-
Neutrino Theory in the Precision Era
Authors:
Asmaa Abada,
Gabriela Barenboim,
Toni Bertólez-Martínez,
Sandipan Bhattacherjee,
Sara Bolognesi,
Patrick D. Bolton,
Nilay Bostan,
Gustavo C. Branco,
Sabya Sachi Chatterjee,
Adriano Cherchiglia,
Marco Chianese,
B. A. Couto e Silva,
Peter B. Denton,
Stephen Dolan,
Marco Drewes,
Ilham El Atmani,
Miguel Escudero,
Ivan Esteban,
Manuel Ettengruber,
Enrique Fernández-Martínez,
Julien Froustey,
Raj Gandhi,
Julia Gehrlein,
Srubabati Goswami,
André de Gouvêa
, et al. (54 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This document summarises discussions on future directions in theoretical neutrino physics, which are the outcome of a neutrino theory workshop held at CERN in February 2025. The starting point is the realisation that neutrino physics offers unique opportunities to address some of the most fundamental questions in physics. This motivates a vigorous experimental programme which the theory community…
▽ More
This document summarises discussions on future directions in theoretical neutrino physics, which are the outcome of a neutrino theory workshop held at CERN in February 2025. The starting point is the realisation that neutrino physics offers unique opportunities to address some of the most fundamental questions in physics. This motivates a vigorous experimental programme which the theory community fully supports. \textbf{A strong effort in theoretical neutrino physics is paramount to optimally take advantage of upcoming neutrino experiments and to explore the synergies with other areas of particle, astroparticle, and nuclear physics, as well as cosmology.} Progress on the theory side has the potential to significantly boost the physics reach of experiments, as well as go well beyond their original scope. Strong collaboration between theory and experiment is essential in the precision era. To foster such collaboration, \textbf{we propose to establish a CERN Neutrino Physics Centre.} Taking inspiration from the highly successful LHC Physics Center at Fermilab, the CERN Neutrino Physics Centre would be the European hub of the neutrino community, covering experimental and theoretical activities.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Neutrino Masses and Phenomenology in Nnaturalness
Authors:
Manuel Ettengruber
Abstract:
In this paper, it is shown that $N$naturalness scenarios have an intrinsic mechanism to suppress neutrino masses. As in other infrared neutrino mass models like extra-dimensional theories or many species theories, the large number of mixing partners is responsible for the neutrino mass suppression. It is shown how neutrino mass matrices arise in $N$naturalness models and the resulting neutrino mix…
▽ More
In this paper, it is shown that $N$naturalness scenarios have an intrinsic mechanism to suppress neutrino masses. As in other infrared neutrino mass models like extra-dimensional theories or many species theories, the large number of mixing partners is responsible for the neutrino mass suppression. It is shown how neutrino mass matrices arise in $N$naturalness models and the resulting neutrino mixing is analyzed. The first result is that a totally democratic coupling among the different sectors like in the original models is already ruled out by the fact that neutrinos are not massless. In the case where the sector couplings deviate from the intersector ones a tower of additional neutrino mass eigenstates appears whose difference between the squared masses, $Δm_{ij}^2$, is determined fully by the theory. The resulting phenomenology of such a tower is investigated and the unique signals in neutrino oscillation experiments, neutrino mass measurements, and neutrinoless double beta decay experiments are discussed. This opens the door for terrestrial tests of $N$naturalness whose phenomenology was so far focused on Cosmology.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Constraints on non-unitary neutrino mixing in light of atmospheric and reactor neutrino data
Authors:
Tetiana Kozynets,
Philipp Eller,
Alan Zander,
Manuel Ettengruber,
D. Jason Koskinen
Abstract:
While the origin of neutrino masses remains unknown, several key neutrino mass generation models result in a non-unitary three-neutrino mixing matrix. To put such models to test, the deviations of the mixing matrix from unitarity can be measured directly through neutrino oscillation experiments. In this study, we perform a Bayesian analysis of the non-unitary mixing model using the recent public d…
▽ More
