Showing 1–12 of 12 results for author: Schwartz, P K

Comment on `The Classical Limit of Teleparallel Gravity'

Authors: Philip K. Schwartz, Arian L. von Blanckenburg

Abstract: We critically discuss the claims of a recent article regarding the Newtonian limit of the teleparallel equivalent of general relativity (TEGR) in pure-tetrad formulation (arXiv:2406.17594). In particular, we refute this article's purported main result that if a regular Newtonian limit exists, the torsion of the limiting derivative operator (i.e., connection) necessarily vanishes. We critically discuss the claims of a recent article regarding the Newtonian limit of the teleparallel equivalent of general relativity (TEGR) in pure-tetrad formulation (arXiv:2406.17594). In particular, we refute this article's purported main result that if a regular Newtonian limit exists, the torsion of the limiting derivative operator (i.e., connection) necessarily vanishes. △ Less

Submitted 7 October, 2024; v1 submitted 3 October, 2024; originally announced October 2024.

Comments: Comment on arXiv:2406.17594. 12+2 pages (main text + references). v2: typos corrected

The Newtonian limit of orthonormal frames in metric theories of gravity

Authors: Philip K. Schwartz, Arian L. von Blanckenburg

Abstract: We extend well-known results on the Newtonian limit of Lorentzian metrics to orthonormal frames. Concretely, we prove that, given a one-parameter family of Lorentzian metrics that in the Newtonian limit converges to a Galilei structure, any family of orthonormal frames for these metrics converges pointwise to a Galilei frame, assuming that the two obvious necessary conditions are satisfied: the sp… ▽ More We extend well-known results on the Newtonian limit of Lorentzian metrics to orthonormal frames. Concretely, we prove that, given a one-parameter family of Lorentzian metrics that in the Newtonian limit converges to a Galilei structure, any family of orthonormal frames for these metrics converges pointwise to a Galilei frame, assuming that the two obvious necessary conditions are satisfied: the spatial frame must not rotate indefinitely as the limit is approached, and the frame's boost velocity with respect to some fixed reference observer needs to converge. △ Less

Submitted 7 October, 2024; v1 submitted 2 October, 2024; originally announced October 2024.

Comments: 11+3+2 pages (main text + references + appendix). v2: reference updated

The classification of general affine connections in Newton--Cartan geometry: Towards metric-affine Newton--Cartan gravity

Authors: Philip K. Schwartz

Abstract: We give a full classification of general affine connections on Galilei manifolds in terms of independently specifiable tensor fields. This generalises the well-known case of (torsional) Galilei connections, i.e. connections compatible with the metric structure of the Galilei manifold. Similarly to the well-known pseudo-Riemannian case, the additional freedom for connections that are not metric-com… ▽ More We give a full classification of general affine connections on Galilei manifolds in terms of independently specifiable tensor fields. This generalises the well-known case of (torsional) Galilei connections, i.e. connections compatible with the metric structure of the Galilei manifold. Similarly to the well-known pseudo-Riemannian case, the additional freedom for connections that are not metric-compatible lies in the covariant derivatives of the two tensors defining the metric structure (the clock form and the space metric), which however are not fully independent of each other. △ Less

Submitted 8 November, 2024; v1 submitted 19 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 20+2+2 pages (main text, references, appendix), to appear in Classical and Quantum Gravity. v2: added references, corrected typos. v3: extended discussion, added references

On gauge transformations in twistless torsional Newton--Cartan geometry

Authors: Arian L. von Blanckenburg, Philip K. Schwartz

Abstract: We observe that in type I twistless torsional Newton--Cartan (TTNC) geometry, one can always find (at least locally) a gauge transformation that transforms a specific locally Galilei-invariant function -- that we dub the `locally Galilei-invariant potential' -- to zero, due to the corresponding equation for the gauge parameter taking the form of a Hamilton--Jacobi equation. In the case of type II… ▽ More We observe that in type I twistless torsional Newton--Cartan (TTNC) geometry, one can always find (at least locally) a gauge transformation that transforms a specific locally Galilei-invariant function -- that we dub the `locally Galilei-invariant potential' -- to zero, due to the corresponding equation for the gauge parameter taking the form of a Hamilton--Jacobi equation. In the case of type II TTNC geometry, the same gauge fixing may locally be performed by subleading spatial diffeomorphisms. We show (a) how this generalises a classical result in standard Newton--Cartan geometry, and (b) how it allows to parametrise the metric structure of a Galilei manifold as well as the gauge equivalence class of the Bargmann form of TTNC geometry in terms of just the space metric and a unit timelike vector field. △ Less

