Showing 1–40 of 40 results for author: Tomboulis, E T

Cluster expansions and chiral symmetry at large density in 2-color QCD

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: $SU(N_c)$ lattice gauge theories with $N_f$ flavors of massless staggered fermions are considered at high quark chemical potential $μ$ and any temperature $T$. In the strong coupling regime (sufficiently small $β$) they have been shown to possess a chiral phase of intact global $U(N_f)\times U(N_f)… ▽ More $SU(N_c)$ lattice gauge theories with $N_f$ flavors of massless staggered fermions are considered at high quark chemical potential $μ$ and any temperature $T$. In the strong coupling regime (sufficiently small $β$) they have been shown to possess a chiral phase of intact global $U(N_f)\times U(N_f)$ symmetry. The proof is by cluster expansions which converge in the infinite volume limit. Extension to weaker coupling does not appear feasible in the presence of complex fermion determinant. For theories with real determinant, however, such as 2-color QCD with fundamental fermions, or any $N_c$ with even $N_f$ and adjoint fermions, such large $μ$ cluster expansions can be used to show chiral behavior of fermionic lattice observables at any gauge coupling. Unfortunately, this absence of color superfluidity/superconductivity at high $μ$ appears to be a lattice artifact due to lattice saturation, a serious problem plaguing the standard finite density formalism on the lattice. Some possible ways of circumventing saturation are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 11 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: 7 pages, 1 figure, Proceedings of the 33rd International Symposium on Lattice Field Theory, 14 -18 July 2015, Kobe, Japan

Chiral symmetry in $SU(N_c)$ gauge theories at high density

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We study $SU(N_c)$ lattice gauge theories with $N_f$ flavors of massless staggered fermions in the presence of quark chemical potential $μ$. A recent exact result that in the strong coupling limit (vanishing inverse gauge coupling $β$) and for sufficiently large $μ$ the theory is in a chiral symmetric phase is here extended into the finite gauge coupling region. A cluster expansion combining a fer… ▽ More We study $SU(N_c)$ lattice gauge theories with $N_f$ flavors of massless staggered fermions in the presence of quark chemical potential $μ$. A recent exact result that in the strong coupling limit (vanishing inverse gauge coupling $β$) and for sufficiently large $μ$ the theory is in a chiral symmetric phase is here extended into the finite gauge coupling region. A cluster expansion combining a fermion spacelike hopping expansion and a strong coupling plaquette expansion is shown to converge for sufficiently large $μ$ and small $β$ at any temperature $T$. All expectations of chirally non-invariant local fermion operators vanish identically, or, equivalently, their correlations cluster exponentially within the expansion implying absence of spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking. The resulting phase at low $T$ may be described as a "quarkyonic" matter phase. Some implications for the phase diagram of $SU(N_c)$ theories are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 9 March, 2014; v1 submitted 3 March, 2014; originally announced March 2014.

Comments: 18 pages, 4 figures, some comments and additional discussion and references included. arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:1304.4678

Journal ref: Int. J. Mod. Phys. A, 29, (2014) 1445004

Conformality at large number of fermion flavors and composite Higgs

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: The many open questions concerning the existence of IR and UV fixed points in gauge theories as a function of the number of fermion flavors and bare coupling are briefly reviewed and discussed. It is pointed out that only a small subset of potential IR-conformal gauge theories, i.e. theories whose IR behavior is determined by an IR fixed point, has so far been examined. It is suggested that the na… ▽ More The many open questions concerning the existence of IR and UV fixed points in gauge theories as a function of the number of fermion flavors and bare coupling are briefly reviewed and discussed. It is pointed out that only a small subset of potential IR-conformal gauge theories, i.e. theories whose IR behavior is determined by an IR fixed point, has so far been examined. It is suggested that the naturally light scalar composites that seem to appear generically as lowest states in the non-QCD-like spectrum of such theories provide a natural basis for composite Higgs models, where the composite Higgs is not a NG boson and some of the usual fine-tuning problems are evaded. △ Less

Submitted 20 November, 2013; originally announced November 2013.

Comments: 7 pages, 3 figures; talk given at the 31st International Symposium on Lattice Field Theory - LATTICE 2013

Chiral symmetry restoration at large chemical potential in strongly coupled SU(N) gauge theories

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We show that at sufficiently large chemical potential SU(N) lattice gauge theories in the strong coupling limit with staggered fermions are in a chirally symmetric phase. The proof employs a polymer cluster expansion which exploits the anisotropy between timelike and spacelike directions in the presence of a quark chemical potential $μ$. The expansion is shown to converge in the infinite volume li… ▽ More We show that at sufficiently large chemical potential SU(N) lattice gauge theories in the strong coupling limit with staggered fermions are in a chirally symmetric phase. The proof employs a polymer cluster expansion which exploits the anisotropy between timelike and spacelike directions in the presence of a quark chemical potential $μ$. The expansion is shown to converge in the infinite volume limit at any temperature for sufficiently large $μ$. All expectations of chirally non-invariant local fermion operators vanish identically, or, equivalently, their correlations cluster exponentially, within the expansion. The expansion itself may serve as a computational tool at large $μ$ and strong coupling. △ Less

Submitted 18 December, 2013; v1 submitted 16 April, 2013; originally announced April 2013.

