,
Michael Doran,
Ghazal Geshnizjani
Abstract:
In a companion paper (hep-th/0609150), we have introduced a model of scalar field dark energy, Cuscuton, which can be realized as the incompressible (or infinite speed of sound) limit of a k-essence fluid. In this paper, we study how Cuscuton modifies the constraint sector of Einstein gravity. In particular, we study Cuscuton cosmology and show that even though Cuscuton can have an arbitrary equ…
▽ More
In a companion paper (hep-th/0609150), we have introduced a model of scalar field dark energy, Cuscuton, which can be realized as the incompressible (or infinite speed of sound) limit of a k-essence fluid. In this paper, we study how Cuscuton modifies the constraint sector of Einstein gravity. In particular, we study Cuscuton cosmology and show that even though Cuscuton can have an arbitrary equation of state, or time dependence, and is thus inhomogeneous; its perturbations do not introduce any additional dynamical degree of freedom and only satisfy a constraint equation, amounting to an effective modification of gravity on large scales. Therefore, Cuscuton can be considered to be a minimal theory of evolving dark energy, or a minimal modification of a cosmological constant, as it has no internal dynamics. Moreover, this is the only modification of Einstein gravity to our knowledge that does not introduce any additional degrees freedom (and is not conformally equivalent to the Einstein gravity). We then study two simple Cuscuton models, with quadratic and exponential potentials. The quadratic model has the exact same expansion history as LCDM, and yet contains an early dark energy component with constant energy fraction, which is constrained to < 2%, mainly from WMAP Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and SDSS Lyman-alpha forest observations. The exponential model has the same expansion history as the DGP self-accelerating braneworld model, but generates a much smaller Integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) effect, and is thus consistent with the CMB observations. Finally, we show that the evolution is local on super-horizon scales, implying that there is no gross violation of causality, despite Cuscuton's infinite speed of sound.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2007; v1 submitted 1 February, 2007;
originally announced February 2007.
-
Cuscuton: A Causal Field Theory with an Infinite Speed of Sound
Authors:
Niayesh Afshordi,
Daniel J. H. Chung,
Ghazal Geshnizjani
Abstract:
We introduce a model of scalar field dark energy, Cuscuton, which can be realized as the incompressible (or infinite speed of sound) limit of a scalar field theory with a non-canonical kinetic term (or k-essence). Even though perturbations of Cuscuton propagate superluminally, we show that they have a locally degenerate phase space volume (or zero entropy), implying that they cannot carry any mi…
▽ More
We introduce a model of scalar field dark energy, Cuscuton, which can be realized as the incompressible (or infinite speed of sound) limit of a scalar field theory with a non-canonical kinetic term (or k-essence). Even though perturbations of Cuscuton propagate superluminally, we show that they have a locally degenerate phase space volume (or zero entropy), implying that they cannot carry any microscopic information, and thus the theory is causal. Even coupling to ordinary scalar fields cannot lead to superluminal signal propagation. Furthermore, we show that the family of constant field hypersurfaces are the family of Constant Mean Curvature (CMC) hypersurfaces, which are the analogs of soap films (or soap bubbles) in a Euclidian space. This enables us to find the most general solution in 1+1 dimensions, whose properties motivate conjectures for global degeneracy of the phase space in higher dimensions. Finally, we show that the Cuscuton action can model the continuum limit of the evolution of a field with discrete degrees of freedom and argue why it is protected against quantum corrections at low energies. While this paper mainly focuses on interesting features of Cuscuton in a Minkowski spacetime, a companion paper (astro-ph/0702002) examines cosmology with Cuscuton dark energy.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2007; v1 submitted 21 September, 2006;
originally announced September 2006.
-
A Note on Perturbations During a Regular Bounce
Authors:
Ghazal Geshnizjani,
Thorsten J. Battefeld
Abstract:
We point out an inconsistency in a method used in the literature for studying adiabatic scalar perturbations in a regular bouncing universe (in four dimensions). The method under scrutiny consists of splitting the Bardeen potential into two pieces with independent evolutions, in order to avoid a singular behavior at the boundaries of the region where the null energy condition (NEC) is violated.…
▽ More
We point out an inconsistency in a method used in the literature for studying adiabatic scalar perturbations in a regular bouncing universe (in four dimensions). The method under scrutiny consists of splitting the Bardeen potential into two pieces with independent evolutions, in order to avoid a singular behavior at the boundaries of the region where the null energy condition (NEC) is violated. However, we argue that this method violates energy-momentum conservation. We then introduce a novel method which provides two independent solutions for the Bardeen potential around the boundaries, even in the case of adiabatic perturbations. The two solutions are well behaved and not divergent.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2005;
originally announced June 2005.
-
Perturbations in a regular bouncing Universe
Authors:
T. J. Battefeld,
G. Geshnizjani
Abstract:
We consider a simple toy model of a regular bouncing universe. The bounce is caused by an extra time-like dimension, which leads to a sign flip of the $ρ^2$ term in the effective four dimensional Randall Sundrum-like description. We find a wide class of possible bounces: big bang avoiding ones for regular matter content, and big rip avoiding ones for phantom matter.
