-
History of Lattice Field Theory from a Statistical Perspective
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz
Abstract:
Researchers working in lattice field theory constitute an established community since the early 1990s, and around the same time the online open-access e-print repository arXiv was created. The fact that this field has a specific arXiv section, hep-lat, which is comprehensively used, provides a unique opportunity for a statistical study of its evolution over the last three decades. We present data…
▽ More
Researchers working in lattice field theory constitute an established community since the early 1990s, and around the same time the online open-access e-print repository arXiv was created. The fact that this field has a specific arXiv section, hep-lat, which is comprehensively used, provides a unique opportunity for a statistical study of its evolution over the last three decades. We present data for the number of entries, $E$, published papers, $P$, and citations, $C$, in total and separated by nations. We compare them to six other arXiv sections (hep-ph, hep-th, gr-qc, nucl-th, quant-ph, cond-mat) and to two socio-economic indices of the nations involved: the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and the Education Index (EI). We present rankings, which are based either on the Hirsch Index H, or on the linear combination $Σ= E + P + 0.05 C$. We consider both extensive and intensive national statistics, i.e. absolute and relative to the population or to the GDP.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
A pion decay constant in the multi-flavor Schwinger model
Authors:
Jaime Fabián Nieto Castellanos,
Ivan Hip,
Wolfgang Bietenholz
Abstract:
The pion decay constant $F_π$ plays an important role in QCD and in Chiral Perturbation Theory. It is hardly known, however, that a corresponding constant exists in the Schwinger model with $N_{\rm f} \geq 2$ degenerate fermion flavors. In this case, the ``pion'' does not decay and $F_π$is dimensionless. Still, $F_π$ can be defined by 2d analogies to the Gell-Mann--Oakes--Renner relation, the Witt…
▽ More
The pion decay constant $F_π$ plays an important role in QCD and in Chiral Perturbation Theory. It is hardly known, however, that a corresponding constant exists in the Schwinger model with $N_{\rm f} \geq 2$ degenerate fermion flavors. In this case, the ``pion'' does not decay and $F_π$is dimensionless. Still, $F_π$ can be defined by 2d analogies to the Gell-Mann--Oakes--Renner relation, the Witten--Veneziano formula and the residual ``pion'' mass in the $δ$-regime. With suitable assumptions, and by inserting simulation data, these QCD-inspired relations are all compatible with $F_π \simeq 1/\sqrt{2π}$ at zero fermion mass, as we observe for $N_{\rm f} = 2, \dots , 6$. We conclude that this is a meaningful constant in the multi-flavor Schwinger model.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Non-equilibrium dynamics of topological defects in the 3d O(2) model
Authors:
Edgar López-Contreras,
Jaime Fabián Nieto Castellanos,
Elías Natanael Polanco-Euán,
Wolfgang Bietenholz
Abstract:
We present a study of the 3d O(2) non-linear $σ$-model on the lattice, which exhibits topological defects in the form of vortices. They tend to organize into vortex lines that bear close analogies with global cosmic strings. Therefore, this model serves as a testbed for studying the dynamics of topological defects. It undergoes a second order phase transition, hence it is appropriate for investiga…
▽ More
We present a study of the 3d O(2) non-linear $σ$-model on the lattice, which exhibits topological defects in the form of vortices. They tend to organize into vortex lines that bear close analogies with global cosmic strings. Therefore, this model serves as a testbed for studying the dynamics of topological defects. It undergoes a second order phase transition, hence it is appropriate for investigating the Kibble-Zurek mechanism. In this regard, we explore the persistence of topological defects when the temperature is rapidly reduced from above to below the critical temperature; this cooling (or "quenching") process takes the system out of equilibrium. We probe a wide range of inverse cooling rates $τ_{\rm Q}$ and final temperatures, employing distinct Monte Carlo algorithms. The results consistently show that the density of persisting topological defects follows a power-law in $τ_{\rm Q}$, in agreement with Zurek's conjecture. On the other hand, at this point our results do not confirm Zurek's prediction for the exponent in this power-law, but its final test is still under investigation.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
An analogue to the pion decay constant in the multi-flavor Schwinger model
Authors:
Jaime Fabián Nieto Castellanos,
Ivan Hip,
Wolfgang Bietenholz
Abstract:
We study the Schwinger model with $N_{\rm f} \geq 2$ degenerate fermion flavors, by means of lattice simulations. We use dynamical Wilson fermions for $N_{\rm f} = 2$, and re-weighted quenched configurations for overlap-hypercube fermions with $N_{\rm f} \leq 6$. In this framework, we explore an analogue of the QCD pion decay constant $F_π$, which is dimensionless in $d=2$, and which has hardly be…
▽ More
We study the Schwinger model with $N_{\rm f} \geq 2$ degenerate fermion flavors, by means of lattice simulations. We use dynamical Wilson fermions for $N_{\rm f} = 2$, and re-weighted quenched configurations for overlap-hypercube fermions with $N_{\rm f} \leq 6$. In this framework, we explore an analogue of the QCD pion decay constant $F_π$, which is dimensionless in $d=2$, and which has hardly been considered in the literature. We determine $F_π$ by three independent methods, with numerical and analytical ingredients. First, we consider the 2-dimensional version of the Gell-Mann--Oakes--Renner relation, where we insert both theoretical and numerical values for the quantities involved. Next we refer to the $δ$-regime, {\it i.e.\ a small spatial volume, where we assume formulae from Chiral Perturbation Theory to apply even in the absence of Nambu-Goldstone bosons. We further postulate an effective relation between $N_{\rm f}$ and the number of relevant, light bosons, which we denote as "pions". Thus $F_π$ is obtained from the residual "pion" mass in the chiral limit, which is a finite-size effect. Finally, we address to the 2-dimensional Witten--Veneziano formula: it yields a value for $F_η$, which we identify with $F_π$, as in large-$N_{\rm c}$ QCD. All three approaches consistently lead to $F_π \simeq 1/\sqrt{2 π}$ at fermion mass $m=0$, which implies that this quantity is meaningful.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2023; v1 submitted 28 April, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
The 3d O(4) model as an effective approach to the QCD phase diagram
Authors:
Edgar López-Contreras,
José Antonio García-Hernández,
Elías Natanael Polanco-Euán,
Wolfgang Bietenholz
Abstract:
The QCD phase diagram is one of the most prominent outstanding puzzles within the Standard Model. Various experiments, which aim at its exploration beyond small baryon density, are operating or in preparation. From the theoretical side, this is an issue of non-perturbative QCD, and therefore of lattice simulations. However, a finite baryon density entails a technical problem (known as the ``sign p…
▽ More
The QCD phase diagram is one of the most prominent outstanding puzzles within the Standard Model. Various experiments, which aim at its exploration beyond small baryon density, are operating or in preparation. From the theoretical side, this is an issue of non-perturbative QCD, and therefore of lattice simulations. However, a finite baryon density entails a technical problem (known as the ``sign problem''), which has not been overcome so far. Here we present a study of an effective theory, the O(4) non-linear sigma model. It performs spontaneous symmetry breaking with the same Lie group structure as 2-flavor QCD in the chiral limit, which strongly suggests that they belong to the same universality class. Since we are interested in high temperature, we further assume dimensional reduction to the 3d O(4) model, which implies topological sectors. As pointed out by Skyrme, Wilczek and others, its topological charge takes the rôle of the baryon number. Hence the baryon chemical potential $μ_{B}$ appears as an imaginary vacuum angle, which can be included in the lattice simulation without any sign problem. We present numerical results for the critical line in the chiral limit, and for the crossover in the presence of light quark masses. Their shapes are compatible with other predictions, but up to the value of about $μ_{B} \approx 300~{\rm MeV}$ we do not find the notorious Critical Endpoint (CEP).