Comments: 19 pages, 4 figures; replaced by published version containing some additional references and comments

Journal ref: J. Math Phys. 54, 122301 (2013)

Critical couplings and string tensions from two-lattice matching of RG decimations

Authors: X. Cheng, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: Critical couplings and string tensions in SU(2) and SU(3) lattice gauge theory are calculated by two-lattice matching of RG block transformations. The transformations are of the potential moving type generating plaquette actions with large number of group characters and exhibit rapid approach to a unique renormalized trajectory. Fixing the critical coupling $β(N_τ)$ at one value of temporal lattic… ▽ More Critical couplings and string tensions in SU(2) and SU(3) lattice gauge theory are calculated by two-lattice matching of RG block transformations. The transformations are of the potential moving type generating plaquette actions with large number of group characters and exhibit rapid approach to a unique renormalized trajectory. Fixing the critical coupling $β(N_τ)$ at one value of temporal lattice extent $N_τ$ by MC simulation, the critical couplings for other values of $N_τ$ are then obtained by lattice matching of these decimations. $β(N_τ)$ values are thus obtained for a range of $N_τ$ and found to be in agreement with MC simulation results to within a few percent in all cases. A similar procedure allows the calculation of string tensions for a range of $β$ values with similarly good agreement with MC data. △ Less

Submitted 25 November, 2012; originally announced November 2012.

Comments: 7 pages, 2 figures, 3 tables, presented at Lattice 2012, June 24-29, 2012, Cairns, Australia

Absence of chiral symmetry breaking in multi-flavor strongly coupled lattice gauge theories

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We consider lattice gauge theories at strong coupling with gauge group $U(N_C)$, or $SU(N_C)$ restricted to the meson sector, and coupled to $N_F$ flavors of fundamental representation staggered fermions. We study the formation of a chiral condensate by means of resummation of a hopping expansion. Different classes of graphs become dominant as the parameter $(N_F/N_C)$ is varied. By performing gra… ▽ More We consider lattice gauge theories at strong coupling with gauge group $U(N_C)$, or $SU(N_C)$ restricted to the meson sector, and coupled to $N_F$ flavors of fundamental representation staggered fermions. We study the formation of a chiral condensate by means of resummation of a hopping expansion. Different classes of graphs become dominant as the parameter $(N_F/N_C)$ is varied. By performing graph resummation we obtain an equation for determining the condensate as a function of $(N_F/N_C)$ and mass $m$. For values of $(N_F/N_C)$ below a critical value one reproduces the well-known result of the existence of a non-vanishing condensate solution in the $m=0$ limit. Above the critical $(N_F/N_C)$ value, however, no such solution exists, its abrupt disappearance indicating a first order transition to a chirally symmetric phase with composite (colorless) excitation spectrum. △ Less

Submitted 17 April, 2013; v1 submitted 20 November, 2012; originally announced November 2012.

Comments: 15 pages, 6 figures, corrected typos, added acknowledgment, published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. 87, 034513 (2013)

Critical couplings and string tensions via lattice matching of RG decimations

Authors: X. Cheng, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We calculate critical couplings and string tensions in SU(2) and SU(3) pure lattice gauge theory by a simple and inexpensive technique of two-lattice matching of RG block transformations. The transformations are potential moving decimations generating plaquette actions with large number of group characters and exhibit rapid approach to a unique renormalized trajectory. Fixing the critical coupling… ▽ More We calculate critical couplings and string tensions in SU(2) and SU(3) pure lattice gauge theory by a simple and inexpensive technique of two-lattice matching of RG block transformations. The transformations are potential moving decimations generating plaquette actions with large number of group characters and exhibit rapid approach to a unique renormalized trajectory. Fixing the critical coupling $β_c(N_τ)$ at one value of temporal lattice length $N_τ$ by MC simulation, the critical couplings for any other value of $N_τ$ are then obtained by lattice matching of the block decimations. We obtain $β_c(N_τ)$ values over the range $N_τ= 3 - 32$ and find agreement with MC simulation results to within a few percent in all cases. A similar procedure allows the calculation of string tensions with similarly good agreement with MC data. △ Less

Submitted 17 June, 2012; originally announced June 2012.

Comments: 12 pages, Latex, 1 figure

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 86, 074507 (2012)

Fermion RG blocking transformations and IR structure

Authors: X. Cheng, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We explore fermion RG block-spinning transformations on the lattice with the aim of studying the IR structure of gauge theories and, in particular, the existence of IR fixed points for varying fermion content. In the case of light fermions the main concern and difficulty is ensuring locality of any adopted blocking scheme. We discuss the problem of constructing a local blocked fermion action in th… ▽ More We explore fermion RG block-spinning transformations on the lattice with the aim of studying the IR structure of gauge theories and, in particular, the existence of IR fixed points for varying fermion content. In the case of light fermions the main concern and difficulty is ensuring locality of any adopted blocking scheme. We discuss the problem of constructing a local blocked fermion action in the background of arbitrary gauge fields. We then discuss the carrying out of accompanying gauge field blocking. In the presence of the blocked fermions implementation of MCRG is not straightforward. By adopting judicious approximations we arrive at an easily implementable approximate RG recursion scheme that allows quick, inexpensive estimates of the location of conformal windows for various groups and fermion representations. We apply this scheme to locate the conformal windows in the case of SU(2) and SU(3) gauge groups. Some of the reasons for the apparent efficacy of this and similar decimation schemes are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 18 December, 2011; originally announced December 2011.

Comments: 10 pages, presented at QCD-TNT-II, September 05-09, 2011, Trento, Italy

Fermion condensates and Lorentz symmetry breaking in strongly-coupled large N gauge theories

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: The possibility of Lorentz symmetry breaking (LSB) has attracted considerable attention in recent years. Spontaneous LSB, in particular, offers the attractive prospect of the graviton as a Nambu-Golstone boson. Here we consider the question of spontaneous LSB in lattice gauge theories via formation of fermion condensates in the strong coupling and large N limits. We employ naive massless fermions… ▽ More The possibility of Lorentz symmetry breaking (LSB) has attracted considerable attention in recent years. Spontaneous LSB, in particular, offers the attractive prospect of the graviton as a Nambu-Golstone boson. Here we consider the question of spontaneous LSB in lattice gauge theories via formation of fermion condensates in the strong coupling and large N limits. We employ naive massless fermions in a fermionic hopping expansion in the presence of sources coupled to various condensate operators of interest. The expansion is summed in the large N limit in two equivalent ways: (i) direct summation of all leading N graphs; and (ii) construction of the corresponding large N effective action for composite operators. When sources are turned off a variety of fermionic condensates is found to persist. These include the chiral symmetry breaking condensates, thus recovering previous results, but also some LSB condensates, in particular, axial vector and rank-2 tensor condensates. Furthermore, in the presence of internal (global) symmetry groups, formation of condensates "locking" internal and external (Lorentz subgroup) symmetries is found to also become possible. Some implications and open questions are briefly discussed. △ Less

Submitted 6 February, 2012; v1 submitted 18 May, 2011; originally announced May 2011.

