-
Comment on "Evidence for dark matter in the inner Milky Way"
Authors:
Stacy McGaugh,
Federico Lelli,
Marcel Pawlowski,
Garry Angus,
Olivier Bienaymé,
Joss Bland-Hawthorn,
Erwin de Blok,
Benoit Famaey,
Filippo Fraternali,
Ken Freeman,
Gianfranco Gentile,
Rodrigo Ibata,
Pavel Kroupa,
Fabian Lüghausen,
Paul McMillan,
David Merritt,
Ivan Minchev,
Giacomo Monari,
Elena D'Onghia,
Alice Quillen,
Bob Sanders,
Jerry Sellwood,
Arnaud Siebert,
Hongsheng Zhao
Abstract:
This is a brief rebuttal to arXiv:1502.03821, which claims to provide the first observational proof of dark matter interior to the solar circle. We point out that this result is not new, and can be traced back at least a quarter century.
This is a brief rebuttal to arXiv:1502.03821, which claims to provide the first observational proof of dark matter interior to the solar circle. We point out that this result is not new, and can be traced back at least a quarter century.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2015; v1 submitted 26 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Constraining the Galaxy's dark halo with RAVE stars
Authors:
T. Piffl,
J. Binney,
P. J. McMillan,
M. Steinmetz,
A. Helmi,
R. F. G. Wyse,
O. Bienaymé,
J. Bland-Hawthorn,
K. Freeman,
B. Gibson,
G. Gilmore,
E. K. Grebel,
G. Kordopatis,
J. F. Navarro,
Q. Parker,
W. A. Reid,
G. Seabroke,
A. Siebert,
F. Watson,
T. Zwitter
Abstract:
We use the kinematics of $\sim200\,000$ giant stars that lie within $\sim 1.5$ kpc of the plane to measure the vertical profile of mass density near the Sun. We find that the dark mass contained within the isodensity surface of the dark halo that passes through the Sun ($(6\pm0.9)\times10^{10}\,\mathrm{M_\odot}$), and the surface density within $0.9$ kpc of the plane (…
▽ More
We use the kinematics of $\sim200\,000$ giant stars that lie within $\sim 1.5$ kpc of the plane to measure the vertical profile of mass density near the Sun. We find that the dark mass contained within the isodensity surface of the dark halo that passes through the Sun ($(6\pm0.9)\times10^{10}\,\mathrm{M_\odot}$), and the surface density within $0.9$ kpc of the plane ($(69\pm10)\,\mathrm{M_\odot\,pc^{-2}}$) are almost independent of the (oblate) halo's axis ratio $q$. If the halo is spherical, 46 per cent of the radial force on the Sun is provided by baryons, and only 4.3 per cent of the Galaxy's mass is baryonic. If the halo is flattened, the baryons contribute even less strongly to the local radial force and to the Galaxy's mass. The dark-matter density at the location of the Sun is $0.0126\,q^{-0.89}\,\mathrm{M_\odot\,pc^{-3}}=0.48\,q^{-0.89}\,\mathrm{GeV\,cm^{-3}}$. When combined with other literature results we find hints for a mildly oblate dark halo with $q \simeq 0.8$. Our value for the dark mass within the solar radius is larger than that predicted by cosmological dark-matter-only simulations but in good agreement with simulations once the effects of baryonic infall are taken into account. Our mass models consist of three double-exponential discs, an oblate bulge and a Navarro-Frenk-White dark-matter halo, and we model the dynamics of the RAVE stars in the corresponding gravitational fields by finding distribution functions $f(\mathbf{J})$ that depend on three action integrals. Statistical errors are completely swamped by systematic uncertainties, the most important of which are the distance to the stars in the photometric and spectroscopic samples and the solar distance to the Galactic centre. Systematics other than the flattening of the dark halo yield overall uncertainties $\sim 15$ per cent.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2014; v1 submitted 16 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
The MACHO Project LMC Microlensing Results from the First Two Years and the Nature of the Galactic Dark Halo
Authors:
C. Alcock,
R. A. Allsman,
D. Alves,
T. S. Axelrod,
A. C. Becker,
D. P. Bennett,
K. H. Cook,
K. C. Freeman,
K. Griest,
J. Guern,
M. J. Lehner,
S. L. Marshall,
B. A. Peterson,
M. R. Pratt,
P. J. Quinn,
A. W. Rodgers,