Focusing on radiation as th…
▽ More
We consider a simple toy model of a regular bouncing universe. The bounce is caused by an extra time-like dimension, which leads to a sign flip of the $ρ^2$ term in the effective four dimensional Randall Sundrum-like description. We find a wide class of possible bounces: big bang avoiding ones for regular matter content, and big rip avoiding ones for phantom matter.
Focusing on radiation as the matter content, we discuss the evolution of scalar, vector and tensor perturbations. We compute a spectral index of $n_s=-1$ for scalar perturbations and a deep blue index for tensor perturbations after invoking vacuum initial conditions, ruling out such a model as a realistic one. We also find that the spectrum (evaluated at Hubble crossing) is sensitive to the bounce. We conclude that it is challenging, but not impossible, for cyclic/ekpyrotic models to succeed, if one can find a regularized version.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2006; v1 submitted 21 March, 2005;
originally announced March 2005.
-
Do Large-Scale Inhomogeneities Explain Away Dark Energy?
Authors:
Ghazal Geshnizjani,
Daniel J. H. Chung,
Niayesh Afshordi
Abstract:
Recently, new arguments (astro-ph/0501152, hep-th/0503117) for how corrections from super-Hubble modes can explain the present-day acceleration of the universe have appeared in the literature. However, in this letter, we argue that, to second order in spatial gradients, these corrections only amount to a renormalization of local spatial curvature, and thus cannot account for the negative deceler…
▽ More
Recently, new arguments (astro-ph/0501152, hep-th/0503117) for how corrections from super-Hubble modes can explain the present-day acceleration of the universe have appeared in the literature. However, in this letter, we argue that, to second order in spatial gradients, these corrections only amount to a renormalization of local spatial curvature, and thus cannot account for the negative deceleration. Moreover, cosmological observations already put severe bounds on such corrections, at the level of a few percent, while in the context of inflationary models, these corrections are typically limited to ~ 10^{-5}. Currently there is no general constraint on the possible correction from higher order gradient terms, but we argue that such corrections are even more constrained in the context of inflationary models.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2005; v1 submitted 24 March, 2005;
originally announced March 2005.
-
Coarse-Grained Back Reaction in Single Scalar Field Driven Inflation
Authors:
Ghazal Geshnizjani,
Niayesh Afshordi
Abstract:
We introduce a self-consistent stochastic coarse-graining method, which includes both metric and scalar field fluctuations, to investigate the back reaction of long wavelength perturbations in single-scalar driven inflation, up to the second (one loop) order. We demonstrate that, although back reaction cannot be significant during the last 70 e-foldings of inflation with a smooth potential, ther…
▽ More
We introduce a self-consistent stochastic coarse-graining method, which includes both metric and scalar field fluctuations, to investigate the back reaction of long wavelength perturbations in single-scalar driven inflation, up to the second (one loop) order. We demonstrate that, although back reaction cannot be significant during the last 70 e-foldings of inflation with a smooth potential, there exist non-smooth inflaton potentials which allow significant back reaction, and are also consistent with cosmological observations. Such non-smooth potentials may lead to the generation of massive primordial black holes, which could be further used to constrain/verify these models.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2004;
originally announced May 2004.
-
On the Initial Conditions for Brane Inflation
Authors:
R. Brandenberger,
G. Geshnizjani,
S. Watson
Abstract:
String theory gives rise to various mechanisms to generate primordial inflation, of which ``brane inflation'' is one of the most widely considered. In this scenario, inflation takes place while two branes are approaching each other, and the modulus field representing the separation between the branes plays the role of the inflaton field. We study the phase space of initial conditions which can l…
▽ More
String theory gives rise to various mechanisms to generate primordial inflation, of which ``brane inflation'' is one of the most widely considered. In this scenario, inflation takes place while two branes are approaching each other, and the modulus field representing the separation between the branes plays the role of the inflaton field. We study the phase space of initial conditions which can lead to a sufficiently long period of cosmological inflation, and find that taking into account the possibility of nonvanishing initial momentum can significantly change the degree of fine tuning of the required initial conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2003; v1 submitted 27 February, 2003;
originally announced February 2003.
-
Back Reaction And Local Cosmological Expansion Rate
Authors:
Ghazal Geshnizjani,
Robert Brandenberger
Abstract:
We calculate the back reaction of cosmological perturbations on a general relativistic variable which measures the local expansion rate of the Universe. Specifically, we consider a cosmological model in which matter is described by a single field. We analyze back reaction both in a matter dominated Universe and in a phase of scalar field-driven chaotic inflation. In both cases, we find that the…
▽ More
We calculate the back reaction of cosmological perturbations on a general relativistic variable which measures the local expansion rate of the Universe. Specifically, we consider a cosmological model in which matter is described by a single field. We analyze back reaction both in a matter dominated Universe and in a phase of scalar field-driven chaotic inflation. In both cases, we find that the leading infrared terms contributing to the back reaction vanish when the local expansion rate is measured at a fixed value of the matter field which is used as a clock, whereas they do not appear to vanish if the expansion rate is evaluated at a fixed value of the background time. We discuss possible implications for more realistic models with a more complicated matter sector.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2002;
originally announced April 2002.
