-
Generative adversarial neural networks for simulating neutrino interactions
Authors:
Jose L. Bonilla,
Krzysztof M. Graczyk,
Artur M. Ankowski,
Rwik Dharmapal Banerjee,
Beata E. Kowal,
Hemant Prasad,
Jan T. Sobczyk
Abstract:
We propose a new approach to simulate neutrino scattering events as an alternative to the standard Monte Carlo generator approach. Generative adversarial neural network (GAN) models are developed to simulate charged current neutrino-carbon collisions in the few-GeV energy range. We consider a simplified framework to generate muon kinematic variables, specifically its energy and scattering angle. G…
▽ More
We propose a new approach to simulate neutrino scattering events as an alternative to the standard Monte Carlo generator approach. Generative adversarial neural network (GAN) models are developed to simulate charged current neutrino-carbon collisions in the few-GeV energy range. We consider a simplified framework to generate muon kinematic variables, specifically its energy and scattering angle. GAN models are trained on simulation data from \nuwro{} Monte Carlo event generator. Two GAN models have been obtained: one simulating quasielastic neutrino-nucleus scatterings and another simulating all interactions at given neutrino energy. The models work for neutrino energy ranging from 300 MeV to 10 GeV. The performance of both models has been assessed using two statistical metrics. It is shown that both GAN models successfully reproduce the distribution of muon kinematics.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2025; v1 submitted 27 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Developments in NuWro Monte Carlo generator
Authors:
Hemant Prasad,
Jan T. Sobczyk,
Artur M. Ankowski,
J. Luis Bonilla,
Rwik Dharmapal Banerjee,
Krzysztof M. Graczyk,
Beata E. Kowal
Abstract:
In this article, we highlight physics improvements in the NuWro Monte Carlo event generator. The upcoming version of NuWro will incorporate the integration of the argon spectral function for quasi-elastic scattering, along with the MINER$ν$A parametrization of the axial form factor. Additionally, the new release will feature the implementation of the Valencia 2020 model for meson exchange current.…
▽ More
In this article, we highlight physics improvements in the NuWro Monte Carlo event generator. The upcoming version of NuWro will incorporate the integration of the argon spectral function for quasi-elastic scattering, along with the MINER$ν$A parametrization of the axial form factor. Additionally, the new release will feature the implementation of the Valencia 2020 model for meson exchange current. The previously used simplistic delta resonance model for single-pion production will be replaced by a more accurate Ghent hybrid model in the upcoming version of NuWro. We also discuss the recent advancements made by the Wroclaw Neutrino Group in applying machine-learning techniques to achieve model-independent reconstruction of lepton-nucleus interactions
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2025; v1 submitted 20 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
New multinucleon knockout model in NuWro Monte Carlo generator
Authors:
Hemant Prasad,
Jan T. Sobczyk,
Artur M. Ankowski,
J. Luis Bonilla,
Rwik Dharmapal Banerjee,
Krzysztof M. Graczyk,
Beata E. Kowal
Abstract:
We present the implementation and results of a new model for the n-particle n-hole ($\it{np-nh}$) contribution in the NuWro event generator, grounded in the theoretical framework established by the Valencia group in 2020. For the $\it{2p2h}$ component, we introduce a novel nucleon sampling function with tunable parameters to approximate correlations in the momenta of outgoing nucleons. These param…
▽ More
We present the implementation and results of a new model for the n-particle n-hole ($\it{np-nh}$) contribution in the NuWro event generator, grounded in the theoretical framework established by the Valencia group in 2020. For the $\it{2p2h}$ component, we introduce a novel nucleon sampling function with tunable parameters to approximate correlations in the momenta of outgoing nucleons. These parameters are calibrated by comparing our results to those of the Valencia model across a range of incoming neutrino energies. In addition, our model incorporates a distinct contribution from the $\it{3p3h}$ mechanism. We discuss the differences between the new NuWro implementation, the original Valencia model, and the previous NuWro version, focusing on the distribution of outgoing nucleon momenta. Finally, we assess the impact of the hadronic model on experimental analyses involving hadronic observables.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Electron-nucleus cross sections from transfer learning
Authors:
Krzysztof M. Graczyk,
Beata E. Kowal,
Artur M. Ankowski,
Rwik Dharmapal Banerjee,
Jose Luis Bonilla,
Hemant Prasad,
Jan T. Sobczyk
Abstract:
Transfer learning (TL) allows a deep neural network (DNN) trained on one type of data to be adapted for new problems with limited information. We propose to use the TL technique in physics. The DNN learns the physics of one process, and after fine-tuning, it makes predictions for related processes. We consider the DNNs, trained on inclusive electron-carbon scattering data, and show that after fine…
▽ More
Transfer learning (TL) allows a deep neural network (DNN) trained on one type of data to be adapted for new problems with limited information. We propose to use the TL technique in physics. The DNN learns the physics of one process, and after fine-tuning, it makes predictions for related processes. We consider the DNNs, trained on inclusive electron-carbon scattering data, and show that after fine-tuning, they accurately predict cross sections for electron interactions with nuclear targets ranging from lithium to iron. The method works even when the DNN is fine-tuned on a small dataset.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Determination of the proton spectral function of \isotope[12][]{C} from $(e,e^\prime p)$ data