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2022; v1 submitted 9 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Semi-vortices and cluster-vorticity: new concepts in the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition
Authors:
Brandon Gómez Bravo,
Bryan D. Juárez Hernández,
Wolfgang Bietenholz
Abstract:
The Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) essential phase transition in the 2d XY model is revisited. Its mechanism is usually described by the (un)binding of vortex--anti-vortex (V--AV) pairs, which does, however, not provide a clear-cut quantitative criterion for criticality. Known sharp criteria are the divergence of the correlation length and a discontinuity of the helicity modulus. Here we pr…
▽ More
The Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) essential phase transition in the 2d XY model is revisited. Its mechanism is usually described by the (un)binding of vortex--anti-vortex (V--AV) pairs, which does, however, not provide a clear-cut quantitative criterion for criticality. Known sharp criteria are the divergence of the correlation length and a discontinuity of the helicity modulus. Here we propose and probe a new criterion: it is based on the concepts of semi-vortices and cluster vorticity, which are formulated in the framework of the multi-cluster algorithm that we use to simulate the 2d XY model.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2022; v1 submitted 3 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
New insight in the 2-flavor Schwinger model based on lattice simulations
Authors:
Jaime Fabián Nieto Castellanos,
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Ivan Hip
Abstract:
We consider the Schwinger model with two degenerate, light fermion flavors by means of lattice simulations. At finite temperature, we probe the viability of a bosonization method by Hosotani et al. Next we explore an analogue to the pion decay constant, which agrees for independent formulations based on the Gell-Mann--Oakes--Renner relation, the 2-dimensional Witten--Veneziano formula and the $δ$-…
▽ More
We consider the Schwinger model with two degenerate, light fermion flavors by means of lattice simulations. At finite temperature, we probe the viability of a bosonization method by Hosotani et al. Next we explore an analogue to the pion decay constant, which agrees for independent formulations based on the Gell-Mann--Oakes--Renner relation, the 2-dimensional Witten--Veneziano formula and the $δ$-regime. Finally we confront several conjectures about the chiral condensate with lattice results.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2022; v1 submitted 20 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Conjecture about the QCD phase diagram
Authors:
José Antonio García-Hernández,
Edgar López-Contreras,
Elías Natanael Polanco-Euán,
Wolfgang Bietenholz
Abstract:
We present a phase diagram study of the O(4) model as an effective theory for 2-flavor QCD. In the chiral limit, both theories perform spontaneous symmetry breaking with isomorphic groups, which suggests that they belong to the same universality class. Since we are interested in high temperature, we further assume dimensional reduction to the 3d O(4) model, which implies topological sectors. Accor…
▽ More
We present a phase diagram study of the O(4) model as an effective theory for 2-flavor QCD. In the chiral limit, both theories perform spontaneous symmetry breaking with isomorphic groups, which suggests that they belong to the same universality class. Since we are interested in high temperature, we further assume dimensional reduction to the 3d O(4) model, which implies topological sectors. According to Skyrme and others, the corresponding topological charge represents the baryon number. Hence the baryon chemical potential $μ_{B}$ appears as an imaginary vacuum angle, which can be included in the lattice simulations without any sign problem. We present simulation results for the critical line in the chiral limit, and for the crossover in the presence of light quark masses. The shapes of these lines are compatible with other conjectures, but up to about $μ_{B} \approx 300$ MeV we do not find a Critical Endpoint, although there are indications for it to be near-by.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2021; v1 submitted 2 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
The Evolution of Lattice Field Theory: a Statistical Study
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz
Abstract:
Researchers working in lattice field theory constitute an established community since the early 1990s, and around the same time the online open-access e-print repository arXiv was created. The fact that this field has a specific arXiv section, hep-lat, provides a unique opportunity for a statistical study of its evolution over the last three decades. We present data for the number of entries, $E$,…
▽ More
Researchers working in lattice field theory constitute an established community since the early 1990s, and around the same time the online open-access e-print repository arXiv was created. The fact that this field has a specific arXiv section, hep-lat, provides a unique opportunity for a statistical study of its evolution over the last three decades. We present data for the number of entries, $E$, published papers, $P$, and citations, $C$, in total and separated by nations. We compare them to 6 other arXiv sections, and to socio-economic indices of the nations involved, namely the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and the Education Index (EI). We present rankings, which are based either on the Hirsch Index $H$, or on the linear combination $Σ= E + P + 0.05 C$. We consider both extensive and intensive national statistics, i.e. absolute and relative to the population or to the GDP.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2021; v1 submitted 5 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Finite temperature and delta-regime in the 2-flavor Schwinger model
Authors:
Ivan Hip,
Jaime Fabián Nieto Castellanos,
Wolfgang Bietenholz
Abstract:
The Schwinger model is often used as a testbed for conceptual and numerical approaches in lattice field theory. Still, some of its rich physical properties in anisotropic volumes have not yet been explored. For the multi-flavor finite temperature Schwinger model there is an approximate solution by Hosotani et al. based on bosonization. We perform lattice simulations and check the validity of this…
▽ More
The Schwinger model is often used as a testbed for conceptual and numerical approaches in lattice field theory. Still, some of its rich physical properties in anisotropic volumes have not yet been explored. For the multi-flavor finite temperature Schwinger model there is an approximate solution by Hosotani et al. based on bosonization. We perform lattice simulations and check the validity of this approximation in the case of two flavors. Next we exchange the rôle of the coordinates to enter the $δ$-regime, and measure the dependence of the residual "pion" mass on the spatial size, at zero temperature. Our results show that universal features, which were derived by Leutwyler, Hasenfratz and Niedermayer referring to quasi-spontaneous symmetry breaking in $d>2$, extend even to $d=2$. This enables the computation of the Schwinger model counterpart of the pion decay constant $F_π$. It is consistent with an earlier determination by Harada et al. who considered the divergence of the axial current in a light-cone formulation, and with analytical results that we conjecture from 2d versions of the Witten--Veneziano formula and the Gell-Mann--Oakes--Renner relation, which suggest $F_π = 1/ \sqrt{2π}$.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Meron- and Semi-Vortex-Clusters as Physical Carriers of Topological Charge and Vorticity
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
João C. Pinto Barros,
Stephan Caspar,
Manes Hornung,
Uwe-Jens Wiese
Abstract:
In O($N$) non-linear $σ$-models on the lattice, the Wolff cluster algorithm is based on rewriting the functional integral in terms of mutually independent clusters. Through improved estimators, the clusters are directly related to physical observables. In the $(N-1)$-d O($N$) model (with an appropriately constrained action) the clusters carry an integer or half-integer topological charge. Clusters…
▽ More
In O($N$) non-linear $σ$-models on the lattice, the Wolff cluster algorithm is based on rewriting the functional integral in terms of mutually independent clusters. Through improved estimators, the clusters are directly related to physical observables. In the $(N-1)$-d O($N$) model (with an appropriately constrained action) the clusters carry an integer or half-integer topological charge. Clusters with topological charge $\pm 1/2$ are denoted as merons. Similarly, in the 2-d O(2) model the clusters carry pairs of semi-vortices and semi-anti-vortices (with vorticity $\pm 1/2$) at their boundary. Using improved estimators, meron- and semi-vortex-clusters provide analytic insight into the topological features of the dynamics. We show that the histograms of the cluster-size distributions scale in the continuum limit, with a fractal dimension $D$, which suggests that the clusters are physical objects. We demonstrate this property analytically for merons and non-merons in the 1-d O(2) model (where $D=1$), and numerically for the 2-d O(2), 2-d O(3), and 3-d O(4) model, for which we observe fractal dimensions $D < d$. In the vicinity of a critical point, a scaling law relates $D$ to a combination of critical exponents. In the 2-d O(3) model, meron- and multi-meron-clusters are responsible for a logarithmic ultraviolet divergence of the topological susceptibility.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2019; v1 submitted 9 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Topological Susceptibility of the 2d O(3) Model under Gradient Flow
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Philippe de Forcrand,
Urs Gerber,
Héctor Mejía-Díaz,
Ilya O. Sandoval
Abstract:
The 2d O(3) model is widely used as a toy model for ferromagnetism and for Quantum Chromodynamics. With the latter it shares --- among other basic aspects --- the property that the continuum functional integral splits into topological sectors. Topology can also be defined in its lattice regularised version, but semi-classical arguments suggest that the topological susceptibility $χ_{\rm t}$ does n…
▽ More
The 2d O(3) model is widely used as a toy model for ferromagnetism and for Quantum Chromodynamics. With the latter it shares --- among other basic aspects --- the property that the continuum functional integral splits into topological sectors. Topology can also be defined in its lattice regularised version, but semi-classical arguments suggest that the topological susceptibility $χ_{\rm t}$ does not scale towards a finite continuum limit. Previous numerical studies confirmed that the quantity $χ_{\rm t}\, ξ^{2}$ diverges at large correlation length $ξ$. Here we investigate the question whether or not this divergence persists when the configurations are smoothened by the Gradient Flow (GF). The GF destroys part of the topological windings; on fine lattices this strongly reduces $χ_{\rm t}$. However, even when the flow time is so long that the GF impact range --- or smoothing radius --- attains $ξ/2$, we do still not observe evidence of continuum scaling.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2018; v1 submitted 24 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Topological Susceptibility under Gradient Flow
Authors:
Héctor Mejía-Díaz,
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Krzysztof Cichy,
Philippe de Forcrand,
Arthur Dromard,
Urs Gerber,
Ilya O. Sandoval
Abstract:
We study the impact of the Gradient Flow on the topology in various models of lattice field theory. The topological susceptibility $χ_{\rm t}$ is measured directly, and by the slab method, which is based on the topological content of sub-volumes ("slabs") and estimates $χ_{\rm t}$ even when the system remains trapped in a fixed topological sector. The results obtained by both methods are essential…
▽ More
We study the impact of the Gradient Flow on the topology in various models of lattice field theory. The topological susceptibility $χ_{\rm t}$ is measured directly, and by the slab method, which is based on the topological content of sub-volumes ("slabs") and estimates $χ_{\rm t}$ even when the system remains trapped in a fixed topological sector. The results obtained by both methods are essentially consistent, but the impact of the Gradient Flow on the characteristic quantity of the slab method seems to be different in 2-flavour QCD and in the 2d O(3) model. In the latter model, we further address the question whether or not the Gradient Flow leads to a finite continuum limit of the topological susceptibility (rescaled by the correlation length squared, $ξ^{2}$). This ongoing study is based on direct measurements of $χ_{\rm t}$ in $L \times L$ lattices, at $L/ξ\simeq 6$.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2017; v1 submitted 4 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Topology in the 2d Heisenberg Model under Gradient Flow
Authors:
Ilya O. Sandoval,
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Philippe de Forcrand,
Urs Gerber,
Héctor Mejía-Díaz
Abstract:
The 2d Heisenberg model --- or 2d O(3) model --- is popular in condensed matter physics, and in particle physics as a toy model for QCD. Along with other analogies, it shares with 4d Yang-Mills theories, and with QCD, the property that the configurations are divided in topological sectors. In the lattice regularisation the topological charge $Q$ can still be defined such that $Q \in \mathbb{Z}$. I…
▽ More
The 2d Heisenberg model --- or 2d O(3) model --- is popular in condensed matter physics, and in particle physics as a toy model for QCD. Along with other analogies, it shares with 4d Yang-Mills theories, and with QCD, the property that the configurations are divided in topological sectors. In the lattice regularisation the topological charge $Q$ can still be defined such that $Q \in \mathbb{Z}$. It has generally been observed, however, that the topological susceptibility $χ_{\rm t} = \langle Q^2 \rangle / V$ does not scale properly in the continuum limit, i.e. that the quantity $χ_{\rm t} ξ^2$ diverges for $ξ\to \infty$ (where $ξ$ is the correlation length in lattice units). Here we address the question whether or not this divergence persists after the application of the Gradient Flow.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless Transition and the Haldane Conjecture: Highlights of the Physics Nobel Prize 2016
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Urs Gerber
Abstract:
The 2016 Physics Nobel Prize honors a variety of discoveries related to topological phases and phase transitions. Here we sketch two exciting facets: the groundbreaking works by John Kosterlitz and David Thouless on phase transitions of infinite order, and by Duncan Haldane on the energy gaps in quantum spin chains. These insights came as surprises in the 1970s and 1980s, respectively, and they ha…
▽ More
The 2016 Physics Nobel Prize honors a variety of discoveries related to topological phases and phase transitions. Here we sketch two exciting facets: the groundbreaking works by John Kosterlitz and David Thouless on phase transitions of infinite order, and by Duncan Haldane on the energy gaps in quantum spin chains. These insights came as surprises in the 1970s and 1980s, respectively, and they have both initiated new fields of research in theoretical and experimental physics.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2017; v1 submitted 19 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
The Slab Method to Measure the Topological Susceptibility
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Krzysztof Cichy,
Philippe de Forcrand,
Arthur Dromard,
Urs Gerber
Abstract:
In simulations of a model with topological sectors, algorithms which proceed in small update steps tend to get stuck in one sector, especially on fine lattices. This distorts the numerical results; in particular it is not straightforward to measure the topological susceptibility chi_t. We test a method to measure chi_t even if configurations from only one sector are available. It is based on the t…
▽ More
In simulations of a model with topological sectors, algorithms which proceed in small update steps tend to get stuck in one sector, especially on fine lattices. This distorts the numerical results; in particular it is not straightforward to measure the topological susceptibility chi_t. We test a method to measure chi_t even if configurations from only one sector are available. It is based on the topological charges in sub-volumes, which we denote as "slab". This enables the evaluation of chi_t, as we demonstrate with numerical results for non-linear sigma-models and for 2-flavour QCD. In the latter case, the gradient flow is applied for the smoothing of the gauge configurations, and the slab method results for chi_t are stable over a broad range of flow times.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2016; v1 submitted 3 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Computing the topological susceptibility from fixed topology QCD simulations
Authors:
Arthur Dromard,
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Krzysztof Cichy,
Marc Wagner
Abstract:
The topological susceptibility is an important quantity in QCD, which can be computed using lattice methods. However, at a fine lattice spacing, or when using high quality chirally symmetric quarks, algorithms which proceed in small update steps --- in particular the HMC algorithm --- tend to get stuck in a single topological sector. In such cases, the computation of the topological susceptibility…
▽ More
The topological susceptibility is an important quantity in QCD, which can be computed using lattice methods. However, at a fine lattice spacing, or when using high quality chirally symmetric quarks, algorithms which proceed in small update steps --- in particular the HMC algorithm --- tend to get stuck in a single topological sector. In such cases, the computation of the topological susceptibility is not straightforward. Here, we explore two methods to extract the topological susceptibility from lattice QCD simulations restricted to a single topological sector. The first method is based on the correlation function of the topological charge density, while the second method relies on measuring the topological charge within spacetime subvolumes. Numerical results for two-flavor QCD obtained by using both methods are presented.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Hadron Physics from Lattice QCD
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz
Abstract:
We sketch the basic ideas of the lattice regularization in Quantum Field Theory, the corresponding Monte Carlo simulations, and applications to Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). This approach enables the numerical measurement of observables at the non-perturbative level. We comment on selected results, with a focus on hadron masses and the link to Chiral Perturbation Theory. At last we address two out…
▽ More
We sketch the basic ideas of the lattice regularization in Quantum Field Theory, the corresponding Monte Carlo simulations, and applications to Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). This approach enables the numerical measurement of observables at the non-perturbative level. We comment on selected results, with a focus on hadron masses and the link to Chiral Perturbation Theory. At last we address two outstanding issues: topological freezing and the sign problem.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Interpreting Numerical Measurements in Fixed Topological Sectors
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Christopher Czaban,
Arthur Dromard,
Urs Gerber,
Christoph P. Hofmann,
Héctor Mejía-Díaz,
Marc Wagner
Abstract:
For quantum field theories with topological sectors, Monte Carlo simulations on fine lattices tend to be obstructed by an extremely long auto-correlation time with respect to the topological charge. Then reliable numerical measurements are feasible only within individual sectors. The challenge is to assemble such restricted measurements in a way that leads to a substantiated approximation to the f…