Submitted 7 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: 12+3 pages (main text, references)

Atom interferometers in weakly curved spacetimes using Bragg diffraction and Bloch oscillations

Authors: Michael Werner, Philip K. Schwartz, Jan-Niclas Kirsten-Siemß, Naceur Gaaloul, Domenico Giulini, Klemens Hammerer

Abstract: We present a systematic approach to determine all relativistic phases up to $\mathcal{O}(c^{-2})$ in light-pulse atom interferometers in weakly curved spacetime that are based on elastic scattering, namely Bragg diffraction and Bloch oscillations. Our analysis is derived from first principles using the parameterized post-Newtonian formalism. In the treatment developed here, we derive algebraic exp… ▽ More We present a systematic approach to determine all relativistic phases up to $\mathcal{O}(c^{-2})$ in light-pulse atom interferometers in weakly curved spacetime that are based on elastic scattering, namely Bragg diffraction and Bloch oscillations. Our analysis is derived from first principles using the parameterized post-Newtonian formalism. In the treatment developed here, we derive algebraic expressions for relativistic phases for arbitrary interferometer geometries in an automated manner. As case studies, we consider symmetric and antisymmetric Ramsey-Bordé interferometers, as well as a symmetric double diffraction interferometer with baseline lengths of 10 m and 100 m. We compare our results to previous calculations conducted for a Mach-Zehnder interferometer. △ Less

Submitted 7 February, 2024; v1 submitted 5 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 22 pages, 3 figures, 4 tables

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 109, 022008 (2024)

Geometric post-Newtonian description of massive spin-half particles in curved spacetime

Authors: Ashkan Alibabaei, Philip K. Schwartz, Domenico Giulini

Abstract: We consider the Dirac equation coupled to an external electromagnetic field in curved four-dimensional spacetime with a given timelike worldline $γ$ representing a classical clock. We use generalised Fermi normal coordinates in a tubular neighbourhood of $γ$ and expand the Dirac equation up to, and including, the second order in the dimensionless parameter given by the ratio of the geodesic distan… ▽ More We consider the Dirac equation coupled to an external electromagnetic field in curved four-dimensional spacetime with a given timelike worldline $γ$ representing a classical clock. We use generalised Fermi normal coordinates in a tubular neighbourhood of $γ$ and expand the Dirac equation up to, and including, the second order in the dimensionless parameter given by the ratio of the geodesic distance to the radii defined by spacetime curvature, linear acceleration of $γ$, and angular velocity of rotation of the employed spatial reference frame along $γ$. With respect to the time measured by the clock $γ$, we compute the Dirac Hamiltonian to that order. On top of this `weak-gravity' expansion we then perform a post-Newtonian expansion up to, and including, the second order of $1/c$, corresponding to a `slow-velocity' expansion with respect to $γ$. As a result of these combined expansions we give the weak-gravity post-Newtonian expression for the Pauli Hamiltonian of a spin-half particle in an external electromagnetic field. This extends and partially corrects recent results from the literature, which we discuss and compare in some detail. △ Less

Submitted 29 October, 2023; v1 submitted 10 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 22+3+13 pages (main text, references, appendix), to appear in Classical and Quantum Gravity. v2: corrected author spelling in arXiv metadata. v3: added references, extended introductory discussion, corrected typos

Journal ref: Classical and Quantum Gravity 40, 235014 (2023)

Teleparallel Newton--Cartan gravity

Authors: Philip K. Schwartz

Abstract: We discuss a teleparallel version of Newton--Cartan gravity. This theory arises as a formal large-speed-of-light limit of the teleparallel equivalent of general relativity (TEGR). Thus, it provides a geometric formulation of the Newtonian limit of TEGR, similar to standard Newton--Cartan gravity being the Newtonian limit of general relativity. We show how by a certain gauge-fixing the standard for… ▽ More We discuss a teleparallel version of Newton--Cartan gravity. This theory arises as a formal large-speed-of-light limit of the teleparallel equivalent of general relativity (TEGR). Thus, it provides a geometric formulation of the Newtonian limit of TEGR, similar to standard Newton--Cartan gravity being the Newtonian limit of general relativity. We show how by a certain gauge-fixing the standard formulation of Newtonian gravity can be recovered. △ Less