C. W. Stubbs,
W. Sutherland,
D. L. Welch
Abstract:
The MACHO Project is a search for dark matter in the form of massive compact halo objects (Machos). Photometric monitoring of millions of stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC), and Galactic bulge is used to search for gravitational microlensing events caused by these otherwise invisible objects. Analysis of the first 2.1 years of photometry of 8.5 million stars…
▽ More
The MACHO Project is a search for dark matter in the form of massive compact halo objects (Machos). Photometric monitoring of millions of stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC), and Galactic bulge is used to search for gravitational microlensing events caused by these otherwise invisible objects. Analysis of the first 2.1 years of photometry of 8.5 million stars in the LMC reveals 8 candidate microlensing events. This is substantially more than the number expected ($\sim 1.1$) from lensing by known stellar populations. The timescales ($\that$) of the events range from 34 to 145 days. We estimate the total microlensing optical depth towards the LMC from events with $2 < \that < 200$ days to be $τ_2^{200} = 2.9 ^{+1.4}_{-0.9} \ten{-7}$ based upon our 8 event sample. This exceeds the optical depth, $τ_{\rm backgnd} = 0.5 \ten{-7}$, expected from known stars, and the difference is to be compared with the optical depth predicted for a ``standard" halo composed entirely of Machos: $τ_{halo} = 4.7\ten{-7}$. Likelihood analysis gives a fairly model independent estimate of the halo mass in Machos within 50 kpc of $2.0^{+1.2}_{-0.7} \ten{11} \msun$, about half of the ``standard halo" value. We also find a most probable Macho mass of $0.5^{+0.3}_{-0.2}\msun$, although this value is strongly model dependent. Additionally, the absence of short duration events places stringent upper limits on the contribution of low-mass Machos: objects from $10^{-4} \msun$ to $0.03 \msun$ contribute $\simlt 20\%$ of the ``standard" dark halo.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 1996;
originally announced June 1996.
-
The MACHO Project: Limits on Planetary Mass Dark Matter in the Galactic Halo from Gravitational Microlensing
Authors:
C. Alcock,
R. A. Allsman,
D. Alves,
T. S. Axelrod,
A. Becker,
D. P. Bennett,
K. H. Cook,
K. C. Freeman,
K. Griest,
J. Guern,
M. J. Lehner,
S. L. Marshall,
B. A. Peterson,
M. R. Pratt,
P. J. Quinn,
A. W. Rodgers,
C. W. Stubbs,
W. Sutherland
Abstract:
The MACHO project has been monitoring about ten million stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud in the search for gravitational microlensing events caused by massive compact halo objects (Machos) in the halo of the Milky Way. In our standard analysis, we have searched this data set for well sampled, long duration microlensing lightcurves, detected several microlensing events consistent with Machos i…
▽ More
The MACHO project has been monitoring about ten million stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud in the search for gravitational microlensing events caused by massive compact halo objects (Machos) in the halo of the Milky Way. In our standard analysis, we have searched this data set for well sampled, long duration microlensing lightcurves, detected several microlensing events consistent with Machos in the 0.1 < m < 1.0 M_sun mass range, and set limits on the abundance of objects with masses 1e-5 < m < 0.1 M_sun. In this paper, we present a different type of analysis involving the search for very short time scale brightenings of stars which is used to set strong limits on the abundance of lower mass Machos. Our analysis of the first two years of data toward the LMC indicates that Machos with masses in the range 2.5e-7 < m < 5.2e-4 M_sun cannot make up the entire mass of a standard spherical dark halo. Combining these results with those from the standard analysis, we find that the halo dark matter may not be comprised of objects with masses 2.5e-7 < m < 8.1e-2 M_sun.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 1996;
originally announced April 1996.
