Reproducibility of the First Image of a Black Hole in the Galaxy M87 from the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) Collaboration
Authors:
Ria Patel,
Brandan Roachell,
Silvina Caino-Lores,
Ross Ketron,
Jacob Leonard,
Nigel Tan,
Duncan Brown,
Ewa Deelman,
Michela Taufer
Abstract:
This paper presents an interdisciplinary effort aiming to develop and share sustainable knowledge necessary to analyze, understand, and use published scientific results to advance reproducibility in multi-messenger astrophysics. Specifically, we target the breakthrough work associated with the generation of the first image of a black hole, called M87. The image was computed by the Event Horizon Te…
▽ More
This paper presents an interdisciplinary effort aiming to develop and share sustainable knowledge necessary to analyze, understand, and use published scientific results to advance reproducibility in multi-messenger astrophysics. Specifically, we target the breakthrough work associated with the generation of the first image of a black hole, called M87. The image was computed by the Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration. Based on the artifacts made available by EHT, we deliver documentation, code, and a computational environment to reproduce the first image of a black hole. Our deliverables support new discovery in multi-messenger astrophysics by providing all the necessary tools for generalizing methods and findings from the EHT use case. Challenges encountered during the reproducibility of EHT results are reported. The result of our effort is an open-source, containerized software package that enables the public to reproduce the first image of a black hole in the galaxy M87.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
Reproducing GW150914: the first observation of gravitational waves from a binary black hole merger
Authors:
Duncan A. Brown,
Karan Vahi,
Michela Taufer,
Von Welch,
Ewa Deelman
Abstract:
In 2016, LIGO and Virgo announced the first observation of gravitational waves from a binary black hole merger, known as GW150914. To establish the confidence of this detection, large-scale scientific workflows were used to measure the event's statistical significance. They used code written by the LIGO/Virgo and were executed on the LIGO Data Grid. The codes are publicly available, but there has…
▽ More
In 2016, LIGO and Virgo announced the first observation of gravitational waves from a binary black hole merger, known as GW150914. To establish the confidence of this detection, large-scale scientific workflows were used to measure the event's statistical significance. They used code written by the LIGO/Virgo and were executed on the LIGO Data Grid. The codes are publicly available, but there has not yet been an attempt to directly reproduce the results, although several analyses have replicated the analysis, confirming the detection. We attempt to reproduce the result presented in the GW150914 discovery paper using publicly available code on the Open Science Grid. We show that we can reproduce the main result but we cannot exactly reproduce the LIGO analysis as the original data set used is not public. We discuss the challenges we encountered and make recommendations for scientists who wish to make their work reproducible.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2021; v1 submitted 14 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