Comments: Revtex, 9 figures, replaced by published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 85, 024042 (2012)

Can Lorentz-breaking fermionic condensates form in large N strongly-coupled Lattice Gauge Theories?

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: The possibility of Lorentz symmetry breaking (LSB) has attracted considerable attention in recent years for a variety of reasons, including the attractive prospect of the graviton as a Goldstone boson. Though a number of effective field theory analyses of such phenomena have recently been given it remains an open question whether they can take place in an underlying UV complete theory. Here we con… ▽ More The possibility of Lorentz symmetry breaking (LSB) has attracted considerable attention in recent years for a variety of reasons, including the attractive prospect of the graviton as a Goldstone boson. Though a number of effective field theory analyses of such phenomena have recently been given it remains an open question whether they can take place in an underlying UV complete theory. Here we consider the question of LSB in large N lattice gauge theories in the strong coupling limit. We apply techniques that have previously been used to correctly predict the formation of chiral symmetry breaking condensates in this limit. Generalizing such methods to other composite operators we find that certain LSB condensates can indeed form. In addition, the interesting possibility arises of condensates that 'lock' internal with external symmetries. △ Less

Submitted 5 November, 2010; originally announced November 2010.

Comments: 7 pages, 3 figures + PoS logo, presented at the XXVIII International Symposium on Lattice Field Theory, Lattice2010

Journal ref: PoS Lattice2010:290,2010

Reply to arXiv:0711.4930[hep-th] by Ito and Seiler

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: In a recent note (arXiv:0711.4930[hep-th]) Ito and Seiler claim that there is a 'missing link' in the derivation in arXiv:0707.2179[hep-th] by the present author; namely, that no proof of a certain inequality used there is given at weak coupling. Here it is pointed out that in fact no such missing link is present. The argument in 0707.2179 is, among other things, specifically constructed so that… ▽ More In a recent note (arXiv:0711.4930[hep-th]) Ito and Seiler claim that there is a 'missing link' in the derivation in arXiv:0707.2179[hep-th] by the present author; namely, that no proof of a certain inequality used there is given at weak coupling. Here it is pointed out that in fact no such missing link is present. The argument in 0707.2179 is, among other things, specifically constructed so that the inequality in question is invoked {\it only} at strong coupling, where it is easily proven. Underlying the mangling of the argument in 0707.2179 by Ito and Seiler are their incorrect statements concerning the dependence of the potential-moving decimation procedures used in 0707.2179 on space-time dimensionality and other decimation parameters. △ Less

Submitted 16 December, 2007; originally announced December 2007.

Comments: 5 pages

Deriving confinement via RG decimations

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We present the general framework and building blocks of a recent derivation of the fact that the SU(2) LGT is in a confining phase for all values of the coupling $0 < β< \infty$, for space-time dimension $d \leq 4$. The method employs approximate but explicitly computable RG decimations that are shown to constrain the exact partition function and order parameters from above and below, and flow f… ▽ More We present the general framework and building blocks of a recent derivation of the fact that the SU(2) LGT is in a confining phase for all values of the coupling $0 < β< \infty$, for space-time dimension $d \leq 4$. The method employs approximate but explicitly computable RG decimations that are shown to constrain the exact partition function and order parameters from above and below, and flow from the weak to the strong coupling regime without encountering a fixed point. △ Less

Submitted 9 October, 2007; originally announced October 2007.

Comments: 7 pages, presented at the XXV International Symposium on Lattice Field Theoy, July 30 - August 4 2007, Regensburg, Germany

Journal ref: PoSLAT2007:336,2007

Improved actions and lattice coarsening effects in MCRG studies in SU(2) LGT

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis, A. Velytsky

Abstract: We study decimation procedures and effective (improved) actions in the framework of Monte Carlo Renormalization Group (MCRG). Particular attention is paid to matching the form of the effective action to the decimation procedure parameters. Using the static quark-antiquark potential in SU(2) LGT we probe different distance scales and find that an effective action containing multiple group represe… ▽ More We study decimation procedures and effective (improved) actions in the framework of Monte Carlo Renormalization Group (MCRG). Particular attention is paid to matching the form of the effective action to the decimation procedure parameters. Using the static quark-antiquark potential in SU(2) LGT we probe different distance scales and find that an effective action containing multiple group representations is capable of reproducing long distance physics well. In particular, appropriate matching results in the practical elimination of the coarsening/fining effect of the lattice spacing under decimation. The short distance regime of the effective theory is also studied. We next carry out studies of effective actions involving both multiple representations and loops beyond the single plaquette towards determining an improved action good over a wide length scale regime. △ Less

Submitted 19 September, 2007; originally announced September 2007.