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski,
Omar Benhar,
Makoto Sakuda
Abstract:
The determination of the nuclear spectral function from the measured cross section of the electron-nucleus scattering process $e + A \to e^\prime + p + (A-1)$is discussed, and illustrated for the case of a carbon target. The theoretical model based on the local density approximation, previously employed to derive the spectral function from a combination of accurate theoretical calculations and exp…
▽ More
The determination of the nuclear spectral function from the measured cross section of the electron-nucleus scattering process $e + A \to e^\prime + p + (A-1)$is discussed, and illustrated for the case of a carbon target. The theoretical model based on the local density approximation, previously employed to derive the spectral function from a combination of accurate theoretical calculations and experimental data, has been developed further by including additional information obtained from measurements performed with high missing energy resolution. The implications for the analysis of $γ$-ray emission associated with nuclear deexcitation are considered.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Empirical fits to inclusive electron-carbon scattering data obtained by deep-learning methods
Authors:
Beata E. Kowal,
Krzysztof M. Graczyk,
Artur M. Ankowski,
Rwik Dharmapal Banerjee,
Hemant Prasad,
Jan T. Sobczyk
Abstract:
Employing the neural network framework, we obtain empirical fits to the electron-scattering cross sections for carbon over a broad kinematic region, extending from the quasielastic peak through resonance excitation to the onset of deep-inelastic scattering. We consider two different methods of obtaining such model-independent parametrizations and the corresponding uncertainties: based on the boots…
▽ More
Employing the neural network framework, we obtain empirical fits to the electron-scattering cross sections for carbon over a broad kinematic region, extending from the quasielastic peak through resonance excitation to the onset of deep-inelastic scattering. We consider two different methods of obtaining such model-independent parametrizations and the corresponding uncertainties: based on the bootstrap approach and the Monte Carlo dropout approach. In our analysis, the $χ^2$ defines the loss function, including point-to-point and normalization uncertainties for each independent set of measurements. Our statistical approaches lead to fits of comparable quality and similar uncertainties of the order of $7$%. To test these models, we compare their predictions to test datasets excluded from the training process and theoretical predictions obtained within the spectral function approach. The predictions of both models agree with experimental measurements and theoretical calculations. We also perform a comparison to a dataset lying beyond the covered kinematic region, and find that the bootstrap approach shows better interpolation and extrapolation abilities than the one based on the dropout algorithm.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2024; v1 submitted 28 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
JLab spectral functions of argon in NuWro and their implications for MicroBooNE
Authors:
Rwik Dharmapal Banerjee,
Artur M. Ankowski,
Krzysztof M. Graczyk,
Beata E. Kowal,
Hemant Prasad,
Jan T. Sobczyk
Abstract:
The Short-Baseline Neutrino program in Fermilab aims to resolve the nature of the low-energy excess events observed in LSND and MiniBooNE, and analyze with unprecedented precision neutrino interactions with argon. These studies require reliable estimate of neutrino cross sections, in particular for charged current quasielastic scattering (CCQE). Here, we report updates of the NuWro Monte Carlo gen…
▽ More
The Short-Baseline Neutrino program in Fermilab aims to resolve the nature of the low-energy excess events observed in LSND and MiniBooNE, and analyze with unprecedented precision neutrino interactions with argon. These studies require reliable estimate of neutrino cross sections, in particular for charged current quasielastic scattering (CCQE). Here, we report updates of the NuWro Monte Carlo generator that, most notably, bring the state-of-the-art spectral functions to model the ground state properties of the argon nucleus, and improve the accuracy of the cross sections at low energies by accounting for the effects of the nuclear Coulomb potential. We discuss these developments in the context of electron and neutrino interactions, by comparing updated NuWro predictions to experimental data from Jefferson Laboratory Hall A and MicroBooNE. The MicroBooNE CCQE data are described with the $χ^2$ per degree of freedom of 0.7, compared with 1.0 in the local Fermi gas model. The largest improvement is observed for the angular distributions of the produced protons, where the $χ^2$ reduces nearly by half. Being obtained using the axial form factor parametrization from MINERvA, our results indicate a~consistency between the CCQE measurements in MINERvA and MicroBooNE.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2024; v1 submitted 20 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Theory of Neutrino Physics -- Snowmass TF11 (aka NF08) Topical Group Report
Authors:
André de Gouvêa,
Irina Mocioiu,
Saori Pastore,
Louis E. Strigari,
L. Alvarez-Ruso,
A. M. Ankowski,
A. B. Balantekin,
V. Brdar,
M. Cadeddu,
S. Carey,
J. Carlson,
M. -C. Chen,
V. Cirigliano,
W. Dekens,
P. B. Denton,
R. Dharmapalan,
L. Everett,
H. Gallagher,
S. Gardiner,
J. Gehrlein,
L. Graf,
W. C. Haxton,
O. Hen,
H. Hergert,
S. Horiuchi
, et al. (22 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This is the report for the topical group Theory of Neutrino Physics (TF11/NF08) for Snowmass 2021. This report summarizes the progress in the field of theoretical neutrino physics in the past decade, the current status of the field, and the prospects for the upcoming decade.