-
The MACHO Project First Year LMC Results: The Microlensing Rate and the Nature of the Galactic Dark Halo
Authors:
C. Alcock,
R. A. Allsman,
T. S. Axelrod,
D. P. Bennett,
K. H. Cook,
K. C. Freeman,
K. Griest,
J. A. Guern,
M. J. Lehner,
S. L. Marshall,
H. -S. Park,
S. Perlmutter,
B. A. Peterson,
M. R. Pratt,
P. J. Quinn,
A. W. Rodgers,
C. W. Stubbs,
W. Sutherland
Abstract:
The MACHO collaboration reports on the analysis of our first year LMC data, 9.5 million light curves with an average of 235 observations each. Automated selection procedures give 3 events consistent with microlensing. We evaluate our experimental detection efficiency using a range of Monte- Carlo simulations. Using a `standard' halo density profile we find that a halo comprised entirely of Macho…
▽ More
The MACHO collaboration reports on the analysis of our first year LMC data, 9.5 million light curves with an average of 235 observations each. Automated selection procedures give 3 events consistent with microlensing. We evaluate our experimental detection efficiency using a range of Monte- Carlo simulations. Using a `standard' halo density profile we find that a halo comprised entirely of Machos in the mass range 3 \ten{-4} to 0.06 \msun would predict > 15 detected events in this dataset; thus a standard spherical halo cannot be dominated by objects in this mass range. Assuming all three events are microlensing of halo objects and fitting a naive spherical halo model to our data yields a Macho halo fraction f =0.19+0.16-0.10, a total mass in Machos (inside 50 kpc) of 7.6+6-4 \ten{10} \msun, and a microlensing optical depth 8.8+7-5 \ten{-8} (68\% CL). Exploring a wide range of halo models we find that our constraints on the Macho fraction are quite model-dependent, but constraints on the total mass in Machos within 50 kpc are quite secure.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 1995;
originally announced June 1995.
-
MACHO COLLABORATION SEARCH FOR BARYONIC DARK MATTER VIA GRAVITATIONAL MICROLENSING
Authors:
K. Griest,
C. Alcock,
R. A. Allsman,
T. S. Axelrod,
D. P. Bennett,
K. H. Cook,
K. C. Freeman,
J. Guern,
M. Lehner,
S. L. Marshall,
S. Perlmutter,
B. A. Peterson,
M. R. Pratt,
P. J. Quinn,
A. W. Rodgers,
C. W. Stubbs,
W. Sutherland,
D. Welch
Abstract:
Results are presented from the MACHO collaboration gravitational microlensing search. The experiment and the nearly 50 microlensing events that have been detected are described. Limits on the baryonic content of the halo are given, as are estimates of the Macho contribution to the dark halo. Optical depths toward the bulge, and several unusual events such as a binary lens and a parallax event ar…
▽ More
Results are presented from the MACHO collaboration gravitational microlensing search. The experiment and the nearly 50 microlensing events that have been detected are described. Limits on the baryonic content of the halo are given, as are estimates of the Macho contribution to the dark halo. Optical depths toward the bulge, and several unusual events such as a binary lens and a parallax event are discussed. Possible interpretations of these results are also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 1995;
originally announced June 1995.
-
EXPERIMENTAL LIMITS ON THE DARK MATTER HALO OF THE GALAXY FROM GRAVITATIONAL MICROLENSING.
Authors:
C. Alcock,
R. A. Allsman,
T. S. Axelrod,
D. P. Bennett,
K. H. Cook,
K. C. Freeman,
K. Griest,
J. A. Guern,
M. J. Lehner,
S. L. Marshall,
H. -S. Park,
S. Perlmutter,
B. A. Peterson,
M. R. Pratt,
P. J. Quinn,
A. W. Rodgers,
C. W. Stubbs,
W. Sutherland,
.
Abstract:
We have monitored 8.6 million stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud for 1.1 years and have found 3 events consistent with gravitational microlensing. We place strong constraints on the Galactic halo content in the form of compact lensing objects in the mass range $10^{-4} \msun$ to $10^{-1} \msun$. Three events is fewer than expected for a standard spherical halo of objects in this mass range, but a…
▽ More
We have monitored 8.6 million stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud for 1.1 years and have found 3 events consistent with gravitational microlensing. We place strong constraints on the Galactic halo content in the form of compact lensing objects in the mass range $10^{-4} \msun$ to $10^{-1} \msun$. Three events is fewer than expected for a standard spherical halo of objects in this mass range, but appears to exceed the number expected from known Galactic populations. Fitting a naive spherical halo model to our data yields a MACHO fraction $f = 0.20^{+0.33}_{-0.14}$, which implies a total MACHO mass (inside 50 kpc) of $8.0^{+14}_{-6}\ten{10} \msun$, and a microlensing optical depth $9^{+15}_{-7} \ten{-8}$ ($\sim 68$\% CL).
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 1995;
originally announced January 1995.