▽ More
For quantum field theories with topological sectors, Monte Carlo simulations on fine lattices tend to be obstructed by an extremely long auto-correlation time with respect to the topological charge. Then reliable numerical measurements are feasible only within individual sectors. The challenge is to assemble such restricted measurements in a way that leads to a substantiated approximation to the fully fledged result, which would correspond to the correct sampling over the entire set of configurations. We test an approach for such a topological summation, which was suggested by Brower, Chandrasekharan, Negele and Wiese. Under suitable conditions, energy levels and susceptibilities can be obtained to a good accuracy, as we demonstrate for O(N) models, SU(2) Yang-Mills theory, and for the Schwinger model.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2016; v1 submitted 17 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Combining ordinary and topological finite volume effects for fixed topology simulations
Authors:
Arthur Dromard,
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Urs Gerber,
Héctor Mejía-Díaz,
Marc Wagner
Abstract:
In lattice quantum field theories with topological sectors, simulations at fine lattice spacings --- with typical algorithms --- tend to freeze topologically. In such cases, specific topological finite size effects have to be taken into account to obtain physical results, which correspond to infinite volume or unfixed topology. Moreover, when a theory like QCD is simulated in a moderate volume, on…
▽ More
In lattice quantum field theories with topological sectors, simulations at fine lattice spacings --- with typical algorithms --- tend to freeze topologically. In such cases, specific topological finite size effects have to be taken into account to obtain physical results, which correspond to infinite volume or unfixed topology. Moreover, when a theory like QCD is simulated in a moderate volume, one also has to overcome ordinary finite volume effects (not related to topology freezing). To extract physical results from simulations affected by both types of finite volume effects, we extend a known relation between hadron masses at fixed and unfixed topology by additionally incorporating ordinary finite volume effects. We present numerical results for SU(2) Yang-Mills theory.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Proposal for the Quantum Simulation of the CP(2) Model on Optical Lattices
Authors:
Catherine Laflamme,
Wynne Evans,
Marcello Dalmonte,
Urs Gerber,
Héctor Mejía-Díaz,
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Uwe-Jens Wiese,
Peter Zoller
Abstract:
The 2d CP(N-1) models share a number of features with QCD, like asymptotic freedom, a dynamically generated mass gap and topological sectors. They have been formulated and analysed successfully in the framework of the so-called D-theory, which provides a smooth access to the continuum limit. In that framework, we propose an experimental set-up for the quantum simulation of the CP(2) model. It is b…
▽ More
The 2d CP(N-1) models share a number of features with QCD, like asymptotic freedom, a dynamically generated mass gap and topological sectors. They have been formulated and analysed successfully in the framework of the so-called D-theory, which provides a smooth access to the continuum limit. In that framework, we propose an experimental set-up for the quantum simulation of the CP(2) model. It is based on ultra-cold Alkaline-Earth Atoms (AEAs) located on the sites of an optical lattice, where the nuclear spins represent the relevant degrees of freedom. We present numerical results for the correlation length and for the real time decay of a false vacuum, to be compared with such a future experiment. The latter could also enable the exploration of theta-vacua and of the phase diagram at finite chemical potentials, since it does not suffer from any sign problem.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Topological Susceptibility from Slabs
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Philippe de Forcrand,
Urs Gerber
Abstract:
In quantum field theories with topological sectors, a non-perturbative quantity of interest is the topological susceptibility chi_t. In principle it seems straightforward to measure chi_t by means of Monte Carlo simulations. However, for local update algorithms and fine lattice spacings, this tends to be difficult, since the Monte Carlo history rarely changes the topological sector. Here we test a…
▽ More
In quantum field theories with topological sectors, a non-perturbative quantity of interest is the topological susceptibility chi_t. In principle it seems straightforward to measure chi_t by means of Monte Carlo simulations. However, for local update algorithms and fine lattice spacings, this tends to be difficult, since the Monte Carlo history rarely changes the topological sector. Here we test a method to measure chi_t even if data from only one sector are available. It is based on the topological charges in sub-volumes, which we denote as slabs. Assuming a Gaussian distribution of these charges, this method enables the evaluation of chi_t, as we demonstrate with numerical results for non-linear sigma-models.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
CP(N-1) Quantum Field Theories with Alkaline-Earth Atoms in Optical Lattices
Authors:
C. Laflamme,
W. Evans,
M. Dalmonte,
U. Gerber,
H. Mejía-Díaz,
W. Bietenholz,
U. -J. Wiese,
P. Zoller
Abstract:
We propose a cold atom implementation to attain the continuum limit of (1+1)-d CP(N-1) quantum field theories. These theories share important features with (3+1)-d QCD, such as asymptotic freedom and $θ$ vacua. Moreover, their continuum limit can be accessed via the mechanism of dimensional reduction. In our scheme, the CP(N-1) degrees of freedom emerge at low energies from a ladder system of SU(N…
▽ More
We propose a cold atom implementation to attain the continuum limit of (1+1)-d CP(N-1) quantum field theories. These theories share important features with (3+1)-d QCD, such as asymptotic freedom and $θ$ vacua. Moreover, their continuum limit can be accessed via the mechanism of dimensional reduction. In our scheme, the CP(N-1) degrees of freedom emerge at low energies from a ladder system of SU(N) quantum spins, where the N spin states are embodied by the nuclear Zeeman states of alkaline-earth atoms, trapped in an optical lattice. Based on Monte Carlo results, we establish that the continuum limit can be demonstrated by an atomic quantum simulation by employing the feature of asymptotic freedom. We discuss a protocol for the adiabatic state preparation of the ground state of the system, the real-time evolution of a false $θ$-vacuum state after a quench, and we propose experiments to unravel the phase diagram at non-zero density.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2016; v1 submitted 24 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Simulations at fixed topology: fixed topology versus ordinary finite volume corrections
Authors:
Arthur Dromard,
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Urs Gerber,
Héctor Mejía-Díaz,
Marc Wagner
Abstract:
Lattice QCD simulations tend to get stuck in a single topological sector at fine lattice spacing, or when using chirally symmetric quarks. In such cases computed observables differ from their full QCD counterparts by finite volume corrections, which need to be understood on a quantitative level. We extend a known relation from the literature between hadron masses at fixed and at unfixed topology b…
▽ More
Lattice QCD simulations tend to get stuck in a single topological sector at fine lattice spacing, or when using chirally symmetric quarks. In such cases computed observables differ from their full QCD counterparts by finite volume corrections, which need to be understood on a quantitative level. We extend a known relation from the literature between hadron masses at fixed and at unfixed topology by incorporating in addition to topological finite volume effects, also ordinary finite volume effects. We present numerical results for SU(2) Yang-Mills theory.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Measuring the Topological Susceptibility in a Fixed Sector
Authors:
Irais Bautista,
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Arthur Dromard,
Urs Gerber,
Christoph P. Hofmann,
Lukas Gonglach,
Héctor Mejía-Díaz,
Marc Wagner
Abstract:
For field theories with a topological charge Q, it is often of interest to measure the topological susceptibility chi_t = ( < Q^2 > - < Q >^2 ) / V. If we manage to perform a Monte Carlo simulation where Q changes frequently, chi_t can be evaluated directly. However, for local update algorithms and fine lattices, the auto-correlation time with respect to Q tends to be extremely long, which invalid…
▽ More
For field theories with a topological charge Q, it is often of interest to measure the topological susceptibility chi_t = ( < Q^2 > - < Q >^2 ) / V. If we manage to perform a Monte Carlo simulation where Q changes frequently, chi_t can be evaluated directly. However, for local update algorithms and fine lattices, the auto-correlation time with respect to Q tends to be extremely long, which invalidates the direct approach. Nevertheless, the measurement of chi_t is still feasible, even when the entire Markov chain is topologically frozen. We test a method for this purpose, based on the correlation of the topological charge density, as suggested by Aoki, Fukaya, Hashimoto and Onogi. Our studies in non-linear sigma-models and in 2d Abelian gauge theory yield accurate results for chi_t, which confirm that the method is applicable. We also obtain promising results in 4d SU(2) Yang-Mills theory, which suggest the applicability of this method in QCD.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2015; v1 submitted 23 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Extracting Physics from Topologically Frozen Markov Chains
Authors:
Urs Gerber,
Irais Bautista,