This is the report for the topical group Theory of Neutrino Physics (TF11/NF08) for Snowmass 2021. This report summarizes the progress in the field of theoretical neutrino physics in the past decade, the current status of the field, and the prospects for the upcoming decade.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Event Generators for High-Energy Physics Experiments
Authors:
J. M. Campbell,
M. Diefenthaler,
T. J. Hobbs,
S. Höche,
J. Isaacson,
F. Kling,
S. Mrenna,
J. Reuter,
S. Alioli,
J. R. Andersen,
C. Andreopoulos,
A. M. Ankowski,
E. C. Aschenauer,
A. Ashkenazi,
M. D. Baker,
J. L. Barrow,
M. van Beekveld,
G. Bewick,
S. Bhattacharya,
N. Bhuiyan,
C. Bierlich,
E. Bothmann,
P. Bredt,
A. Broggio,
A. Buckley
, et al. (187 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We provide an overview of the status of Monte-Carlo event generators for high-energy particle physics. Guided by the experimental needs and requirements, we highlight areas of active development, and opportunities for future improvements. Particular emphasis is given to physics models and algorithms that are employed across a variety of experiments. These common themes in event generator developme…
▽ More
We provide an overview of the status of Monte-Carlo event generators for high-energy particle physics. Guided by the experimental needs and requirements, we highlight areas of active development, and opportunities for future improvements. Particular emphasis is given to physics models and algorithms that are employed across a variety of experiments. These common themes in event generator development lead to a more comprehensive understanding of physics at the highest energies and intensities, and allow models to be tested against a wealth of data that have been accumulated over the past decades. A cohesive approach to event generator development will allow these models to be further improved and systematic uncertainties to be reduced, directly contributing to future experimental success. Event generators are part of a much larger ecosystem of computational tools. They typically involve a number of unknown model parameters that must be tuned to experimental data, while maintaining the integrity of the underlying physics models. Making both these data, and the analyses with which they have been obtained accessible to future users is an essential aspect of open science and data preservation. It ensures the consistency of physics models across a variety of experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2025; v1 submitted 21 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Theoretical tools for neutrino scattering: interplay between lattice QCD, EFTs, nuclear physics, phenomenology, and neutrino event generators
Authors:
L. Alvarez Ruso,
A. M. Ankowski,
S. Bacca,
A. B. Balantekin,
J. Carlson,
S. Gardiner,
R. Gonzalez-Jimenez,
R. Gupta,
T. J. Hobbs,
M. Hoferichter,
J. Isaacson,
N. Jachowicz,
W. I. Jay,
T. Katori,
F. Kling,
A. S. Kronfeld,
S. W. Li,
H. -W. Lin,
K. -F. Liu,
A. Lovato,
K. Mahn,
J. Menendez,
A. S. Meyer,
J. Morfin,
S. Pastore
, et al. (36 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Maximizing the discovery potential of increasingly precise neutrino experiments will require an improved theoretical understanding of neutrino-nucleus cross sections over a wide range of energies. Low-energy interactions are needed to reconstruct the energies of astrophysical neutrinos from supernovae bursts and search for new physics using increasingly precise measurement of coherent elastic neut…
▽ More
Maximizing the discovery potential of increasingly precise neutrino experiments will require an improved theoretical understanding of neutrino-nucleus cross sections over a wide range of energies. Low-energy interactions are needed to reconstruct the energies of astrophysical neutrinos from supernovae bursts and search for new physics using increasingly precise measurement of coherent elastic neutrino scattering. Higher-energy interactions involve a variety of reaction mechanisms including quasi-elastic scattering, resonance production, and deep inelastic scattering that must all be included to reliably predict cross sections for energies relevant to DUNE and other accelerator neutrino experiments. This white paper discusses the theoretical status, challenges, required resources, and path forward for achieving precise predictions of neutrino-nucleus scattering and emphasizes the need for a coordinated theoretical effort involved lattice QCD, nuclear effective theories, phenomenological models of the transition region, and event generators.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2022; v1 submitted 16 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Electron Scattering and Neutrino Physics
Authors:
A. M. Ankowski,
A. Ashkenazi,
S. Bacca,
J. L. Barrow,
M. Betancourt,
A. Bodek,
M. E. Christy,
L. Doria. S. Dytman,
A. Friedland,
O. Hen,
C. J. Horowitz,
N. Jachowicz,
W. Ketchum,
T. Lux,
K. Mahn,
C. Mariani,
J. Newby,
V. Pandey,
A. Papadopoulou,
E. Radicioni,
F. Sánchez,
C. Sfienti,
J. M. Udías,
L. Weinstein,
L. Alvarez-Ruso
, et al. (28 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
A thorough understanding of neutrino-nucleus scattering physics is crucial for the successful execution of the entire US neutrino physics program. Neutrino-nucleus interaction constitutes one of the biggest systematic uncertainties in neutrino experiments - both at intermediate energies affecting long-baseline Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE), as well as at low energies affecting cohere…
▽ More