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures; Lattice 2007 (Theoretical developments)

Journal ref: PoSLAT2007:381,2007

Confinement for all values of the coupling in four-dimensional SU(2) gauge theory

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: A derivation is given from first principles of the fact that the SU(2) gauge theory is in a confining phase for all values of the coupling $0 < g < \infty$ defined at lattice spacing (UV regulator) $a$, and space-time dimension $d \leq 4$. The strategy is to employ approximate RG decimation transformations of the potential moving type which give both upper and lower bounds on the partition funct… ▽ More A derivation is given from first principles of the fact that the SU(2) gauge theory is in a confining phase for all values of the coupling $0 < g < \infty$ defined at lattice spacing (UV regulator) $a$, and space-time dimension $d \leq 4$. The strategy is to employ approximate RG decimation transformations of the potential moving type which give both upper and lower bounds on the partition function at each successive decimation step. By interpolation between these bounds an exact representation of the partition function is obtained on progressively coarser lattices. In the same manner, one obtains a representation of the partition function in the presence of external center flux. Under successive decimations the flow of the effective action in these representations is constrained by that in the upper and lower bounds which are easily explicitly computable. Confining behavior for the vortex free energy order parameter (ratio of partition functions with and without external flux), hence `area law' for the Wilson loop, is the result for any initial coupling. Keeping the string tension fixed determines the dependence $g(a)$, which is such that $g(a) \to 0$ for $a \to 0$. △ Less

Submitted 15 July, 2007; originally announced July 2007.

Comments: 49 pages, 3 figures

String tension and removal of lattice coarsening effects in Monte Carlo Renormalization Group

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis, A. Velytsky

Abstract: We study the computation of the static quark potential under decimations in the Monte Carlo Renormalization Group (MCRG). Employing a multi-representation plaquette action, we find that fine-tuning the decimation prescription so that the MCRG equilibrium self-consistency condition is satisfied produces dramatic improvement at large distances. In particular, lattice coarsening (change of effectiv… ▽ More We study the computation of the static quark potential under decimations in the Monte Carlo Renormalization Group (MCRG). Employing a multi-representation plaquette action, we find that fine-tuning the decimation prescription so that the MCRG equilibrium self-consistency condition is satisfied produces dramatic improvement at large distances. In particular, lattice coarsening (change of effective lattice spacing on action-generated lattices after decimation) is nearly eliminated. Failure to correctly tune the decimation, on the other hand, produces large coarsening effects, of order 50% or more, consistent with those seen in previous studies. We also study rotational invariance restoration at short distances, where no particular improvement is seen for this action. △ Less

Submitted 2 May, 2007; originally announced May 2007.

Comments: 10 pages, 3 figures, 3 tables

Journal ref: Int.J.Mod.Phys.A23:803-812,2008

Improving the improved action

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis, A. Velytsky

Abstract: We investigate the construction of improved actions by the Monte Carlo Renormalization Group method in the context of SU(2) gauge theory utilizing different decimation procedures and effective actions. We demonstrate that the basic self-consistency requirement for correct application of MCRG, i.e. that the decimated configurations are equilibrium configurations of the adopted form of the effecti… ▽ More We investigate the construction of improved actions by the Monte Carlo Renormalization Group method in the context of SU(2) gauge theory utilizing different decimation procedures and effective actions. We demonstrate that the basic self-consistency requirement for correct application of MCRG, i.e. that the decimated configurations are equilibrium configurations of the adopted form of the effective action, can only be achieved by careful fine-tuning of the choice of decimation prescription and/or action. △ Less

Submitted 28 February, 2007; originally announced February 2007.

Comments: 8 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.Lett.98:181601,2007

Renormalization Group Therapy

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis, A. Velytsky

Abstract: We point out a general problem with the procedures commonly used to obtain improved actions from MCRG decimated configurations. Straightforward measurement of the couplings from the decimated configurations, by one of the known methods, can result into actions that do not correctly reproduce the physics on the undecimated lattice. This is because the decimated configurations are generally not re… ▽ More We point out a general problem with the procedures commonly used to obtain improved actions from MCRG decimated configurations. Straightforward measurement of the couplings from the decimated configurations, by one of the known methods, can result into actions that do not correctly reproduce the physics on the undecimated lattice. This is because the decimated configurations are generally not representative of the equilibrium configurations of the assumed form of the effective action at the measured couplings. Curing this involves fine-tuning of the chosen MCRG decimation procedure, which is also dependent on the form assumed for the effective action. We illustrate this in decimation studies of the SU(2) LGT using Swendsen and Double Smeared Blocking decimation procedures. A single-plaquette improved action involving five group representations and free of this pathology is given. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2007; originally announced February 2007.

Comments: 18 pages, 9 figures, 9 tables

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D75:076002,2007

RG decimation study of SU(2) gauge theory

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis, Alexander Velytsky

Abstract: We report on numerical studies of RG decimations in SU(2) gauge theory. We study in particular a class of plaquette actions involving sums of group representations. We measure a number of observables representative of different length scales in order to investigate the transformation of the system under different choices of spin blocking, and examine the flow of the effective action couplings. A… ▽ More We report on numerical studies of RG decimations in SU(2) gauge theory. We study in particular a class of plaquette actions involving sums of group representations. We measure a number of observables representative of different length scales in order to investigate the transformation of the system under different choices of spin blocking, and examine the flow of the effective action couplings. A need for a projection to some class of effective actions on the configurations resulting from the adopted numerical decimation procedures is demonstrated. A numerical decimation procedure resulting in the effective single plaquette Lagrangian tailored to reproduce different medium/large scale physics is devised. △ Less

Submitted 26 September, 2006; v1 submitted 26 September, 2006; originally announced September 2006.