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Héctor Mejía-Díaz,
Christoph P. Hofmann
Abstract:
In Monte Carlo simulations with a local update algorithm, the auto-correlation with respect to the topological charge tends to become very long. In the extreme case one can only perform reliable measurements within fixed sectors. We investigate approaches to extract physical information from such topologically frozen simulations. Recent results in a set of sigma-models and gauge theories are encou…
▽ More
In Monte Carlo simulations with a local update algorithm, the auto-correlation with respect to the topological charge tends to become very long. In the extreme case one can only perform reliable measurements within fixed sectors. We investigate approaches to extract physical information from such topologically frozen simulations. Recent results in a set of sigma-models and gauge theories are encouraging. In a suitable regime, the correct value of some observable can be evaluated to a good accuracy. In addition there are ways to estimate the value of the topological susceptibility.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
The Continuum Phase Diagram of the 2d Non-Commutative lambda phi**4 Model
Authors:
Héctor Mejía-Díaz,
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Marco Panero
Abstract:
We present a non-perturbative study of the lambda phi**4 model on a non-commutative plane. The lattice regularised form can be mapped onto a Hermitian matrix model, which enables Monte Carlo simulations. Numerical data reveal the phase diagram; at large lambda it contains a "striped phase", which is absent in the commutative case. We explore the question whether or not this phenomenon persists in…
▽ More
We present a non-perturbative study of the lambda phi**4 model on a non-commutative plane. The lattice regularised form can be mapped onto a Hermitian matrix model, which enables Monte Carlo simulations. Numerical data reveal the phase diagram; at large lambda it contains a "striped phase", which is absent in the commutative case. We explore the question whether or not this phenomenon persists in a Double Scaling Limit (DSL), which extrapolates simultaneously to the continuum and to infinite volume, at a fixed non-commutativity parameter. To this end, we introduce a dimensional lattice spacing based on the decay of the correlation function. Our results provide evidence for the existence of a striped phase even in the DSL, which implies the spontaneous breaking of translation symmetry. Due to the non-locality of this model, this does not contradict the Mermin-Wagner Theorem.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2014; v1 submitted 13 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Scalar fields in a non-commutative space
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Frank Hofheinz,
Héctor Mejía-Díaz,
Marco Panero
Abstract:
We discuss the lambda phi**4 model in 2- and 3-dimensional non-commutative spaces. The mapping onto a Hermitian matrix model enables its non-perturbative investigation by Monte Carlo simulations. The numerical results reveal a phase where stripe patterns dominate. In d=3 we show that in this phase the dispersion relation is deformed in the IR regime, in agreement with the property of UV/IR mixing.…
▽ More
We discuss the lambda phi**4 model in 2- and 3-dimensional non-commutative spaces. The mapping onto a Hermitian matrix model enables its non-perturbative investigation by Monte Carlo simulations. The numerical results reveal a phase where stripe patterns dominate. In d=3 we show that in this phase the dispersion relation is deformed in the IR regime, in agreement with the property of UV/IR mixing. This "striped phase" also occurs in d=2. For both dimensions we provide evidence that it persists in the simultaneous limit to the continuum and to infinite volume ("Double Scaling Limit"). This implies the spontaneous breaking of translation symmetry.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Interpretation of topologically restricted measurements in lattice sigma-models
Authors:
Irais Bautista,
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Urs Gerber,
Christoph P. Hofmann,
Héctor Mejía-Díaz,
Lilian Prado
Abstract:
We consider models with topological sectors, and difficulties with their Monte Carlo simulation. In particular we are concerned with the situation where a simulation has an extremely long auto-correlation time with respect to the topological charge. Then reliable numerical measurements are possible only within single topological sectors. The challenge is to assemble such restricted measurements to…
▽ More
We consider models with topological sectors, and difficulties with their Monte Carlo simulation. In particular we are concerned with the situation where a simulation has an extremely long auto-correlation time with respect to the topological charge. Then reliable numerical measurements are possible only within single topological sectors. The challenge is to assemble such restricted measurements to obtain an approximation for the full-fledged result, which corresponds to the correct sampling over the entire set of configurations. Under certain conditions this is possible, and it provides in addition an estimate for the topological susceptibility chi_t. Moreover, the evaluation of chi_t might be feasible even from data in just one topological sector, based on the correlation of the topological charge density. Here we present numerical test results for these techniques in the framework of non-linear sigma-models.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
New insight into the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition
Authors:
Urs Gerber,
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Fernando G Rejón-Barrera
Abstract:
We investigate the 2d XY model by using the constraint angle action, which belongs to the class of topological lattice actions. These actions violate important features usually demanded for a lattice action, such as the correct classical continuum limit and the applicability of perturbation theory. Nevertheless, they still lead to the same universal quantum continuum limit and show excellent scali…
▽ More
We investigate the 2d XY model by using the constraint angle action, which belongs to the class of topological lattice actions. These actions violate important features usually demanded for a lattice action, such as the correct classical continuum limit and the applicability of perturbation theory. Nevertheless, they still lead to the same universal quantum continuum limit and show excellent scaling behavior. By using the constraint angle action we gain new insight into the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition of the 2d XY model. This phase transition is of special interest since it is one of the few examples of a phase transition beyond second order. It is of infinite order and therefore an essential phase transition. In particular, we observe an excellent scaling behavior of the helicity modulus, which characterizes this phase transition. We also observe that the mechanism of (un)binding vortex--anti-vortex pairs follows the usual pattern, although free vortices do not require any energy in the formulation of the 2d XY model using the constraint angle action.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Microscopic Dirac Spectrum in a 2d Gauge Theory with Zero Chiral Condensate
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Ivan Hip,
David Landa-Marbán
Abstract:
Fermionic theories with a vanishing chiral condensate (in the chiral limit) have recently attracted considerable interest; in particular variants of multi-flavour QCD are candidates for this behaviour. Here we consider the 2-flavour Schwinger model as a simple theory with this property. Based on simulations with light dynamical overlap fermions, we test the hypothesis that in such models the low l…
▽ More
Fermionic theories with a vanishing chiral condensate (in the chiral limit) have recently attracted considerable interest; in particular variants of multi-flavour QCD are candidates for this behaviour. Here we consider the 2-flavour Schwinger model as a simple theory with this property. Based on simulations with light dynamical overlap fermions, we test the hypothesis that in such models the low lying Dirac eigenvalues could be decorrelated. That has been observed in 4d Yang-Mills theories at high temperature, but it cannot be confirmed for the 2-flavour Schwinger model. We also discuss subtleties in the evaluation of the mass anomalous dimension and its IR extrapolation.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
O(N) Models with Topological Lattice Actions
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Michael Bögli,
Urs Gerber,
Ferenc Niedermayer,
Michele Pepe,
Fernando G. Rejón-Barrera,
Uwe-Jens Wiese
Abstract:
A variety of lattice discretisations of continuum actions has been considered, usually requiring the correct classical continuum limit. Here we discuss "weird" lattice formulations without that property, namely lattice actions that are invariant under most continuous deformations of the field configuration, in one version even without any coupling constants. It turns out that universality is power…
▽ More
A variety of lattice discretisations of continuum actions has been considered, usually requiring the correct classical continuum limit. Here we discuss "weird" lattice formulations without that property, namely lattice actions that are invariant under most continuous deformations of the field configuration, in one version even without any coupling constants. It turns out that universality is powerful enough to still provide the correct quantum continuum limit, despite the absence of a classical limit, or a perturbative expansion. We demonstrate this for a set of O(N) models (or non-linear $σ$-models). Amazingly, such "weird" lattice actions are not only in the right universality class, but some of them even have practical benefits, in particular an excellent scaling behaviour.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless Transition with a Constraint Lattice Action