A thorough understanding of neutrino-nucleus scattering physics is crucial for the successful execution of the entire US neutrino physics program. Neutrino-nucleus interaction constitutes one of the biggest systematic uncertainties in neutrino experiments - both at intermediate energies affecting long-baseline Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE), as well as at low energies affecting coherent scattering neutrino program - and could well be the difference between achieving or missing discovery level precision. To this end, electron-nucleus scattering experiments provide vital information to test, assess and validate different nuclear models and event generators intended to be used in neutrino experiments. In this white paper, we highlight connections between electron- and neutrino-nucleus scattering physics at energies ranging from 10s of MeV to a few GeV, review the status of ongoing and planned electron scattering experiments, identify gaps, and layout a path forward that benefits the neutrino community. We also highlight the systemic challenges with respect to the divide between the nuclear and high-energy physics communities and funding that presents additional hurdle in mobilizing these connections to the benefit of neutrino programs.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2023; v1 submitted 14 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Assessing the accuracy of the GENIE event generator with electron-scattering data
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski,
Alexander Friedland
Abstract:
Precision neutrino oscillation experiments of the future---of which DUNE is a prime example---require reliable event generator tools. The 1--4 GeV energy regime, in which DUNE will operate, is marked by the transition from the low-energy nuclear physics domain to that of perturbative QCD, resulting in rich and highly complex physics. Given this complexity, it is important to establish a validation…
▽ More
Precision neutrino oscillation experiments of the future---of which DUNE is a prime example---require reliable event generator tools. The 1--4 GeV energy regime, in which DUNE will operate, is marked by the transition from the low-energy nuclear physics domain to that of perturbative QCD, resulting in rich and highly complex physics. Given this complexity, it is important to establish a validation procedure capable of disentangling the physical processes and testing each of them individually. Here, we demonstrate the utility of this approach by benchmarking the GENIE generator, currently used by all Fermilab-based experiments, against a broad set of inclusive electron-scattering data. This comparison takes advantage of the fact that, while electron-nucleus and neutrino-nucleus processes share a lot of common physics, electron scattering gives one access to precisely known beam energies and scattering kinematics. Exploring the kinematic parameter range relevant to DUNE in this manner, we observe patterns of large discrepancies between the generator and data. These discrepancies are most prominent in the pion-producing regimes and are present not only in medium-sized nuclei, including argon, but also in deuterium and hydrogen targets, indicating mismodeled hadronic physics. Several directions for possible improvement are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2020; v1 submitted 21 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Lepton-Nucleus Cross Section Measurements for DUNE with the LDMX Detector
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski,
Alexander Friedland,
Shirley Weishi Li,
Omar Moreno,
Philip Schuster,
Natalia Toro,
Nhan Tran
Abstract:
We point out that the LDMX (Light Dark Matter eXperiment) detector design, conceived to search for sub-GeV dark matter, will also have very advantageous characteristics to pursue electron-nucleus scattering measurements of direct relevance to the neutrino program at DUNE and elsewhere. These characteristics include a 4-GeV electron beam, a precision tracker, electromagnetic and hadronic calorimete…
▽ More
We point out that the LDMX (Light Dark Matter eXperiment) detector design, conceived to search for sub-GeV dark matter, will also have very advantageous characteristics to pursue electron-nucleus scattering measurements of direct relevance to the neutrino program at DUNE and elsewhere. These characteristics include a 4-GeV electron beam, a precision tracker, electromagnetic and hadronic calorimeters with near 2$π$ azimuthal acceptance from the forward beam axis out to $\sim$40$^\circ$ angle, and low reconstruction energy threshold. LDMX thus could provide (semi)exclusive cross section measurements, with detailed information about final-state electrons, pions, protons, and neutrons. We compare the predictions of two widely used neutrino generators (GENIE, GiBUU) in the LDMX region of acceptance to illustrate the large modeling discrepancies in electron-nucleus interactions at DUNE-like kinematics. We argue that discriminating between these predictions is well within the capabilities of the LDMX detector.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2020; v1 submitted 12 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Measurement of the cross sections for inclusive electron scattering in the E12-14-012 experiment at Jefferson Lab
Authors:
M. Murphy,
H. Dai,
L. Gu,
D. Abrams,
A. M. Ankowski,
B. Aljawrneh,
S. Alsalmi,
J. Bane,
S. Barcus,
O. Benhar,
V. Bellini,
J. Bericic,
D. Biswas,
A. Camsonne,
J. Castellanos,
J. -P. Chen,
M. E. Christy,
K. Craycraft,
R. Cruz-Torres,
D. Day,
S. -C. Dusa,
E. Fuchey,
T. Gautam,
C. Giusti,
J. Gomez
, et al. (34 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The E12-14-012 experiment performed at Jefferson Lab Hall A has collected inclusive electron-scattering data for different targets at the kinematics corresponding to beam energy 2.222 GeV and scattering angle 15.54 deg. Here we present a comprehensive analysis of the collected data and compare the double-differential cross sections for inclusive scattering of electrons, extracted using solid targe…
▽ More
The E12-14-012 experiment performed at Jefferson Lab Hall A has collected inclusive electron-scattering data for different targets at the kinematics corresponding to beam energy 2.222 GeV and scattering angle 15.54 deg. Here we present a comprehensive analysis of the collected data and compare the double-differential cross sections for inclusive scattering of electrons, extracted using solid targets (aluminum, carbon, and titanium) and a closed argon-gas cell. The data extend over broad range of energy transfer, where quasielastic interaction, Delta-resonance excitation, and inelastic scattering yield contributions to the cross section. The double-differential cross sections are reported with high precision (~3%) for all targets over the covered kinematic range.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2019; v1 submitted 5 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Effect of the charged-lepton's mass on the quasielastic neutrino cross sections