Comments: 7 pages, Lattice 2006 (Confinement and Topology), several typos corrected

Journal ref: PoSLAT2006:077,2006

RG decimation-based approach to confinement and computation on coarser lattices

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: A systematic procedure is presented for connecting short to long scales in LGT. Approximate decimations are used which can provide both upper and lower bounds on the partition function. Its exact value is then obtained by interpolation between the bounds. By iterating the procedure representations of the partition function as well as other physical quantities can be obtained on progressively coa… ▽ More A systematic procedure is presented for connecting short to long scales in LGT. Approximate decimations are used which can provide both upper and lower bounds on the partition function. Its exact value is then obtained by interpolation between the bounds. By iterating the procedure representations of the partition function as well as other physical quantities can be obtained on progressively coarser lattices. For SU(2) IR flow into the confining strong coupling regime results for any initial $β$. △ Less

Submitted 23 September, 2005; originally announced September 2005.

Comments: 6 pages, Latex + PoS.cls, Lattice 2005, Topology and Confinement

Journal ref: PoS LAT2005 (2005) 311

Deconfinement transition dynamics and early thermalization in QGP

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis, A. Velytsky

Abstract: We perform SU(3) Lattice Gauge Theory simulations of the deconfinement transition attempting to mimic conditions encountered in heavy ion collisions. Specifically, we perform a sudden temperature quench across the deconfinement temperature, and follow the response of the system in successive simulation sweeps under spatial lattice expansion and temperature fall-off. In measurements of the Polyak… ▽ More We perform SU(3) Lattice Gauge Theory simulations of the deconfinement transition attempting to mimic conditions encountered in heavy ion collisions. Specifically, we perform a sudden temperature quench across the deconfinement temperature, and follow the response of the system in successive simulation sweeps under spatial lattice expansion and temperature fall-off. In measurements of the Polyakov loop and structure functions a robust strong signal of global instability response is observed through the exponential growth of low momentum modes. Development of these long range modes isotropizes the system which reaches thermalization shortly afterwards, and enters a stage of quasi-equilibrium expansion and cooling till its return to the confinement phase. The time scale characterizing full growth of the long range modes is largely unaffected by the conditions of spatial expansion and temperature variation in the system, and is much shorter than the scale set by the interval to return to the confinement phase. The wide separation of these two scales is such that it naturally results in isotropization times well inside 1 fm/c. △ Less

Submitted 28 October, 2005; v1 submitted 15 July, 2005; originally announced July 2005.

Comments: 11 pages, 8 eps figures, added references, typos corrected

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D72 (2005) 074509

RG Decimations and Confinement

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We outline the steps in a derivation of the statement that the SU(2) gauge theory is in a confining phase for all values of the coupling, $0 < β<\infty$, defined at lattice spacing a. The approach employed is to obtain both upper and lower bounds for the partition function and the `twisted' partition function in terms of approximate decimation transformations. The behavior of the exact quantitie… ▽ More We outline the steps in a derivation of the statement that the SU(2) gauge theory is in a confining phase for all values of the coupling, $0 < β<\infty$, defined at lattice spacing a. The approach employed is to obtain both upper and lower bounds for the partition function and the `twisted' partition function in terms of approximate decimation transformations. The behavior of the exact quantities is thus constrained by that of the easily computable bounding decimations. △ Less

Submitted 6 September, 2004; originally announced September 2004.

Comments: 6 pages, 1 figure, latex using espcrc2.sty, presented at `QCD Down Under', Adelaide, Australia, May 10-19, 2004

Connecting short to long scales in the confining vacuum

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We study approximate decimations in SU(N) LGT that connect the short to long distance regimes. Simple `bond-moving' decimations turn out to provide both upper and lower bounds on the exact partition function. This leads to a representation of the exact partition function in terms of successive decimations whose effective couplings flows are related to those of the easily computable bond-moving d… ▽ More We study approximate decimations in SU(N) LGT that connect the short to long distance regimes. Simple `bond-moving' decimations turn out to provide both upper and lower bounds on the exact partition function. This leads to a representation of the exact partition function in terms of successive decimations whose effective couplings flows are related to those of the easily computable bond-moving decimations. The implications for a derivation of confinement from first principles are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 16 November, 2003; originally announced November 2003.

Comments: 10 pages, 2 figures, Latex, Invited talk at Confinement 2003, Tokyo, Japan, July 21-24, 2003, to appear in the proceedings

From short to long scales in the QCD vacuum

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We study approximate decimations in SU(N) LGT that connect the short to long distance regimes, and provide both upper and lower bounds on the exact partition function. This leads to a representation of the exact partition function in terms of successive decimations. The implications for a derivation of confinement from first principles are discussed. We study approximate decimations in SU(N) LGT that connect the short to long distance regimes, and provide both upper and lower bounds on the exact partition function. This leads to a representation of the exact partition function in terms of successive decimations. The implications for a derivation of confinement from first principles are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 1 September, 2003; originally announced September 2003.

Comments: 3 pages, talk presented at Lattice2003(topology)

Loop inequalities and confinement

Authors: E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We consider correlation inequalities that follow from the well-known loop equations of LGT, and their analogues in spin systems. They provide a way of bounding long range by short or intermediate range correlations. In several cases the method easily reproduces results that otherwise require considerable effort to obtain. In particular, in the case of the 2-dimensional O(N) spin model, where lar… ▽ More We consider correlation inequalities that follow from the well-known loop equations of LGT, and their analogues in spin systems. They provide a way of bounding long range by short or intermediate range correlations. In several cases the method easily reproduces results that otherwise require considerable effort to obtain. In particular, in the case of the 2-dimensional O(N) spin model, where large N analytical results are available, the absence of a phase transition and the exponential decay of correlations for all $β$ is easily demonstrated. We report on the possible application of this technique to the analogous 4-dimensional problem of area law for the Wilson loop in LGT at large $β$. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2002; originally announced September 2002.

Comments: Lattice2002(topology), 3 pages

Vortex waistlines and vortex gas

Authors: T. G. Kovács, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We investigate the manner in which a linear potential arises from fluctuations due to vortices linked with the Wilson loop. In particular, the customary naive picture is critically reexamined. We investigate the manner in which a linear potential arises from fluctuations due to vortices linked with the Wilson loop. In particular, the customary naive picture is critically reexamined. △ Less

Submitted 15 October, 2001; originally announced October 2001.