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Urs Gerber,
Fernando G. Rejón-Barrera
Abstract:
The 2d XY model exhibits an essential phase transition, which was predicted long ago --- by Berezinskii, Kosterlitz and Thouless (BKT) --- to be driven by the (un)binding of vortex--anti-vortex pairs. This transition has been confirmed for the standard lattice action, and for actions with distinct couplings, in agreement with universality. Here we study a highly unconventional formulation of this…
▽ More
The 2d XY model exhibits an essential phase transition, which was predicted long ago --- by Berezinskii, Kosterlitz and Thouless (BKT) --- to be driven by the (un)binding of vortex--anti-vortex pairs. This transition has been confirmed for the standard lattice action, and for actions with distinct couplings, in agreement with universality. Here we study a highly unconventional formulation of this model, which belongs to the class of topological lattice actions: it does not have any couplings at all, but just a constraint for the relative angles between nearest neighbour spins. By means of dynamical boundary conditions we measure the helicity modulus Upsilon, which shows that this formulation performs a BKT phase transition as well. Its finite size effects are amazingly mild, in contrast to other lattice actions. This provides one of the most precise numerical confirmations ever of a BKT transition in this model. On the other hand, up to the lattice sizes that we explored, there are deviations from the spin wave approximation, for instance for the Binder cumulant U_4 and for the leading finite size correction to Upsilon. Finally we observe that the (un)binding mechanism follows the usual pattern, although free vortices do not require any energy in this formulation. Due to that observation, one should reconsider an aspect of the established picture, which estimates the critical temperature based on this energy requirement.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2013; v1 submitted 1 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Features of a 2d Gauge Theory with Vanishing Chiral Condensate
Authors:
David Landa-Marbán,
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Ivan Hip
Abstract:
The Schwinger model with $N_f \geq 2$ flavors is a simple example for a fermionic model with zero chiral condensate Sigma (in the chiral limit). We consider numerical data for two light flavors, based on simulations with dynamical chiral lattice fermions. We test properties and predictions that were put forward in the recent literature for models with Sigma = 0, which include IR conformal theories…
▽ More
The Schwinger model with $N_f \geq 2$ flavors is a simple example for a fermionic model with zero chiral condensate Sigma (in the chiral limit). We consider numerical data for two light flavors, based on simulations with dynamical chiral lattice fermions. We test properties and predictions that were put forward in the recent literature for models with Sigma = 0, which include IR conformal theories. In particular we probe the decorrelation of low lying Dirac eigenvalues, and we discuss the mass anomalous dimension and its IR extrapolation. Here we encounter subtleties, which may urge caution with analogous efforts in other models, such as multi-flavor QCD.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2014; v1 submitted 30 June, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Topological Lattice Actions for the 2d XY Model
Authors:
W. Bietenholz,
M. Bögli,
F. Niedermayer,
M. Pepe,
F. G. Rejón-Barrera,
U. -J. Wiese
Abstract:
We consider the 2d XY Model with topological lattice actions, which are invariant against small deformations of the field configuration. These actions constrain the angle between neighbouring spins by an upper bound, or they explicitly suppress vortices (and anti-vortices). Although topological actions do not have a classical limit, they still lead to the universal behaviour of the Berezinskii-Kos…
▽ More
We consider the 2d XY Model with topological lattice actions, which are invariant against small deformations of the field configuration. These actions constrain the angle between neighbouring spins by an upper bound, or they explicitly suppress vortices (and anti-vortices). Although topological actions do not have a classical limit, they still lead to the universal behaviour of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) phase transition - at least up to moderate vortex suppression. Thus our study underscores the robustness of universality, which persists even when basic principles of classical physics are violated. In the massive phase, the analytically known Step Scaling Function (SSF) is reproduced in numerical simulations. In the massless phase, the BKT value of the critical exponent eta_c is confirmed. Hence, even though for some topological actions vortices cost zero energy, they still drive the standard BKT transition. In addition we identify a vortex-free transition point, which deviates from the BKT behaviour.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2012; v1 submitted 3 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Topological Summation in Lattice Gauge Theory
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Ivan Hip
Abstract:
In gauge theories the field configurations often occur in distinct topological sectors. In a lattice regularised system with chiral fermions, these sectors can be defined by referring to the Atiyah-Singer Index Theorem. However, if such a model is simulated with local updates of the lattice gauge configuration, the Monte Carlo history tends to get stuck in one sector for many steps, in particular…
▽ More
In gauge theories the field configurations often occur in distinct topological sectors. In a lattice regularised system with chiral fermions, these sectors can be defined by referring to the Atiyah-Singer Index Theorem. However, if such a model is simulated with local updates of the lattice gauge configuration, the Monte Carlo history tends to get stuck in one sector for many steps, in particular on fine lattices. Then expectation values can be measured only within specific sectors. Here we present a pilot study in the 2-flavour Schwinger model which explores methods of approximating the complete result for an observable - corresponding to a suitable sum over all sectors - based on numerical measurements in a few specific topological sectors. We also probe various procedures for an indirect evaluation of the topological susceptibility, starting from such topologically restricted measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2012;
originally announced January 2012.
-
A Numerical Study of the 2-Flavour Schwinger Model with Dynamical Overlap Hypercube Fermions
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Ivan Hip,
Stanislav Shcheredin,
Jan Volkholz
Abstract:
We present numerical results for the 2-flavour Schwinger model with dynamical chiral lattice fermions. We insert an approximately chiral hypercube Dirac operator into the overlap formula to construct the overlap hypercube operator. This is an exact solution to the Ginsparg-Wilson relation, with an excellent level of locality and scaling. Due to its similarity with the hypercubic kernel, a low poly…
▽ More
We present numerical results for the 2-flavour Schwinger model with dynamical chiral lattice fermions. We insert an approximately chiral hypercube Dirac operator into the overlap formula to construct the overlap hypercube operator. This is an exact solution to the Ginsparg-Wilson relation, with an excellent level of locality and scaling. Due to its similarity with the hypercubic kernel, a low polynomial in this kernel provides a numerically efficient Hybrid Monte Carlo force. We measure the microscopic Dirac spectrum and discuss the corresponding scale-invariant parameter, which takes a surprising form. This is an interesting case, since Random Matrix Theory is unexplored for this setting, where the chiral condensate Σ vanishes in the chiral limit. We also measure Σ and the "pion" mass, in distinct topological sectors. In this context we discuss and probe the topological summation of observables by various methods, as well as the evaluation of the topological susceptibility. The feasibility of this summation is essential for the prospects of dynamical overlap fermions in QCD.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2012; v1 submitted 12 September, 2011;
originally announced September 2011.
-
QCD in the delta-Regime
Authors:
W. Bietenholz,
N. Cundy,
M. Gockeler,
R. Horsley,
Y. Nakamura,
D. Pleiter,
P. E. L. Rakow,
G. Schierholz,
J. M. Zanotti
Abstract:
The delta-regime of QCD is characterised by light quarks in a small spatial box, but a large extent in (Euclidean) time. In this setting a specific variant of chiral perturbation theory - the delta-expansion - applies, based on a quantum mechanical treatment of the quasi one-dimensional system. In particular, for vanishing quark masses one obtains a residual pion mass M_pi^R, which has been comput…
▽ More
The delta-regime of QCD is characterised by light quarks in a small spatial box, but a large extent in (Euclidean) time. In this setting a specific variant of chiral perturbation theory - the delta-expansion - applies, based on a quantum mechanical treatment of the quasi one-dimensional system. In particular, for vanishing quark masses one obtains a residual pion mass M_pi^R, which has been computed to the third order in the delta-expansion. A comparison with numerical measurements of this residual mass allows for a new determination of some Low Energy Constants, which appear in the chiral Lagrangian. We first review the attempts to simulate 2-flavour QCD directly in the delta-regime. This is very tedious, but results compatible with the predictions for M_pi^R have been obtained. Then we show that an extrapolation of pion masses measured in a larger volume towards the delta-regime leads to good agreement with the theoretical predictions. From those results, we also extract a value for the (controversial) sub-leading Low Energy Constant \bar l_3.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2011;
originally announced March 2011.