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski
Abstract:
Martini et al. [Phys. Rev. C 94, 015501 (2016)] recently observed that when the produced-lepton's mass plays an important role, the charged-current quasielastic cross section for muon neutrinos can be higher than that for electron neutrinos. Here I argue that this effect appears solely in the theoretical descriptions of nuclear effects in which nucleon knockout requires the energy and momentum tra…
▽ More
Martini et al. [Phys. Rev. C 94, 015501 (2016)] recently observed that when the produced-lepton's mass plays an important role, the charged-current quasielastic cross section for muon neutrinos can be higher than that for electron neutrinos. Here I argue that this effect appears solely in the theoretical descriptions of nuclear effects in which nucleon knockout requires the energy and momentum transfers to lie in a narrow range of the kinematically allowed values.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2017; v1 submitted 4 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Nuclear effects are relevant to the calorimetric reconstruction of neutrino energy
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski
Abstract:
As the calorimetric method of neutrino-energy reconstruction is generally considered to be largely insensitive to nuclear effects, its application seems to be an effective way for reducing systematic uncertainties in oscillation experiments. To verify the validity of this opinion, we quantitatively study the sensitivity of the calorimetric energy reconstruction to the effect of final-state interac…
▽ More
As the calorimetric method of neutrino-energy reconstruction is generally considered to be largely insensitive to nuclear effects, its application seems to be an effective way for reducing systematic uncertainties in oscillation experiments. To verify the validity of this opinion, we quantitatively study the sensitivity of the calorimetric energy reconstruction to the effect of final-state interactions in an ideal detector and in a realistic scenario. We find that when particles escaping detection carry away a non-negligible fraction of neutrino energy, the calorimetric reconstruction method becomes sensitive to nuclear effects which, in turn, affects the outcome of the oscillation analysis. These findings suggest that the best strategy for reduction of systematic uncertainties in future neutrino-oscillation studies---such as the Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment---is to increase their sensitivity to particles of low energy. The ambitious precision goals appear also to require an extensive development of theoretical models capable of providing an accurate predictions for exclusive cross sections of well-controlled uncertainties.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Systematic uncertainties in long-baseline neutrino-oscillation experiments
Authors:
Artur M Ankowski,
Camillo Mariani
Abstract:
Future neutrino-oscillation experiments are expected to bring definite answers to the questions of neutrino-mass hierarchy and violation of charge-parity symmetry in the lepton sector. To realize this ambitious program it is necessary to ensure a significant reduction of uncertainties, particularly those related to neutrino-energy reconstruction. In this paper, we discuss different sources of syst…
▽ More
Future neutrino-oscillation experiments are expected to bring definite answers to the questions of neutrino-mass hierarchy and violation of charge-parity symmetry in the lepton sector. To realize this ambitious program it is necessary to ensure a significant reduction of uncertainties, particularly those related to neutrino-energy reconstruction. In this paper, we discuss different sources of systematic uncertainties, paying special attention to those arising from nuclear effects and detector response. By analyzing nuclear effects we show the importance of developing accurate theoretical models, capable to provide quantitative description of neutrino cross sections, together with the relevance of their implementation in Monte Carlo generators and extensive testing against lepton-scattering data. We also point out the fundamental role of efforts aiming to determine detector responses in test-beam exposures.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2017; v1 submitted 1 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Effect of the $2p2h$ cross-section uncertainties on an analysis of neutrino oscillations
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski,
Omar Benhar,
Camillo Mariani,
Erica Vagnoni
Abstract:
We report the results of a study aimed at quantifying the impact on the oscillation analysis of the uncertainties associated with the description of the neutrino-nucleus cross section in the two-particle--two-hole sector. The results of our calculations, based on the kinematic method of energy reconstruction and carried out comparing two data-driven approaches, show that the existing discrepancies…
▽ More
We report the results of a study aimed at quantifying the impact on the oscillation analysis of the uncertainties associated with the description of the neutrino-nucleus cross section in the two-particle--two-hole sector. The results of our calculations, based on the kinematic method of energy reconstruction and carried out comparing two data-driven approaches, show that the existing discrepancies in the neutrino cross sections have a sizable effect on the extracted oscillation parameters, particularly in the antineutrino channel.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2016; v1 submitted 3 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Improved estimate of the cross section for inverse beta decay
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski
Abstract:
The hypothesis of the conserved vector current, relating the vector weak and isovector electromagnetic currents, plays a fundamental role in quantitative description of neutrino interactions. Despite being experimentally confirmed with great precision, it is not fully implemented in existing calculations of the cross section for inverse beta decay, the dominant mechanism of antineutrino scattering…