Comments: Lattice2001(confinement), 3 pages, 1 eps figure, LaTex

Report number: UCLA/01/TEP/31

Journal ref: Nucl.Phys.Proc.Suppl.106:670-672,2002

Vortex waistlines and long range fluctuations

Authors: T. G. Kovacs, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We examine the manner in which a linear potential results from fluctuations due to vortices linked with the Wilson loop. Our discussion is based on exact relations and inequalities between the Wilson loop and the vortex and electric flux order parameters. We show that, contrary to the customary naive picture, only vortex fluctuations of thickness of the order of the spatial linear size of the lo… ▽ More We examine the manner in which a linear potential results from fluctuations due to vortices linked with the Wilson loop. Our discussion is based on exact relations and inequalities between the Wilson loop and the vortex and electric flux order parameters. We show that, contrary to the customary naive picture, only vortex fluctuations of thickness of the order of the spatial linear size of the loop are capable of producing a strictly linear potential. An effective theory of these long range fluctuations emerges naturally in the form of a strongly coupled Z(N) lattice gauge theory. We also point out that dynamical fermions introduced in this medium undergo chiral symmetry breaking. △ Less

Submitted 26 October, 2001; v1 submitted 14 August, 2001; originally announced August 2001.

Comments: 17 pages, LaTex file with 7 eps figures, revised references, minor comments added

Report number: UCLA/01/TEP/15

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D65 (2002) 074501

Vortex structure of the vacuum and confinement

Authors: T. G. Kovács, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We discuss the recently published numerical computations of the vortex free energy. They dramatically demonstrate that the excitation probability for a sufficiently thick vortex approaches unity at large beta, i.e. that thick vortices `condense' in the vacuum. This is known to imply confinement. An analytical approach for exploring this phenomenon is also outlined. We discuss the recently published numerical computations of the vortex free energy. They dramatically demonstrate that the excitation probability for a sufficiently thick vortex approaches unity at large beta, i.e. that thick vortices `condense' in the vacuum. This is known to imply confinement. An analytical approach for exploring this phenomenon is also outlined. △ Less

Submitted 30 October, 2000; originally announced October 2000.

Comments: LATTICE2000 (Topology and Vacuum), 4 pages, 1 epsf figure, LaTeX

Report number: UCLA/00/TEP/30

Journal ref: Nucl.Phys.Proc.Suppl. 94 (2001) 518-521

Computation of the Vortex Free Energy in SU(2) Gauge Theory

Authors: T. G. Kovacs, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We present the first measurement of the vortex free-energy order parameter at weak coupling for SU(2) in simulations employing multihistogram methods. The result shows that the excitation probability for a sufficiently thick vortex in the vacuum tends to unity. This is rigorously known to provide a necessary and sufficient condition for maintaining confinement at weak coupling in SU(N) gauge the… ▽ More We present the first measurement of the vortex free-energy order parameter at weak coupling for SU(2) in simulations employing multihistogram methods. The result shows that the excitation probability for a sufficiently thick vortex in the vacuum tends to unity. This is rigorously known to provide a necessary and sufficient condition for maintaining confinement at weak coupling in SU(N) gauge theories. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2000; v1 submitted 3 February, 2000; originally announced February 2000.

Comments: 7 pages, LaTeX with 3 eps figures, minor changes, replacement of Fig. 3

Report number: UCLA/00/TEP/06, INLO-PUB 02/00

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.Lett. 85 (2000) 704-707

Vortices and confinement

Authors: T. G. Kovács, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We review recent developments in the vortex picture of confinement. We discuss numerical simulations demonstrating that the entire asymptotic string tension is due to vortex-induced fluctuations of the Wilson loop. Analytical and numerical results concerning the presence of vortices as the necessary and sufficient condition for confinement at arbitrarily weak coupling in SU(N) gauge theories are… ▽ More We review recent developments in the vortex picture of confinement. We discuss numerical simulations demonstrating that the entire asymptotic string tension is due to vortex-induced fluctuations of the Wilson loop. Analytical and numerical results concerning the presence of vortices as the necessary and sufficient condition for confinement at arbitrarily weak coupling in SU(N) gauge theories are also discussed. △ Less

Submitted 23 December, 1999; v1 submitted 23 December, 1999; originally announced December 1999.

Comments: 12 pages, LaTeX file, 2 epsf figures. Contribution to the Proceedings of the workshop ``Lattice fermions and the structure of the vacuum'', 5-9 October 1999, Dubna, Russia

Report number: UCLA/99/TEP/49

Bound on the string tension by the excitation probability for a vortex

Authors: T. G. Kovács, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: A lower bound on the string tension for large beta in SU(2) LGT is derived. The derivation is from first principles and bounds the string tension from below by the expectation for the excitation of a single `tagged' thick vortex winding around the lattice. Thus confinement follows if this expectation remains nonvanishing at large beta. Numerical simulations are presented to show that this is ind… ▽ More A lower bound on the string tension for large beta in SU(2) LGT is derived. The derivation is from first principles and bounds the string tension from below by the expectation for the excitation of a single `tagged' thick vortex winding around the lattice. Thus confinement follows if this expectation remains nonvanishing at large beta. Numerical simulations are presented to show that this is indeed the case. △ Less

Submitted 20 August, 1999; originally announced August 1999.