-
Flavour blindness and patterns of flavour symmetry breaking in lattice simulations of up, down and strange quarks
Authors:
W. Bietenholz,
V. Bornyakov,
M. Göckeler,
R. Horsley,
W. G. Lockhart,
Y. Nakamura,
H. Perlt,
D. Pleiter,
P. E. L. Rakow,
G. Schierholz,
A. Schiller,
T. Streuer,
H. Stüben,
F. Winter,
J. M. Zanotti
Abstract:
QCD lattice simulations with 2+1 flavours (when two quark flavours are mass degenerate) typically start at rather large up-down and strange quark masses and extrapolate first the strange quark mass and then the up-down quark mass to its respective physical value. Here we discuss an alternative method of tuning the quark masses, in which the singlet quark mass is kept fixed. Using group theory the…
▽ More
QCD lattice simulations with 2+1 flavours (when two quark flavours are mass degenerate) typically start at rather large up-down and strange quark masses and extrapolate first the strange quark mass and then the up-down quark mass to its respective physical value. Here we discuss an alternative method of tuning the quark masses, in which the singlet quark mass is kept fixed. Using group theory the possible quark mass polynomials for a Taylor expansion about the flavour symmetric line are found, first for the general 1+1+1 flavour case and then for the 2+1 flavour case. This ensures that the kaon always has mass less than the physical kaon mass. This method of tuning quark masses then enables highly constrained polynomial fits to be used in the extrapolation of hadron masses to their physical values. Numerical results for the 2+1 flavour case confirm the usefulness of this expansion and an extrapolation to the physical pion mass gives hadron mass values to within a few percent of their experimental values. Singlet quantities remain constant which allows the lattice spacing to be determined from hadron masses (without necessarily being at the physical point). Furthermore an extension of this programme to include partially quenched results is given.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2011; v1 submitted 25 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Flavour symmetry breaking and tuning the strange quark mass for 2+1 quark flavours
Authors:
W. Bietenholz,
V. Bornyakov,
M. Göckeler,
T. Hemmert,
R. Horsley,
W. G. Lockhart,
Y. Nakamura,
H. Perlt,
D. Pleiter,
P. E. L. Rakow,
A. Schäfer,
G. Schierholz,
A. Schiller,
T. Streuer,
H. Stüben,
F. Winter,
J. M. Zanotti
Abstract:
QCD lattice simulations with 2+1 flavours typically start at rather large up-down and strange quark masses and extrapolate first the strange quark mass to its physical value and then the up-down quark mass. An alternative method of tuning the quark masses is discussed here in which the singlet quark mass is kept fixed, which ensures that the kaon always has mass less than the physical kaon mass. U…
▽ More
QCD lattice simulations with 2+1 flavours typically start at rather large up-down and strange quark masses and extrapolate first the strange quark mass to its physical value and then the up-down quark mass. An alternative method of tuning the quark masses is discussed here in which the singlet quark mass is kept fixed, which ensures that the kaon always has mass less than the physical kaon mass. Using group theory the possible quark mass polynomials for a Taylor expansion about the flavour symmetric line are found, which enables highly constrained fits to be used in the extrapolation of hadrons to the physical pion mass. Numerical results confirm the usefulness of this expansion and an extrapolation to the physical pion mass gives hadron mass values to within a few percent of their experimental values.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
Topological Lattice Actions
Authors:
W. Bietenholz,
U. Gerber,
M. Pepe,
U. -J. Wiese
Abstract:
We consider lattice field theories with topological actions, which are invariant against small deformations of the fields. Some of these actions have infinite barriers separating different topological sectors. Topological actions do not have the correct classical continuum limit and they cannot be treated using perturbation theory, but they still yield the correct quantum continuum limit. To show…
▽ More
We consider lattice field theories with topological actions, which are invariant against small deformations of the fields. Some of these actions have infinite barriers separating different topological sectors. Topological actions do not have the correct classical continuum limit and they cannot be treated using perturbation theory, but they still yield the correct quantum continuum limit. To show this, we present analytic studies of the 1-d O(2) and O(3) model, as well as Monte Carlo simulations of the 2-d O(3) model using topological lattice actions. Some topological actions obey and others violate a lattice Schwarz inequality between the action and the topological charge Q. Irrespective of this, in the 2-d O(3) model the topological susceptibility χ_t = ł< Q^2 >/V is logarithmically divergent in the continuum limit. Still, at non-zero distance the correlator of the topological charge density has a finite continuum limit which is consistent with analytic predictions. Our study shows explicitly that some classically important features of an action are irrelevant for reaching the correct quantum continuum limit.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2010; v1 submitted 11 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
-
The Photon Dispersion as an Indicator for New Physics ?
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz
Abstract:
We first comment on the search for a deviation from the linear photon dispersion relation, in particular based on cosmic photons from Gamma Ray Bursts. Then we consider the non-commutative space as a theoretical concept that could lead to such a deviation, which would be a manifestation of Lorentz Invariance Violation. In particular we review a numerical study of pure U(1) gauge theory in a 4d non…
▽ More
We first comment on the search for a deviation from the linear photon dispersion relation, in particular based on cosmic photons from Gamma Ray Bursts. Then we consider the non-commutative space as a theoretical concept that could lead to such a deviation, which would be a manifestation of Lorentz Invariance Violation. In particular we review a numerical study of pure U(1) gauge theory in a 4d non-commutative space. Starting from a finite lattice, we explore the phase diagram and the extrapolation to the continuum and infinite volume. These simultaneous limits - taken at fixed non-commutativity - lead to a phase of broken Poincare symmetry, where the photon appears to be IR stable, despite a negative IR divergence to one loop.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2010; v1 submitted 23 August, 2010;
originally announced August 2010.
-
Chiral Fermions on the Lattice
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz
Abstract:
In the last century the non-perturbative regularization of chiral fermions was a long-standing problem. We review how this problem was finally overcome by the formulation of a modified but exact form of chiral symmetry on the lattice. This also provides a sound definition of the topological charge of lattice gauge configurations. We illustrate a variety of applications to QCD in the p-, the epsilo…
▽ More
In the last century the non-perturbative regularization of chiral fermions was a long-standing problem. We review how this problem was finally overcome by the formulation of a modified but exact form of chiral symmetry on the lattice. This also provides a sound definition of the topological charge of lattice gauge configurations. We illustrate a variety of applications to QCD in the p-, the epsilon- and the delta-regime, where simulation results can now be related to Random Matrix Theory and Chiral Perturbation Theory. The latter contains Low Energy Constants as free parameters, and we comment on their evaluation from first principles of QCD.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2010;
originally announced July 2010.
-
Exploring the Nucleon Structure from First Principles of QCD
Authors:
W. Bietenholz,
N. Cundy,
M. Gockeler,
R. Horsley,
H. Perlt,
D. Pleiter,
P. E. L. Rakow,
G. Schierholz,
A. Schiller,
T. Streuer,
J. M. Zanotti
Abstract:
Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) is generally assumed to be the fundamental theory underlying nuclear physics. In recent years there is progress towards investigating the nucleon structure from first principles of QCD. Although this structure is best revealed in Deep Inelastic Scattering, a consistent analysis has to be performed in a fully non-perturbative scheme. The only known method for this purpo…
▽ More
Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) is generally assumed to be the fundamental theory underlying nuclear physics. In recent years there is progress towards investigating the nucleon structure from first principles of QCD. Although this structure is best revealed in Deep Inelastic Scattering, a consistent analysis has to be performed in a fully non-perturbative scheme. The only known method for this purpose are lattice simulations. We first sketch the ideas of Monte Carlo simulations in lattice gauge theory. Then we comment in particular on the issues of chiral symmetry and operator mixing. Finally we present our results for the Bjorken variable of a single quark, and for the second Nachtmann moment of the nucleon structure functions.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2010; v1 submitted 12 April, 2010;
originally announced April 2010.