While the origin of neutrino masses remains unknown, several key neutrino mass generation models result in a non-unitary three-neutrino mixing matrix. To put such models to test, the deviations of the mixing matrix from unitarity can be measured directly through neutrino oscillation experiments. In this study, we perform a Bayesian analysis of the non-unitary mixing model using the recent public data from atmospheric and reactor neutrino experiments - namely IceCube-DeepCore, Daya Bay, and KamLAND. The novelty of our approach compared to the preceding global fits for non-unitarity is in the detailed treatment of the atmospheric neutrino data, which for the first time includes the relevant flux and detector systematic uncertainties. From the Bayesian posteriors on the individual mixing matrix elements, we derive the non-unitarity constraints in the form of normalisations and closures of the mixing matrix rows and columns, assuming either a fully unconstrained matrix or a physically motivated submatrix scenario. We find comparable constraints for electron and tau row normalisations as other similar studies in literature, and additionally reveal strong correlations between muon and tau row constraints induced by the atmospheric systematic uncertainties. We find that the current data is well described by both unitary and non-unitary mixing models, with a strong preference for the unitary mixing indicated by the Bayes factor. With the upcoming IceCube-Upgrade and JUNO detectors, both featuring superior energy resolution compared to the current atmospheric and reactor neutrino experiments, our constraints on the row normalisations in the submatrix case are expected to improve by 25%, 40%, and 20% in the electron, muon, and tau sectors respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2025; v1 submitted 29 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Testing the Number of Neutrino Species with a Global Fit of Neutrino Data
Authors:
Manuel Ettengruber,
Alan Zander,
Philipp Eller
Abstract:
We present the first experimental constraints on models with many additional neutrino species in an analysis of current neutrino data. These types of models are motivated as a solution to the hierarchy problem by lowering the species scale of gravity to TeV. Additionally, they offer a natural mechanism to generate small neutrino masses and provide interesting dark matter candidates. This study ana…
▽ More
We present the first experimental constraints on models with many additional neutrino species in an analysis of current neutrino data. These types of models are motivated as a solution to the hierarchy problem by lowering the species scale of gravity to TeV. Additionally, they offer a natural mechanism to generate small neutrino masses and provide interesting dark matter candidates. This study analyzes data from DayaBay, KamLAND, MINOS, NOvA and KATRIN. We do not find evidence for the presence of any additional neutrino species, therefore we report lower bounds on the allowed number of neutrino species realized in nature. For the normal/inverted neutrino mass ordering, we can give a lower bound on the number of neutrino species of O(30) and O(100), respectively, over a large range of the parameter space.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Kaluza-Klein Spectroscopy from Neutron Oscillations into Hidden Dimensions
Authors:
Gia Dvali,
Manuel Ettengruber,
Anja Stuhlfauth
Abstract:
Neutrons and neutrinos are natural probes for new physics. Since they carry no conserved gauge quantum numbers, both can easily mix with the fermions from hidden sectors. A particularly interesting effect is the oscillation of a neutron or a neutrino into a fermion propagating in large extra dimensions. In fact, such a mixing has been identified as the possible origin of small neutrino mass. In th…
▽ More
Neutrons and neutrinos are natural probes for new physics. Since they carry no conserved gauge quantum numbers, both can easily mix with the fermions from hidden sectors. A particularly interesting effect is the oscillation of a neutron or a neutrino into a fermion propagating in large extra dimensions. In fact, such a mixing has been identified as the possible origin of small neutrino mass. In this paper, we study neutron oscillations into an extra-dimensional fermion and show that this effect provides a resonance imaging of the Kaluza-Klein tower. The remarkable feature of this phenomenon is its generic nature: because of a fine spacing of the Kaluza-Klein tower, neutrons at a variety of energy levels, both free or within nuclei, find a bulk oscillation partner. In particular, the partner can be a Kaluza-Klein mode of the same species that gives mass to the neutrino. The existence of bulk states matching the neutron energy levels of nuclear spectra gives rise to tight constraints as well as to potentially observable effects. For a free neutron, we predict recurrent resonant oscillations occurring with the values of the magnetic field correlated with the KK levels. We derive bounds on extra dimensions from ultra-cold neutron experiments and suggest signatures for refined measurements, which, in particular, can probe the parameter space motivated by the Hierarchy Problem. Ultra-cold neutron experiments offer a unique way of Kaluza-Klein spectroscopy.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
How Many Dark Neutrino Sectors Does Cosmology Allow?
Authors:
Alan Zander,
Manuel Ettengruber,
Philipp Eller
Abstract:
We present the very first constraints on the number of Standard Model (SM) copies with an additional Dirac right-handed neutrino. From cosmology, we are able to pose strong limits on large regions of the parameter space. Moreover, we show that it is possible to account for the right dark matter density in form of stable particles from the dark sectors.