Comments: LATTICE99(confine), 3 pages, 3 epsf figures, LaTeX, espcrc2.sty

Report number: UCLA/99/TEP/29

Journal ref: Nucl.Phys.Proc.Suppl. 83 (2000) 553-555

On P-vortices and the Gribov problem

Authors: Tamas G. Kovacs, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We study the possible connection between centre vortices and P-vortices in SU(2) gauge theory. After briefly recalling some essential properties of centre vortices we point out that there is no known a priori connection between the gauge dependent P-vortices and the gauge invariant centre vortices. We then show by Monte Carlo simulations that the `centre projected physics' strongly depends on th… ▽ More We study the possible connection between centre vortices and P-vortices in SU(2) gauge theory. After briefly recalling some essential properties of centre vortices we point out that there is no known a priori connection between the gauge dependent P-vortices and the gauge invariant centre vortices. We then show by Monte Carlo simulations that the `centre projected physics' strongly depends on the gauge copy from which the maximal centre gauge fixing is started. This reveals the presence of Gribov problems, and casts some doubts on the physical meaning of P-vortices, and should be further investigated. △ Less

Submitted 21 May, 1999; originally announced May 1999.

Comments: 8 pages, LaTeX with 2 eps figures

Report number: UCLA/99/TEP/25, INLO-PUB-11/99

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. B463 (1999) 104-108

SU(3) string tension and the presence of vortices

Authors: T. G. Kovács, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: Lattice simulations are presented showing the expectation of the fluctuation of the Wilson loop solely by elements of the center to fully reproduce the SU(3) heavy quark potential. The results are stable under smoothing, and point to thick vortices as being responsible for the full SU(3) tension. An analytic result on the necessary presence of thick vortices for confinement at weak coupling is a… ▽ More Lattice simulations are presented showing the expectation of the fluctuation of the Wilson loop solely by elements of the center to fully reproduce the SU(3) heavy quark potential. The results are stable under smoothing, and point to thick vortices as being responsible for the full SU(3) tension. An analytic result on the necessary presence of thick vortices for confinement at weak coupling is also presented. △ Less

Submitted 27 August, 1998; originally announced August 1998.

Comments: LATTICE98(confine)

Report number: UCLA/98/TEP/25

Journal ref: Nucl.Phys.Proc.Suppl. 73 (1999) 566-568

Vortices and the SU(3) string tension

Authors: T. G. Kovács, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We present simulation results comparing the SU(3) heavy quark potential extracted from the full Wilson loop expectation to that extracted from the expectation of the Wilson loop fluctuation solely by elements of Z(3). The two potentials are found to coincide. This agreement is stable under multiple smoothings of the configurations which remove short distance fluctuations, and thus reflects long-… ▽ More We present simulation results comparing the SU(3) heavy quark potential extracted from the full Wilson loop expectation to that extracted from the expectation of the Wilson loop fluctuation solely by elements of Z(3). The two potentials are found to coincide. This agreement is stable under multiple smoothings of the configurations which remove short distance fluctuations, and thus reflects long-distance physics. It strongly indicates that the asymptotic string tension arises from thick center vortices linking with the Wilson loop. △ Less

Submitted 12 July, 1998; originally announced July 1998.

Comments: 8 pages, LaTeX file with 6 eps figures

Report number: UCLA/98/TEP/15, COLO-HEP-412

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. B443 (1998) 239-243

Absence of confinement in the absence of vortices

Authors: T. G. Kovács, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We consider the Wilson loop expectation in SU(2) lattice gauge theory in the presence of constraints. The constraints eliminate from the functional measure gauge field configurations whose physical interpretation is that of thick center vortices linking with the loop. We give a simple proof that, for dimension $d \geq 3$, the so constrained Wilson loop follows perimeter law, i.e. non-confining b… ▽ More We consider the Wilson loop expectation in SU(2) lattice gauge theory in the presence of constraints. The constraints eliminate from the functional measure gauge field configurations whose physical interpretation is that of thick center vortices linking with the loop. We give a simple proof that, for dimension $d \geq 3$, the so constrained Wilson loop follows perimeter law, i.e. non-confining behavior, at weak coupling (low temperature). Thus the presence of vortex configurations is a necessary condition for confinement. △ Less

Submitted 25 June, 1998; originally announced June 1998.

Comments: 14 pages, LaTeX file

Report number: UCLA/98/TEP/14

Journal ref: J.Math.Phys. 40 (1999) 4677-4687

Vortices and confinement at weak coupling

Authors: Tamas G. Kovacs, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We discuss the physical picture of thick vortices as the mechanism responsible for confinement at arbitrarily weak coupling in SU(2) gauge theory. By introducing appropriate variables on the lattice we distinguish between thin, thick and `hybrid' vortices, the latter involving Z(2) monopole loop boundaries. We present numerical lattice simulation results that demonstrate that the full SU(2) stri… ▽ More We discuss the physical picture of thick vortices as the mechanism responsible for confinement at arbitrarily weak coupling in SU(2) gauge theory. By introducing appropriate variables on the lattice we distinguish between thin, thick and `hybrid' vortices, the latter involving Z(2) monopole loop boundaries. We present numerical lattice simulation results that demonstrate that the full SU(2) string tension at weak coupling arises from the presence of vortices linked to the Wilson loop. Conversely, excluding linked vortices eliminates the confining potential. The numerical results are stable under alternate choice of lattice action as well as a smoothing procedure which removes short distance fluctuations while preserving long distance physics. △ Less

Submitted 5 November, 1997; originally announced November 1997.

Comments: 21 pages, LaTeX

Report number: COLO-HEP-392 and UCLA/97/TEP/22

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 57, 4054 (1998)

Z(2) vortices and the string tension in SU(2) gauge theory

Authors: Tamas G. Kovacs, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We exhibit the appropriate variables allowing the plus-minus (Z(2)) `reduction' of the Wilson loop operator which provides a direct measure of the thin, thick and `mixed' Z(2) topological, gauge-invariant vortices in SU(2) LGT. Simulations with the Wilson action, as well as a perfect action smoothing procedure, show the string tension to be reproduced from the contributions of these excitations. We exhibit the appropriate variables allowing the plus-minus (Z(2)) `reduction' of the Wilson loop operator which provides a direct measure of the thin, thick and `mixed' Z(2) topological, gauge-invariant vortices in SU(2) LGT. Simulations with the Wilson action, as well as a perfect action smoothing procedure, show the string tension to be reproduced from the contributions of these excitations. △ Less

Submitted 15 September, 1997; originally announced September 1997.