-
Tuning the strange quark mass in lattice simulations
Authors:
W. Bietenholz,
V. Bornyakov,
N. Cundy,
M. Göckeler,
R. Horsley,
A. D. Kennedy,
W. G. Lockhart,
Y. Nakamura,
H. Perlt,
D. Pleiter,
P. E. L. Rakow,
A. Schäfer,
G. Schierholz,
A. Schiller,
H. Stüben,
J. M. Zanotti
Abstract:
QCD lattice simulations with 2+1 flavours typically start at rather large up-down and strange quark masses and extrapolate first the strange quark mass to its physical value and then the up-down quark mass. An alternative method of tuning the quark masses is discussed here in which the singlet quark mass is kept fixed, which ensures that the kaon always has mass less than the physical kaon mass.…
▽ More
QCD lattice simulations with 2+1 flavours typically start at rather large up-down and strange quark masses and extrapolate first the strange quark mass to its physical value and then the up-down quark mass. An alternative method of tuning the quark masses is discussed here in which the singlet quark mass is kept fixed, which ensures that the kaon always has mass less than the physical kaon mass. It can also take into account the different renormalisations (for singlet and non-singlet quark masses) occurring for non-chirally invariant lattice fermions and so allows a smooth extrapolation to the physical quark masses. This procedure enables a wide range of quark masses to be probed, including the case with a heavy up-down quark mass and light strange quark mass. Results show the correct order for the baryon octet and decuplet spectrum and an extrapolation to the physical pion mass gives mass values to within a few percent of their experimental values.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2010; v1 submitted 4 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
-
Pion in a Box
Authors:
W. Bietenholz,
M. Göckeler,
R. Horsley,
Y. Nakamura,
D. Pleiter,
P. E. L. Rakow,
G. Schierholz,
J. M. Zanotti
Abstract:
The residual mass of the pion in a finite spatial box at vanishing quark masses, the mass gap, is computed with two flavors of dynamical clover fermions. The result is compared with predictions of chiral perturbation theory in the delta regime.
The residual mass of the pion in a finite spatial box at vanishing quark masses, the mass gap, is computed with two flavors of dynamical clover fermions. The result is compared with predictions of chiral perturbation theory in the delta regime.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2010; v1 submitted 8 February, 2010;
originally announced February 2010.
-
Quark structure from the lattice Operator Product Expansion
Authors:
W. Bietenholz,
N. Cundy,
M. Göckeler,
R. Horsley,
H. Perlt,
D. Pleiter,
P. E. L. Rakow,
G. Schierholz,
A. Schiller,
T. Streuer,
J. M. Zanotti
Abstract:
We have reported elsewhere in this conference on our continuing project to determine non-perturbative Wilson coefficients on the lattice, as a step towards a completely non-perturbative determination of the nucleon structure. In this talk we discuss how these Wilson coefficients can be used to extract Nachtmann moments of structure functions, using the case of off-shell Landau-gauge quarks as a…
▽ More
We have reported elsewhere in this conference on our continuing project to determine non-perturbative Wilson coefficients on the lattice, as a step towards a completely non-perturbative determination of the nucleon structure. In this talk we discuss how these Wilson coefficients can be used to extract Nachtmann moments of structure functions, using the case of off-shell Landau-gauge quarks as a first simple example. This work is done using overlap fermions, because their improved chiral properties reduce the difficulties due to operator mixing.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2009;
originally announced November 2009.
-
Results from 2+1 flavours of SLiNC fermions
Authors:
W. Bietenholz,
V. Bornyakov,
N. Cundy,
M. Göckeler,
R. Horsley,
A. D. Kennedy,
Y. Nakamura,
H. Perlt,
D. Pleiter,
P. E. L. Rakow,
A. Schäfer,
G. Schierholz,
A. Schiller,
H. Stüben,
J. M. Zanotti
Abstract:
QCD results are presented for a 2+1 flavour fermion clover action (which we call the SLiNC action). A method of tuning the quark masses to their physical values is discussed. In this method the singlet quark mass is kept fixed, which solves the problem of different renormalisations (for singlet and non-singlet quark masses) occuring for non-chirally invariant lattice fermions. This procedure ena…
▽ More
QCD results are presented for a 2+1 flavour fermion clover action (which we call the SLiNC action). A method of tuning the quark masses to their physical values is discussed. In this method the singlet quark mass is kept fixed, which solves the problem of different renormalisations (for singlet and non-singlet quark masses) occuring for non-chirally invariant lattice fermions. This procedure enables a wide range of quark masses to be probed, including the case with a heavy up-down quark mass and light strange quark mass. Preliminary results show the correct splittings for the baryon (octet and) decuplet spectrum.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2009;
originally announced October 2009.
-
A Non-Perturbative Operator Product Expansion
Authors:
W. Bietenholz,
N. Cundy,
M. Goeckeler,
R. Horsley,
H. Perlt,
D. Pleiter,
P. E. L. Rakow,
G. Schierholz,
A. Schiller,
T. Streuer,
J. M. Zanotti
Abstract:
Nucleon structure functions can be observed in Deep Inelastic Scattering experiments, but it is an outstanding challenge to confront them with fully non-perturbative QCD results. For this purpose we investigate the product of electromagnetic currents (with large photon momenta) between quark states (of low momenta). By means of an Operator Product Expansion the structure function can be decompos…
▽ More
Nucleon structure functions can be observed in Deep Inelastic Scattering experiments, but it is an outstanding challenge to confront them with fully non-perturbative QCD results. For this purpose we investigate the product of electromagnetic currents (with large photon momenta) between quark states (of low momenta). By means of an Operator Product Expansion the structure function can be decomposed into matrix elements of local operators, and Wilson coefficients. For consistency both have to be computed non-perturbatively. Here we present precision results for a set of Wilson coefficients. They are evaluated from propagators for numerous quark momenta on the lattice, where the use of chiral fermions suppresses undesired operator mixing. This over-determines the Wilson coefficients, but reliable results can be extracted by means of a Singular Value Decomposition.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2009;
originally announced October 2009.
-
Spectral study of a chiral limit without chiral condensate
Authors:
Wolfgang Bietenholz,
Ivan Hip
Abstract:
Random Matrix Theory (RMT) has elaborated successful predictions for Dirac spectra in field theoretical models. However, a generic assumption by RMT has been a non-vanishing chiral condensate $Σ$ in the chiral limit. Here we consider the 2-flavour Schwinger model, where this assumption does not hold. We simulated this model with dynamical overlap hypercube fermions, and entered terra incognita b…
▽ More
Random Matrix Theory (RMT) has elaborated successful predictions for Dirac spectra in field theoretical models. However, a generic assumption by RMT has been a non-vanishing chiral condensate $Σ$ in the chiral limit. Here we consider the 2-flavour Schwinger model, where this assumption does not hold. We simulated this model with dynamical overlap hypercube fermions, and entered terra incognita by analysing this Dirac spectrum. The usual RMT prediction for the unfolded level spacing distribution in a unitary ensemble is precisely confirmed. The microscopic spectrum does not perform a Banks-Casher plateau. Instead the obvious expectation is a density of the lowest eigenvalue $λ_{1}$ which increases $\propto λ_{1}^{1/3}$. That would correspond to a scale-invariant parameter $\propto λV^{3/4}$, which is, however, incompatible with our data. Instead we observe to high precision a scale-invariant parameter $z \propto λV^{5/8}$. This surprising result implies a microscopic spectral density $\propto λ_1^{3/5}$, which still remains to be understood in the light of RMT.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2009; v1 submitted 11 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