▽ More
The hypothesis of the conserved vector current, relating the vector weak and isovector electromagnetic currents, plays a fundamental role in quantitative description of neutrino interactions. Despite being experimentally confirmed with great precision, it is not fully implemented in existing calculations of the cross section for inverse beta decay, the dominant mechanism of antineutrino scattering at energies below a few tens of MeV. In this article, I estimate the corresponding cross section and its uncertainty, ensuring conservation of the vector current. While converging to previous calculations at energies of several MeV, the obtained result is appreciably lower and predicts more directional positron production near the reaction threshold. These findings suggest that in the current estimate of the flux of geologically produced antineutrinos the 232Th and 238U components may be underestimated by 6.1 and 3.7%, respectively. The proposed search for light sterile neutrinos using a 144Ce--144Pr source is predicted to collect the total event rate lower by 3% than previously estimated and to observe a spectral distortion that could be misinterpreted as an oscillation signal. In reactor-antineutrino experiments, together with a re-evaluation of the positron spectra, the predicted event rate should be reduced by 0.9%, diminishing the size of the reported anomaly.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Missing energy and the measurement of the CP-violating phase in neutrino oscillations
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski,
Pilar Coloma,
Patrick Huber,
Camillo Mariani,
Erica Vagnoni
Abstract:
In the next generation of long-baseline neutrino oscillation experiments, aiming to determine the charge-parity violating phase $δ_{CP}$ in the appearance channel, fine-grained time-projection chambers are expected to play an important role. In this Letter, we analyze an influence of realistic detector capabilities on the $δ_{CP}$ sensitivity for a setup similar to that of the Deep Underground Neu…
▽ More
In the next generation of long-baseline neutrino oscillation experiments, aiming to determine the charge-parity violating phase $δ_{CP}$ in the appearance channel, fine-grained time-projection chambers are expected to play an important role. In this Letter, we analyze an influence of realistic detector capabilities on the $δ_{CP}$ sensitivity for a setup similar to that of the Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment. We find that the effect of the missing energy, carried out by undetected particles, is sizable. Although the reconstructed neutrino energy can be corrected for the missing energy, the accuracy of such procedure has to exceed 20\%, to avoid a sizable bias in the extracted $δ_{CP}$ value.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2015; v1 submitted 30 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Comparison of the calorimetric and kinematic methods of neutrino energy reconstruction in disappearance experiments
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski,
Omar Benhar,
Pilar Coloma,
Patrick Huber,
Chun-Min Jen,
Camillo Mariani,
Davide Meloni,
Erica Vagnoni
Abstract:
To be able to achieve their physics goals, future neutrino-oscillation experiments will need to reconstruct the neutrino energy with very high accuracy. In this work, we analyze how the energy reconstruction may be affected by realistic detection capabilities, such as energy resolutions, efficiencies, and thresholds. This allows us to estimate how well the detector performance needs to be determin…
▽ More
To be able to achieve their physics goals, future neutrino-oscillation experiments will need to reconstruct the neutrino energy with very high accuracy. In this work, we analyze how the energy reconstruction may be affected by realistic detection capabilities, such as energy resolutions, efficiencies, and thresholds. This allows us to estimate how well the detector performance needs to be determined a priori in order to avoid a sizable bias in the measurement of the relevant oscillation parameters. We compare the kinematic and calorimetric methods of energy reconstruction in the context of two muon-neutrino disappearance experiments operating in different energy regimes. For the calorimetric reconstruction method, we find that the detector performance has to be estimated with a ~10% accuracy to avoid a significant bias in the extracted oscillation parameters. On the other hand, in the case of kinematic energy reconstruction, we observe that the results exhibit less sensitivity to an overestimation of the detector capabilities.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2015; v1 submitted 30 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Charged-current quasielastic scattering of muon antineutrino and neutrino in the MINERvA experiment
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski
Abstract:
One of the largest sources of systematic uncertainties in ongoing neutrino-oscillation measurements is the description of nuclear effects. Its considerable reduction is expected thanks to the dedicated studies of (anti)neutrino-nucleus interactions in the MINERvA experiment. In this article, the calculations within the spectral function approach are compared to the charged-current quasielastic cro…
▽ More
One of the largest sources of systematic uncertainties in ongoing neutrino-oscillation measurements is the description of nuclear effects. Its considerable reduction is expected thanks to the dedicated studies of (anti)neutrino-nucleus interactions in the MINERvA experiment. In this article, the calculations within the spectral function approach are compared to the charged-current quasielastic cross sections reported from MINERvA. The obtained results show that the effect of final-state interactions on the (anti)muon kinematics plays pivotal role in reproducing the experimental data.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2015; v1 submitted 11 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Estimate of the theoretical uncertainty of the cross sections for nucleon knockout in neutral-current neutrino-oxygen interactions