Submitted 24 April, 2023; v1 submitted 21 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 28+4+1 pages (main text, references, appendix), published in Classical and Quantum Gravity. v2: extended discussions, added references, corrected typos. v3: corrected typo

Journal ref: Classical and Quantum Gravity 40, 105008 (2023)

Coupling Quantum Matter and Gravity

Authors: Domenico Giulini, André Großardt, Philip K. Schwartz

Abstract: In this contribution we deal with several issues one encounters when trying to couple quantum matter to classical gravitational fields. We start with a general background discussion and then move on to two more technical sections. In the first technical part we consider the question how the Hamiltonian of a composite two-particle system in an external gravitational field can be computed in a syste… ▽ More In this contribution we deal with several issues one encounters when trying to couple quantum matter to classical gravitational fields. We start with a general background discussion and then move on to two more technical sections. In the first technical part we consider the question how the Hamiltonian of a composite two-particle system in an external gravitational field can be computed in a systematic post-Newtonian setting without backreaction. This enables us to reliably estimate the consistency and completeness of less systematic and more intuitive approaches that attempt to solve this problem by adding `relativistic effects' by hand. In the second technical part we consider the question of how quantum matter may act as source for classical gravitational fields via the semiclassical Einstein equations. Statements to the effect that this approach is fundamentally inconsistent are critically reviewed. △ Less

Submitted 21 November, 2022; v1 submitted 11 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Comments: 53+6 pages (main text + references), 1 figure. Invited contribution to the forthcoming book "Modified and Quantum Gravity - From Theory to Experimental Searches on All Scales", eds. C. Lämmerzahl and C. Pfeifer. v2: Added exercises and concluding remarks; minor reformulations

Journal ref: in: C. Pfeifer, C. Lämmerzahl (eds.), Modified and Quantum Gravity, Lecture Notes in Physics 1017 (Springer, Cham, 2023)

Post-Newtonian Description of Quantum Systems in Gravitational Fields

Authors: Philip K. Schwartz

Abstract: This thesis deals with the systematic treatment of quantum-mechanical systems in post-Newtonian gravitational fields. Starting from clearly spelled-out assumptions, employing a framework of geometric background structures defining the notion of a post-Newtonian expansion, our systematic approach allows to properly derive the post-Newtonian coupling of quantum-mechanical systems to gravity based on… ▽ More This thesis deals with the systematic treatment of quantum-mechanical systems in post-Newtonian gravitational fields. Starting from clearly spelled-out assumptions, employing a framework of geometric background structures defining the notion of a post-Newtonian expansion, our systematic approach allows to properly derive the post-Newtonian coupling of quantum-mechanical systems to gravity based on first principles. This sets it apart from more heuristic approaches that are commonly employed, for example, in the description of quantum-optical experiments under gravity. Regarding single particles, we compare simple canonical quantisation of a free particle in curved spacetime to formal expansions of the minimally coupled Klein-Gordon equation, which may be motivated from QFT in curved spacetimes. Specifically, we develop a general WKB-like post-Newtonian expansion of the KG equation to arbitrary order in $c^{-1}$. Furthermore, for stationary spacetimes, we show that the Hamiltonians arising from expansions of the KG equation and from canonical quantisation agree up to linear order in particle momentum, independent of any expansion in $c^{-1}$. Concerning composite systems, we perform a fully detailed systematic derivation of the first order post-Newtonian quantum Hamiltonian describing the dynamics of an electromagnetically bound two-particle system situated in external electromagnetic and gravitational fields, the latter being described by the Eddington-Robertson PPN metric. In the last, independent part of the thesis, we prove two uniqueness results characterising the Newton--Wigner position observable for Poincaré-invariant classical Hamiltonian systems: one is a direct classical analogue of the quantum Newton--Wigner theorem, and the other clarifies the geometric interpretation of the Newton--Wigner position as `centre of spin', as proposed by Fleming in 1965. △ Less

Submitted 5 October, 2020; v1 submitted 23 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: Doctoral thesis. 145 pages (12 front matter + 113 main text + 20 back matter). Includes material from arXiv:1812.05181, arXiv:1908.06929, and arXiv:2004.09723. Includes an extended version of the results from arXiv:1908.06929. v2: included keywords (to match version that will be published)