-
Theory of Exploring the Dark Halo with Microlensing 1: Power--Law Models
Authors:
C. Alcock,
R. A. Allsman,
T. S. Axelrod,
D. P. Bennett,
K. H. Cook,
N. W. Evans,
K. C. Freeman,
K. Griest,
J. Jijina,
M. Lehner,
S. L. Marshall,
S. Perlmutter,
B. A. Peterson,
M. R. Pratt,
P. J. Quinn,
A. W. Rodgers,
C. W. Stubbs,
W. Sutherland
Abstract:
The detection of microlensing has opened the way for the development of new methods in galactic astronomy. This series of papers investigates what microlensing can teach us about the structure and shape of the dark halo. In this paper we present formulas for the microlensing rate, optical depth and event duration distributions for a simple set of axisymmetric disk-halo models. The halos are base…
▽ More
The detection of microlensing has opened the way for the development of new methods in galactic astronomy. This series of papers investigates what microlensing can teach us about the structure and shape of the dark halo. In this paper we present formulas for the microlensing rate, optical depth and event duration distributions for a simple set of axisymmetric disk-halo models. The halos are based on the "power--law models" which have simple velocity distributions. Using these models, we show that there is a large uncertainty in the predicted microlensing rate because of uncertainty in the halo parameters. For example, models which reproduce the measured galactic observables to within their errors still differ in microlensing rate towards the Magellanic Clouds by more than a factor of ten. We find that while the more easily computed optical depth correlates well with microlensing rate, the ratio of optical depth to rate can vary by a factor of two (or greater if the disk is maximal). Comparison of microlensing rates towards the Large and Small Magellanic Clouds (LMC and SMC) and M31 can be used to aid determinations of the halo flattening and rotation curve slope. For example, the ratio of microlensing rates towards the LMC and SMC is $\sim 0.7-0.8$ for E0 halos and $\sim 1.0 - 1.2$ for E7 halos (c.f. Sackett \& Gould 1993). Once the flattening has been established, the ratio of microlensing rates towards M31 and the LMC may help to distinguish between models with rising, flat or falling rotation curves. Comparison of rates along LMC and galactic bulge lines-of-sight gives useful information on the halo core radius, although this may not be so easy to extract in practice. Maximal disk models provide substantially smaller halo optical depths, shorter event durations and even larger model uncertainties.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 1994;
originally announced November 1994.
-
Possible Gravitational Microlensing of a Star in the Large Magellanic Cloud
Authors:
C. Alcock,
C. W. Akerlof,
R. A. Allsman,
T. S. Axelrod,
D. P. Bennett,
S. Chan,
K. H. Cook,
K. C. Freeman,
K. Griest,
S. L. Marshall,
H-S. Park,
S. Perlmutter,
B. A. Peterson,
M. R. Pratt,
P. J. Quinn,
A. W. Rodgers,
C. W. Stubbs,
W. Sutherland
Abstract:
There is now abundant evidence for the presence of large quantities of unseen matter surrounding normal galaxies, including our own$^{1,2}$. The nature of this `dark matter' is unknown, except that it cannot be made of normal stars, dust, or gas, as they would be easily detected. Exotic particles such as axions, massive neutrinos or other weakly interacting massive particles (collectively known…
▽ More
There is now abundant evidence for the presence of large quantities of unseen matter surrounding normal galaxies, including our own$^{1,2}$. The nature of this `dark matter' is unknown, except that it cannot be made of normal stars, dust, or gas, as they would be easily detected. Exotic particles such as axions, massive neutrinos or other weakly interacting massive particles (collectively known as WIMPs) have been proposed)$^{3,4}$, but have yet to be detected. A less exotic alternative is normal matter in the form of bodies with masses ranging from that of a large planet to a few $ \msun$. Such objects, known collectively as massive compact halo objects$^5$ (MACHOs) might be brown dwarfs or `Jupiters' (bodies too small to produce their own energy by fusion), neutron stars, old white dwarfs, or black holes. Paczynski$^6$ suggested that MACHOs might act as gravitational microlenses, occasionally causing the apparent brightness of distant background stars temporarily to increase. We are conducting a microlensing experiment to determine whether the dark matter halo of our galaxy is made up of MACHOs. Here we report a candidate for a microlensing event, detected by monitoring the light curves of 1.8 million stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud for one year. The light curve shows no variation for most of the year of data taking, and an upward excursion lasting over 1 month, with a maximum increase of $\approx \bf 2$ mag. The most probable lens mass, inferred from the duration of the event, is $\bf \sim 0.1 \,\msun$.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 1993;
originally announced September 1993.