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski,
Maria B. Barbaro,
Omar Benhar,
Juan A. Caballero,
Carlotta Giusti,
Raúl González-Jiménez,
Guillermo D. Megias,
Andrea Meucci
Abstract:
Free nucleons propagating in water are known to produce gamma rays, which form a background to the searches for diffuse supernova neutrinos and sterile neutrinos carried out with Cherenkov detectors. As a consequence, the process of nucleon knockout induced by neutral-current quasielastic interactions of atmospheric (anti)neutrinos with oxygen needs to be under control at the quantitative level in…
▽ More
Free nucleons propagating in water are known to produce gamma rays, which form a background to the searches for diffuse supernova neutrinos and sterile neutrinos carried out with Cherenkov detectors. As a consequence, the process of nucleon knockout induced by neutral-current quasielastic interactions of atmospheric (anti)neutrinos with oxygen needs to be under control at the quantitative level in the background simulations of the ongoing and future experiments. In this paper, we provide a quantitative assessment of the uncertainty associated with the theoretical description of the nuclear cross sections, estimating it from the discrepancies between the predictions of different models.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Improving the accuracy of neutrino energy reconstruction in charged-current quasielastic scattering off nuclear targets
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski,
Omar Benhar,
Makoto Sakuda
Abstract:
We report the results of a theoretical study of quasielastic electron and neutrino interactions with carbon. Our approach takes into account the effects of final-state interactions between the struck nucleon and the residual nucleus, neglected in the impulse approximation, through a generalization of the spectral function formalism. The calculated electron-scattering cross sections turn out to be…
▽ More
We report the results of a theoretical study of quasielastic electron and neutrino interactions with carbon. Our approach takes into account the effects of final-state interactions between the struck nucleon and the residual nucleus, neglected in the impulse approximation, through a generalization of the spectral function formalism. The calculated electron-scattering cross sections turn out to be in very good agreement with the available data over a broad kinematical region. The impact of nuclear effects on the reconstruction of neutrino energy in charged-current quasielastic processes is also studied, and the results of our approach are compared to the predictions of the relativistic Fermi gas model, routinely employed in most Monte Carlo simulations. Finally, we discuss the limitations of the existing procedure for energy reconstruction and propose a new, improved, one. At energy ~600 MeV, we observe a sizable difference between neutrino and antineutrino scattering, important for the measurements of charge-parity symmetry violation. Our analysis suggests that a reliable determination of neutrino energy can only be obtained from models validated by a systematic comparison to the available electron-scattering data.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2015; v1 submitted 22 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Consistent analysis of neutral- and charged-current (anti)neutrino scattering off carbon
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski
Abstract:
Good understanding of the cross sections for (anti)neutrino scattering off nuclear targets in the few-GeV energy region is a prerequisite for the correct interpretation of results of ongoing and planned oscillation experiments. To clarify a possible source of disagreement between recent measurements of the cross sections on carbon, we analyze the available data within an approach based on the real…
▽ More
Good understanding of the cross sections for (anti)neutrino scattering off nuclear targets in the few-GeV energy region is a prerequisite for the correct interpretation of results of ongoing and planned oscillation experiments. To clarify a possible source of disagreement between recent measurements of the cross sections on carbon, we analyze the available data within an approach based on the realistic spectral function of carbon, treating neutral-current elastic (NCE) and charged-current quasielastic (CCQE) processes on equal footing. We show that the axial mass from the shape analysis of the MiniBooNE data is in good agreement with the results reported by the BNL E734 and NOMAD Collaborations. However, the combined analysis of the NCE and CCQE data does not seem to support the contribution of multinucleon final states being large enough to explain the normalization of the MiniBooNE-reported cross sections.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Consistent analysis of neutral- and charged-current neutrino scattering off carbon
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski
Abstract:
Background: Good understanding of the cross sections for (anti)neutrino scattering off nuclear targets in the few-GeV energy region is a prerequisite for correct interpretation of results of ongoing and planned oscillation experiments.
Purpose: Clarify possible source of disagreement between recent measurements of the cross sections on carbon.
Method: Nuclear effects in (anti)neutrino scatteri…
▽ More
Background: Good understanding of the cross sections for (anti)neutrino scattering off nuclear targets in the few-GeV energy region is a prerequisite for correct interpretation of results of ongoing and planned oscillation experiments.
Purpose: Clarify possible source of disagreement between recent measurements of the cross sections on carbon.
Method: Nuclear effects in (anti)neutrino scattering off carbon nucleus are described using the spectral function approach. The effect of two- and multi-nucleon final states is accounted for by applying an effective value of the axial mass, fixed to 1.23 GeV. Neutral-current elastic (NCE) and charged-current quasielastic (CCQE) processes are treated on equal footing.