Comments: 3 pages, LaTeX, 4 figures, uses espcrc2.sty, Talk given at LATTICE97

Report number: COLO-HEP-386

Journal ref: Nucl.Phys.Proc.Suppl. 63 (1998) 534-536

SO(3) monopoles, vortices and confinement in SU(2) gauge theory

Authors: Tamas G. Kovacs, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We report on further progress in our programme of understanding confinement in 3d and 4d SU(2) gauge theory in terms of Z(2) monopoles. A sufficient condition for confinement was previously translated into Z(2) monopole correlation inequalities in a related SO(3) gauge theory. We shall discuss the physical picture underlying this scenario and present some Monte Carlo evidence concerning the mono… ▽ More We report on further progress in our programme of understanding confinement in 3d and 4d SU(2) gauge theory in terms of Z(2) monopoles. A sufficient condition for confinement was previously translated into Z(2) monopole correlation inequalities in a related SO(3) gauge theory. We shall discuss the physical picture underlying this scenario and present some Monte Carlo evidence concerning the monopole correlation inequalities. △ Less

Submitted 26 July, 1996; originally announced July 1996.

Comments: Talk presented at LATTICE96(topology), 3 pages LaTeX, 2 figures (in LaTeX), uses esprc2.sty

Report number: UCLA/96/TEP/23

Journal ref: Nucl.Phys.Proc.Suppl. 53 (1997) 509-511

SO(3) vortices and disorder in the 2d SU(2) chiral model

Authors: Tamás G. Kovács, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We study the correlation function of the 2d SU(2) principal chiral model on the lattice. By rewriting the model in terms of Z(2) degrees of freedom coupled to SO(3) vortices we show that the vortices play a crucial role in disordering the correlations at low temperature. Using a series of exact transformations we prove that, if satisfied, certain inequalities between vortex correlations imply ex… ▽ More We study the correlation function of the 2d SU(2) principal chiral model on the lattice. By rewriting the model in terms of Z(2) degrees of freedom coupled to SO(3) vortices we show that the vortices play a crucial role in disordering the correlations at low temperature. Using a series of exact transformations we prove that, if satisfied, certain inequalities between vortex correlations imply exponential fall-off of the correlation function at arbitrarily low temperatures. We also present some Monte Carlo evidence that these correlation inequalities are indeed satisfied. Our method can be easily translated to the language of 4d SU(2) gauge theory to establish the role of corresponding SO(3) monopoles in maintaining confinement at small couplings. △ Less

Submitted 7 August, 1995; originally announced August 1995.

Comments: 13 pages LaTeX

Report number: UCLA/95/TEP/25

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. B367 (1996) 254-258

Topology on the lattice; 2d Yang-Mills theories with a theta term

Authors: Tamás G. Kovács, E. T. Tomboulis, Zsolt Schram

Abstract: We study two-dimensional U($N$) and SU($N$) gauge theories with a topological term on arbitrary surfaces. Starting from a lattice formulation we derive the continuum limit of the action which turns out to be a generalisation of the heat kernel in the presence of a topological term. In the continuum limit we can reconstruct the topological information encoded in the theta term. In the topological… ▽ More We study two-dimensional U($N$) and SU($N$) gauge theories with a topological term on arbitrary surfaces. Starting from a lattice formulation we derive the continuum limit of the action which turns out to be a generalisation of the heat kernel in the presence of a topological term. In the continuum limit we can reconstruct the topological information encoded in the theta term. In the topologically trivial cases the theta term gives only a trivial shift to the ground state energy but in the topologically nontrivial ones it remains to be coupled to the dynamics in the continuum. In particular for the U($N$) gauge group on orientable surfaces it gives rise to a phase transition at $θ= π$, similar to the ones observed in other models. Using the equivalence of 2d QCD and a 1d fermion gas on a circle we rewrite our result in the fermionic language and show that the theta term can be also interpreted as an external magnetic field imposed on the fermions. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 1995; originally announced May 1995.

Comments: 19 pages LaTeX

Report number: UCLA/95/TEP/14

Journal ref: Nucl.Phys. B454 (1995) 45-58

The SU(2) $\times$ SU(2) chiral spin model in terms of SO(3) and Z$_2$ variables: vortices and disorder

Authors: Tamás G. Kovaács, E. T. Tomboulis

Abstract: We rewrite the two-dimensional SU(2)$\times$ SU(2) chiral spin model in terms of SO(3) and {\bf Z}$_2$ degrees of freedom. The transformation, which is motivated by a similar representation of the corresponding lattice gauge theory in higher dimensions, exhibits the presence of dynamical SO(3) vortices and associated strings. We present arguments that (pairs of) SO(3) vortices with long strings… ▽ More We rewrite the two-dimensional SU(2)$\times$ SU(2) chiral spin model in terms of SO(3) and {\bf Z}$_2$ degrees of freedom. The transformation, which is motivated by a similar representation of the corresponding lattice gauge theory in higher dimensions, exhibits the presence of dynamical SO(3) vortices and associated strings. We present arguments that (pairs of) SO(3) vortices with long strings play a crucial role in disordering the spin system at arbitrarily low temperatures. △ Less

Submitted 3 November, 1993; originally announced November 1993.

Comments: 13 pages, UCLA/93/TEP/39

Journal ref: Phys.Lett. B321 (1994) 75-79