We present the very first constraints on the number of Standard Model (SM) copies with an additional Dirac right-handed neutrino. From cosmology, we are able to pose strong limits on large regions of the parameter space. Moreover, we show that it is possible to account for the right dark matter density in form of stable particles from the dark sectors.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2024; v1 submitted 1 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Consequences of Multiple Axions in Theories with Dark Yang-Mills Groups
Authors:
Manuel Ettengruber,
Emmanouil Koutsangelas
Abstract:
General consistency requirements of Quantum Gravity demand the existence of one axion per Yang-Mills group. In this work, we consider theories with dark Yang-Mills sectors and investigate general phenomenological implications of these necessary axions. We carry out computations for two simple models, namely a pure Yang-Mills sector and $N$ exact Standard Model copies. For the former, the misalignm…
▽ More
General consistency requirements of Quantum Gravity demand the existence of one axion per Yang-Mills group. In this work, we consider theories with dark Yang-Mills sectors and investigate general phenomenological implications of these necessary axions. We carry out computations for two simple models, namely a pure Yang-Mills sector and $N$ exact Standard Model copies. For the former, the misalignment mechanism results in a minimal dark confinement scale $Λ_{\rm conf} \gtrsim 1 \, {\rm eV}$ if the dark sector axion is supposed to make up the dark matter. For the latter, the misalignment mechanism without fine-tuning of the initial misalignment angle places an upper bound on $N$ below the species bound. When the PQ symmetries are broken during inflation, the collective isocurvature fluctuations do not necessarily tighten the bound on the inflationary Hubble scale arising from a single axion. We also point out that axion stars collectively made from axions of different dark sectors with a suppressed mass spectrum are not possible. Lastly, for the two models at hand, intersector interaction through axion kinetic mixing leads to the existence of two distinct axion states. For a single dark YM sector, the upper bound $Λ_{\rm conf} \lesssim 10^{12} \, {\rm GeV}$ emerges from the stability requirement of the dark sector axion. For $N$ exact SM copies, the mass and photon coupling of the second state is completely determined after a potential measurement of the analogous parameters of the first axion.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Discovering neutrinoless double-beta decay in the era of precision neutrino cosmology
Authors:
Manuel Ettengruber,
Matteo Agostini,
Allen Caldwell,
Philipp Eller,
Oliver Schulz
Abstract:
We evaluate the discovery probability of a combined analysis of proposed neutrinoless double-beta decay experiments in a scenario with normal ordered neutrino masses. The discovery probability strongly depends on the value of the lightest neutrino mass, ranging from zero in case of vanishing masses and up to 80-90\% for values just below the current constraints. We study the discovery probability…
▽ More
We evaluate the discovery probability of a combined analysis of proposed neutrinoless double-beta decay experiments in a scenario with normal ordered neutrino masses. The discovery probability strongly depends on the value of the lightest neutrino mass, ranging from zero in case of vanishing masses and up to 80-90\% for values just below the current constraints. We study the discovery probability in different scenarios, focusing on the exciting prospect in which cosmological surveys will measure the sum of neutrino masses. Uncertainties in nuclear matrix element calculations partially compensate each other when data from different isotopes are available. Although a discovery is not granted, the theoretical motivations for these searches and the presence of scenarios with high discovery probability strongly motivates the proposed international, multi-isotope experimental program.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Neutrino Physics in TeV Scale Gravity Theories
Authors:
Manuel Ettengruber
Abstract:
In this paper, the general features of the neutrino sector in TeV scale quantum gravity theories, such as ADD and Many Species Theory, is investigated. This class of theories has an inherent way to generate small neutrino masses. After reviewing this mechanism it is generalized to a realistic three-flavour case. Furthermore, a procedure is presented how to diagonalize a mass matrix which is genera…
▽ More
In this paper, the general features of the neutrino sector in TeV scale quantum gravity theories, such as ADD and Many Species Theory, is investigated. This class of theories has an inherent way to generate small neutrino masses. After reviewing this mechanism it is generalized to a realistic three-flavour case. Furthermore, a procedure is presented how to diagonalize a mass matrix which is generated by this class of theories and how one can find the Standard Model flavour eigenstates. The developed general approach is applied to two specific scenarios within ADD and Many Species Theory and possible effects on neutrino oscillations and on unitarity of the lepton mixing matrix are calculated. Finally, a short overview of phenomenology which can be potentially testable by the nowadays neutrino experiments is presented.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
A Global Bayesian Analysis of Neutrino Mass Data
Authors:
Allen Caldwell,
Manuel Ettengruber,
Alexander Merle,
Oliver Schulz,
Maximilian Totzauer
Abstract:
We perform a global Bayesian analysis of currently available neutrino data, putting data from oscillation experiments, neutrinoless double beta decay ($0νββ$), and precision cosmology on an equal footing. We evaluate the discovery potential of future $0νββ$ experiments and the Bayes factor of the two possible neutrino mass ordering schemes for different prior choices. We show that the indication f…
▽ More
We perform a global Bayesian analysis of currently available neutrino data, putting data from oscillation experiments, neutrinoless double beta decay ($0νββ$), and precision cosmology on an equal footing. We evaluate the discovery potential of future $0νββ$ experiments and the Bayes factor of the two possible neutrino mass ordering schemes for different prior choices. We show that the indication for normal ordering is still very mild and does not strongly depend on realistic prior assumptions or different combinations of cosmological data sets. We find a wide range for $0νββ$ discovery potential, depending on the absolute neutrino mass scale, mass ordering and achievable background level.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2021; v1 submitted 4 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