Results: The differential and total cross sections for the energy ranging from a few hundreds of MeV to 100 GeV are obtained and compared to the available data from the BNL E734, MiniBooNE, and NOMAD experiments.
Conclusions: Nuclear effects in NCE and CCQE scattering seem to be very similar. Within the spectral function approach, the axial mass from the shape analysis of the MiniBooNE data is in good agreement with the results reported by the BNL E734 and NOMAD Collaborations. However, the combined analysis of NCE and CCQE data does not seem to support the contribution of multi-nucleon final states being large enough to explain the normalization of the MiniBooNE-reported cross sections.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2012; v1 submitted 22 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
The γ-ray production in neutral-current neutrino oxygen interaction in the energy range above 100 MeV
Authors:
T. Mori,
R. Yamaguchi,
M. Sakuda,
A. M. Ankowski,
O. Benhar
Abstract:
We calculate the cross section of the gamma-ray production from neutral-current neutrino-oxygen quasi-elastic interaction, $ν+\^{16}O \rightarrow ν+p+^{15}N*$, or $ν+^{16}O \rightarrow ν+n+^{15}O*$, in which the residual nuclei (15N* or 15O*) lead to the gamma-ray emission with gamma-ray energy >6 MeV at the branching ratio of 41%. Above 200 MeV, this cross section dominates over that of gamma-ray…
▽ More
We calculate the cross section of the gamma-ray production from neutral-current neutrino-oxygen quasi-elastic interaction, $ν+\^{16}O \rightarrow ν+p+^{15}N*$, or $ν+^{16}O \rightarrow ν+n+^{15}O*$, in which the residual nuclei (15N* or 15O*) lead to the gamma-ray emission with gamma-ray energy >6 MeV at the branching ratio of 41%. Above 200 MeV, this cross section dominates over that of gamma-ray production from the inelastic reaction, $ν+^{16}O->ν+^{16}O*$. In the present calculation, spectral function and the spectroscopic factors of $1p_{1/2}, 1p_{3/2} and 1s_{1/2}$ states are essential. The gamma-ray production is dominated by the deexcitation of $1p_{3/2}$ state of the residual nucleus.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
-
Analysis of the Q^2-dependence of charged-current quasielastic processes in neutrino-nucleus interactions
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski,
Omar Benhar,
Nicola Farina
Abstract:
We discuss the observed disagreement between the Q^2 distributions of neutrino-nucleus quasielastic events, measured by a number of recent experiments, and the predictions of Monte Carlo simulations based on the relativistic Fermi gas model. The results of our analysis suggest that these discrepancies are likely to be ascribable to both the breakdown of the impulse approximation and the limitation…
▽ More
We discuss the observed disagreement between the Q^2 distributions of neutrino-nucleus quasielastic events, measured by a number of recent experiments, and the predictions of Monte Carlo simulations based on the relativistic Fermi gas model. The results of our analysis suggest that these discrepancies are likely to be ascribable to both the breakdown of the impulse approximation and the limitations of the Fermi gas description. Several issues related to the extraction of the Q^2 distributions from the experimental data are also discussed, and new kinematical variables, which would allow for an improved analysis, are proposed.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2010; v1 submitted 4 January, 2010;
originally announced January 2010.
-
Argon spectral function and neutrino interactions
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski,
Jan T. Sobczyk
Abstract:
The argon spectral function is constructed and applied to neutrino-argon cross section computations in the plane wave impulse approximation with the Pauli blocking final state interaction effect taken into account. The approximations of the construction method are critically analyzed using the example of oxygen for which more detailed computations are available. An effective description of nucle…
▽ More
The argon spectral function is constructed and applied to neutrino-argon cross section computations in the plane wave impulse approximation with the Pauli blocking final state interaction effect taken into account. The approximations of the construction method are critically analyzed using the example of oxygen for which more detailed computations are available. An effective description of nucleus based on the information contained in a spectral function is proposed. It is demonstrated that its predictions are close to those obtained from the complete spectral function. The effective description can be easily applied in Monte Carlo event generators.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2006; v1 submitted 1 December, 2005;
originally announced December 2005.
-
High-energy limit of neutrino quasielastic cross section
Authors:
Artur M. Ankowski
Abstract:
It's a common knowledge that the quasielastic neutrino-neutron and antineutrino-proton cross sections tend to the same constant as (anti)neutrino energy becomes high. In this paper we calculate the exact expression of the limit in terms of the parameters describing quasielastic scattering. We check that even at very high energies only small absolute values of the four-momentum transfer contribut…
▽ More
It's a common knowledge that the quasielastic neutrino-neutron and antineutrino-proton cross sections tend to the same constant as (anti)neutrino energy becomes high. In this paper we calculate the exact expression of the limit in terms of the parameters describing quasielastic scattering. We check that even at very high energies only small absolute values of the four-momentum transfer contribute to the cross section, hence the Fermi theory can be applied. The dipole approximation of the form factors allows to perform analytic calculations. Obtained results are neutrino-flavour independent.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2005; v1 submitted 18 March, 2005;
originally announced March 2005.