MSC Class: 83C25; 81T20; 81V45; 37J39

Classical perspectives on the Newton--Wigner position observable

Authors: Philip K. Schwartz, Domenico Giulini

Abstract: This paper deals with the Newton--Wigner position observable for Poincaré-invariant classical systems. We prove an existence and uniqueness theorem for elementary systems that parallels the well-known Newton--Wigner theorem in the quantum context. We also discuss and justify the geometric interpretation of the Newton--Wigner position as `centre of spin', already proposed by Fleming in 1965 again i… ▽ More This paper deals with the Newton--Wigner position observable for Poincaré-invariant classical systems. We prove an existence and uniqueness theorem for elementary systems that parallels the well-known Newton--Wigner theorem in the quantum context. We also discuss and justify the geometric interpretation of the Newton--Wigner position as `centre of spin', already proposed by Fleming in 1965 again in the quantum context. △ Less

Submitted 9 September, 2020; v1 submitted 20 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: 28+5+4 pages (main text, references, appendices), to appear in International Journal of Geometric Methods in Modern Physics. v2: Added references, corrected typos, restructured references v3: Corrected typos, changed MSC class (better-fitting class in MSC2020)

MSC Class: 37J39; 70H33; 83A05

Journal ref: Int. J. Geom. Methods Mod. Phys. 17, 2050176 (2020)

Post-Newtonian Hamiltonian description of an atom in a weak gravitational field

Authors: Philip K. Schwartz, Domenico Giulini

Abstract: We extend the systematic calculation of an approximately relativistic Hamiltonian for centre of mass and internal dynamics of an electromagnetically bound two-particle system by Sonnleitner and Barnett [1] to the case including a weak post-Newtonian gravitational background field, described by the Eddington--Robertson parametrised post-Newtonian metric. Starting from a proper relativistic descript… ▽ More We extend the systematic calculation of an approximately relativistic Hamiltonian for centre of mass and internal dynamics of an electromagnetically bound two-particle system by Sonnleitner and Barnett [1] to the case including a weak post-Newtonian gravitational background field, described by the Eddington--Robertson parametrised post-Newtonian metric. Starting from a proper relativistic description of the situation, this approach allows to systematically derive the coupling of the model system to gravity, instead of `guessing' it by means of classical notions of relativistic effects. We embed this technical result into a critical discussion concerning the problem of implementing and interpreting general couplings to the gravitational field and the connected problem of how to properly address the question concerning the validity of the Equivalence Principle in Quantum Mechanics. △ Less

Submitted 26 October, 2019; v1 submitted 19 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 27+4+3 pages (main text, appendix, and references), to be published in Physical Review A. Differences to v1: added references, extended conclusions, corrected typos

MSC Class: 81V17; 81V45

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 100, 052116 (2019)

Post-Newtonian corrections to Schrödinger equations in gravitational fields

Authors: Philip K. Schwartz, Domenico Giulini

Abstract: In this paper we extend the WKB-like `non-relativistic' expansion of the minimally coupled Klein--Gordon equation after Kiefer and Singh [1], Lämmerzahl [2] and Giulini and Großardt [3] to arbitrary order in $c^{-1}$, leading to Schrödinger equations describing a quantum particle in a general gravitational field, and compare the results with canonical quantisation of a free particle in curved spac… ▽ More In this paper we extend the WKB-like `non-relativistic' expansion of the minimally coupled Klein--Gordon equation after Kiefer and Singh [1], Lämmerzahl [2] and Giulini and Großardt [3] to arbitrary order in $c^{-1}$, leading to Schrödinger equations describing a quantum particle in a general gravitational field, and compare the results with canonical quantisation of a free particle in curved spacetime, following Wajima et al. [4]. Furthermore, using a more operator-algebraic approach, the Klein--Gordon equation and the canonical quantisation method are shown to lead to the same results for some special terms in the Hamiltonian describing a single particle in a general stationary spacetime, without any `non-relativistic' expansion. △ Less

Submitted 29 October, 2019; v1 submitted 12 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Comments: 28 pages, published in Classical and Quantum Gravity. v2: corrected typos, revised section 2 and beginning of section 3, extended discussion of results in section 3. v3: corrected reference [10]

Journal ref: Classical and Quantum Gravity 36 (2019) 095016